my father, Aryak Sangye and Gyarong Tenzin are old friends and I knew him, as well in India when, I was a young boy then. His personal story is true and powerful, as a second-generation exile, we are grateful and proud of first-generation exiles, who sacrificed so much for Tibet. I feel the translater did a great job in translation, given that we have many dialects in Tibet, spoken language is different provinces is different from each province. I am thankful to Tibet Oral History Organisation for preserving Tibetan History and culture.
Sincerely respect to those like Garong Tenzin who sacrifice their life for Tibet and protect HH Dalia lama will remain for ever in the history of Tibet .Story is extremely sad, but remains the spirit of Tibet very strong .
I appreciate to this program interviewers and all related ones. There is one catch that the translator did not understand some words, eg. When the father came to know that he was being put into life imprisonment, he said "oh, I did not know, if I knew this, there were things to do", not "better to die". this she misunderstood. anyway thank you very much.
Yes, unfortunately, sometimes our interpreters were not able to translate everything accurately. But the purpose of the interpreter was to provide a brief, summary interpretation in order to allow the interview to proceed; it was not his/her job to do a precise, full translation between English and Tibetan. We have added a note to all our videos explaining that the written transcripts are the most accurate English translation for the interviews because these are based word-for-word on the statements of the interviewee and not the interpreter.
I cried n felt deeply said when I listen m watched this brave man story but translator she was trying translate Best But she don’t understand what the old man was saying his life story
Tibet Oral History Project with good intention but interpretation are mostly incompetent. This one is one of the better ones but still some mistakes and not very good at tranlating the essence of the talk
The interviewer did try to be fair and revealed a lot of inadvertent facts about Tibet. This is the story of a middle CASTE farmer who owned land and property. As a class they did suffer some losses. The poor people (serfs and slaves) were inculcated from birth their previous life was evil so they must suffer and endure this life so their next reincarnation would be much improved. They were the ones the CCP tried to rescue from the oppressive feudal caste system. The upper caste Lamas, and aristocrats were the one who fought and failed and escaped to India with the help of loyal faithfuls. The overall picture of Tibet was no portrait of Shangri La.
![ร้อยพ่อพันแม่ - WanMai [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XY2pNYASEbg/mqdefault.jpg)
my father, Aryak Sangye and Gyarong Tenzin are old friends and I knew him, as well in India when, I was a young boy then. His personal story is true and powerful, as a second-generation exile, we are grateful and proud of first-generation exiles, who sacrificed so much for Tibet. I feel the translater did a great job in translation, given that we have many dialects in Tibet, spoken language is different provinces is different from each province. I am thankful to Tibet Oral History Organisation for preserving Tibetan History and culture.
Best translater of the world she is very nice translater 🎉
Sincerely respect to those like Garong Tenzin who sacrifice their life for Tibet and protect HH Dalia lama will remain for ever in the history of Tibet .Story is extremely sad, but remains the spirit of Tibet very strong .
I really appreciate everyone working hard for this wonderful project but I realized some main points is not translating. Might be missing I guess
I appreciate to this program interviewers and all related ones. There is one catch that the translator did not understand some words, eg. When the father came to know that he was being put into life imprisonment, he said "oh, I did not know, if I knew this, there were things to do", not "better to die". this she misunderstood. anyway thank you very much.
Yes, unfortunately, sometimes our interpreters were not able to translate everything accurately. But the purpose of the interpreter was to provide a brief, summary interpretation in order to allow the interview to proceed; it was not his/her job to do a precise, full translation between English and Tibetan. We have added a note to all our videos explaining that the written transcripts are the most accurate English translation for the interviews because these are based word-for-word on the statements of the interviewee and not the interpreter.
Jampel Tsultrim l
I cried n felt deeply said when I listen m watched this brave man story but translator she was trying translate Best But she don’t understand what the old man was saying his life story
He said Che-doe-shoe but translator saying Kyi Khoi, Doher and it’s completely different
So Sad his story 🙏🙏🙏
Gyalrong was only considered tibetan by Chinese government
Many talked were not translate properly because the translator born in exile n has less knowledge of about Tibet
Tibet Oral History Project with good intention but interpretation are mostly incompetent. This one is one of the better ones but still some mistakes and not very good at tranlating the essence of the talk
I would rather put subtitle instead of crappy translation made of robotic voice without any feelings and emotions in words.
སྐད་སྒྱུར་གྱི་གསལ་པོ་ཤེས་ཀྱི་མི་འདུག
The translator needs to understand Chinese
The interviewer did try to be fair and revealed a lot of inadvertent facts about Tibet. This is the story of a middle CASTE farmer who owned land and property. As a class they did suffer some losses. The poor people (serfs and slaves) were inculcated from birth their previous life was evil so they must suffer and endure this life so their next reincarnation would be much improved. They were the ones the CCP tried to rescue from the oppressive feudal caste system. The upper caste Lamas, and aristocrats were the one who fought and failed and escaped to India with the help of loyal faithfuls. The overall picture of Tibet was no portrait of Shangri La.
It was not caste system but class system.
say story but little lies