What did Varys hear in the flames?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 พ.ค. 2024
- Explore the best of fantasy and sci-fi in depth, with analysis of the worlds of Lord of the Rings, Game of Thrones, The Witcher and more.
For more A Song of Ice and Fire content: • Secrets of Winterfell ...
Join me on Patreon - / indeepgeek
My channel for live content, including interviews and weekly livestreams - / @idglive
My audiobook channel: The Well Told Tale - / thewelltoldtale
Follow me on:
Twitter - @indeepgeek
Instagram - indeepgeekofficial
Facebook - / indeepgeek
TikTok - @indeepgeek
For merch, audiobooks, and all things In Deep Geek, explore my website - www.indeepgeek.com
Thank you to the talented artists who allowed their work to be featured in this video. You can find them and buy your own prints by following the links below:
Amok - / amokrus
Vanessa Cole - vanessa-cole.pixels.com/
This video was brought to you with support from my amazing Patreon community - special thanks to
Stephanie Frederick, Joshua Clark, Maura Lee, Rabbi Rob Thomas, Brooke Geer Person, Josh Bielemeier, Jane, Vance, Amy Southerland, Ivie Hilburn, Jimmy, Vercingetorix, John-Paul DeLuca, Filbert, Frank Glad, lemmy101, The Lady Gordon, Edward Ryan, Stephanie B, Coleen, Ben Androvich, Nana L, Brennan Barnes, Ivanka Hainzl, Howland’s Little Sister, Charis Messalina de Valence, Donna Daley, Cade Norman, Murray D, NOscar, Rick Hoppe, Leathery Wings, James Pisano, Bridget Boyle, TheStarkInWinterfell, Ellemcee, Alannah Prestayn of Braavos, Raymond Joy, Jonathan Harrison, Petyr Pebble, Jason Mauleon Rosario, Milton Christopher Appling, Edward Ennett, Katy Smith, 26Artgirl, Karen Thomas, Rickon, Cathrine Furseth, James Fitzpatrick, Doug Hughes, lawnduck20, Perseffanie, Emily Mole, Lady Dane, The Late Escapist, Natalie Donald, J. Gregory Henderson, whalawitsa, Luna Cascade, Dan MacKay, Johnny Targs, Kevin Warner, Julie Bernard, Bear, Susan Lonergan, Bo Riley, Lyle Hammac, Alex Butter, Pam Peterson, Bettina Charlotte Nielsen, T boz, Angela Marie Young, Sarah Awesomesauce, Stephanie Erickson, KaliKo_Jack, SeaGreenMango, GeorgeRRTolkien, Antihero Association, Richard Woodard, Caiden Timmons, ThatVBGuy, Tyler Barnhart, John H. Austin, Jr, NikFromNJ, Ty Farnsworth, Beesman, EJ, Willow Button, Julia Kendall, Jonny Ceriani, Mary Frances Angelini, Emma Sheiman, Joseph Jones, Christine Denny, Julien Dubois, Leland, Max Kingdom, Tricia Brady, LiK, Simen Dalstein, Scott Maraldo, Shelley J, Karen Wennerlind, Nathan Drumm, Martin Sjöstrand, Kristen H, King of Imps, Minerva Gale, Eric Nelson, Michiel Venema, Kate, Brandie Roberts, Kendra Summers, reed m, Commander Ray, Mayra Lawson, Lola Roebuck, Mark P, Nicole Stewart, Norse Sultan, Rasler, Steven Spauldingt, Patrick Ward, Amy vh Hines, Slippery1989, Una Haller, Almo71, Ravi Kakarala, Jacob Culp, Janet Lyn, NikFromNJ, Magepie, Ms. Fox, Jon Greenwood, Jahan, Justice, Courtney, Biscuit Jones, Biscuit Jones, Cookie Tywyn, Ranabir Mitra, CRChesnutt, Kip Ingram, Savannah Smith, Tadeo D'Oria, Mario Murray, Leland, AaronM127, Denis Warner, Callie Summers, Gena Z, Joseph Barresi, Karen, KGO, Martin Maleček, Karamy CG, Alvino V, DickCrabb’sSquire, Haley Harstad, Ian Landsman, Lord Medici, Mathew Pauley, Aidan Butler and Phelan Walker
Affiliate Links - (buying books from our Bookshop.org shop supports this channel and local bookshops at no extra cost to you.)
Books for fans of A Song of Ice and Fire:
uk.bookshop.org/lists/a-song-...
Other books we love:
uk.bookshop.org/shop/indeepgeek
Thanks for watching!
(All pictures used are in the public domain, or used under fair use copyright laws, or with the express permission of the artist). - บันเทิง
This is a revised and updated version of a video first uploaded in July 2018
Where are the Images of the sorcerer(6:04) and Young Varys(4:31) sourced From? Are they the artists in the description? I ask because they look like official video captures, and If they are, I've missed a show.
What mic do you use Robert?! I can't get over the sound quality of your voice!
shame it couldn't be re-rendered in 1080 or better
@diox8tony A.I. artwork no doubt.
@@mrsnulchhe just has an incredible voice for speaking, and especially storytelling... He enunciates well and is also articulate.. this is, of course, my personal opinion.. but that doesn't make it any less true!
He heard the actual Winds of Winter release date.
Alternate universe, then?
😂😂😂
:D :D
I’m so god damn mad at this point all I can do is give u a like.
So all he heard was static?
Bloodraven is the answer to every mystery. Who was the sorcerer speaking to? Bloodraven. Who is Jaquen Hagar? Bloodraven. Why do I keep eating cheese even though it doesn't always agree with me? Bloodraven
Who sent the catspaw assassin? Bloodraven...
(Actually, I wouldn't put it past him.)
Yes. But who sent Bloodraven?
Ans: I’m not saying it was aliens…
@@PermanentExile is shierra sea star an alien
Still got 998 answered to match is remaining eyes🤷🏼♂️🤓😎✌🏼
@@PermanentExileI dunno 🤷🏼♂️ Maybe it was Haviland Tuff or the ones who created the Wild Card Virus 🦠? 🤓😎✌🏼
The voice: « Your call is important to us, please hold for the next available…. »
the voice wanted to talk to him about his car warranty?
@@tooslow4065 That was the exact joke I wanted to make, but it seems you got here before me, so here's a like instead.
press 1 for valyrian
The voice told him about how they botched the ending of Season 8
"And since that day I have hated magic"
"The Sorcerer called and a voice answered telling wiener jokes and saying 'muh queen' alot, it was very strange"
😭😭😭😭😭😭
"And since that day I have hated screenwriters."
😂😂😂
🤣
The Unsullied mention to Dany that their God, 'The Mother of Hosts' speaks only to them ever since their manhood was sacrified to the fire...
Great point. I often wonder if Varys is actually an unsullied soldier selected to work to manipulate the kingdoms for someone's benefit.
I completely forgot about this
Brilliant observation.
@Walk_on_Part_In_a_War Unsullied do get chubby if not bought in large numbers...
Huuuuh. Now there's something to consider.
Man, long-distance prices in the day were really out of hand.
They had you by the balls
9:17 “…simply some kind of long distance communication”
In Braavos roaming charges cost an arm and a leg, but in Myr…
OUCH!!!
You’re what David Attenborough is to nature documentaries to the world of A song of Ice and Fire . Loving these updated videos.
"We are trying to reach you about your car's extended warranty."
I can just hear Rumpelstiltskin "All magic comes at a price, dearie!"
Robert Carlyle did an amazing job with that part! He really made the character come to life. And I loved the costumes he wore! 😍 An all-around great character, one of my all time favorites. ❤
@@mjean6762 He was, by far, my favorite character and actor in that entire show.
Yessssss we love a Rumple moment
Interestingly, GRRM implied in an interview a few years ago that the flames may not have actually spoken. Time and memory have colored things, so spake Martin.
However, I don’t take this to mean that Varys did not hear a voice. Only that trauma and time have made him misremember where it came from. Rather than the flames, I think George is hinting that there was someone else in the room…
If we don’t know who the wizard is, then we certainly can’t guess at who this potential other person is. But the presence of a second, particularly one responding to the ritual, may change the context of the event. Rather than it not mattering who Varys is, maybe it matter a great deal, and he was castrated to ensure the end of his line. Maybe he is a Blackfyre after all?
Interesting observation. Maybe he was after all focussed on seeing his body part burn and didn't properly register who spoke, after all. But yeah too little to build on. It could've been anyone.
Keep in mind that just because it didn’t come from the fire, doesn’t mean it wasn’t “magical” per se.
If the sacrifice was made to summon an entity, that could be what was speaking and answer who the “other” person in the room was.
@@wizardvrse7338 oh I’m sure it was magical. My only idea here is that maybe he was in such a state that he didn’t realize someone had walked into the room, or he has simply forgotten this third-party.
"What did Varys hear in the flames, and why was it Bloodraven?"
"If all events and people and character's past were related". I think the writers of Star Wars should take note of this.
Definitely. New Star Wars feels so small
C3PO is the Forrest Gump of Star Wars.
I immediately thought of Star Wars as well. It feels like that universe has about 5 planets and a few dozen people, mostly related to each other.
BINGO
In Star War's defence, that story in NOT about the whole galaxy, but the struggle between Light and Dark side of force, plus, most of Star Wars is set in the Skywalker Saga, hence why everything is so connected.
And against it, there's Lando appearing in fucking Star Wars Rebels and ehhhhh
Strangely, blue flames are actually hotter than red/orange/yellow flames.
If u burn a fridge u get green flames.
That's not strange. It's common knowledge
That massively depends on the fuel.
What you maybe mean is "the blue part of a flame is hotter than the red part".
Just colouring a flame blue by adding something that burns blue doesn't do a lot to the flames temperature.
@@leichtmeister Thank you! For context everyone, hand sanitizer burns blue, and you can hold it in your hand as it burns.
I wish the video had mentioned… In the show, the Red Priestess asks Varys if he wants to know who the voice was and what it said. D&D then drop it like a hot plate. Was this a “show only” thing, or were D&D glossing over something GRRM told them?
Yes! I was thinking this as I was watching the video. Such a mystery! Love it!
Important thing to note, regarding Varys being a Blackfyre, I recently learned that eunuchs don't go bald - so George is probably trying to subtly draw our attention to the fact that Varys' head is something he purposely shaves. Has he something to hide? If we get to a situation where Varys is unable to shave his head, (if he is imprisoned for example) might we see something he doesn't want us to?
Hair in the books were the first thing people in power woud notice if they want to figure your heritage...then your eyes, body shape and so on...but Hair is the first on the check list. That would explain why Varys shave his head, always is wearing long clothes and almost never look powerful people directly in the eyes alegating that do not want to disrespect looking directly. Varys know how the game for power works...and do not intend to draw too much attention.
Varys uses a lot of disguises. Wouldn't being bald create the largest change when wearing a wig and allow for ease of use? I don't think he's as fat as we are lead to believe too. We've probably seen him in a lot more scenes than we realize.
@@stuartingram8492 Varys also uses glamours. I wouldnt be surprised if what were told is his normal appearance is actually a disguise.
This is tempting to think that he's secretly a distant Targaryen or Blackfyre bastard and was bought because of his hair, making him shave it afterwards, and that blue flames represent the great other, and it's possible I guess, but as you said nor everything will (nor should) be connected to one another. But some things will be. So I guess wait n see on that. Well, that is if we ever have the final books
The whole thing had a Lovecraftian vibe as far as I can tell. So I'm thinking either 'The Great Other', 'The Drowned God' or some other eldritch horror.
I think the point of the scene is to plant the seed that these horrors are real is this universe and one could be serving them unwittingly while believing to server a benevolent power as Stanis seems to be.
R'hlor isn't something I would call "benevolent" considering all the burning of people.
@@inthefade Yes, but despite that Melesandre still believes that he is, is the point.
I was thinking Euron Greyjoy. Don't know if the age and timing works out, how old actually is Varys?
@@toggerz7487 You think Euron was the voice or the sorcerer?
I figured the change in his voice signified that he was using his real voice.
That was always my first understanding... That we were seeing/hearing him be completely candid and vulnerable for the first, perhaps only, time.
I believe that's why the song of ice and fire became an unfinishable project. George has simple too many loose ends to tie up. He simply could not burn and eunuch's manly parts in peace. He had to come up with a mystery for that as well.
His voice changes because he's traumatised. On some level he's gone back there - when he was that terrified boy
Or maybe thats what he wants Tyrion to think? Either way, I do think Varys would be conscious of his tone of voice
Bloodraven speaking via great grand nephew's smoldering junk
Voice in the flames: We've been trying to reach you about your chariot's extended warranty!
In some cases i actually prefer the ambiguity , as it adds to the mystery & intrigue imo. Also makes the universe and arcana feel that much bigger and aspects ineffable. When you have all the answers and a total grasp on all the questions and mysteries to me it makes the universe feel much smaller and tangible. There are certain reveals of course we want and need but others almost best left to speculation , as it drives imagination and future debate. Certain reveals can actually be underwhelming compared to theories and speculation. To me has to be the right balance of necessary reveals along with mysteries / unexplained and imo GRRM strikes that balance very well. The mysteries and ambiguous elements add to the vastness and intrigue.
Per Varys' sorcerer incident , as the vid says it seems to be mostly how it affected and drove Varys from that moment forward more than anything else. As is the case with many other in-universe magical and / or prophetically related events / concepts. Lets say even Varys potentially not fully understanding what happened to him (let alone the reader) could add to the impact even more. And why the sorcerer selected V many of us think he is likely of Valyrian blood , quite likely a Blackfyre even , so that magical and also royal blood could be the reason he was coveted. As the Blackfyres are essentially Targs / with Targ blood , just an illegitimate line originated via two very legitimate & royal Targs.
I like that line of thinking. Not knowing may just be part of the fun, as a magician would tell you perhaps.
If it's got something to do with the whites I'd like to know, otherwise I am okay not knowing. I just keep wanting to see more of the Others
@@divyanshu.26 in this case i'd personally rather keep it mysterious. To me just does not seem directly tied into the biggest magical goings on most influential to the main plot . Its a vast universe with all sorts of different magic , so would be interesting if this is beyond the magic we've already encountered in the narrative. Just shows the vastness and scale of mystery at play in this universe.
@@divyanshu.26 i even think about the Aegon I prophecy reveal , its nice to know of course. But does that reveal really making the Targs more interesting , dynamic or complex ? It actually somewhat turns them into white-knights and justifies the Conquest. I personally enjoyed the speculation in terms of what drove Aegon , was the Conquest fully justified or not ? etc.
Overall GRRM tends to strike the balance of reveals and mysteries quite well. So i'd rather he hold back in certain cases than over-reveal. Even if any of the Lannister siblings are Targs or not (Jaime , Cersei and Tyrion) ; to me its more fun to look for clues in either direction (which of course GRRM gives clues to multiple possibilities) and speculate about it. Rather than simply given a direct answer on that. Ntm not sure there is a definitive in-universe vehicle for clarity regarding a concept like that anyway.
Its been a long time since I read the books and watched the show but didn't Varys have the sorcerer locked up in a box when he told Tyrion this, so Varys must have got the info from the sorcerer? So he must reveal this in the books when or if they ever get released.
The show and the books may, and probably will, end up very different from each other.
Plus, even in the show I don't think it's ever outright said the dude in the box is THE sorcerer. Big V may just be taking out some other practitioner, and not THE guy.
@@abrahamroloff8671 I hope the book ends differently, the show did not end well😃. I had forgotten about the sorcerer a long time ago but now I need to know what happened.😁
"Dany kinda forgot about the iron fleet but they certainly haven't forgotten about her"
Cant believe no one ever thinks it could be something to do with the great other/ white walkers. Blue flames
It said "Shave your head if you're going bald, it looks better"
Maybe Bran talking with Varys in Astral-projection time travel? Maybe there are no gods in this universe, only elemental magic?
Or, It's only a lie. Maybe Varys never hear a voice
The idea that it is a lie makes no sense to me. How would it help Varys? Tyrion needed no more motivation to fight Stannis. If Stannis won, Tyrion dies. His family dies. His power and influence die. Tyrion needs no more motivation to do his best to halt the coming storm.
No, I think it is clear that Varys wasn't lying. I do not think we will ever learn what he heard, or if it even existed: Varys could've been wrong, misled by pain and drugs. But he wasn't lying.
Varys “did not understand”.
But he remembered the words. And eventually of course he would have translated them. So now he does understand what was said, and it is important for Varys’ character and development.
You’re right, that’s totally a Varys thing to say. A truth that tells a lie.
Its really quite synchronistic that I just watched Game of Thrones all the way through in the last month and you are making so many videos about it too at the same time.
“What did Varys hear in the flames? We don’t know “
Glad I watched the video
And I'm glad I read your comment. xD
lmao
I wonder if Pyat Pree might be the sorcerer, or somehow related. After dany burns down the house of the undying, Pyat is found gibbering in some unknown tongue.
(...and jumping from foot to foot. ... maybe a little like Patchface? hrm)
tin foil. but maybe Pyat was a lesser solo sorcerer in traveling through Lys to find kings blood, and his mutilation of Varys connected him with his future serving the house of the undying in Qarth. Maybe he meant to do similar things with dany (using kings blood for magic), but was thwarted.
plus, he pulls a knife when he comes at Dany. - what kind of knife? maybe it was hooked?
omfg dude! this is solid! i like it
This channel endures past the facile fandom, to remind us of the genius of Martin's world building.
Oh, yes, gotta love Martin's colonialist style of world building. lol
@@esmepryde6490 I hear Wakanda will make an appearance in the next installment. Hug that plush toy tight, lady, and wish upon a star.
@@esmepryde6490 And yet you're here on a video about his stories? lmao
@@TheDawntide And yet YOU are here on a video about his stories? Are you talking to yourself? And then laughing at how you imagined you slam-dunked on your comment? Get your head right, silly.
@@Cletus_the_Elder why not? hes "borrowed' from everywhere else
...Maybe the "sorcerer" was a younger Marwyn the Mage using knowledge acquired in Ashai (on his way back, perhaps). Marwyn joins Dany. Varys is with (F)Aegon. At a tense and crucial moment of negotiations between the two camps, Varys spots and recognizes him and loses it. In a rage he loses control and undermines everything he's worked for while Tyrion looks on laughing. Doubtful maybe, but it would be fun.
I think that if it's anyone we know about already, it's 100% Marwyn. I'd still say it's more likely not anyone specially important.
i think the wizard was talking to Marwyn in Assai 🤷🏿♀🤷🏿♀
my theory is that the sorcerer actually was doing something that to us would have seemed very minor, the idea that the magic that turned varys into who he was was actually a rather mundane and minor affair.
Yeah, dude was getting lottery numbers
"But to me, it was Tuesday."
Earlier today I was in the grocery store and I pulled a vine ripened tomato off of its vine.
I thought "root and stem..." and my mind drifted to... "what did Varys hear?"
I came home to this video. Spooky.
Do you often think about mutilated genetalia when you're out shopping?
@@syndrome5372 Doesn't everyone?
I have always had the feeling that situation was tied in with the white walkers and that was what woke them up
I think it may have been some of the most genuine dialogue we’ve had from him. But like everyone, I’m left guessing as to whether that’s true or not.
Vary's manhood = glass candle
= Hot Pie = bowls of brown
Oh Ho THAT IS A SHINY shiny bit of tinfoil! Nice!!
What struck me as interesting is the timing on this. I wonder if the ritual is what woke the night king back up and stared the process of the long night.
Granted we never know for sure what George is planning, but I don't understand how this would make sense ? Like why would a sacrifice with fire magic "activate" some ice magic ?
ok now you're freaking me out. what if Varys is a survived "ice baby"????🤔🤔🤔🤔
@@guillaumeesce8113 For perhaps the same reason as say dragon glass would kill white walkers?
@@Raye938 nah that seems like such a minor and tertiary detail to be the literal inciting action of the entire story. Its never even brought up again at any point.
@@OfficialChrissums So far.
GRRM did say in an interview not to take Varys's story about hearing a voice too literally as it happened a long time ago and Varys might be misremembering things. As too why Varys was castrated, they say there is power in kings’ blood and according to Crusader Chris, Varys might be one of the few remaining Blackfyre's if Illyrio Mopatis's wife Serra was Varys's sister or related somehow. Varys could have been castrated by someone (possibly a certain rogue maester with his own agenda) determined to end the threat posed by the Blackfyre's once and for all. Though why Varys's wasn't just killed outright if he was such a threat remains a mystery.
Is English your first language?
@@Richard_Nickerson Sorry about my typos, I fixed them.
This. GRRM is way more concerned with how we told stories of magic in our own history than actual magic in the traditional fantasy sense.
@@Richard_NickersonThat was quite rude.
@@Knight860I don't think an apology was necessary. That was a rude and inappropriate question.
I had a tinfoil theory that it was the Yellow Emperor out in Carcosa in a RP that I was in once. Focused in the east, in fact the reason there were dragons in the Shadowlands. It was kind of original when we did it but I freely admit it was spurious as hell.
But, yeah. If you need to speak across the world...
A fellow True Detective fan, I see. : )
I wouldn't be surprised if GRRM himself doesn't even know.
People tend to see faces and shapes in clouds and burnt toast. Mishear song lyrics. It is possible that Varys' drugged and terrified mind thought random fire sounds (crackling, hissing) sounded like foreign speach just to make sense of the situation. Maybe a rouge sorcerer wanted a vision in the flames, but it doesn't mean he was important or that it was linked to the overall story. Not every nut job is part of a larger conspiracy. Bad people do bad things without a greater plan to it. The most important takes from that story are how this shaped Varys, his beliefs and attitude, and also why Varys was chosen in the first place and why he was worth a lot of money.
Maybe it was firelord Ozai?
Azula, surely
Lol, I luv this.
❤ Varys
Awesome video as always!
Three IDG videos in a week? Sign me up! (Although, I know the cat's paw was "payback" for last week.)
I love the frozen fire/dragon glass myth
I also wonder will we ever know who is the new Asor Ahai is, or the answer of all the other prophecies. It looks like many of them are happening as told - like the "girl with the serpents in her hair", but also are made to be very ambiguous and different characters interpret them differently. As Melisandre tried to explain, the pictures she sees in the flames are real visions, but their meaning is never clear, as it depends how well you understood/interpreted them. This is a side of the magic and prophesies I really enjoy, as is really close to real life prophesies - like the Delphi Oracle telling the king "A big empire will fall" and him interpreting it as he will win the war, but it was his empire that ended up falling. I have the feeling that many of the prophecies and magic will never be fully explain, but as you said - there is no need for it. The interesting thing is how those things affect peoples lives.
The videos on friday make me very happy!
I'll read the books when they're all finished - I couldn't bare the thought of the only extant ending being the TV adaptation!
Consider it as a high budget fanfic. Then read the books and imagine your own ending. If we get more books that is great but I have a feeling, even if grrm finishes ADOS, he won't answer every question or resolve every storyline.
We are gonna be left with a ton of unanswered questions either way. Therefore, I do hope you try them out! Take your time and enjoy them; you never know, perhaps TWOW will be out by the time you finish them!😊
I am a hopeful fan and I still have faith in winds of winter but there is absolutely no chance that the whole series will ever be finished even if grrm lived to 200
You’ll never read the books then 😂
They'll never be finished and book 5 is right of the rails anyway. Almost as much nonsense as the last series of the show.
Unfortunately at this rate I don't think he will ever finish the series. He's 75 years old
Beautiful video!!!
What I don’t get is that if Varys hates magic so much, why would he be trying to put a someone with valyrian blood (assuming Young Griff is a targaryen/blackfyre) on the throne? valyrians seem intrinsically tied to dragons and magic so you’d think he’d hate them. unless he himself is one
The Dragons have been dead for a long time. I don't think Varys associates them with the sorcerer. We know he gave Aerys the correct advice on whether to let in Tywin, so it seems Aerys wanted that Valyrian descendant to survive as long as possible.
Given how good Varys is at playing different roles, I do not believe that him noticeably changing his voice is something like an „involuntary artifact“ of a prepared story. Either he did believe his story was true, and the change happened due to his emotional state, or he was simply faking that as a signal „now I am telling the truth, please believe me“. Which brings us not one bit further to the truth. And I doubt we will ever know what George really intended.
A scene in episode 5, season 6 merits, Varys - not lying. A red sorceress recounts his exact story, in the throne room of the great pyramid. As I haven't read the books, I don't know if this was a series adaptation or not, but it certainly ties into this video.
I've always felt like Varys is a secret Targaryen, and I think he knows it. It would explain his plots to help Young Griff, as well as Daenerys and Viserys through Illyrio in the first book.
I love your vids so much I’ll give you airtime on a rewatch 😘
Im kinda on team parlor tricks on this one. He was a young child, and a drugged one at that. We dont know that he actually heard anything, and we dont know that the spell actually worked (surely if it had, the sorcerer would want to keep Varys around to sacrifice other bits of him for other spells? He'd already paid a lot for Varys, it seems it'd be a waste to just throw away a potent and expensive magical ingredient) Its possible Varys was chosen because he had some secret kingly heritage, but its just as possible that the sorcerer just mistakenly believed he did. Given that fire magic didnt really work very well at the time, I really think the most likely explanation is that either the spell didnt work, or that Varys simply made the whole thing up.
corn! corn!
No answer is much scarier than any real answer.
Maybe Bran talking with Varys in Astral-projection time travel? Maybe there are no gods in this universe, only elemental magic?
Or, It's only a lie. Maybe Varys never hear a voice.
My interpretation of "A song of ice and fire" before ever reading the books was, that the fire may melt the ice, but it will turn to water and out out the flames. What's the middle ground between ice and fire? Water. The Ironborn, and their Drowned God.
He heard a slight whisper from Frank Reynolds saying "just throw me in the trash"
Probably no larger significance on the story than being the kickstart for Varys' charachter and possibly a hint for him being a Blackfyre. The blue flames just hinting at this being something more than a mere trick.
There's always the possibility that George himself doesn't know the answer.
It makes you wonder if Varys is even a Eunuch at all. How would anyone know he was a Eunuch unless he told them? Or is this perhaps just a well known part of his childhood history?
It certainly seems like it could be a made up story but that begs the question, why would he make this up? It seems unlikely he came up with the story on the spot just for Tyrion, unless perhaps this was from a play he performed in as a child?
Either way this is one of the most interesting mysteries to me, one we will likely never have a definitive answer to.
This becoming a meta commentary on theories and loose plot threads from the theory and loose plot threads guy blew me
11:56 I mean, yeah of course you’re right here. But damn is that a pretty significant seen with big implications for a big unknown factor in the world to be just hand waved away as “ah it’s just backstory for this character and influenced why he acts like he does now, don’t look into it further.” 😅
I wholeheartedly agree. I think it’s just a mystery that explains some of Varys’ character and motivations. And I also think that his voice changes because he was telling the truth.
He heard the sound of Dan and Dave laughing maniacally.
Varys is a Targaryen, ice and fire both burn in the extreme. The Old Targaryens, as the traveled north, discovered they didn’t burn, or freeze burn! The Great Others are of Old Valyeria.
I think royal blood being special is just a misunderstanding of ancient blood magic. Likely relating to Valyrians. E.g. everyone with "Royal blood" that we've seen had their blood used can trace their lineage back to old Valyria in some sense. The Children of the Forrest do something similar but with the blood of the first men.
It's where my mind goes when I'm trying to explain the relevance of the dragons bringing magic back. Since Fire and Blood/World of Ice and Fire we've been speculating that there's some genetic experiment angle to old Valyria. But where would the comet fit into all of this? Is it even real? An illusion by Quaith? Tyrek Lannister? That would be an interesting video.
"It spoke in a language that Varys did not understand..."
- This is our last attempt to reach you about your cars extended warranty.
Varys: "... and since that day, I have hated magic..."
We can also deduce that the being being contacted must be very evil, based on what it takes to get its attention.
I hadn’t thought that Varys made it up. I believe it’s true and agree that it’s more important in the story how Varys reacted than what really happened. I didn’t realize this was Varys convincing Tyrion that he was personally against Stannis due to his use of magic.
My guess would be some sort of spell to communicate with the unalive, given the "offering" perhaps symbolizing some sort of rebirth or something, then the blue flame tied to all the wight magic
Robert, I would love to see you collaborate with Michael talks about things. I’ve recently become acquainted with his catalog and I think his theories are well founded and excellent
What color is the flame around glass candles? Isn't there some type of flame
I think he heard some maester doing the candle test, but was too young to recognize the accent. "Hello?! HEllo is this thing on?! Wait, I can hear something, Hello!!!"
It also made him suspicious of in particular! We shouldn't forget that.
After his conversation with Kinvara, I think he heard Daenerys saying Dracarys
People seem to always attribute the return of dragons as being the cause of magic returning to the world, but I wonder if something else caused magic to return and dragons were a result.
Like perhaps Aeron Greyjoy did something offscreen or the comet was the cause of magic returning, and it initiated the rise of the white walkers, and glass candles started working again, and dragons were born, etc.
Kinvara asked if Varys wanted to know what the voice said in the flames, she was actually just fishing for an answer herself because nobody actually knows
"This is the voice of the Mysterons"
I've always liked the theory that Varys is a Blackfyre because they paid so much for him for kingsblood, and he shaves his head to hide his silver hair. It could explain why he's sympathetic to Faegon in the books.
One of the best and creepiest mysteries that always stays in my mind…
By the way Robert, I've just started reading the "Memory Sorrow and Thorn" books by Tad Williamson, which Martin says were a great influence on him. There are many many things in the first book which are clear bases for Martin's setting and premise, some even seem to hint at things to come or the ancient past of Westeros. Have you thought of looking into MSTh and unpacking these concurrences?
There's something about this that reminds me of The Tower of the Elephant from the stories of Conan but it's been awhile.
Let me refresh my memory and I'll get back to you but most of the mysteries in ASoIaF seem to be of the Hyperborean Age.
I highly doubt the sorcerer was trying to contact someone in the land of the living, simply because potentally royal blood seems like too big a price to waste on a phone call.
I love telling people that. that the prophecies or what happens isn't necessarily the most important part, what matters more is how those events shape the characters that DO survive
Great points being made from 9:45
The ASOIAF world is more realistic BECAUSE we're not given all the answers. There will be plotlines left to be interpreted by the reader. And every reader will have a different perspective.
On that point, if GRRM doesn't finish the books then that's OK. It means we're left wondering and guessing about the futures of these characters, same as we might do in real life for our loved ones.
I’m partial to the theory that Varys is a blackfyre and Serra’s brother. His name sounds Targaryen, as does hers. Why else would he and Illyrio trust each other so completely and be so set on putting Aegon on the throne? Plus how the sorcerer sought him out specifically, paid a huge sum for him, there’s more to him than just an orphan mummer.
As for who was the voice in the flames, I think either the Great Other makes the most sense. Or whatever force is in the heart of winter. It’s really the only blue flame associated thing that was active before the dragons hatched. And the only one not really accessible by travel. The warlocks seem to worship whatever or whoever the heart of winter represents, so maybe that’s who the sorcerer is.
i wonder if Marwyn the Mage was the certain man, specifically due to the word “sorcerer.”
i can think of two possibilities of something being in the fire itself that has certain properties - obsidian or the ebony wood from the trees in Qarth.
obsidian - perhaps he was attempting to craft into a glass candle (or attempting to light one). There may have been no dragons around, but if Varys were a Blackfire & thus had dragon blood…
and perhaps it worked, just for a moment, and the voice was of someone communicating through a glass candle…perhaps without even knowing.
or, much like with the palantir bringing Sauron’s eye to Pippin, maybe the Great Other broke through.
or, rather than obsidian, perhaps the fire was made using one of the black barked trees with the blue leaves that likely are the source of Shade of the Evening, and the voice was merely a hallucinogenic effect.
Varys heard the voice say “i’m calling you about your car’s extended warranty”
Ever since that day he hated magic
I read a theory in a fanfiction that Varys heard the name “Blood Stone Emperor”.
Funk Soul Brother
Calling it now, 3-eyed-Bran will speak in the voice from the flames to Varys.
"What did Varys hear in the flames?"
It was a whisper: "The... final two books... will never... get finished".
I am falling more in the camp of Varys having king's blood, and king's blood being better chance for magic to happen pre-dragons
This is why Martin's horror works so well. He maintains the mystery to it.