Conrad, my son, you are now the leader of the Austro-Hungarian Armed forces and part of the army has been encircled near Pzemysl, will you either: Ask the Germans for help in their front, avoiding the Carpathian mountains/Let the encircled troops surrender after delaying the enemy or will you attack the Russian positions at the Carpathian mountains during winter? Conrad: ... >Cut to Austro-Hungarian soldiers dying of frost and to Russian machine guns in the Carpathian mountains
Why do people keep saying "thanks for the likes"? The ones who liked your comment simply agree with what you said. It's not about you. Nobody "liked" you in this context.
I liked this just as much as your Eastern Front videos; the detailed animation showing the positions and movements of each unit is incredible. The amount of research needed must be colossal, but the result is greatly appreciated by myself and (so far) 28,000 other viewers.
Mr. Eastory. I'll have you know I have been subbed to you for a while now, even before WW2. And I immediately thought of this channel when I first saw the maps in WW2 channel, and jumped with joy to realize you were involved. Fantastic work, and I must say this work is what makes WW2 channel so much easier to understand than WW1, as for WW1 channel I had to pull up google maps to see where the places exactly were. Also when the maps were later added, they were not as conveniently animated to really get a glimpse of the speed and scale it happened. Perhaps it is less documented in WW1 to draw such detailed map, but regardless, you raised the quality of what is already very high of WW2 channel. Thank you very much!
Same here. Indy Neidell hates comments that go against the mainstream official narrative of WW2. Dont want to look at his channel any more or hear him here.
As fellow Estonian, proud to see your channel is doing good and your collab with Time Ghost History is amazing, really helps to give the perspective how front lines moved turing the war.
I watched the whole vid without knowing that I had spent almost an hour , u make ur vids so interesting that I didn't even know when the time passed , keep up the good work :D
The fact that it's a collection of different clips makes the audio a bit odd... could you revoice it yourself Eastory, when you have free time, in ten years? Other than that, of course, the video is great :)
Too bad the Battle of the Grebbeberg isn't mentioned although in the grand scheme of this I understand and impressed by the amazing results achieved here (I mean Eastery's animations, and to some certain extent the German offensive as well).
Even though the battle itself is important from dutch viewpoint, in itself it really eas just a sideshow, so with their limited resources (especially what they had back then) i think it was a good idea zo leave it out. Overall this period with the early stages of barbarossa are between the most intense part of the war, so i hope that when at the end they will make something to deliver a lot of important details missed in the rush.
I wished it was. Very informative to see in-real-time on maps. Same wish for the attack on the Moerdijk-bridges, Dordrecht- and Rotterdam which spans four days. There is a lot written, but nothing really easily visualised.
im pausing the video to read eng subtitles in every 10 seconds. it is such a big fortune if your mother language is english. that makes you absorb contents like this into your brain so easily
Great work! I see so much improvement and effort in this long video, it probably took months to make! You deserve over 1 million subs! I have high respect to everyone who was working on this long and hard project!
@@suisso14 It's more an issue of trying to cut out all the stuff from the episode that doesn't pertain to the map/military movement, when some deliveries are referencing other stuff and so it comes off really weirdly. I wish he had narrated it for this video, even if more vaguely
Fifty-five minutes of moving maps! I was wondering if You would indeed do this: combining all Your WWII maps into this dense format, and You did! And not only Europe, every theatre, even China, in chronological order, that is extra super! Yes, pls continue this formate, this is most excellent work!
Ah. I saw this in my recommended, thought the thumbnail looked a lot like the WW2 In Real Time channel's maps and came to check if this wasn't some unauthorized reupload. I'm happy to see that instead of that, it's from the creators themselves. Love the maps by the way, they look amazing
I wish these videos were created as data on an interactive map so you could zoom and pan as you'd like instead of being restricted to the video. Great job though, amazing work.
Probably the Best Maps on youtube, considering most map videos comprise of only red and blue pushing each other without any additional information whatsoever.
France: We have this impenetrable defensive line that can resist all of your attacks Germany: Okay. *Goes around the Maginot Line* Finland: We have this impenetrable defensive line that can resist all of your attacks USSR: We'll see about that *Charges straight into the Mannerhime Line*
@@julianmhall meanwhile in some alternate universe, France fortified the Belgian border making an invasion via Belgium impossible, but then Germany invades via the French-German border
Some events have been forgotten in the video such as: -The Sarr Offensive in september 39, the only allied ground offensive against Germany during the phoney war (the French advanced 8 km with almost no resistance before retreiving, since the HQ was planning everything on a defensive plan) -The Battle of the Heligoland Bight in december 39, first aircraft battle engaging the RAF against the Luftwaffe. -All the Battle of the Atlantic wich was pretty rough in the west (compared to the Phoney War), especially with the "odyssey" of the pocket battleship the Admiral Graf Spee, accumulating a dreadful list of casualities upon the british fleet, untill beeing hunted down in Uruguay at the battle of the River Plate in december 39. There could be others events missed here and there, but overfall, you've done a pretty good job.
This is awesome, brilliant work! Thank you. Something I've noticed though is that sometimes the division icons are disproportionately to the other, such as with japan and China. It might be due to the size and strength of the division, but that's debatable because french, german, Norwegian, and British icons were even. In tandem, it could be a combination of many division into larged groups to reduce animation costs. It's not that serious, but it might be misleading of the actual strength of the army. Thats all folks, thanks for reading!
@G E T R E K T He did not show that the USSR had been at war with Japan since the spring of 1939, and it was only when the war with Japan ended, the USSR entered Poland.
Chinese units were far smaller than Japanese units. IIRC a Chinese division often only had 5,000 to 6,000 men, compared to the 20,000+ men of a Japanese division.
Rather ambitious project. There is a lot to cover if one is going to go through all events in World War Two in real time like this and at this level of detail. A great thing to watch.
Enthalpy obviously, because it has been taken Out of context. If you want the context, you should watch World War 2s Videos (you should watch them anyways, because they are great)
@@chaoskoenig139 I personally can't find them on the channel Did I miss them because ich really want to watch the uncut versions of this amazing video:(
@@ssnful123 Well there are certain parts that jump around without warning and some things are not described as clearly. For example, he talks about how Japan is making advances but all of a sudden says that China is now retaking territory, or when he talks about Lithuania signing a mutual assistance pact and then immediately jumps to the Winter War without stating the reasons.
Aerial_Morello Do you actually realize how much work was put into this or how much more work it would take to narrate this again? The Audio has been tanken Out of context. If you want the context, you should watch World War 2s Videos (you should watch them anyways, because they are great)
It would be nice if you could show an uninterrupted sequence of each conflict with the dates as references. Its a bit confusing to keep track of the Winter War and Chinese-Japanese war simultaneously. Thanks!
when I heard of Battlefield V's "untold stories of WWII", I expected something like the Winter War and China, not nameless desert battle or mom and daughter blowing up the heavy water plant that the British SAS did.
This video is so good and informative! Some things that can be improved: - better audio (the speaker isn’t synced well, sometimes it’s to quiet, sometimes to loud) - Name the Country / area when you jump from one place to another (example France -> China, sometimes it’s a bit fast, that makes it easier to follow) - I really liked the pictures of the generals you showed in the beginning, could have more pics of all the guys when you introduce them
I love the idea of these kind of videos. However, the editing feels a bit choppy and it is difficult to follow along in some parts. I understand that the clips are just taken straight from the weekly episodes though, so it is understandable.
Can you please make this again but with you narrating? This guy is nice and clear but he sounds like he's narrating a soccer match. Your voice is so much smoother and your accent is beautiful.
2:10 "they reach the river both north and south of pzemysl"
*WW1 conrad von hotzendorf flashback*
Conrad, my son, you are now the leader of the Austro-Hungarian Armed forces and part of the army has been encircled near Pzemysl, will you either: Ask the Germans for help in their front, avoiding the Carpathian mountains/Let the encircled troops surrender after delaying the enemy or will you attack the Russian positions at the Carpathian mountains during winter?
Conrad:
...
>Cut to Austro-Hungarian soldiers dying of frost and to Russian machine guns in the Carpathian mountains
@@marco5916 Russians: *Are actually being somewhat competent*
Indy Neidell sure loves to flex about being able to pronounce Przemysl
@@timmccarthy872 It's literally the easiest word to pronounce lol, lots of people can pronounce it :P
And speaking of World War I, did you know that the battle of France from World War II has the same events as the one from World War I.
This video doesn’t have a single ad in it.... respect for this man
I just got one lol
@@D.S.S_YT same
"You can use the timestamps to move to the event of your interest". How about if i just watch all of it
Haha same
I feel like its disrespectful to use any of the time stamp, he worked on an 1 hour video then some people watch only the timestamp.
Why hunt onions if you can watch the whole video? I mean, you don't need onions if you don't need timestamps.
"That's crazy, there's so much here to take in all at once"
HOW ABOUT I DO, ANYWAY
I did. In one breath :)
I love how the invasion of Poland sounds like a sport narrator while the Russian front sounds like a documentary
I must say... you have quickly risen to the top of my list when it comes to historical videos! Keep up the great work!
He makes some of the best content out there
Indy always been my favorite historian ever since World War 1 videos highly recommended
@@michaeljaquez4737 ha, I see what you did there!
Why do people keep saying "thanks for the likes"? The ones who liked your comment simply agree with what you said. It's not about you. Nobody "liked" you in this context.
@@juppheinekken3465 a lil’ harsh, but yeah.
13:30 - ''The Action has been called off mid afternoon...''
13:33 - '' 10 THOUSAND JAPANESE!"
HOI player pauses and jumps to another theater 😂
@@rookiebird9382 Fr xD that is me
@@rookiebird9382 well yes
This is a truly epic piece of work, I can’t imagine the effort and time all this took to assemble. Thank you
Theres no ads
even better.
I liked this just as much as your Eastern Front videos; the detailed animation showing the positions and movements of each unit is incredible. The amount of research needed must be colossal, but the result is greatly appreciated by myself and (so far) 28,000 other viewers.
Might be late but true..
Boy in 1939: When I grow up...
One Austrian painter: I’m gonna stop you right there
Hey pal.👋👋 Where do i even start? 🤔 Great comment, Good structure and most important of all. It’s made with passion 👏 Keep up the good work😁😁
Stalin: I have already killed around 12 million people in 1939. Including the extermination of poles living in USSR in 1938.
Mr. Eastory. I'll have you know I have been subbed to you for a while now, even before WW2. And I immediately thought of this channel when I first saw the maps in WW2 channel, and jumped with joy to realize you were involved. Fantastic work, and I must say this work is what makes WW2 channel so much easier to understand than WW1, as for WW1 channel I had to pull up google maps to see where the places exactly were. Also when the maps were later added, they were not as conveniently animated to really get a glimpse of the speed and scale it happened. Perhaps it is less documented in WW1 to draw such detailed map, but regardless, you raised the quality of what is already very high of WW2 channel. Thank you very much!
I prefer Eastory narrating, just saying.
Yes, I agree.
Yep... This guy has a good and clear voice but sounds like someone commentating a boxing match in the 60's or something.
Same here. Indy Neidell hates comments that go against the mainstream official narrative of WW2. Dont want to look at his channel any more or hear him here.
Yep same, Eastory is just so chill and clear. Especially when he says "all out attack".
@@ramagon234 this video is a cutout videos of him talking ofc its gonna be like this... He just cut out part of his videos that has his maps
Everyone in the comments just saying Indy’s commentary is like sport commentary.
ikr
Great work!
ok
Hi
Definitely want the next years! That was brilliant. Good work! Can't wait for the rest
As fellow Estonian, proud to see your channel is doing good and your collab with Time Ghost History is amazing, really helps to give the perspective how front lines moved turing the war.
There are so many channels that make map videos, but yours are my favorite.
Love it! The map parts are the best parts of the WW2 Videos
I watched the whole vid without knowing that I had spent almost an hour , u make ur vids so interesting that I didn't even know when the time passed , keep up the good work :D
I really liked the way you described all the wars and battles within a specific time period, instead of a single war. Keep up the good work!
Wonderful production!
The fact that it's a collection of different clips makes the audio a bit odd... could you revoice it yourself Eastory, when you have free time, in ten years?
Other than that, of course, the video is great :)
Just watch the ww2 channel
Eastory's voice and narration is like golden honey.
@@grindelz I do watch the WW2 channel already as well, thank you, but you, sir, are missing the point.
@@SNOUPS4 ok sorry sir
10 years 🤣🤣
Terima kasih.
This is the best info I've seen made about WW2. Love it very much, keep it up!
I need this kind of video for the next years too. Good work!
Eastory: Uploads
Me: *Heavy Breathing*
Astonishing video lads, thank you!
He talks as if he is commenting on some sport.
Nice username
I still can't get over he says "ReEeEeEd Army"
Out of context it does sound odd, in the actual videos (which I recommend) he's just trying to convey the frantic pace with which of the events occur.
that is the best way to describe it
@The Valkist Fascists fuck off
I never thought I'd enjoy almost an hour of lines and circles but here I'm wishing it was even longer
And squares
انت عراقي
@@مليونمشاهدة-ش2ف نعم
Too bad the Battle of the Grebbeberg isn't mentioned although in the grand scheme of this I understand and impressed by the amazing results achieved here (I mean Eastery's animations, and to some certain extent the German offensive as well).
Maybe they could check out your channel for that😁
Even though the battle itself is important from dutch viewpoint, in itself it really eas just a sideshow, so with their limited resources (especially what they had back then) i think it was a good idea zo leave it out. Overall this period with the early stages of barbarossa are between the most intense part of the war, so i hope that when at the end they will make something to deliver a lot of important details missed in the rush.
I wished it was. Very informative to see in-real-time on maps. Same wish for the attack on the Moerdijk-bridges, Dordrecht- and Rotterdam which spans four days. There is a lot written, but nothing really easily visualised.
@@tjokflots look up the NIMH Nederlands instituut voor militaire historie. Zijn ook op TH-cam en visualiseren het ook.
You said eastery, the channel name is eastory
im pausing the video to read eng subtitles in every 10 seconds. it is such a big fortune if your mother language is english.
that makes you absorb contents like this into your brain so easily
55 minutes of Eastory map animations compiled into 1 video, this is a great day :)
What is this? An hour-long compilation of Indy's narration and Eastory's maps? Am I in heaven? :D Thanks so much.
Great work! I see so much improvement and effort in this long video, it probably took months to make! You deserve over 1 million subs! I have high respect to everyone who was working on this long and hard project!
Indy is one of my favorite narrators, strong work all around.
I was waiting for this. I'm so glad you did this. I like this part of the episodes and was hoping they would be put together.
I love how he's narrating like hes a commentator on a sport match
Sorry but, I kinda like the original narration by Eastory better. But still a good video.
I like the Eastory narrator but Indy is pretty awesome.
Too bad the audia is not synched properly
@@suisso14 It's more an issue of trying to cut out all the stuff from the episode that doesn't pertain to the map/military movement, when some deliveries are referencing other stuff and so it comes off really weirdly. I wish he had narrated it for this video, even if more vaguely
the voice of the narrator in the video is similar to the voice of the radio ww2
I can always recognise Eastory's work by its high quality in the weekly WW2 episodes. Keep it up!
Fifty-five minutes of moving maps! I was wondering if You would indeed do this: combining all Your WWII maps into this dense format, and You did! And not only Europe, every theatre, even China, in chronological order, that is extra super! Yes, pls continue this formate, this is most excellent work!
I love your seamless transition between fronts. As well as the geopolitical details each week. Good job.
I'm gonna be honest here... This was amazing! Love the maps, love the information from all theaters around the globe!
Ah. I saw this in my recommended, thought the thumbnail looked a lot like the WW2 In Real Time channel's maps and came to check if this wasn't some unauthorized reupload. I'm happy to see that instead of that, it's from the creators themselves.
Love the maps by the way, they look amazing
I'm truly impressed with this hard work 👌
This is the typr of content i spend days looking for. Thank you
Eastory: Just click on the timestamps to go to your only interests
Me: Doesnt click any because the entire video is my interest
@Man Being the TH-cam Account I wonder who you are xd
Is that rise of nations in your profile picture?
Ditto.
There's no other channel I like quite as much as this one, and that's not for lack of competition.
yes bro this is exactly what I've been waiting for
I personally would put an ad at the end of a section but this man is a legend
Awesome stuff. I'd love to see some physical maps thrown in to the mix.
Fantastic job.
Thank you VERY much for creating/posting this.
I wish these videos were created as data on an interactive map so you could zoom and pan as you'd like instead of being restricted to the video.
Great job though, amazing work.
It would be cool if you could you remove the audio and then have it just the changing frontlines. But, THIS IS AMAZING!
Probably the Best Maps on youtube, considering most map videos comprise of only red and blue pushing each other
without any additional information whatsoever.
This is great work! Please continue with the entire war.
13:33 omg in just 1 second i am teleported to the war zone in china... i am confused and my mind is still in finland...
Me too
Perhaps all of China should be put into one place or cut altogether...
@@Eastory ok
@@blitzkrupp8583 ok
@@dog811 ok
France: We have this impenetrable defensive line that can resist all of your attacks
Germany: Okay. *Goes around the Maginot Line*
Finland: We have this impenetrable defensive line that can resist all of your attacks
USSR: We'll see about that
*Charges straight into the Mannerhime Line*
One of my favourite references to the Maginot Line is that it ignored Germany's' 'traditional' route of invading France via Belgium.
@@julianmhall meanwhile in some alternate universe, France fortified the Belgian border making an invasion via Belgium impossible, but then Germany invades via the French-German border
@@lelouchvibritannia7809 thank you for the sarcasm. Not at all helpful.
@@julianmhall
Joke: -------->
You: >:(
Finland still won the Winter War in 1939/40.
It’s a shame this channel and the world war 1/2 channels are underlooked they deserve more attention
Bro I love your Videos
I hear Indy.
A surprise, to be sure, but a welcome one
Thanks so much for creating this!
“Avengers end game will be the biggest cross over in history”
Me: this is
Edit: damn dats crazy 200 likes
i think youve had enough soy and nintendo switch for today
It's supposed to say Infinity War though
SuperLeosid ah shit your right
@@SuperLeosid no its endgame
@@Dkshddh no its not
Amazing content as always Eastory!! 😮 i haven't seen content like this ANYWHERE!
Some events have been forgotten in the video such as:
-The Sarr Offensive in september 39, the only allied ground offensive against Germany during the phoney war (the French advanced 8 km with almost no resistance before retreiving, since the HQ was planning everything on a defensive plan)
-The Battle of the Heligoland Bight in december 39, first aircraft battle engaging the RAF against the Luftwaffe.
-All the Battle of the Atlantic wich was pretty rough in the west (compared to the Phoney War), especially with the "odyssey" of the pocket battleship the Admiral Graf Spee, accumulating a dreadful list of casualities upon the british fleet, untill beeing hunted down in Uruguay at the battle of the River Plate in december 39.
There could be others events missed here and there, but overfall, you've done a pretty good job.
the western allies had offesnive plans, but only in 1940
We have been waiting for this video for so long. Well done, Eastory!
This is awesome, brilliant work! Thank you. Something I've noticed though is that sometimes the division icons are disproportionately to the other, such as with japan and China. It might be due to the size and strength of the division, but that's debatable because french, german, Norwegian, and British icons were even. In tandem, it could be a combination of many division into larged groups to reduce animation costs. It's not that serious, but it might be misleading of the actual strength of the army.
Thats all folks, thanks for reading!
@G E T R E K T He did not show that the USSR had been at war with Japan since the spring of 1939, and it was only when the war with Japan ended, the USSR entered Poland.
Chinese units were far smaller than Japanese units. IIRC a Chinese division often only had 5,000 to 6,000 men, compared to the 20,000+ men of a Japanese division.
Still love this channel and can't wait for more
MASTERPIECE: Sept 1939 - Aug 1940 - so many events happened and changed the world so much in 1 year.
Rather ambitious project. There is a lot to cover if one is going to go through all events in World War Two in real time like this and at this level of detail. A great thing to watch.
I would love to see a series on the Second Sino-Japanese War. You're amazing by the way 😍
Well your in luck now
Good video keep it up!
I love all your content but the editing on this one is awkward.
Enthalpy obviously, because it has been taken Out of context. If you want the context, you should watch World War 2s Videos (you should watch them anyways, because they are great)
What about it was awkward? I didn’t really see anything wrong
@@chaoskoenig139 I personally can't find them on the channel Did I miss them because ich really want to watch the uncut versions of this amazing video:(
Kevin Schöneberg no the world war 2 TH-cam Channel where they Cover ww2 week by week
@@ssnful123 Well there are certain parts that jump around without warning and some things are not described as clearly. For example, he talks about how Japan is making advances but all of a sudden says that China is now retaking territory, or when he talks about Lithuania signing a mutual assistance pact and then immediately jumps to the Winter War without stating the reasons.
I don't have time to watch this right now, but holy cow you have been busy. Thanks for the upload, will enjoy soon!!! :D
Me: sees this video
my brain: click!!
Damn bro, you just went over the thought process of the 12,000 other people who have seen this video.
Thanks for the original and hilarious joke.
why does this have so many likes
Might be one of the best videos I've ever seen on WW2. Never have I watched and listened this closely.
I know the story sooo well, but the narrator & animations are sooo perfect that I watched this video anyways
I didn't know Indy was gonna be in this one still, a suprise to be sure, but a welcome one
Battle of Poland *exist* Eastory: Perfect place to put the chinse battle
Battle of Norway too ;)
Ah yes, Chinse
Chinae
Chinse
Chinesi
outstanding production from beginning to end
Animate the Balkan Campaign of WW1 next!
Good thing he's mostly already done it.
They already did, in World War 2 Channel.
69likes not gonna ruin it
Very well done. Excellent and much needed. Seems obvious now that you have produced it.
A version of this narrated by Eastory would be fantastic, great animated map as always but I had to watch it muted
I agree with Aerial. Indy did a great job and the video is awesome however I feel like Eastory tells the events better.
Aerial_Morello Do you actually realize how much work was put into this or how much more work it would take to narrate this again?
The Audio has been tanken Out of context. If you want the context, you should watch World War 2s Videos (you should watch them anyways, because they are great)
Agree. Indy doesn't belong here.
Same for me. Original guy is WAY better.
@lol shit I don't mind Indy's voice or anything, but the transition between each sound clip is a little jarring
Oh my god. I've been looking forward to this
1:00 why does no one ever mention Slovakia's participation? The units are even right there (on the right) but no one ever mentions that...
Saar offensive...? ?? ???
Yeah why not
@@johnhauser3580 they were under German control and leadership
@@space__idklmao Nope, they were under Slovakian leadership, Slovakia's president was already the prime minister of Slovakia under Czech law.
Awesome format!! Loved it. Looking forward to the next one.
EmperorTigerstar: Why do I hear boss music?
Ahhaah
his videos are inaccurate lol and poorly researched too
I love this idea it was so hard before because I had to keep searching different stuff but now in one video, now this is ultimate content
It would be nice if you could show an uninterrupted sequence of each conflict with the dates as references. Its a bit confusing to keep track of the Winter War and Chinese-Japanese war simultaneously. Thanks!
Thanks for the video!! It'll be helpful for Mapping!!
when I heard of Battlefield V's "untold stories of WWII", I expected something like the Winter War and China, not nameless desert battle or mom and daughter blowing up the heavy water plant that the British SAS did.
nice work! kudos on getting indy to narrate
This video is so good and informative! Some things that can be improved:
- better audio (the speaker isn’t synced well, sometimes it’s to quiet, sometimes to loud)
- Name the Country / area when you jump from one place to another (example France -> China, sometimes it’s a bit fast, that makes it easier to follow)
- I really liked the pictures of the generals you showed in the beginning, could have more pics of all the guys when you introduce them
Just got here, first video in the channel, and only with the intro you gained my subscribe man... what a nice video.
1:22 “the main thrust in the center”
Fantastic video. You're doing a great job man, thank you for all your work and effort to provide such quality content for free
*"Haha france = surrender"*
Denmark: *surrenders in a day*
Austria: willingly accepts German occupation
It was a quarter of a day or 6 hour lol lile how
France was a world power had more tanks than the Germans.
@@cumunist2120 Voted mate 99.6% of the population voted for the reunification
Amazing video! Great stuff and fantastic information and imagery provided in the video. Please continue to do more years of WWII in this way!
I love the idea of these kind of videos. However, the editing feels a bit choppy and it is difficult to follow along in some parts. I understand that the clips are just taken straight from the weekly episodes though, so it is understandable.
Yeah there were a couple edits that could have been done better.
Can you please make this again but with you narrating? This guy is nice and clear but he sounds like he's narrating a soccer match. Your voice is so much smoother and your accent is beautiful.
Шикарная и большая работа, творите еще :)