When I listen to it, I never realize it’s 10 minutes. It goes by so fast for me and that’s VERY impressive for a long song. Like?? She made 10 minutes feel like a regular 3:30 song
the power of story telling huh, the 5 minute version has a better build up to climax and fall back, but she did great with the buildi up and sustaining that power in that BRIDGE AHHHH.
A lot of the lyrics allude to other songs tbh. -Her turning 21 connects to 22 as her 21st birthday was possibly her worst, so she wanted to make 22 her best -Him not showing up to her birthday connects to “The Moment I Knew” -The “twin flame” lyric connects to “State of Grace” -“did the love affair maim you too” connects to “Sad Beautiful Tragic” -and many more but it’s a lot to cover in a comment lmao
Whenever I hear the long outro of this song, it makes me think of a conversation she’s either having to him or herself where she’s trying to convince herself/him that it wasn’t just her imagination. Those feelings and moments were real. Like, “You can’t say you(he) felt nothing for me. It was rare, I was there. I remember it, you remember it.”
@@Ok_Loren Yes. I love that part. And I usually despise overly long outros lol but it really fits here. Everything in this song has a purpose. I love it 🥰🫶🏻
This song... anyone who's ever loved someone who hurt you and you really truly loved them. This is song grabs you by the hand and pulls you back for a few seconds ~ you remember who you were then and who you are now. It's like smiling when you think of that person and you can't even begin to describe the feeling of it all, the song lingers and you do too - just for a moment before continuing forward.
It was originally cut to around 5 min for the original Red album. But, that version was the cut/edited version from a much longer 10+ minute song. This is closer to how the song was originally written in 2011 before it was cut. This song now is the longest’ #1 song in history beating out the 50 year record “American Pie”. I’d like to see you react to the Vault tracks from Red TV. Starting with Ronan (not officially a vault track but it’s not on the original Red album). I think Red TV is still performing outstanding for a re-released 10- yr old album.
it's so strange to me cause whenever i listen to a song 3 times it's pratically "oh 10 minutes or 15 minutes have passed"... but this song.... THIS SONg... listening to it 3 times is 30 minutes... half an hour... and it didnt feel like it
So she is re-recording her old albums because her old record label sold the original masters to a third-party, and i it offered them to her for extortionate prices. In order to make a statement about artists owning the work that they wrote, she is reproducing her old albums under her new record label to regain ownership. But as part of this she has added old songs that were cut from the albums originally, to show that she is the one who made these albums and knows what didn’t make it.
They never offered to sell the masters. They offered to give her one past album due every one new album she delivered, which means she would never own them. So she left. The label then sold the company to a third party instead of giving her the opportunity to purchase her masters.
they sold them to scooter who had bullied her for years and they said if she wanted her albums she had to record a new one for them for her to have an old one they did a lot of shitty things and basically tried to manipulate her etc they were never going to let her own her masters
To cut it short, she only gave them the fish. She didn't teach them how to get it that they became selfish enough to own the whole lake to control her from fishing. So she wrapped up everything, get to the boat and starts to travel the sea. They didn't know that she's the brightest and amazing fisherwoman out bc they are always belittle her. They can never outsmart her.
I’d love to see you react to the short film, just purely to see if it’s exactly what you were envisioning in your head. I know I was amazed when the short film came out, because it was perfectly what I evisioned in my head before I even had a visual to go along with it.
Taylor does not own the master recording of her first six albums and they were bought by someone she hates. As a result, she is re recording all of them (using Taylor´s Version to differentiate them) so that she owns them and devaluates the original ones. In each re recording she releases extra songs from the vault that were written for the album but did not make it. In this case, it´s the originial version of ATW which was cut down to 5min for the original RED album (2012)
I am a 90's kid and my attention span is not like the Tiktok generation. So if Taylor makes a 1 hr long song it won't matter I would still listen to it with the same attention to a 5 min song. Anyway this song is a masterpiece.
this is hilarious because i know at least 12 people my age ("tiktok generation") who had this song on repeat for days when it came out. and thousands more if we count online fans. Taylor swift is for all ages no matter how long her songs are :)
@@bhoot3732 I wouldn't blame them, we've been in quarantine, stuck with our families, with an internationally declining mental health average, for years now. if they want to have fun on tiktok and make Jokes™ I don't see why we should judge them. it's better than breaking the health and safety laws, and it's funny how youtube of all places has these comments when 10 years ago it was /youtube/ that was (old man voice) "ruining the kids attention span" like... overall, don't be judgy. live your life. let them live theirs
that was great! im loving Heat Above by Greta Van Fleet, and also the Live Performance of Meet Me at our spot by Willow and Tyler Cole (The ANXIETY) .... so if you want to react to them id love it!
![PASULOL รามเกียรติ์ ตอนที่ 4 นนทกพบรัก [Ramakien Ep.4: Nonthok in love]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tMUQgmZzf_A/mqdefault.jpg)
![Exile - Taylor Swift ft. Bon Iver (Long Pond Sessions) [FIRST LISTEN]](/img/n.gif)
Its the longest number one song in the history with out any radio play
When I listen to it, I never realize it’s 10 minutes. It goes by so fast for me and that’s VERY impressive for a long song. Like?? She made 10 minutes feel like a regular 3:30 song
the power of story telling huh, the 5 minute version has a better build up to climax and fall back, but she did great with the buildi up and sustaining that power in that BRIDGE AHHHH.
it's actually 20 minutes, her co-writer said it in an interview
This song actually hit #1 on the Billboard top 100
Wow!
@@nathanlongwell
The 10 min song has a short film
You may want to react to it
For 13 weeks right?
It actually debuted at number 1 but went down to number 2 the next week and didn’t go back to 1
@@kxxn693 1-4 and then fell off bc of Christmas songs
i enjoy watching people who enjoy listening to Taylor😭😭
I loved watching you enjoy this song! She is indeed a lyrical genius
A lot of the lyrics allude to other songs tbh.
-Her turning 21 connects to 22 as her 21st birthday was possibly her worst, so she wanted to make 22 her best
-Him not showing up to her birthday connects to “The Moment I Knew”
-The “twin flame” lyric connects to “State of Grace”
-“did the love affair maim you too” connects to “Sad Beautiful Tragic”
-and many more but it’s a lot to cover in a comment lmao
the three months in the grave part connects to we are never ever getting back together
Whenever I hear the long outro of this song, it makes me think of a conversation she’s either having to him or herself where she’s trying to convince herself/him that it wasn’t just her imagination. Those feelings and moments were real. Like, “You can’t say you(he) felt nothing for me. It was rare, I was there. I remember it, you remember it.”
I always think of that way, too. She’s not letting him gaslight her.
@@Ok_Loren Yes. I love that part. And I usually despise overly long outros lol but it really fits here. Everything in this song has a purpose. I love it 🥰🫶🏻
Listen to nothin new or forever winter by taylor!! you won't regret
Watch the short film!!! Omg it's amazing!
Ok! I’ll have to check it out!
This song... anyone who's ever loved someone who hurt you and you really truly loved them. This is song grabs you by the hand and pulls you back for a few seconds ~ you remember who you were then and who you are now. It's like smiling when you think of that person and you can't even begin to describe the feeling of it all, the song lingers and you do too - just for a moment before continuing forward.
Beautifully worded
@@nathanlongwell thank you 🥺 have an amazing day!
The line "So casually cruel in the name of being honest" breaks me every time.
It's such a masterpiece
It was originally cut to around 5 min for the original Red album. But, that version was the cut/edited version from a much longer 10+ minute song. This is closer to how the song was originally written in 2011 before it was cut. This song now is the longest’ #1 song in history beating out the 50 year record “American Pie”.
I’d like to see you react to the Vault tracks from Red TV. Starting with Ronan (not officially a vault track but it’s not on the original Red album). I think Red TV is still performing outstanding for a re-released 10- yr old album.
it's so strange to me cause whenever i listen to a song 3 times it's pratically "oh 10 minutes or 15 minutes have passed"... but this song.... THIS SONg... listening to it 3 times is 30 minutes... half an hour... and it didnt feel like it
What would I give to listen to this for the first time...
So she is re-recording her old albums because her old record label sold the original masters to a third-party, and i it offered them to her for extortionate prices. In order to make a statement about artists owning the work that they wrote, she is reproducing her old albums under her new record label to regain ownership. But as part of this she has added old songs that were cut from the albums originally, to show that she is the one who made these albums and knows what didn’t make it.
They never offered to sell the masters. They offered to give her one past album due every one new album she delivered, which means she would never own them. So she left. The label then sold the company to a third party instead of giving her the opportunity to purchase her masters.
they sold them to scooter who had bullied her for years and they said if she wanted her albums she had to record a new one for them for her to have an old one they did a lot of shitty things and basically tried to manipulate her etc they were never going to let her own her masters
To cut it short, she only gave them the fish. She didn't teach them how to get it that they became selfish enough to own the whole lake to control her from fishing. So she wrapped up everything, get to the boat and starts to travel the sea. They didn't know that she's the brightest and amazing fisherwoman out bc they are always belittle her. They can never outsmart her.
@@alexdr751 so beautifully written
I used to listen to All Too Well with you when I felt lonely and it helped me a lot to get better. Thanks for your reaction .❤️
I finally found it😍 that song means so much to me🤭 it's a top 5 best song of her periodth
Like a good book you can’t put down, this song I can’t stop listening to it. It’s a masterpiece as is Taylor Swift.
I love the Sad girl autumn version of this song, its more cut back and focused on the vocals.
LETS GOOOO
The copyright gods have smiled upon you, huh? 👀
Yeahhh. Always the worst. Had to wait a month, but we here
Amazing song for me
Maybe it does sound repetitive because she is actually revisiting and rerecording her old albums? I genuinely cannot wait for 1989 TV
I’d love to see you react to the short film, just purely to see if it’s exactly what you were envisioning in your head. I know I was amazed when the short film came out, because it was perfectly what I evisioned in my head before I even had a visual to go along with it.
The outro is one of the best parts of the song. Taylor/Antonoff classic!
I lowkey thought that you were Niall Horan and got excited
Dang!! 😄
@@nathanlongwell I don’t know why but google translate changed your “dang” to “spread” and that’s just so funny to me 🙈💀💀
It translated to Pale for me, that’s weird and funny at the same time.
Taylor does not own the master recording of her first six albums and they were bought by someone she hates. As a result, she is re recording all of them (using Taylor´s Version to differentiate them) so that she owns them and devaluates the original ones. In each re recording she releases extra songs from the vault that were written for the album but did not make it. In this case, it´s the originial version of ATW which was cut down to 5min for the original RED album (2012)
Listen to Message in a bottle!!!!!!
Kept you like an oath part is it for me. Never again xox
WHY SO FAAAR AWAY?? RELEASE ITTT
Its from Red Album
I am a 90's kid and my attention span is not like the Tiktok generation. So if Taylor makes a 1 hr long song it won't matter I would still listen to it with the same attention to a 5 min song. Anyway this song is a masterpiece.
this is hilarious because i know at least 12 people my age ("tiktok generation") who had this song on repeat for days when it came out. and thousands more if we count online fans. Taylor swift is for all ages no matter how long her songs are :)
I hate how our whole generation has been named the “TikTok generation” cuz of some American kids who had nothing better to do-
@@bhoot3732 I wouldn't blame them, we've been in quarantine, stuck with our families, with an internationally declining mental health average, for years now. if they want to have fun on tiktok and make Jokes™ I don't see why we should judge them. it's better than breaking the health and safety laws, and it's funny how youtube of all places has these comments when 10 years ago it was /youtube/ that was (old man voice) "ruining the kids attention span" like...
overall, don't be judgy. live your life. let them live theirs
i have adhd and am also the "tiktok generation" and have listened to this song non-stop.
Watching you love this made me love you. Damn
❤️❤️❤️💯
react to The Moment I Knew plz, it's s relevent song.
Ahhh. You're so cute! 😇❤
that was great! im loving Heat Above by Greta Van Fleet, and also the Live Performance of Meet Me at our spot by Willow and Tyler Cole (The ANXIETY) .... so if you want to react to them id love it!
Awesome!! Let me check em out! Thanks for the suggestion!
Please! React to Short Film! It’s amazing 🙏🏼
react to the short film of this song
how are ur videos not blocked by yt? lol
I always dispute, and hope for the best. Sometimes they get blocked 🤷🏼♂️
Olivia Rodrigo 4MV reaction please
React more Taylor
Please react to Blue weekend by Wolf Alice or Keep reacting to Red TV
ahh it's an 8-minute song and a 2 minute outro. still great though