CAN TIBET BE FREE? / LT GEN P R SHANKAR (R)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 เม.ย. 2024
- #GUNNERSSHOT #InternationalRelations #UPSC #CSE #StrategicAffairs #defence
CAN #TIBET BE FREE? / LT GEN P R SHANKAR (R)
GUNNERS SHOT IS A CHANNEL FOR DEFENCE & STRATEGIC AFFAIRS, TECHNOLOGY AND WELFARE OF ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL.
GUNNERS SHOT is a channel in which the best of Indian Military and Strategic experts express their views and opinions.
GUNNERS SHOT is a non partisan channel devoted to high quality.
Support Gunners Shot with your contribution through GPay to +91 9384855773
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT TH-cam CHANNEL@ / @gunnersshot9829
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT TECH CHANNEL @ / @gunnersshottech-jl6gp
Join the channel as a member @ / @gunnersshot9829
THIS VIDEO IS AVAILABLE IN PODCAST FORM @ / @gunnersshot9829
Gunners Shot TH-cam Channel has multiple .playlists to enhance your viewing experience.
All articles are available @ www.gunnersshot.com
Follow Gunners Shot WhatsApp Channel @ whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaEZ...
Twitter : @palepurshankar or @gunners_shot1
Join Telegram group @ t.me/gunnersshot
Disclaimer : Views expressed on this channel by this who appear on it are their personal opinions and can not be attributed to GUNNERS SHOT
We as Bharatiya should support Tibetian Independence. Not only have the Chinese occupied this holy land illegally but we have a moral duty to support our brother buddhists. Besides its a buffer against the aggressive behaviour of the Chinese towards us.
I am in full support of your ideas.
Jai Hind Vande Matram 🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
Incredible India 🇮🇳♥️
Thank you bro
Tibet ka Azadi Barat ka suraksha is our slogan since 50 yrs....its a true n truth sir....Love u Indian bro n sis.
Sir Watching your podcast from France, love your points! We Tibetans should take the first step towards our independence. Thank you sir! Jai Hind! Jai Tibet!
FreeTibet..విజయీభవ... JaisriRam
Jai Shri Ram. So true. Tibet's Independence is India's security. As India never share border with China in the past till 1949-1959. We Tibetans are thankful to you for bringing Tibet's issue and solving Tibet's issue has a KEY to solve India's border issue with China for forever.
Thank you Lt Gen Shankar for your well researched piece. There was no time any of the Chinese, Mongol or Manchu rulers have ever taken over Tibet. It was made impossible by the tyranny of distance and the mountains that no army could over come. However, the communists were victorious in the Chinese civil war and were confident to wage war on Tibet with military help from the USSR. Even so, they sought the forced consent of independent Tibet by coercing Tibet to sign the so called “17 point treaty” between the Government of Tibet and the PRC. They recognised Tibet as a seperate country from China by adding mischievously “returning to the mother land”!!!!!! It clearly showed Tibet was seperate from China and the draft was crafted by the CCP itself!!!!
The trickle of Tibetan refugee from occupied Tibet was curbed by the PRC by pumping millions of dollars to Nepal to train its police and installing police station on the Nepal side of the Tibet-Nepal border. Tibetans want to escape from occupied Tibet more than the waves of Chinese escaping PRC through Ecuador to Mexico and to the US. Tibetans can’t escape because of severe restriction by the PRC on the Tibet-Nepal border. Even when Tibetans make it to the Nepali side, the Nepali police who are paid handsomely by the Chinese deport them instantly to get their reward from the Chinese communists! India must stand for Tibet and support the movement by having more recognition of the exile Government. It should invite Tibetan parlimentaries to meet face to face with Indian parliamentarians. It should also speak up for Tibet in international arena whenever the opportunity arises. Kublai Khan didn’t rule Tibet! He converted to Buddhism and took Choegyal Phakpa as his preceptor. When he received a holy initiation on Heyvajra, he offered Tibet to Choegyal Phakpa and Choegyal Phakpa ruled Tibet. This is how the Sakya Lama rule was introduced in Tibet and in fact this is how Lama rule in Tibet was first introduced!
Agreed but India has no moral obligation as such to help us. Even in individual life of a person can’t be brought to happiness unless he or she wants it the most. Not India should rather India could in this present situations. We should be one as the general had emphasised repeatedly. Take an example of Indian themselves. We can learn lot from their struggle of independence.
@@kungagyaltsen2839 Tibet for India is not a question of moral obligation! It’s national security! Before the Chinese illegal occupation of Tibet in 1949/50, India never had any danger emanating from Tibet for centuries!!! Tibet was a Buddhist nation of peace and tranquility. We looked to India as the holy land (Arya Bhumi). But once Tibet was occupied by communist China, troubles started immediately which culminated in the Chinese invasion of India in 1962 and occupation of Aksai Hind! Anybody with a brain as small as that of a midget will know that an independent Tibet is the ONLY WAY TO SECURE INDIA’S NORTHERN BORDER WITH TIBET. It a historical fact that TIBET WAS A BUFFER STATE between India and China which kept India secure and peace in Asia! The British rulers of India NEVER RECOGNISED CHINESE SOVEREIGNTY OVER TIBET! They knew that any hostile power in Tibet would jeopardise British India’s security!!! Unfortunately, Independent India’s leaders were too eager to go to bed with the wily Chinese communists and endorsed Chinese baseless claims over Tibet to cozy with the Chinese communists! Now you can see the Himalayan blunder playing out between China and India in the Himalayas with endless incursions, encroachments, salami slicing of Indian territory and clashes between troops as we saw in Galwan and having to spent billions of dollars for infrastructure and retain 90,000 troops all across Arunachal Pradesh, Himachal, Sikkim and Ladakh! TO REINSTATE INDEPENDENT TIBET AS THE HISTORICAL BUFFER STATE IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF INDIA, CHINA AND WHOLE OF ASIA FOR PEACE AND PROSPERITY!!! WITHOUT IT SOONER OR LATER, WAR IS LIKELY TO BREAK OUT SINCE COMMUNIST CHINA IS CLAIMING MORE AND MORE INDIAN TERRITORY SUCH AS ARUNACHAL PRADESH AND LADAKH! India will be FORCED TO GO TO WAR to defend its territory!
Thank you sir for making effort to talk on Tibet. We appreciate it a lot.. We hope you will continue with it. I think Justice will win in the end.
Free Tibet and make it a global movement… Tibet needs freedom from Chinese imperialism
do u have the guts
Need to make Viral message like# free Tibet
Tibet is independent country free tibet
@Shivshakti998 india took 200 years to free them self from British rules. No India no China. Independent Tibet. Tibet don’t want to be in situation lik Ladakh or Sikkim or tawang.
@Shivshakti998 😂😂 nobody is talking about Indian civilization oldest or not. We are talking about how long it took for india to get its independent from British over 200 years. FYI Country of Bangladesh was created with a help of Tibetans who were in Indian army. And list goes on golden Tample, kargil war,
@Shivshakti998 Bhutan was never invaded by any nation till British ruled in India and became a vassal state same with Sikkim and arunachal pradesh and from the Nepal side mustang. The Himalayan region been thriving before they came in contact with india. When Tibet become independent country again the Himalayan people and the culture will Flourish ones again.
I love India and Indian people,thank you so much for supporting us.🙏🙏🙏
Respected General Sir every year there is a Tibet market here. A few years ago i have seen on every price tag they wrote Tibet ki aazadi Bharat ki suraksha.
good.
unfortunately they have not gone beyond that.
@@gunnersshot9829 Symbols are important.
Made in Tibet, Tag does make no difference. If Kashmiris write Made in Kashmir will you endorse it.
@@shariqaman731 are you asking for made in Shanghai made in Beijing likewise
Sat sri akaal Honorable Shanker sahib ji as well all listeners, Thanks a lot for have a talk on TIBBET ISSUE,, this should be a agenda for our main stream media... wonderful analysis.. JAI HIND, VANDEMATRAM...Free Tibbet..
Namaste. Bharath mata ki Jai.
Tashi Delek. Thank you Genarel Saab. ❤
Tashi Delek
Thank u very much for supporting tibet. May god bless u Sir!!!
Thank you sir Please help us free TIBET from red china
This funny word Suzerainty was coined by the British Raj in India. The explanation of this funny word Suzerainty, is China has claim over Tibet but has no control over Tibet and this word remained until the end of the British rule in India. Our Tibetan King Songtsen Gambo has two wifes, first and elder Queen Balsa was princess of Nepal and the second Queen was a Chinese princess, we Tibetans called Gyalsa. Both Princess each brought with them the Statue of Buddha but the Buddhism came to Tibet from India and not as the Chinese say it came from China. But it is true that Buddhism first came to China before it came to Tibet. Thank you Shankar sab for bringing such topic on Tibet to the Indian public. 🙏🙏🙏
this is same ..right now china is claiming rarunachal pradesh eventhough there is no control...
Thank you so much. JAI INDIA 🇮🇳 JAI TIBET 🙏
This year at minimum 20 students have been killed there during the regular March curfew in Lhasa and resulting Resistance.
Sir, we thank you for sharing your experience and guidance about Tibet. हमे तिब्बत के विषय में शांत और दीर्घकालीन योजना पर कार्य करने की जरुरत है। तिब्बत को आजाद तो करना ही है और यह हमारी दीर्घकालीन योजना होनी चाहिए। इसमें आपके द्वारा सुझाए गए विषयों पर जैसे ग्रामीण तिब्बती क्षेत्र से आजादी के लिए लोगों को जागरूक करना आदि। स्थानीय लोगों का साथ और सहयोग विजय मे एक महत्वपूर्ण भूमिका निभाता है। हमें संपूर्ण हिमालय क्षेत्र चीन से आजाद करवाना है। प्रणाम।
On behalf of our Tibetan people, may I convey u A Grand Salute for ur good deeds 🙏may God bless you👃👃👃
You are the only security expert who explains and educates us in Hindi. Keep it up!
Thank you for great presentation. So call Tibetan youth congress, SFT around the world needs to start the revolution with the strategies.
I am from Arunachal it is wonderful presentation on Tibet issue.
# free tibet
# free south tibet
#free khalistan
@@AwaisAli-rd2qp : Tibet is a country existed which was occupied by China. Whereas no such country like Kalisthan existed to fight for.
@@AwaisAli-rd2qp free world from Islamic terrorists
Haha. These responses from PRC 50c warriors are hilarious.
This is a heavy hitting and much needed episode. Though gen.Ravishankar has previously advised for India to have "strategic patience", this episode underlines the necessity to act on policy on a priority basis.
The level of insights need to be appreciated about the demographic spread of Tibetan allegiances w.r.t to freedom vs indifference vs co-opting ccp. It is a complex scenario indeed!! Bottomline is, this is upto Tibetan people and external actors including Bharat would have to defer to original (uninfluenced) interests of Tibetan people for eternal peace in the region. Independent Tibet helped with this peace for 100s of years and it shall continue. Bharat failed (and probably did not have the might) to act when ccp occupied Tibet. Hopefully the time to correct that wrong will come soon and Tibetan people with help from others would be ready to act to be free.
Thanks for another insightful episode sir.
Love Tibet, Love Bharat.
Love Tibetan people. Love Bharti people.
Love Tibetan culture, Love Bharti culture.
Love Buddhism, Love Sanathan Dharma.
Peace, love, heal, meditate.
Transcendental meditation for world peace, and prosperity.
India's support for Tibet is highly valued. Whether it's providing refuge or acknowledging the small land area, India has played its part as a Dharma teacher. Tibet expressed its gratitude by offering heavy gold and other precious stones to the Indian government when His holiness first arrived. I know that isn’t much for what India has done for Tibetans. India need not fear war, as Tibetans are willing to sacrifice themselves for their ally. Despite not being fully literate or having modern power, Tibetans possess sincerity and patience. Notably, revered Tibetan masters like Shanta Rakshita, Shanti Deva, Nagarjuna, and Arya Deva are all Indians. I admire India for its sincere and honest approach.
Huge respect sir, your perspective has given many new ways for Tibetans..they should come up with new energy..
I don't have any words to Thank you General Saab 🙏 Your speech is incredible and touchs our heart ♥️ Thank u Sir ,, n thank u India 🇮🇳
Dear General Sir! Thanks for so many wonderful , informativ videos, Most importantant Big thanks for helping to keep poeple like me more informed . Jai Hind !!!
Great insights General
True. We have been using this as a slogan ever since I was a little kid. Tibbat Ki Azadi, Bharat ki Suraksha. If you delve deeper, this has a deeper meaning. But it remained just a slogan.
Free Tibet Jai Hind
Free south Tibet
It is really insightful and thoughtful video sir. We have been asking for Tibet’s independence since time immemorial. Hoping to get cleared from the gray zone. 🙏🙏🙏
All the best
This is one of the best broadcast you have done. At 1.06.08 you are absolutely correct sir one Chinese also said that if India exploit Tibet we will exploit the north east .
100 percent Tibet Will be free one day I hope. Free Tibet jai hind jai Bharat ✊
Could you also mention the role of SFF in winning the East Pakistan war prior to becoming Bangladesh? Without its role, things would be different altogether.
I agree
PRANAM NAMAN
...General ji...JAI HIND...
Good insight, man is slave of circumstances without their fault, but i blame catalyst who help to ruin .
Great sir. Excellent facts on Tibet.
Great talk Sir.
Thank you for this informative information. Gai Hind! Gai Bharat! Gai Tibet!
A tibetan from Nepal ! Sir I am very thankful to your for taking our cause to an outstanding level of outreach and enthusiasm . Tibetans are ready to compromise with a genuine autonomy with the PRC under the very humble and a very non violent guidance of HH THE DALAI LAMA. Sir once again than you very much !
Hello sir thank you for so much and I am very happy to know this kind of knowledge about Tibet
Thank you very much sir, we are very grateful to you. Thanks for all
Thank you for sharing honest views ..
Salute sir
Thank you Generally very generous and supportive, informative
Thank you sir. And keep continue please 🙏
We hope one day Tibet will be free and we can go to lhasa on a pilgrimage like in the ancient time. ❤ ladakh
Respected Shankar sir. I want to say that from mid 6th century to 7th century period of king Songtsen Gampo, he sent Tibetan scolars to India for relationship and Buddhist philosophy. Tibet made relationship with India century before, but I think India failed to respond to Tibet, because India was struggling themselves under British. As you said those all are history, but now India is one of the super power of the world. India can now help Tibet as being a teacher from history. Many Tibetan wants to come to India, but China shoot at side while the Tibetan crossing the borders to India. Tibetan will never obey China, don't worry about that. Tibet needs more supporters like India to free Tibet. I think other countries are benefitting from China for cheap goods which are most stole from Tibet. Tibet was and still is a rich in resources like rivers for electricity and many natural resources. You said Tibetan are getting some developments from China. Imagine if China couldn't occupied Tibet then Tibet surely make continue relationship with India and India and Tibet both benefit a lot and much more developed. In the end all Tibetan want freedom, but Tibet is not capable to start war against China, because of our religion. That's why Dalai Lama is trying to solve through dialog and free Tibet.
I am with you
A superpower with a per capita GDP of less than $3,000? A severely hungry superpower?
Thank you Sir❤❤❤
Big bharat should lead the tibet movement. Tibet independent is more benefits for bharat than any other countries
Thank you Sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏
thanks you so much Sir.
Thank you very much sir !!
Sir. Thank you so much for telling the about Tibet. Wish you a very happy life ahead.
Thank you sir
Excellent analysis sir
th-cam.com/video/Gek7y0cqxxQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Xdc-Vb6AaaSWxwP5
Thank you, sir. It's good to hear your perspective on the Tibet issue. I appreciate your insights; I'm listening from Canada.
Thank you for your sharing tibet cause and history. You are true responsible indian sir. I salute you behalf of all tibetan LT General sab,🫡 free tibet
Thinks you sir jai bharat jai tibet ❤❤❤
General sir,
You bring out the exact strategy which I have been pondering in respect of Tibet.
Great analysis.
Thanks,
Jai hind
Jai Hind.
Thank you sir🙏🙏🙏 JAI TIBAT JAI BARAT
Thanks sir
Welcome
Thank you so much 🙏🏼🙏🏼
The Intro Video
is Awesome
Truly like a
General's Channel
As Missile Hits the Ground..
The Message says
"Welcome to Gunnershot"
A General's Welcome
Especially for
Enemies of Bharat
Watching
Thank you Lt Gen P R Shankar,thank you Indian Government,Jai Hind, Jai Tibet
first great detail presentation about Tibetan history, impressed and appreciated as a Tibetan born and grew up in India till mid 20's and left for the western civilization..much respect for the truth and the detail story of Tibet.thank you sir
FREE TIBET, ✌️🇮🇳 🇺🇲 🇯🇵 ✌️👍
A very thought provoking, well researched and realistic talk.
A few thoughts (albeit highly imaginative but still in realm of possibility)
1. It is clear that a gradual change will not bring independence to Tibet. Only an intense incident can give Tibet independence
2. What can the sudden, intense event be (mostly likely external)
a. Most likely would be a Muslim-world backed liberation of Xin Jiang riding on which Tibet can get independence
b. If a violent independence movement takes place in China, the world can exploit the chaos to wrench out Tibet, Xin Jiang and Manchuria
c. A nuclear attack by China on any country, followed by a massive retaliatory attack by the the US and allies. Like Japan in 1945, China will be forced to cede Xinjiang, Tibet and Manchuria as settlement.
3. If China becomes democratic, wry likely on the basis of return to Buddhist roots, the 1988 Dalai Lama’s Middle Path proposal would possibility be implemented hoping for a realisation of Independent Tibet at a later date.
4. You are very right that modernisation and passing of time, is diluting the concept of Buddhist Tibet.
5. There is no traction for Buddhist nationalism. India should take initiate the revival of the concept of Buddhist nationhood and nationalism.
6. Looks like at this point of time true autonomy seems the most probable situation
7. Like one of the viewer question. The Dalai Lama is the biggest rallying point for Tibet and sadly he is a mortal
Hmm
How about a world wide boycott of Chinese goods until they vacate occupied Tibet ? Similar to anti-apartheid movement
@@ramrao668 Has too happen. We had Piyush Goel saying at business meet that Indian businessmen on see profit. Even if Chinese goods are 5% cheaper they will buy Chinese. Most or many goods in Amazon etc are Chinese. The country of origin is never displayed prominently. It is in some small print. Like burning a house to drive out a rat. To unseat the ruling party our politicians are even ready to sleep with our enemies. Nationalists are branded as Fascists.
In short, Govt is doing all it can to move away from China within the allowable limits of WTO and other world bodies. The citizens should also join in the effort to reduce the China dependence to strengthen the Governments effort. We need have citizens’ Nationalism in Commerce and Economy also. South Korea and Japan are the best examples.
Thank you very much for supporting us 🙏🙏🙏
Thank you so much Sir! I m a Tibeten 43 of age living in abroad . I still train like an army . My grandfather was in Gorkha regiment, my uncle and father served ssf vikas regiment. Saying all that I don’t mean to say war is only the wway seeing Tibets position. I want to keep myself ready for everything. I like your views. I see a bit of His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama in your character. You are a very rational person. Jai Tibet Jai Bharat!
Thank you for the real story
General Sir, Loved the intro of hitting the beach bulls eye 👁 ❤
Thank you for the open my mind.
My pleasure!
Thank you so much sir ❤
Thank you Sir for sharing your deep knowledge with us. I as a tibetan also don’t know much. I’m educating myself through ur videos 🙏
❤❤❤
thanks sir jai ind jai tib
Jai hind sir Vijay ho maha bharat thank you india❤
❤
Thank you sir about talking Tibet
Your topic on Tibet' freedom no dought is literally and beautifully analysed. History reflects nobody is ever powerful and no country remains permanently powerful. Everything will get changed according to existing situation and circumstances. Anyway, very nice analysis on Tibet's liberty. Thank you for focussing past, present and future situation.
Save Tibet!
👍👍🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️
Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Sir 🙏
There is also one angle left. Between us and Tibet, countries like Nepal and Bhutan is also there supporting tibetian refugees. Freedom movement will definitely ignite from there.
🤔
Thank you for your research so well done on TIBET. We really are worrying for culture n traditional way of life under threat n supression by comminist regime.
Very well elucidated sir
So nice of you
Of course it can be, it ought to be! India must help, soonest!
I was eagrly waiting for this episode as I really wanted to know about Tibet and that too from a well informed person thank you sir
th-cam.com/video/Gek7y0cqxxQ/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Xdc-Vb6AaaSWxwP5
I hope I did not disappoint
@@everuttejon9886who told you that tibetans hate indian ...pls don't spread hatred we tibetans only hate china on this beautiful earth
Wonderful Geo-politics Teaching ....Jai Tibet Jai Bharath .. Every Tibetan needs to work forwards..Traning of Modern Military warfare for every Tibetan is very Important..Spirit of nationalism is very low among Exile Tibetan ..
Jai hind jai Tibet.❤❤❤
Arunachal, Assam, Naga land , Utter pradesh is part of Tibbet,
Hmm
Thank you Gen. Shankar for a wonderful insightful session on Tibet. It resonates much with what I have been thinking for some time now.
The time has come for Indians to act on it. Some thoughts
1. Have Centres of Tibetan studies in atleast some universities - preferably Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata - some of the oldest ones in India. We know so little about Tibet. The Tibetan Govt in exile must pursue this with Govt of India. There are two confucious institutes still active in India - one in Mumbai, and one in Manipal, I think. (on a side note, those need to be closed down. We can learn mandarin from Taiwan)
2. For all maps published in India, or shown in India, especially on mobile apps, all Tibetan places must show Tibetan/Indian names, in Tibetan language. Right now they show Chinese names in Mandarin for Tibetan places. Eg. Manassarovar and Rakshas Tal show up with some Chinese name on Google Maps. So also for places in Tibet right opposite Nathu La. This is unacceptable. Govt of India can, and must enforce this. We, the people, must demand it.
3. Buddhism went from India to Tibet. I'm guessing Tibetans would love to visit Buddhist centres in India, so we need to promote that.
4. Tibetan Govt in Exile must do more to promote Tibetan festivals, culture in India. Let the Indian people know. At the same time, they should be publish more articles and documentaries of how the CCP is repressing Tibetans in Tibet.
Chinese expansionist policy (they have already decided that Tibet is the palm and now they are after Five fingers 1. Bhutan, 2. Sikkim, 3. Arunachal, 4. Ladakh, 5. Nepal. They have already forcefully captured Tibet and now are after 5 fingers….
Sir, at 17:00, you mentioned the monks protest on March 89'. To this day, there are curfews in Tibet for upto 4 months in universities in Lhasa.
I did know that
You are the real Hero. the sun, moon, and truth cannot hide. Tibetan Independence for India Indian security. It's Time for Neheru's ignorance. New India must fight for the truth for India's security.