I personally like Rosie a lot and I think she structures a lot of her comedy around either subversion of her disability or the "what is she going to say next" dark humor which suits having to wait on the edge of your seat for her to finish. A lot of people would find her jokes really funny written or if an able bodied person did them, they are just impatient or have some intolerance/discomfort around disability that they haven't had to confront yet. I've had a number of taskmaster contestants that I haven't found that funny personally or I didn't think added a lot to the show but none of them have had this kind of hate, because no one should.
Personally for me, I am too impatient. But that's fine, she's very popular and I don't need to enjoy everyone's comedy. However the crazy people review bombing would not be doing it if she wasn't disabled, I don't get why people just don't watch if they don't want too.
Personally I haven't enjoyed shows with her on before, usually because of how she has to deliver the jokes. A lot of panel shows work on fast paced back and forth. The timing gets lost a lot with her, which is a shame, but can't be helped. Taskmaster on the other hand always has a more casual feel to it, and is edited really well. Absolutely enjoying her addition to the cast, she's great on it.
I had no idea Rosie was getting any kind of hate for being on the show. I have enjoyed this season *so much* because of her. Normally it takes quite a few episodes for me to really acclimate to the cast. The past two seasons (16 & 17) it took until the finale for me to feel warmed up to the cast and so having her there has really brought a fun attitude to the show. I love being able to look forward to the weekly upload on the official channel :D Also, I love that you included the part about what her stand up is like because that's what I enjoy about it as well. I was introduced to Rosie on the big fat quiz gameshow and one day I was curious to watch her on stage. I don't like to admit it, but I did have some discomfort around her disability and I wasn't aware that I did until I watched a few of her sets on youtube. She does a great job at subversion that can hold a mirror up to the intolerance/discomfort and had me reexamine why I was thinking that way.
@@adventureisntfar she gets hate literally every time she appears on TV, so I'm not surprised. It sucks, but there are still marginalized groups that people feel okay about being *openly* bigoted against. I imagine if more of those kinda people had clocked Mae Martin's pronouns and top surgery, they would have review-bombed their season as well.
My girlfriend and I were talking about Rosie yesterday. I love her, she’s hilarious… but I wish they would at least put proper captions when she’s the one reading the rules. Sometimes it’s a little difficult to understand, and the entire task depends on it
I agree, i have a lot of audio issues processing sometimes and I think she's great but I'd love to have captions so I can keep up and TH-cam auto generated ones suckkkk
The official taskmaster channel has subs on it :) I honestly run into this issue with the show in general, never specifically Rosie because sometimes Alex is hard to hear and Greg can speak quicker than I am able to process. Or a contestant just has a thick accent 😅
What a lot of people who claim to love UK panel shows but say they just don’t like Rosie Jones’ humour and therefore claim this series is “bad” don’t realise that they’ve very likely been pissing themselves laughing at her humour for years. Jones is a prolific writer especially for panel shows so if they love Cats does Countdown, WILTY, Mock the Week they’ve probably enjoyed a lot of her jokes. It’s just that many are uncomfortable with having people with disabilities front and centre especially when it is so visible.
Personally I think what she says is funny. As you say, she has done lots of comedy writing for popular shows. Unfortunately I just don't personally think her timing and delivery are very good, but I completely understand that that isn't something she can control. I don't think people should be hating on her any more than any other comedian.
i'm not the biggest fan of rosie's humour but she has unfairly been the target for idiots for a long time here in the UK who don't understand that if you don't like something on TV you can just not watch it and that's okay!
People ARE actually allowed to have an opinion, despite what you may think.... As well as allowed to post a negative review if they do not like something. Get off your high horse.
Yeah, I personally have the comedic sensibilities of a Victorian maiden aunt, so Rosie’s very frank style of humour is a bit much for me, but I know why other people enjoy her work and I can’t deny that she has been brilliant on Taskmaster. People who write her off wholesale have no idea how they are telling on themselves.
Being German your "fear" from the word 'digger' is so funny. Here 'digga' (but some people are weird so it's more like 'digger') is like 'Dude' or 'Bro' in English lol Also, completely unrelated, but Coach if you read this, I want you to know that there's a Girl on the Boise Beach Volleyball Team who's name is Avery Allen and I think that's pretty cool. They also have a 6'1 Goth Mommy.
I am not the biggest fan of Rosie as a comedian, but I am greatly enjoying the new season - them included. Nothing feels pandering and they are thriving in the format.
I have my own issues with Rosie, but it’s not because she’s disabled (I’m also disabled), it’s because she wilfully uses the r-slur despite not having an intellectual disability, despite many people with intellectual disabilities asking her to stop. She says she’s “reclaiming” it, but it’s not hers to reclaim. My uncle was given the r-slur as an official diagnosis (it was the 60s) and faced so much stigma because of it. This is why I don’t like her, not because of any of the drama around Taskmaster. That said, this is a weak series, but across the board. None of the five comedians are particularly shining this time around, though Baba and Andy have had their moments.
But is not on purpose, why hate on someone that's just living and having a career just like everyone else? The internet is so used to everything so fast, so automatic that they can't spare a couple seconds to a joke that is a little bit slow? English speakers can't read a caption? Her delivery is part of her comedy, now.
@@liriolira1772 No comedian is bad on purpose, yet they are constantly judged for how well they can deliver a joke. It's fine that she chose this career despite her massive disadvantage, but that doesn't mean everyone has to pretend it isn't an issue. If a chef born without taste buds decides to open a restaurant that's great, but if the food tastes horrendous I'm not coming back and might even leave a bad review
@Skappy616 She's not bad, that comparison doesn't make sense, people are just impatient. One thing is saying "oh, I didn't find that joke funny" but people attack her, her bit, her landing, but she's brilliant in working not only around, but in her favor.
@@liriolira1772 How you deliver a joke is very important and she obviously has limited options for her delivery. Comedic timing is important, she is very limited in that too. I don't think there is any comedy video on TH-cam that people would enjoy watching if the playback speed was stuck on 25%. I also don't know any comedian who intentionally tells jokes word by word at a quarter the speed thinking it's a great delivery, so I have my doubts that her delivery works in her favor at all
Ngl I clicked on this video and saw you plug a channel and thought, odd it isn’t linked, then clocked this was the nee channel. More stanz is good stanz
Belly buttons are so weird and mine is deep too. I hate it. But it’s a common thing to deal with, so sometimes jokes about that kind of thing, even if they’re a little gross, is funny. I honestly don’t know what “outties” even really means? I don’t think I’ve ever seen someone with an outtie 😭 wtf is that like
I won't lie, I thought I was going to be pretty mid on Rosie. When she was announced, I watched some of her stuff and while it was funny, I found it a little hard to follow at times. Boy, egg on my face was I wrong. She is regularly the reason I laugh the hardest each episode, especially how she plays off of Jack Dee. She is wonderful.
Honestly I was very sceptical of Rosie Jones joining taskmaster ... Because even though she is funny at times in other British shows that solely focus on talking, her jokes tend to take ages to be delivered and usually make the show come to a grinding halt. That being said....She has been hilarious and absurd on taskmaster. For the first few episodes I had to put on subtitles for her, but now I don't need them anymore
I'm not a fan of her comedy. Half of the time she gives a monologue and it doesn't end up with a joke. The British humour can be very cutting with comedians roasting each other and I think the other comedians are really nice to her. I wish they would rip her a bit, and I'm sure we would see a much wittier Rosie when she bites back. I hope my critic isn't derogatory to her.
About to contribute absolutely nothing to the actual conversation being had in the comments but I had an elderly family member stick a letter opener in her ear after she supposedly got a pill stuck in there and the absurdity of it still makes me giggle. Definitely a little biased but Rosie's retelling of a similar story made me laugh, the delivery and tone didn't detract from the comedy for me at least.
i agree, the hate is unjustified but as someone who really appreciates quick wit humour (like lee mack) more than any other brand of comedy, I find her delivery to be not to my taste
you and the rest of the world that doesnt speak english in almost every media we wanna wach, we use subtitles, and she is speaking your language bro, its not that hard
@@hummmnaotemnome2646 I watch TH-cam while I'm studying or working usually cause of time constraints. The time I get where I can spend my undivided attention on entertainment is exceedingly limited and rare. And subtitles by necessity require undivided attention. Respectfully, not for me. I'm just not going to spend that rare and limited resource on TH-cam videos.
I personally don't find her that funny, I think by the time the punchline comes I'm over the joke. However I'm just not going to watch, people review bombing the series is crazy behaviour. If she wasn't disabled people wouldn't be review bombing
In any other context, I’d be worried to comment this but… yes, yes the nipple has changed places and it’s weird every time I see it. I wish it would go back to the way it used to be 😢
I personally like Rosie a lot and I think she structures a lot of her comedy around either subversion of her disability or the "what is she going to say next" dark humor which suits having to wait on the edge of your seat for her to finish. A lot of people would find her jokes really funny written or if an able bodied person did them, they are just impatient or have some intolerance/discomfort around disability that they haven't had to confront yet. I've had a number of taskmaster contestants that I haven't found that funny personally or I didn't think added a lot to the show but none of them have had this kind of hate, because no one should.
Personally for me, I am too impatient. But that's fine, she's very popular and I don't need to enjoy everyone's comedy.
However the crazy people review bombing would not be doing it if she wasn't disabled, I don't get why people just don't watch if they don't want too.
Absolutely this
Personally I haven't enjoyed shows with her on before, usually because of how she has to deliver the jokes. A lot of panel shows work on fast paced back and forth. The timing gets lost a lot with her, which is a shame, but can't be helped.
Taskmaster on the other hand always has a more casual feel to it, and is edited really well. Absolutely enjoying her addition to the cast, she's great on it.
I had no idea Rosie was getting any kind of hate for being on the show. I have enjoyed this season *so much* because of her. Normally it takes quite a few episodes for me to really acclimate to the cast. The past two seasons (16 & 17) it took until the finale for me to feel warmed up to the cast and so having her there has really brought a fun attitude to the show. I love being able to look forward to the weekly upload on the official channel :D
Also, I love that you included the part about what her stand up is like because that's what I enjoy about it as well. I was introduced to Rosie on the big fat quiz gameshow and one day I was curious to watch her on stage. I don't like to admit it, but I did have some discomfort around her disability and I wasn't aware that I did until I watched a few of her sets on youtube. She does a great job at subversion that can hold a mirror up to the intolerance/discomfort and had me reexamine why I was thinking that way.
@@adventureisntfar she gets hate literally every time she appears on TV, so I'm not surprised.
It sucks, but there are still marginalized groups that people feel okay about being *openly* bigoted against.
I imagine if more of those kinda people had clocked Mae Martin's pronouns and top surgery, they would have review-bombed their season as well.
My girlfriend and I were talking about Rosie yesterday. I love her, she’s hilarious… but I wish they would at least put proper captions when she’s the one reading the rules. Sometimes it’s a little difficult to understand, and the entire task depends on it
You can always rewind. Or turn on captions on TH-cam.
I agree, i have a lot of audio issues processing sometimes and I think she's great but I'd love to have captions so I can keep up and TH-cam auto generated ones suckkkk
they fixed the youtube captions after the first episode, they have proper captions not autogenerated ones from day one.
The official taskmaster channel has subs on it :) I honestly run into this issue with the show in general, never specifically Rosie because sometimes Alex is hard to hear and Greg can speak quicker than I am able to process. Or a contestant just has a thick accent 😅
@@somefreshbread captions on TH-cam don’t understand her. That’s the point I’m making.
Ima be real the lunchables follow-up video popped up in my recommended and I didn’t realize until after the video that it wasn’t the main channel
Love that, this is just more stanz so should be same vibes
What a lot of people who claim to love UK panel shows but say they just don’t like Rosie Jones’ humour and therefore claim this series is “bad” don’t realise that they’ve very likely been pissing themselves laughing at her humour for years. Jones is a prolific writer especially for panel shows so if they love Cats does Countdown, WILTY, Mock the Week they’ve probably enjoyed a lot of her jokes. It’s just that many are uncomfortable with having people with disabilities front and centre especially when it is so visible.
Personally I think what she says is funny. As you say, she has done lots of comedy writing for popular shows. Unfortunately I just don't personally think her timing and delivery are very good, but I completely understand that that isn't something she can control. I don't think people should be hating on her any more than any other comedian.
i'm not the biggest fan of rosie's humour but she has unfairly been the target for idiots for a long time here in the UK who don't understand that if you don't like something on TV you can just not watch it and that's okay!
People ARE actually allowed to have an opinion, despite what you may think.... As well as allowed to post a negative review if they do not like something. Get off your high horse.
@ the irony of you responding to an opinion to tell me I shouldn’t have my opinion is not lost on me.
Yeah, I personally have the comedic sensibilities of a Victorian maiden aunt, so Rosie’s very frank style of humour is a bit much for me, but I know why other people enjoy her work and I can’t deny that she has been brilliant on Taskmaster. People who write her off wholesale have no idea how they are telling on themselves.
Being German your "fear" from the word 'digger' is so funny. Here 'digga' (but some people are weird so it's more like 'digger') is like 'Dude' or 'Bro' in English lol
Also, completely unrelated, but Coach if you read this, I want you to know that there's a Girl on the Boise Beach Volleyball Team who's name is Avery Allen and I think that's pretty cool. They also have a 6'1 Goth Mommy.
I am not the biggest fan of Rosie as a comedian, but I am greatly enjoying the new season - them included. Nothing feels pandering and they are thriving in the format.
I love how Rosie is always telling Alex how rediculous he is
I have my own issues with Rosie, but it’s not because she’s disabled (I’m also disabled), it’s because she wilfully uses the r-slur despite not having an intellectual disability, despite many people with intellectual disabilities asking her to stop. She says she’s “reclaiming” it, but it’s not hers to reclaim. My uncle was given the r-slur as an official diagnosis (it was the 60s) and faced so much stigma because of it. This is why I don’t like her, not because of any of the drama around Taskmaster.
That said, this is a weak series, but across the board. None of the five comedians are particularly shining this time around, though Baba and Andy have had their moments.
I think she's funny, but I do understand how people might not like her slow delivery.
But is not on purpose, why hate on someone that's just living and having a career just like everyone else? The internet is so used to everything so fast, so automatic that they can't spare a couple seconds to a joke that is a little bit slow? English speakers can't read a caption? Her delivery is part of her comedy, now.
@@liriolira1772 No comedian is bad on purpose, yet they are constantly judged for how well they can deliver a joke. It's fine that she chose this career despite her massive disadvantage, but that doesn't mean everyone has to pretend it isn't an issue.
If a chef born without taste buds decides to open a restaurant that's great, but if the food tastes horrendous I'm not coming back and might even leave a bad review
@Skappy616 She's not bad, that comparison doesn't make sense, people are just impatient. One thing is saying "oh, I didn't find that joke funny" but people attack her, her bit, her landing, but she's brilliant in working not only around, but in her favor.
@@liriolira1772 How you deliver a joke is very important and she obviously has limited options for her delivery. Comedic timing is important, she is very limited in that too.
I don't think there is any comedy video on TH-cam that people would enjoy watching if the playback speed was stuck on 25%. I also don't know any comedian who intentionally tells jokes word by word at a quarter the speed thinking it's a great delivery, so I have my doubts that her delivery works in her favor at all
@@Skappy616Bad comedians can learn to be better, you can't learn your way out of cerebral palsy
I’ve never particularly liked her comedy before but she’s the best on this series for sure for me
It's annoying to listen to
Most people are annoying to listen to
Tv is for the few that aren't
A button up over an undershirt is a timeless look, I will die on this hill
Ngl I clicked on this video and saw you plug a channel and thought, odd it isn’t linked, then clocked this was the nee channel. More stanz is good stanz
Wtf Stanz why are you coming after me for wearing a T-shirt under my button up. I don't want my coworkers seeing my pale flesh and dark chest hair
Since you started reacting to these I have watched every British, Australian, and NZ taskmaster. It’s our favorite part of the week
6:35 - Had the same reaction as Stanz, that polo is SICK
Once the captions got better on TH-cam, Rosie became better but she's not my cup of tea.
using the edgeworth investigations theme is a goated choice by staniel
Belly buttons are so weird and mine is deep too. I hate it. But it’s a common thing to deal with, so sometimes jokes about that kind of thing, even if they’re a little gross, is funny.
I honestly don’t know what “outties” even really means? I don’t think I’ve ever seen someone with an outtie 😭 wtf is that like
I won't lie, I thought I was going to be pretty mid on Rosie. When she was announced, I watched some of her stuff and while it was funny, I found it a little hard to follow at times. Boy, egg on my face was I wrong. She is regularly the reason I laugh the hardest each episode, especially how she plays off of Jack Dee. She is wonderful.
We're already almost at 10k subs. We're so close to the goon cave reveal, I can almost smell it
Honestly I was very sceptical of Rosie Jones joining taskmaster ... Because even though she is funny at times in other British shows that solely focus on talking, her jokes tend to take ages to be delivered and usually make the show come to a grinding halt.
That being said....She has been hilarious and absurd on taskmaster. For the first few episodes I had to put on subtitles for her, but now I don't need them anymore
I'm not a fan of her comedy. Half of the time she gives a monologue and it doesn't end up with a joke. The British humour can be very cutting with comedians roasting each other and I think the other comedians are really nice to her. I wish they would rip her a bit, and I'm sure we would see a much wittier Rosie when she bites back. I hope my critic isn't derogatory to her.
About to contribute absolutely nothing to the actual conversation being had in the comments but I had an elderly family member stick a letter opener in her ear after she supposedly got a pill stuck in there and the absurdity of it still makes me giggle. Definitely a little biased but Rosie's retelling of a similar story made me laugh, the delivery and tone didn't detract from the comedy for me at least.
i just cant handle rosies comedy delivery
To be honest, the hate is obviously uncalled for, but it does kinda ruin the flow of the show and I dont find her that funny.
i agree, the hate is unjustified but as someone who really appreciates quick wit humour (like lee mack) more than any other brand of comedy, I find her delivery to be not to my taste
Feels weird to say the hates uncalled for and then agree with the hate lol
The subtitles werent released on 1st episode. Funny af when I can see the dark humor
@@Only_Stanzimagine not understanding the difference between hate and criticism 💀
@@Only_StanzHe's obviously talking about the series being review bombed. Not about people disliking her comedy in general, which is a fine take.
Dude the shirt is hella sick
I miss the days of stanz taskmaster and video games :(
It took me a bit to understand her, between the British accent and cerebral palsy. But she is great, so funny
10:12 hold on pause
Took me way too long to realize this wasn't just the main channel
Babbabooey, just commenting and liking to help this vid in the algo.
I don't think she's funny, I coulda done without her, but a lot has to happen before I stop watching Taskmaster. That show is genius.
4:12 Stanz is a confirmed goon on the inside
i love me some more stanz
I can't understand her without subtitles ill be honest. Im not hating but I'm not watching the new season cause its kinda a pain.
you and the rest of the world that doesnt speak english in almost every media we wanna wach, we use subtitles, and she is speaking your language bro, its not that hard
@@hummmnaotemnome2646it is objectively hard to understand her.
@@hummmnaotemnome2646 I watch TH-cam while I'm studying or working usually cause of time constraints. The time I get where I can spend my undivided attention on entertainment is exceedingly limited and rare. And subtitles by necessity require undivided attention. Respectfully, not for me. I'm just not going to spend that rare and limited resource on TH-cam videos.
I personally don't find her that funny, I think by the time the punchline comes I'm over the joke. However I'm just not going to watch, people review bombing the series is crazy behaviour. If she wasn't disabled people wouldn't be review bombing
@@Skellevision32 100% agree. It's still a great show. It's insane to review bomb it over something so petty and minor.
so blessed i got recommended this channel, love all of the stanz content
I adore Rosie so much
In any other context, I’d be worried to comment this but… yes, yes the nipple has changed places and it’s weird every time I see it. I wish it would go back to the way it used to be 😢
waiting for the belly button reveal
I always love when Rosie is on a show because I know I’m definitely going to laugh that episode.
Stanziel
Crazy I didn't know this was a side channel
They probably got reviewed bombed cause they remembered its a British show.
Excuse me, since when were there a second channel? MORE STANZ
Stanzy fans
Was about to go sub to only stanz but im already there.
Oh hello.
Nice comment ❤
LETS GO MORE STANZ
Lemme hit that sub button, thank me later hahaaha 😏
The hate is uncalled for and people who are mad at her being on the show suck
Bad take.
People wanting that Rosie do not have dissability because is inconvenient for them are absolutely idiots.
I can understand people not finding her funny but the people giving her hate are just ableist douches.