Thank you for speaking reason. My great grandfather was a filipino scout in WWII and my father an Iraq vet. from the storys alone both the fighting men and the enemy are diffrent there is no place for comparison.
A video about the struggles of war and the pain and death in war absolutely go along with this song. And I didn't see anyone passing out cake, remarking what a lovely time they're having. Killing and watching your friends die around you is painful. Rise Against isn't cool with that. Therefore, this video gets the point across quite nicely.
My goodness, I have to say, I admire your perseverance. For hating my video, you sure have a tendency to return to it quite often. It seems like anything I say will fall on deaf ears but I’ll try anyway. I know Rise Against is anti-war. I’ve followed them for years, and their message is obvious. However, I believe this applies to recent/present day conflicts such as Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan, instances in which our reasoning for invading were “sketchy” and questionable at best.
American intervention in WWII was completely justified: the Axis powers were a real threat to American and European security. We were not embroiled in controversy and wrapped up in red-tape like we are nowadays. America was united in the cause, not broken up and fragmented like we are nowadays, because in WWII, the war effort was WORTH DYING FOR.
Great song, Great HBO miniseries, Honestly if you know both of them as well as I do, they do not work with each other. No doubt a good quality video, but I am seriously doubting the connection.
I get hate comments from watchers of this video pretty often, so I have to return to this video to read them ;) Anyway, I understand your point, but I still disagree with it. I don't personally like videos like these with Rise Against's songs, but it's just my opinion :)
People can do what they want and I want to criticize this video because I think it's against Rise Against's message. I have my opinion of this video and you have yours. And about communism, it's not synonym for dictatorship. Communism is only one kind of economic system. Both capitalists and communists have made lot of bad things, but for some reason they don't talk much about Chile or Argentina capitalist-dictatorships in American schools.
@xWhiteXFeatherx yeah im the same i think its okay from what i watch so far but again the characters just arent up to scratch with the chars from easy company
the orders were also given to take no prisoners and to leave no survivors so not obeying and shooting them would go against orders and could get our soldiers into trouble with their commanding officers.
the times when you were fighting for love and peace in the world are over. pleaser realise that modern warfare is not about stabilizing for mankind reason but for financial reasons. i understand your arguement and i think from your view it's right, but keep in mind that these times are not ours anymore.
It's not like the soldiers are gonna put their guns down and say "Gosh darn it, they turned around! Now we can't shoot!" Secondly, yes, I know Rise Against is a popular anti-war band, I'm quite a big fan of theirs. However, I find it impossible, even downright ignorant, to try and compare WWII to the present-day wars being waged right now. I would begin delving into the details of my comparison, but frankly this character limit is far too short. Go ahead, dislike my video, I really don't mind.
Ya see, if you could have just said THAT instead of mentally masturbating we could have nipped this in the bud. This video is far from pro-war, if it was pro-war it would be glorifying events, which it isn't. The song's meaning is essentially "War is horrible, but sometimes things are worth dying for", which the video gets across quite well.
Ya see, the difference is we didn't "execute" the Germans. We fought against the armies yes, but we didn't go after civilians. This video seems to get the point that "War is horrible" quite well, look at the expressions on the character's faces. Pleas explain, exactly how this is "pro-war"?
That's not an execution they could of turned around and shot and execution is shooting men or women that have surrendered or have no means to fight men retreating always get fired upon the germans would have done the same and it's been like that in every war
American soldiers killed 504 civilians in My Lai. Does that give Vietnamese soldiers right to execute all American soldiers, even 99% of them had nothing to do with human right violations? Nazis did horrible things during WWII, but only very small part of battlefront soldiers were ever involved in them. And again, because Rise Against is anti-war band, I personally think that showing pro-war video with their song is pretty foolish.
We didn't execute normal germans you idiot we took majority prisoners and most were tried that comttited crimes and a their are a few cases of ss being shot but even the German army hated them and they were bad and the germans tried to kill. Everyone not aryan and they shot allied prisoners later in the war and did Shit like attacking a felid hospital killing the doctor and slitting the throats of the wounded I'm happy to say every German that was part of that was killed and mai lai was not ordered by the top a rogue guy ordered it and some Americans even tried to stop it and one pilot did and he got his guns out which is nicer then what I would have done the men who killed in that massacre should have been shot and disgraced are army and this video is not glorifying war this series told about how terblie war was and. The things they fought for were worth dying for
Very nice job of matching awesome song and awesome video material.
Honour to you.
watch out guys, this guy has read a WHOLE 100 books. Impressive!
truly wonderful video
This is the most amazing thing ive seen in a long time.
I applaud you for this.
Band of brothers is the best series ever it is just so epic everyone should see it
Rise against andBand of brothers?! talk about clutching it up! \m/
Rise against is my love and this video is amaaaazing!!
loved it
are u kidding me? people are arguing about the video? this is a song, listen to it, love it, hate it, no one cares.
Thank you for speaking reason. My great grandfather was a filipino scout in WWII and my father an Iraq vet. from the storys alone both the fighting men and the enemy are diffrent there is no place for comparison.
A video about the struggles of war and the pain and death in war absolutely go along with this song. And I didn't see anyone passing out cake, remarking what a lovely time they're having. Killing and watching your friends die around you is painful. Rise Against isn't cool with that. Therefore, this video gets the point across quite nicely.
Battle of Bloody Gulch!!!!!!!!!!!! This is a crazy video!
I know this is a month overdue, but thank you! There's nothing quite like a calm, well-reasoned discussion on TH-cam haha
hey, here in 2020, edit and the song is still perfect
This is awesome to hear! I kinda thought all these videos had been forgotten. Glad you liked it :)
Michael Kula they keep appearing, in my algorithm atleast :) thank you for the answer back on a 7 year old video!
@@MichaelKula nah band of brothers is the best show and this is an amazing song
this song is AWESOME, the video is great too good job!
Amazing vid!
i love how you made this video. good job!! :)
PLEASE DO MORE VIDEOS LIKE THESE!
It's the two great Bands combined; Band Of Brothers w/ Rise Against.
Awesome vid mate!
The song really suits it 5/5
AWESOME!
loved it
Rise against is awsome
lol in Call of Duty 1 there are Maps (carentan) that look EXACTLY THE SAME!!!
so cool :D
the second map (in the nature) is brecourt
so funny ^^
The GREATEST war series EVER made.
Ooooooo RA!!!!
No the pacific is better, because its the us army in band of brothers their chant is Hoorah not oora. Oorah is the Marines chant. Idiot
Nostalgia...
My goodness, I have to say, I admire your perseverance. For hating my video, you sure have a tendency to return to it quite often.
It seems like anything I say will fall on deaf ears but I’ll try anyway. I know Rise Against is anti-war. I’ve followed them for years, and their message is obvious. However, I believe this applies to recent/present day conflicts such as Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan, instances in which our reasoning for invading were “sketchy” and questionable at best.
amazing video
i think the song fitted perfect into this clip
Cool video
Band of Brothers > The Pacific
Great editing, song choice and video choice
Amen brother.
badass video! rise against is the shit
American intervention in WWII was completely justified: the Axis powers were a real threat to American and European security. We were not embroiled in controversy and wrapped up in red-tape like we are nowadays. America was united in the cause, not broken up and fragmented like we are nowadays, because in WWII, the war effort was WORTH DYING FOR.
nice!
Your a beast.
genial!
nice
sick ass intro
Rise Against FTW
Yep, indeed.
In this time and period the WORLD WAS WORTH DYING FOR!
is band of brothers an serie or an movie?
Fucking amazing video and song
That's music
Great song, Great HBO miniseries, Honestly if you know both of them as well as I do, they do not work with each other. No doubt a good quality video, but I am seriously doubting the connection.
I get hate comments from watchers of this video pretty often, so I have to return to this video to read them ;)
Anyway, I understand your point, but I still disagree with it. I don't personally like videos like these with Rise Against's songs, but it's just my opinion :)
Did you make the video?
@xWhiteXFeatherx so youve probly been watching the pacific
How long did it take?
you know iv always found "easy company's" name a bit ironic seeing as how they had some if not the hardest missions in the german campaign lol
Aw!
hard^^
best 2 things in the world :p
they weren't retreating they where finding cover to fire back from, when you are in an ambush you get out of the kill zone regroup and counter attack,
People can do what they want and I want to criticize this video because I think it's against Rise Against's message. I have my opinion of this video and you have yours.
And about communism, it's not synonym for dictatorship. Communism is only one kind of economic system. Both capitalists and communists have made lot of bad things, but for some reason they don't talk much about Chile or Argentina capitalist-dictatorships in American schools.
Well America never killed over 20 million of it's own people cough cough Soviet union under stalin
@xWhiteXFeatherx yeah im the same i think its okay from what i watch so far but again the characters just arent up to scratch with the chars from easy company
you should make a Pacific one
what white feather??
@jonthewolf i agree..
but Judas Priest have a song called worth dying for... so, this is a copy... but i love rise against
the orders were also given to take no prisoners and to leave no survivors so not obeying and shooting them would go against orders and could get our soldiers into trouble with their commanding officers.
war is easily enjoyed by those that have no experience in it.
the times when you were fighting for love and peace in the world are over. pleaser realise that modern warfare is not about stabilizing for mankind reason but for financial reasons. i understand your arguement and i think from your view it's right, but keep in mind that these times are not ours anymore.
@jonthewolf dam a year ago i was in iraq fuck time flys and this vid has been out awhile.
It's not like the soldiers are gonna put their guns down and say "Gosh darn it, they turned around! Now we can't shoot!"
Secondly, yes, I know Rise Against is a popular anti-war band, I'm quite a big fan of theirs. However, I find it impossible, even downright ignorant, to try and compare WWII to the present-day wars being waged right now. I would begin delving into the details of my comparison, but frankly this character limit is far too short. Go ahead, dislike my video, I really don't mind.
Ya see, if you could have just said THAT instead of mentally masturbating we could have nipped this in the bud. This video is far from pro-war, if it was pro-war it would be glorifying events, which it isn't. The song's meaning is essentially "War is horrible, but sometimes things are worth dying for", which the video gets across quite well.
if u need a good ww 2 movie then u gotta watch band of brothers.
@xWhiteXFeatherx im a hug military buff and weapons expert and military expert :) thats y im going into the USMC
i hope that people don't see that as a tribute to war...like someone of the corps...
Ya see, the difference is we didn't "execute" the Germans. We fought against the armies yes, but we didn't go after civilians. This video seems to get the point that "War is horrible" quite well, look at the expressions on the character's faces.
Pleas explain, exactly how this is "pro-war"?
you got the lyrics all wrong
So... Rise Against, one of the most popular anti-war bands at the time, and video of U.S. soldiers executing retreating soldiers.
That's not an execution they could of turned around and shot and execution is shooting men or women that have surrendered or have no means to fight men retreating always get fired upon the germans would have done the same and it's been like that in every war
with serie i mean something like the pacific
Yep, but Rise Against is against that. I just think that military videos and RA songs doesn't fit together.
A couple hours
Ever heard about provocative writing? ;) But my point was that Rise Against is anti-war and this video is pro-war.
@nextgengamer100 its good man not as good but i enjoyed watching it it is worth the time
Well now that's just mean and uncalled for.
i swear this is from black hawk down
what
Sebrom MC none of this is from black hawk down
1993 black hawk down 1940s band of brothers
what?
sorry i know im a duch, i didnt get this "new youtube" shit
@xceedpLusBoflex its not good... ITS FUCKIN THE BEST!
American soldiers killed 504 civilians in My Lai. Does that give Vietnamese soldiers right to execute all American soldiers, even 99% of them had nothing to do with human right violations? Nazis did horrible things during WWII, but only very small part of battlefront soldiers were ever involved in them.
And again, because Rise Against is anti-war band, I personally think that showing pro-war video with their song is pretty foolish.
We didn't execute normal germans you idiot we took majority prisoners and most were tried that comttited crimes and a their are a few cases of ss being shot but even the German army hated them and they were bad and the germans tried to kill. Everyone not aryan and they shot allied prisoners later in the war and did Shit like attacking a felid hospital killing the doctor and slitting the throats of the wounded I'm happy to say every German that was part of that was killed and mai lai was not ordered by the top a rogue guy ordered it and some Americans even tried to stop it and one pilot did and he got his guns out which is nicer then what I would have done the men who killed in that massacre should have been shot and disgraced are army and this video is not glorifying war this series told about how terblie war was and. The things they fought for were worth dying for