I’m also listening to this in 2023, good songs last forever ❤ I’m sorry about your friend, it’s sad when friendships end (I can’t write in chinese yet, sorry for answering in english)
I know I'm 2 years late but just in case any English speaker happens to find this video I'll just throw a little explanation for the song here. Disclaimer: I'm not the biggest history buff, but I'm gonna try my best. The main characters are Fu Jian 苻坚 (older guy) and Murong Chong 慕容沖 (younger guy), both historical figures. Fu Jian (317-355) was the emperor who founded Former Qin state of the Sixteen Kingdoms, which was a turbulent period in Chinese history where Northern China was fractured into states. The current monastic dynasty (Jin) fell into chaos, everyone fighting each other. History, basically. So this guy was born into the kingdom of Han Zhao but then broke away from the kingdom and formed his own nation, Former Qin. He also took over several other neighboring states, including Former Yan of the Murong family in 370, in order to unite northern China. After Former Yan was destroyed, several Murong clan members were appointed officials in the new government. Murong Chong (~359-386) was one of them. He was very beautiful, and Fu Jian took an interest in both him and his sister (reminder that they were both teens. big yikes). He favoured both of them dearly, marrying the sister and having a sexual relationship with the brother. Rumours around the capital city Chang'an had it that Fu Jian had brought "two phoenixes" into his palace. Of course Murong Chong was humiliated by all this. He was a prince that had been reduced to a plaything for the enemy of his clan and entire kingdom, so naturally he got a position in another province and ran away from the palace. After hearing that his uncle and brother were leading separate rebellions against Fu Jian, he decided to join them. Murong Chong then took the title of crown prince of Western Yan, a state founded by his brother. Fu Jian sent him a robe and a message reminding him of their past relationship in order to make peace, but he wouldn't have it. He later became emperor and seizing Chang'an, causing a terrible famine in the city, while Fu Jian had to move away. More war happened and Fu Jian was killed. The title of the song can be translated to "Dwelling Phoenix", with Phoenix being Murong Chong's nickname. The item shown at the end is a whip that I read was mentioned in a remark by Fu Jian, but somehow Murong Chong's holding it in the MV? Was it an actual thing? Don't know about this one tbh. So yeah, a messed up and tragic story. But it seemed Wangchuan had put a more... romantic and melancholic spin on it.
我冲过来吹爆老大！！！！（小声：那几个差评的怕不是把差评键看成了dis i like.... 因为老大唱歌超好听啊） AAAAAAA Marblue!!!!! (did the people who disliked accidentally read it as dis i like....? because this is awsome.)
三无的声音真的很耐听 越听越入味 有种感情充斥在里面
一开始其实我作为路人是无感的
后来听了夜樱后真的迷上了
被圈粉不是瞬间 是个过程 而我很享受这个过程
现在我终于可以说 三无是我最喜欢的翻唱歌手
没有之一
以后也不会轻易改变
+1我和你一摸一样
我是听三畿道。。听着听着看到她提到三无老大，本来还听不惯但是不懂怎么慢慢的，越听就循环了😂😂
三无有毒！
我是听到寄月明
@@lessname145 寄明月
我是偶然聽《十二鎮魂歌》就被下毒了。
2023還在聽🥺
被曾經的好朋友推薦，結果被對方封鎖。但現在還是很愛這首😢
I’m also listening to this in 2023, good songs last forever ❤ I’m sorry about your friend, it’s sad when friendships end
(I can’t write in chinese yet, sorry for answering in english)
首先表三無!最喜歡三無的翻唱，超有感覺!
然後看了評論區，倒也不必可憐慕容沖罵苻堅，晉書上寫"堅又幸之"不是強迫的字眼，給他描述是"沖毒暴關中，人皆流散，道路斷絕，千里無煙"他們都是有能力野心的人，不需要憐憫，更何況撇開他們的糾葛，苻堅算是魏晉時期非常優秀的君主，因為這件小插曲就被打成壞人大可不必，頂多是有損私德。
還有其他人想不想幫他們湊cp礙不著你，你既不是苻堅又不是慕容沖，就你知道他們的感情?房玄齡都沒寫的內容你們倒是一個比一個清楚呢，慕容沖給你托的夢?愛嗑cp就嗑、不愛吃這對就不嗑，按頭強迫站隊的都是有病:)
我不討厭苻堅也不討厭慕容沖，創作裡我只看臉。但我清楚苻堅收小男孩當男寵是事實，慕容沖屠城也是事實，不洗白不抹黑。
贊同
@芷喬 ？？？
@芷喬 就只是想表示 你說的那句意思是什麼 或是你回覆的是樓主只是貼錯人名
@芷喬 畢竟當時睡矇了 剛醒就看到你的評 把我整的更矇了🤣
矇嘞矇嘞，這貼文到底是褒是貶?
開始是說歌好聽，再來又把歌詞罵了一遍
但最後又不洗白不抹黑.....
原本對三無沒甚麼感覺
結果聽了她唱的忘川系列後，瞬間路轉粉！唱得太有韻味了！
一年多了 每次聽都還是會被前奏的笛聲帥到
你又来了哈哈 支持你！
I know I'm 2 years late but just in case any English speaker happens to find this video I'll just throw a little explanation for the song here. Disclaimer: I'm not the biggest history buff, but I'm gonna try my best.
The main characters are Fu Jian 苻坚 (older guy) and Murong Chong 慕容沖 (younger guy), both historical figures. Fu Jian (317-355) was the emperor who founded Former Qin state of the Sixteen Kingdoms, which was a turbulent period in Chinese history where Northern China was fractured into states. The current monastic dynasty (Jin) fell into chaos, everyone fighting each other. History, basically.
So this guy was born into the kingdom of Han Zhao but then broke away from the kingdom and formed his own nation, Former Qin. He also took over several other neighboring states, including Former Yan of the Murong family in 370, in order to unite northern China.
After Former Yan was destroyed, several Murong clan members were appointed officials in the new government. Murong Chong (~359-386) was one of them. He was very beautiful, and Fu Jian took an interest in both him and his sister (reminder that they were both teens. big yikes). He favoured both of them dearly, marrying the sister and having a sexual relationship with the brother. Rumours around the capital city Chang'an had it that Fu Jian had brought "two phoenixes" into his palace.
Of course Murong Chong was humiliated by all this. He was a prince that had been reduced to a plaything for the enemy of his clan and entire kingdom, so naturally he got a position in another province and ran away from the palace. After hearing that his uncle and brother were leading separate rebellions against Fu Jian, he decided to join them.
Murong Chong then took the title of crown prince of Western Yan, a state founded by his brother. Fu Jian sent him a robe and a message reminding him of their past relationship in order to make peace, but he wouldn't have it. He later became emperor and seizing Chang'an, causing a terrible famine in the city, while Fu Jian had to move away. More war happened and Fu Jian was killed.
The title of the song can be translated to "Dwelling Phoenix", with Phoenix being Murong Chong's nickname. The item shown at the end is a whip that I read was mentioned in a remark by Fu Jian, but somehow Murong Chong's holding it in the MV? Was it an actual thing? Don't know about this one tbh.
So yeah, a messed up and tragic story. But it seemed Wangchuan had put a more... romantic and melancholic spin on it.
wow...
This is in time because i actually have finals about this in like 5mins and I did not study at all so thanks❤️
there is a typo, fu jian 337-385
苻坚 not 苻健, 苻健 is the founder of former qin, 苻坚 is the 3rd emperor who had the relationship with Murongs
@@ashi6742 the song isn't true histroy, Murong Chong was very cruel, and betrayed Fu Jian, and Fu Jian is the more handsome one.
清辉映着深堂 风月入酒一觞
有人已经与我饮畅
却还要我当 纵马白衣少年郎
残棋停在掌上 死局欲盖弥彰
有人故作眉眼疏狂
与我交过手 与我留过伤
却想求个美满收场
谯鼓响 烽烟茫茫
剑影刀光 阴谋阳谋 影影幢幢
这生死场上 有谁真愿谁 无恙
兴许 青竹早凋
碧梧已僵 人事本难防
只在 旧时旧日 大梦了一场
从此 天各一方 各自怀想
不如两相忘
非黄泉路上
此生王不见王
一夜长安冷雨 几声马蹄彷徨
烽火长燃撞破天光
只拂一拂袖 挥别了当年模样
千里江山入眼 谁不志在四方
行到水穷不曾回望
吟鞭断流水
也能断情长
前尘往事何必思量
纵然是 斯人已去
天地纵广 转眼又成几家沙场
夜半听楼角 纵马迎天光 凄怆
兴许 青竹早凋
碧梧已僵 人事本难防
只在旧时旧日大梦了一场
从此天各一方各自怀想
不如两相忘
非黄泉路上 此生王不见王
贪痴疏狂 暗自滋长 变了当年模样
相视一望 近乎咫尺 远在山岗
语息温凉 吞吐如霜
化在你眉睫上
生死一念算过场
冷不防
三千铁衣披霜 万籁绝响
举目是残阳
回首 剑拔弩张 箭已在弦上
耳畔 江海有声 山河无量
呼万寿无疆
却无人共看
这人间多荒唐
却无人共看这人间多荒唐
謝謝❤
慕容沖怎麼可能愛他呢
只有恨了吧
我发现不管是什么歌，只要是三无唱的就是好听（今年七月才入的坑
三無的歌都很好聽
動畫越來越精緻了耶，至於歌聲從以前就很好聽了~
建議把cp濾鏡拔掉再來聽這首歌
前奏就跪了，歌聲情感更是一絕
歐吼 tk大大
tk大大！！
大師球tk!
野生tk!!
“此生王不見王。”這句最好。
我倒是喜歡(“卻無人共看這人間多荒唐
同
被這句洗腦(聽一次就入腦中
慘烈前生，悽慘轉世，悲慘不堪，今生走完，何方去向。
@@yingluo5900 同
慕容沖，西燕國主
符堅，前秦天王
歷史上他們是真有一腿，後來也真的是王不見王……這歌詞真神
慕容冲就一被推上去的傀儡，一会就被手下乱兵剁了，和符坚并列王不见王那真是侮辱了符坚😅
符坚哪怕落魄的时候，他儿子被慕容冲大败他都气得大骂说被这白毛小儿打败，然后逼他儿子自杀。
慕容冲从来就是个男宠水平，符坚压根没瞧得起他过
很棒的組合！ 🥳 感謝您再次收錄我們的歌曲♥
古風入坑的前幾曲 真的好愛 三無的詮釋好讚
三無的聲音，很輕柔。
聽著聽著會很好睡。
三无唱的真心好听
被歌燒到，特別跑去維基了解這段恩怨情仇。
「此生王不見王」聽起來像是雙王鼎立，但其實他們都沒活多久XD” 在慕容沖攻入長安的兩年內，苻堅和慕容沖就都分別死在不同人手中。
在那個充滿戰亂的時期，今日稱王，可能明天就被殺了。慕容沖（鮮卑族）在384年圍攻長安，苻堅（氐族）被困在長安，要不投降要不餓死，走投無路的他在 385年西逃，結果被另一勢力姚萇（羌族）逮到殺死。
而慕容沖則是在苻堅西逃後入據長安稱帝，但在隔年 386年被他的部下韓延殺死。
等好久了！就是這首！老大賽高～
我要表白這個繪師!!!!
強力大力表白 這這這圖實在太香了
給你一千萬個擁抱加愛心
我已經忘記我何時入坑的了，只記得迷上三無之后，當我要播放歌單時，就只剩忘川風華錄這個選擇了......
好喜歡忘川風華錄系列!!!!三無大大翻唱的好好聽!!!!!!!!!!美哭QAQ
三無♡好聽💕 只要有你的歌我就會聽 哈哈哈真的好聽 大愛💕
三无就这首歌来说翻唱是最好听的。哦漏的也不错，蛀牙有段惊艳点。其他的都蛮普通的。
聽到我起雞皮疙瘩啊！
超級好聽😍
表白!!好好聽啊啊!!!感動...
神曲，毒愛老大唱的古風
真的好好聽唷!愛了愛了~~~😍😍😍😍😍
忘川系列最神的一首，2023還在循環😢
我就知道三月月不會缺席！
希望老大的感冒能快點好！
被三無大大超渡成功，上班有好歌聽好開心
抓到一個阿貝(咦
@@user-eu8xz5td7r 你是誰www
我冲过来吹爆老大！！！！（小声：那几个差评的怕不是把差评键看成了dis i like.... 因为老大唱歌超好听啊）
AAAAAAA Marblue!!!!! (did the people who disliked accidentally read it as dis i like....? because this is awsome.)
超級好聽~~😁
Qīng huīyìngzhe shēn táng, fēngyuè rù jiǔ yī shāng
yǒurén yǐjīng yǔ wǒ yǐn chàng
què hái yào wǒ dāng, zòng mǎ báiyī shàonián láng
cánqí tíng zài zhǎngshàng, sǐ jú yùgàimízhāng
yǒurén gù zuò méiyǎn shūkuáng
yǔ wǒ jiāo guòshǒu, yǔ wǒ liúguò shāng
què xiǎng qiú gè měimǎn shōuchǎng
qiáo gǔ xiǎng, fēngyān mángmáng
jiàn yǐng dāo guāng, yīnmóu yáng móu, yǐng yǐng chuángchuáng
zhè shēngsǐ chǎng shàng, yǒu shéi zhēn yuàn shéi, wúyàng
xīngxǔ, qīngzhú zǎo diāo
bì wú yǐ jiāng, rénshì běn nán fáng
zhǐ zài, jiùshí jiù rì, dà mèngle yī chǎng
cóngcǐ, tiāngèyīfāng, gèzì huáixiǎng
bùrú liǎng xiāng wàng
fēi huángquánlù shàng
cǐshēng wáng
bùjiàn wáng
yīyè cháng'ān lěng yǔ, jǐ shēng mǎtí fǎnghuáng
fēnghuǒ cháng rán zhuàng pò tiānguāng
zhǐ fú yī fúxiù, huī bié liǎo dàng nián múyàng
qiānlǐ jiāngshān rùyǎn, shéi bù zhì zài sìfāng
xíng dào shuǐ qióng bùcéng huí wàng
yín biān duàn liúshuǐ
yě néng duàn qíng cháng
qiánchén wǎngshì hébì sīliang
zòngrán shì, sī rén yǐ qù
tiāndì zòng guǎng, zhuǎnyǎn yòu chéng jǐ jiā shāchǎng
yèbàn tīng lóu jiǎo, zòng mǎ yíng tiānguāng, qīchuàng
xīngxǔ, qīngzhú zǎo diāo
bì wú yǐ jiāng, rénshì běn nán fáng
zhǐ zài, jiùshí jiù rì, dà mèngle yī chǎng
cóngcǐ, tiāngèyīfāng, gèzì huáixiǎng
bùrú liǎng xiāng wàng
fēi huángquánlù shàng
cǐshēng wáng
bùjiàn wáng
tān chī shūkuáng, ànzì zīzhǎng, biàn liǎo dàng nián múyàng
xiāng shì yīwàng, jìnhū zhǐchǐ, yuǎn zài shān gǎng
yǔ xī wēn liáng/tūntǔ rú shuāng
huà zài nǐ méijié shàng
shēngsǐ yīniàn suàn guòchǎng
lěngbùfáng
sānqiān
tiě yī pī shuāng
wànlài juéxiǎng
jǔmù shì cányáng
huíshǒu, jiànbánǔzhāng, jiàn yǐ zài xián shàng
ěr pàn, jiānghǎi yǒushēng
shānhé wúliàng, hū wànshòuwújiāng
què wú rén gòng kàn
zhè rénjiān duō huāngtáng
què wú rén gòng kàn
zhè rénjiān duō huāngtáng
聽了三四個版本，還是三無的最讚!!
我第一次听 疯狂爱上就三無❤
三無的歌聽起來都超感動
凰啊......慕容沖的人生真的很悲劇呢(｡•́︿•̀｡)（剛剛看了下面有人放上的歌曲裡的人物對照~
我特地去查了整段历史
@@yingluo5900 同上
然而其实冲哥自己也是个典中典人
非黄泉路上，此生王不见王，这个很好！
三無大大真的很猛不管唱哪一首都好好聽
三無姐姐常古風的個異常好聽
讚讚 三無大哥好厲害 美聲
這PV 這歌聲 美炸了♥
我來了三無
新人降臨
忘川集里最喜欢的一首歌😭😭😭
這首歌有點像在影射兩岸……
（以中原王朝的角度來說）
😢
「譙鼓響 烽煙茫茫
劍影刀光 陰謀陽謀 影影幢幢
這生死場上 有誰真願誰 無恙
興許 青竹早凋
碧梧已僵 人事本難防
只在 舊時舊日 大夢了一場
從此 天各一方
各自懷想 不如兩相忘
非黃泉路上 此生王不見王」
撼動人心
超級好聽！
這首真好聽😯
剛好醒腦~~
很好听！未听先赞！
迎天光起床!!!
是tk大大！
好聽好聽
超讚
一早就能聽到三無大大的聲音
(///∇///)
因為這首 入了忘川風華錄的坑啊~~
好好聽QAQ三無大神請收下我的膝蓋QAQ
完了，中毒太深，我把两个男的看成了一对😂😂
我也是
就应该是一对吧？这不是慕容冲和苻坚吗？
原本就是bl，
@@user-ob9hl2fi3u 哦，我懂了
腐女腐男的本性:不需多講，一看就知😂
好聽
太好听了！
三無啊啊啊啊啊啊❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
非黃泉路上 此生王不見王
這句.....
我只能重複聽好幾遍以表激情(誤誤誤誤誤!!!!(大誤!!!
“鳳凰何不高飛還故鄉 無故在此取滅亡”
有老大的地方就有我(*๓´╰╯`๓)♡
三无从来不让我失望啊
眼熟眼熟
我爱三无啊啊😭😭😭
1.25也不錯
最喜欢老大的声音了(>V
夜半聽樓角，縱馬迎天光，起～床～～～～
好听
從爆哥那邊知道這首歌的很讚
哇好好听😭😭😭
哇啊啊啊啊
他俩最后不止分出了胜负，也还把当年的他们葬在了旧时光……唉……卦不敢算尽，畏天道无常。谁能料定结局呢？
老大賽高
Seems interesting, is there any movie or anime or whatever about the real story ?
啊啊啊等到三月月！
[斷流鞭]“棲凰”
苻堅x慕容沖
我將授斷鞭流席卷
天下的雄心交到你
手中
你此一生
注定無法擺脫我的
影子
慶幸自己先來聽三無女神的WWW因為後來去聽了初版，感覺...缺了一點點的狂氣?但是還是期待忘川風華錄以後的發展ouo
Yeah抢到沙发！
總而言之先扔個讚
水一下~
嗷嗷嗷嗷嗷嗷頭香！！！！（轉圈撒花）
可可可可惡他頭香(踩他的花)
This is my goddess!
苻堅和慕容沖，講真的😅就是渣攻毒受吧⋯⋯
是的，简直互相伤害🤣
重了鳳名，獨留凰心！悲笑過往情
這動畫... (跪
女聲竟然比男聲還要MAN 真是不可思議...
三无是女的？我一直覺得是男的⋯
@@atlantis2470 三無大大是女的呦～聲音比較攻
@@atlantis2470 你是周深的歌听多了
@@ximesange5500 深深聲音真的很好聽啊
@@LinLin-vz7yc 一直都在觉得星儿是攻，可这时候。。。咳咳
❤️
早就在追了，可是今天居然发现还没订阅。。。尴尬😅
能在此求到這首歌的笛子譜嗎?跪求各位大神們了!!
我聽哭了 Q^Q
去查了历史的我，受也很有毒😂这cp绝了
♡
表白老大
誰跟我一樣剛聽節奏就收藏的呢OwO~~
+1
+1
符堅想不到自己千多年後還有一劫😂
呜呜呜呜吹爆