FFXI - How Do Ambuscade Weapons Compare to REMA Weapons?

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 48

  • @cloudchiefarcade
    @cloudchiefarcade  5 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    After further testing I posted this video about Weapon Skill Criticals: th-cam.com/video/F4HyFLLJpn8/w-d-xo.html

  • @aro1284
    @aro1284 5 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    COR is a special case since these are their first melee endgame weapons aside from su5. But for COR dual wielding sword dagger is extremely strong. Great acc, att magic damage and magic att. Buffs savage blade of course but also buffs leaden salute and quick draw quite well.

  • @cloudchiefarcade
    @cloudchiefarcade  5 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I look forward to hearing your thoughts about Ambuscade Weapons as well as the other things discussed in this video. I imagine some of my thoughts on this will be controversial. Let the debate begin!

  • @zenxyphen4443
    @zenxyphen4443 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Thank you for that Crit Tangent!! Seriously tho! Love your guides thank you for making them!

  • @shenratensai
    @shenratensai 5 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    I still think Ryunohiege beats out the Shining one lance, when you factor in Aftermath & Afterglow, & the bonuses it gives to your Wyvrn
    It's just leagues better i believe, I can't think of any situations where the extra crit from Impulse driver would really matter.

  • @kynikostashasch2218
    @kynikostashasch2218 5 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    You forgot the relic hidden effect, maths i've seen on BG put most of the ambu weapons behind their relic counterparts even without R15

  • @atomicskull6405
    @atomicskull6405 5 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    SE clearly lost their minds with the dagger, After the WS update Eviceration was already in the same ballpark as Mercy Stroke or a 100% TP Rudra's Storm and adding 50% damage to it on top of that is just madness. In addition to that you still get the ACC and ATT stats offhand and it's DMG and delay is virtually the same as Mandau and Twashtar which makes in the best offhand dagger for REMA weapons in situations where a single high fTP WS is better than a multi hit. Evisceration is fTP 1.25 on all 5 hits, 6 if dual wielded and it is TP=chance to crit, and it's one of the weird fTP replicating WS where gear like the fortia neck and belt affect all hits. So it's a must have for any dagger job whether you have a REMA or not. Mummu +2 set is probably the best WS set for this with it's +35% critical hit rate bonus.

  • @lordtreybennett
    @lordtreybennett 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    You dont have to use decimation to get the SC bonus on the axe. SC bonus just increases based on total number of WSs used in skill chain.

  • @Callbeast
    @Callbeast 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    Great video! Loving the steady stream of ffxi content. It feels like a golden age.

  • @JosephArata
    @JosephArata ปีที่แล้ว

    Hachimonji with Kasha > Shoha > Light > Fudo > Light lvl 4, with 100% double attack rate from store TP +100. Any amount over 100 becomes triple attack percentage. I don't see a downside here to using the Hachimonji. Where Kasha is hamstringed into generally less damage since it's single hit without Hachimonji, Shoha and Fudo do fairly decent damage on their own, but Masamune has been done to death at this point, there are other options other than spending hundreds of millions on upgrade items for Empyrean. At least for people who don't already have a Masamune started, the Hachimonji seems to be an easier weapon to get through Ambuscade. The trial weapon to just do the WS unlock to get Fudo takes considerably less time/money to complete, than a full Masamune.

  • @jimenezz79
    @jimenezz79 5 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I just noticed I have 3 pulse weapon!
    Probably I will get the sword for my blue mage!

    • @cloudchiefarcade
      @cloudchiefarcade  5 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Nice! Ambuscade Sword and Club are both very strong for BLU

    • @jimenezz79
      @jimenezz79 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      cloudchief arcade woot I love your videos a lot information great good. Cloud!

  • @aaronwlkr
    @aaronwlkr 5 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I use the Kaja tachi as a main weapon while I wait to get my t4's clears for Doji. I'm pretty much always in 2nd or 3rd place for damage in all the events I've done, OMEN, DD wave 1, 2, 3, ect , since that weapon was released. Those below me have AG REMA's. That's not to say my weapon is better, its just that, because you have a 119 AG weapon, you are not simply doing more damage by having that weapon equipped. You still have to put in the effort to play the job. So I'd say to those putting in 110%, these weapons are not bad at all, unless maybe you run into a REMA AG person that is also putting in 110%, but in most of my experiences, the AG REMA people are asleep at the keyboard. I'd love to upgrade it again, but glow weapons seem to not be in my favor. Just my .02$

  • @agonzalez8924
    @agonzalez8924 5 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Nice vid man!
    Anyhow, just my own two cents... as mentioned in your review, there is no clear cut winner as to what is the best overall weapon. Everything in ffxi is situational, and although that's a boring answer, it is the truth. I believe SE wants to encourage its players to work at being perfect for all situations. That means you may have to adjust not just your gear sets, but also your weapon for every battle. For example: If you want to be the perfect DRK, you must be able to drop big dick torcleavers, so you build a calad..but then you must also be able to keep your self alive, so you gotta be able to switch to apoc mid battle. Later you might need to switch to mythic for some other function. TP gain is so insanely fast these days that its now feasible to just change weapons on the fly. Many players have already been doing this, and i think its cool that SE developers are in tune with this fad, and are continuing to develop ways to keep players engaged.

  • @sagepirotess6312
    @sagepirotess6312 5 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Well as you said you can make 2 a month easily. So rema whitch takes 150 to 300mil gil. It seems easy weapon for casual players.
    Me, i want to know about the staff ws on sch. You can use that to solo darkness, so how does it compare with atomic staff.
    As for relics scythe still awesome. As for blu, its how will it compare to the new sword that decreases ca ba timer by 25%.
    As for empy staff, 50% fast cast and after affect.

  • @foomp
    @foomp 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    I got myself a Kaja sword for BLU and, to be honest, I'm a little underwhelmed by it versus other non-DREAM swords. It seems more suited for COR than other sword users. Yeah, it's great damage for Savage Blade, but it really doesn't do much overall compared to say... an NQ Tanmogayi. Given what people say about the difference of Kaja sword vs Naegling, I don't think it'll be much to bother for. If you lack a good sword though, definitely go for it. Otherwise, it just doesn't seem worth prioritizing over other weapons if you play other jobs.

    • @SageAtoreis
      @SageAtoreis 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      Naegling is 2nd best sword for pure DPS on BLU (Tizona is first) if you have enough accuracy to pair it with TP bonus sword in offhand. If you can't it's still very good for CDC, especially if it helps you reach attack cap with it's special mechanic (that mechanic is really potent actually). It's also the best for Sanguine blade and hybrid builds when you want to mix in nukes or magic burst of your skillchains.

    • @tyalangan
      @tyalangan 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      BartekSWT wouldn’t Naegling only be second best if attack isn’t capped? Otherwise wouldn’t Sequence/Thib be better from the higher base damage and additional TP bonus?

    • @SageAtoreis
      @SageAtoreis 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@tyalangan If you are at attack cap, you are probably in strong buffs scenario, so you have samurai roll. With Samurai roll you will frequently overflow with TP above 1250TP, which is the border point for Sequence/Thib to reach 3000TP with moonshade earring. So every time you go above 1250TP, that TP bonus is wasted. Naegling also has big advantage of having +40acc and +15dex, so 50+ effective accuracy for Thib which is a bless for this build. Sequence can get up to +30 accuracy from upgrades, but almost none prioritize getting ranks on Sequence, so it's usually no accuracy on it at all.

    • @tyalangan
      @tyalangan 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      BartekSWT great points. Thanks for the insight. I’ll probably do sword first for RDM then instead of bow or dagger for sub over ternion

    • @foomp
      @foomp 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@SageAtoreis I'm not saying it's a bad sword or anything, nor that in specific setups it can't be one of the best. I'm just saying that its overall output doesn't seem to be as huge as people make it out to be, compared to the other options available. Even in those specific setups.
      It just seems like people are overhyping it because of the hype with the polearm. Because that's so huge of an impact compared to other 2h weapons (including most DREAM), all other good weapons from it are suddenly making the same impact... when it's not the case at all. Again though, this is just my observation with Kaja. People were saying the same thing about that, that they do for Naegling.
      Reminds me of instances where people got Tizona/Almace and realized it doesn't suddenly make their damage go through the roof. As though they thought they would go from 10000 damage with Coladas to 99999 damage with ultimates.

  • @BlaiseArath
    @BlaiseArath 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    Thank you for not undervaluing the Club. That thing is absolutely broken if you're fighting something like Skeletons or pots, anything that takes additional Blunt Damage melts to it.

  • @FaeQueenCory
    @FaeQueenCory 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    I agree.... Mostly.
    I think you're too focused on the physical side of things. Magicwise, these are near universally the best in slot... Mostly.
    I also must point out how some of the extra effects are poorly worded. (Like how the Staff apparently is just how much TP you currently have, not based on the TP used in Retribution.) And any that have "Weapon Skill:" on them have the effect for all WSs, not just the linked WS. (That and the high Macc and INT on the Sword is why I would argue that it's the best of the lot.)

  • @shperax
    @shperax 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I think they need to rework Great Axe for WAR cause utilizing Fencer on WAR with the Ambu sword you can't WS for under 2k TP Savage Blades and thats broken. Great Axe can't even come close to that kind of DPS. I can Consistently hit 40K SB on the highest lvl content while soloing. Throw in Ayame to always open light SC and your doing insane damage. With a party of real players (GEO mostly) you can easily hit 60-80k Savage blades. Savage Blade is very powerful but most noticeable on WAR because of the Fencer Job trait. I just don't feel that WAR was meant to be played with a Sword and Shield. But im not gonna stop taking advantage of it over inferior damage. I just use Gaxe for AoE damage when i need it now. And Gsword just for fun.

  • @integrityalpha6922
    @integrityalpha6922 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    U think it’s worth getting the Kaja knife for thf if I already have an Aeneas? Like would it ever make sense to main the Kaja and offhand aeonic?

    • @cloudchiefarcade
      @cloudchiefarcade  5 ปีที่แล้ว

      I think Kaja knife would be a good offhand. If you know you will be using Evis alot it might be worth mainhanding. Most of the time though you would want to keep Aeonic mainhand.

  • @tenzen839
    @tenzen839 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    i hope they dont nerf the ambus weapons . and boost the remas to have a real nice balance

  • @darylalltop
    @darylalltop 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    If you have gil to burn you can make a pulse weapon from buying 5 cells off the auction house.

    • @Red-fs1jw
      @Red-fs1jw ปีที่แล้ว

      Might as well just speed up a rema production at that point

  • @canis760
    @canis760 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    Could you explain what a lot of the effects are? I still can't figure out what the scythe does.

    • @cloudchiefarcade
      @cloudchiefarcade  5 ปีที่แล้ว

      That is a good idea. I will make a video going through what each of them does in detail.

  • @Armyguy03190
    @Armyguy03190 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    blu's on my server are dw clubs stage5 and 4 for magic set up's

  • @nezkeys79
    @nezkeys79 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    Hey...i had a better time on efts in escha thanks but it can still be rough. I keep getting animation lock tho on a big pull...getting stuck inside lots of enemies rotating around my character...and not engaging...which of course makes you die because trusts wont heal you (the second thing i detest about the game). Both these things can happen wherever i go tho.
    All in all i think im just too far behind even with ochain and aegis. Never entered omen or dynamis divergence...and theres no way i can solo the harder ambuscades. I did solo the VE and E one tho. My gear us regular sulevias and 119 relic and AF gear

  • @Nightweaver1
    @Nightweaver1 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    I see so many Shining Ones lately. SO. MANY.

  • @nemeanlioness
    @nemeanlioness 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    I only go after special ultimates like idris and epeolatry.

    • @nezkeys79
      @nezkeys79 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      Ochain and aegis are the best! XD

    • @nemeanlioness
      @nemeanlioness 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@nezkeys79 yes, burtang is not nessesary but those two are.

    • @nezkeys79
      @nezkeys79 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      @@nemeanlioness im making burtgang anyway but yeah its not as aqesome as the shields in comparison

    • @strayargus9382
      @strayargus9382 4 ปีที่แล้ว

      Boring lol

  • @gabrielmorales6120
    @gabrielmorales6120 4 ปีที่แล้ว

    This video could have been 1:30 long. You pretty much said it at that point. It's allllll situational 1000% of the time. It's based on your gear, the mob, party setup, solo setup, even the damn current game day becomes a factor.

  • @lordtreybennett
    @lordtreybennett 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    This video has some bad information. While they do only boost the damage of 1 WS, the other effects work on all weapon skills for the most part. Plus you somehow missed savage blade all the things (and black halo most of the things). Maybe when you made this video people didn't understand that many of the effects are not tied to the specific ws the weapon boosts.
    Nageling, Tauret, Max, the Katana, Polearm, and GS are all really great weapons. Bow, Axe, staff, h2h, GA, and the grip all have many great uses, and can be the best option depending gon task and job. GK is neat. It is fun to amass massive amounts of STP on nin so with a good sam roll, hit 200+ stp and have 100% triple attack (plus quad attack % of whatever you can get past 200 stp).
    i am rambling. Some of them (Sword, dagger, club, polearm, and katana) are as good as or better than many REMAs and not having them can be a detriment. All of them are amazing weapons compared to anything that isn't a REAM or Odyssey weapon.

  • @SageAtoreis
    @SageAtoreis 5 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Please stop. Dont make up things. You cant crit on WS that cant crit (the ones that can crit has that in description). Its super easy to test. Go to abyssea and make some WS that doesnt scale with tp. Then take all the crit rate/damage atmas on and go make same ws. It would make like double damage 70% of the time. It wont. It cant crit. There is also no such thing like having no crit rate. Minimum crit rate is 5% and usually another 5% from merits, so everyone have at least base 5% crit rate active all the time and if all ws can crit, they would at least 5% of a time. Your test was inaccurate and thats it.
    Shining One is the only thing outside of abilities like mighty strikes or climactic flourish or sneak/trick attack etc. That can force a crit on non crit WS. Thats why its such a big deal. It also doesnt have 50% crit rate. It has around +5-10% crit rate at 1000tp and around +25% crit rate at 3000tp. It also let you crit on any polearm WS but still makes Impulse Drive MUCH better than any of them, so it kinda also force you to use that one WS if you go for max damage. Whats also important here is that its by far the best piercing option for WAR and SAM.
    Decimation actually has very rare sc property which is fusion. It can chain Light with a lot of frequently used WS like Savage blade, Resolution, Tachi: Schoha, Mordant Rime. It can also self 4 step light sc with Decimation>SmashAxe>Decimation>Decimation, which is a very solid skillchain.

    • @SageAtoreis
      @SageAtoreis 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      If that video of this guy doing Ground strikes was the actual test for crits then it proves nothing. you are simply not aware of some mechanicc in this game.
      Notice his first hit on Twitherym without Dia III was 575 damage. With Dia III he his those mobs for range of 674 to 906 and it made one hit for 575 before Dia III. This imply his attack to defense ratio is around 1.9 without Dia III. He has 1087 attack and those from must be around 570. So on Ground strike his ratio is around 3.3 (Ground Strike has +75% attack bonus). That gives us min final pdif 3.3 - 0.375 = 2.925 and maximum final pdif 3.9375. Which means that WS randomly without ANY crit varies from 2.925 pdif to 3.9375 pdif. Additionaly his highest BS was with 1165 TP, while lowest with 1001 TP. Lastly it was on different Toad and toads there has 106-108 lv.
      So in the end with all those variables, the highest GS might even be 50% stronger than lowest one on those toads and that 3572 was 47% stronger than that 2417 one, so it doesn't prove any crits on non crit WS.

  • @shanemitchell2211
    @shanemitchell2211 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    I do not think this is the final upgrade like you keep saying

  • @kevinpacman8013
    @kevinpacman8013 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    Wasted pulse weapon on Gk before realizing it was complete doodoo mult-strike sounds good but it's def trickery not good . 2 hit max unless stacked triple hit, it's a lolgk

  • @ShiyoKozuki
    @ShiyoKozuki 4 ปีที่แล้ว

    WS cannot crit unless they specifically say so or you SA/TA, it's been tested hundreds of thousands of times. Your eyeballing is not accurate testing.

  • @anguel87
    @anguel87 5 ปีที่แล้ว

    doesn tit beat a REMA ? YES !
    aeonics R15 DRG here, when doing dynamis i feel really frustrated to no ends, with my trishula R15 i can pull off a good 20K lets say 25K if im lucky, a SAM was litterally spamming impulse drive over n over, and was like on discord "oh 70K, oh 90K, oh 65K" and lets say that even if i were close to doing 50K (and ANY DRG player here know that you wont see those number even fully buffed at max)
    so are they broken and way too Overpowred ? big YES !!
    PS: im frustrated because it take a strong effort (its not anyone that can beat reisen helms) + R15 means jeuno wave 3 clear (again not anyone can do it !) + gettign TO R15 cost 140M so yeah, really annoyed as fu.. to see a "super easy" weapon to get, be that strong !