I'm so glad Bob Dylan leaves the comments open on his music. I also feel truly blessed to share this life with one of the greatest musicians in world history. I seen you in Toledo in 2007 and it changed my young life. I stood in the crowd and seen a man who wasted zero talent that was given to him. I had read books about this musician before of course, and knew all about the public hardships he went through, but to see him on stage, knowing everything he has done and will continue to do, is beyond words. Glory to Christ for the talent that is Bob Dylan.
I love the instrumentation and that light percussion on this song. It almost is like a music box but somehow in a different sort of archaic manner. It is so unique and powerfully simple and nothing like anything for it's time. It's like walking down the street in your childhood on an Autumn day with the sunlight filtering through the golden leaves that aches to ponder what Winter will bring. God Bless Bob Dylan and his host of musicians. Just to witness this sort of genius is a pleasure.
It was mine as well during a time in my life many years ago where I allowed myself to be idealistic. The lyrics don’t resonate as much now but Dylan’s conviction in his singing here still is mesmerizing.
Yes, me too. Some of Bob Dylan's songs have this human warmth that you can feel wrapped up in when you take a rest with your lover in front of the fireplace after you both escaped the cruelty and perversion of the world together.
This is one of those songs that still give me goosebumps. How can you really thank someone for creating such high quality for so many decades? Thank you Mister D.
"LOVE YOU NOT FOR WHAT YOU ARE BUT FOR WHAT YOUR NOT" WHAT A FANTASICALLY ORIGINAL EXPRESSION, ESPECIALLY FOR THAT ERA WHEN MOST LYRICISTS ARE EXTOLLING THE VIRTUE OF BEAUTY ETC HE COMES UP WITH A LYRIC WHICH POINTS TO THE DEEPER ASPECTS OF LOVE
I was born in 1947. When I was in HS my coolest friend told me about Bob Dylan in the Village. From his first album I was interested in all he had to say in his songs. I soon was going to his NYC area concerts. With each decade he helped me get through my most difficult times I. my life. Today I'm so happy he is still with us all. I only wish that the people in high places the ones at the controls would understand his messages. Until then. Enjoy all you see and do. Thank you Bob Dylan. ps my grandson is named Dylan
One more cup of coffee and then a shower and clothes. Gonna clean a bedroom downstairs today and move back downstairs. Moved upstairs after my brother left a week after my dad died and been meaning to clean that room downstairs ever since. Todays the day. It’s the nicest bedroom in the house. X
Sometimes you have to feel sorry for those who have not had their lives enriched by listen8ng to this man's mercurial music over the decades. This this is an out take! Which shows just how brilliant this guy is. Thanks, Bob, for enriching my life
Some of Bob Dylan's songs have this human warmth that you can feel wrapped up in when you take a rest with your lover in front of the fireplace after you both escaped the cruelty and perversion of the world together.
I never knew this was a Dylan song! Reading Richard Thompson’s autobiography and he talks about it- I always thought it was a Fairport Convention tune. I had to look it up. Love this.
Bob, Nico then Fairport Convention. The evolution of a song in the best folk tradition. Gotta pay homage to Bob as the primary source to Fairport's genius working of this.
You will search, babe, at any cost But how long, babe, can you search for what is not lost? Everybody will help you Some people are very kind But if I can save you any time Come on, give it to me I'll keep it with mine I can't help it if you might think I am odd If I say I'm not loving you not for what you are But for what you're not Everybody will help you Discover what you set out to find But if I can save you any time Come on, give it to me I'll keep it with mine The train leaves at half past ten But it'll be back in the same old spot again The conductor He's still stuck on the line And if I can save you any time Come on, give it to me I'll keep it with mine
How long can one search for what is not lost? First heard this by Sandy and Fairport, then Nico later on. I think this first appeared on the "John Birch Society Blues" bootleg.
@@timothyryan6018 I know. I think it may be Universal's doing, right? It is pretty nice of them to put a few songs on here though. This song is an outtake from the 'Bringing It All Back Home' sessions and first released on Biograph in 1985 (the cover for which is shown here).
Just found the coffee. It was in the freezer exactly where it was supposed to be. So I of course looked everywhere else. Under piles of hats, in the fridge, in the bin, in the living room. I'm obviously losing my marbles. Come quick!!!
A really great tune from the mid-60s. However, not releasing it on "Bringing It All Back Home" was probably the right move - it sounds pretty out of place when injected anywhere on that album. Always sounded like a good fit for the preceding "Another Side of Bob Dylan", though, if only it had been a bit earlier.
I'm guessing this song not released in 1963 because the studio was still not letting Dylan release "Another Side . . . " from protest, "topical" songs? Yet I agree it's much better than much of what he released in 1964. Why not then?
Wow. So tired still I’ve slept for Ireland 🇮🇪 this past 36 hours. This song. Wow. Again. But I’m gonna try and locate my original Biograph. Think I know where it is. Unlike the feckin coffee.
I’m just up and spent ten minutes trying to find the feckin coffee. It’s in a container and it seems to have disappeared off the face of this earth. Fuckit. I’ve another unopened one. Just weird.
I was gonna bowl my coffee into the pins but lost my mug in a row of wheel barrrows. They had gathered so much moth my papers flew the winds back to a breeze and finally settled on a trumpet. Just then Irene called saying her ears were ringing from a sandless beach she had visited before she war born. She asked me why? I answered: "I is someone else."
@@stevensimoneschi9029 once upon a time there was a Welsh woman who gave birth to a boy who would grow up to believe that he was in the greatest rock band which ever existed. He also believed he was Irish. Like John Hurt the wonderful English actor who cried on Who Do You Think You Are? when he was told he was not Irish. He’d spent his whole life believing he was Irish which is probably why one his last and wondrous one man performances was in The Gate theatre in Dublin In Beckett’s Krapp’s Last Tape. I waited for him in the bar afterwards in a shabby red coat but he didn’t come. Probably gone off to be sick as he’d had to eat two yes two bananas onstage. John was hurt to be told we can’t locate your Irish blood and we’re a team of expert British and even actual Irish genealogists or at least that’s what we tell people for the purpose of getting to work on this popular programme. And the man in the greatest rock band in history, someone’s history, I’d say, Bono’s history told his mother he was going to call himself The Edge and wear a woolly hat that even his wife or doctors would never be able to remove. And so it came to pass. And when I heard that story first I just bawled my eyes out.
It sounds like he's playing with a metronome which is fine with me. This is the best performance by anybody including Bob. He redid it later, but those version miss the mark. This has a quality to it that is magic.
I'm only mentioning it to separate the better verion of this tune from another one out there. The other one has no magic to it. I've love the tapper version ever since I heard it on a bootleg I bought in the early 70s. @@garymccarthy2906
Irene can’t talk right now her text says which means she’s with her evil little sister Anne who hates me and it’s not possible apparently to talk to me while in Anne’s house ffs. Getting somewhat fed up with Irene’s lack of backbone.
Wanna talk to Irene who’s coming here Thursday. She should be up soon as she takes a yoga class Sunday morning East Belfast at 10. I want her to come early and give me a hand with shifting some furniture and with mowing the lawns and cutting hedges if it stays dry til then. Mary T coming for dinner then too. Those two not seen each other in years. They’re both very excited. As am I. Should be fun. I’m making dinner. Irene staying over. But just wish Catherine was here too. It’s her birthday 15/4. Same date as my mum’s mum Annie B.
@@stevensimoneschi9029 I have. And yet somehow still ppl think I may not have read it. Well tbh I haven’t read it all. Life’s been too hectic so far. I’ve put it to one side to read after my retirement from chaos. But even one of my longest friends bought me a copy about five years ago. For my birthday. I of course thanked her but came away thinking after all this time or tome, did even she really think I’d not tracked down a copy before I was fifty? I’ve had a copy since probably 86. I’ve now got two. Two nice covers. I’ve looked at the covers a lot. That’s something.
@@patriciathewisher2315 the covers often delay a photograph of ten big ink stains. But pend only spill the piglets truth when their delaying the evitable love of purple. Colors sing but their songs are rip tidian foam hammerers. Drink the breakers and swallow the fakers. Thus, we swear falsehoods that illuminate truthful shame.
I love this song when it's performed by Fairport convention. I don't like Dylan's vocie but he made some damned good songs like Si tu dois partir also sang by Sandy denny.
her version was a fiasco. Marianne Faithfull's was better but this Dylan version is musically speaking and feel wise the best reading of the song IMHO.
he had the song for 4 years before meeting her apparently... or he "told her" (LOL) that he did... what a smart ass this guy 🤣🤣🤣white lies don't hurt though, just sayin' 🙏
![ประสบการณ์ จ้าง Developer ที่ผมจะไม่มีวันลืม [ภาค1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bzivN4KDg-k/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm so glad Bob Dylan leaves the comments open on his music. I also feel truly blessed to share this life with one of the greatest musicians in world history. I seen you in Toledo in 2007 and it changed my young life. I stood in the crowd and seen a man who wasted zero talent that was given to him. I had read books about this musician before of course, and knew all about the public hardships he went through, but to see him on stage, knowing everything he has done and will continue to do, is beyond words. Glory to Christ for the talent that is Bob Dylan.
I love the instrumentation and that light percussion on this song. It almost is like a music box but somehow in a different sort of archaic manner. It is so unique and powerfully simple and nothing like anything for it's time. It's like walking down the street in your childhood on an Autumn day with the sunlight filtering through the golden leaves that aches to ponder what Winter will bring. God Bless Bob Dylan and his host of musicians. Just to witness this sort of genius is a pleasure.
Beautiful impressions!🙌
I agree. This version has haunted me for years.
I totally understand what you are saying
Yes! If you're not tripping you might as well be.
The percussion sounds like just his foot tapping while playing the tack piano
I know he's written hundreds of great songs, but this is my favorite. By far.
It was mine as well during a time in my life many years ago where I allowed myself to be idealistic. The lyrics don’t resonate as much now but Dylan’s conviction in his singing here still is mesmerizing.
This is my wife and I’s wedding song , she plays the piano and we both sing . Like freaking all in the family lol
this one really sinks in@@cactaceous
One of my favorites and there are so much to choose from.😊
I love the music whatever instrument I hear … BobSinging I always Love.
Its GRAND Bob Dylan🌹🌺❣️
Dylan's songs are some of my best friends.. I've known them that long.
Yea they stay with u through thick and thin
Yes, me too. Some of Bob Dylan's songs have this human warmth that you can feel wrapped up in when you take a rest with your lover in front of the fireplace after you both escaped the cruelty and perversion of the world together.
A beautiful and perfect song. ❤
This is one of those songs that still give me goosebumps. How can you really thank someone for creating such high quality for so many decades? Thank you Mister D.
This is a wonderful arrangement and Bob is like a beautiful loving bird singing from the tree branches! Love it!♥️🥰
That's a nice analogy too. Everyone aches for this kind of songwriting and I guess they only come along every hundred years or so...
Really nice description.
"LOVE YOU NOT FOR WHAT YOU ARE BUT FOR WHAT YOUR NOT"
WHAT A FANTASICALLY ORIGINAL EXPRESSION, ESPECIALLY FOR THAT ERA WHEN MOST LYRICISTS ARE EXTOLLING THE VIRTUE OF BEAUTY ETC HE COMES UP WITH A LYRIC WHICH POINTS TO THE DEEPER ASPECTS OF LOVE
This song is so great. I only knew that Bob gave Nico this to record. Never heard it until today on my Cutting Edge box set.
I was born in 1947. When I was in HS my coolest friend told me about Bob Dylan in the Village. From his first album I was interested in all he had to say in his songs. I soon was going to his NYC area concerts. With each decade he helped me get through my most difficult times I. my life. Today I'm so happy he is still with us all. I only wish that the people in high places the ones at the controls would understand his messages. Until then. Enjoy all you see and do. Thank you Bob Dylan. ps my grandson is named Dylan
One more cup of coffee and then a shower and clothes. Gonna clean a bedroom downstairs today and move back downstairs. Moved upstairs after my brother left a week after my dad died and been meaning to clean that room downstairs ever since. Todays the day. It’s the nicest bedroom in the house. X
Bob Dylan got me into playing music.
This one is in my top of favorite songs
Sometimes you have to feel sorry for those who have not had their lives enriched by listen8ng to this man's mercurial music over the decades. This this is an out take! Which shows just how brilliant this guy is. Thanks, Bob, for enriching my life
...love it so much 🔥
Some of Bob Dylan's songs have this human warmth that you can feel wrapped up in when you take a rest with your lover in front of the fireplace after you both escaped the cruelty and perversion of the world together.
I like this song, it gives me hope.
we will have hope together
❤ this cuz it softens my hard spots.
This song in the movie I'm not there stopped me in my tracks. Glad it's on youtube now for all to love.
I never knew this was a Dylan song! Reading Richard Thompson’s autobiography and he talks about it- I always thought it was a Fairport Convention tune. I had to look it up. Love this.
Possibly one of his best songs...and the best cover song...
There are some outstanding covers of Dylan's songs, and this one is perhaps the best example
Very special lyrics.
Shoutout to the movie, "I'm Not There" Dir: Todd Haynes for introducing me to this hidden gem in Bob's mass catalogue.
It was featured on the box set Biograph. Back then, he could read a phone book and it would please me.😊
Bob, Nico then Fairport Convention. The evolution of a song in the best folk tradition. Gotta pay homage to Bob as the primary source to Fairport's genius working of this.
Dylans’ voice is both plaintive and chilling at the same time. Even the covers of this song cannot compare with the original.
Thank you for your help❣️💞🤝😻🌈
masterpiece
Love to you my beloved Dylan. Peace
You will search, babe, at any cost
But how long, babe, can you search for what is not lost?
Everybody will help you
Some people are very kind
But if I can save you any time
Come on, give it to me
I'll keep it with mine
I can't help it if you might think I am odd
If I say I'm not loving you not for what you are
But for what you're not
Everybody will help you
Discover what you set out to find
But if I can save you any time
Come on, give it to me
I'll keep it with mine
The train leaves at half past ten
But it'll be back in the same old spot again
The conductor
He's still stuck on the line
And if I can save you any time
Come on, give it to me
I'll keep it with mine
💛💛💛
FANTASTIC ... BEAUTIFUL, O...thanks ~ O
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Back here again... Still great *** haaa
🎵🎹⭐️
Thx Bob! and Michael Monsuer and Colleen Saidman Yee! Luv Ya All!
In un piccolo villaggio vicino ad Atene , Dylan scrive l’ll keep with mine , dedicata a Nico e suo figlio Ari 💕 ❤️
I like these songs where he seems to step out of whatever moment the moment is. John Wesley Harding... there's a a lot of that in there, too.
Classic Bob of course. Check out the Resonars version; very different but not to be missed.
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
How long can one search for what is not lost? First heard this by Sandy and Fairport, then Nico later on. I think this first appeared on the "John Birch Society Blues" bootleg.
Love this tune.. But is 1963 the correct date for this version?
1965.
@@thesocialspleen Thx.. Wow Dylan dumped a boat load of songs today.
@@timothyryan6018 I know. I think it may be Universal's doing, right? It is pretty nice of them to put a few songs on here though. This song is an outtake from the 'Bringing It All Back Home' sessions and first released on Biograph in 1985 (the cover for which is shown here).
listen to his voice - it is definitely not 65
@@fredfat3128 What year do you think it is? 1981? 😂 It is 1965.
Just found the coffee. It was in the freezer exactly where it was supposed to be. So I of course looked everywhere else. Under piles of hats, in the fridge, in the bin, in the living room. I'm obviously losing my marbles. Come quick!!!
Ja, wie lange wollen wir noch nach etwas suchen, das wir gar nicht verloren haben?
A really great tune from the mid-60s. However, not releasing it on "Bringing It All Back Home" was probably the right move - it sounds pretty out of place when injected anywhere on that album. Always sounded like a good fit for the preceding "Another Side of Bob Dylan", though, if only it had been a bit earlier.
An organ-infected, nasal voiced version would have fit "Blonde On Blonde" perfectly I think
Maybe if he’d released it as a single it would’ve been a massive hit
@@kanjiwooowooo3202 I was thinking the music sounded closer to It Takes A Lot to Laugh…
I pretty much think that it’s just where it is and has been.
the piano makes me think of Highway 61 straight away!
This song would still be beautiful even without the lyrics
I'm guessing this song not released in 1963 because the studio was still not letting Dylan release "Another Side . . . " from protest, "topical" songs? Yet I agree it's much better than much of what he released in 1964. Why not then?
Wow. So tired still I’ve slept for Ireland 🇮🇪 this past 36 hours. This song. Wow. Again. But I’m gonna try and locate my original Biograph. Think I know where it is. Unlike the feckin coffee.
Nico's version is excellent (which was my introduction to this song.) Check it out.
Every list of "Bob Dylan's Best Love Songs" or whatever that doesn't include this one is wrong.
As with the sleeve notes, the date is wrong.
This song is from 1965
Hats off to Fairport Convention for providing a melody to this song.
1963? I thought it was from 1965.
Sandy Denny and Fairport did this song proper justice.
Fairport Convention’s cover may be more musically pleasing but Dylan infuses this song with a raw haunting mystery.
@@richardnishiki-finley97 Spoken like a Dylan fanatic.
@@billythedog-309 But what he spoke explains why we are Dylan fanatics
@@GD-rd6ig rather than music fanatics.
@@billythedog-309 I can only speak for me, but that's a distinction I can live with.
You will search at any cost. If that doesn't resonate with you, your probably no good.
still fucking searching... 🙏the eternal search goes on
Yup. It does
I’m just up and spent ten minutes trying to find the feckin coffee. It’s in a container and it seems to have disappeared off the face of this earth. Fuckit. I’ve another unopened one. Just weird.
I was gonna bowl my coffee into the pins but lost my mug in a row of wheel barrrows. They had gathered so much moth my papers flew the winds back to a breeze and finally settled on a trumpet. Just then Irene called saying her ears were ringing from a sandless beach she had visited before she war born. She asked me why? I answered: "I is someone else."
@@stevensimoneschi9029 once upon a time there was a Welsh woman who gave birth to a boy who would grow up to believe that he was in the greatest rock band which ever existed. He also believed he was Irish. Like John Hurt the wonderful English actor who cried on Who Do You Think You Are? when he was told he was not Irish. He’d spent his whole life believing he was Irish which is probably why one his last and wondrous one man performances was in The Gate theatre in Dublin In Beckett’s Krapp’s Last Tape. I waited for him in the bar afterwards in a shabby red coat but he didn’t come. Probably gone off to be sick as he’d had to eat two yes two bananas onstage. John was hurt to be told we can’t locate your Irish blood and we’re a team of expert British and even actual Irish genealogists or at least that’s what we tell people for the purpose of getting to work on this popular programme. And the man in the greatest rock band in history, someone’s history, I’d say, Bono’s history told his mother he was going to call himself The Edge and wear a woolly hat that even his wife or doctors would never be able to remove. And so it came to pass. And when I heard that story first I just bawled my eyes out.
It sounds like he's playing with a metronome which is fine with me. This is the best performance by anybody including Bob. He redid it later, but those version miss the mark. This has a quality to it that is magic.
Its his foot tapping
@@jim7831 I know that, but he's doing like he's playing with a metronome.
The foot tapping is an old blues technique. John Lee Hooker did it on many tunes.
I'm only mentioning it to separate the better verion of this tune from another one out there. The other one has no magic to it. I've love the tapper version ever since I heard it on a bootleg I bought in the early 70s.
@@garymccarthy2906
Irene can’t talk right now her text says which means she’s with her evil little sister Anne who hates me and it’s not possible apparently to talk to me while in Anne’s house ffs. Getting somewhat fed up with Irene’s lack of backbone.
Wanna talk to Irene who’s coming here Thursday. She should be up soon as she takes a yoga class Sunday morning East Belfast at 10. I want her to come early and give me a hand with shifting some furniture and with mowing the lawns and cutting hedges if it stays dry til then. Mary T coming for dinner then too. Those two not seen each other in years. They’re both very excited. As am I. Should be fun. I’m making dinner. Irene staying over. But just wish Catherine was here too. It’s her birthday 15/4. Same date as my mum’s mum Annie B.
Someone read Tarantula
@@stevensimoneschi9029 I have. And yet somehow still ppl think I may not have read it. Well tbh I haven’t read it all. Life’s been too hectic so far. I’ve put it to one side to read after my retirement from chaos. But even one of my longest friends bought me a copy about five years ago. For my birthday. I of course thanked her but came away thinking after all this time or tome, did even she really think I’d not tracked down a copy before I was fifty? I’ve had a copy since probably 86. I’ve now got two. Two nice covers. I’ve looked at the covers a lot. That’s something.
@@patriciathewisher2315 the covers often delay a photograph of ten big ink stains. But pend only spill the piglets truth when their delaying the evitable love of purple. Colors sing but their songs are rip tidian foam hammerers. Drink the breakers and swallow the fakers. Thus, we swear falsehoods that illuminate truthful shame.
@@stevensimoneschi9029 couldn’t have said it better meself
Shoulda ended up on Another Side.
I love this song when it's performed by Fairport convention. I don't like Dylan's vocie but he made some damned good songs like Si tu dois partir also sang by Sandy denny.
Ya, forensially speaking, better left off the album. Ya. Good Lord. It's about weight and gravity. Not a number on a playlist.
nico completely shat on him with her version. superior in every way
There’s always gotta be one of em in the comment section.
She wishes
her version was a fiasco. Marianne Faithfull's was better but this Dylan version is musically speaking and feel wise the best reading of the song IMHO.
I love Nico's! Didn't Dylan write it for her? Or did he give it to her already written? I know it was one of the two.
he had the song for 4 years before meeting her apparently... or he "told her" (LOL) that he did... what a smart ass this guy 🤣🤣🤣white lies don't hurt though, just sayin' 🙏
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️