@@bookwormliv No, the beautiful thing is not his death, it's much more about the story, which is heartbreaking and cold, but it's also beautiful, lovely and warm and teaches us that we should appreciate our loved ones before it's too late
I know, same, but I think it's beautiful, just like autumn says, sad things can be beautiful too. It's a beautiful story, lovely and warm, but also heartbreaking and cold
i finished it yesterday and i’m still balling. every song i listen to i try to think of a way to connect autumn and finny to it. i’m seriously so attached to these characters that i don’t even know if i can put myself through the torture of a second book.
Finny’s last words to Autumn were “when I get back things are going to be the way they were always supposed to be”. The very last sentence in the book is “I feel like things are going to turn out the way they were always supposed to be” 😭😭😭
There was so much foreshadowing about the death too. Like when she was talking about Romeo and Juliet, when the funny’s mom said she was scared he would die from a car accident, and all of the mentions of death.
Spoiler alert: didn't cry but idk how to explain when it was written 8 August Phineas smith died😢they haven't been together for even a day and also the fact he didn't died cuz of the accident he touched sylvie and was electrocuted was even worse They loved eachother so much since they were young but were to scared to admit only if they would've this would never happen only if he had been with her
I cried so many times as I read this book my dad once said reading a book for the first time is a gift you can never read a book for the first time again so cherish it
i’ve never and i mean NEVER have cried over a book or movie, but this one ended that, idk if it’s because of the pacing or if it’s because i’ve been in a similar situation but this one seriously pulled on my heartstrings
ive never seen someone describe this book good enough like you just did 😭 i had to sit there and stare at a wall for ten minutes after finishing the book 😭😭
You explained my emotions towards this book PERFECTLY! I absolutely adored this book. I couldn't put it as my 2nd favorite, so this book and another book are my number 1 favorites. This book did a lot more mental damage to me than I thought it would. And I got it at Walmart! I don't even know how to describe what I wanna say. You said it perfectly for me, and I'm so glad this book is a thing even though now I feel so empty and hollow on the inside, as of this actually happened to me. which, in a certain case, it did. I've lost family members suddenly the same way, and I relate to Autumn a lot more than I'll admit. I'm so glad I begged my parents to buy me this book.
After the introduction, everything is replaying in autumn‘s head after she locked herself in Finny’s room. The second one is worth it to see Finny’s POV, and the other POVs but I def cried more than once🥲
I totally felt the same way..😢😢 I’m currently in the middle of the second book though because I had to know what happens/happened. I’ve not stopped crying since I’ve picked it up.. it really makes you look at life and life before I became an adult
I stayed up till 5 am finishing it and I am still sobbing about it and there is no way I’m making through the second book without crying as soon as I open the book
The beauty of this book is that you can change the ending to their story 💕 the way i see it is finny "dying" is a horrible nightmare. In my story finny doesnt get out of his car right away. He takes that extra time after lightening stikes. He gets to Sylvie & calls for help. His car gets towed. Sylvie & him go to the hospital to get checked up. They call their loved one's. Finny calls his mom & his mom tells Autumns mom. The moment in the book when autum gets woken up from her sleep at night ("finny?" "Oh, autumn") thats her mom coming in not to tell her that finny is dead, but that he's been in an accident, but he's okay. He's waiitng for them there to get picked up by them. They're finally able to be together without any guilt. Finny suprises autum with a ton of her favorite candy (if only i had told her) he picked up from the convenient store on his way to sylvie's. They go on to go to college in Springfield while autumn is pregnant with their baby. He pursues med school & she follows her dreams to be a writer 💕💕💕💕 everything else is all part of a horrible lucid dream finny had (reference to if only i had told her). He mentioned in his point of view that he gets very lucid dreams. He had this horrible dream while he was sleeping with autumn the night they made love. It was thanks to that dream that he waited until the lighting struck until he got out of the car to go after Sylvie. Eveything worked out at the end 💕💕💕
All the other parts that play along with finny dying is just a what if he died scenario. It just goes to show how loved finny is. It shows how deep Autumn's love for finny runs. It just proves how much they belong together. How truly tragic life would be without each other in it. & How blessed they truly are to get this chance to finally be together. 💕💕💕
This book left me in a state of minor depression it stuck with me for three months and then i got the sequel and I think I cried a total of 4 HOURS!! Now I feel empty inside and I don’t know how to continue with life.
i sobbed so hard in that book. i always knew something was off abt her friend group and i knew they weren’t good for autumn when they convinced alex to break up with his girlfriend and get back with sasha. they should have just let him be happy. i remember staying up all night just thinking about how unfair that book is but how good it is
I though the same thing. I didn't think I could read the second one. A few months later, I bought it anyways and read it. Let me tell you it it 10 times more sad than the first one. You will not stop crying, it is literally torture.
oh my god i read it during school, and at the end i was sobbing. hysterically. my teacher thought somebody in my family died. my classmates laughed at me when they figured out it was about a book. i have never cried so hard reading a book. i will never be the same. this is supposed to be dramatic.
I already bought this book last month but I stopped reading it on the middle, because it feels so hard to continue. My heart feels heavy while reading it. Like, I know what will happen but I can't accept it.
I read the second book and can confirm your crisis will expand in the NEED to know and the frustration of knowing and the questions left not asked. Like BRU! Jack my guy was on a whole role and just STOPPED! Like duuuude! IT WAS HER FAULT! 😭 just read it and let me know im not alone in hating silvy
I just finished the 2nd book and I am balling my eyes out but you definitely need to read it because it helps you understand more even tho it’s super sad 😭
this book made me cry so much i was like heart broken. when i got the book i finished the book that same day i couldn’t put that book down. and when it was like the last 10 chapters i was sobbing the whole time
Ye I just finished it and cried a lot. When I read it, I found a part of me that I never knew it existed but when finn dies it was lost again never to be found.
And you can’t understand that this won’t make you cry like the sequel did to me I cried so hard for so long I’m dead “if only I had told her “is the best thing you will ever read
I bought that book today and now I don’t want to read it because of how broken she sound and I know she’s on the verge of tears.. it literally hurting my heart hearing her, I do not want to go through that while reading it!!😭😭 Edit: I’m still watching this and I’m starting to tear up listening to her voice!!!! It so broken, thats making absolutely sad for her.
it's totally okay! 😭 I'm reading that book right now and trust me , the sad part would only be at the end ! While reading it , it's actually super cute but sometimes you have to sit and think about things , but overall it's very fun to read this one! Totally recommend (unless you can't handle the emotions)
"Finny?" "Oh Autumn..." At the end BROKE me! 😭 I made a whole Playlist on Spotify named that, (dedicated to the book OBVI). But I got this book from my school library... I just started reading the next book and I haven't started crying yet, but I'm going to I know it!
I just finished the book and I Cried alot. But like the way she calls him Finny and the way he took care of her even when they weren't friends likee I CANT
I just finished it and when autumn wrote that finny had died on the 8 of august and when she was thinking over and over again that if he had been here this wouldn't of happened if he had been with me .. The last lines broke me and call me emotional for all I care but this book rlly broke me
This book paralyzed me so much.This book is never going to be out of my mind ever and i probably can never read this book again.I always felt like sad book gave me a kind of diff comfort but everytime i feel sad my mind wanders into this this book that all i can think abt is alternative endings shitt i feel like my heart is tightening ❤.😢
damn she sold me the book. i like watching people's reactions about books before i start reading it and this is it. this is the kind of reaction that makes me wanna read it.
It was so triggering to me.... I have lost a best friend to suicide, i lost 4 other people in the span of 5 years. I'm a sophomore. I wasn't expecting this at all. I also wasn't paying as much attention in the beginning so i had no clue that ot would happen. I cried for hours because it was just too real in my own life. So please before you read this book make sure nothing in your life could possibly be triggered by this book
I like the first book better than the second. But the second one is actually told in 3 perspectives and it's so sad because of the irony of stuff that Finn says that we all know is coming
i just finished this book like five minutes ago and i just need like a couple hours of sitting and staring at the wall trying to think about what i just read. i didn’t even cry at the end, i just feel so numb. (in a good way, i absolutely loved this book) im giving it five stars, i would give it six if i could
when I read this my mind totally blanked and I fully forgot that the end is at the start. I was over there thinking they were gonna get happily married and have kids.
I screamed when I finished this book honestly it’s one of the worst but best books you will ever read and I don’t recommend reading the second one just leave it at that
It took me three days to complete it, and although I'm a bit emotional, I didn't cry like I thought I might when I placed the order. There were definitely other emotions involved, but overall, it felt quite predictable to me without any real twists. 😅
I listened to the audiobook two nights ago not knowing much about the book. Towards the end I ran to my mom room crying. 😭 I love the book,but I didn’t know how triggering that book would be I had a whole anxiety attack and cried myself to sleep the night I finished. I ordered the second book today imma need therapy after this 😂
I had to stop reading "Educated" by Tara Westover because it was too sad. I just read "Eleonor Oliphant is Completely Fine." I finished it but... unfortunately I could relate to her. It was sad.
I found that book at my science teacher on the floor and I took it saying I need to read more and then when I finnshed the book I was sobbing and this was all at school
I just finished this book!! I loved the writing and the style. I knew somehow Finny would die in his car but going to talk to that "B" I was so upset!! Life is so short! Enjoy every min. of it!
⚠️ Spoiler, alert⚠️🥀 This is my all time favorite book ever!!! I just read it 2 days ago and I’m still ugly crying over it makes me so sad knowing there not a movie about it or anything and how she has to live her life knowing, the only person who helped her with her pain was finny smith but he’s not here anymore and now I’m crying again!! I keep telling my friends I want to have kids named finny and autumn!! I keep ugly crying in school bc of this book a certain songs triggers me and makes be cry I was sobbing the next day (Monday) bc I couldn’t stop crying of this amazing book and I can’t find another book like this!!! I can’t wait to get the book about finnys version!!! 😭 🥀📕❤️
I feel the same I just finished the book and oh boy I did not expect that I was crying so hard like the deserved more time together 😭 I don’t think I can read Finny’s version I’m like broken in the best way possible 😭😭
@@Olivia0426 omg girl I wish I can hug you!!! I know how you feel!! But you have like a whole month before reading it to forget about everything!! IT COMES FEB 6th and if you read the book it’s ends with us there making a movies and it comes out FEB 9TH SORRY JUST LOVE READING
Hi, I loved it a lot... However I have a doubt, how did Autumn know Jammy and Sasha cheated on her? How did she know he was gonna break up... I couldn't get that part... I knows it's all about Fin and Autumn and have loved it.. However just wanted to know how did she find out before James told her?
Ok so I just finished the book and I’m a bit confused by the ending, what my understanding is, that finny died and then autumn tries to commit Yk but then it brings up her being pregnant? I tried to read it over to see if I missed something but I’m confused someone please explain the ending to me 😭🙏
yeah basically, when finny dies she cuts herself, then she’s in the hospital and finds out she’s pregnant, she thought of trying to harm herself again but decided not to knowing finny wouldn’t approve
![TEEDEE TADA - DIAMOND NARAKORN X LEGO LYKN [Special Dance Performance]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QgtZedFeumA/mqdefault.jpg)
“Sometimes sad things are beautiful”
~ Autumn
Don’t know about that Autumn… was Finny dying beautiful? NO!
@@bookwormliv No, the beautiful thing is not his death, it's much more about the story, which is heartbreaking and cold, but it's also beautiful, lovely and warm and teaches us that we should appreciate our loved ones before it's too late
I know, same, but I think it's beautiful, just like autumn says, sad things can be beautiful too. It's a beautiful story, lovely and warm, but also heartbreaking and cold
i finished it yesterday and i’m still balling. every song i listen to i try to think of a way to connect autumn and finny to it. i’m seriously so attached to these characters that i don’t even know if i can put myself through the torture of a second book.
@@kali.b13omg sand I think I need help I can’t stop crying
Finny’s last words to Autumn were “when I get back things are going to be the way they were always supposed to be”. The very last sentence in the book is “I feel like things are going to turn out the way they were always supposed to be” 😭😭😭
Best book ever I’m crying so hard rn omg I can’t even read it again cuz imma cry the whole time
I just finished reading the book and maybe it’s me because I didn’t cry.
@@RajwinderSran-df7sk I mean that’s impressive I still cry sometimes
@@ItsRylee865 Spoiler ⚠️
Honesty i’m surprised that I didn’t cry for Autumn and Finny dying.
@@RajwinderSran-df7sk fr
Wait did autumn died ?@@RajwinderSran-df7sk
There was so much foreshadowing about the death too. Like when she was talking about Romeo and Juliet, when the funny’s mom said she was scared he would die from a car accident, and all of the mentions of death.
Omg frr
Spoiler alert:
didn't cry but idk how to explain when it was written 8 August Phineas smith died😢they haven't been together for even a day and also the fact he didn't died cuz of the accident he touched sylvie and was electrocuted was even worse
They loved eachother so much since they were young but were to scared to admit only if they would've this would never happen only if he had been with her
Did you- did you just give a spoiler?-
@@starplayzreadbio373 im so sorry😭
@@starplayzreadbio373it literally said spoiler
I cried so many times as I read this book my dad once said reading a book for the first time is a gift you can never read a book for the first time again so cherish it
I love what your dad said. I’ll remember this ❤
i’ve never and i mean NEVER have cried over a book or movie, but this one ended that, idk if it’s because of the pacing or if it’s because i’ve been in a similar situation but this one seriously pulled on my heartstrings
ive never seen someone describe this book good enough like you just did 😭 i had to sit there and stare at a wall for ten minutes after finishing the book 😭😭
Same
Okay but that is literally the best description
You explained my emotions towards this book PERFECTLY! I absolutely adored this book. I couldn't put it as my 2nd favorite, so this book and another book are my number 1 favorites.
This book did a lot more mental damage to me than I thought it would. And I got it at Walmart! I don't even know how to describe what I wanna say. You said it perfectly for me, and I'm so glad this book is a thing even though now I feel so empty and hollow on the inside, as of this actually happened to me. which, in a certain case, it did. I've lost family members suddenly the same way, and I relate to Autumn a lot more than I'll admit. I'm so glad I begged my parents to buy me this book.
It's so true but so funny when people say a hook that emotional destroyed us to be a favourite 🤣🤣🤣
second one hurts a lot more. especially if you can put yourself in a situation where you relate to what jack is going through.
What is the name of the second one ?
If I had told her@@hoodybaker8249
@@hoodybaker8249 If only i had told her
After the introduction, everything is replaying in autumn‘s head after she locked herself in Finny’s room.
The second one is worth it to see Finny’s POV, and the other POVs but I def cried more than once🥲
i just finished the book and this is making me cry even harder 😭😭 idk if i should watch the second book or not, idk if i can handle it
I totally felt the same way..😢😢 I’m currently in the middle of the second book though because I had to know what happens/happened. I’ve not stopped crying since I’ve picked it up.. it really makes you look at life and life before I became an adult
I stayed up till 5 am finishing it and I am still sobbing about it and there is no way I’m making through the second book without crying as soon as I open the book
The beauty of this book is that you can change the ending to their story 💕 the way i see it is finny "dying" is a horrible nightmare. In my story finny doesnt get out of his car right away. He takes that extra time after lightening stikes. He gets to Sylvie & calls for help. His car gets towed. Sylvie & him go to the hospital to get checked up. They call their loved one's. Finny calls his mom & his mom tells Autumns mom. The moment in the book when autum gets woken up from her sleep at night ("finny?" "Oh, autumn") thats her mom coming in not to tell her that finny is dead, but that he's been in an accident, but he's okay. He's waiitng for them there to get picked up by them. They're finally able to be together without any guilt. Finny suprises autum with a ton of her favorite candy (if only i had told her) he picked up from the convenient store on his way to sylvie's. They go on to go to college in Springfield while autumn is pregnant with their baby. He pursues med school & she follows her dreams to be a writer 💕💕💕💕 everything else is all part of a horrible lucid dream finny had (reference to if only i had told her). He mentioned in his point of view that he gets very lucid dreams. He had this horrible dream while he was sleeping with autumn the night they made love. It was thanks to that dream that he waited until the lighting struck until he got out of the car to go after Sylvie. Eveything worked out at the end 💕💕💕
All the other parts that play along with finny dying is just a what if he died scenario. It just goes to show how loved finny is. It shows how deep Autumn's love for finny runs. It just proves how much they belong together. How truly tragic life would be without each other in it. & How blessed they truly are to get this chance to finally be together. 💕💕💕
The only thing sad is that the book is over & that they didn't get together sooner!! I'm gonna miss following along on their love story 😭💞
Yall nobody warned me about the huge triggers so just be careful 🫶🏻 and be aware 💔😭
This book left me in a state of minor depression it stuck with me for three months and then i got the sequel and I think I cried a total of 4 HOURS!! Now I feel empty inside and I don’t know how to continue with life.
i sobbed so hard in that book. i always knew something was off abt her friend group and i knew they weren’t good for autumn when they convinced alex to break up with his girlfriend and get back with sasha. they should have just let him be happy. i remember staying up all night just thinking about how unfair that book is but how good it is
My favorite book. The second book is actually from 3 different perspectives, I put myself through the torture and it was so worth it💔
I though the same thing. I didn't think I could read the second one. A few months later, I bought it anyways and read it. Let me tell you it it 10 times more sad than the first one. You will not stop crying, it is literally torture.
oh my god i read it during school, and at the end i was sobbing. hysterically. my teacher thought somebody in my family died. my classmates laughed at me when they figured out it was about a book. i have never cried so hard reading a book. i will never be the same. this is supposed to be dramatic.
have you read a thousand boy kisses?
@@Cora-eq4kb i havent, should i?
@@sadierose22 It is really really sad. I read it and it was good. i started crying on page 13
@@Cora-eq4kb oh i definitely need to read it then lol thank you!!
@@Cora-eq4kb ahhh i love that u recommended this book its so good, im on page 45 and ive cried like 3 times
I already bought this book last month but I stopped reading it on the middle, because it feels so hard to continue. My heart feels heavy while reading it. Like, I know what will happen but I can't accept it.
I read the second book and can confirm your crisis will expand in the NEED to know and the frustration of knowing and the questions left not asked. Like BRU! Jack my guy was on a whole role and just STOPPED! Like duuuude! IT WAS HER FAULT! 😭 just read it and let me know im not alone in hating silvy
I just finished the 2nd book and I am balling my eyes out but you definitely need to read it because it helps you understand more even tho it’s super sad 😭
this book made me cry so much i was like heart broken. when i got the book i finished the book that same day i couldn’t put that book down. and when it was like the last 10 chapters i was sobbing the whole time
Ye I just finished it and cried a lot. When I read it, I found a part of me that I never knew it existed but when finn dies it was lost again never to be found.
You ruined it for other people (not me)
BROOO U RUINED IT
i couldn’t cry i was in shock😭
I literally bawled my eyes out.
And you can’t understand that this won’t make you cry like the sequel did to me I cried so hard for so long I’m dead “if only I had told her “is the best thing you will ever read
that book made me shed so many tears i literally almost passed out from dehydration. read the second book at your own risk fs
I have just finished reading this novel and oh it left me broken... I love Finny,and how I wish finny and autumn to be together till the end. 😓
i just finished it.. still balling and i’ve never realated more
im still crying i read it ages agooo ughhhhhh
this books ending made me SOB ON MY FLOOR for like an hour
i just finished reading it like a minute ago. why. just why. i’m planning on reading “if only i had told her” but i know i’m gonna cry more.
😭😭 So fucking sad but a beautiful ending 😭❤
I bought that book today and now I don’t want to read it because of how broken she sound and I know she’s on the verge of tears.. it literally hurting my heart hearing her, I do not want to go through that while reading it!!😭😭
Edit: I’m still watching this and I’m starting to tear up listening to her voice!!!! It so broken, thats making absolutely sad for her.
it's totally okay! 😭 I'm reading that book right now and trust me , the sad part would only be at the end ! While reading it , it's actually super cute but sometimes you have to sit and think about things , but overall it's very fun to read this one! Totally recommend (unless you can't handle the emotions)
@@saumyasoni2224yea I’m still going to read the book even though I can’t handle emotions for shit.. I spent my money on it so I got to read it..
"Finny?" "Oh Autumn..." At the end BROKE me! 😭 I made a whole Playlist on Spotify named that, (dedicated to the book OBVI). But I got this book from my school library... I just started reading the next book and I haven't started crying yet, but I'm going to I know it!
I just finished the book and I Cried alot. But like the way she calls him Finny and the way he took care of her even when they weren't friends likee I CANT
Nah, but the fact that Autumn is pregnant with finny's baby, but he's dead, makes me wanna cry so hard 😢
TOOK THE WORDS LITERALLY OUT OF MY MOUTH😢
Described my feelings for it perfectly.
reading his pov now 🥲🥲🥲🥲
I just read that i cried for 10 minutes... "don't bother knocking down the door, call the cops and let them deal with it." IM GONNA DIE
Just finished and floating on my tears 😭😭😭😭😩😩😩
I just wish we had Sylvies perspective in the second book
I just finished it and when autumn wrote that finny had died on the 8 of august and when she was thinking over and over again that if he had been here this wouldn't of happened if he had been with me ..
The last lines broke me and call me emotional for all I care but this book rlly broke me
I read the 2nd book and hardly shed any tears-not that it isn’t sad I was just able to hold them back while I couldn’t for the first book
This book paralyzed me so much.This book is never going to be out of my mind ever and i probably can never read this book again.I always felt like sad book gave me a kind of diff comfort but everytime i feel sad my mind wanders into this this book that all i can think abt is alternative endings shitt i feel like my heart is tightening ❤.😢
damn she sold me the book. i like watching people's reactions about books before i start reading it and this is it. this is the kind of reaction that makes me wanna read it.
It was so triggering to me.... I have lost a best friend to suicide, i lost 4 other people in the span of 5 years. I'm a sophomore. I wasn't expecting this at all. I also wasn't paying as much attention in the beginning so i had no clue that ot would happen. I cried for hours because it was just too real in my own life. So please before you read this book make sure nothing in your life could possibly be triggered by this book
Okay, definitely have to start it now 🫠
Be prepared it’s really sad! And I mean really sad for someone who doesn’t cry when it’s a sad movie I cried so hard because of this book
@@gacha_girl0.1 I finally started it but now I’m scared to finish it!!!!!!!!
@@jvsmxn I finished it today I was crying my eyes out
@@gacha_girl0.1 I’m not readyyyyy 😭 and you say you don’t cry. I DO! AT EVERYTHING!!!!!!!!
When I read this I didn’t really understand the beginning about him and Sylvie dying but it KILLED me at the end!!! FINNY IS MY BOOK BF 😭😭
This was the first book I had ever bought with my own money. Was not a disappointment at all.
the 2nd book is even sadder… I’m reading it now!
It started with the end but as the story went on i forgot about the end, i completely forgot he was going to die, i now feel broken
I cried, lemme just say that I cried to hard, Autumn and Finny shared their final kiss😭😭😭😭
The end destroyed me.😢
I'm actually soo dense bc I didn't know how it would end until it happened... But I read the second book immediately after and I sobbed so much
I just finished it, and i completely agree with everything you said. I cried for 10 minutes and i never do that with any book
I like the first book better than the second. But the second one is actually told in 3 perspectives and it's so sad because of the irony of stuff that Finn says that we all know is coming
I flipping sobbed 😭
the whole time while i was reading the book i was thinking “im not gonna cry ik what happens” but when it actually happened i cried so much.😭
I CRIED I NEVER CRY OVER BOOKS
I just finished it after starting it this morning, my best friend has had many calls.
I felt same after finishing shatter me 1st book
⚠️Tw: this book has mentions of suicide, teen pregnancy, depression, and depictions of death⚠️
i just finished this book like five minutes ago and i just need like a couple hours of sitting and staring at the wall trying to think about what i just read. i didn’t even cry at the end, i just feel so numb. (in a good way, i absolutely loved this book) im giving it five stars, i would give it six if i could
if only he had been with me by Laura Nowlin
when I read this my mind totally blanked and I fully forgot that the end is at the start. I was over there thinking they were gonna get happily married and have kids.
I screamed when I finished this book honestly it’s one of the worst but best books you will ever read and I don’t recommend reading the second one just leave it at that
It took me three days to complete it, and although I'm a bit emotional, I didn't cry like I thought I might when I placed the order. There were definitely other emotions involved, but overall, it felt quite predictable to me without any real twists. 😅
This had me devastated this book❤😢
The second book has jacks perspective afterwards and I was not nearly okay for about 10 hours afterwards
I just finished this and I can’t stop crying😭😭😭
I LOVE this book, but had to wait a couple months before reading the second one
I just finished this book not even 5 minutes ago, i cried so much. Idk what to do now...
I listened to the audiobook two nights ago not knowing much about the book. Towards the end I ran to my mom room crying. 😭 I love the book,but I didn’t know how triggering that book would be I had a whole anxiety attack and cried myself to sleep the night I finished. I ordered the second book today imma need therapy after this 😂
U explained this book perfectly
It was sooo good and sad at the same time .
I stoped before I got to the sad part I just couldn’t go through that after everything that I read.
I just got done with this book and I am not ok😭
I had to stop reading "Educated" by Tara Westover because it was too sad. I just read "Eleonor Oliphant is Completely Fine." I finished it but... unfortunately I could relate to her. It was sad.
the second book broke me
i cried at the end of this
you will 100% cry harder if you read the second one. Still one of my favorite books and I totally recommend it, but you will cry harder fs 😂
I found that book at my science teacher on the floor and I took it saying I need to read more and then when I finnshed the book I was sobbing and this was all at school
I just finished this book!! I loved the writing and the style. I knew somehow Finny would die in his car but going to talk to that "B" I was so upset!! Life is so short! Enjoy every min. of it!
there’s a new book about finnys perspective. it’s so good
I saw this book at walmart thought oh okay it must be some silly teen romance...bought it, im now forever torn 😢
The other books is called"if only i told her"
⚠️ Spoiler, alert⚠️🥀
This is my all time favorite book ever!!! I just read it 2 days ago and I’m still ugly crying over it makes me so sad knowing there not a movie about it or anything and how she has to live her life knowing, the only person who helped her with her pain was finny smith but he’s not here anymore and now I’m crying again!! I keep telling my friends I want to have kids named finny and autumn!! I keep ugly crying in school bc of this book a certain songs triggers me and makes be cry I was sobbing the next day (Monday) bc I couldn’t stop crying of this amazing book and I can’t find another book like this!!! I can’t wait to get the book about finnys version!!! 😭 🥀📕❤️
I feel the same I just finished the book and oh boy I did not expect that I was crying so hard like the deserved more time together 😭 I don’t think I can read Finny’s version I’m like broken in the best way possible 😭😭
@@Olivia0426 omg girl I wish I can hug you!!! I know how you feel!! But you have like a whole month before reading it to forget about everything!! IT COMES FEB 6th and if you read the book it’s ends with us there making a movies and it comes out FEB 9TH SORRY JUST LOVE READING
@@Jacob_elordi.issohot huh they’re making a movie?? My friend isn’t really a fan of reading but she said she would watch a movie if there is one
@@Olivia0426 lol yes!! There Making a movie of “It ends with us” I looked it up on google and everything!
Finished the book in a matter of hours and I agree this book feels incomplete and I'm numb and don't know how to feel
This but the book "a thousand boy kisses"
Bro, I was thinking whether I should buy this or not but now I really wanna read it.
It’s worth it. But the end tho 😢
Hi, I loved it a lot... However I have a doubt, how did Autumn know Jammy and Sasha cheated on her? How did she know he was gonna break up... I couldn't get that part...
I knows it's all about Fin and Autumn and have loved it.. However just wanted to know how did she find out before James told her?
Bro I fucking cried so hard to the point where I got a headache and it was one am 💀
Ok so I just finished the book and I’m a bit confused by the ending, what my understanding is, that finny died and then autumn tries to commit Yk but then it brings up her being pregnant? I tried to read it over to see if I missed something but I’m confused someone please explain the ending to me 😭🙏
yeah basically, when finny dies she cuts herself, then she’s in the hospital and finds out she’s pregnant, she thought of trying to harm herself again but decided not to knowing finny wouldn’t approve
i love it but i was sobbing at the end ☹️