Did you make v1 of this recipe? Let me know how this updated version stacks up! Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today’s video! Get 20% OFF + Free International Shipping + 2 Free Gifts with my code “BRIANL” at manscaped.com/brianlagerstrom
I made the 3rd version of the bread, but already changed the flour to bread and the whole wheat to rye flour, talking about taste, the rye was perfect. The dutch oven held up just fine and I do have a banneton. Not so sure I will try your new version, I am more then happy with the old altered version I absolutely have mastered. Thank you, was the first time ever the bread turned out as I remember it from Germany.
I think I have literally clicked into the original video like 100 times. This was my gateway to bread, and now I suddenly have like, a million bread books and proofing baskets and a sourdough starter and a Challenger pan. We haven't bought bread in years. I'm so excited for so many more people to discover this one!
I'm the very same, each step I check again, each time I make the bread. I think it's a cunning plan to get lots of views, psychological methods being administered definitely 😂😂
Same here! I used to watch the original video at least once a week when making bread, and now I've got my own starter, a couple books as well, and am experimenting with different types of flour, fermentation times and temperatures, and whatever else you can experiment with with bread. Thanks Brian!
Here my text version I created so I don't have to watch the video over and over again.😅 I halfed his recipe. This way my wife and I have no leftovers after eating it for 3 days. Bread V2.0 - 75g room temp water - Small pinch yeast -75g bread flour Let sit for at least 4h to 24h - 125g warm water - 6g fresh yeast or 2g instant yeast - All the poolish Mix into water -200g bread flour or all purpose flour - 6g Salt - 25g whole wheat or 9 grain flour - Mix together until smooth - Cover and let sit for 30 minutes - Wet hand really good, grab part of dough, pull up until it almost rips and let fall on other side of bowl 8 times - scoop underneath turn 90 degrees until there is almost a ball - cover and let sit for another 30 minutes - repeat folding and cover again for an hour - flour flat area put dough on it - grab side of it with 3 fingers, pull it out and fold it back on the dough to cover it by 60%, do this 7 to 8 times - turn ball over and do rotate loaf keeping the seem in the center and on the bottom - flip it seem side up into 9in proofing basket, tuck it a bit more to seal real good - proof on the counter for 30 min - preheat oven to 500° Fahrenheit with Lodge Dutch oven in it - proof on the counter for another 30 min - flour top of loaf and Dutch oven well - lower loaf top side down into D-oven - score on top with siccors - put lid on - reduce temp to 485° and bake for 18min take lid of and bake for another 20 to 25 min at 465 F - bake dark to get more flavour
Just FYI for whoever cares. I changed my receipt and added a pinch of ground cumin to it. I like it much better this way but my wife doesn't. I think it makes the bread a little bit more interesting. 😋
I cut the dough from the original recipe in two, bake one in the pot and the other half goes in the fridge in a proofing basket so it's ready for the next day bake. The first one doesn't last very long 😂
I’ve made this recipe at least a half dozen times now on two different continents and have to say I love it. The last time I baked this I changed up a couple things that worked well; First, like you do in the second way to bake, I divided it half but shaped both halves as boules but froze one. Then, when I wanted to bake the second loaf, I put it in the fridge 2 days before I wanted to bake it. Put it on the counter 2 hours before baking. I found that lowering the temp by 20 degrees kept the bottom from burning and immediately burning the corn meal. And I didn’t lower the temp after removing the lid. I also liberally sprayed the boule with water before putting the lid on. Thanks for continuing to make great recipes that can be made by the average home cook. I go to your site and videos at least weekly to plan the menu.
I have always used v1 but I did use bread flour all the time with great results I put black olives in it and feta it beats any brought bread I have come across This is my thank you gift for people who have help me and it gives me such pleasure baking bread and giving it away I found you through covid and bake every 2weeks thank you so much for making my time in the kitchen fill of joy when I bake your bread
@@BrianLagerstrompeople are so weird! I'm always surprised at what people kick off about in the comments on your videos. I don't know how you have the patience honestly! Please don't delete your OG recipes though, they are still good and are staples for some of us who have been around since weeds & sardines ❤
@@BrianLagerstrom I think it's amazing! Would be up for a revisit of other older recipes, whether it's an updated & improved method, extra variations, etc. Not sure if the YT algo gods would smile upon that but I would find it fascinating. NB this comes from someone who watches all your videos, often several times, even on the rare occasions that particular vid isn't something I would choose to make for my family.
FOR ALL CANADIAN VIEWERS: I have made Brians V1.0 many times, and had great results every single time. During my bread baking obsession I was going around looking at all the bread flours available, comparing it to AP flour, and it seems that in Canada at least , all and I mean ALL flour is strong flour, 4 g protein per 30 g of flour, putting it at 12-13 grams per 100 grams. I was able to find some posts explaining why that is at the time. But am unable to quote them at this time. So ... long story short ... In Canada at least , don't stress about finding bread flour ... Just look for the flour which shows 4 g protein per 30 grams ... and it is in fact most of it. I hope it clears some things up , as this singular thing sent me down a rabbit hole that I couldn't crawl out of for quite some time until I got my answer ... don't stress it , Canadian flour , even AP is good for this recipe. I hope this clears some doubts up for anyone dealing with what I have gone through. All Day Brian, All day. :)
This is so good to know! I ran around Toronto for months trying to find bread flour, but it was always sold out or simply not stocked (until I just went and bought a megabag from Costco). I've been using Brian's V1.0 recipe with 2/3 AP and 1/3 bread flour and it always turns out extremely delicious without being too difficult to work with.
@@Stripbolt Costco bread flour which I also bought, has the same protein content as any of the other ones available in a regular store , so no need to run around, I;ve made it with costco bread, as well as 5roses AP, both same protein content, I think living up north , flour is all high protein
My mother in law taught me to make bread when I was a newlywed. She made the best bread! She lived in northern Maine and would only use Robin Hood flour that she got in Canada in huge bags! I never understood why Canadian flour would be any different than ours but it was. Now I know why!
I've been doing the big dog at home since you posted the v1 recipe here. While making it over and over I eventually adapted the water/flour ratio to get a more consistent and manageable dough. Interestingly, I've been using a water quantity that is close to the one you mentioned in this v2 recipe. Therefore, it seems that we have found improvements as independent experimenters. Nice! PS: my kids say that the bread is not singing but howling since it's the big dog. :D
So many YT cooking shows are like "Watch me make a thing", Bri is like "here's how you make this thing" and that's not just more useful but also demonstrates a higher level of skill.
The original recipe was a game changer for me in the pandemic, to the point that I basically didn't buy bread for a year or two. I tweaked it over time and settled on this for the flours: 200g bread flour 100g wheat flour 100g dark rye flour Absolutely killer sandwich bread
Think I'm going to have to steal your recipe for this weeks bread lol. I've been thinking about adding wheat too my rye bread, and this is a good ratio.
I am a long-time viewer. I've tried a number of your videos. I love how you carry the viewer along with the what's, why's , when's, and how's of what you are making. I didn't try the first bread, but guy your way to instruct to have a home cook feeling like a chef is amazing. My bread came out great! Thanks for your content
When I first got into bread/dough-making two years ago, yours was one of my main sources of instruction. I learnt how to do strength-building folds from this channel, and your videos gave me so much knowledge and confidence to figure things out as I went. I changed jobs last year and have a lot less time and attention to bake now, and the last few loaves I've experimented with came out quite disappointing, but once I saw this video, I knew I had to make it. This is the first dough in a long time that has felt perfect and right, and it was such a joy to work with them. The loaves are in the oven now, and I'm so excited to have them for dinner tomorrow. Thank you for reminding me how much I love this, Bri!
I absolutely LOVE this style video. The mix of your normal voice over and the conversational style while you cooked, was very engaging. Plus I learned a ton by hearing the why behind your various changes.
Hey Bri, one of the things I think worth addressing in this video is about the temperature in your house when you start proofing the dough. I remember reading a comment thread on one of your videos about how your kitchen appears to be warmer than most and some people found WAY better results when they let their doughs rest for longer than the video specified. Moreover, I think it would also help to mention how Altitude plays a role in breadmaking and how different pressures cause dough to act differently during baking. Regardless, I absolutely love this video and I can't wait to try this since I finally got an oven at my new place.
My kitchen here in the UK changes temp wildly both month to month and even hour to hour, so this is all stuff I'd love to see more info about. Great shout.
I have a much colder house than normal (Avg 15degC last few weeks) what i do is simply pre-heat water in the microwave and also pre-warm the oven to a very low temp (no more than 50degC, but turn it off when the dough goes in) for proofing. If I've just come home from work I'll also put the bowl on top of my car bonnet. Ha. I've never bothered to look into altitude and pressure - defies the point of 'beginner' ? - but just looked it up and my house is at about 200m above sealevel and about 1023hPa. My bread still works out fantastic even though I haven't included these data into my recipe.
Baking at 23°C is standard, the most important thing is the T°c of the water which should be comprised between 16 and 20°C. The hotter your kitchen is the cooler the water must be. The wheat temperature is a minor factor in the equation.
interestingly "room-temperature" has a scientific standard, typically taken as 23C (74F). When Bri says "proof at room temperature" i think "way warmer than my cold ass 15C (59F) house, and plan accordingly
I just want to say the revisiting and explaining the “whys” of all this is EXTREMELY HELPFUL!! I’d love any and all re-dives and deep-dives on bread strategies anytime
I am a v1 user, and I started routinely making my own bread since. I appreciate the updated format using this recipe/process. The Big Dog never disappoints.
I'm 37, and have been baking bread since I'm 20. This recipe gave me the best, the BEST results, using simple All-purpose flour from a Mexican supermarket. It was the star of last night friend's dinner. The crust, the texture, the flavor... Perfect, all around. The sounds when it was cooling on the rack. Magnificent. Thank you for your work!
Hey Brian! I’ve made your original several times without any issues using Canadian all purpose flours… it has a protein content of approximately 13% depending on the brand. Just an FYI for your Canadian viewers. As well, thanks again for your fantastic channel and recipes. You have definitely changed eating in my house.
I can’t believe how good this bread is! I watched this video many times, and finally made just the easy mode ciabatta with no steam. I could not wait more than a few minutes and the bread is still warm from the oven. It is definitely the best bread I’ve ever made. It may be the best bread I’ve ever eaten. Thank you Brian! I will be making this again.
I love the way this video was shot and narrated. It’s cool having some moments of “real time Bri,” not just scripted, which is also always very thorough. Long time viewer! Love the content
I'm a long time viewer as well and I really didn't like the new camera tricks. For me it felt like it was more unprofessional than usual.. I like the normal style!
I make version 1 regularly with strong bread flower. I mix and shape it the night before and let it rise over night in a banneton in the fridge. This way i can eat this amazing bread fresh for breakfast. The whole family loves is. Thanks Bri for this gamechanger!
One thing you should add to your recipe, especially for the big one, is to let it cool completely or about an hour. I've sometimes felt rushed and would cut my bread 20 mins after baking and the center would still be slightly wet. Cutting early is a big mistake that beginners do especially cuz it smells so good!
Love to see that you’re experimenting with doing the narration live rather than as a recording after the fact. Keep it up big dog ❤ your recipes are the real deal
The mark of a true professional is what you just did. Could be so easy to rest on years of experience and left it at that. Instead, taking the time to listen, readjust and still create awesome food is genuinely awesome.
I started with your version 1.0 and struggled with the AP flour issue. Settled on bread flour and it really started working for me. I normally do two batches of he big dog version as I can fit my two Dutch ovens in my oven. I always add a teaspoon of bakers malt which makes a huge difference in the crust. I’ve used the same recipe to do cinnamon raisin bread (flatten dough and add a bunch of cinnamon and about 1 cup of raisins then form loaf) and an olive loaf (1 cup each of halved Kalamata olives & castelvetrano olives). The former makes amazing French toast and the latter is perfect with artichoke dip. Thank you so much, Brian!
I made the v2, "big dog" today. It didn't come out as large as I expected it to be, but not bad! I had put my poolish in the fridge after 24 hours and took it out the next day and let it warm up to room temp. Mabye a "fresh" poolish would've been better? Haven't tasted it yet (I really want to dive in, but it's too soon!). Smells great! Looks good, too! Thank you! Brian your instructions are great, very straightforward and to the point. You also exhibit a great sense of humor and humility. I really appreciate your content, and will be making more of your breads and other recipes! Thanks again! I think this is my 7th loaf of bread, ever! Fun!
One thing I like about your channel is that you are very informative. Most recipes tell you to follow a bunch of steps without explaining the importance of it, and how it changes the bread
I made this recipe (the third variation), and here are my notes: 1. I followed the directions exactly. All ingredients were weighed using a digital scale. I don't know if this is necessary, but it worked. 3. I let the pre-fermentation sit for a full day. It really didn't take off until about 6 hours in, so I'd say that 4 hours isn't long enough. Also, the longer it sits the more flavorful it becomes. 4. At each stage my loaf was shaggier and less aesthetically appealing that his. However, it still turned out fine. 5. I used a straight cast iron dutch oven (not enameled) and it turned out fine. The resulting loaf was PHENOMENAL. Open and airy crumb with a thin and crisp crust. It has Restaurant quality flavor and smells fantastic. The most magical moment was when I placed the loaf on the counter to cool and I could hear it crackle.
I make your V1 version of the big dog all the time. It was also my beginner loaf so I just had to learn to deal with the higher hydration - but that was all skill building! Luckily for me, I never noticed you said to use AP flour in the original recipe and so have used bread flour all along. So cool you re-made this video for people to try again. One thing I do differently, I don't have time in the evenings to finish a loaf in one night, so I make the poolish night 1, the bulk on night 2 (put it in the fridge after 2 SBFs), then night 3 it comes out of the fridge, warms up to room temp, shape, prove bake. I actually think the second overnight for the bulk improves the flavour. Cheers!
I make your last recipe regularly (so thanks a lot, Bri), my flour mix is 250g wheat bread flour, 100g spelt flour (if i'm feeling fancy) 30g rye flour 20g wholemeal rye flour (so little cuz this stuff looks like ash) Experimenting with different flours is actually so much fun, every each way you get something a bit different and you can find your fav.
Hey dude, I have one of the top comments on your original, I love it, and it came out perfect the first try. I've made it well over 300 times since then. While I've personally never made bread before that, you made it extremely easy to do so, without your instructions I'm sure I would have had a hard time; that being said, I've since sent that same recipe to 9 people, not one of them has been able to make it, claiming "too stick/hard to work with" as the problem. This will definitely help them out a lot, and I'll share with them this updated one. I will also try it tomorrow with Bread Flower, but I'm sure it will end up perfect just like the AP version. Thank you for making a baker out of me Brian. Much love.
I'm struggling to understand if the bake time is 22 minutes after removing the lid or 10 minutes. The lid on bake time is 12 minutes and then when taking out of the oven he said "after 22 minutes...." Maybe I'm understanding it too literally.
Brian, your bread recipe was the first bread I ever attempted. I absolutely butchered it, but it was bread that got me through some serious food insecurity last year. Since then your rustic bread has become my go-to bread which my family absolutely loves. I'm deeply grateful for that video and absolutely stoked for the improved recipe!
Hey Bri, I made your bread this morning. It was my first ever bread baking endeavor. I went for the Big Dog and it is delicious. Thanks for sharing your experience and expertise.
I love the change to your videos... a mix of you talking in person and voice-over! Nice one Brian. A minor change but it totally changes the feel of the video. Love your work.
@@BrianLagerstrom Yep the hand-held camera shots focusing on what you are doing also add an extra level over static head-on shots. Makes it flow much smoother than a what can feel like a selection of cuts stitched together. A great balance of information without either getting too complicated or being patronising.
Awesome, Brian. I baked my first loaves from your first video, which was a perfect starting place. From there I went to fully fledged sourdough. Now I've come back to a poolish style loaf that gives me the optimum bread to effort ratio. Thanks for your great videos.
I definitely used your video to get started baking bread. Overall I had only a couple issues - all you addressed in this video. Thanks for taking the time to make an update!
That is so beautiful! More families should have this traditional weekly family gathering, but it has been lost in our busy, scattered culture. You and your wife are gems!
I made this "good" loaf as my first go at hand mixing and kneading bread (I've used my stand mixer for every other recipe I've done). It turned out INCREDIBLE, so I took a picture, sent it to my mom. My mom has never made bread without a bread machine, and she made a "good" loaf with success,first try!
Hi Brian, Thanks for the update and for confirming my suspicions about the flour. I've tried version 1 several times, and when I used plain flour it really didn't work. Also in version 1 you suggest decreasing the water because 78% can be too much for us mere mortals in bread making, so I reduced from 280g to 250g of water, exactly the amount in version 2. When it worked I used Italian flour Caputo Cuoco with 12% protein. Today I made version 2 with Caputo Manitoba Oro, which has 14%. I took the liberty of modifying it a bit, I used 100g of water + 150g of beer and I also added 90g of Parmesan cheese. It turned out sooo good! Tomorrow I'll make it with wine. Each time I used the Dutch oven version. I bought an iron pan that has a smooth lid on top so I can use it upside down, so it's easy to put the dough in and out. I believe that with a flour as strong as Manitoba Oro maybe I can increase the hydration a little, what do you say? Congratulations for the channel and thank you very much ! Greetings from Brazil
I've made V1 quite a bit but cut the water back to 302 grams to make the Big Dog. It turns out quite well. Just made V2 last night but made the poolish a day ahead. It's interesting that you ditched the oil and the sugar and I think the bread is better for it. This was a very tasty bread and certainly much easier to work than V1. My only disappointment was the Big Dog didn't rise as much as I had hoped. It turns out that yeast that is almost a year past its expiration date is a bit stunted! I can't wait to try again with fresh yeast. When I was doing the no-knead bread, I used to drop the dough ball into the dutch oven (like in this video) and almost always deformed the bread by hitting the side or getting it uneven (plus, it's just a little too easy to graze that blistering hot pan with a finger). These days, I drop the dough from the banneton onto a square of parchment paper. After scoring, I grab the edges of the parchment paper and lower the loaf into the hot pan. My loaves are now beautiful and I no longer burn my hands.
I'm having the same issue with my dough deflating on the move from banneton to dutch oven. Am I overproofing? I'll try the parchment paper today and see if that helps.
I've made V1 countless times in an ongoing endeavor to get the AP to behave as yours did in that video. My bread making confidence waned. I was on the verge of losing all hope and turning in my apron and dutch oven. Alone on the baking cart, its label turned away in sorrow, sat my bread flour. The container untouched for weeks. Shame lay heavy in my once joyful kitchen. The dishwasher wept. No longer did the Kitchenaid trust me to take it for a spin. Even the Instant Pot chimed in, red letters passing by like a Times Square billboard message, "Dear God, please, don't let her touch me!" The Vitamix cord wrapping round it in a comforting embrace. Could it be that the skills I'd gained, no matter how small, were disappearing? A dark vision crept into my mind. James, paring knife in hand, slit open a vanilla bean. Carefully scraping its insides, he said, "Let's get rid of the seeds...," flicking them into the sink. O M GOSH!! I've become Anti Baker!! In that very moment, a familiar voice broke in, " ... the recipe wasn't perfect. " 😮 What? Bread flour? Bread flour! I ran at once to the tear-stained container. "He was wrong!" Today, I stand aproned, mixing bowl in hand, slapping and folding, proud once again. Order up! Let's eat this thing!
I started with version 1, and it always came out ridiculously wet. It still made good bread, but never had a good rise because I couldn't reliably work with it. So I tried bread flour, a bit more wheat flour, and suddenly my bread was perfect. Glad to see an updated video addressing the hydration. One of the best channels for baked good and recipes in general.
BMAN! So glad to see a redux of my go-to recipe for 2+ years straight. While my technique has improved over time (thanks SBFs), these new ratios with bread flour will probs be the game changers to take it over the top. I can’t wait to report back, but I can already tell that this recipe is BOULIN’
Since I used this recipe and loved it, I wanted to give my own little tip. I didn't want to damage my Dutch oven, so instead I baked the 3rd loaf style on a baking sheet. And for the steam I instead used a spray bottle full of water and sprayed the inside of the oven 5-6 times as soon as I put the breat in. The crust came out fantastic!
Version 1 has been my weekly bread recipe for a couple of years now, and over that time I have moved to adding 450g of flour instead of 400, as well as using 50g of whole wheat, 300 of bread, and 100 of AP flour. Sounds like you made similar changes, I’ll try this one and compare!
Thanks for this, Brian! My kitchen has never smelled better. I am a new bread maker, at age 55, and I came to bread making with ZERO cooking / baking experience. It was just something to do because I miss my mom. She made really good bread. My first attempt at bread was the “easiest” video (not yours.) I think you were sort of calling this video out when you said your recipe was the easiest bread “that is actually good.” I will say the other guy’s easiest bread was actually very good and I might have stopped right there. I made it a few times, and then went looking for something more adventurous, which is how I found your video. Went straight for the Big Dog. Wow. OK… It is objectively better. Whether it’s the poolish or the Dutch oven method or the good bread flour or all three is academic. I added a smidge of water. Two ounces maybe. Probably not necessary. It felt dry to me. I used to knead bread, 45 years ago, so not an expert opinion by any means. No arguing with results! I have made various things of wood and metals. When I saw a video of someone folding up dough, I was reminded of pattern welded steel, and I realized I could do that. I’m so glad I did. Thank you so much for explaining it clearly and showing exactly what to do. If I can follow your instructions and make this bread, anybody can.
Ahhh so excited! These are literally the two issues I've had: 1) Too wet dough 2) slacky even after folding I thought I was doing something wrong and it was demotivating, but my loaves were still so delicious so I persevered the past year. I cannot WAIT to try with your updated recipe and see how good the loaves will be. Thank you so much for being a great resource and doing this update video! If only I saw it 10 hours ago, as I started a loaf today and literally saw this video after I finished shaping and started preheating my oven haha!
I think I have probably made version 1 over 20 times at this point. It made me fall in love with baking. Thanks for continuing to make bread accessible to home cooks!
I've been struggling to make a good 'sour-faux' bread for ages, both with discard recipes and poolish, but honestly this is a game changer. I made the Big Dog yesterday, and it turned out just perfect. Many thanks for the super-clear instructions!
I like to use King Arthur which is 11.7%. It splits the difference and I use it for everything without too much trouble. I found working the dough more solves the wetness problem he was talking about.
I've never been much of a baker. Growing up I always loved my grandmother's homemade bread. Finally, I'm stepping up into the adventure of exploring how to make my own bread. I've checked out these "artisan" type loaves shown on TH-cam, that brag ease of preparation and no kneading. But, there are A TON of little details that are always missing, and the kinds of details lacking are actually pretty consistent. This video was great because you're actually testing/trying/proofing each new attempt and making significant changes that create a different product. This made for a great learning experience because it cuts down on how many times I need to fail by practicing or trying new things in the WRONG way. One of the big, any maybe most valuable thing I learned from this post was how punishing high heat baking is on ceramic coated cast iron. I would have NEVER known that and would likely have destroyed mine in the process. So, black Friday sales, I'm putting one of those Lodge Dutch ovens on my shopping list! Thanks so much for this. Oh, and the instruction on the Poolish was a bonus I could not have anticipated...THANK YOU!!
Big thanks for 1.0 and now 2.0! Version 1.0 kicked off a year of baking for me and yes I did struggle with the initial recipe but with the assistance of some of the comments I altered it and finally succeeded making a Big Dawg, pure bliss! Now roughly a year later this pops up in my feed, crazy. Will have to give this recipe a shot and see the difference. Thanks!
Just pulled this “Big Dawg” out of the oven and it is singing! BTW, for everyone who is wondering, I used parchment paper because I always do and I baked it in a Challenger bread pan because I have it. I followed the recipe as written without any problems with stretch and folds and shaping!
After watching the video many times, I've perfected a delicious loaf using the recipe. It's now a regular part of my meals. I follow the recipe exactly, using whole wheat flour, and the bread turns out wonderfully. I've been making Mark Bittman’s New York Times bread for years, but this new recipe is even better. I also enjoy the educational and entertaining style of Brian, and I find my Taormina Covered Dutch Oven works well for this recipe. I've even asked for a Lodge cast-iron Dutch oven for Christmas, as I am a fan of simple cookware and using high-quality ingredients from places like Whole Foods, Fresh markets, and local food stores. I am still practicing proper scoring on the top of the loaves for the perfect appearance, but the texture, flavor, and overall look of the bread are already perfect. My guests have only had positive things to say about it, and I am very grateful for this amazing 2.0 version of the recipe. Thank you, Brian!
I am doing this today. I was thinking of making 2 loaves of bread using the third method, since I don't have a Dutch oven big enough to get the whole dough in there. Here in Finland, ap flour usually has 12.5-13g proteinin per 100g. I use flour where is exactly 13g. Edit. The breads turned out excellent. Maybe next time I'll use a little less flour when I'm not making bread for the first time. I always start making bread with this recipe for myself and my family. Really good recipe, I recommend it. Thanks for this Brian!
Version 1.0 has been part of my Saturday morning ritual for months now (I was a little late to the party lol). I’ll be trying out these ratios for sure this weekend. Got some good ideas for further experimenting in the comments too!
I’ve made this recipe several times and I love it. So happy to hear you clarify about the protein content of the flour you used in the first video. I’ve had such success with bread flour and the one time I tried this with APF it was a mess. Thanks man. You rock!
One important thing about loafs #2 and #3 that you don't mention in either video is the pizza steel you've got under the dutch oven. The first couple times I tried to make either they turned out almost perfect, but the bottom was burned straight black and took some of the fun out of eating it. I wondered for a while why I was getting that when you weren't, until I noticed you were putting the dutch oven onto a pizza steel. I then did the same and, voila, a perfectly browned bottom! Because of the longer cook time, particularly on loaf #3, you really need that steel or stone to guard against direct heat from the oven element to prevent burning. Love the videos, this channel got me into baking!
I did option 3 on my first try and it turned out PERFECT. I'm now making a double batch because my neighbor saw my pic on FB and I offered to make them a loaf. Thank you for the amazing recipe.
Great update to the original video, Brian! I was one of those that had the problem with the dough being too wet to efficiently work with. So I had catered the recipe with a little bit less water/using bread flour and have been making the third version of this recipe for the better part of a year. Glad to see the updated version.
That's so nuts, I literally made the bread from the last recipe a couple of days ago. It tasted good but didn't rise during the prove for some reason :/
@@BrianLagerstrom Hey Brian, you are probably right about that. I let it rise overnight in the fridge before shaping and proving it in the basket, so probably didn't give it enough time to come back to room temperature when I did that.
I have now made this bread two days in a row. Both were 24° poolish preferment, one in the Dutch oven, and one in the cast iron you showed. And I did the "best" version. I cannot believe how good this bread is. For some reason it takes me back to when I lived in England as a child, and one of the breads there. So disappointed when we came to the states, where we stayed! So this is so welcome! Thank you!
I made version 1.0 many times. I think I combined a few recipes, but now have basically my own amalgam recipe. Thank you for helping get into making my own bread.
I've made the first version according to the recipe several times in the past to mixed results. Eventually I started to just experiment with my own recipe for the dough. I ditch the whole wheat flour and just use all purpose. I do the poolish the previous night by volume with a cup measure of flour, shaken to level, and the same cup measure filled with water. A pinch of yeast and just leave that overnight. Other than that, its blooming the yeast in warm water and a tablespoon of sugar in the stand mixer then add poolish, swish it around to mix, then add four cups of flour, a tablespoon of salt, another tablespoon of sugar, set it to mix for ten minutes. Then I come in with four tablespoons of softened butter, one at a time until they're all incorporated. I take the bowl out of the mixer, put on gloves and do the stretch and fold method to bring it together, flip it seam side down and leave it to rise for an hour. Halfway through that rise, I get the oven preheating with the dutch oven inside. When the time comes, into the dutch oven goes cornmeal, then I transfer the dough into the oven, score the top and bake it following your times. When it comes out, it smells amazing, tastes amazing and has just the nicest crunchy crust. I've no idea if anything I did made any difference, but its a pretty common bread for me to make now.
This really is the best cooking channel. I love the way you wove the instructional interludes into the voiceover work. I hope you stick with that in future vids!
I just wanted to say that this tutorial was the most informative recipe, good fun and egoless. I can come back to this video whenever I teach somebody to make great bread. Many thanks!
I made the big boule today (my first ever) after mastering your baguette recipe. On a whim, I used the baguette dough recipe (up until the split into two) and got a pretty good loaf. I’ll try the longer autolysis next time, but it’s hard to imagine it could have a better result. Thanks for teaching me to make real bread!
Brian this is simply the best loaf of bread I’ve ever made. I make it Friday night with sourdough starter, let it rest overnight in the fridge and present it warm on Saturday for brunch. It’s a wonderful loaf of bread and I’m winning all sorts of brownie points at home so thank you!!
I made the biggest one , and I’m in Florida we constantly have the ac pumping here . I let the polish go for 2 days and the dough for double proofing time , and the bread came out amazing . Great video and recipe .
I’ve made both versions, thank you for the new and improved 2.0. I baked the big dog Boule yesterday and added 6 ounces of 1/4” diced sharp cheddar and 90 grams of rough chopped pickled Jalapeños. It came out amazing. I added the cheese and Jalapeños in during the second fold. Thank you for the great recipes and easy to follow instructions.
I also do this at times. My original attempts used shredded cheese and it just disappears, so I moved to the cubes. Much better results. I also put a 1/4 cup or so of cheese on top of the bread with sliced rings of jalapeno.
On my 4th time making this bread and it’s only gotten better. Thanks for being so thorough in this video Brian! First and only bread recipe I use and I swear by it now. Cheers👍🏼
Hey man, I'm so excited. Ive been doing this recipe for about 6times the last three months. Im so happy you made a new one to fix these issues. I can't wait to try it.
I've made this bread loads of times over the last few years. I've always done the loaf 3 method. It works great but the one thing I'd change is the cooking time. I'm not sure if I've just got a stronger oven but I usually cook mine for 18 min covered and then maybe another 10-13 minutes uncovered. Anymore than that and the bottom will get completely burned. But aside from that love the recipe and thank you for an improved recipe update.
I have no experience making bread, but I happen to have all the equipment this recipe calls for. I made loaf 3 of version 2.0 and I'm really impressed with how light, spongy and delicious it came out! .. and so easy to make. I used ap flour (from New Zealand) which I suspect is high enough quality because the ratios were great. I also sieved wheat bran from wheat flour instead of using cornmeal to protect loaf from surface of dutch oven. Thanks Brian, this will be my weekly go-to recipe :)
Yes! I have made that big dog loaf so many times! It is one of my favorite things to cook, and all my friends and family love it. Can't wait to make one with these new techniques. I could never get it to rise quite as big as yours so I'm guessing I'll have even better results now.
I’ve worked up from your first recipe. My enhancements included adding a higher amount of Whole Wheat flour, 5 grams of yeast in the poolish and then no more. The Diastatic Malt powder is key and I add about 15 grams vs 10 you previously spec’d. I think allowing more time to rise, then fold and stretch/strengthen makes a huge difference and given the time already being committed, an extra hour or two of rising and folding is more than worth it. Preheating the oven to 550 for 30+ minutes and then lowering it to 485 is the best for baguettes and 465 for cast iron pot version allows for more pot and less bake time required. My thoughts. Personally I think you’re and incredible talent and I love your videos and recipes. All the best!
Did you make v1 of this recipe? Let me know how this updated version stacks up!
Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today’s video! Get 20% OFF + Free International Shipping + 2 Free Gifts with my code “BRIANL” at manscaped.com/brianlagerstrom
i heard that if you say the name of your favourite youtuber 3 times they pin you:
Brian Lagerstrom,
Brian lagerstrom,
Brian Lagerstrom
I've made the large loaf from v1 multiple times, and it's always been fantastic. Looking forward to trying the new version soon!
I made the 3rd version of the bread, but already changed the flour to bread and the whole wheat to rye flour, talking about taste, the rye was perfect. The dutch oven held up just fine and I do have a banneton. Not so sure I will try your new version, I am more then happy with the old altered version I absolutely have mastered. Thank you, was the first time ever the bread turned out as I remember it from Germany.
I made level 2 and it was outstanding, so excited for this one
I did make it, and it came out okay. I did version 3. I have a pic somewhere. I'm sure I used bread flour, because I always do.
I think I have literally clicked into the original video like 100 times. This was my gateway to bread, and now I suddenly have like, a million bread books and proofing baskets and a sourdough starter and a Challenger pan. We haven't bought bread in years. I'm so excited for so many more people to discover this one!
That sounds amazing!! I'd love to get to that point
Brian is our bread god 😀😀
I'm the very same, each step I check again, each time I make the bread. I think it's a cunning plan to get lots of views, psychological methods being administered definitely 😂😂
Class
Same here! I used to watch the original video at least once a week when making bread, and now I've got my own starter, a couple books as well, and am experimenting with different types of flour, fermentation times and temperatures, and whatever else you can experiment with with bread. Thanks Brian!
Here my text version I created so I don't have to watch the video over and over again.😅 I halfed his recipe. This way my wife and I have no leftovers after eating it for 3 days.
Bread V2.0
- 75g room temp water
- Small pinch yeast
-75g bread flour
Let sit for at least 4h to 24h
- 125g warm water
- 6g fresh yeast or 2g instant yeast
- All the poolish
Mix into water
-200g bread flour or all purpose flour
- 6g Salt
- 25g whole wheat or 9 grain flour
- Mix together until smooth
- Cover and let sit for 30 minutes
- Wet hand really good, grab part of dough, pull up until it almost rips and let fall on other side of bowl 8 times
- scoop underneath turn 90 degrees until there is almost a ball
- cover and let sit for another 30 minutes
- repeat folding and cover again for an hour
- flour flat area put dough on it
- grab side of it with 3 fingers, pull it out and fold it back on the dough to cover it by 60%, do this 7 to 8 times
- turn ball over and do rotate loaf keeping the seem in the center and on the bottom
- flip it seem side up into 9in proofing basket, tuck it a bit more to seal real good
- proof on the counter for 30 min
- preheat oven to 500° Fahrenheit with Lodge Dutch oven in it
- proof on the counter for another 30 min
- flour top of loaf and Dutch oven well
- lower loaf top side down into D-oven
- score on top with siccors
- put lid on
- reduce temp to 485° and bake for 18min
take lid of and bake for another 20 to 25 min at 465 F
- bake dark to get more flavour
Thank you!
Just FYI for whoever cares. I changed my receipt and added a pinch of ground cumin to it. I like it much better this way but my wife doesn't. I think it makes the bread a little bit more interesting. 😋
I cut the dough from the original recipe in two, bake one in the pot and the other half goes in the fridge in a proofing basket so it's ready for the next day bake. The first one doesn't last very long 😂
There's a text version in the description.
@@arturjogi2667It doesn’t have instructions. It’s just a list of ingredients. Not helpful.
Thank you for looking back and not being afraid to say "I could have done better". Everyone gets a better recipe out of this!
He does this a lot actually. This guy is the best food youtuber for people who actually want to make the stuff they watch. At least best I know
I’ve made this recipe at least a half dozen times now on two different continents and have to say I love it.
The last time I baked this I changed up a couple things that worked well; First, like you do in the second way to bake, I divided it half but shaped both halves as boules but froze one. Then, when I wanted to bake the second loaf, I put it in the fridge 2 days before I wanted to bake it. Put it on the counter 2 hours before baking.
I found that lowering the temp by 20 degrees kept the bottom from burning and immediately burning the corn meal. And I didn’t lower the temp after removing the lid. I also liberally sprayed the boule with water before putting the lid on.
Thanks for continuing to make great recipes that can be made by the average home cook. I go to your site and videos at least weekly to plan the menu.
The level of quality instruction here is off the charts. Best YT cooking channel.
Best YT cooking channel. Full Stop!
Almost as good as the dance party my toddlers have at the end of these videos 💃 🕺
Was thinking the same thing, this is one of the best instructional videos I've seen on YT.
Hands down. He makes intimidating recipes much more approachable!!!
Chef Jean-Pierre is better, by far.
I have always used v1 but I did use bread flour all the time with great results
I put black olives in it and feta it beats any brought bread I have come across
This is my thank you gift for people who have help me and it gives me such pleasure baking bread and giving it away
I found you through covid and bake every 2weeks thank you so much for making my time in the kitchen fill of joy when I bake your bread
I appreciate your commitment to keep improving your recipes!
I’m so glad to hear that. Some people get but hurt when I redo content
@@BrianLagerstrompeople are so weird! I'm always surprised at what people kick off about in the comments on your videos. I don't know how you have the patience honestly!
Please don't delete your OG recipes though, they are still good and are staples for some of us who have been around since weeds & sardines ❤
Npc comment
@@BrianLagerstrom I think it's amazing! Would be up for a revisit of other older recipes, whether it's an updated & improved method, extra variations, etc. Not sure if the YT algo gods would smile upon that but I would find it fascinating. NB this comes from someone who watches all your videos, often several times, even on the rare occasions that particular vid isn't something I would choose to make for my family.
@@urie4769 not long from now npcs will have feelings too
FOR ALL CANADIAN VIEWERS: I have made Brians V1.0 many times, and had great results every single time. During my bread baking obsession I was going around looking at all the bread flours available, comparing it to AP flour, and it seems that in Canada at least , all and I mean ALL flour is strong flour, 4 g protein per 30 g of flour, putting it at 12-13 grams per 100 grams. I was able to find some posts explaining why that is at the time. But am unable to quote them at this time. So ... long story short ... In Canada at least , don't stress about finding bread flour ... Just look for the flour which shows 4 g protein per 30 grams ... and it is in fact most of it. I hope it clears some things up , as this singular thing sent me down a rabbit hole that I couldn't crawl out of for quite some time until I got my answer ... don't stress it , Canadian flour , even AP is good for this recipe. I hope this clears some doubts up for anyone dealing with what I have gone through. All Day Brian, All day. :)
This is so good to know! I ran around Toronto for months trying to find bread flour, but it was always sold out or simply not stocked (until I just went and bought a megabag from Costco). I've been using Brian's V1.0 recipe with 2/3 AP and 1/3 bread flour and it always turns out extremely delicious without being too difficult to work with.
@@Stripbolt Costco bread flour which I also bought, has the same protein content as any of the other ones available in a regular store , so no need to run around, I;ve made it with costco bread, as well as 5roses AP, both same protein content, I think living up north , flour is all high protein
I’m based in the UK but the bread flour I use is from Canadian wheat and I can confirm that Canadian flour is the best I’ve ever used.
I'm U.S. based but a lot of people seem to be using Robin Hood up in Canada.
My mother in law taught me to make bread when I was a newlywed. She made the best bread! She lived in northern Maine and would only use Robin Hood flour that she got in Canada in huge bags! I never understood why Canadian flour would be any different than ours but it was. Now I know why!
I've been doing the big dog at home since you posted the v1 recipe here. While making it over and over I eventually adapted the water/flour ratio to get a more consistent and manageable dough. Interestingly, I've been using a water quantity that is close to the one you mentioned in this v2 recipe. Therefore, it seems that we have found improvements as independent experimenters. Nice!
PS: my kids say that the bread is not singing but howling since it's the big dog. :D
So many YT cooking shows are like "Watch me make a thing", Bri is like "here's how you make this thing" and that's not just more useful but also demonstrates a higher level of skill.
what?
I don't remember the contents of the video that made me comment this.
@@Scerttle bro took back his comment
@@asat103lmao you're right
The original recipe was a game changer for me in the pandemic, to the point that I basically didn't buy bread for a year or two. I tweaked it over time and settled on this for the flours:
200g bread flour
100g wheat flour
100g dark rye flour
Absolutely killer sandwich bread
Nice. A darker variation. Love it
same hydration?
@@Mario-fn7po yes
Think I'm going to have to steal your recipe for this weeks bread lol. I've been thinking about adding wheat too my rye bread, and this is a good ratio.
@@BobTheBald2 Do it! It's so good. Nice density and flavor.
I am a long-time viewer. I've tried a number of your videos. I love how you carry the viewer along with the what's, why's , when's, and how's of what you are making. I didn't try the first bread, but guy your way to instruct to have a home cook feeling like a chef is amazing. My bread came out great! Thanks for your content
When I first got into bread/dough-making two years ago, yours was one of my main sources of instruction. I learnt how to do strength-building folds from this channel, and your videos gave me so much knowledge and confidence to figure things out as I went. I changed jobs last year and have a lot less time and attention to bake now, and the last few loaves I've experimented with came out quite disappointing, but once I saw this video, I knew I had to make it. This is the first dough in a long time that has felt perfect and right, and it was such a joy to work with them. The loaves are in the oven now, and I'm so excited to have them for dinner tomorrow. Thank you for reminding me how much I love this, Bri!
I absolutely LOVE this style video. The mix of your normal voice over and the conversational style while you cooked, was very engaging. Plus I learned a ton by hearing the why behind your various changes.
Hey Bri, one of the things I think worth addressing in this video is about the temperature in your house when you start proofing the dough. I remember reading a comment thread on one of your videos about how your kitchen appears to be warmer than most and some people found WAY better results when they let their doughs rest for longer than the video specified. Moreover, I think it would also help to mention how Altitude plays a role in breadmaking and how different pressures cause dough to act differently during baking. Regardless, I absolutely love this video and I can't wait to try this since I finally got an oven at my new place.
My kitchen here in the UK changes temp wildly both month to month and even hour to hour, so this is all stuff I'd love to see more info about. Great shout.
I have a much colder house than normal (Avg 15degC last few weeks) what i do is simply pre-heat water in the microwave and also pre-warm the oven to a very low temp (no more than 50degC, but turn it off when the dough goes in) for proofing.
If I've just come home from work I'll also put the bowl on top of my car bonnet. Ha.
I've never bothered to look into altitude and pressure - defies the point of 'beginner' ? - but just looked it up and my house is at about 200m above sealevel and about 1023hPa. My bread still works out fantastic even though I haven't included these data into my recipe.
Baking at 23°C is standard, the most important thing is the T°c of the water which should be comprised between 16 and 20°C. The hotter your kitchen is the cooler the water must be. The wheat temperature is a minor factor in the equation.
interestingly "room-temperature" has a scientific standard, typically taken as 23C (74F).
When Bri says "proof at room temperature" i think "way warmer than my cold ass 15C (59F) house, and plan accordingly
@@thisswanwearssocks 15C house?? you must be Santa Claus:))))
I just want to say the revisiting and explaining the “whys” of all this is EXTREMELY HELPFUL!! I’d love any and all re-dives and deep-dives on bread strategies anytime
I am a v1 user, and I started routinely making my own bread since. I appreciate the updated format using this recipe/process. The Big Dog never disappoints.
I'm 37, and have been baking bread since I'm 20. This recipe gave me the best, the BEST results, using simple All-purpose flour from a Mexican supermarket. It was the star of last night friend's dinner. The crust, the texture, the flavor... Perfect, all around. The sounds when it was cooling on the rack. Magnificent. Thank you for your work!
Hey Brian! I’ve made your original several times without any issues using Canadian all purpose flours… it has a protein content of approximately 13% depending on the brand. Just an FYI for your Canadian viewers. As well, thanks again for your fantastic channel and recipes. You have definitely changed eating in my house.
Good catch! You saved me a return trip to the grocery store. Canadian all-purpose all the way.
I can’t believe how good this bread is! I watched this video many times, and finally made just the easy mode ciabatta with no steam. I could not wait more than a few minutes and the bread is still warm from the oven. It is definitely the best bread I’ve ever made. It may be the best bread I’ve ever eaten. Thank you Brian! I will be making this again.
I love the way this video was shot and narrated. It’s cool having some moments of “real time Bri,” not just scripted, which is also always very thorough. Long time viewer! Love the content
I'm a long time viewer as well and I really didn't like the new camera tricks. For me it felt like it was more unprofessional than usual.. I like the normal style!
I make version 1 regularly with strong bread flower. I mix and shape it the night before and let it rise over night in a banneton in the fridge. This way i can eat this amazing bread fresh for breakfast. The whole family loves is. Thanks Bri for this gamechanger!
I do the same. I love fermenting it overnight and baking in the morning:)
@@donatapluskota9875 That's an awesome idea. Thanks for giving this to me.
One thing you should add to your recipe, especially for the big one, is to let it cool completely or about an hour. I've sometimes felt rushed and would cut my bread 20 mins after baking and the center would still be slightly wet. Cutting early is a big mistake that beginners do especially cuz it smells so good!
Warm bread is good. Hot bread is not. Wait for it. It is worth the wait.
How long do you have to wait?? I'm hungry!
Omg one of the hardest things about making bread! You're so right, I think Brian takes it for granted but it's such an easy mistake
@mattlevault5140 I think if we want to get into the bread warm, usually better to make smaller loaves so some stays fresher.
I make that mistake every time.
Love to see that you’re experimenting with doing the narration live rather than as a recording after the fact. Keep it up big dog ❤ your recipes are the real deal
Thanks! I hope people like it.
@@BrianLagerstromi'm sorry Bri I didn't like it :( I felt like it was an uncut video
This was the first video that got me into baking bread two years ago. Love that you made a follow up!
The mark of a true professional is what you just did. Could be so easy to rest on years of experience and left it at that. Instead, taking the time to listen, readjust and still create awesome food is genuinely awesome.
Who else skipped right to the third option on their first try? 😂😂
I did.
I used his first video and didn't have a Dutch oven so I made option 1 like 20 times but when I got one for Christmas the next day I did that big boy
✋ ... and it was a disaster 😝
I did. Never made anything like bread before. I added rosemary, roasted garlic, and pepper jack cheese. Came out dope. Doing another tomorrow
The OG video 3rd loaf was the first bread I ever made!
I started with your version 1.0 and struggled with the AP flour issue. Settled on bread flour and it really started working for me. I normally do two batches of he big dog version as I can fit my two Dutch ovens in my oven. I always add a teaspoon of bakers malt which makes a huge difference in the crust.
I’ve used the same recipe to do cinnamon raisin bread (flatten dough and add a bunch of cinnamon and about 1 cup of raisins then form loaf) and an olive loaf (1 cup each of halved Kalamata olives & castelvetrano olives).
The former makes amazing French toast and the latter is perfect with artichoke dip.
Thank you so much, Brian!
I made the v2, "big dog" today. It didn't come out as large as I expected it to be, but not bad! I had put my poolish in the fridge after 24 hours and took it out the next day and let it warm up to room temp. Mabye a "fresh" poolish would've been better? Haven't tasted it yet (I really want to dive in, but it's too soon!). Smells great! Looks good, too! Thank you! Brian your instructions are great, very straightforward and to the point. You also exhibit a great sense of humor and humility. I really appreciate your content, and will be making more of your breads and other recipes! Thanks again! I think this is my 7th loaf of bread, ever! Fun!
One thing I like about your channel is that you are very informative. Most recipes tell you to follow a bunch of steps without explaining the importance of it, and how it changes the bread
I made this recipe (the third variation), and here are my notes:
1. I followed the directions exactly. All ingredients were weighed using a digital scale. I don't know if this is necessary, but it worked.
3. I let the pre-fermentation sit for a full day. It really didn't take off until about 6 hours in, so I'd say that 4 hours isn't long enough. Also, the longer it sits the more flavorful it becomes.
4. At each stage my loaf was shaggier and less aesthetically appealing that his. However, it still turned out fine.
5. I used a straight cast iron dutch oven (not enameled) and it turned out fine.
The resulting loaf was PHENOMENAL. Open and airy crumb with a thin and crisp crust. It has Restaurant quality flavor and smells fantastic.
The most magical moment was when I placed the loaf on the counter to cool and I could hear it crackle.
I make your V1 version of the big dog all the time. It was also my beginner loaf so I just had to learn to deal with the higher hydration - but that was all skill building! Luckily for me, I never noticed you said to use AP flour in the original recipe and so have used bread flour all along. So cool you re-made this video for people to try again.
One thing I do differently, I don't have time in the evenings to finish a loaf in one night, so I make the poolish night 1, the bulk on night 2 (put it in the fridge after 2 SBFs), then night 3 it comes out of the fridge, warms up to room temp, shape, prove bake. I actually think the second overnight for the bulk improves the flavour. Cheers!
I make your last recipe regularly (so thanks a lot, Bri), my flour mix is
250g wheat bread flour,
100g spelt flour (if i'm feeling fancy)
30g rye flour
20g wholemeal rye flour (so little cuz this stuff looks like ash)
Experimenting with different flours is actually so much fun, every each way you get something a bit different and you can find your fav.
Hey dude, I have one of the top comments on your original, I love it, and it came out perfect the first try. I've made it well over 300 times since then. While I've personally never made bread before that, you made it extremely easy to do so, without your instructions I'm sure I would have had a hard time; that being said, I've since sent that same recipe to 9 people, not one of them has been able to make it, claiming "too stick/hard to work with" as the problem. This will definitely help them out a lot, and I'll share with them this updated one. I will also try it tomorrow with Bread Flower, but I'm sure it will end up perfect just like the AP version. Thank you for making a baker out of me Brian. Much love.
Just made this today. Went with option 2. First proper loaf of bread I've ever made and it turned out amazing!
I'm struggling to understand if the bake time is 22 minutes after removing the lid or 10 minutes. The lid on bake time is 12 minutes and then when taking out of the oven he said "after 22 minutes...." Maybe I'm understanding it too literally.
Kudos to you for admitting to when you got something wrong/overlooked something because of your level of experience being WAY higher to everyone else
Tried version 1 last week and it was OK, then I found version 2 and a proof setting on my oven and it came out perfect. Thank you!
Brian, your bread recipe was the first bread I ever attempted. I absolutely butchered it, but it was bread that got me through some serious food insecurity last year. Since then your rustic bread has become my go-to bread which my family absolutely loves. I'm deeply grateful for that video and absolutely stoked for the improved recipe!
you are so important for many homecooks and homebakers, cheers to you and your content!
You are a wonderful person and an excellent baker. I have baked loaves and cooked meals I never thought were within my skill level thanks to you Brian
Hey Bri, I made your bread this morning. It was my first ever bread baking endeavor. I went for the Big Dog and it is delicious. Thanks for sharing your experience and expertise.
I often tried to make a decent bread at home, but this recipe was the first that worked for me!
I love the change to your videos... a mix of you talking in person and voice-over! Nice one Brian. A minor change but it totally changes the feel of the video. Love your work.
Oh it’s cool that you noticed. I’m experimenting with bringing in a bit more of a live feel to keep things interesting. Thanks for watching
@@BrianLagerstrom Yep the hand-held camera shots focusing on what you are doing also add an extra level over static head-on shots. Makes it flow much smoother than a what can feel like a selection of cuts stitched together. A great balance of information without either getting too complicated or being patronising.
Awesome, Brian. I baked my first loaves from your first video, which was a perfect starting place. From there I went to fully fledged sourdough. Now I've come back to a poolish style loaf that gives me the optimum bread to effort ratio. Thanks for your great videos.
I definitely used your video to get started baking bread. Overall I had only a couple issues - all you addressed in this video. Thanks for taking the time to make an update!
Great to hear!great to hear. Really curious to hear what you think of the updated formula.
Thanks
My wife and I have my parents over every Friday and we serve one of your recipes. Thanks for all the great meals! A recipe request: salisbury steak.
That is so beautiful! More families should have this traditional weekly family gathering, but it has been lost in our busy, scattered culture. You and your wife are gems!
I made this "good" loaf as my first go at hand mixing and kneading bread (I've used my stand mixer for every other recipe I've done). It turned out INCREDIBLE, so I took a picture, sent it to my mom. My mom has never made bread without a bread machine, and she made a "good" loaf with success,first try!
Love the new format! Camera movement and live audio!! Killin it, Bri!
Recipe is dope as usual! Thanks B-Man!
Hi Brian,
Thanks for the update and for confirming my suspicions about the flour. I've tried version 1 several times, and when I used plain flour it really didn't work. Also in version 1 you suggest decreasing the water because 78% can be too much for us mere mortals in bread making, so I reduced from 280g to 250g of water, exactly the amount in version 2. When it worked I used Italian flour Caputo Cuoco with 12% protein.
Today I made version 2 with Caputo Manitoba Oro, which has 14%. I took the liberty of modifying it a bit, I used 100g of water + 150g of beer and I also added 90g of Parmesan cheese. It turned out sooo good! Tomorrow I'll make it with wine. Each time I used the Dutch oven version. I bought an iron pan that has a smooth lid on top so I can use it upside down, so it's easy to put the dough in and out. I believe that with a flour as strong as Manitoba Oro maybe I can increase the hydration a little, what do you say?
Congratulations for the channel and thank you very much !
Greetings from Brazil
I've made V1 quite a bit but cut the water back to 302 grams to make the Big Dog. It turns out quite well.
Just made V2 last night but made the poolish a day ahead. It's interesting that you ditched the oil and the sugar and I think the bread is better for it. This was a very tasty bread and certainly much easier to work than V1.
My only disappointment was the Big Dog didn't rise as much as I had hoped. It turns out that yeast that is almost a year past its expiration date is a bit stunted! I can't wait to try again with fresh yeast.
When I was doing the no-knead bread, I used to drop the dough ball into the dutch oven (like in this video) and almost always deformed the bread by hitting the side or getting it uneven (plus, it's just a little too easy to graze that blistering hot pan with a finger). These days, I drop the dough from the banneton onto a square of parchment paper. After scoring, I grab the edges of the parchment paper and lower the loaf into the hot pan. My loaves are now beautiful and I no longer burn my hands.
Don't think there was oil and sugar in V1
I'm having the same issue with my dough deflating on the move from banneton to dutch oven. Am I overproofing? I'll try the parchment paper today and see if that helps.
Thanks!
I've made V1 countless times in an ongoing endeavor to get the AP to behave as yours did in that video. My bread making confidence waned. I was on the verge of losing all hope and turning in my apron and dutch oven. Alone on the baking cart, its label turned away in sorrow, sat my bread flour. The container untouched for weeks. Shame lay heavy in my once joyful kitchen. The dishwasher wept. No longer did the Kitchenaid trust me to take it for a spin. Even the Instant Pot chimed in, red letters passing by like a Times Square billboard message, "Dear God, please, don't let her touch me!" The Vitamix cord wrapping round it in a comforting embrace. Could it be that the skills I'd gained, no matter how small, were disappearing? A dark vision crept into my mind. James, paring knife in hand, slit open a vanilla bean. Carefully scraping its insides, he said, "Let's get rid of the seeds...," flicking them into the sink. O M GOSH!! I've become Anti Baker!! In that very moment, a familiar voice broke in, " ... the recipe wasn't perfect. " 😮 What? Bread flour? Bread flour! I ran at once to the tear-stained container. "He was wrong!" Today, I stand aproned, mixing bowl in hand, slapping and folding, proud once again. Order up! Let's eat this thing!
I started with version 1, and it always came out ridiculously wet. It still made good bread, but never had a good rise because I couldn't reliably work with it.
So I tried bread flour, a bit more wheat flour, and suddenly my bread was perfect. Glad to see an updated video addressing the hydration. One of the best channels for baked good and recipes in general.
BMAN! So glad to see a redux of my go-to recipe for 2+ years straight. While my technique has improved over time (thanks SBFs), these new ratios with bread flour will probs be the game changers to take it over the top. I can’t wait to report back, but I can already tell that this recipe is BOULIN’
Since I used this recipe and loved it, I wanted to give my own little tip. I didn't want to damage my Dutch oven, so instead I baked the 3rd loaf style on a baking sheet. And for the steam I instead used a spray bottle full of water and sprayed the inside of the oven 5-6 times as soon as I put the breat in. The crust came out fantastic!
Version 1 has been my weekly bread recipe for a couple of years now, and over that time I have moved to adding 450g of flour instead of 400, as well as using 50g of whole wheat, 300 of bread, and 100 of AP flour. Sounds like you made similar changes, I’ll try this one and compare!
Thanks for this, Brian! My kitchen has never smelled better.
I am a new bread maker, at age 55, and I came to bread making with ZERO cooking / baking experience. It was just something to do because I miss my mom. She made really good bread.
My first attempt at bread was the “easiest” video (not yours.) I think you were sort of calling this video out when you said your recipe was the easiest bread “that is actually good.”
I will say the other guy’s easiest bread was actually very good and I might have stopped right there. I made it a few times, and then went looking for something more adventurous, which is how I found your video. Went straight for the Big Dog.
Wow. OK… It is objectively better. Whether it’s the poolish or the Dutch oven method or the good bread flour or all three is academic.
I added a smidge of water. Two ounces maybe. Probably not necessary. It felt dry to me. I used to knead bread, 45 years ago, so not an expert opinion by any means. No arguing with results!
I have made various things of wood and metals. When I saw a video of someone folding up dough, I was reminded of pattern welded steel, and I realized I could do that. I’m so glad I did.
Thank you so much for explaining it clearly and showing exactly what to do. If I can follow your instructions and make this bread, anybody can.
Ahhh so excited! These are literally the two issues I've had:
1) Too wet dough
2) slacky even after folding
I thought I was doing something wrong and it was demotivating, but my loaves were still so delicious so I persevered the past year.
I cannot WAIT to try with your updated recipe and see how good the loaves will be. Thank you so much for being a great resource and doing this update video! If only I saw it 10 hours ago, as I started a loaf today and literally saw this video after I finished shaping and started preheating my oven haha!
my dough is also much more sticky... first loaf going in the oven soon hope it turns out
I think I have probably made version 1 over 20 times at this point. It made me fall in love with baking. Thanks for continuing to make bread accessible to home cooks!
I've been struggling to make a good 'sour-faux' bread for ages, both with discard recipes and poolish, but honestly this is a game changer. I made the Big Dog yesterday, and it turned out just perfect. Many thanks for the super-clear instructions!
Fun fact: the all-purpose flour in Canada has the same protein content as bread flour in the US.
Fun fact: no
wait what? Crazy.
So how much more does bread flour in canada have? I've been making most of Brian's recipes using bread flour in canada
Depends on the brand.
@@blipzimmerman1792 Rogers AP is 12-13%, bread is 13-14%, Rye is 10-12%
I like to use King Arthur which is 11.7%. It splits the difference and I use it for everything without too much trouble.
I found working the dough more solves the wetness problem he was talking about.
I've never been much of a baker. Growing up I always loved my grandmother's homemade bread. Finally, I'm stepping up into the adventure of exploring how to make my own bread. I've checked out these "artisan" type loaves shown on TH-cam, that brag ease of preparation and no kneading. But, there are A TON of little details that are always missing, and the kinds of details lacking are actually pretty consistent. This video was great because you're actually testing/trying/proofing each new attempt and making significant changes that create a different product. This made for a great learning experience because it cuts down on how many times I need to fail by practicing or trying new things in the WRONG way. One of the big, any maybe most valuable thing I learned from this post was how punishing high heat baking is on ceramic coated cast iron. I would have NEVER known that and would likely have destroyed mine in the process. So, black Friday sales, I'm putting one of those Lodge Dutch ovens on my shopping list! Thanks so much for this. Oh, and the instruction on the Poolish was a bonus I could not have anticipated...THANK YOU!!
I love your sandwich bread recipe. Comes out perfect every time.
I agree. It is the version I go back to over and over.
Big thanks for 1.0 and now 2.0!
Version 1.0 kicked off a year of baking for me and yes I did struggle with the initial recipe but with the assistance of some of the comments I altered it and finally succeeded making a Big Dawg, pure bliss!
Now roughly a year later this pops up in my feed, crazy. Will have to give this recipe a shot and see the difference. Thanks!
Just pulled this “Big Dawg” out of the oven and it is singing! BTW, for everyone who is wondering, I used parchment paper because I always do and I baked it in a Challenger bread pan because I have it. I followed the recipe as written without any problems with stretch and folds and shaping!
I'm glad to hear your boule baked fine using the parchment. I will next time!
The original recipe was the reason I subscribed to this channel!! Can’t wait to try the update! Great work Bri!!
My few attempts following your original video resulted in more puddles than loaves--glad to know it wasn't just me messing up enormously somehow 😅
After watching the video many times, I've perfected a delicious loaf using the recipe. It's now a regular part of my meals. I follow the recipe exactly, using whole wheat flour, and the bread turns out wonderfully. I've been making Mark Bittman’s New York Times bread for years, but this new recipe is even better. I also enjoy the educational and entertaining style of Brian, and I find my Taormina Covered Dutch Oven works well for this recipe. I've even asked for a Lodge cast-iron Dutch oven for Christmas, as I am a fan of simple cookware and using high-quality ingredients from places like Whole Foods, Fresh markets, and local food stores. I am still practicing proper scoring on the top of the loaves for the perfect appearance, but the texture, flavor, and overall look of the bread are already perfect. My guests have only had positive things to say about it, and I am very grateful for this amazing 2.0 version of the recipe. Thank you, Brian!
I am doing this today. I was thinking of making 2 loaves of bread using the third method, since I don't have a Dutch oven big enough to get the whole dough in there. Here in Finland, ap flour usually has 12.5-13g proteinin per 100g. I use flour where is exactly 13g.
Edit. The breads turned out excellent. Maybe next time I'll use a little less flour when I'm not making bread for the first time. I always start making bread with this recipe for myself and my family. Really good recipe, I recommend it. Thanks for this Brian!
As a bread guy thats been making bread since i was 5yrs old. This channel is on point! Keep up the great work Brian!
Version 1.0 has been part of my Saturday morning ritual for months now (I was a little late to the party lol). I’ll be trying out these ratios for sure this weekend. Got some good ideas for further experimenting in the comments too!
I’ve made this recipe several times and I love it. So happy to hear you clarify about the protein content of the flour you used in the first video. I’ve had such success with bread flour and the one time I tried this with APF it was a mess.
Thanks man. You rock!
One important thing about loafs #2 and #3 that you don't mention in either video is the pizza steel you've got under the dutch oven. The first couple times I tried to make either they turned out almost perfect, but the bottom was burned straight black and took some of the fun out of eating it. I wondered for a while why I was getting that when you weren't, until I noticed you were putting the dutch oven onto a pizza steel. I then did the same and, voila, a perfectly browned bottom! Because of the longer cook time, particularly on loaf #3, you really need that steel or stone to guard against direct heat from the oven element to prevent burning.
Love the videos, this channel got me into baking!
I’ve made this 4 times and have been trying to solve the burning bottom problem! Thank you!
I don’t have this issue.
I did option 3 on my first try and it turned out PERFECT. I'm now making a double batch because my neighbor saw my pic on FB and I offered to make them a loaf. Thank you for the amazing recipe.
I’m bready
Great update to the original video, Brian!
I was one of those that had the problem with the dough being too wet to efficiently work with. So I had catered the recipe with a little bit less water/using bread flour and have been making the third version of this recipe for the better part of a year. Glad to see the updated version.
That's so nuts, I literally made the bread from the last recipe a couple of days ago. It tasted good but didn't rise during the prove for some reason :/
Cold dough I’m sure. Use warmer water and keep it in a warm spot. Sub 72f and things slow dramatically
@@BrianLagerstrom Hey Brian, you are probably right about that. I let it rise overnight in the fridge before shaping and proving it in the basket, so probably didn't give it enough time to come back to room temperature when I did that.
v1 was my go-to bread recipe for a LONG time! I definitely ran into the issues mentioned, but it stood the test of time. I can't wait to try v2!!
I dont get how he plops the risen bread into the dutch oven without it degassing 🤷♂️
Proper shaping and not over proofing.
Came here looking for this question. Thanks!
I have now made this bread two days in a row. Both were 24° poolish preferment, one in the Dutch oven, and one in the cast iron you showed. And I did the "best" version. I cannot believe how good this bread is. For some reason it takes me back to when I lived in England as a child, and one of the breads there. So disappointed when we came to the states, where we stayed! So this is so welcome! Thank you!
Why does it look like he stole Joshua weissmans old kitchen 😭😭
Thanks!
I made version 1.0 many times. I think I combined a few recipes, but now have basically my own amalgam recipe. Thank you for helping get into making my own bread.
I've made the first version according to the recipe several times in the past to mixed results. Eventually I started to just experiment with my own recipe for the dough. I ditch the whole wheat flour and just use all purpose. I do the poolish the previous night by volume with a cup measure of flour, shaken to level, and the same cup measure filled with water. A pinch of yeast and just leave that overnight. Other than that, its blooming the yeast in warm water and a tablespoon of sugar in the stand mixer then add poolish, swish it around to mix, then add four cups of flour, a tablespoon of salt, another tablespoon of sugar, set it to mix for ten minutes. Then I come in with four tablespoons of softened butter, one at a time until they're all incorporated. I take the bowl out of the mixer, put on gloves and do the stretch and fold method to bring it together, flip it seam side down and leave it to rise for an hour. Halfway through that rise, I get the oven preheating with the dutch oven inside. When the time comes, into the dutch oven goes cornmeal, then I transfer the dough into the oven, score the top and bake it following your times. When it comes out, it smells amazing, tastes amazing and has just the nicest crunchy crust. I've no idea if anything I did made any difference, but its a pretty common bread for me to make now.
This really is the best cooking channel. I love the way you wove the instructional interludes into the voiceover work. I hope you stick with that in future vids!
I just wanted to say that this tutorial was the most informative recipe, good fun and egoless.
I can come back to this video whenever I teach somebody to make great bread.
Many thanks!
I made the big boule today (my first ever) after mastering your baguette recipe. On a whim, I used the baguette dough recipe (up until the split into two) and got a pretty good loaf. I’ll try the longer autolysis next time, but it’s hard to imagine it could have a better result. Thanks for teaching me to make real bread!
Brian this is simply the best loaf of bread I’ve ever made. I make it Friday night with sourdough starter, let it rest overnight in the fridge and present it warm on Saturday for brunch. It’s a wonderful loaf of bread and I’m winning all sorts of brownie points at home so thank you!!
really appreciate directly talking to the camera in real time and the hand held shot - really adds to the instruction.
Thanks for the feedback
I made the biggest one , and I’m in Florida we constantly have the ac pumping here . I let the polish go for 2 days and the dough for double proofing time , and the bread came out amazing . Great video and recipe .
I’ve made both versions, thank you for the new and improved 2.0. I baked the big dog Boule yesterday and added 6 ounces of 1/4” diced sharp cheddar and 90 grams of rough chopped pickled Jalapeños. It came out amazing. I added the cheese and Jalapeños in during the second fold.
Thank you for the great recipes and easy to follow instructions.
I also do this at times. My original attempts used shredded cheese and it just disappears, so I moved to the cubes. Much better results. I also put a 1/4 cup or so of cheese on top of the bread with sliced rings of jalapeno.
On my 4th time making this bread and it’s only gotten better. Thanks for being so thorough in this video Brian! First and only bread recipe I use and I swear by it now. Cheers👍🏼
Hey man, I'm so excited.
Ive been doing this recipe for about 6times the last three months. Im so happy you made a new one to fix these issues. I can't wait to try it.
Best of luck with it
@@BrianLagerstrom thank you😊, I'll inform you on my process
Your hard work and effort shows and is appreciated. Thank you
I've made this bread loads of times over the last few years. I've always done the loaf 3 method. It works great but the one thing I'd change is the cooking time. I'm not sure if I've just got a stronger oven but I usually cook mine for 18 min covered and then maybe another 10-13 minutes uncovered. Anymore than that and the bottom will get completely burned. But aside from that love the recipe and thank you for an improved recipe update.
I have no experience making bread, but I happen to have all the equipment this recipe calls for. I made loaf 3 of version 2.0 and I'm really impressed with how light, spongy and delicious it came out! .. and so easy to make. I used ap flour (from New Zealand) which I suspect is high enough quality because the ratios were great. I also sieved wheat bran from wheat flour instead of using cornmeal to protect loaf from surface of dutch oven. Thanks Brian, this will be my weekly go-to recipe :)
Yes! I have made that big dog loaf so many times! It is one of my favorite things to cook, and all my friends and family love it. Can't wait to make one with these new techniques. I could never get it to rise quite as big as yours so I'm guessing I'll have even better results now.
I’ve worked up from your first recipe. My enhancements included adding a higher amount of Whole Wheat flour, 5 grams of yeast in the poolish and then no more. The Diastatic Malt powder is key and I add about 15 grams vs 10 you previously spec’d. I think allowing more time to rise, then fold and stretch/strengthen makes a huge difference and given the time already being committed, an extra hour or two of rising and folding is more than worth it. Preheating the oven to 550 for 30+ minutes and then lowering it to 485 is the best for baguettes and 465 for cast iron pot version allows for more pot and less bake time required. My thoughts. Personally I think you’re and incredible talent and I love your videos and recipes. All the best!