I’m simply love the way how u explain & educate about singing. I’m not a singer neither am i a super fan of any artists in all your videos. I listen to random musics as a lighting programmer for concerts. But u really made understand more about vocal. I have watched almost all your hmm i will put it as i mean i see it as ‘education’ videos of vocal. I ❤ it! Please don’t stop doing this.
this is charice's all by myself ver from philippines. you might as well want to give a reaction to charice's performances. will definitely give you goosebumps😊🇵🇭
Her English name "Ghost" is a direct translation from her Chinese nickname "鬼鬼“. In Chinese there are these words such as "鬼馬""鬼點子” where the character "鬼" just means quirky, smart, witty, which is probably where the inspiration for her nickname came from, but the character also means "Ghost" in other contexts
我觉得有些可惜的地方，是没播放完对战的两位先手由开始到对战完后，到最后结果出来后完整版，我相信那时看到老师的脸色会更精彩百倍，又有对比又有爆点更有出彩点更有为何会型成奇案，老师的看法会不会有更大的出彩点形成更大的惊喜。 赵大格的aint no mountain high enough 是否真得灵魂到可以胜最好之一的女歌手黄宵雲，是否东西方的看法不同，或是媒体都在暗箱里，不然我都不知道到底是谁在打谁的脸了，8年前的黄宵雲就能成中国最好之一，那对比现在到底是进步到怎样了
Sou brasileiro, Como pode uma pessoa cantar desse jeito e perder a competição eu não sei que tipo de jurado é esse que não percebe a grandiosidade dessa menina que canta como ninguém, canta com a alma essa sabe o que faz é um privilégio ouvi-la cantar.
黃宵雲 還唱了 5th Element 那首crazy song。可以看一下 單依純 也有好幾首動聽的英文歌，可以讓老師多review一下。 Sorry would go a long way Paper Heart Weak Remember Me (中英雙語) Part of your world (中文版) 感覺Rozette對那些她本身耳熟能詳的歌比較有共情感。
Glad that you react to her Ghost Huang! Try her 黄霄云-打开（当打之年）、那时的光、Oracle （live) 、天下无双、左手指月 all these are mind blowing performances, especially at her age!
THANKS for doing this video. Chills immediately ran down my spine when you said she is one of the best signers in China, and I concur. Unbelievably this was also the song that had her eliminated from the Voice and it remains the biggest upset in the show's history. Now, the case be closed. The judges were definately....🐠🐠
I believe she took inspiration from Charice's version. Charice was a Filipino singing prodigy who got discovered on TH-cam and for a short while had worked with David Foster touring the world alongside big names like Patti LaBelle, Brian McKnight, Josh Groban and more.
Too bad that fans from different camps among the young female Chinese singers often "fight" against each other. Popularity in China is being shared. She is one the the better ones I like to listen especially on this song. Too bad, not on all the songs she sings. I think I am starting to notice that Coach Rozette is good in judging on appropriate usage of techniques.
Have you heard Charice"s cover of this song? She performed it several years ago in Mandalay Bay with David Foster and I would love to hear your reaction to it.
You should do a video on several the voice contestant's performance. The 5th season in particular has some strong performances during the battle rounds. At the time it wasn't called The Voice anymore, they rebranded it to Sing!China and it was their first season, probably some legal issues. Anyway, one is the 郑迦文《Goodbye My Lover》cover of James blunt's original and another is 徐歌阳《一万次悲伤》a cover of a song from a Chinese band. The latter especially, kind of went viral, her subsequent performances I feel, didn't match up tot hat bar she set with that performance in the first battle round. the Jame's blunt cover had pretty much similar arrangement to the original, even his singing too which I think is what's so great about it because contestant tend to try and change the arrangement and make it different to give it their own spin and whatnot but he didn't. To me, those 2 performances are the best 2 performance in the entire season even though it was so early in the season, but would be interesting to see if it holds up to your technical scrutiny as well
Have u heard the version of Charice for this song with David Foster I find her rendition (the voice) of this song influenced by Charice Hope ull do a reaction with it to❤
@@elles.7331 I've noticed that part which is the exactly same pattern runs of Charice version immediately.It's because I am the huge fan of Charice. Althought, she became into HE. Missed her.
黃霄雲是近年來華語歌手裡最不科學的完美存在，幾乎沒有任何能挑剔的地方，太令人震驚的表演🎤
個人給予最最高的評價，絕對沒有之一。
認同
認同
近幾年 就出了 她跟周深兩個怪物.....都不像人 兩個一開口都讓我頭皮發麻
是的，一群黑子带节奏说没感情，请问哪里没感情了？？？？？？
認同
我也覺得她歌聲超富情感也超有技巧
12:10当老师完整演绎这一句的时候，那震撼的感觉直冲天灵盖，真的好强。希望华语乐坛能多一点老师这样的歌手，而不是满大街“完美”的修音歌曲
黃霄雲 左手指月!! 但其實她的現場幾乎都神級 看哪個我都開心😁
黄霄云是天才。
當年她輸了，真令我傷心
她是第一名畢業
絕對出色
又漂亮
現在看到她的成就
很替她開心❤
毕竟好声音第四季她才16岁，能达到汪峰组四强很不错了，貌似参加完好声音，她就去中央音乐学院报道了，学成之后《星辰大海》就进入不温不火的时期了
一直很想老師評黄霄雲😍終於看到了！！真的強炸！！期待天下無雙和左手指月的評價！！
老師果然是實力唱將👏👍
我个人最喜欢周深，但黄霄云确实是天才中的天才。这种条件出现在内娱更是难得。
当年听黄霄云这首震撼到无法言语，谢谢老师的点评，受益匪浅。
I’m simply love the way how u explain & educate about singing. I’m not a singer neither am i a super fan of any artists in all your videos. I listen to random musics as a lighting programmer for concerts. But u really made understand more about vocal. I have watched almost all your hmm i will put it as i mean i see it as ‘education’ videos of vocal. I ❤ it! Please don’t stop doing this.
很少看到老師 給出那麼高的評價
喜歡黃霄雲！很開心老師喜歡她。她cover的左手指月，跟阿蘭合作的"餘年"，還有跟尚雯婕的"不鼓自鳴"，都很美。或許老師會有興趣聽聽？
也非常喜歡最後老師的版本，強混很強！是颯爽派大女主的all by myself❤很讚啊
(唯一缺點是太短了，廳不過癮啊)
當初看她這場輸了的時候差點沒把電視砸了，真的是非常厲害，所有挑惕她只有技巧沒感情的那些所謂的「評審老師」，要馬是黑幕，要馬就是認知自己不如對方，只能用那種方式詆毀。永遠支持黃
只能说除了硬实力的张碧晨和单依纯两冠军以外，好像现在当红实力派的都是些早早被淘汰掉的选手，懂的都懂😂😂
@@ffodadwwc 張碧晨該屆並不是最強 在那英組也只能算中上
@@qt3953 确实。但可能是看在她的潜质，毕竟很多内幕我们不懂，张的外型和实力都互相匹配，而且如今的成长也确实对得起当年的冠军头衔。
@@ffodadwwc這個我贊同
哥们，这是个节目，是有出资人的，人家花钱了，当然要捧人家指定的人选，黄是来做客的，属于蹭吃，还顺便挣钱，这已经是赚上加赚了。
这是买卖，既然是买卖，就有主力商品，和代卖商品，心态平和些，她又不是就一个节目，就死翘翘了，以后大有机会啊。
黃霄雲-我用所有报答爱
+1
支持
我一直都觉得她超级强，没有任何疑问，但是之前她被黑的很厉害的那一阵，我都开始有点怀疑自己是不是听觉出了问题，难道是我太主观臆断了？今天看到这么专业的评论才知道自己没问题，同时也认识到了“大众”的影响力真的不是一点半点，低水平歌手可以吹成神，高水平歌手可以被喷成过街老鼠。
大陆观众普遍喜欢装乖的艺人，她在歌手节目上几句话没讲'对'，网络观众就再也无法欣赏她的音乐。这其实是很可悲的状况，典型例子 像华晨宇这种33岁的清纯男孩才能吃得开。
某花就是其中代表，唱歌永远千篇一律，嘶吼过后呻吟。一丝情感也无被吹成拯救华语年轻一代的神。黄霄云就是年龄小，需要经验和情感精力，结果就被群嘲。
不是你的问题，是他们的问题 没脑子和自己的思想，跟风还有看一段综艺片段就自以为认识她了🙄 还网暴 可见素质 内心有多黑暗
@@brandfeng5114 某花還是有喜歡他的客群，他的風格本身很極端沒錯，但不代表你可以否定那一客群，花被黑慘某部分可以說是粉絲太吹害的。
Aww I love her ❤ amazing vocals
在老師眼裡黃霄雲就是女版周深😂
她真的超強～聲音很高，可厚實可輕薄
科班出身，聲樂，海豚音各種技術都是嚇死人的
貨真價值的超級實力派女歌手😂😂😂
唱歌沒感情被黑，個人是覺得她有些歌曲或者live是看得出感情揣摩的，甚至眼神都可以透露出她用心放感情❤
不認同，周深不會只顧炫技！
大错特错🤔️，老师眼里黄就是一个可塑之才，一位明日之星，而且还年轻！
同样的，没有经历和阅历以及时间去沉淀，同样的歌她唱就会给人差一点的感觉，每个人喜好不一样，起码没感动到我，不是否认她的实力！
当你拿深深做对比，抱歉了，我也是资深海米一枚，深深一路走过来的艰辛，黄并没有体会过，这点拿深深的大鱼是最佳例子，一直在变化一直在提高，最开始的电影演唱，到配合郭的双人鱼，再到歌手的大鱼进化版！
老师是欣赏黄，但对深深是真爱粉，差别大去了😅😅
周深的粉絲真可怕😧
得罪不起，得罪不起！
好好好，你們說的都對，我也是很喜歡周深的
已經看過無數次他的視頻～
但絕對不及你們對他的愛，你們的愛比他父母還高，比天還高，我也只是以老師觀點比喻而已，這只是比喻，沒必要這麼在乎挑語病，老師外國人哪會知道周深經歷過什麼，哪又會知道霄雲經歷過什麼，他們兩個都有被黑過，被世人無法接受過，只不過是不同層面，不同程度，不同理解，也沒有所謂的誰比誰更可憐、更值得被關注、更值得被同情，只是以一個外國老師什麼都不懂以聲音的樂理程度、造詣、技術來看，霄雲對老師來說可能是女版周深，沒必要這麼在乎用字遣詞，這樣比喻也不行，那只能說太狹隘了，海米應該在這世界容不下任何周深二詞的比喻與分享看法，任何人都不能跟你們的深深比。
@@DavidWu1105我是霄雲的粉絲 也很喜歡周深 不過我很擔心深深被歌迷捧得太高而招來黒粉 最後甚至淪落到華晨宇現在這樣
黃霄雲的「天下無雙」 真的要做一期
跟左手指月一起做一期吧
那場修音太多了
@@吳侑澤-d8q并没有，她唱了这首很多次现场，她唱啥歌都不修音 反而很多时候是反修音，修音对她来说只是有更好音质而已
@@khaisiang1806 反修音也是修音啊，主要是這樣點評就不好看了，會失真
超期待這期的！黃霄雲超強的版本
真的享受！！好棒❤也謝謝橘老師帶著我們來看
為什麼聽起來是舒服的😊
这两个完全可以长期做，都是很强的年轻人
老師說得對 真的是中國最優秀的女歌手
黄霄云一直都很强
She is really great and lovely! Frank and friendly, really really very rare!
黃霄雲是音樂學院出來的，大家可以去聽他的唱的魔笛，是有實力的
他唱的夜后聲音技巧超強! 美聲技術純熟! 但表情不對! 夜后是很邪惡兇惡如同巫婆! 他表情太清純可愛了!
She is also capable in classical and opera music!
聽霄雲唱這首歌簡直雞皮疙瘩掉滿地
老實說這老師說的完全跟我想的一樣，她初期會每個尾都加轉音，觀眾容易會審美疲勞，但是整體來說技巧厲害的可怕。
但是現在我聽起來尾音問題也沒了，主歌簡單了很多，現在她唱歌完全是完美，天籟，不接受反駁😂
❤
One of the best singers in China? That's a crazy compliment.
this is charice's all by myself ver from philippines. you might as well want to give a reaction to charice's performances. will definitely give you goosebumps😊🇵🇭
老師提到副歌那段很像席琳狄翁的時候… 我認為這種稱讚是每個歌手至高的讚許和榮耀了…
Her English name "Ghost" is a direct translation from her Chinese nickname "鬼鬼“. In Chinese there are these words such as "鬼馬""鬼點子” where the character "鬼" just means quirky, smart, witty, which is probably where the inspiration for her nickname came from, but the character also means "Ghost" in other contexts
Oh my my 神
Very happy to hear suck kind of comments , for I just like it so much to listen to Huang Xiao Yun.
I would love to hear Rozette react to her 左手指月。she is great.
有機會也可以聽聽看黃霄雲的「sad sometimes 」想了解老師對電子音樂的感受跟想法。
我觉得有些可惜的地方，是没播放完对战的两位先手由开始到对战完后，到最后结果出来后完整版，我相信那时看到老师的脸色会更精彩百倍，又有对比又有爆点更有出彩点更有为何会型成奇案，老师的看法会不会有更大的出彩点形成更大的惊喜。
赵大格的aint no mountain high enough 是否真得灵魂到可以胜最好之一的女歌手黄宵雲，是否东西方的看法不同，或是媒体都在暗箱里，不然我都不知道到底是谁在打谁的脸了，8年前的黄宵雲就能成中国最好之一，那对比现在到底是进步到怎样了
我很喜欢看见老师做评论时双手舞动，面部表情十足都样子。
為黃霄雲的歌聲點讚，就是喜歡，不容反駁。
Lovely
求讚推高，再敲碗林憶蓮大魔王😂忍不住了，當Rozette老師說霄雲是華語頭三的時候。。《我是歌手》的任何一首都可以：她有唱Leona Lewis的《Run》，無賴則氣音和belting都有、魔王級盛夏光年。。。首首精華，不能盡錄，相信Rozette會喜歡
Very professional comment.
有人说归功于黄霄云的学院派的美声的专业学习 歌剧的演唱技巧，专业第一名等等😅当然后天的学习可能塑造一个人的专业素养，而且每年音乐学院都有各唱法的专业第一名，好像也没有都像她一样，如同老师的评论说的一样 她是现象级的！一个某方面的卓越超群和天才，当然90%归功于自己的天赋，后天的可有可无的所谓人为的大众化 制式化的学习 也只是对天赋的精雕细琢，而且对某些人浑然天成的天赋异禀来讲 是画蛇添足、弄巧成拙、非常多余的😂😂希望黄霄云和周深都能唱出自己更多的作品和经久不衰的个人作品❤
Sou brasileiro, Como pode uma pessoa cantar desse jeito e perder a competição eu não sei que tipo de jurado é esse que não percebe a grandiosidade dessa menina que canta como ninguém, canta com a alma essa sabe o que faz é um privilégio ouvi-la cantar.
Sorry the scandal of this competition is the winner is set
Love Rosette‘s reaction as usual, they are fun to watch and insightful. FYI, Huang Xiaoyun is also known as Wink XY😂
黃宵雲 還唱了 5th Element 那首crazy song。可以看一下
單依純 也有好幾首動聽的英文歌，可以讓老師多review一下。
Sorry would go a long way
Paper Heart
Weak
Remember Me (中英雙語)
Part of your world (中文版)
感覺Rozette對那些她本身耳熟能詳的歌比較有共情感。
希望可以看到近期霄雲表演的解說！
Glad that you react to her Ghost Huang! Try her 黄霄云-打开（当打之年）、那时的光、Oracle （live) 、天下无双、左手指月 all these are mind blowing performances, especially at her age!
THANKS for doing this video. Chills immediately ran down my spine when you said she is one of the best signers in China, and I concur. Unbelievably this was also the song that had her eliminated from the Voice and it remains the biggest upset in the show's history. Now, the case be closed. The judges were definately....🐠🐠
Try Gigi de Lana's version or rendition of "All By Myself", tnx! ❤❤❤
I believe she took inspiration from Charice's version. Charice was a Filipino singing prodigy who got discovered on TH-cam and for a short while had worked with David Foster touring the world alongside big names like Patti LaBelle, Brian McKnight, Josh Groban and more.
Her vocal is amazing. Just unparalleled. I have the moment of feeling everyone else's songs rubbish when changing immediately from hers to others🤣🤣
這頻道曾出現的年輕歌手
我最喜歡的女歌手是黃霄雲.男歌手是周深
目前那個高音現場唱最好的還是夏芮絲 胸聲十足
老师歌瘾犯了，中门对狙😂中国还有很多优秀的年轻歌手，老师可以慢慢挖掘。
當年我覺得一個16女孩能唱成這樣，只能說未來可期
當年聽驚為天人，也感慨這麼小的年紀竟然能表達這麼複雜的情緒真不簡單，可惜節目有黑料，雖然沒有取得名次，但幸運的是並沒有影響她的演藝發展
@@echooohce 当年节目没黑料，是底下的媒体评委们因为讨厌汪峰而故意淘汰掉他战队的黄霄云。
好声音冤案来了
推荐歌曲-谭维维(乌兰巴托的夜)
推荐+1❤❤❤
推❤
Rozette 老師還是技癢下場來一段了，
雖然不意外就是了~
Agree no more with Rosette, this young girl is now one of the top talented singers in China! 🎉
喜欢
老师可能不知道 这场PK 黄霄云居然输了 可笑 哈哈😂
沒錯 旁邊的男生應該跟老師講的 講中國好聲音有多陰暗 還有之前老師讚譽有加的coco 也被節目欺負 還死亡的事
正常 誰付的錢多誰就贏 付的少就淘汰
应该要两个都听，看看老师评价，和表情😂😂
輸就輸了，有什麼可笑，你厲害怎麼不去當導師
@@sheyokoso講這些要幹嘛，能改變什麼，這個頻道老師只是對音樂給於評價，你不喜歡好聲音不要看就好，到處取暖有意義嗎
My top 2 favorite famale singer, Huang XiaoYun, and Shan YiChun
贵州大山里来的，纯天然的纯真
I love her.
单依纯和黄霄雲都打算做长期系列吗，虽然各听了两场但都才刚刚开始的感觉，比较重要的现场都还没听😂
这个版本的黄霄雲如今听起来甚至有点陌生了。现在的唱法变化挺大的，头声明显变强了很多，但是混声中真声的比例似乎降低了。有时候会比较怀念这个时期的唱法，感觉更“流行”一点
单依纯好想要去歌手2024，之后应该挺多素材可以react。
@@FCG-j4h 这种消息未免太捕风捉影了，这节目有没有还不一定呢
黄霄云确实是优秀的实力派！可否麻烦老师有机会听听姚贝娜…
光光聽了娜的，黃宵雲好很多，
期待老师评论她唱的左手指月
她和周深，都是评委不可达到的高度。
以前有没有评过姚贝娜的《all by myself》，对比一下会很有意思。
敲碗黄绮珊-我是歌手power of love👏
哈哈 刚查了 7月25在周深《人是》留言有让小编来点黄霄云，老师应该会喜欢 学院派 🤭👍👍🤣
老師聽葉秉桓唱歌可能會瘋掉😂
Pls tell coach she’s from classical opera background like zhou shen.
这两年也有些作品。比起来感觉还是进步挺大的
Please try a Amei concerts review. The best mandarin female singer.
想看老師反應sohyang 的I have nothing
Too bad that fans from different camps among the young female Chinese singers often "fight" against each other. Popularity in China is being shared. She is one the the better ones I like to listen especially on this song. Too bad, not on all the songs she sings.
I think I am starting to notice that Coach Rozette is good in judging on appropriate usage of techniques.
Have you heard Charice"s cover of this song? She performed it several years ago in Mandalay Bay with David Foster and I would love to hear your reaction to it.
I also find her (the voice contestant) version influenced by rendition of charice with this song
求点评张敬轩！！！！！Hins Cheung
9:10 唱得上去是一回事 維持住又是另一回事w
想聽阿妹版本的I Will always love u
想聽24歲的麵包唱這首歌，會跟16時的麵包
有什麼差別😂😊
我想只會更好
真的是太恐怖了😮
JJ Lin 也有翻唱 All by myself.. 想看老师的reaction
Would like you to react to Charice’s version then, since this arrangement is largely based on that.
trueeee this is charice's version 😅
簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍
遇廣告看完看🈵
期待reaction LD的声乐游乐场
You should do a video on several the voice contestant's performance. The 5th season in particular has some strong performances during the battle rounds. At the time it wasn't called The Voice anymore, they rebranded it to Sing!China and it was their first season, probably some legal issues.
Anyway, one is the 郑迦文《Goodbye My Lover》cover of James blunt's original and another is 徐歌阳《一万次悲伤》a cover of a song from a Chinese band. The latter especially, kind of went viral, her subsequent performances I feel, didn't match up tot hat bar she set with that performance in the first battle round.
the Jame's blunt cover had pretty much similar arrangement to the original, even his singing too which I think is what's so great about it because contestant tend to try and change the arrangement and make it different to give it their own spin and whatnot but he didn't.
To me, those 2 performances are the best 2 performance in the entire season even though it was so early in the season, but would be interesting to see if it holds up to your technical scrutiny as well
黄霄云太完美了，大陆的人就说她唱歌没有感情，总是打压她
说的是声音原创性太少，但是模仿很厉害
@@hsiangron 看看国内舆论再说
Have u heard the version of Charice for this song with David Foster
I find her rendition (the voice) of this song influenced by Charice
Hope ull do a reaction with it to❤
這個版本是模仿 Chairce 版本的吧
希望老師也可以聽看看 Chairce 版！
希望能看老师能点评 菲律宾 丁诗瑀 Birdy ( All by myself)
這邊就能看出中文的聲調快把歐美人士搞死了🤣老師很可愛也努力的想抓準
黄霄云的水平一直都是超一流，但是那个阶段的她声音还比较闷在里面。推荐老师点评黄霄云和林志炫的《#给电影人的情书》，她的声音终于打开了。看黄霄云和林志炫的《#给电影人的情书》如何完成老林声音年轻化的蜕变，再和单依纯的版本一起对比一下。我一直觉得单依纯和黄霄云超级厉害，不知道老师觉得谁更厉害哈哈，还有老师的besty深深的版本🤣🤣这下子更难了。
我们的歌 她当时状态不好，还是react她唱的寸心，我用所有报答爱，不鼓自鸣那些
You should listen to jj lins version of this song with david foster
Charice Pempengco 唱的有可能的都評一下，佢應該係除原唱外演繹得最好
小编，可以放一下姚贝娜🙏吗，她也唱过这首歌
其實黃這個版本的部分是 參照 Charice 的翻唱 不知道有沒有人注意到~~ 但兩位都是很厲害的歌手
yes, charice's version is so popular.
@@elles.7331 I've noticed that part which is the exactly same pattern runs of Charice version immediately.It's because I am the huge fan of Charice. Althought, she became into HE. Missed her.
Could reveal HEBE or SODA Green see if you like their Voice. ❤😊
I want to send you my singing video, but I don’t have that high quality 😂😂😂
可以請ROZETTE老師點評一下 黃宣 的 獨上C樓嗎？
黃宣的音色真的很特別呢～