@@brandong298I mean most singers and voice coaches have Beyoncés rendition in their top 3 along with Whitney and Mariah so…but Mariah and Beyoncé are my top 2. Jennifer Hudson 3rd. Jazmine Sullivan 4th
I like this description from the Internet: Whitney Houston's rendition was full of courage & bravery; Mariah Carey's one was sorrow with the strength of recovery from such a tragedy. Their historical backgrounds are different.
@@daydream10.18 I know I was just continuing our banter lol. I obviously prefer Whitney and Mariah. I love how powerful Whitney’s is and how unique and pretty Mariah’s is. Along with Stephanie Mills those are my two favorite singers. Add Bruno Mars as an honorable mention lol.
This is my personal favorite rendition. It’s so musical. No theatrics until the end. Her voice is almost sad yet hopefully at the beginning. She shows incredible restraint. It’s almost fancy in delivery.
@@haute2deathMinnie Riperton was great but she didn’t have much power to her voice. She had a very sweet romantic light voice with an incredible range. Beyond whistle notes, there aren’t that many similarities between her and Minnie.
@@haute2deathYou say that as if being inspired by other singers and then turning that into greatness is a bad thing… also Mariah didn’t “copy” Minnie. Their whistles have their own unique textures and tones. There’s a fine line between being inspired by someone and outright copying. Otherwise, would you say the same about Whitney with two of her influences: Aretha and Dionne? Absolutely not, that would be ridiculous. There are many similarities because she learned from them, but she didn’t copy and even came to surpass them. The same goes with Mariah getting inspiration from Minnie, finding her own sound and artistry, and then surpassing her in creative usage of whistle notes. Also, Minnie didn’t invent whistle notes. She was just an original user of that register in pop music. But it’s not like Mariah’s only vocal strength is her whistles. That’s just a small extra nice thing she has in addition to the rest of her incredible voice.
Mariah was carefully chosen because they needed somebody to inspire patriotism, this was one of the first big events with a lot of people in one spot after 9/11 she was meant to comfort and at the same time make american people feel safe in their own country and she nailed it. Its powerful, regal, very elegant and nobody will be able to deliver it this way is not just the whistle,, her tone is just simply beautiful.
Mariah is not only incredible to listen to, she comes with a unique interpretation that cannot be reproduced by other artists, and when we analyze what was done in a score, we get the real dimension of how colossal her performances are. .
Whitney and Mariah killed it. I have seen so many great artists have done amazing jobs on this song and i love them all. But the ways Whitney and Mariah sang were obviously stood out. I love this two artists a lot. ❤😢
Mariah is the Only Artist I know that can literally change one song to better, she is the most sang the most different and beautiful style of this anthem. She is a LEGEND
Mariah Carey The Star Spanggled banner is the best for me ... inly Mariah Can do that rendition .. with her signature, well that is a whistle .. she cam sing using her whusstle goshhh...
PLEASE DO MARIAH CAREYS SONG FROM HER LATEST ALBUM “GIVING ME LIFE FT SLICK RICK AND BLOOD ORANGE” YOU HAVE TO SEE WHAT CURRENT MARIAH IS DOING!!!!!!!!!!🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Just because Mariah can't sing that way anymore, they've lost trust and confidence already towards Mariah. Well this Performance is a reminder how Great and One-of-a-kind Mariah is,,, she'a a gem of Music, she's like a shooting star that only comes once in a lifetime. Whitney was Great indeed, but Mariah is on a different league of her own.
PLEASE react to My All in Italy live (Pavarotti and friends concert) I promise you you’ll be impressed! 🔥 oh and Hi from the UK 🇬🇧 👋🏼 I love your channel!!
It’s a shame Mariah and Whitney became famous late to early 90s when the labels just smashed out song after song , no rest and absolutely ruined the gifts they had. Look Mariah still has a great voice, but to have 15 number ones from 1990 to 99 clearly shows the label gave her zero rest. Same with Whitney, maybe not at the level Mariah got due to drugs. But they definitely didn’t help. You don’t see Beyoncé etc having that problem these days. 90s where bad for that
Mariah pushed HERSELF she has said this a billion times other than promo bs before her breakdown. Has nothing to do with her writing number one hits they pour out of her
@@paulp4342 they pushed her during the Glitter era everything before that was mostly her. As shitty of a husband Tommy was he didn’t push her to tour like other artists and she didn’t burn herself out physically and mentally until she left and stopped taking her bipolar meds along with all the partying. Try and keep up.
This True but beyoncé did playback on her tour, and im not the one who say it there are many people thats notice, and thats why she continues with her voice
![BOWKYLION - วิงวอน (ex-change) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cLdnZWDaO-w/mqdefault.jpg)
Whitney sang it like UNITED STATES is in the battle while Mariah sang it like UNITED STATES won the battle already
Notice how United States always get involved with wars
right. the palace now has a queen
Mariah's performance was after 9/11, that's why it's a more solemn version
She does those runs really, really fast. Her sense of pitch and melody is unparalleled.
Her rendition was so cinematic
Only Whitney and Mariah's version got me chills, omg.
Only Mariah & Whitney did the best renditions!❤
@@hughw2377 Faith Hill is a close third.
@brandong298 yeah Faith definitely an honourable mention!
Beyoncé says hello
@@YhuGoghBoy Tell her to go find Adele.
@@brandong298I mean most singers and voice coaches have Beyoncés rendition in their top 3 along with Whitney and Mariah so…but Mariah and Beyoncé are my top 2. Jennifer Hudson 3rd. Jazmine Sullivan 4th
I like this description from the Internet:
Whitney Houston's rendition was full of courage & bravery;
Mariah Carey's one was sorrow with the strength of recovery from such a tragedy.
Their historical backgrounds are different.
Whitney and Mariah are my two favorite singers but neither was as entertaining as Fergie.
@@brandong298 LMAO 💀
@@daydream10.18 Who needs those perfect on pitch notes? So boring.
@@brandong298 I didn't say I disagreed. I just thought it was funny.
@@daydream10.18 I know I was just continuing our banter lol. I obviously prefer Whitney and Mariah. I love how powerful Whitney’s is and how unique and pretty Mariah’s is. Along with Stephanie Mills those are my two favorite singers. Add Bruno Mars as an honorable mention lol.
This is my personal favorite rendition. It’s so musical. No theatrics until the end. Her voice is almost sad yet hopefully at the beginning. She shows incredible restraint. It’s almost fancy in delivery.
the resonance on the word "GLARE" then "AIR" unworldly, breathtaking, ethereal, supernatural
I adore Whitney but Mariah sang this anthem and took it to another level. Her voice. Damn. Shes not the songbird supreme for nothing! Queen!
Whitney was the best to ever do it... The Voice! Have you ever heard of Minnie Rippleton?
@@haute2deathMariah did her own thing
@@haute2deathMinnie Riperton was great but she didn’t have much power to her voice. She had a very sweet romantic light voice with an incredible range. Beyond whistle notes, there aren’t that many similarities between her and Minnie.
@@superninja6481 B4 Mariah was a Minnie Rippleton. Where do you think her high pitch was copied from?
@@haute2deathYou say that as if being inspired by other singers and then turning that into greatness is a bad thing… also Mariah didn’t “copy” Minnie. Their whistles have their own unique textures and tones. There’s a fine line between being inspired by someone and outright copying.
Otherwise, would you say the same about Whitney with two of her influences: Aretha and Dionne? Absolutely not, that would be ridiculous. There are many similarities because she learned from them, but she didn’t copy and even came to surpass them. The same goes with Mariah getting inspiration from Minnie, finding her own sound and artistry, and then surpassing her in creative usage of whistle notes.
Also, Minnie didn’t invent whistle notes. She was just an original user of that register in pop music. But it’s not like Mariah’s only vocal strength is her whistles. That’s just a small extra nice thing she has in addition to the rest of her incredible voice.
Please react her Stevie Wonder’s You and I cover. Her lower tones are incredible!
yessss
Yesss I come back to her rendition of this song over and over bc her low notes were just impeccable.. chef’s kiss
Great lows... but 🥱
Yessss
Omg! Mariah Carey: "Often imitated, never duplicated."
Mariah was carefully chosen because they needed somebody to inspire patriotism, this was one of the first big events with a lot of people in one spot after 9/11 she was meant to comfort and at the same time make american people feel safe in their own country and she nailed it. Its powerful, regal, very elegant and nobody will be able to deliver it this way is not just the whistle,, her tone is just simply beautiful.
That's the comment im looking for cazse ,you r right
Great reaction. You can’t deny this rendition it’s just magical. And to think this was during her “worst year” when she had a breakdown.
Mariah Carey -absolutely PHENOMENAL! Unparalleled musicality! Her voice takes you to another universe!
Mariah Carey's rendition of Star Spangled Banner was the most spectacular in my opinion. 💯💯💯🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭♥️♥️♥️🎶🎶🎶
indeed pure of emotions and passionate❤️
And let's not forget that people copied her ending. Nobody was ending it like that until her.
Totally agree with you
Loved this reaction. She slayed the national anthem. This the first Super Bowl following 9/11
I feel like Mariah can sing 'ABCD" like this and we would still feel that! ❤🦋
Mariah is not only incredible to listen to, she comes with a unique interpretation that cannot be reproduced by other artists, and when we analyze what was done in a score, we get the real dimension of how colossal her performances are. .
The 🎙 Songbird 🎵 Supreme 🦋
Whitney and Mariah killed it. I have seen so many great artists have done amazing jobs on this song and i love them all. But the ways Whitney and Mariah sang were obviously stood out. I love this two artists a lot. ❤😢
She’s extremely and rare talent I mean she can sing her face off
Mariah did what she had to do ! Flawless
Mariah is the Only Artist I know that can literally change one song to better, she is the most sang the most different and beautiful style of this anthem. She is a LEGEND
Mariah just blows me away🎉🦋🦋🦋❤❤
wowwwww she s amazing 😍
I’m Australian and I loved listening to Mariah - the Songbird Supreme sing your national anthem!
The Songbird Supreme 👑🔥 the Greatest vocalist ever!💯
Love Mariah...Girl you did it again.
She did it best in my opinion...
ONLY, Whitney and Mariah... the GOATS. PERIODT!
Mariah Carey is the only artist who give me chills & makes me emotional ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Mariah just sent us to heaven!
Mariah Carey is the best singer in the world..
Love from Israel 🇺🇸❤️🇮🇱
Mariah, Whitney, Gladys Knight and Marving Gaye ❤❤❤
Spectacular musicianship and vocal delivery OMG🔥
SHE IS THE GODDESS OF VOCALS
Whitney's version was before a war, Mariah's version is after.
Fergie was during the war.
@@brandong298 she's the reason for the war 😭😭😭
@@GeloMeme Damn she might be a terrorist.
@@GeloMeme ahhh😭🤣
USA is always at war……..
The crowd reaction to the whistle note ❤
The best version ❤
Lol u know u reaching, no one topped Whitney that why Whitney's is a top5 pop hit as well! But go awwfffff gurl!!!!
@@Bigdrip840lol
Cute
Whoever wrote not Fergie needs to go to JAIL!💀
Idc what people say I love fergies rendition 🤣
Mariah Carey The Star Spanggled banner is the best for me ... inly Mariah Can do that rendition .. with her signature, well that is a whistle .. she cam sing using her whusstle goshhh...
Oh guys I loved your reaction ❤ thanks for reacting to my queen ❤
Thank you guys for this!!!❤
❤ Mariah
Faith Hill’s is highly underrated as well
❤❤❤❤wowwwww Mariah ❤❤❤❤❤
That silky voice is what i love from her
1:41 saying Mariah Carey isn’t sexy especially at this time is just crazy… she was gorgeous!!
Sexy? Mariah is absolutely gorgeous
Great reaction…❤
I looooove ❤
I mean her Glitter era for me is her strongest vocals ever
#GabrielHenrique 🖐 I suggest for your reaction the talented Gabriel Henrique with the cover I HAVE NOTTING😊
Have you already watched Gabriel Henrique? He sings as well as she does.
Plllllllleeeeeeeeaaaase react to Mariah Carey live in tokyo 1996 - Just be good to me 🤯
Plz reac more Mariah live ❤❤❤❤❤
❤❤❤❤
If y’all haven’t already heard it . Listen to my favorite song … Mine Again
Please react on Mariah Carey’s live performance at the 48th Annual Grammy Awards.
REACTiON GABRiEL HENRiQUE MUSiC
PLEASE DO MARIAH CAREYS SONG FROM HER LATEST ALBUM “GIVING ME LIFE FT SLICK RICK AND BLOOD ORANGE” YOU HAVE TO SEE WHAT CURRENT MARIAH IS DOING!!!!!!!!!!🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Yall gotta watch beyonces Super Bowl 2004
Guys, please react to her live performance tribute for Stevie Wonder. It's called "You and I"
Whitney - before the battle
Mariah - after the battle
Chris Stapleton is up there too
Just because Mariah can't sing that way anymore, they've lost trust and confidence already towards Mariah. Well this Performance is a reminder how Great and One-of-a-kind Mariah is,,, she'a a gem of Music, she's like a shooting star that only comes once in a lifetime. Whitney was Great indeed, but Mariah is on a different league of her own.
PLEASE react to My All in Italy live (Pavarotti and friends concert) I promise you you’ll be impressed! 🔥 oh and Hi from the UK 🇬🇧 👋🏼 I love your channel!!
❤
Pls react to we belong together/ fly like a bird live at the grammys
React Mariah Carey and Michael Bolton we are not making love anymore
Only Whitney FIRST & MC are in the book of the 25 best moments of the game for this
And the music originated from England but I do believe a national anthem should be sung by everyone not just a individual
Hi could you check Sohyang's national anthem US National Anthem for NBA game(2014.03.01) too ?
This was after or before Whitney's performing?
React to jhuds version
It’s a shame Mariah and Whitney became famous late to early 90s when the labels just smashed out song after song , no rest and absolutely ruined the gifts they had. Look Mariah still has a great voice, but to have 15 number ones from 1990 to 99 clearly shows the label gave her zero rest. Same with Whitney, maybe not at the level Mariah got due to drugs. But they definitely didn’t help. You don’t see Beyoncé etc having that problem these days. 90s where bad for that
Mariah pushed HERSELF she has said this a billion times other than promo bs before her breakdown. Has nothing to do with her writing number one hits they pour out of her
@@strangerthings88 what you on about, doesn’t even make sense. She says they pushed her also
@@paulp4342 they pushed her during the Glitter era everything before that was mostly her. As shitty of a husband Tommy was he didn’t push her to tour like other artists and she didn’t burn herself out physically and mentally until she left and stopped taking her bipolar meds along with all the partying. Try and keep up.
This True but beyoncé did playback on her tour, and im not the one who say it there are many people thats notice, and thats why she continues with her voice
@@Shinespheres Mariah has severe nodules. People only attack her for using playback it’s really unfair.
She can and in fact, does play around with her voice, but Whitney had THE VOICE, hands down…
Why people bring Whitney, it seems they need to bring down other artists so they can shine too…MARIAH STILL THE GOAT
Please react #gabrielhenrique
Whitney owns this anthem. Good attempt though Mariah ❤
Try to react Morissette Amon from the Philippines she is combination of mariah,witney and celine
For me the greatest National anthems are
1.Whitney
2.Beyoncé
3.Mariah
Fell a sleep, for a sec-lol