Jaishankar, UK Foreign Secy Truss in conversation at India-UK Strategic Futures Forum
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 พ.ค. 2024
- #ThePrintUncut
Indian External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar and UK Foreign Secretary Elizabeth Truss were speaking at the First India-UK Strategic Futures Forum, moderated by Dean Godson. The conversation was hosted by the Indian Council of World Affairs and Policy Exchange, UK.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
![ใจดำกับฉันก่อน - วงทัพห้า [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I48wa4qurAU/mqdefault.jpg)
Mr. Jaishankar is astonishing and unapologetically taking sense. More Power to you, Sir. Indian Foreign Policy is in safe hands for sure.
Dr. Jaishankar
Meanwhile
Foreign policy failed
Why opposition is so dumb
But
Definately economy failed
S. Jaishankar
He's retiring it seems... He was one of the outgoing Rajya Sabha members who were addressed recently by the PM
@@matthewmitchells8008 I am skeptical about ur point because Dr. S Jaishankar was elected in RS only after the general elections in 2019.
It's astonishing to see a Brit posturing about "historical responsibility" as a counter to Jaishankar's point about proximity.
It's seriously rich for them given their history!
Where's India's "historical" Koh-I-Noor?
Truss, just like most people in Boris' cabinet, is a moron
@@JaswantSingh-ym9zo adorning the symbolic middle finger Britain shows to the colonies
This is what I wanted to say 🥴
NOTE: West calling it an invasion. India calls it conflict. Fantastic! ❤
Well
Really? I wasn't even listening to her.
It,s true
Looted 45 trillion dollar 💲 💰 during colonial time.
th-cam.com/video/x_jGPf764d0/w-d-xo.html
India calling it invasion as well. You only listen to one person for Mode government
Watch the last 5 minutes for the key point everyone wants to know. Jaishankar was brilliant.
how about timestamps?
R1
the foriegn secretary just avoided topics and the reporter trying to be smart acted arrogant and jaishankar destroyed it in a moment. great.
Perhaps the best foreign minister on Earth. Kudos to the largest democracy for actually electing people who represent your interests and the long term future of democracy, which is not the US nor the UK corporate rigged oligarch systems
He just literally killing the questions related to the indias buying of oil and gas in different forums and dialogue so aptly and boldly that even a 10th grade guy would love to be like him😃😋
Jaishankar is literally unstoppable. This man needs to be our EAM for as long as he can, we're lucky to have him.
So true man
Well only thing he bends over a lot for tussian and Chinese ministet
As Long As There Is BJP. He's there. 👍
TTb
She didn't speak a single word on aggression of CCP against India. How strange ? And they expect us to condemn Russia. We won't, and we shouldn't.
CCP aggression is limited to border skirmishes where india fought back, whereas russia is killing innocent civilians and destroying a democratic country. If someone can't condemn that on humanitarian ground then he/she isn't a good person anyway.
The British and US will do their best to push schism between India, China and Russia - also India and Pakistan. I don't need to say "divide and rule" - it's well known.
She refused to even condemn Pak terror in her interview with Som.
She would hate for China and India to sort out their problems , divide and rule.
Indians tend to inflate their tension with their neighbors. Note that from the global Perspective, your boader skirmishes with Pakistan and China is miniscule. Pakistan and China don't even mention them because there are simply bigger issues.
Support India 🇮🇳 from Tajikistan 🇹🇯
Focus on our region
❤❤❤
I just love how Sir has been spearheading our foreign policy.
2019 was when he was brought in
2020- Covid 19
2021- Galwan
2022- Afghanistan and Ukraine
I don't think anyone would have been able to do a better job and his experience of being a career diplomat definitely helps.
You missed the most important period, when India revoked Article 370.😃
Mr.Jaishankar to foreign diplomacy is analogous to Sachin Tendulkar to cricket. He is amongst the best diplomats across the world today. He puts India at the epicentre of world diplomacy. At this rate, he will become all time greats.
Said before he is the best bet to become Secretary General of U. N.
Dr Jaishankar is an absolute legend in the making. India is blessed to have him and I pray the people of India realise this as well as how much BJP has done for India in such a short time compared to the Congress years. Love to 🇮🇳 from 🇬🇧
100%
Yes bro love you from India 🇮🇳
Exactly!! The tactics to distract the people to bjps contribution have been incessant , but i hope the common man does see it and realize its significance!
On historical relationship she said ...India is celebrating independence day this year! Hahaha OMG!
Her response was like Ex girlfriends asking to be friends after a breakup 😂😂
It's been 75 years and they still haven't moved away from colonial mindset
@RKA ME what are the solutions then ?
@RKA ME Correct India should educate everyone in the only living Indian classical language, Tamil. Tamil MPs need to obtain permission to speak Tamil in the Indian parliament. It is a shame.
@RKA ME English language use?
Believe me Indians and the world will ditch English once England returns all the loot,compensate every life it took,artefacts etc!
The Brits still have the colonial arrogance as always.
When didn’t they leave it ?
Lol ww1 ww2 are fabricated!
Brits know how much they need india.
They have experience how USA surpassed them without help of brits.
Same goes for india. India will surpass USA and china. They know disaster if India join group of Russia and China. BRICS will be strongest organization.
Organization of future superpower countries.
Apologies 😔
@@VR46314 don’t be apologetic civilians had nothing to do with it ! Together let’s all colonizers out !
Damn they are still living in their colonial mindset..
We are blessed to have such a strong dominant leadership
modi hai toh mumkin hai
@@pranav7418 well it's not about just modi 😒
Pura team effort h and there are various other reasons like Indian economy, our market etc
Sirf ek admi par kabhi dependent nhi rehte kabhi always turns out to be disaster..
“Understand there is a fundamental problem if an aggressor can get away with invading a sovereign nation”
Words from the descendant(truss) of the very same aggressors.
🤣🤣
And the same UK who were instrumental in the US led invasion of Iraq, Libya and Afghanistan in 2003, 2011 and 2001.
Selective memory loss on them having been a worlwide aggressor 😅😂
Wah. For Ukraine UK has a historical responsibility. Towards India, UK only wants to look forward and avoid historical responsibility.
This is how UK always gets its way, and it helps to have educated everyone's elite so they only know the history UK wants them to.
Apologies from a British person , these politicians aren’t representative of us
I love Minister Jaishankar. He is certainly Prime Minister material and I hope to see him advance through the ranks of politics to one day become the Prime Minister of India. His thinking ability is second to none in the foreign ministry diaspora and his experience and skills will be very valuable to a country like India - An India that's just beginning to leave its mark on geopolitics and the art of diplomacy.
Not everyone doing good is worthy of being prime minister, Being PM is about leadership.
PM should be great at domestic politics and with people on ground. EAM Jaishankar is perfect for external affairs. Not more, not less
No he is not pm material....
Manmohan is a great finance minister we saw how that end up when he becomes pm .
Jai Shankar views can be soothing for Egalitarians and Elite and for well educated ppl which is roughly 10 % of ind population.
For rest ,Banana Politics works.
@@jayasree6722 his government was great we didn't go to recession even during the 2008 global recession. modi government has made india hit lowest of the lows in all criteria
She was stammering while speaking on historical responsibilities of UK to India 😂
lmao 🤣
He should have asked her for a cheque.
@@casteretpollux for kohinoor you mean ?
she is an embarrassment... she needs a lesson on public speaking from Mr Jaishankar
@@emperor270353 she is now my PM 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Tight slap from Jaishankarji 😁🙏🏻
Yes at the end 😂, When he brought up EU oil purchasing from Russia 😂😂
Liked from 38:00..😀 Truss: About Ukraine-we have to look at the past. About India- We have to look at only future (forget the past)...The last part about cheap energy from Russia was superb..
She is forgetting that India is stronger and she has come to India and their stance on Kashmir about 370 was shameless
The word from Dr Jaishankar "May I Just Add A Word There?" Made the real news.
This is pretty amazing that the Brit is trying her best to steer the conversation to Ukr-Rus while the Indian Minister has very tactfully steered the dialog away from Ukr-Rus centric. Probably the most brilliant External Affairs Minister ever coming from India.
Dr Jaishankar is to astute, competent and experienced a Diplomat and Minister to be taken in by the likes of the Hon. UK Foreign Secretary here. He is also too dignified to be impolite! It is a new world order. The sooner the western governments recognize it, the smoother life will be for their people.
It seemed to me FM Jaishankar was more diplomatic and long-sighted. Secy Truss seemed more political and focused on the immediate short-term situation in the Ukraine. Anyway, good discussion overall.
I think jaishankar is remembering that they intervened and suggested even in their parliament that 370 abrogation was wrong and almost implied that kashmir should be free
And why would we forget that
They also didn't do much about afganistan, we are left alone to take the danger
@@urjafest2048 I think you meant the UK implied Kashmir should secede. We all agree that Kashmiris deserve a life free of extremism or economic backwardness, which is what removing 370 intends to accomplish.
No Secy Truss lost the plot and lost the focus on India's neutrality and the fact that India must be responsible for maintaining India's neutrality! Quite a lot of hot air from the Indian gentleman! The first prize must go to the advocate who can win a guarantee from India not to fuel the Russian war. Nothing but that Indian guarantee is important now.
@@dianamincher6479 You got the guarantee now after all this time of the invasion?
I think she should leave. UK has never shared technology with India. UK has always voted against us in every single international forum on every single issue. We don't have any potential to improve these relations unless that has changed for at least a decade.
The British still think that they are the ‘stiff upper lip’ of the past that others would be submissive to their condescending attitude to the past colonial ‘subjects’! Wrong! Wake up and smell the coffee, it is a different world out there!
It's really irritating to listen to her rubbish talks.
45 trillion is a heck of a lot of money. Textiles were all gone. They have ruined so many nations. Came to India to lecture
i think uk should be removed from un permanent seat....they are useless in that position...
@@ashutoshpati7794 uk has become a vassal state for us I don't think us gonna lose that leverage in UN.
The kashmir and the tibetan border issues are left over of british history which is still a bitter thorn between india, china and pakustan.
I'm sure US UK covertly boost these divisions.
Superb reply by Mr. Jaishankar 👏👏👏 These kind of people required in our Indian politics
UK condemning Russia for invading other country 🤣🤣🤣
UK got rich by invading and colonising, and now they're like "we're done, we're at the top, now everyone stops!" Like a petulant child 😂
It never fails to amaze me when UK minister speaks at international forum as though they have a black hole on their own atrocities committed in India, how to proceed on lecturing India what policy India should embrace.
The typical "zero sum" game is truly astounding.
Usa too Oil wars and whole Europeans!!
100%
Just get over it. She wasn’t the foreign minister serving Churchill when the atterocities happened.
@@akshaydabhadkar851 I guess there's one thing UK can always rely on India... obedient servant.
@@tigading2177 sorry if I unintentionally offended you.
how "shameless" they are bringing up the word ''HISTORY'' every time.
Time to change history in Bharata perspective
Time for India to colonise Britain by year 2050
They don’t even teach their Children about their own colonial history imagine
Dr jaishankar, you should have given her a tight history of what war, genocide, famine, activating inter-ethnic-religious conflicts and of course partition has done to India. Still this b!tch has the audacity to come and talk "HISTORY"!? Man! We need to shove up some spicy curry up on her a&&
who are they? Indians or BJP?
well you look troubled. May family living with you shower mercy and grace on you.
She is almost forcing Our FM to criticize Russia
Loved it to hear and watch updated tune of world from great knowledgeable personalities. Thanks Print.
Dr Jaishankar is a brilliant speaker with great charm and logic... He makes indian foreign policy very presentable and great even during troubled times... we are proud of him and his astonishing expertise...
Dr JaiShankar salute to you.
Amazing to see how you captured and turned that last moment to give your bit of strong reply to western campaigns against India’s interests.
Just love it 👌🙏
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
When UK talking about invasion with India, I just couldn't stop giggling.
It is telling that Mr Jaishankar has greater grasp of the english language than his British counterpart. Intellectually, she is a pygmy, compared to him.
It’s amazing UK wants now to see where they are with India all of sudden it’s been so many years and it wasn’t top priority
Wonderful response by S Jayshankar sir...!!!
What is India's policy in regard to Russia? Is India serious about it's neutrality? We can't work out if India is neutral or not?
Jai Sankar's jabardast punch in last to Truss
42:00 here is the future FM! Flawlessly eloquent and polite, asking hardest question there is. Priority of an FM. Imagine a diplomatic corps of such students trained in the ways of Jai-Fu!
Infact all of India's diplomats comes from the same cadre of Jaishankar with the same training. He himself was an IFS officer before becoming the minister.
This lines breaks every pre-thinking -- India is entitled to its perception of world.
Jai shankar sir is unmatched spellbound talent
i think last question and its answers were the soul of the meeting. Because india unlike uk is trying it's best to stay neutral, with keeping in mind the national interest. so india's stand in world now majorly depends upon this issue where her policy of neutrality isn't amusing to west. The reply of elizabeth to this very question is some glimpse of their future policy.
S Jaishankar is one of those people for whom I'd like to see political parties coming together and agreeing on the fact that he's the right man for the job across different elected cabinets.
Having an expert rather than a politician in the chair of EAM is such a relief 🙌
Dr. Jaishankar has FANTASTIC & COMPREHENSIVE holistic view of the geo-politics. Very clearly leading India's position and LEADERSHIP.
The man for the moment! Couldn't have asked for ANYONE better!
The British while they ruled India had two types of relationship with Russia.While they fought in the Crimea they somehow tried to accommodate Russia with the sole aim of keeping them away from India. Besides depending on Russian arms India has to keep Russia away from the Pakistan, China axis. India cannot afford to antagonise Russia. This is perhaps the defining moment of India's foreign policy. It cannot afford to distance itself from the West.
Speaking from the West all I can say is that the US and UK have both been hegemonic world imperialist powers and they mean to stay so with whatever ruthless, open and covert means they choose. They are in deviousness, experience and imperial ambition of a different order to other powers. They are looters, not to be trusted.
China is also under pressure from the US and UK .
Ultimately my personal hope is for eventual melting away of national enmities and borders and an end to oligarchy. In the meantime active peacekeeping is the best that can be done.
So it must be truly neutral.
thank you for posting this discussion
she ignores British empires evil deeds ,saying Russia ignores soverinty lol
Strengthening our relationship and India's neutrality is paramount so get a guarantee that India will not fuel Putin's war by purchasing Russian oil during the Russian war! Liz Truss is essentially stating the obvious. Liz failed to get the assurances we need. She's exposing our vulnerabilities without getting any guarantees from Modi. There is zero humility!
Kkkkkkkkk
47:27 "MAY I JUST ADD A WORD THERE ?" They didn't want to let Dr S Jai Shankar speak about his own perspective to the question . As if someone would ask this question and Truss would give an answer about India's oil purchase . Coreography at its best . But the anchor let Truss to respond .These are the people who looted 45 Trillion $ from India . Absolutely shameful, disgusting hypocrites.
True and they have a gall asking help here when they are threatened!!
We should be neutral or stand with Russia
@@urjafest2048 dude.. they are not asking for help.. if u observe the whole interview, the underlying vein is that they are very arrogant and blackmailing us that if we don't help them, they won't consider us a humans.
Thank you for sharing...best minister of external affairs till now India had.
I respect how Dr. Jaishankar has been so busy with diplomatic meetings and still have time to be on a program with Britain’s foreign minister.
Clown shows can be enjoyable. :D. It is Punch and Judy.
This guy is phenomenal!!!
" I am not gonna tell India what to do" this single line justified how defensive her approach was in this whole conversation.
They used excellent foreign diplomacy. They used these to impress the Indian officials to sign the free trade deal which benefited UK immensely. That's why they were defensive
He just outclassed her with sheer brilliance.
Just imagine if this was a dialogue between the Foreign Secy of Pak and Uk the conversation would have been all about Kashmir 😂
Uk is promoter of kashimr issue against india do not forgot
😂
@@raj-khotmarathawarriorclan the world does not give a shit kashmir anymore. I mean we removed it's special status and declared kashmir as part our sovereign nation and the world carries on like nothing happend.
nice discussion.
He is right person at right place and on right time.
Good discussion 👌 thanks from Sri Lanka
I strongly believe that world should focus on climate change than war industry (or defence industry more formally) 🤔 🤷
When we see a Historical Monument , it can also be a representation of Barbarianism
When she talks about South Korea and Singapore at 2:37 her little stare gives away her thoughts to demean India's decision to stay neutral and to abstain from publicly calling out Russia when west is the agressor hiding behind Nato forces since 2014
Jaishankar Ji more precise on his words what's the India's position in geopolitical situation
UK Secretary seems to only have ukraine on agenda. Jaishanker handled very tough question commendably well by not taking sides yet holding india's interest high without making any eyebrows raised.
Thanks "The Print"
She tried really hard to make jai shankar sir to say negative comments on Russia 😂😂😂
Want this guy to be PM of India in 2024, would love to vote him. He's quick to counter-that too logically, has the qualification requirements, wise and never backs down, no matter who's infront of you.
But even i know, BJP won't let him run for PM
He is a best place where we need him
well he already doing justice to this post. For wining the election (specially PM post ) you need ground support. So Social media make u famous but cant let u win election..
This man was chosen personally by the PM and appointed to his current position by the PM as well. Yet you sit and criticise them. This hard bold appoach on the international stage has been established by the pm in all his travels overseas. You might want to rethink your dislike for bjp.
What was the need to throw Russia issue in India... Who are they to dictate terms to India as to whom to consider and whom not to...
India has declared herself to be neutral. The free world will need proof of this!
As Truss was in India, request her to watch RRR which was released recently. As she respects sovereignty of nations, she might like the film.
😂😂
LMFAO
😂
The name shouldn't be about India Uk future strategic forums but it should be about Ukraine debate cause that's what they do
Come on UK grow up
Wow both were brilliant from their respective POV
No she could only made historically inconsistent ideological arguments.
Truss: "Germany has changed its entire energy policy"...
Very true... The German goverment is asking its citizens to chop wood for fires for heat (if you have a fireplace?) and to shower less. Kaboem. Energy policy changed.
Hahaha, 😆 I live in Germany and its not that bad
UK should be last country to talk about morality
Have the intelligence to understand that people and nations and indeed the world change/s, and there is a difference between past and present, and perhaps colonialism was needed (though perhaps in a less brutal avatar) to bring structure, and order, and robust and just systems to the relatively less advanced nations. The Indian army, parliamentary system, the railroad and indeed India's unification as a nation, has much to thank the British for.
My comments are the same as Shasi Menon/I fully agree, also he is very brilliant and diplomatic, The right person for the job
I gave lot of respect for him
If we rely on UK for security we are done.
We are not fools to trust UK
Ukraine was!
Trust again......ever 😀
Mr. Jaishankar is superstar in diplomacy.
Thanks Jai Sir ... 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Thankyou Jaishankar 🙏
Dr. Jaishankar did well to DEFLECT the strategic defence partnership question to "global competition". Liz Truss seemed like a SALESWOMAN.
The last Question and answer is the conclusion of this meeting.. jaishankar concluded it in a minute what India's stand.
Love you s jai shankar love 🇮🇳 from North East .
Just watch last 5 minutes ... it's a 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Jaishankar nailed it at the last 👍🏻👍🏻
I could sit and listen and truly enjoy Mr.Jaishankar's presentation and comments and wisdom for several hours. What a contradiction between these two speakers! I don't know why the other person was involved in this forum. Propaganda is recognized from one speaker's side, which is not surprising considering the source.
Its very interesting to see the pull from both sides. Sec Tuss is consistently pulling dialogue in the direction of Russia-Ukraine event while FM Jaishankar trying to focus on mutual relationship more than others.
I think FM Jaishankar seems to be more sensible and will be better for both sides to work rather than focusing only on one issue.
When the s jaishankar ji speak it gives me a goosebumps
These people who are combination of all 7 colour of rainbow are the most dual faced people
Ancient india had always have wonderful AMAZING envoys in wars peace science technology spirituality politics ect.ect.in modern times its like history repeating itself in terms of Indias continuous civilizational gains on THE MOVE....om ekam sat satyam gyanee satiyameva jaiyate vijaiyaooommm....
38:54 is the question "what is historical responsibility". It cannot be restricted to the past 25 years.
JAISHANKAR SIR IS GENIUS
QUESTION for Liz Truss - If China puts missiles and surveillance on Ireland border - what would Britain do?
Hey it's Russia and usa both faults .. we can't deny Russia did a wrong thing. USA used deplomacy to cover it's enemy ...every country do that we also try to overcome pakistan and china in every aspects but through our soft power and diplomacy not by war . In the same way Russia should have use diplomacy ( as all the countries are usually doing so )
UK will have a moral obligation to secure its doorstep. The same moral obligation Russia has been deprived of.
Quite impressive her extempore articulation as well
Jaishankar speach have more sense. He speaks various topics referring to some countries as example. It's fentastic
Europe would cease to exist without Russian LN Gas.
We could be close to that. The war in Ukraine is a UK war against the EU and particularly Germany as well as a USUK war against Russia.
@@casteretpollux why does brit forget their invasion and why did she forget that they meddled with Indian police of Kashmir
Afghanistan happened also close to us
Now they are worried !!! 😠
39:40 second ha ha they journalist made her stammer when asked about historical relationship 😂
Historical responsibility??? Really britan??? Really???
At 48.50 Nice escape from UK 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Its remember a Tamil comedy dialogue
If ur head is bleeding then is a blood for others it's a tomato sauce 🤣😅
உனக்கு வந்தா ரத்தம் எனக்கு வந்தா தக்காளி சட்டினியா
🤣🤣
Mr Jaishankar is a born diplomat!!
Jai hind .
Vande Mataram.
🙏🙏🙏
I would have loved the same unapologetic attitude with the gulf
The response is clearly a sarcastic slap from Sir Jaisankar
I love jaishankar sir .
47:40 goosebumps. 🔥🔥👍🏼👍🏼
Man people like him make us so proud