What if Sidious and Palpatine were Different People? Trilogy - What if Star Wars
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
- Welcome to the full trilogy of what if Sidious and Palpatine were different people! Born on the planet of Naboo, the Force sensitive Sheev Palpatine would soon rise up to become the face of two worlds. One as a Sith Lord under the apprenticeship of Darth Plagueis, and the other as an innocent senator in the Galactic Republic. The predictable Jedi were oblivious to his true identity and the fact that they were both the same, and they were made to pay with a capitulation of their Order. But what if Sidious and Palpatine were diiferent people? Would the Sith still rise? Would Order 66 still happen? All of that is about to be revealed…
Part 1: • What if Sidious and Pa...
Part 2: • What if Sidious and Pa...
Part 3: • What if Sidious and Pa...
Subscribe: / @starwarsadrian
Sports channel: / @whatifsports6694
Twitter: / whatifadrian
I always think about the past and events that could have changed. On my channel you will find What Ifs on any question of your choice. So come and join my channel by subscribing if you want to and lets think 'What If' together!
Music Used:
Song: Escape from the Temple
Artist: Per Kiilstofte
Escape from the Temple by Per Kiilstofte
machinimasound...
Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
(creativecommon...)
Thank you for your suggestions over the last few videos! Got loads of new what ifs coming up! Here's the three parts put together in case you wanted it one video.
Michael Aldredge-Greenwell ..
you should do what if palpatine had a twin one being good one being bad
Wait a minute i just thought of something could you use force lighting to cook an egg
Could you do what if Anakin and vader are two different people
What is palpatine wasn’t a sith lord
ok let us be real, if Palpatine and Sidious were separate people, Palpatine would have been one of the most likeable star wars characters because his charismatic, kind, friendly personality would be genuine.
Agreed. Palpatine would've been one of the most beloved characters in Star Wars as well as one of the most cunning as he would've been the one person to be able to possibly outwit the Sith.
He can still be evil 🤷🏻♀️
@@TimTheEnchanter0 🙄
He's a politician😂@@TimTheEnchanter0
I feel like good Palpatine would be a serious threat to the sith. Even if this version isn't force sensitive, he is still a strategic genius, and could counter the sith and separatists at most turns
the sepies wouldn't have a chance
Well, out of all people who know you best, your brother should be in the top 5
Yes, that's what I was thinking too. Even the Sith would have to severely modify their plans to get rid of Palpatine. He would've been able to work with Yoda and the Jedi to outwit the Sith and the Separatists. Frankly, it would've taken a lot of crooked people in the Republic and massive meddling from the Sith to turn enough worlds against the Republic to trigger the Clone Wars if Palpatine wasn't Sidious and was a good person.
Palpatine: it's over brother! I have a gun!
Sidious: you underestimates my power
Palpatine: dont try it
Palpatine:I always take a blaster to a lightsaber fight.
If Palpatine and Sidious are different people, than who is the Senate?
hmm
I am the senate
@@accentbrent3342 Not Yet.
It’s treason then
Palpetine.
Good guy palpatine
This means a legitimate positive relationship between Palpatine and skywalker
Ye
Cody: Hey Palpatine. We’re throwing a party at the Jedi Temple for the defeat of the Sith. How many pizzas should we order?
Palpatine: Order 66.
Cody: *Yes, my lord.*
(hears gunshots)
He meant 66 Pizzas right??
Yeah probably that
"oh shit I forgot about order 66 I knew that was a safety hazard."
Palpatine- …Oh uhh…Oops…I should have deleted that order sooner.
(Contacts Cody) Umm…Commander Cody…This is gonna be really awkward but…remember when I said order 66?
Cody- Yes my lord?
Palpatine- Please don’t call me that. But as I was saying…Well this is gonna sound awkward but…Remember when you asked how many pizzas you guys should order?…
Cody- Yeah and you said…Oh…Ohhhhhh…
maybe do : what if anakin killed obi-wan when he was rako hardeen
Great idea 💡!!
Or maybe during the fall.
ooooh ya
What if force healing existed from the beginning.
Qui-gon would live, Obi-Wan could heal Anakin's skin.
Anakins fall would never happen
It actually did just not as extreme
It did nobody could do it
Matthew Hotson Kenobi did it in the very first movie to wake up Luke
i figured that Lucas was going to throw us a curve ball and in Episode 3 we learn that Sidious was not Palpatine but took his place, that maybe Sidious tricked the Jedi into thinking Palpatine was the Sith Lord and the Jedi killed Palpatine then Sidious took his place claiming to be Palpatine and that the Jedi tried to take over...... the rest is the same
I thought that to at age 9
That's what I hoped the prequels would reveal too, its big plot twist so that Palpatine is revealed to be an actual good person whose killed by the Jedi who get tricked by Sidious who then takes Palpatine's place AS Palpatine and has them wiped out.
Who actually IS Sidious? An evil clone created, raised and trained by Plagueis. A scenario like that would've been as big a plot twist as Vader being revealed to be Luke's father.
What if Darth Maul, Savage Opress, And Feral Were Jedi?
Unlikely Darth Maul would be a Jedi, he’s a dathomirian, not an iridonian.
Feral was not force sensitive
What if Anakin and Darth Vader were different people, like how Obi-Wan Kenobi described it in A New Hope?
What if Darth Sidious and senator Palpatine were two completely separate personalities residing within the same body? My initial thoughts for this fanfiction are that Palpatine is not for sensitive but his other personality Darth Sidious is...
You should do what if Vader and anakin were different people
Then I believe he would have died in order 66 and Vader wouldn’t have turned back to light since no special connection
Then Vader would be more powerful because Palpatine will personally train him
Gabie 490 but Vader wouldn’t have any special needs or connections to palpatine so unless he’s a maul 2.0 which would just be kenobied like the maul 1.0 and maul 1.5 were
@@someonesomeone4262 and then there will be a final confrontaition the chosen one of the dark vs the chosen one of the force
Gabie 490 wdym dark chosen one darth Vader wasn’t the dark chosen one he was just the chosen one but turned to the dark side
What if Ahsoka would have become a traveling power converter sales person and sold some to Luke so he wouldn't have needed to go to town for them?
Best ending
Can you do what if anakin knew palpatine was lying before he killed mace windu
Then we wouldn't have 4, 5, and 6. That's what would happen.
I wanna see this theory as a fan film. It could start out leading the viewer to believe Palpatine is sidious, but reveal the truth when Palpatine destroys the last sith
What if the light side of the force was a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural
Ikr
It kind of is
Anakin would never join sith then
Then there would be Jedi Master Plagueis
In this Sidious is still Palpatine, just a different one
Actually one of my favorite what if scenarios.
I did not expect that ending. One of your best videos.
This is my favorite Star wars what if yet I love this thing great work
At this point all major characters just need twins so we can play out everything
WhatIf Adrian please do what if Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader were different people?
YESSSSSSSS!!! THANK YOU!! I always wondered about this scenario!! You honestly made my day today!
So basically sidious was palpatine twin brother ...wow this would get people confused tbh
I rather liked this story. It has sort of, KANE & ABLE, ring to it. The ultimate sibling rivalry, ending in one, killing the other...& the guye every one trusted at first, getting to be the ...anti-hero, saving the day, in the end. This would bring the war to a stop, with how it was cleared up, how it actually was started, in the first place...forcing the separated governments, to rejoin...seeing the mannipulations.
If anything, I think you should continue thi story, on those lines..to show how every one comes back together, even though Qui-Gon, doesn't prevent Anakin, from his more personal path, his mentorship, prevents his ambishon getting out of hand. As such, when he desides it's to much, he gives up his goal of a JEDI title, reveals his new family ties, & while keeping personal ties to the JEDI order, gives up his official status as a member. thouh shocked, they except this, & let go with out arguing...though grudgingly.
I love your channel keep up the great stuff!!
You know it's out there out of the box stories like there that proves why real Star wars fans are infinitely better than Disney
What if Palpatine never said "Dewit"
Actually thought this when I saw the Phantom Menace at 9. Reasoning was it was too obvious for him to be Sidious and maybe Palps got possessed
8:14 *[Visible Confusion]*
10:25 is much worse. Can't hear a word at 10:27
What if Anakin had been the one to leave the jedi order and Ahsoka stayed, instead of Ahsoka,Anakin would be framed for the bombing of the temple, and he in turn would leave the order, While Ahsoka stayed behind. Also Anakin would become fulcrum in Rebels.
Would that mean Luke and Leia wouldn't be born?
What about ahsoka?
What if anikan didn’t fall to the dark side
George wants us to believe it!
isn't this means Sidious is technically a Palpatine? Just not Sheev?
9:57 UNO REVERSE
This is going to get nuts
What if Palpatine wasn't the Senate?
This was an interesting concept.
Sidious wouldn't die so quickly he was too smart & too clever but good "What If" story
They are, from a certain point of view.
TFP Megatron ahhh yes
What if there was 2 Palpatines like cloned
In cannon, Palpatine had clones of himself made so he could be immortal, and one of these clones was the father of rey lol
I love this idea
Your Obi-Wan is EXTREMELY out of character here. He wouldn't be someone to succumb to the kind of jealousy you're having him succumb to.
be funny to see good boy palps as a grandpa to luke
*turns Obi Wan into bad guy within 3 sentences* oooookay pal
What if Palpatine and Sidious were the same person but with two different personalities. ( multiple personality disorder)
What is Palpatine was neither Jedi or Sith
0:00
i thought Sidious and Palpatine were 2 different people and Palpatine took Sidious's life and name he said he's master taught him so I thought Sidious was palpatines master
nope. Palpatine and sidious were the same
What if Palpatine was a Jedi?
Got an idea
What if anakin and darth vader were different persons
Or what if he had split personality disorder?
It was always treason then.
Mind trick on palpitine
For once Palpatine is good
Then who is the Senate if Palpatine and Sidious are different
Very interesting.
well there will be 2 senates
What if Vader and Luke's father where different people
Palpy the good
Star wars theory was plap being controlled by a demon
Dew it
Do a what if Palpatine was anakins father
He technically was since if I am not mistaken (which I might be) he used the force to make aniken which is y he has such a high midaclorian count
Is that still canon
Then it would not be unlimited powah
LIMITED. POWAHHHHHHHHH.
0
what if Palpatine was never born?
order 66 would never happen, anakin's nightmere would not happen either :)
Then the line of the Sith would go very different. Anakin, Maul and Count would not be Sith Lords and Plagueis would have a different apprentice.