You are the reason I developed a deep interest in philosophy. Your insights and discussions sparked a passion in me that I didn't know existed. Because of this newfound enthusiasm, I decided to change my optional subject for the civil service exam from sociology to philosophy. This transformation in my academic path is entirely thanks to you, and I'm eager to start a series exploring the great philosophers in depth. Love from INDIA
@3rd_POV sir, honestly speaking you don't need any mic or camera. The spontaneity of your expression and the simplicity of this setup make your videos very pure and lovely to watch. The side notes are pure love, your laughter in between are sheer pleasure to listen to. This content, raw and unedited, is awesome the way it is. However boosting the post and try to reach more people is what I'll recommend. This content deserves views in millions.
Then a God dances through me This line took me back 3 years ago. Today I found the sentence to express my feelings/experience that I had so long back. .. 🥺🥺🥺
The best explaination of western philosphy even better than some of english writers and most of the TH-cam recordings of western youtubers . In urdu language it is an extraordinary effort to teach western philosophy in such a docile and interesting teaching /explaination skills. ❤❤❤ Gratitude sir!!!
Yi Masail-e-Tasawuf yi Apka bayaan Ham toh wasay apko wali samjh bhi chuke hai haha ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Thanks a million for this video. Each second of this video is so important.
what a spectacular explanation ,i think this video was the end of all philosophy and science , you are a gem to us great work sir ,keep doing the good job.
Thank you so much for presenting Nietzsche in such an accessible yet nuanced way. I've always wanted to read Nietzsche, and after watching your videos, I feel it will be much easier for me to do so.
I'm a Student of English Literature 🥸 but to be honest Sir, your Videos are too much worthy for me, too much informative than my Whole syllabus.. 🤍🖤 Thanks for giving us the wisdom..❤️💝
I am the student of English Literature. Pichley 5 mahinoo sey mey es channel ko sunta aa raha hun. To be honest, bohut youtubers dekhey hey jo education k realted banatey hey magar unka koe taste nhe. Jb sey meney ess channel ko suna hey baaqu TH-camrs mey bhul chuka hun. Apka andazey bayan kamal hey muhtaram. Mey jb b sota hey ap ka koe vidoe clip start kar k sunta hun awr neend aa jati hey. Ap sey bohut new new ideas sekhi hey. Apko sunney k baad jb class mey bath tha hun, aisa lgta hey k mujhey bohut kuxh ata hey awr confident k sath apna point of view share karta hun. Lastly, agr ap merey neighbor hotey ya merey city mey hotey then to be honest, Ap sey har week milta sir awr sekhta ap sey. Love and respect from the bottom of my heart. ❤
Thank you - I am giving you a task - share my videos in your groups- itnay kum views atay hain kay maza hi naheen ata -- share my videos and ask your friends to tune into my channel- it’s free hahaha
@shingoDX Hey thanks for your comment. After your comment - I checked Taimur's channel - he swings towards analytical philosophy -- which is NOT philosophy at all. Analytical philosophy is DEAD. If I start to get reasonable number of views - I will show you what is CONTINENTAL philosophy ---the real philosophy. He is working for last 8 years and not a single video on Heidegger, Wittgenstein, Rorty, Foucault, Kierkegaard, Deluze or Husserl, Berguson, or any of the linguistic philosophers (only exception is Hegel - which he covers because he is a Marxist) I noticed he has also made some videos on British political philosophers - but those videos were very academic in nature. This is just a light hearted comment
Kindly make a video on political view of maulana maududi, if you can.. Also i would love to listen how khilafat and mulukiyat ne apko barbad kiya tha.. . Love you from India..
@@3rd_POV Sir, I would recommend you to just watch one video of Dhruv Rathee. I'm sure you may not watch it because I'm saying so. But believe me or not, his visual quality is mind blowing and the way he prepares to deliver is sharp and to the point. He can see himself in 3rd person i.e. through camera's eyes and his audience's demographics. He's a professional Educational TH-cam Channel in Urdu/Hindi. [Side Note: Educational Channel need even more visuals and attention grabbing tricks than pure entertainment channels.] Hope it helps! Love you sir because we both are from Pakistan. 🤔🤨
@@3rd_POV I tried to search for your videos on my wife’s phone and I tried 3rd pov nothing came , I end up typing Plato’s dialogues in Urdu still you were third search . I know I am not giving you any solution brother but making you aware as I myself is completely inept in tech
Thank you for uploading part 2 on Nietzsche. Please make more content on Nietzsche, in fact, make some comparison videos of Nietzsche with his contemporary writers.
How do you see Islam as a religion in the hands of a new generation that is seeking answers to everything? Since I started reading philosophy and science, I have become agnostic and believe that no belief system can withstand the test of time. Human cognitive and creative abilities continue to evolve, and belief systems often remain static throughout history. This clash between evolving intelligence and static belief systems may no longer be sustainable. What do you say?
@@3rd_POV no I'm just asking your point of view on it. What I said was that reading science and particularly philosophy, as it could to everyone, made me skeptical.
Great job.sir shuru mai jab ao khuda ke love ke bary main bat kr rhe thy. Ap ne phir saza ki bat ki to ap ne christianity bol diya lekin woh saza wala concept ap islam ka bta rhy thy. Shukriya sir. Waiting for your videos. Great work
Hum muvahhid hain hamara kesh hai tark-e-rusuum Millaten jab mit gayin ajza-e-iimaan ho gayin - Mirza Ghalib Will really love to see you come up with impending explorations on the the Islamic and Indian Philosophical traditions (and maybe after then Masnavis, Divans, Upanishads and much more), thereby enriching us with thorough understandings and insights with immense knowledge and wisdom as you've been doing up til now. Lots of Love ❤
Sahi kaha maulavi ne aisa bana diya hai khuda jiss se nafrat dar lagta hai piyr ka ehesas hi nikal dete hai sir zindagi ek aazab bana dete hai maulana sir ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Ibn-e-Rusd tou apni jaan hai --Yar woh alag dunya hai --Arastu ki dunya -- uskay liye alag background chahiye --I will definitely cover that but before that I will have to make a few videos on Arastu ….lets see when we get time for Arastu
Great. You must do all the chapters. I am trying to grasp the whole concept of TSZ and ask myself to conceive/learn with an analogy. Will it be correct to say that Nietzsche advocates to “give rise to your power to buy” instead of “buying on sale or buy cheap”. ?? I am unsure??
@@3rd_POV okay , thanks sir...aapke channel se jo gyaan milta h or sunkar maja bhi aata h...aapke subscribers millions me hone chahiye the but log knowledge chahate hi nhi 🙄🙄
Sir ji please I tried to find the starting poem of Faiz Ahmed Faiz but couldn't find it. Please write it in description or in comments. I want to write it down.
Bhai I tried to find it on internet I could not find - it is a small poem - given below BA-NOOK-e-Shamsheer (Title) Meray A-baa kay thay na mahram-e-Tauq-o-Zangeer Woh Mazameen jo ada karta hai ab mera Qalam Nook-e-shamsheer pey likhtay thay ba-nook-e-shamsheer Roshanai say jo main karta hoon kaghaz pay raqam sang-o-sahra pay woh kartay thay laho say tahreer
For Plato read Symposium- love is the desire to immortalize yourself - yeah sounds strange but that is what Plato thinks. Nietzsche’s view on love kept changing as he matured into his system- Nietzsche does not think in terms of virtues (that’s Platonic thinking), Nietzsche thinks in terms of instincts and yes love he considers a basic instinct.
Bohat Aala...But my respected teacher...when we study Quran, there is mention of "Don't you have Reason(Aql)", many times....and Islam is a reveled religion and it stresses too much upon reasoning ...what is your point of Quran on Reasoning....thanks
80 90% videos dekh li many. oor banaeen . you are amazing
Even Nietzsche's chapter length is eccentric.❤😂
I am student of political science and doing my masters in it. I’ve got a great insight from your videos. Love from India
Thanks
You are the reason I developed a deep interest in philosophy. Your insights and discussions sparked a passion in me that I didn't know existed. Because of this newfound enthusiasm, I decided to change my optional subject for the civil service exam from sociology to philosophy. This transformation in my academic path is entirely thanks to you, and I'm eager to start a series exploring the great philosophers in depth.
Love from INDIA
I am really honoured and humbled after reading your comments- thank you very much- wishing you all the best in your future ventures.
@@3rd_POV Thank you so much for your kind words and good wishes. It means a lot to me!
And which translation of this book are you holding in your hand ??
I really like your videos. Keep posting the vedio
ah, its getting difficult to fall asleep without watching your videos
hahaha
Please keep on talking and posting. Regardless of the views.
Appreciate all your work.
Sir we want more videos on thus spoke Zarathustra chapters please❤
Ok, I will make one more video on TSZ
Comfort Nhi Chahiye , adventure, explore chahiye.... Peace nhi chahiye war chahiye challenge improvement chahiye
Thanks a lot sir for making another part on thus spoke Zarathustra🥰❤️
Keep it up😊
@3rd_POV sir, honestly speaking you don't need any mic or camera. The spontaneity of your expression and the simplicity of this setup make your videos very pure and lovely to watch. The side notes are pure love, your laughter in between are sheer pleasure to listen to. This content, raw and unedited, is awesome the way it is.
However boosting the post and try to reach more people is what I'll recommend. This content deserves views in millions.
Hey - thanks brother
Then a God dances through me
This line took me back 3 years ago. Today I found the sentence to express my feelings/experience that I had so long back. .. 🥺🥺🥺
Great writer great topic great interpetsioner
The best explaination of western philosphy even better than some of english writers and most of the TH-cam recordings of western youtubers . In urdu language it is an extraordinary effort to teach western philosophy in such a docile and interesting teaching /explaination skills. ❤❤❤ Gratitude sir!!!
Thanks
آپ کی تفہیم قابل رشک ہے۔
Bohat shukriya Janab. Aapka feedback aur kaam karnay kay liye himmat paida karta hai.
All time favourite channel on TH-cam ❤❤
Thx
TSZ is such keenly woven labyrinth and varily it looks back too,yet one word for this masterpiece: abundance.
Agreed - it's a very tough nut to crack.
Yi Masail-e-Tasawuf yi Apka bayaan
Ham toh wasay apko wali samjh bhi chuke hai haha
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Thanks a million for this video. Each second of this video is so important.
Thx brother
what a spectacular explanation ,i think this video was the end of all philosophy and science , you are a gem to us great work sir ,keep doing the good job.
Wow, thank you!
@@3rd_POV ❤
Thank-you so much sir for these very insightful videos
Thx
I respect your knowledge and your presentation and style
Thank you so much for presenting Nietzsche in such an accessible yet nuanced way. I've always wanted to read Nietzsche, and after watching your videos, I feel it will be much easier for me to do so.
You're very welcome!
One of your best work. Amazing explanation
Thx
No.1 Nietzsche
Aa gya shahzada.... maza anay wala hy ajj... hahaha
Hahaha
I'm a Student of English Literature 🥸 but to be honest Sir, your Videos are too much worthy for me, too much informative than my Whole syllabus.. 🤍🖤
Thanks for giving us the wisdom..❤️💝
Thanks Moazzam
@@3rd_POV ❤️
I am the student of English Literature. Pichley 5 mahinoo sey mey es channel ko sunta aa raha hun. To be honest, bohut youtubers dekhey hey jo education k realted banatey hey magar unka koe taste nhe. Jb sey meney ess channel ko suna hey baaqu TH-camrs mey bhul chuka hun.
Apka andazey bayan kamal hey muhtaram. Mey jb b sota hey ap ka koe vidoe clip start kar k sunta hun awr neend aa jati hey. Ap sey bohut new new ideas sekhi hey. Apko sunney k baad jb class mey bath tha hun, aisa lgta hey k mujhey bohut kuxh ata hey awr confident k sath apna point of view share karta hun.
Lastly, agr ap merey neighbor hotey ya merey city mey hotey then to be honest, Ap sey har week milta sir awr sekhta ap sey.
Love and respect from the bottom of my heart. ❤
Thank you - I am giving you a task - share my videos in your groups- itnay kum views atay hain kay maza hi naheen ata -- share my videos and ask your friends to tune into my channel- it’s free hahaha
صرف یہی کہنا چاہتا کہ "استاد محترم!!" ❤❤❤
Thanks man
Sir, we have been waiting passionately for your videos. Plz jaldi upload kren. More videos on Nietzsche's Zarathustra
Coming up soon
Sir thankU for enlightening with your knowledge ☺️
Thank you for your knowledge
Bravo Ali ! How hv u gathered so much Knowledge Wisdom ? What an effort ! I salute u !
Thank you Sir!! Really appreciate your feedback!!!
Live long and prosper, Ali.
Thanks Fatima - you too!!
Bohot wait rehta hy apki videos ka. .
Plz more chapters, sir . ❤
Yes, I will. Thx
I just comment before starting a video it's surely a masterpiece👍 like a previous one and learn something new .
Thanks - yes if you watch till the end there will be a few things that will surprise you!!!
Waiting for next chapter
Keep it up Sir
Thank you Sir.
You are most welcome
Sir Make whole book. Page 1 to last page. So much to absorb.
Ok I will cover a few more chapters
Great sir jee love U ❤️
Konichiwa 👋🏾 arigato 🍀
2 my favourite philosopher
Dr Taimur Rahman and You sir ❤
@shingoDX
Hey thanks for your comment. After your comment - I checked Taimur's channel - he swings towards analytical philosophy -- which is NOT philosophy at all. Analytical philosophy is DEAD.
If I start to get reasonable number of views - I will show you what is CONTINENTAL philosophy ---the real philosophy.
He is working for last 8 years and not a single video on Heidegger, Wittgenstein, Rorty, Foucault, Kierkegaard, Deluze or Husserl, Berguson, or any of the linguistic philosophers (only exception is Hegel - which he covers because he is a Marxist)
I noticed he has also made some videos on British political philosophers - but those videos were very academic in nature.
This is just a light hearted comment
@@3rd_POVsir please check desiphilosopher and quest
Kindly make a video on political view of maulana maududi, if you can.. Also i would love to listen how khilafat and mulukiyat ne apko barbad kiya tha.. . Love you from India..
Awesome ❤❤❤
bohot maza agaya...
amazingly described everything, you've became daily dose kinda thing for me,I'd love that if you make one video on Iqbal and his philosophy..
Sure - will cover that one day
Everyone who's reached this comment, please like the video and comment something so that the TH-cam algorithm give it a little boost. 😄😄
Me also was about to write the same brother
Thank you friends - somehow I think TH-cam does not promote my videos- don’t know much about the algorithm, greatly appreciate your support here.
@@3rd_POV Sir, I would recommend you to just watch one video of Dhruv Rathee. I'm sure you may not watch it because I'm saying so. But believe me or not, his visual quality is mind blowing and the way he prepares to deliver is sharp and to the point. He can see himself in 3rd person i.e. through camera's eyes and his audience's demographics. He's a professional Educational TH-cam Channel in Urdu/Hindi.
[Side Note: Educational Channel need even more visuals and attention grabbing tricks than pure entertainment channels.]
Hope it helps! Love you sir because we both are from Pakistan. 🤔🤨
Please tell me what should I do - I am not a technical person- I don’t know about cameras and mics- get me in contact with someone please. Thx
@@3rd_POV I tried to search for your videos on my wife’s phone and I tried 3rd pov nothing came , I end up typing Plato’s dialogues in Urdu still you were third search . I know I am not giving you any solution brother but making you aware as I myself is completely inept in tech
Don't worry about views bro. You are doing an amazing job. Everything will follow. It has to.
Thank you for uploading part 2 on Nietzsche. Please make more content on Nietzsche, in fact, make some comparison videos of Nietzsche with his contemporary writers.
Sure
How do you see Islam as a religion in the hands of a new generation that is seeking answers to everything? Since I started reading philosophy and science, I have become agnostic and believe that no belief system can withstand the test of time. Human cognitive and creative abilities continue to evolve, and belief systems often remain static throughout history. This clash between evolving intelligence and static belief systems may no longer be sustainable. What do you say?
@@mshahzaib2002 so you think Philosophy or science will give you the answers- they will just scratch your itch
@@3rd_POV no I'm just asking your point of view on it. What I said was that reading science and particularly philosophy, as it could to everyone, made me skeptical.
In one of your videos you mentioned that fiction is the biggest truth and asked to drop a comment for explanation. Can you elaborate on that?
Good Morning Ali Hasan Sir..✨
Morning Sir
thank sir
keep uploading such videos
Thx
behtreen, brilliant way of communication and story telling style, keep making them abhi views nh Hein but trust me you will get a burst of views
Thanks a ton
Thank you Sir!
Your content is always fruitful plzz keep videos on it would be blessed if you make videos on homer and trogon war
Thanks
Sir u r changing my life
Thx
please make more videos u r just great
great lecture, sir
Plz make more videoz on chapters of thus spake zaathustra
Another masterpiece bro 😍😍 dabadab tay patapat 🤣🤣
Great job.sir shuru mai jab ao khuda ke love ke bary main bat kr rhe thy. Ap ne phir saza ki bat ki to ap ne christianity bol diya lekin woh saza wala concept ap islam ka bta rhy thy. Shukriya sir. Waiting for your videos. Great work
Hum muvahhid hain hamara kesh hai tark-e-rusuum
Millaten jab mit gayin ajza-e-iimaan ho gayin
- Mirza Ghalib
Will really love to see you come up with impending explorations on the the Islamic and Indian Philosophical traditions (and maybe after then Masnavis, Divans, Upanishads and much more), thereby enriching us with thorough understandings and insights with immense knowledge and wisdom as you've been doing up til now.
Lots of Love ❤
Kia zabardast shaer suna dia zalim- yes I plan to cover many areas- stay tuned and thanks for appreciating my work
Sir your content is amazing 😍 love every video watching twice most of the videos
Please share in your groups
Well explained ❤
Sahi kaha maulavi ne aisa bana diya hai khuda jiss se nafrat dar lagta hai piyr ka ehesas hi nikal dete hai sir zindagi ek aazab bana dete hai maulana sir ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Sir a video on Al Ghazali, Ibn e Sina & Ibn e Rushd
Ibn-e-Rusd tou apni jaan hai --Yar woh alag dunya hai --Arastu ki dunya -- uskay liye alag background chahiye --I will definitely cover that but before that I will have to make a few videos on Arastu ….lets see when we get time for Arastu
Great. You must do all the chapters. I am trying to grasp the whole concept of TSZ and ask myself to conceive/learn with an analogy. Will it be correct to say that Nietzsche advocates to “give rise to your power to buy” instead of “buying on sale or buy cheap”. ?? I am unsure??
I am unsure too brother- stay away from People who claim that they know the truth!!
Beautiful yar make more videos on the other chapters
Thank you sir
Sir Beyond Good And Evil Par B Videos Lain Plz ❤❤❤❤
Aye gi
@@3rd_POV thnk u sir
WOULD YOU LIKE TO HAVE YOUR THOUGHT ON HEIDEGGER , ALSO A PHILOSOPHICAL AND HISTORICAL ELABORATION ON OLD TESTAMENT . THANKS FOR YOUR LECTURES .
Sir we want complete Western philosophy lectures if you get time in your busy schedule.thanks
Hey- thanks - bhai views hi naheen a rahay Kia karoon...lol
With bravado, you’re inspiring people to question things rather than blindly accepting them. 👏👏👏
Thanks
as superb as always 🤎
Please share in your groups
U right sir about religions , and mujhe lgta philosophy doobe hue logon ko tyhrna sikhati hai religion pr ...
40 ki umar me markar 70 ki umar me dafan huna aap hame zindagi ka aur sahi jine ka tariqa bata dete hu asani se sir ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Please make more videos on TSZ
Thx - yes I will.
Love from india ❤
Thanks
How to understand Nietzsche as a beginner? which book you recommend to start from?
Untimely Meditations- this could be a good starting point.
sir waiting for series of lectures..
kindly upload videos sir ... waiting
You are amazing 😍 sir...❤
Thank you so much 😀
Please make video on warrior chapter
Please do the book chapter by chapter
Keep it up
Mashallah good
Great
Sir Eastern philosopher pr bhi banaiye video like osho, shankracharye , J. Krishnmurti😊😊😊
I have started reading them, it will take some time before I am ready for those discussions. But started reading!!
@@3rd_POV okay , thanks sir...aapke channel se jo gyaan milta h or sunkar maja bhi aata h...aapke subscribers millions me hone chahiye the but log knowledge chahate hi nhi 🙄🙄
Thx
thankyou
Nietzsche talking on love
Plato: hold my symposium 😅
Hahaha
Sir aap bhiii apna khayal rakhyega darrr laga rehtaa hyy apkiii explanation bhttt achiii hyy aap tou ubermensch ban chukyy ho
Lol
Make more vedio on thus spake zarathustra
Yes - will do
I would believe only in a God, who could dance... Amazing
Aap apni bhi soch btaya kriye ki aap us philosopher ke bare me kya sochte Hain
Sir ji please I tried to find the starting poem of Faiz Ahmed Faiz but couldn't find it. Please write it in description or in comments. I want to write it down.
Ok- will send you the link- in the evening- once back home from work
Bhai I tried to find it on internet I could not find - it is a small poem - given below
BA-NOOK-e-Shamsheer (Title)
Meray A-baa kay thay na mahram-e-Tauq-o-Zangeer
Woh Mazameen jo ada karta hai ab mera Qalam
Nook-e-shamsheer pey likhtay thay ba-nook-e-shamsheer
Roshanai say jo main karta hoon kaghaz pay raqam
sang-o-sahra pay woh kartay thay laho say tahreer
@@3rd_POV Thank you so much Sir ji!.
beautiful 😍😍😍
Sir ek Khalil Gibran pr bhi ek video banaiye please...
Ok
Is love a virtue according to Plato or Nietzsche?
For Plato read Symposium- love is the desire to immortalize yourself - yeah sounds strange but that is what Plato thinks.
Nietzsche’s view on love kept changing as he matured into his system- Nietzsche does not think in terms of virtues (that’s Platonic thinking), Nietzsche thinks in terms of instincts and yes love he considers a basic instinct.
@@3rd_POV okay okay and Thank you.
and yes I will surely read Plato's all dialogues inshahallah. These days reading the Stranger by Albert Camus.
❤❤❤
Bohat Aala...But my respected teacher...when we study Quran, there is mention of "Don't you have Reason(Aql)", many times....and Islam is a reveled religion and it stresses too much upon reasoning ...what is your point of Quran on Reasoning....thanks
Can we understand God?