on the other hand because of the limited scale of this war policy... perhaps it's not worth fighting and losing soldiers over these terms of engagement and the best thing to do is stop for now and come back after biden leaves the white house and trump moves back in... or come back with a new pm one dedicated to winning...
There is better evidence for non human made UFO's than for God. God is fiction created in the minds of humans. Our connection with Israel is by and large real, from a partial heritage point of view...
Moshe Feiglin understands the issues very well. No surprises from Bibi, very predictable. Decisive action, as you have stated, is not possible under with the current Govt, high command and high court reign.
I agree with the Rav about Iran, Bibi did say in his speech they were going for Iran. I pray its true because we need to end this horrible war. I also pray Hashem will help us end this horrible war, bring Mochiach and techeus hameisim. Inbthe meantime its wonderful to have a quite red alert app B"H and bli ayin hora. So relaxing
Off course Israeli young men died for nothing as whole world was ready to help in ceasefire and spare these young men who died . Oslo has won , netanyahu has failed , khamenei has won , Sinwar has won ..MBS and Sissi and Erdogan have lost ..
Something does not add up here. Should we not go to the streets yet…with those in the north who obviously can’t go home under the insane “ceasefire agreement”? Praying Lebanon won’t accept it!! ❤️🇮🇱
I thought that the cease fire included the stipulation that no Lebaneese or terrorist would approach within 5 miles of the Israeli border or risk getting shot in the head. I don't really know if that is what I heard. I was listening to the news in Hebrew while I was driving and I thought that was what they said but not sure.
None of us have any clue what happened behind closed doors and what he was threatened with. He is playing the goal game and waiting for Trump to get into power. Politics is a game and he is playing it.
It’s cowardice. Bibi is so unstable in his behavior. One day brave one day coward. This is so upsetting!!!! What happened to we’ll fight with our nails if we have to????
Netanyahu wants to kiss up to trump and people forget the aa accords the 2nd phase is to start giving up judea and Samaria as annexation was promised not to do for this deal. I hope this turns out a repeat of what sharon did.
General Observation Quantum Jidadics Though ojects look inert ( ceasefire ) , they are not . Their atoms never cease moving . Eg .India Pakistan ceasefire and unceasing Pakistani islamic terror attacks on India.
If you want to keep land from flooding in a particular area, is it wise to try to destroy the sea or to keep it at bay with infrastructure? If you try to destroy the sea, it is so vast that more and more water will keep coming at you and you will use up all your energy ending in failure- because too much exists for the amount of space, it evaporates but then comes back as rain. Maybe Netanyahu has decided strategically that Iran iand Hesbullah are like the sea and it is a better decision to have infrastracture which endures keeping Iran at bay- let the Iranian regime ware out its energies with its persuits. This can be seen as a martial arts kind of philosophy which leaves space for opponent to disipate or waste their power. I'm not saying this is correct- just that it is a plausible stratergy. Netanyahu has not surrended to Hamas.
The Lebanese people of the south are descended from people who where Jews around the time of the last days of Judea and Samaria before Jesus and his followers started changing he demographics. You should be seeing a peace with them, and accept limits to what land Israel seeks because those people are also descended from the line of Isaac, they are just the people who converted to Christianity after Jesus and then later most families converted to Islam, but you can view them as fellow ethnic brothers and as subsects of the same faith, especially the Muslims whos concept of God is the same. Remember, Arabic is a just a language to the Lebanese, but ethnically as the DNA proves, the people there have the same genetics as the historical Jews, and the same is true for the Palestinians whos ethnicity is far closer to the historical Jews than any modern day European Jews. The issue is that most Israelis see Lebanese and Palestinians as sub human, and pretend they are ethnically different when they are not. A peace based on the original 1967 UN lines will be accepted by Palestinians and Lebanese and all Muslims, and this would lead to eventually integrating Israel into the region with trade and respect, but instead , extremists like Jonathan Pollard only see the zero sum game thinking and seek to treat their fellow Canaanite neighbors as Amalek, but despite all the biblical stories, the Jews are descended from the common ancestry of Canaanites just like Lebanese and Palestinians just as Hebrew is almost identical to Canaanite/Phoenician/Punic languages.
Im an Australian and not religious but even i can see that's not the problem at all, all groups live together in Israel fairly peacefully, there is even many Arab muslims in the IDF (they could call themselves Palestine if liked as have the DNA) All that would happen if Israel agreed to 1967 UN lines, is it would mean Jews wouldn't be able to live on or even visit the lands that they were named after Judea and that they have so much connection and history too, but worse is Israel would still be a attacked but from positions that look directly over Israel including built up areas. It's insane to think Palestinians would ever be happy with a two state solution, they wont be happy until there is no Israel and no jews, many aren't shy about this. From the river to the sea, isn't the 1967 UN lines.
There are no culture of Palestine they are refugees mixed from desert lands gypsies mostly and Arabs mixed from the regions Gaza's the Palestine is not on Koran as a culture a tribe nothing Palestine as a name on Israel on land not a people only if Palestine was a state it's not a state yet they are still trying to make a state though the say they Palestine the word is not Arabic and no economy or culture language exist they say Palestine as the are staying and most came from Arab region some Arab people too they never had a state but used the word if I live in wilderness as Ido on a farm I say I'm from the country not from the area and we are in a country the wilderness iS our culture we are wild but out state is not it's just a place we are citizens and Gaza's Palestine's have Israel citizenship and permits not Palestine because it never was a state. Not real only a name Arabs are called Palestine due to living there but it's the same land as Israel too only Israel can register them legally as Palestine was never a legal state to do so proof Israel did not steal the land Arabs lived there years with Jews Arab squatters but they all had peace together
@@Elly-d4d it's a quip that holds truth, the REAL father of the Palestinian Movement is Leonid Brezhnev. Palestine (detached from history as the Roman name for Judea), is a Soviet psy-op to poker finger in America's eye and betray Israel for leaning to America instead of leaning towards the USSR.
@@goldersgreen2177 They can be be better appreciated if they describe those books and contents than in adding fire to wars which can only consume more children and youngsters of all sides .
These Rabbi need to be called out and need to put the same energy in condemning the genocide in Gaza Period! All 🇮🇱 does targets civilians women & children in 🇵🇸 & 🇱🇧 absolutely it’s shameful & shocking!
The treachery was initiated by US intelligence in refusing to live up to the agreements to share US intel with little besieged Israel. He saw the injustice, called it out, and the US intel system refused to rectify their wrongdoing. Yes, he wrongly took action to right the wrong and he was severely punished for it.
These long bearded gentlemen could make themselves more useful to us gentiles by pointing out the books .seen behind and explain briefly their contents . Regarding war , this war has not ended if hamas and PLA is not involved in ceasefire and peace , grand and total war is still inevitable ..
you need to understand the goals of Hamas , they stuck to retrieve their hostages, and to end the Abraham accord because it meant peace with all Arabs without ensuring a fair peace for them, they achieved the main goal of ending the Abraham accord and the Palestinians are no longer politically isolated. So from here , its up to Israel to decide if they can accept the coming peace. Israel cant handle a war without America, they could not make any gains in Lebanon despite all of Pollards tough talk, if America retreats from empire, then Israel will choose peace, and the day Israel accepts peace based on the 1967 lines, there will be a permanent peace, and with the coming increase in political pressure, the Israelis will eventually be forced to accept peace and so they should as the Palestinians and Lebanese and the dependents of ethnic Israelites who converted to Christianity and eventually many to Islam.
Jonathan, what you need to understand, there is also an outside world and a civilian and economic world. If ceasefire gets Hezballah behind Litani and gets the thing shut down for good (for much longer time than 18 years it has been since 2006) than that outweighs clearly going deeper into debt, economic crisis, loosing more soldiers. Becoming a more and more unjustified a 1st class pariah state. Have problems with the economy and people who could have jobs have non, if tourism and specific economic branches collapse ever more or stay collapsed. We can fight forever if we want to, basically you could escalate the Ground War on the ground step by step into Syria, Iran, Iraq and Turkey. They are proud maniacs, they rather starve their children to deasth than stop fighting without keeping any kind of face in an agreement... So either have a straightforward Plan to have greater Israel or something like Levant Federation under full Israeli rule or find the exit rather sooner than later with ceasefire agreement...
"If ceasefire gets Hezballah behind Litani and gets the thing shut down for good (for much longer time than 18 years it has been since 2006)" This really is the primary question. Would it last that long?
Bibi is not a traitor. It's a lot easier to say what he should and shouldn't do than to be in his shoes. I can't imagine the stress that he's under but I think he's done a great job so far. I know I'll probably get a lot of flack for saying that but that's my opinion and I'm entitled to it. I respect you Mr Pollard very much and have learned a lot from your discussions with the Rabbi but I don't agree with you here about him being a traitor.
this is a betrayal of immense proportions...
on the other hand because of the limited scale of this war policy... perhaps it's not worth fighting and losing soldiers over these terms of engagement and the best thing to do is stop for now and come back after biden leaves the white house and trump moves back in... or come back with a new pm one dedicated to winning...
Not at all
@@Avocado740 not at all what?
@@primoshe2 to the "on the otber hand" comment
@Avocado740 but the war is going badly with heavy casualties because as usual israel is being forced to fight with both hands tied behind its back...
There should never be a cease fire until victory is achieved.
There’s no “victory” against an ideology at least try to understand that. This Genocide must and will end one way or another!
Dear Rav David and Jonathan, Shalom from Givat Chananya/Abu Tor, Jerusalem. Aryeh Yosef
God is steering His people to ask for Him alone.
There is better evidence for non human made UFO's than for God. God is fiction created in the minds of humans. Our connection with Israel is by and large real, from a partial heritage point of view...
I pray Mr. Jonathan Pollard get a very serious senior Government job to help protect Israel 🇮🇱
Moshe Feiglin understands the issues very well.
No surprises from Bibi, very predictable.
Decisive action, as you have stated, is not possible under with the current Govt, high command and high court reign.
I wish Israel would have Moshe as their prime minister he is a true patriot
Only Feiglin
Moshe Fegelein? Wasn't he a German officer or are you being funny.
@@australiaprisonisland9156 didn't know that
I agree with the Rav about Iran, Bibi did say in his speech they were going for Iran. I pray its true because we need to end this horrible war. I also pray Hashem will help us end this horrible war, bring Mochiach and techeus hameisim. Inbthe meantime its wonderful to have a quite red alert app B"H and bli ayin hora. So relaxing
Thank you for being with us, our light and truth, Hashem is with you, do not leave us Rav, you are our teacher❤
Why to let hezbollah survive especially after pager operation
Off course Israeli young men died for nothing as whole world was ready to help in ceasefire and spare these young men who died . Oslo has won , netanyahu has failed , khamenei has won , Sinwar has won ..MBS and Sissi and Erdogan have lost ..
Agree. Thanks JP
We were betrayed
🇮🇱 Lost Again To Lebanon 🇱🇧 😂
Something does not add up here. Should we not go to the streets yet…with those in the north who obviously can’t go home under the insane “ceasefire agreement”? Praying Lebanon won’t accept it!! ❤️🇮🇱
Boo Boo the Landscaper mows the lawn once again!!!
Disgusting!
Out with Netanyahu, in with Feiglin.
Hermann Fegelein?
Out with traitor joe. Bibi is a victim.
No to Fegelein, Fegelein, Fegelein!
I thought that the cease fire included the stipulation that no Lebaneese or terrorist would approach within 5 miles of the Israeli border or risk getting shot in the head. I don't really know if that is what I heard. I was listening to the news in Hebrew while I was driving and I thought that was what they said but not sure.
Ben Gvir etc should stop it!
None of us have any clue what happened behind closed doors and what he was threatened with. He is playing the goal game and waiting for Trump to get into power. Politics is a game and he is playing it.
Has this been agreed to by all parties😡😡😡😡😡🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Not yet. Pending condition is that Israel has to pay for rebuilt of Gaza and all the damage caused in Lebnan
@@mohammedomer4246 bwahahahahaha
It’s cowardice. Bibi is so unstable in his behavior. One day brave one day coward. This is so upsetting!!!! What happened to we’ll fight with our nails if we have to????
Netanyahu wants to kiss up to trump and people forget the aa accords the 2nd phase is to start giving up judea and Samaria as annexation was promised not to do for this deal. I hope this turns out a repeat of what sharon did.
General Observation
Quantum Jidadics
Though ojects look inert ( ceasefire ) , they are not . Their atoms never cease moving .
Eg .India Pakistan ceasefire and unceasing Pakistani islamic terror attacks on India.
Trump’s newest son in law is Lebanese
The hatred of Zionists knows no bounds.
And his daughter, son in law, and
their children are Jewish. Trump has shown whose side he's on.
Empty set !Israeli and IDF
I highly doubt there will be a ceasefire.
I hope you are correct
@@MsJASM007 Katz and Bibi cannot remove the generals now. The generals are recruited not to achieve any military victory for the current government.
If you want to keep land from flooding in a particular area, is it wise to try to destroy the sea or to keep it at bay with infrastructure?
If you try to destroy the sea, it is so vast that more and more water will keep coming at you and you will use up all your energy ending in failure- because too much exists for the amount of space, it evaporates but then comes back as rain.
Maybe Netanyahu has decided strategically that Iran iand Hesbullah are like the sea and it is a better decision to have infrastracture which endures keeping Iran at bay- let the Iranian regime ware out its energies with its persuits. This can be seen as a martial arts kind of philosophy which leaves space for opponent to disipate or waste their power.
I'm not saying this is correct- just that it is a plausible stratergy.
Netanyahu has not surrended to Hamas.
Thumbs up are never accurate as mine is broken or does not respond this evening.
The Lebanese people of the south are descended from people who where Jews around the time of the last days of Judea and Samaria before Jesus and his followers started changing he demographics. You should be seeing a peace with them, and accept limits to what land Israel seeks because those people are also descended from the line of Isaac, they are just the people who converted to Christianity after Jesus and then later most families converted to Islam, but you can view them as fellow ethnic brothers and as subsects of the same faith, especially the Muslims whos concept of God is the same. Remember, Arabic is a just a language to the Lebanese, but ethnically as the DNA proves, the people there have the same genetics as the historical Jews, and the same is true for the Palestinians whos ethnicity is far closer to the historical Jews than any modern day European Jews.
The issue is that most Israelis see Lebanese and Palestinians as sub human, and pretend they are ethnically different when they are not. A peace based on the original 1967 UN lines will be accepted by Palestinians and Lebanese and all Muslims, and this would lead to eventually integrating Israel into the region with trade and respect, but instead , extremists like Jonathan Pollard only see the zero sum game thinking and seek to treat their fellow Canaanite neighbors as Amalek, but despite all the biblical stories, the Jews are descended from the common ancestry of Canaanites just like Lebanese and Palestinians just as Hebrew is almost identical to Canaanite/Phoenician/Punic languages.
Im an Australian and not religious but even i can see that's not the problem at all, all groups live together in Israel fairly peacefully, there is even many Arab muslims in the IDF (they could call themselves Palestine if liked as have the DNA)
All that would happen if Israel agreed to 1967 UN lines, is it would mean Jews wouldn't be able to live on or even visit the lands that they were named after Judea and that they have so much connection and history too, but worse is Israel would still be a attacked but from positions that look directly over Israel including built up areas.
It's insane to think Palestinians would ever be happy with a two state solution, they wont be happy until there is no Israel and no jews, many aren't shy about this.
From the river to the sea, isn't the 1967 UN lines.
There are no culture of Palestine they are refugees mixed from desert lands gypsies mostly and Arabs mixed from the regions Gaza's the Palestine is not on Koran as a culture a tribe nothing Palestine as a name on Israel on land not a people only if Palestine was a state it's not a state yet they are still trying to make a state though the say they Palestine the word is not Arabic and no economy or culture language exist they say Palestine as the are staying and most came from Arab region some Arab people too they never had a state but used the word if I live in wilderness as Ido on a farm I say I'm from the country not from the area and we are in a country the wilderness iS our culture we are wild but out state is not it's just a place we are citizens and Gaza's Palestine's have Israel citizenship and permits not Palestine because it never was a state. Not real only a name Arabs are called Palestine due to living there but it's the same land as Israel too only Israel can register them legally as Palestine was never a legal state to do so proof Israel did not steal the land Arabs lived there years with Jews Arab squatters but they all had peace together
@@Elly-d4d it's a quip that holds truth, the REAL father of the Palestinian Movement is Leonid Brezhnev. Palestine (detached from history as the Roman name for Judea), is a Soviet psy-op to poker finger in America's eye and betray Israel for leaning to America instead of leaning towards the USSR.
Sad.
You lost. You lost. swallow it and accept it
Bibi is papal
Found the stress of this fanatic pretty amusing! Wow..has he ever got a warped view of the truth!
Have u considered that Bibi is biding time until Trump inauguration? Least of 2 evils
@@barryvallen1072 or being blackmailed and threatened.
Hope you're right!
All through the Bible the Jews stopped short of what God told them to do
Living in a bubble and lying to themselves
I am a bit serious about content of these books behind ..I know these are not intelligence documents ..
They are religious books
@@goldersgreen2177 They can be be better appreciated if they describe those books and contents than in adding fire to wars which can only consume more children and youngsters of all sides .
These Rabbi need to be called out and need to put the same energy in condemning the genocide in Gaza Period! All 🇮🇱 does targets civilians women & children in 🇵🇸 & 🇱🇧 absolutely it’s shameful & shocking!
Nonsense, what a crock of lies and misinformation. How dare you!
Quand un traitre parle de trahison!!!!
Free Palestine
From Hamas and jihadists.
Vibrant hommage d'une chanteuse th-cam.com/video/CJgnxEfmoeU/w-d-xo.html
Falestine n'existe jamais , Liban est Iran 😅
Now cry!😢😢😂😂😂🎉
😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉
look up pollard's history of treachery and theft
The treachery was initiated by US intelligence in refusing to live up to the agreements to share US intel with little besieged Israel. He saw the injustice, called it out, and the US intel system refused to rectify their wrongdoing. Yes, he wrongly took action to right the wrong and he was severely punished for it.
😂😂😂
Maybe don’t knock so much…try to understand his position….now is not the time for negativity of any sort…
These long bearded gentlemen could make themselves more useful to us gentiles by pointing out the books .seen behind and explain briefly their contents . Regarding war , this war has not ended if hamas and PLA is not involved in ceasefire and peace , grand and total war is still inevitable ..
you need to understand the goals of Hamas , they stuck to retrieve their hostages, and to end the Abraham accord because it meant peace with all Arabs without ensuring a fair peace for them, they achieved the main goal of ending the Abraham accord and the Palestinians are no longer politically isolated. So from here , its up to Israel to decide if they can accept the coming peace. Israel cant handle a war without America, they could not make any gains in Lebanon despite all of Pollards tough talk, if America retreats from empire, then Israel will choose peace, and the day Israel accepts peace based on the 1967 lines, there will be a permanent peace, and with the coming increase in political pressure, the Israelis will eventually be forced to accept peace and so they should as the Palestinians and Lebanese and the dependents of ethnic Israelites who converted to Christianity and eventually many to Islam.
They are religious books
Alternative is to accept what Jews had accepted 1400 years back that is to accept zimmi state of Islamic super empires which has ensured Jews survival
Nasralla also wanted the special tax from Jews . Didn’t work well for him
Why don't you two pick up the fight instead of disparaging the army.
Jonathan, what you need to understand, there is also an outside world and a civilian and economic world. If ceasefire gets Hezballah behind Litani and gets the thing shut down for good (for much longer time than 18 years it has been since 2006) than that outweighs clearly going deeper into debt, economic crisis, loosing more soldiers. Becoming a more and more unjustified a 1st class pariah state. Have problems with the economy and people who could have jobs have non, if tourism and specific economic branches collapse ever more or stay collapsed. We can fight forever if we want to, basically you could escalate the Ground War on the ground step by step into Syria, Iran, Iraq and Turkey. They are proud maniacs, they rather starve their children to deasth than stop fighting without keeping any kind of face in an agreement... So either have a straightforward Plan to have greater Israel or something like Levant Federation under full Israeli rule or find the exit rather sooner than later with ceasefire agreement...
What you need to understand is, that there are men on this thread not, wussies. You comment signifies just that.
Are you a soldier? @@pesach613
It is not biblical.
"If ceasefire gets Hezballah behind Litani and gets the thing shut down for good (for much longer time than 18 years it has been since 2006)"
This really is the primary question. Would it last that long?
Bibi is not a traitor. It's a lot easier to say what he should and shouldn't do than to be in his shoes. I can't imagine the stress that he's under but I think he's done a great job so far. I know I'll probably get a lot of flack for saying that but that's my opinion and I'm entitled to it.
I respect you Mr Pollard very much and have learned a lot from your discussions with the Rabbi but I don't agree with you here about him being a traitor.