How come i never seen this channel before I was looking for a Muslim who speaks in this subjects just to find No other than brother Mohammed hijab to do it Thank you brother 💝💝💝
Asalam u alaykum, I think this is Londoniyyah part 6, Jazakum Allahu Khair and I’ve really been enjoying these sessions, they are unique and very educational and there is definitely nothing like them, keep it up InshaAllah
Kantian ethics has great merits especially in humanising others, in opposition to Machiavelli and pleasure based ethics. However, it lacks stratification or hierarchy of moral values - some crimes are objectively worse than others. Further, it can reduce us to mechanising our daily lives and not taking into consideration the myriad moral grey areas we encounter. We can also ask how Kant decides an action is moral or not. Where would he stand with LGBTQ? This is where we need the Creator of morality itself to tell us what is objectively moral and grounded in reality (discussion leads to Euthyphro Dilemma and moral realism vs idealism). We need consequentialism in deciding certain moral decisions in order not to cause unnecessary harm to ourselves or others. Ultimately, any man made moral system or ideology will have holes in it because it reflects the myopia, biases and limits of the created, in contrast to the abundance of the Creator of all.
I had a question seems you might help me understand. I have hard time understanding deontological ethics. Let's say if there is an active shooter who has taken hostage 100 people and you have a gun. You are in a position to take down the shooter easily. According to deontological ethical philosophy, the action of taking down the shooter is wrong so you may not do it. On the other hand, the action of taking down the shooter may also mean protecting lives of people then it becomes morally right. I just can't understand a concrete example of deontological ethics.
@@WalidsArtChannel that why we use what pleases god as a scale to measure what is moraly right and wrong because those man made ethical theories dont work all the time and confuse alot of people
30:50 I think Hijab missed what the brother was trying to say. Suicide and lying are two points or examples mentioned by Kant as being unethical, in the scenario offered by the brother, hypothetically what is the moral thing to do when the person says that he is going to kill himself, will he commit suicide while keeping his words but then act unethically in killing himself, or would he act contrastingly to his words (id est lying) while not committing this unethical act of killing himself.
I believe Ustaz Human responsed based on the fact that a lie means to speak khilaful waqi' (against reality), in that case a lie would only be in relation to the present or the past not the future. Because his statement "Im GOING to kill myself" is an intention for the future and not a 'khabar' per day hence he's essentially describing his current mental state which isn't really a lie unless we know what he's feeling at that very time. Wallahu a'lam
Having said that I thought the mentioned universalising principal was "don't make false promises" this is very different to lying. So many examples would lose their relevance, wallahu a'lam
Salam at 22:09 could you please clarify the exceptions or delete this bit otherwise islamophobes can cut the clip and insinuate something against what you are promoting.
I have a “trolley problem” that I myself experienced. Imagine Christ needs appendectomy urgently, meanwhile a firearm case arrives in the hospital wherein the lad has shot himself in apparent suicide attempt? With your ethics who’ll you treat first?
This proves islam is men made religion. where in quran you can fine 5 pillar of islam? show me references in quran, my friend The first pillar of Islam is There is no god but God (and) Muhammad is the messenger of God." The Second Pillar of Islam is Salah 5 times/day, The Third Pillar of Islam is Zakāt, or alms giving The Fourth Pillar of Islam is Sawm, or fasting. The final Pillar of Islam is the Hajj, or pilgrimage.
@@TheHeartInTheSpade Gotham/Muhammad do you know how to write and read your name? At 5 years old: I do not know how to write and read. At 7 years old: I do not know how to write and read. At 25 years old: I do not know how to write and read. At 40 years old: I do not know how to write and read. At 64 years old: I do not know how to write and read. Wow that is a miracle of al lah. only 28-6 letters, my friend. The burden is yours. You carry books on your back. Read! Read! Read! your books my Muslim friends. isaiah 29:11 And the entire vision will be to you like the words sealed in a scroll. If it is handed to someone to read, he will say, “I cannot, because it is sealed.” 12 Or if the scroll is handed to one unable to read, he will say, “I cannot read.” 13 Therefore the Lord said: “These people draw near to Me with their mouths and honor Me with their lips, but their hearts are far from Me. Their worship of Me is but rules taught by men. 14 Therefore I will again confound these people with wonder upon wonder. The wisdom of the wise will vanish, and the intelligence of the intelligent will be hidden. if jews said that Al lah is a donkey, solomon had a fly carpet and a magic ring, Al lah created from the sweat of a horse, the punishment of the grave, how your profit moe can verify them out
@@pursueexcellence7737 Checking Muhammad’s mental health in Quran! 1 Funny Quotes from mu ham mad profit of al lah on Satan Muhammad taught some pretty interesting things about satan. Many of them are fanciful. Muhammad said that yawning is from Satan. The Prophet said, “Yawning is from Satan and if anyone of you yawns, he should check his yawning as much as possible, for if anyone of you (during the act of yawning) should say: ‘Ha’, Satan will laugh at him.” Volume 4, Book 54, Number 509: Narrated Abu Huraira:
I love ❤️ mohammed hijab. May Allah make him into an even bigger man mountain and give him the highest place in janaa and be welcomed by our Prophet. 🙏 ameen.
Idk, you complimented kant's philosophy but I think it was pretty weak in terms of not being to able to lie. There's a thousand holes in it. So why did you compliment him, was I missing something.
you keep critiquing by using the word machiavelian - did you listen to the poem by that revert sister Bell (Quran - The Goodly Life) or her revert story which she uploaded a few weeks ago she uses this same argument in both?
This proves islam is men made religion. where in quran you can fine 5 pillar of islam? show me references in quran, my friend The first pillar of Islam is There is no god but God (and) Muhammad is the messenger of God." The Second Pillar of Islam is Salah 5 times/day, The Third Pillar of Islam is Zakāt, or alms giving The Fourth Pillar of Islam is Sawm, or fasting. The final Pillar of Islam is the Hajj, or pilgrimage.
@@ibra1616 remove this verse from your quran and hadith first, my friend The Qur'an calls Christians and Jews "the worst of creatures" (98:6) and commands you to violently subjugate us (9:29). Christians are being mercilessly persecuted in Muslim lands by your brothers and sisters. And you ask why we bother to respond? It's all out of hatred, right? Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying: The last hour would not come unless the Muslims will fight against the Jews and the Muslims would kill them until the Jews would hide themselves behind a stone or a tree and a stone or a tree would say: Muslim, or the servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me; come and kill him; but the tree Gharqad would not say, for it is the tree of the Jews. But you don't see anything hateful in what the Qur'an says about non-Muslims (for instance, when Allah says that he has no love for non-Muslims in 3:32)? And you have no objections to 4:34, 4:24, 5:51, etc.? if you do not agree with me, then you are terrorist, go in peace, my friend from peace nobleist
@@ibra1616 Who are islamophobias according to islam some one who knows more then muslim about islam. some one non muslim who knows al lah is a donkey. Non muslim who knows muhammad is a pedophile, a murder, a thief, a necrophile. a lair, a false profit, a bewitched messenger, a rapist, a cross dresser, pee like a girl, eye line makeuper, etc etc. why do u follow guy like mu ham mad, my friend
@@seeki3315 1st talk like a literate person no muslim is going to hear your message if you are going to talk about their faith in this way they will think that you are a nincompoop and will ignore you
31:00 the proper paradox is "Man said I will kill myself after an hour. Kant came and saw the man. If he says don't kill yourself, he is allowing him to lie. If he says don't lie and commit suicide, he is allowing him to commit suicide which is immoral according to him."
@Mystic Dalton Yes you can say that, but there is a difference. Saying I hate my life so I will commit suicide is not what the man is saying. Though you can argue that the motive is that, but he is generally making a statement.
Hi, can anybody clarify? Since deontology ethics have its limitations, can I use utilitarianism/ consequentialism to resolve such limitations. For eg, the lying scenario. Since I cannot lie under kantian ethics, can I adopt utilitarianism to justify lying to save my husband from being killed? So is it possible to merge the three ethic theories (virtue, consequentialism and kantian deontology) instead of treating them in isolation? Idk if I worded my query correctly but is it possible to view these 3 theories comprehensively?
@@nadiahisa9827 Absolute morality cannot exist without a creator because only a creator would be able to decide what is moral and what is not. Human morality changes by the day👍🏽
@@nadiahisa9827 morals are deontological in nature in Islam. this doesn't mean that lying is absolutely wrong always rather what this means is that lying can be justifiable in some circumstances ie we subscribe to objective moral framework not absolute morality. So, there is a difference between both. BTW I am answering from Islamic perspective.
ofc you can. that’s literally what 95% of the atheists do. a real small number of atheists is either that or that. most of them mix both approaches to cover up the defects that both approaches have. but that’s only to help them in implementation (real life situations). Theoretically those 2 approaches are not compatible and will never be able to mix to 1 superior ethic. bcs they contradict each other but in implementation many people still do it. the problem then is- at the end of the day, they only choose which approach „feels“ right in which situation. so basically the mix of both is worth sh“t. its just an excuse to justify their actions
I think you can use Peter singer's arguments from utilitarianism.he says it's okay to kill a disabled child of you.because that child is a long term pain for you.and if you killed the baby you can give birth to another healthy child.so if you looking to life from a utilitarian consiquentiolist view killing a disabled baby is okay. this is how he reasoning.and it shows the main negative side of consequentialism.
@JeffNippard should listen to this serie. May God give him guidance. I'm listening to this while lifting as recently listened to Jeffs video about morning workout as well, that's why I mentioned him fyi
This proves islam is men made religion. where in quran you can fine 5 pillar of islam? show me references in quran, my friend The first pillar of Islam is There is no god but God (and) Muhammad is the messenger of God." The Second Pillar of Islam is Salah 5 times/day, The Third Pillar of Islam is Zakāt, or alms giving The Fourth Pillar of Islam is Sawm, or fasting. The final Pillar of Islam is the Hajj, or pilgrimage.
How come i never seen this channel before
I was looking for a Muslim who speaks in this subjects just to find No other than brother Mohammed hijab to do it
Thank you brother 💝💝💝
Asalam u alaykum, I think this is Londoniyyah part 6, Jazakum Allahu Khair and I’ve really been enjoying these sessions, they are unique and very educational and there is definitely nothing like them, keep it up InshaAllah
Kantian ethics has great merits especially in humanising others, in opposition to Machiavelli and pleasure based ethics. However, it lacks stratification or hierarchy of moral values - some crimes are objectively worse than others. Further, it can reduce us to mechanising our daily lives and not taking into consideration the myriad moral grey areas we encounter. We can also ask how Kant decides an action is moral or not. Where would he stand with LGBTQ? This is where we need the Creator of morality itself to tell us what is objectively moral and grounded in reality (discussion leads to Euthyphro Dilemma and moral realism vs idealism). We need consequentialism in deciding certain moral decisions in order not to cause unnecessary harm to ourselves or others. Ultimately, any man made moral system or ideology will have holes in it because it reflects the myopia, biases and limits of the created, in contrast to the abundance of the Creator of all.
the Euthyphro Dilemma is a false one
I had a question seems you might help me understand. I have hard time understanding deontological ethics. Let's say if there is an active shooter who has taken hostage 100 people and you have a gun. You are in a position to take down the shooter easily. According to deontological ethical philosophy, the action of taking down the shooter is wrong so you may not do it. On the other hand, the action of taking down the shooter may also mean protecting lives of people then it becomes morally right. I just can't understand a concrete example of deontological ethics.
good point, thanks
@@WalidsArtChannel that why we use what pleases god as a scale to measure what is moraly right and wrong because those man made ethical theories dont work all the time and confuse alot of people
Well said brother❤
This really helps for philosophy a level. Thank you Mr Hijab!
Alhamdullilah. Very educating
Is there a link to be able to access notes/slides on this series? Jazakallah.
Absolutely loving this, thanks
30:50 I think Hijab missed what the brother was trying to say. Suicide and lying are two points or examples mentioned by Kant as being unethical, in the scenario offered by the brother, hypothetically what is the moral thing to do when the person says that he is going to kill himself, will he commit suicide while keeping his words but then act unethically in killing himself, or would he act contrastingly to his words (id est lying) while not committing this unethical act of killing himself.
I believe Ustaz Human responsed based on the fact that a lie means to speak khilaful waqi' (against reality), in that case a lie would only be in relation to the present or the past not the future. Because his statement "Im GOING to kill myself" is an intention for the future and not a 'khabar' per day hence he's essentially describing his current mental state which isn't really a lie unless we know what he's feeling at that very time. Wallahu a'lam
Ustaz Hijab*
Per say*
Having said that I thought the mentioned universalising principal was "don't make false promises" this is very different to lying. So many examples would lose their relevance, wallahu a'lam
Wa'alaikum assalaam wa rehmatu'LLAHI wa barakatuh
Salam at 22:09 could you please clarify the exceptions or delete this bit otherwise islamophobes can cut the clip and insinuate something against what you are promoting.
I have a “trolley problem” that I myself experienced. Imagine Christ needs appendectomy urgently, meanwhile a firearm case arrives in the hospital wherein the lad has shot himself in apparent suicide attempt? With your ethics who’ll you treat first?
Are those slides available??
Pls ..
Please recommend some books for us.
This proves islam is men made religion.
where in quran you can fine 5 pillar of islam?
show me references in quran, my friend
The first pillar of Islam is
There is no god but God (and) Muhammad is the messenger of God."
The Second Pillar of Islam is Salah 5 times/day,
The Third Pillar of Islam is Zakāt, or alms giving
The Fourth Pillar of Islam is Sawm, or fasting.
The final Pillar of Islam is the Hajj, or pilgrimage.
@@seeki3315 bro? XD
@@TheHeartInTheSpade Gotham/Muhammad do you know how to write and read your name?
At 5 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
At 7 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
At 25 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
At 40 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
At 64 years old: I do not know how to write and read.
Wow that is a miracle of al lah.
only 28-6 letters, my friend.
The burden is yours.
You carry books on your back.
Read! Read! Read! your books my Muslim friends.
isaiah 29:11 And the entire vision will be to you like the words sealed in a scroll. If it is handed to someone to read, he will say, “I cannot, because it is sealed.” 12 Or if the scroll is handed to one unable to read, he will say, “I cannot read.”
13 Therefore the Lord said:
“These people draw near to Me with their mouths
and honor Me with their lips,
but their hearts are far from Me.
Their worship of Me is but rules taught by men.
14 Therefore I will again confound these people
with wonder upon wonder.
The wisdom of the wise will vanish,
and the intelligence of the intelligent will be hidden.
if jews said that Al lah is a donkey, solomon had a fly carpet and a magic ring, Al lah created from the sweat of a horse, the punishment of the grave,
how your profit moe can verify them out
@@seeki3315 get a life dude! An 9yo can break your args in secs.
@@pursueexcellence7737 Checking Muhammad’s mental health in Quran!
1 Funny Quotes from mu ham mad profit of al lah on Satan
Muhammad taught some pretty interesting things about satan. Many of them are fanciful.
Muhammad said that yawning is from Satan.
The Prophet said, “Yawning is from Satan and if anyone of you yawns, he should check his yawning as much as possible, for if anyone of you (during the act of yawning) should say: ‘Ha’, Satan will laugh at him.” Volume 4, Book 54, Number 509: Narrated Abu Huraira:
I love ❤️ mohammed hijab. May Allah make him into an even bigger man mountain and give him the highest place in janaa and be welcomed by our Prophet. 🙏 ameen.
masha ALLAH
who wrote the poems?
Subhanallah, and they call Islam and the Muslims extremists.
Love from kashmir (india)
Idk, you complimented kant's philosophy but I think it was pretty weak in terms of not being to able to lie. There's a thousand holes in it. So why did you compliment him, was I missing something.
I need shehada
you keep critiquing by using the word machiavelian - did you listen to the poem by that revert sister Bell (Quran - The Goodly Life) or her revert story which she uploaded a few weeks ago
she uses this same argument in both?
This proves islam is men made religion.
where in quran you can fine 5 pillar of islam?
show me references in quran, my friend
The first pillar of Islam is
There is no god but God (and) Muhammad is the messenger of God."
The Second Pillar of Islam is Salah 5 times/day,
The Third Pillar of Islam is Zakāt, or alms giving
The Fourth Pillar of Islam is Sawm, or fasting.
The final Pillar of Islam is the Hajj, or pilgrimage.
@@ibra1616 remove this verse from your quran and hadith first, my friend
The Qur'an calls Christians and Jews "the worst of creatures" (98:6) and commands you to violently subjugate us (9:29). Christians are being mercilessly persecuted in Muslim lands by your brothers and sisters. And you ask why we bother to respond? It's all out of hatred, right?
Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying:
The last hour would not come unless the Muslims will fight against the Jews and the Muslims would kill them until the Jews would hide themselves behind a stone or a tree and a stone or a tree would say: Muslim, or the servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me; come and kill him; but the tree Gharqad would not say, for it is the tree of the Jews.
But you don't see anything hateful in what the Qur'an says about non-Muslims (for instance, when Allah says that he has no love for non-Muslims in 3:32)? And you have no objections to 4:34, 4:24, 5:51, etc.?
if you do not agree with me, then you are terrorist,
go in peace, my friend
from peace nobleist
@@ibra1616 Who are islamophobias according to islam
some one who knows more then muslim about islam.
some one non muslim who knows al lah is a donkey.
Non muslim who knows muhammad is a pedophile, a murder, a thief, a necrophile. a lair, a false profit, a bewitched messenger, a rapist, a cross dresser, pee like a girl, eye line makeuper, etc etc.
why do u follow guy like mu ham mad, my friend
@@roxanne2749 YES
what is trinity according to a donkey al lah in quran, my friend?
1+1+1=3 and 1+1+1=1; who is a donkey believed these, my friend?
@@seeki3315 1st talk like a literate person no muslim is going to hear your message if you are going to talk about their faith in this way they will think that you are a nincompoop and will ignore you
Ask Bart he knows the Best
I always waiting this type of series and I love this series so much thank you so much to you and your team. May Allaha bless you
31:00 the proper paradox is "Man said I will kill myself after an hour. Kant came and saw the man. If he says don't kill yourself, he is allowing him to lie. If he says don't lie and commit suicide, he is allowing him to commit suicide which is immoral according to him."
@Mystic Dalton Yes you can say that, but there is a difference. Saying I hate my life so I will commit suicide is not what the man is saying. Though you can argue that the motive is that, but he is generally making a statement.
Fake story?
above my head
@@kingsentertainment786 it is not if you really think about it.
Been waiting for this word of wisdom. :D
Keep it up u guys, let me Mohamed hijab know we're super duper benefiting from this series
Hi, can anybody clarify? Since deontology ethics have its limitations, can I use utilitarianism/ consequentialism to resolve such limitations. For eg, the lying scenario. Since I cannot lie under kantian ethics, can I adopt utilitarianism to justify lying to save my husband from being killed? So is it possible to merge the three ethic theories (virtue, consequentialism and kantian deontology) instead of treating them in isolation? Idk if I worded my query correctly but is it possible to view these 3 theories comprehensively?
If it is possible, then could I say that the 3 ethics are successful in constructing moral theories independent of religion?
@@nadiahisa9827 Absolute morality cannot exist without a creator because only a creator would be able to decide what is moral and what is not. Human morality changes by the day👍🏽
@@nadiahisa9827 morals are deontological in nature in Islam. this doesn't mean that lying is absolutely wrong always rather what this means is that lying can be justifiable in some circumstances ie we subscribe to objective moral framework not absolute morality. So, there is a difference between both. BTW I am answering from Islamic perspective.
ofc you can. that’s literally what 95% of the atheists do. a real small number of atheists is either that or that. most of them mix both approaches to cover up the defects that both approaches have. but that’s only to help them in implementation (real life situations). Theoretically those 2 approaches are not compatible and will never be able to mix to 1 superior ethic. bcs they contradict each other but in implementation many people still do it. the problem then is- at the end of the day, they only choose which approach „feels“ right in which situation. so basically the mix of both is worth sh“t. its just an excuse to justify their actions
@@tempoyato2333 really good point bro
Masterclass☝🏽
I Just finished your article about free will. Your conclusion paragraph left me in tears
Very beneficial truly appreciate this series!
Please update the title. And JazakAllah for these uploads.
I think you can use Peter singer's arguments from utilitarianism.he says it's okay to kill a disabled child of you.because that child is a long term pain for you.and if you killed the baby you can give birth to another healthy child.so if you looking to life from a utilitarian consiquentiolist view killing a disabled baby is okay.
this is how he reasoning.and it shows the main negative side of consequentialism.
جزاک الله خيرا
Assalamu alaykum, it's not healthy to drink from plastic bottles, salam.
That's what I've heard but are there any decent studies that actually prove that?👍🏽. I mean it's usually the most convenient😁
@JeffNippard should listen to this serie. May God give him guidance.
I'm listening to this while lifting as recently listened to Jeffs video about morning workout as well, that's why I mentioned him fyi
Wahabi/salafis seething at Hijabs progress lmho
Jazakumullah khayr
Jazakallahu khairan
Do you know how does Mohammed hijab earn his keep? What is his job actually m
Used to be a History teacher but not sure these days
Contradiction is ending their career.
I think this part is part 6, and not 5. Haha
This proves islam is men made religion.
where in quran you can fine 5 pillar of islam?
show me references in quran, my friend
The first pillar of Islam is
There is no god but God (and) Muhammad is the messenger of God."
The Second Pillar of Islam is Salah 5 times/day,
The Third Pillar of Islam is Zakāt, or alms giving
The Fourth Pillar of Islam is Sawm, or fasting.
The final Pillar of Islam is the Hajj, or pilgrimage.
They are there.
Is that a haram painting I see behind him? You should know better, Hijab.
Bro i just checked ur channel, satisfying deaths? What the hell is wrong with you lol
@@somedonny8466I enjoy it.
Where I can find the part 2 of this?