Making an Infinite LEGO Domino Ring
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 พ.ค. 2024
- A never ending (theoretically) domino ring, built using LEGO bricks. Turn on captions for some commentary on the build.
Building instructions: jkbrickworks.com/infinite-dom...
1 hour live stream test: th-cam.com/users/liveUtSvkF64d6w
The ring contains 64 dominos. A ramp runs along the inside of the ring, opposite the falling dominos, to lift them back up. A Mindstorms EV3 is used to monitor and control the speed of the ramp so that it matches the falling dominos.
0:00 Domino Design
1:09 Designing the Lift Mechanism
2:58 Building and Testing the Ring
4:55 Full Operation
5:42 Simplified Control Logic and Data Display
6:17 Demonstration and Stats
Shout out to @GrantDavis for his awesome infinite domino machine ( • Infinite LEGO Domino M... ), which inspired me to finally finish this project.
Support us on Patreon: / jkbrickworks
Instagram: / jasonallemann
#LEGO #domino #infinite - บันเทิง
You know, this would be an amazing loading screen for a Lego game.
True
my pc would need a loading screen for the loading screen lol. would be really dope tho you got that right
agree
@@blakethegreat3093 i mean it's not like it would be live rendered, just a video file
bro the video was already mind blowing and then you gave the most mind blowing idea of the whole time man DAMN heads off to both of you guys
Gotta love the engineering behind using the sensor to speed up or slow down when necessary, essentially eliminating randomness. And the smart move to close it by going really fast, so the dominos end up upward.
I got annoyed pretty quickly raising them back up manually after every test, which is why I finally programmed in the fast finish. So happy I finally did that. :)
@@JKBrickworks from my understanding you used a simple closed circuit PID (proportional-integral-derivative) system to control the speed of the motors
@@bescotdude9121 Hes using just P
@@bescotdude9121 A VERY simplified version of PID.
@@RafaAelM it's been a while since I took my controls class, but this seems like an integral controller. I could be wrong though.
Everyone be talking about engineering and how cool this is (which I absolutely agree with) while I’m just here in my early morning state and enjoying how relaxing this is. No annoying clickbait, no screaming/hyping up the viewer, just a guy building something cool with legos. This is what TH-cam should be.
It can be that and more, i say
It's SOOOO relaxing... I love it.
This is literally the first thing I did after waking up today😂
Since this is on TH-cam, it is that… and more. And some people really love the screaming/hype, etc.
Little bit their way, little bit your way is a good way to be.
TH-cam should be whatever people want it to be. Pick and choose what you like.
The struggle towards getting up after being knocked down again and again is enough to fill a machine’s heart. One must imagine the legos happy.
Never gonna keep them down!
How do I like a comment more than once?
Legos explaining Sisyphus. 😂
This ring... to hold... ME?
lego sisyphus
This is impressive. Your speed control allows this contraption to work on different planets with different gravity values. You know, in case you get stuck on the moon with a bunch of Legos and nothing else to do.
Yeah bro😂😂
We’ve all been in that predicament before
@@Skaetbullfr, happened last week. Was on Jupiter and there were 967 Lego’s on the ground, so I made this and a life-size Peter Griffin
Classic situation
Ij🎉❤😊😂😅🎉😮😢k
This one is just pure masterpiece
pure bliss
pièce de résistance
Yea
A gravity powered, neverending machine...hmmm. Maybe?
Its not a masterpiece, your life is just pathetic
One must imagine Sisyphus happy.
wow
One must imagine syphisus as a lego domino machine
This must be the new World Record! The difficulty of solving the synchronization problem is seriously underrated. Such an elegant final design. Bravo!
Thanks, dude!
The OG is here lmao
@Grant Davis: I watched your version of the infinite domino loop when it came out. That was really impressive. And now... well it goes even beyond that :) I'm really looking forward to see an endurance test for this build! @JK Brickworks, this is so great :) At first, I wondered what the sensor was for, then the speed regulation explanation, of course that wasn't as simple as using any rotation speed. It must have been a lot of work to fine tune this model
The difference between yours and his are that yours at not fixed at the base (like real domino's) and his are fixed. Not diminishing JKs design, it's an incredible build!! Just pointing this out that I think they'd fall in different categories
@@MozzaBallBill there must be a way to combine both design and end up with a infinite loop without fixing the base.
I love how theres no annoying music and the commentary is in subtitles
Annoying music or to loud music has turned me off many channels. I wonder if it's some dumb ass TH-cam promotor/assistant who advises channels of such baloney behind the scenes?!?
I hate the ASMR aspect of it
@@KyleBaran90 then mute it
This is a sweet build. If the motor was quieter, the clacking of the dominoes would be very relaxing.
This is THE most satisfying build I have ever seen. It is hypnotizing, complex and also simple at the same time. Well done! It should be on display some where. Contemporary art.
I would fully expect to see something like this in the window of a toy shop, running indefinitely to attract attention. Very cool, love the build
Has nothing to do with free energy...This system is motorized....
@@bobgonzales9680 he never said it was free energy
@@panzerkamfwagon4ausfh464 but someone needs to make it clear that it is not.
@@bobgonzales9680 Even though nobody insinuated that it had anything to do with free energy?
Yeah... Nobody insinuated anything... and the "indefinitely" keyword has nothing to do with any sort of confusing statement.
Gosh I hate normies so much.
This is genuinely the most satisfying thing that exists that's not a 3D render animation.
There's a lot of really satisfying lego creations, like that one dude's lego torque converters and engines
The only thing that comes to mind is: "Aaaaaaaaaah..."
So satisfying.
Everything except for that ice block
@@JinnaiT and what’s interesting, at least for this one in particular that it actually adjusts it’s speed accordingly by judging if the current domino that’s falling is inline with the front of the cart that pushes them back up.
One must imagine the Lego Dominos Restacking Machine happy...
This may be one of the most beautiful things I've ever seen designed.
That's so satisfying, it should be an official lego set
Pls no. Lego would only fck it up and make it 200 each.
@@LukasDorian With the parts and equiptment he used, im fairly sure this guy spent more than 200 already.
@@Bonde7280 And of course, his time and effort coming up with the idea and implementing it are worth nothing. /s
It shouldn't be a set. This man is actually applying lego the way it was originally intended. box of loose parts without a manual and using imagination, creativity (And in this case engineering) to create your own masterpieces without Lego© telling you how to do it
They'd probably make it as a part of Mindstorms add on collection if presented in the name of education.
So uh… can we have a hour long version of this…? It’s so cool to watch, I want it to keep going!!!
Indeed! I'll do an hour long test at some point, maybe as a live stream.
10 hour domino stream
TH-cam Short will do it too i think 🤡
Kind of relaxing to watch... so please do the 1 hour version
If I had one of these I'd just stare at it all day
*One Must Imagine Sisyphus Happy.*
One must imagine legos dominos happy
Not enough space here to express how incredible this really is. Inspirational engineering... This world needs so many more like you!
th-cam.com/video/-L2co1AFaYo/w-d-xo.html
People who play with LEGOs?
You have put everything into this comment. Well played. Fully nonsense, but you win. You win. Basially nothing. Like your comment.
@@BeholdTheLight23 Lol, nicely put! Thanks...
lol, all i kept thinking was its a pity he couldn't power the train with the falling dominos, but yeah i guess it still looks ok
Wow, completely blown away by the robustness and repeatability in this mechanism. Amazing work as always!
Cheers, thanks dude!
@@JKBrickworks hi im a really big fan of your vids and brick machines and the b3, you all are masters of lego creation, you should deserve more subs
I love that you show each advancement of the mechanism even though it means disassembling parts repeatedly
One must imagine Sisyphus arranging the dominoes
As an engineer I like each part of the project, but especially the simple but effective speed control. You've totally earned those 6 million views!
engineer gaming
@@sandyt3799 AYY, TF2 MOMENT
Tick tock (tf2 momen)
could you explain more about the speed control part?
@@CrawElis
It's shown in the video from 4:30. A photo sensor is used for detection of a single domino position. The times for light and darkness are measured; if the dark time is longer than the light time then the speed is increased, if the light time is longer than the dark time then the speed is decreased. That's it.
I love how you evolved each piece and concept so it felt like I was participating and not just observing. I understood why most of the changes were made. Very satisfying!
It's like watching an inventor's mind at work.
@@ddebenedictis Minus the failed solutions lol
he gives a complete step by step with the subtitles turned on.
@@hoodiedude4204 i’d have totally missed that one without you, thanks!
Not only that, but the fact it was clear what was going on without any spoken remarks is pretty great.
Lego needs to pay you money for this. A great advertisement for their products.
You’ve created a monster. My son is obsessed with your builds. Is there a place I can get a materials list for these builds?
Brick Technology also makes awesome lego stuff
In the video description, he has a link to his website of "build instructions" which includes a parts list.
I like this a lot because it shows the trial and error process as well. While you're building you show the problems that arise and how you solved them. Very cool.
yea fr
Yes! That's exactly what I wanted to say. This actually teaches the viewer about R+D, it's not just "Hey, look at this cool thing". Sending this to my niblings!!
@@HandmadeDarcynibling
same
@@HandmadeDarcy sending this to your WHAT???
Of course, I need a 10 hour video of this machine running!
10 hourlater: battery 0%
It’s not a perpetual motion machine, it’s cool, but will not run forever on energy it created.
@@charlesbaldo No shit Captain Obvious. No one ever implied that. You can easily make a 10-hour video using the magic of video editing.
@Charles true, but it is run off of a motor that is powered by externally generated electricity, so it doesn't need to be perpetual. As long as you can run power to both mindstorm cortexes, it can run as long as you need it
Wouldnt a gif be easier to make, tho?
One must imagine the infinite Lego dmino machine happy
*insert sisyphus meme here*
I wish I was LEGO Technic smart. Great job Jason, this is amazing!
Can i have a lego delorean set🙏
Cheers, thanks dude!
The idea alone is mindblowing even by this channels' high standard. Wow.
This is a loading icon that is accually entertaining to watch, LEGO®games should use something like this
“One must imagine lego brick happy”
As many have commented already, this is one of the best Lego creations ever put on display. The attention to detail, the satisfactory use of pieces, the math behind it - all topped by the fact that you make it stop by catching up to the falling domino so that they end up standing up. World class 🏆
Turn on captions for some commentary on the build. Skip to 4:55 to see it in operation.
1 hour live stream test: th-cam.com/users/liveUtSvkF64d6w
Shout out to @grantdavis for inspiring me to finally finish this project.
no
👍
Can you make a 10 hour version of this running please?
You have made your lego dominoes do the wave like at a sports stadium.
Beat the record for longest domino
Incredibly satisfying to watch the whole thing in action.
One must imagine Legophus happy.
New lego loading screen
This is art, play and science in one piece. I'd love to have something similar as a center piece in my living room
i would of just made it turn on whenever my xbox is on a loading screen lol
provided it could plug into the wall and doesn't make obscene levels of noise. The real beauty would be a multi-leveled version of this, where you use the arms as different branches like a tree.
yea but dat hoe loud asff fr
@@derongregoire7106 This is actual footage from egg head island
@@derongregoire7106 THE ONE PIECE IS REALLLL
Beautiful, smooth, and simple. Great work.
the amount of satisfaction I have received from watching this is immeasurable
and my day is complete
That tiny algorithm to synchronize the speed is brilliant and elegant. I'm a software developer, and I feel like I would have spent days scratching my head only to come up with a complicated solution that only kinda works. Really good stuff.
I played with LEGO as a child and I'm 61 years of age now. I think it has to be one of the best innovative toys ever invented. It certainly kept me entertained for hours on end building everything from cars to trains to castles to space stations and rockets! The advances & improvements LEGO have introduced throughout the years are truly astonishing. Yeah, I reckon LEGO is still the best as I have often sat & watched my own kids & now my grandkids amuse themselves on rainy days when it's been too wet to play outdoors. 🤗🤗🥰🥰😍😍
...and then you step on one barefoot in the middle of the night.
Thats gotta be painful
And now kids just play Minecraft
th-cam.com/video/-L2co1AFaYo/w-d-xo.html
Why not join them
Damn that's awesome, each part is simple and elegant.
And the video is great, explains every detail clearly with no words. Even the speed control error feedback loop was explained simply and clearly, I love this
This one deserves the attribute "satisfying". I could watch it for hours.
My favorite thing? How you demonstrate the iterative process of design. Sharing that is so important to people learning - especially kids - how to troubleshoot and innovate until the idea in their head can become reality.
So genius, so satisfying!
An hour-long livestream of this would be terrific!
I admire the creativity behind the idea of making this contraption in the first place.
Love watching his videos because of the designs and testing he shows in his builds
This is why I love LEGO, you can make anything.
When you have the cash…(agreed tho)
The LEGO Technic system is a modern marvel. I wonder what kind of machine it can’t make.
Internal combustion engine without modified metal parts
@@gremie442 that’s kind of a silly answer, you wouldn’t be able to make a normal combustion engine without metal parts
@@gremie442 you honestly probably could with something likenlow pressure butane, though youd leak it everywhere.
There's something almost hypnotizing about this. Quite satisfying in any case.
ABSOTIVELY POSILUTELY correct!
This is actually pretty satisfying
what you've made is really interesting because even if you plug in the EVA3, it'll still stop running before infinity because you're losing energy each time a domino hits another, but it's so small that it would run for a long ass time anyway, this is really cool
This is incorrect (if you treat 'plugged in' as an endless power supply, of course it is correct in the 'heat death of the universe means no falling dominos' sense). The potential energy added to a domino by setting it up exactly equals the energy lost in collisions as it falls; as long as the ramp keeps setting them up (and nothing breaks), the dominos can fall forever.
I love that stopping the run results in setting all the dominos to their up state instead of just stopping the run.
I like how you frame the building process as though you are conjuring the exactly correct piece you need out of thin air. I assume it's sort of a reenactment of the design process, but it's very satisfying to watch - like a collapsing Jenga tower played in reverse. As others have said, marvelous work on this one - really ingenious!
"One must imagine Sisyphus happy."
Its amazing how Lego company came this far designing all these complex components from simple brick mounting house building games. This video is awesome as always
I appreciate that you show the design process in these videos, people tend to forget that a design is more than assembling the prices. And the result is awesome as always
Such an elegant solution to the problem. Having the pieces on hinges is a good compromise but I just can't help but think it's not the same as having them without hinges. The biggest problem in reassembling dominos in my opinion is balancing them back up. So that's a completely separate problem, but definitely a challenge to take this to the next level.
In the end this looks amazing in operation no matter what.
Thanks, agreed, my 'pie in the sky' original goal was (and still is) to build some kind of infinite domino run machine with free standing dominos. After a lot of consideration, I decided to start with this, much simpler, project. I'll work my way up to it. :)
@@JKBrickworks that's the way to do it! Work your way up! Looking forward to it
th-cam.com/video/NkP6TM1Fptc/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=GrantDavis
This is what you want
With free standing dominoes, you'd either need a wall on either side of them to ensure they always dropped in a consistent manner (which would ruin the appearance), or you'd need a mechanism to align them before standing them back up - tricky in such a confined space.
@@JKBrickworks Maybe a magnetic bottom (so it stays in place) weeble-wobble (so it stands back up) designed domino. It would be difficult to keep the forward momentum going.
This is the best lego creation i have ever seen🥹
I'm already marvelling at the fact that you managed to build a perfect circle with LEGOs...
This has got to be the most satisfying Lego build ever to me.
You're SOO right!
And again, Jason manages to make it look so simple and elegant. So impressive!
This is even better than I thought it would be
6:53 one must imagine lego domino ring happy
Would be interesting to see what wear they get on the corners sliding on the other domino's after a week or something
I would love to see how long it has to run for before it breaks (not including batteries)
@@jaredholland5844 Let me guess...you're an engineer, right??? 😉😄
I was thinking wear on the reset mechanism, but yeah
Not an engineer, more like contrarian.
5:07 Looks like CG at rhis angle. So satisfying
The commentary in the captions was great.
Super interesting to watch how you put this together.
The way you showed it on a trial and error basis from the beginning to the end is amazing! A hundred likes to this video!
This is phenomenal. World record level stuff.
genuinely one of the best Lego videos I've seen
bro this is literaly sooo satisfying to me
10 hour version when?!
This is art on every level. Bravo.
With how this leverages the train tracks so elegantly, if the ramp train was pushed/pulled by a train engine then the dominos could theoretically be arranged into all sorts of arbitrary loop shapes as well!
Wow this is cool! The things that set up the dominos is also satisfying
It would be cool if the flat plates on the side were a different color from the rest of the domino so there was a wave of color as they fell
I also loved how you showed the troubleshooting and trying different things to get it to work
This was extremely satisfying to watch as it all comes together, superb editing and awesome build!
Love the commentary, really fleshes out the experience.
this needs to be an official lego set
I'm only two minutes in, and I already appreciate how you let us in on the design process - showing us what did work or what didn't work and how you fixed it.
😾😾😾😾😾😾😾😾😾😾😾😾😾😾
What I thought was interesting is how my instinct was that it couldn't go forever because the initial push added energy into the "fall wave" and friction is always taking it away. And then I remembered that the wave is powered by the potential energy gained by lifting the dominoes, and my brain exploded a little bit thinking about how the work done on lifting them is used to knock them back down.
nice
That’s great, now give me your lunch money nerd.
bro i could watch this guy build with legos for hours
This is amazing. This would make for an art installation worth looking at!
That's really impressive!
One thing I would change is to make the top and sides of the domino pieces have different colors. This way the moving wave would give a cool iridescent effect. The fully saturated red color makes it hard to see.
Amazing work!
Great idea. I'll add it to the list of things to try.
@@JKBrickworks if you'll do it, you can put that on the top by using a raimbow shading for the side and black for the top.
I don't have the words to truly convey how much I adore this.
Amazing, perfectly finalized project!
great job dude now you just opened a portal to the 71st dimension
You absolutely CRUSHED IT with this one. So awesome.
He really *flipped* the idea of a regular LEGO build. This is definitely *falling* into my collection of good videos.
He didn't crush it. He made it *fall* into place.
I've never been good with engineering and such. I guess this sort of thing just *clicks* for him
Watching the build in action is just unexplainably satisfying
One of the coolest things I've seen recently. Amazing.
The world is a better place with people who do this sort of thing!
Always awesome to see creativity mixed in with engineering. Thanks for sharing
This is insane! Beautifull design, amazing idea, and top notch video!! Congrats, i love it!
*ENDLESS DOMINOES!! EVEN IF IT'S NOT PIZZA!*
Seriously though, this is incredibly satisfying to watch, absolutely solves the annoying problem of having to put them back up again. And yes, Lego should really consider using something like this for a loading screen.
This is so satisfying to watch