@@Goldigga5 i've been a kpop fan for almost 2 years so most of what i know is new stuff, ateez is my ult group so love the new stuff but i find myself appreciating the old music too because it's some of the iconic things that new artists grew up with and learned from :')
i first listened to this song when i was 11! you won't believe how happy i am rn that I've finally recalled the title of this song after almost of 9yrs been looking for it because ive forgotten the title😭
Definitely, one of the saddest and most beautiful kpop mvs I've ever seen... This is actually my first time hearing a VIXX song, but it won't be the last
N ~ leader and main dancer. N is uncontestedly fabulous, and he is the eomma of the group, always taking care of the other members. 0:56 Leo ~ main vocal. Leo is very camera-shy and so he initially comes off as cold and uncaring when in reality he's just uncomfortable. Don't be alarmed if you see other Starlights freaking out when he merely smiles or laughs XD. 0:39 Ken ~ (self-proclaimed) cutie main vocal. It's really hard to describe Ken, he's kind of crazy but in the very best sense of the word. He always makes everybody laugh at any possible moment. disturbing lack of ken in this video. quick flash of him singing "kkeutnado" at 2:34. he also sings the super high note at the end with his arms crossed. Ravi ~ main rapper. Ravi is sort of (in my opinion) the second leader in that he's very responsible, N's emotional support, and has also composed a bunch of their non-title-track songs. 1:20 (a.k.a. the hershey's kiss guy) Hongbin ~ visual and actor. Hongbin seems very sweet and innocent, it's incredibly easy to make him laugh, but don't be fooled. You will come to realize that he is incredibly snarky and sarcastic. 1:09 and also the actor in the story Hyuk ~ maknae. Horrifyingly underestimated in the beginning, but thank goodness he's getting more lines and more confidence every day! We lovingly call him Satan because he's a rude snarky little sh*t who loves to prank and mess with the others. starts singing at 1:17 I recommend watching some older VIXX TV to learn the members better :) VIXX does mostly dark/fantasy concepts, my favorites being Error, Hyde, On and On, and Voodoo Doll. Also check out Eternity and Chained Up. Some really good non-title-tracks are Secret Night, Beautiful Killer, B.O.D.Y, Sad Ending, What U Waiting For (Ravi-composed), and Light Up the Darkness. If you like ballads, try Love Letter, Thank You For Being Born, and Badbye.
Coming back to this after almost 10 years is so sad, the group is pretty much done now and living their separate lives. I remember waiting at midnight for the video to release and following them religiously. Then I grew up and life took over. Now, I only occasionally listen to them but whenever I do I'm filled with so much nostalgia. They were beyond talented and deserved so much recognition. I hope that all of them are happy and living well.
Every time I watch this I cry, for 3 reasons. 1- It's one of the most sad videos I've ever seen. 2- The song it's self is so good and I can't handle it. 3- Ravi's hat.
You know, he was the only one who wear it. If the whole Vixx and this girl had it too, the men in black wouldn't find them. What a pitty everybody didn't take it serious and made fun of it...
In case this mv confused you: Hongbin is, mostly, looking at his past. He had a girlfriend, or wife. She got sick and died, leaving him heartbroken. He decided to recreate her into a cyborg. To do this, he became one himself so he could be with her forever. He gave her the real girl's memories. However, the misuse of cyborgs was illegal, and she was almost taken away, but he got her back; the ending shows how they came together as one heart, symbolizing finding true love no matter what. The others play no major roles; I believe Hongbin only created them to see if building a human would work. I LOVE HOW VIXX MUSIC VIDEOS TELL STORIES
When you talked about story in Mv, I used to mentioned those group like Gfriend, and Red velvet. They bringing up storyline in their mv and connect by previous mv that's looking so great. And make me refresh the old Kpop song 😢
@@nrsherra968 I don't know, I prefer the old kpop storyline.. now even if they had a good storyline.. their songs, the rhythm, the production.. all sounds like a pop song. They almost lost their touch as a Korean singer. Most of the group now appears cool, amazing and badass in their music videos.. few groups sounds like the real and old kpop.. which is the original
@Just a Sana Fanboy it's fine for every one has their own taste though? most people will probably prefer older kpop since it wasn't too influenced by western beats.
the nostaligia ommggg 😭 The old kpop days were something else indeed. TVXQ, SNSD, Infinite, b2st, vixx, BAP, Shinee and so many more these new kpop fans will never know about. Damn.
New kpop fans started to run behind popularity and after that this unique era of kpop which made by these 2nd generation masterpieces started to ruin. I’m really disappointed on new kpop fans with my experiences of 7years as a kpop fan😔.
i just became a kpop fan like 6 months ago, but most of my favorite songs are old kpop, like ngl a lot of the recent kpop kinda is starting to sound the same also i came back to watch this bc spotify removed basically all of vixx's songs :((((( i really hope thats a temporary thing cuz this is my favorite song and i NEED it on my playlist
@@oiyoi6974 me too it's been 2 years that I am into kpop and I'm totally attached to all 2nd generation bands and love them so much more than this generation and SNSD are just my ult band with SHINee
VIXX are really unique by their dark concepts. It took my interest and made me their fan. I just feel the emotions by the music so hard. It is really amazing. How can it be so touching? It's just some instrumental things and words I don't even understand. So why I shake and cry about how it's beautiful? I am scared and angry and sad and in love and I actually can't explain what I feel. I just wanted to say, that I love this song and this band. Thank you for reading this. And I am sorry, I can't speak english this well. EDIT : Thank you for likes, I am happy that so many people are interested in what I am saying. I had never before get this much attention and my comments was often being ignored. Thank you! Lots of love.
Dam I cry every time I watch this video. I became Hongbin biased after this. He won me over. Their voices are stunning. I looked up the lyrics and they hit pretty hard.
Comentario en español:) Con esta canción me siento frustrada y emocionada, no sé, muchas cosas a la vez, sus voces transmiten, la actuación fue buena y la coreografía es hermosa y el hecho de que sea bastante literal me encanta, todo es excelente, sin duda alguna una perfomance de buena calidad
I JUST. I DON'T UNDERSTAND I MEAN VIXX COME ON HOW IS EVERY SONG PERFECTION. HOW IS EVERY DANCE PERFECTION. WAITING FOR THE DANCE PRACTICE SO I CAN COVER THIS AT LIGHTNING SPEED OH MY GOD.
This is such an iconic mv. The amount of work put into it and the portrayal of emotions! This is what true talent looks like. Deserves much more recognition.
I miss these types of old kpop music videos where there’s no theories, no speculations, just straight tragic/romantic storylines from beginning to end.
3 days ago I found this masterpiece and I'm obsessed with it. I can't stop listenning to this amazing song. Where have I been all this time? It's a pity, VIXX are not ot6 now. I first learned about these talented guys when I saw Hongbin in a drama. Starlights is a nice fandom, I wish you and VIXX good luck, fighting!
So I was just sitting here with tears streaming down my face and then Ravi showed up with that metal mound on his head and now I'm sobbing while laughing hysterically.
it is a weird hat but it strangely fits the music video well XD I have been questioning what he is wearing on his head for the past 3~4 years watching this music video
@@violet_peaches_7198 i won't call them concept kings just yet (esp since the title was actually given to vixx by korean medias) BUT oneus is definitely heading to the right direction 🥳
I miss old kpop so much The songs, the music videos, the (heavy) eyeliner When groups had their own (music) style I’m glad I could experience these times
This was near the end of the Orchestral Electro + Heavy Eyeliner days of K-pop. Time has passed by so quickly that you won't even realize that this style isn't "in" anymore and that the trends have changed over the past 6 years. I wonder whether 6-9 years from now if people will be nostalgic for 2020-2022 Music. All I know is I grew up over this style as someone born in the 2000s, so realizing that it's long gone is amazing to think about. Time has passed by so quickly.
Awona Macingwane Vlogs! I’m sorry but vixx concepts are on a whole new level that’s why they are known as Concept kings because every comeback has a new concept and I love bts but bts doesn’t really have concepts like vixx does
both bts and vixx have good concepts. but i like vixx more becuase its more fantasy based while bts is based on real things i guess? still both are great. but im more of a fantasy girl
I'm a hardcore army, and now I'm starting with VIXX, and I have to admit that VIXX's concepts are uniques. In my opinion, better than BTS 😂😂 As I said, I love BTS and their conceps are incredible, but a lot of them are pretty common between the idol's groups. Now I see why people call VIXX "The Kings of Concept" 😂
Can we all just take a moment to appreciate a few things? 1. VIXX's amazing group choreographies that always fit the song and the fact that they work so well together. 2. Hongbin's acting. Omg ma feels! 3. The plot and its tragic beauty 4. The cinematography. Amazing. 5. The song. Holy crap, this song is awesome and everyone sounds amazing. 6. Ravi's hat. Enough said.
Meghna Shankar 1. Omfg YES. 2. I knoooowwww ;_; He's not even my bias and I just wanted to hug him in this MV! 3. Totally. 4. I know, right? 5. I love the song and everything (and Leo's voice just asdkfhldkjghdfg AND HONGBIN FOR THE LOVE OF GOD DO NOT SING IN THAT LOW REGISTER UNLESS YOU WANT TO PERMANENTLY FUCK UP MY BIAS LIST), but the _lyrics_ adksjfhdkljghdjkf T.T Just... just look up the translation if you haven't already. 6. Oh God, I _know_. What the actual fuck, costume department? Even Ravi himself said he hated that thing.
와 진짜 심장에 해롭다.... 진짜 약간 심박수 빨라진것같아요..... 이런 헌신적인 느낌.. 그냥 내 전부를 다 갖다 바치는 이런 느낌 너무 설레요...... 진짜 충격과 공포와 설렘을 다 갖다가 마구 뒤섞은 것 같은 감정을 느끼게 함. 어딘가 스산하고 공포스럽고 괴기스러운 면마저 눈을 떼지 못하게 하는 요소 중 하나임..
I've watched this MV so many times and I think I just noticed that the girl is mouthing "Saranghae" as her last words to Hongbin before she finally closes her eyes (shutting down). Also, their tears during their final moments, man! You can't see it right away, but taking a closer look you'll see tears streaking across their face. 😭 These details are so subtle, but realizing that makes this MV even more amazing and still tops as my all time favorite song! 💕💕 Gosh, I love VIXX!
The Universe League issue reminded me of this beautiful song. Thank you btw, I'm glad to hear it like not for the first time but it's been a long time... This is such a great song.
I remember crying everytime I watch this years ago. So rare to see creative concept with actually good music like this lately. Really miss the old days
I remember one of my friends was VIXX fan and asked me if i know them and i said "Yes, i love their new song 'Error.'" and she said to me"Lmao, that was 2 years ago." I was so suprised because the song was so fresh in my memory. However, now it's been 6 years and this song is still such a bop.
Miss this Kpop era😢! We used to like others groups music besides our fav idols, nowadays the Kpop industry is really frustrating, the dirty competition and fandoms fights and wars. We used to support other groups and respect their music😢. Sad for the new fans that missed this Golden era.
Definitely top 10 and up music video in storyline/plot for kpop music videos this year. VIXX never ceases to be amazing and Jellyfish hats off to you for delivering cream of the crop concepts. If they aren't mindblowing then it isn't VIXX. My favorite MV of VIXX's and not just because i'm Kara biased with Youngji....but I am jealous as I'm sure fans are jealous of the scenes with Hongbin haha.
this is the first time i actually checked up on vixx and damn this is unbelievable. i mean rn i only knowN TO BTS but i am open to be a multistan.. THIS WAS ASWM THO
Hongbin and Himchan of B.A.P. are two examples of singers who have like this sweet looking face but then they open their mouths and this deep manly voice comes out and you're like um where did that come from??
+Izy Kuro Nekomimi no Bishoujo Yes. i thought he was a little cinamon roll at first but then i heart him singing and i was like OH MAN HOLY SHIT! Now hes my UB
I love being apart of the Starlight fandom, I have been in it for awhile now and still love it just the same. There is not as much drama within the fandom or as many fan wars. I still love all of the other groups I am apart of (which is all of them tbh, I really get into kpop). Starlights are much calmer but still support VIXX with extreme enthusiasm, it is nice to see this. I also love how VIXX spoils Starlights endlessly.
This is literally the best M/V I've ever seen before. After watching Moorim School and falling in love with Hongbin's acting, I realized he was part of a K-Pop group (that actually sang for Moorim School), so I looked them up. This was the first song I discovered, and I have watched it so many times already and I still want to see it again. Hongbin's part is so cool - such a deep, open voice. Can't wait to hear more of their music!
I just discovered Vixx last week because of Ken and their guestings and I already love them then even without listening to their music yet. But now I'm here listening to Error and I'm almost closed to tears and I can't believe I'm only listening to them now. Consider me a new fan!
It's already 2019 but this song is still underrated
Edit: yoww it's 2020 alreadyy!!
agree..bcoz of this song i know vixx and become a fan...😊♥
how is this underrated
@@nuguteentrash6354 I think i'm saw carat👀 ㅋㅋ
@@gardennie yup im also a carat im multi..elf carat exo-l nctenz monbebe starlight vip aghase inspirit bbc melody...😊♥
Vixx menang kok diacara2 musik dgn lagu ni , thn 2014-2016 tu tahun2 emasnya vixx
the fact that suddenly everyone coming back here to listen this holy song
Yeah👌
quarantine has prompted me to come back and stream this
I feel kpop then was so much more different than now. Those days really were something else. This brings memories back
@@stringbean5259
Been binging old K-pop songs, new wave kpop just isn't the same but gems like this will never die so at least we've got that.
@@Goldigga5 i've been a kpop fan for almost 2 years so most of what i know is new stuff, ateez is my ult group so love the new stuff but i find myself appreciating the old music too because it's some of the iconic things that new artists grew up with and learned from :')
I want to feel sad, but Ravi's hat won't ever let it happen.
sameeee
We have a same brain hahahahhha
same hahahha
Same here😂😂
No soy de corea pero me gusta esta cancion hablo español
If you’re listening to this song in 2023/2024, then you’re a legend. SUCH A MASTERPIECE.
I miss vixx so freaking much 😢 😫 😩 😭
I miss them so bad :((
❤❤❤
i first listened to this song when i was 11! you won't believe how happy i am rn that I've finally recalled the title of this song after almost of 9yrs been looking for it because ive forgotten the title😭
❤
This is seriously one of my favorite KPOP song and MV! Genius!
heyitsfeiii AMEN!
Oh hey. Nice running into you here. I have the urge to learn more about these guys....
heyitsfeiii I agree
FEII !!!
And the cleverest idea from VIXX:
The hat that Ravi wear
Definitely, one of the saddest and most beautiful kpop mvs I've ever seen... This is actually my first time hearing a VIXX song, but it won't be the last
Welcome to the fandom ^_^ let us know if you need help learning the members or want song recommendations
K-Pop Biased Thanks!!! And actually... I do need some Help... And I'd be very grateful if you recommend me some songs ^-^
Welcome to the fandom. Now, you can't escape of them. You will love them forever hahahah O.O
N ~ leader and main dancer. N is uncontestedly fabulous, and he is the eomma of the group, always taking care of the other members. 0:56
Leo ~ main vocal. Leo is very camera-shy and so he initially comes off as cold and uncaring when in reality he's just uncomfortable. Don't be alarmed if you see other Starlights freaking out when he merely smiles or laughs XD. 0:39
Ken ~ (self-proclaimed) cutie main vocal. It's really hard to describe Ken, he's kind of crazy but in the very best sense of the word. He always makes everybody laugh at any possible moment. disturbing lack of ken in this video. quick flash of him singing "kkeutnado" at 2:34. he also sings the super high note at the end with his arms crossed.
Ravi ~ main rapper. Ravi is sort of (in my opinion) the second leader in that he's very responsible, N's emotional support, and has also composed a bunch of their non-title-track songs. 1:20 (a.k.a. the hershey's kiss guy)
Hongbin ~ visual and actor. Hongbin seems very sweet and innocent, it's incredibly easy to make him laugh, but don't be fooled. You will come to realize that he is incredibly snarky and sarcastic. 1:09 and also the actor in the story
Hyuk ~ maknae. Horrifyingly underestimated in the beginning, but thank goodness he's getting more lines and more confidence every day! We lovingly call him Satan because he's a rude snarky little sh*t who loves to prank and mess with the others. starts singing at 1:17
I recommend watching some older VIXX TV to learn the members better :)
VIXX does mostly dark/fantasy concepts, my favorites being Error, Hyde, On and On, and Voodoo Doll. Also check out Eternity and Chained Up. Some really good non-title-tracks are Secret Night, Beautiful Killer, B.O.D.Y, Sad Ending, What U Waiting For (Ravi-composed), and Light Up the Darkness. If you like ballads, try Love Letter, Thank You For Being Born, and Badbye.
K-Pop Biased Wow, this is a lot of information! Thanks, I think this way I'll get faster in the fandom!!!
Because of coronavirus I'm bringing back memories 😭😭😭 I miss the "old K-pop"
😀😀😀
Me too.I'm just wondering were are they now,because they don't have new songs
Saida 000 Me too XD
Same..
same as me 😢 i miss them so much n i miss me 😢
Coming back to this after almost 10 years is so sad, the group is pretty much done now and living their separate lives. I remember waiting at midnight for the video to release and following them religiously. Then I grew up and life took over. Now, I only occasionally listen to them but whenever I do I'm filled with so much nostalgia. They were beyond talented and deserved so much recognition. I hope that all of them are happy and living well.
It really hurts now.. how our life was better with colourful kpop 😢 now life is empty
Every time I watch this I cry, for 3 reasons.
1- It's one of the most sad videos I've ever seen.
2- The song it's self is so good and I can't handle it.
3- Ravi's hat.
yep same
Number three got me whEEZING
Ravi's hat lol
Wheezing through the tears
YALL NEED TO STOP OH MY GOD 💀
up to this day, no one knows what Ravi is wearing on his head.
@Just a Sana Fanboy why did i wheeze -
It's to avoid Illuminati waves
You know, he was the only one who wear it. If the whole Vixx and this girl had it too, the men in black wouldn't find them. What a pitty everybody didn't take it serious and made fun of it...
I'm so angry because of this hat. It makes me so aggressiv for some reasons xD
Lol ask him only
In case this mv confused you:
Hongbin is, mostly, looking at his past. He had a girlfriend, or wife. She got sick and died, leaving him heartbroken. He decided to recreate her into a cyborg. To do this, he became one himself so he could be with her forever. He gave her the real girl's memories. However, the misuse of cyborgs was illegal, and she was almost taken away, but he got her back; the ending shows how they came together as one heart, symbolizing finding true love no matter what. The others play no major roles; I believe Hongbin only created them to see if building a human would work. I LOVE HOW VIXX MUSIC VIDEOS TELL STORIES
Isn't d grl a Japanese singer or something? D one who was in roommates with Jackson?
Aziee Yepthomi she is kara’s former member. her name is youngji :)
It is 2023, and still here I am Error still one of the best MVs. Miss my boys so so much. Me waiting patiently and craving for a VIXX comeback.
They're having a comeback on 21 November
@@bluespring6931 And I am super excited about it. I even already pre-Ordered my copy of Continuum.
FRRR THIS SHI SO GOOD
the best part about the old kpop was the story in mv which is missing these days. it used to make me feel so much connected with the idols.
Right? Now everyone trying to look cool
Same, those I really miss those mvs with a proper storyline, you could look at dreamcatcher's rose blue mv though, it does have a consistent story.
When you talked about story in Mv, I used to mentioned those group like Gfriend, and Red velvet. They bringing up storyline in their mv and connect by previous mv that's looking so great. And make me refresh the old Kpop song 😢
@@nrsherra968 I don't know, I prefer the old kpop storyline.. now even if they had a good storyline.. their songs, the rhythm, the production.. all sounds like a pop song. They almost lost their touch as a Korean singer. Most of the group now appears cool, amazing and badass in their music videos.. few groups sounds like the real and old kpop.. which is the original
@Just a Sana Fanboy it's fine for every one has their own taste though? most people will probably prefer older kpop since it wasn't too influenced by western beats.
the nostaligia ommggg 😭 The old kpop days were something else indeed. TVXQ, SNSD, Infinite, b2st, vixx, BAP, Shinee and so many more these new kpop fans will never know about. Damn.
New kpop fans started to run behind popularity and after that this unique era of kpop which made by these 2nd generation masterpieces started to ruin. I’m really disappointed on new kpop fans with my experiences of 7years as a kpop fan😔.
i just became a kpop fan like 6 months ago, but most of my favorite songs are old kpop, like ngl a lot of the recent kpop kinda is starting to sound the same
also i came back to watch this bc spotify removed basically all of vixx's songs :((((( i really hope thats a temporary thing cuz this is my favorite song and i NEED it on my playlist
@@oiyoi6974 me too it's been 2 years that I am into kpop and I'm totally attached to all 2nd generation bands and love them so much more than this generation and SNSD are just my ult band with SHINee
Yeah it's a shame
That's right
VIXX are really unique by their dark concepts. It took my interest and made me their fan. I just feel the emotions by the music so hard. It is really amazing. How can it be so touching? It's just some instrumental things and words I don't even understand. So why I shake and cry about how it's beautiful? I am scared and angry and sad and in love and I actually can't explain what I feel. I just wanted to say, that I love this song and this band.
Thank you for reading this. And I am sorry, I can't speak english this well.
EDIT : Thank you for likes, I am happy that so many people are interested in what I am saying. I had never before get this much attention and my comments was often being ignored. Thank you! Lots of love.
Hundredth likes of your comment.
i love vixx my love hkn
I feel the same. This music is just too beautiful
Dam I cry every time I watch this video. I became Hongbin biased after this. He won me over. Their voices are stunning. I looked up the lyrics and they hit pretty hard.
Comentario en español:)
Con esta canción me siento frustrada y emocionada, no sé, muchas cosas a la vez, sus voces transmiten, la actuación fue buena y la coreografía es hermosa y el hecho de que sea bastante literal me encanta, todo es excelente, sin duda alguna una perfomance de buena calidad
This is whole ass 16 episode kdrama right here!
No one else coming close to their concepts... I miss themm
😭
do you ever just cry because a whole vixx exists
I JUST. I DON'T UNDERSTAND I MEAN VIXX COME ON HOW IS EVERY SONG PERFECTION. HOW IS EVERY DANCE PERFECTION. WAITING FOR THE DANCE PRACTICE SO I CAN COVER THIS AT LIGHTNING SPEED OH MY GOD.
Cover it as soon as you can please Heather!! :3
67cynthike67 I think the dance practice will come out after 1 mil. views on the MV but not 100% sure. Gahhh
IM HERE SCREAMING MY HEAD OFF HEATHER OMFG
Jellybeannose Yeah it's 1 million.
But imagine how soon that will be- were like 7 minutes in and its already at 400 views
Jellybeannose LMAO HEATHER I KNEW YOU WERE GONNA BE HERE!!
so yall telling me this group has been here the whole time and ive been sleeping on them
wow.
Dabi’s Daddy aish me too 😔✌️
Since 2012,, same here. Just knew them in 2018, where i first entered kpop and they were the 1st one i got into and still my fave group.
Welcome 😁
Same here
same... i only found them last year (2019) :( tbh i wish i’d found them earlier
This is such an iconic mv. The amount of work put into it and the portrayal of emotions! This is what true talent looks like. Deserves much more recognition.
i hear someone crying.
oh, wait. it's me.
Lay Papas Fritas haha accurate though
Lay Papas Fritas And me. This dang video gets me everytime
Lay Papas Fritas Haha I know, I cry everytime. And Hongbin's tears almost made me cry at first (>////
Same
Lay Papas Fritas true
i hate when talented groups dont get recognition. 10 million and it was released 2014?!! this is a beautiful song why aren't there more views?🙁
Ikr, this was the first kpop song I ever listened too!!This is so unfair!
That's pity because it is my favourite song in general
IKR... This song is also available on CJENMMUSIC Official which has 4.4M views, btw.
Kookie's Suga Glazed Donut thats so sad💔 this song had me in tears!
SunKissedTaeTae
I miss these types of old kpop music videos where there’s no theories, no speculations, just straight tragic/romantic storylines from beginning to end.
Yes! Those were the times 🥺
Yes it’s fourth generation but I can’t come over this. I really want Songs like these again…
And don’t get me wrong fourth generation is also nice😅
You came for 2022 SM entertainment’s dumb overbloated ass and came hard.
Stream Hype Boy by NewJeans for real 4th gen music
“No theories, no speculations”….
Are you sure we are talking about VIXX!?
Because I have some news for you…. 😅
VIXX… the kings of “It’s… complicated”
3 days ago I found this masterpiece and I'm obsessed with it. I can't stop listenning to this amazing song. Where have I been all this time? It's a pity, VIXX are not ot6 now. I first learned about these talented guys when I saw Hongbin in a drama. Starlights is a nice fandom, I wish you and VIXX good luck, fighting!
Hongbin is robot because his beauty can’t be real
Yup you're right💓
You’re right It’s 2020 and I still think Hongbin is the most handsome Idol I ever see
@Just a Sana Fanboy you don't just remind me of the sadness i'm feeling right now
This is a deep storylined MV and then there's Ravi looking like a gnome with his hat ( 1:21 )
Mx Kays 😂😂😂
Mx Kays look, I’m just glad he’s not fainting again?
@Tannah LEWCZUK 😂😭
@Tannah LEWCZUK such a funny comment
😂😂😂😂
I miss the old K-Pop 😭 SNSD, T-ara, 2NE1, Wonder Girl, f(X), Sistar, EXID, VIXX, Beast, Big Bang, Infinite, BTOB, B1A4, B.A.P, Block B...
Same😭😭
2nd gen kpop
:((
Sameeeee
Mblaq, Boyfriend
My heart hurts every time I watch this MV. The story and the song are heart-wrenching. It's so beautifully made.
Crying, again, this never gets old. If you want tears, please come here. i am sure we will find a place for you.
Old kpop is so much better tbh
old kpop hits different bro
@@ally376 literally ❤️❤️
MISS OLD KPOP . LETS CRY TOGATHER MATE :'(
No kidding. 😭😭😭💔💔💔
I MISS THIS ERA OF KPOP LIKE CRAZY
So I was just sitting here with tears streaming down my face and then Ravi showed up with that metal mound on his head and now I'm sobbing while laughing hysterically.
Sophie G this song is so emotional that hat saved us from depresion :-)
Sophie G i just choked on my drink help
уже 2023 год, но каждый раз, когда я слушаю эту песню, по коже пробегают мурашки. шедевр, больше у меня слов нет
Proof that Hongbin is like,
peak performance visual
I can't stand watching him cry....Even if it's fake.....NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I know right
@@atinyseonghwa Same. He is just the most adorable little thing. (he's not really little just figuratively )
who of these great performers is Hongbin?
the main actor @@PersonManManManMan
I don't know why I'm crying. It's either because Hongbin is crying, or I laughed too hard at Ravi's hat
Noelle Killarney bless that hat tho
it is a weird hat but it strangely fits the music video well XD I have been questioning what he is wearing on his head for the past 3~4 years watching this music video
Leonardo Ravinchi i love your name so much :')
Rofl
The world wasn’t ready for VIXX at that time :(
I agree :(
اعرف الاغنية يوم كان عمري 5 والحين عمري13
@@Kang_daniel_wife
نونو 😂😂🤍
This hit me right in the feels, as you are probably 100% right :(
que vuelvan
I remember when VIXX was literally one of the most famous K-Pop group
WE NEED A VIXX COMEBACK Y'ALL I MISS THEM SO MUCH.
I know I am not the only one :(
I miss them
THEY NEED TO COME BACK AND SAVE KPOP CONCEPTS AGAIN T-T
@@gomenz631 alot of people won't admit is but vixx is the concept king to today's mv
yes :( miss all of them
Ot6😭🙏
Until this day no other group did what VIXX did with different concepts, You got to respect them for that , KINGS of the concepts
Don't worry , there's a group called oneus in the 4th gen who are the concept kings , hope you look into them. They give me Vixx vibes
@@violet_peaches_7198 i won't call them concept kings just yet (esp since the title was actually given to vixx by korean medias) BUT oneus is definitely heading to the right direction 🥳
@@disenthrall4859 True
@@violet_peaches_7198 l was almost gonna tell this 😅
There is but a girl group though, but i can't say this group is the same as vixx but it's almost similar
The girl group name Dreamcatcher
This song will forever be iconic,
and don't tell me otherwise
I miss old kpop so much
The songs, the music videos, the (heavy) eyeliner
When groups had their own (music) style
I’m glad I could experience these times
still one of the best title tracks to ever exist in kpop industry
Definitely, but by all means, it’s also very hard to top this kind of quality
That's true.😍
I think vixx is one of the boy groups who really try their best in being a idol boy group
Veed Aquamarine true
Veed Aquamarine where's the lie.. 😭😭😭
Yes to this
Rin린2513 Well they tried really hard to be a girl group as well.
@@yennavaneeuwijk1890 true😂😂
Are you dutch by any chance?
Hongbin's voice, Hongbin's face, Hongbin's abs, Hongbin's dimples, Hongbin crying, Hongbin with that girl, I'm just not okay right now
I feel you
Yeah, and his incredible acting skills. I miss him so much❤
This still holds up years later as one of the best mvs ever made. Always makes me tear up. Vixx was way ahead of their time. ❤
Rewatched this is 2020 and it still makes me cry.
Me too😭😭😭😭😭
Same😭😭 I really love them ppl gotta stop sleeping on them!
same kkkjjkjk i miss that time
ME TOO AND THIS IS THE FIRST TIME THAT I SEE A MV KPOP
Me 2😭😭
Damn starlights still here right? I miss vixx so much :((
still here and will always be here💕💕💕
Yess always ❤️
We here, always gonna be here
I’m here
I never left💫💜💙💜 I miss them so much!
this song hurts a little more that it did before, i'll never get to see vixx as a whole now
Me too😭
I miss them 😭
😭😭
I know I felt that so hard😭😭😭😫
wait, I'm new, what happened???
They don’t make these kind of masterpieces anymore 🥹 I left K-pop longtime ago but I still comeback to watch!
This was near the end of the Orchestral Electro + Heavy Eyeliner days of K-pop. Time has passed by so quickly that you won't even realize that this style isn't "in" anymore and that the trends have changed over the past 6 years. I wonder whether 6-9 years from now if people will be nostalgic for 2020-2022 Music. All I know is I grew up over this style as someone born in the 2000s, so realizing that it's long gone is amazing to think about. Time has passed by so quickly.
"heavy eyeliner days" lol true 😂
This is so true. 😭😭
exactly its not easy to find a song with good instrumentals these days
Well The Sandman on Netflix at least brought back that aesthetic with Dream’s style in the bonus episode
Vixx actually has such interesting concepts mainly for a boy band like wow
Awona Macingwane Vlogs! Agree, I'm a hardcore army but I like vixx's weird and odd concepts like voodoo and this
Awona Macingwane Vlogs! I’m sorry but vixx concepts are on a whole new level that’s why they are known as Concept kings because every comeback has a new concept and I love bts but bts doesn’t really have concepts like vixx does
I'm a hardcore army. But of what I can see, Vixx has more "twisted" concepts. I think that VIXX Is are the kings of concepts and BTS will follow them.
both bts and vixx have good concepts. but i like vixx more becuase its more fantasy based while bts is based on real things i guess? still both are great. but im more of a fantasy girl
I'm a hardcore army, and now I'm starting with VIXX, and I have to admit that VIXX's concepts are uniques. In my opinion, better than BTS 😂😂 As I said, I love BTS and their conceps are incredible, but a lot of them are pretty common between the idol's groups. Now I see why people call VIXX "The Kings of Concept" 😂
Can we all just take a moment to appreciate a few things?
1. VIXX's amazing group choreographies that always fit the song and the fact that they work so well together.
2. Hongbin's acting. Omg ma feels!
3. The plot and its tragic beauty
4. The cinematography. Amazing.
5. The song. Holy crap, this song is awesome and everyone sounds amazing.
6. Ravi's hat. Enough said.
1. It's kind of a miracle
2. He has a lot of potential!
3. A lot of effort went into it :D
4. RIGHT?
5. RIGHT????
6. Nope I don't see anything there
Meghna Shankar 1. Omfg YES.
2. I knoooowwww ;_; He's not even my bias and I just wanted to hug him in this MV!
3. Totally.
4. I know, right?
5. I love the song and everything (and Leo's voice just asdkfhldkjghdfg AND HONGBIN FOR THE LOVE OF GOD DO NOT SING IN THAT LOW REGISTER UNLESS YOU WANT TO PERMANENTLY FUCK UP MY BIAS LIST), but the _lyrics_ adksjfhdkljghdjkf T.T Just... just look up the translation if you haven't already.
6. Oh God, I _know_. What the actual fuck, costume department? Even Ravi himself said he hated that thing.
***** Um... wut?
Rosie Deacon I guess he is referring to that shit on Ravi's head as a garbage bag.
back to the days when kpop was on a different level... i miss this kind of kpop, these kind of MV's
For new fans, VIXX is a group of guys who sing only songs that satisfy them rather then songs that would make them famous. This is why I love VIXX 💕 💕
omg your profile is Haebin I love you
Hongbin: *conveniently cries while shirt is unbuttoned ;)))*
VIXX are seriously sooo underrated, like HOW??!?
I don't really think so they have won many awards and have had world tours already and even got a solo concert 2 years in
+lol56ari she probably means why aren't they popular like BTS, Exo, got7
+lol56ari I mean, why isn't everyone talking about them? I don't think VIXX will ever receive the recondition that deserve
+Melisa Mantilla I agree! They are so good not to be hyped about!
Agreed! They're so talented they deserve more recognition
와 진짜 심장에 해롭다.... 진짜 약간 심박수 빨라진것같아요.....
이런 헌신적인 느낌.. 그냥 내 전부를 다 갖다 바치는 이런 느낌 너무 설레요......
진짜 충격과 공포와 설렘을 다 갖다가 마구 뒤섞은 것 같은 감정을 느끼게 함.
어딘가 스산하고 공포스럽고 괴기스러운 면마저 눈을 떼지 못하게 하는 요소 중 하나임..
We love vixx, we support them, we support HongBin
I hope oneday fans comeback here to support them
@@walkwithmil9727 i'm here! Waiting for vixx to comeback into my life ;(
I m exo-l i support him tho vixx is ot6 no one can change
Starlight forever I miss hongbin so much T-T
@@cresenciavalencia8569 may I know what happen to hongbin?
I am still getting chills from this song. Iconic. Like Ravi's tinfoil hat, never forget this masterpiece
2020 anyone? There was nothing error with that
I found one:
Ravi's hat
@@kathydelossantos2144 Yeahh its too weird🤫
Xder kot..haha
ERAH HUSNA ✌️
Waa
Happiest 11th Anniversary VIXX!! ❤ I will attend a concert if they do have it, miss you guys 😢
Yah mat fao famile
I've watched this MV so many times and I think I just noticed that the girl is mouthing "Saranghae" as her last words to Hongbin before she finally closes her eyes (shutting down).
Also, their tears during their final moments, man! You can't see it right away, but taking a closer look you'll see tears streaking across their face. 😭
These details are so subtle, but realizing that makes this MV even more amazing and still tops as my all time favorite song! 💕💕 Gosh, I love VIXX!
Another perfect song from VIXX.
PS: Wow, they look so handsome in the video. Also the girl in the video is so beautiful.
ya,they all beautiful
That girl is also a kpop idol... She is KARA's maknae Youngji...
I listened to this again and many memories flooded my mind 😢💔
Who's here in 2019 ??
I love them
Lol this MV never gets old
💔💔💔💔
Baek hyunee this is literally me rn
The Universe League issue reminded me of this beautiful song. Thank you btw, I'm glad to hear it like not for the first time but it's been a long time... This is such a great song.
Me: "I'm not into K-pop, I'm just not bothered for it"
*Discovered vixx*
Also me: "umm never mind this is too good!!!!"
Also, I'm not crying, you are
literally me in 2018
ohh i see we share the same destiny concerning kpop
I remember crying everytime I watch this years ago. So rare to see creative concept with actually good music like this lately. Really miss the old days
Same I miss this type of kpop music
Count me in. I miss this type of concepts and creativity
until nowww aaaaaah
I almost cried 💔
If you have time, I hope you can check 'Why' by ONF...
Ravi’s hat is the highlight of this video
ROFL
이 곡은 Vixx의 명곡이다.
난 자주 찾아 듣고 보고 있다.
This is my first VIXX song. I wasn't prepared for this. I'm genuinely crying.
@Excuse Me Jungkook You nice keep going! I also knew VIXX also because watching MOORIM.
same-
Welcome to the fandom
Welcome to the fandom new STARLIGHT☆
I don't read vixx fanfics, but I'm pretty sure this video debuted a shit ton of good robot fanfics into the vixx fandom.
I was thinking the same thing
You should've seen us after chained up
This is the best comment ever.
+Mint doesn't give an f Yoongi lol xDDD
whats gonna happen after dynamite... OR FANTasy,
I remember one of my friends was VIXX fan and asked me if i know them and i said "Yes, i love their new song 'Error.'" and she said to me"Lmao, that was 2 years ago." I was so suprised because the song was so fresh in my memory. However, now it's been 6 years and this song is still such a bop.
Help???? I've been thinking like this too :(
Miss this Kpop era😢! We used to like others groups music besides our fav idols, nowadays the Kpop industry is really frustrating, the dirty competition and fandoms fights and wars. We used to support other groups and respect their music😢. Sad for the new fans that missed this Golden era.
can someone please send then to museum because they're a piece of art.
The last choreo was awesome... This is my first vixx mv I've ever watched and I love then!
Their choreo always tell a story. You can tell that even the minute details are well thought of and done with the concept in mind.
Everybody say thank you Vixx for constantly provided bops and amazing performances
This deserves 1B views but nope because i dont think these days fans know this masterpiece... I literally love this soooo much 🥺
Don't worry. It's on Geometry Dash now :) Still verifying the level.
Literally the only thing wrong with this MV is Ravi's hat.
Rhiannon Edwards he hated it too >.
I feel sorry for the hat
Its so true it looks like a tinfoil hat
U mean the only thing Funny!?
😂😂😂
looks like a trash can with paint onto it
Definitely top 10 and up music video in storyline/plot for kpop music videos this year. VIXX never ceases to be amazing and Jellyfish hats off to you for delivering cream of the crop concepts. If they aren't mindblowing then it isn't VIXX. My favorite MV of VIXX's and not just because i'm Kara biased with Youngji....but I am jealous as I'm sure fans are jealous of the scenes with Hongbin haha.
Yeeeeeeeeeh!!! ^-^
I would like to be acting with Youngji!!!
Yeahhh~~that's true!
Hey mrpopo I totally agree it's amazing watching your reaction next
Agree!!! I love it!!
Lee Hongbin, youre such an amazing actor and artist. We love and support you so much. Please smile and be happy. #weloveyouHongbin
Why are good songs in Kpop always underrated?!!!
I'm sorry but this type of productions are the one who deserves more 300 millions of views.
Damn right!!
@Daniel Perez Alvarez which MV are you talking about?
this is the first time i actually checked up on vixx and damn this is unbelievable. i mean rn i only knowN TO BTS but i am open to be a multistan.. THIS WAS ASWM THO
it took me 5 years to realize that the girl is mouthing "I love you" in the end
Just finish me
Simon Lerbs oh ow
I did not even knew that!
I watched this before because of VIXX and also Heo Youngji. ^^
I was today years old
i realized this after reading your comment and suddenly it makes the song 35x more sad
It's mid-2018 but I still can't get over Ravi's hat
just love Taeil,please
Honey, no one is 😂
its 2019 and no one has got over it
Elsa😂😁😀😎😘😘😚😙😊😊😊😊😔😱😱😱😱😇😇😇😇🙅🙅🙅🙅🚵🚵🚵🚵🚵🚵🚵🚵🚵🚵👫👫👫👫👫👫👫👫👫👫👫👫👫✌✌✌💕💕💕💕💕💕💕si💖💖💕💖💕💕💕💕💕💕💕No te extrañaré y te morís a ti mi amor sí
*I NEED THAT HAT*
@@PersonManManManMan si 💖 💗💖💗💖💗💖💗💖💗💖💗💗💗💋💋💖 Dios guapo mua
they no longer make a music video like this anymore. the drama? the acting? the music? man i miss those days
Hongbin and Himchan of B.A.P. are two examples of singers who have like this sweet looking face but then they open their mouths and this deep manly voice comes out and you're like um where did that come from??
+Ian J There needs to be more deep/baritone singers in kpop. They add so much to the harmonies and song.
+Ian J TaeTae aint an exeption either XD haha when you hear them - you're already melted...
+Izy Kuro Nekomimi no Bishoujo Yes. i thought he was a little cinamon roll at first but then i heart him singing and i was like OH MAN HOLY SHIT!
Now hes my UB
+BTSTrash hahhahaha same here gawl! XD but on does not simply choose a bias in BTS!!! (and the past tense of "hear" is "heard", "heart" is
+Bapsae Also Kim Taehyung
I love being apart of the Starlight fandom, I have been in it for awhile now and still love it just the same. There is not as much drama within the fandom or as many fan wars. I still love all of the other groups I am apart of (which is all of them tbh, I really get into kpop). Starlights are much calmer but still support VIXX with extreme enthusiasm, it is nice to see this. I also love how VIXX spoils Starlights endlessly.
they spoil us and give us great music :)
they are truly the concept kings of kpop. no one can make videos like theirs, they all feel like movies of some kind. so proud to be a starlight
🥺💖💖
facts
Forever
A song from 10 years ago sneaking its way into my Spotify Wrapped. Great music never fades. VIXX, you are timeless.
beautiful song, beautiful choreography, beautiful music video. this deserves 100m views tbh
The first video I'm watching in 2018. Off to a good start 👌
yes
SOOOOOO?????
hopefully no more weird hats (like ravi’s) in your 2018 though
Phan On The Side
That’s good luck, especially since it’s VIXX!
This is literally the best M/V I've ever seen before. After watching Moorim School and falling in love with Hongbin's acting, I realized he was part of a K-Pop group (that actually sang for Moorim School), so I looked them up. This was the first song I discovered, and I have watched it so many times already and I still want to see it again. Hongbin's part is so cool - such a deep, open voice. Can't wait to hear more of their music!
The same here, though my first song was "Alive" from Moorim School.
It's impossible to listen to this song and watch the video without tears😢
I love Error sm. Thank you VIXX!!!❤
I just discovered Vixx last week because of Ken and their guestings and I already love them then even without listening to their music yet. But now I'm here listening to Error and I'm almost closed to tears and I can't believe I'm only listening to them now. Consider me a new fan!
Sarah Jane Palo welcome to the fandom, St☆rlight baby! :)
I can't believe I am just finding out about Vixx now
how is that even possible
I am disappointed in myself
seriously they are flipping amazing
Soooo guys, who's on a VIXX marathon again? 😭😂
me
🙋♀️ i miss them ;;-;;
ME
Me 🤧❤
Meeee
Still my fav kpop song ever. Hopefully their upcoming comeback will have their old sound
This group is something else. Their concepts are always so interesting, their dance and visuals too. One of my favorite songs
2:03 that part was Awesome I REALLY LOVE THEIR VOICES BUT I ALSO LOVE THEIR VISUALS. *VIXX FIGHTING*
after 7 years, still cried for this MV, also for Hongbin :(
Same 🥲
I miss him 😭🥺
Yes. Hongbin was my bias and this is my absolute favorite song of VIXX and many others. 🥺💔
What happened to Hongbin?
Yeah boi
Kpop highkey needs to bring this genre back
Fr
Fr
Fr