Devdutt Pattanaik decodes the Hanuman Chalisa and leadership approaches of Indira, Shiva and Vishnu
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 พ.ย. 2024
- Devdutt Pattanaik discusses mythology, karma and his books “My Hanuman Chalisa” and “My Gita” with Shoma Chaudhury at Algebra, The Arts & Ideas Club, Gurgaon on 28-August 2017.
According to Devdutt Pattanaik, Ram is not a leader because he is not leading anyone anywhere. He also believes that the key characteristics of the Hanuman Chalisa are strength and wisdom, which is what drives the iconography of Hanuman.
Pattanaik also feels that one cannot understand mythology without knowing physics and biology.
Devdutt Pattanaik is a writer and a revisionist of mythology in India. He constantly brings home how the Indian tradition is different from the West and the need for Indians to study their scriptures from their own perspective. He has authored numerous books including “My Hanuman Chalisa”, “My Gita”, and “Business Sutra: An Indian Approach to Management”. He is also known to incorporate myth into human resource management.
Subscribe To "Algebra Club" Channel HERE: goo.gl/Y9TB76
For more content from "Algebra Club", click HERE: goo.gl/24X5NH
Like "Algebra Club" on Facebook HERE: goo.gl/B66ZA6
Follow "Algebra Club" on Twitter HERE: goo.gl/JWLpTj
---
Algebra takes the idea of a club - a universe of the likeminded - and expands it to new paradigms. The key idea behind Algebra is to bring together a fellowship of people who believe great cities are built not just on infrastructure but a life of the mind; who understand robust and liberal societies need the oxygen of great conversation and nuanced thinking. At a time when we are increasingly surrounded by rage and noise, Algebra is that unique live and continuous space where people could go for a genuine exchange of ideas and exposure to issues; where new seeds could be sparked, fresh perspectives formed, and intelligent connections made.
Algebra - the Arts and Ideas Club is designed to host over 60 conversations over the year with topline thinkers and practitioners from almost every discipline that impacts human affairs: politics, economy, environment, spirituality, cinema, medicine, science, technology, music, media, literature, the arts, sports, people’s movements, et al. In a line, Algebra is a space where one can meet an exciting, cutting-edge spectrum of people shaping the world in different ways. Where one can test one’s ideas, challenge one’s perspectives, and build friendships. A sort of fellowship of the curious and engaged.
Membership to Algebra is by invitation or referral. If you know an Algebra member, ask them to put you in touch with us. For more, click HERE: www.algebrathec...
![[LIVE] นาทีนี้ต้องพี่ทนาย | ทนายแก้ว vs ทนายไพศาล | #คุยให้เด็กมันฟัง EP.47 (02/11/67)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HmquaO-PL_M/mqdefault.jpg)
Whenever I see the anchor.
I can just simply visualize how Shurpankha must have looked in Ramayana.
Right
hahaha great shot bro you make me laugh like my stomach is paining now
Actually the word ""surpanakha"" means stylish beautiful nails,she's not ugly looking evil woman as shown in TV magazine etc
@@mridulagrawal6687 hahahaha new joke by media. surpanakha means stylish.
@@digitalmarketingpretoria surpanakha means stylish nails,nakha in sanskrit means nails,surpa has 2 meanings,beautiful and stylish,read a sanskrit dictionary, then talk,r just read valmiki ramayan,it's mentioned specifically in it,not Tulsidas ramayan
Devdutt Patnayak has given new dimension to our scriptures and worth to hear and understand our scriptures deeply .
Exactly.
hahahahahahaha these indian anchors who think their english intellectt and diction is superb...when they come tot west...they are ridiculed and joked at about their intellect....whereas an inteeligent hindu with his or her strong indian dialect is revered in US, Uk, Australia etc .....jai ho bharat ke putra
why don't they speak hindi or sanskrit............that is to demeaning to them
These anchors should also discuss and debate other religions and their problems.
hahahah you are true bro still English so called intellectual people don't know actually what is Hinduism even they research for years of years. But yes bro thats true they still our newclear weapon's concept from our scripture, also lots of science concept they still from our scripture. like plastic surgery, astronomy, maths, lots of concept they solved. forget about this dumb ass devmuthh he is nothing but english intellectual i say they really smart they are minority but with mind game they ruled on 200 countries and still they dominating on us with only mind game. We are really a stupid people. Our own people are always get corrupted like this devmuthh is corrupted by british in old time when british came to india first they corrupted one of the king and then they devided one by one other kinds and ruled on us for decads. same way now they corrupting this kinds of ass to change narrative of new generations of india. like the same they did in africa i am in south africa if you come and check here the local people don't even have any idea what is their own history. white people in south africa they claiming that south african land belong to british people bcoz first dutch came to south africa and they start civilization in south africa and then black came to south africa. thats the narrative they created here. and there is 11 tribe here in south africa but everyone don't trust on each other and they fight with each other and white british people is dominating on this all tribes still
Rightly said.
wow well spoken sir🙏🏽
Like every Indian Journo, even Shoma is jelous of Arnab. I don't understand why people compare themselves to someone else always?
I am very glad to mention, now-a-days even Shoma does not want to become that person who screams and spreads hate...
She says " this is going to be a long conversation, so lets move on" -- When she is unable to bulldoze her agenda (narrative) to blame Hinduism.
Well not really, after consenting with the audience she did reply and Devdutt on lack of justifying the caste system blankly said "reject it". Great talk by Devdutt though .
brother this dumb is funded by future group and future group is funded by western countries which is funded by federal reserve bank of usa so you can understand from where this all agenda is coming from
@@shaarangbuckal3775 not really, devadutt did justify it. It's just that, as people we are not able to overcome the fact that caste system has changed and not the same as in the scriptures.
Closed minds
Her question was very valid. If people think , that everything is a consequence of past life ,then no one will fight any injustice. if every harm done to you, purposefully by someone, is thought of, as past life consequence, you will never fight any injustice. This will result in the privileged always being privileged, and oppressed being oppressed. It will become a tool for oppression. People revolted to injustice, and as a result the circumstances changed. Take India's example. When we were ruled by the British, if all our freedom fighters thought that our being ruled by them, is a result of our past actions, then no one would have fought for our freedom. And we would not have seen this light of independence.
When you stand before your parents’ photo& bow, it is not before the photo but to rouse your memory to living impression in one’s memory: the outside details trivial,, important only being characteristic of the personalities: if you do not achieve this, you are before an icon. The difference is well brought by the author-speaker.
Life is for me and was for me not a fair game so far, but yet I am still fighting for my life..now the difference is now I am fighting life not only for me but for some dearones in my life. I am totally proud to be in a culture which gives you the options to accept or to reject divine lords, gods and/or goddesses. As a "sanadhana dharma" believer/seeker, I wish everyone the peace and happiness and/or whatever they are looking for in their life...love you all...and thanks for the video.
I really appreciate this talk. Huge respect and thanks to the Mr. Pattanaik for decoding the Indian Mythology and taking us back to our original roots. In the same breath I would like to say that the hate that Ms. Chaudhury is receiving is misdirected. We agree that the British came and changed the education system and as Mr. Pattanaik says we have to be aware and accept the consequences instead of viciously attacking someone for it. A lot of our mythology was misinterpreted yes, but if we have no Ms. Chaudhury's to ask questions then there also no chance for Mr. Pattakanik's to answer and correct us. Mr Pattaknaik is reminding us again and again to not be judgmental and keep aside morality of right and wrong and look at the things just the way there are. A lot of us cleared our own doubts because this conversation happened. Putting down another person for their opinions which goes against our belief construct is exactly what Hinduism points to be wary of. I have been in your shoes and over the course of time very humbled and thankful to realize what Hinduism truly stands for by trying to practicing some of it and not just be swayed by pride of being a Hindu.
Anchor also in a way representing the general mass when it comes to drive the conversation. Its good to ask stupid question rather than assume you know everything. I didn't find her arrogant.
Devdutt Pattanaik is an erudite mythologist. 44:06 What a superb reply by Mr Pattanaik🔥🔥🔥 ! This video has so many wonderful snippets. For an example, portion from 49:24 to 50:44
Would love to see My Quran from Mr Pattanaik
Nothing against you bro , but I think you didn't understand his concept , there can be no 'my' quran , there can be only th Qur'an , because of the nature of it , in the biblical idea of Islam , Christianity and Judaism , the authority is absolute , and the rules are universal which forces you to be homogeneous with everyone else , and therefore their scriptures are not subjective in nature . But the Hindu/Buddhist/Jain beliefs are such that , they allow one's conscience and their principles are set in such that one can use them to overcome , hunger and fear of one's animalistic nature (as in humans without knowledge are animals) .
Read his book 'Eden'.
Then he will get sar tan se juda lol
Devdutt should have a conversation with the mystic Sadhguru.
Why? Do classical dancers learn from folk dancers?
I would say both can learn from/understand each other
@@vinamrasinghai7319 why not
@Manchester United thats your mythology
@Manchester United and why dp u think he is fraud..just because he is fighting for upliftment of Indian culture its creating problem for Christian missionaries in South India to convert Hindus to christian, thus they made false allegation against SADHGURU to Defame him...now u put yourself on Sadhguru's place and think, what if some random guy put allegation on you that ypu killed his wife or abused his wife and defame u in a false case, how will u feel..imagine for a moment the scenario then comment..
We need more of this kind of conversation.
This man just gave the best knowledge you could ever grasp
th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
Watch the video below, he is fake, please don’t follow him..
Lol
15:06: The confidence born out of ignorance is just amazing.... this was a direct reference to the Anchor but looks like she did not understand.
Who want devdutt and sadhguru on same side on same program against all these urban naxals ,and arrogant anchors and teach them a lesson they never forget about India and Hinduism's reality.
This Lady i Possessed by MODI and Obsessed with western education.
Whenever I listen Devdutt ...I learn meaning of so much know words ...which we perceived as obvious meaning.....and explanation of concept of Diversity and Karma is remarkable ...make lot of sense....Good job Devdutt Jee !
th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
No he is trying to be famous by calling himself a mythological, our Sanatan Dharma is not a myth.. please understand and stop following him..
@Amadeus You do your job, I know what I am doing. The people like you always talk the same way, IT cell and what not..Sanatana Dharma is beyond your understanding, so need not discuss..Take good care of yourself..And yes May be you have seen second time but I have been learning and writing the facts for many years now..
@@priyak3107 Priya behen, Sanatan dharm/ Hinduism may not be a mythology, it is based on Ramayan, Mahabharath, and Bhagwat geeta. Valmiki Ramayan narrates Sri Ram, in rage and revenge, murdered Ravan and Khumbhkaran, for Sita haran with the help of a monkey, Hanuman that failed to pluck out a Sanjivini bootie from dorangiri parvat, yet Hanuman brokeapart the parvat. LOl. Monkeys including Hanuman evolved with a tail and NO wings necessary to fly, still, the monkey, Hanuman is claimed to fly across Bharat carrying the Dorangiri parvat like a cargo airplane to light a fire with its flaming tail to Lanka to burn the inhabitants to deat for KATIL Ram.Only Valmiki saw a flying monkey across Bharat. Flying monkey is aeronautically FALSE and flaming tail is biologically ABSURD. Ramayan is a kalpanic katha even if Sri Ram was a son of Dashrath maharaj. Similarly, Krishna intervened in the mahabharath ydh to resolve the family feud between, the Pandavas against Kauravas. Even if the ydh happened Kauravas being 100 sons of blind dhritarashtra and Gandhari is statistically and biologically Jhoot, making Mahabharath a kalpanic katha. Bhagwat Geeta is believed to contain verbal discourse between Krishna and Arjun at the Mahabharath ydh, 5561 BCE. Both died without leaving any manuscript necessary to print. The earliest pringing of Bhagwat Geeta occurred in the 15th century, after many generation over a few centuries without the manuscript containing the verbal discourse between Arjun and Krishna. Bhagwat Geeta is FALSELY claims to contain Krishna's discourse with Arjun. Priya behen, Facts lrad to the truth and the truth is bitter. Only the truth shal set yo, priya behen, free. Satyemeva Jayete.
Symbols are powerful. Our tradition has been offering to everyone for thousands of years.
How come she thinks that She is at all better than Arnab????
What does Shoma want to do for a sanitary workers? She rejects to the concept of Karma but doesn't know what is the alternative.
She wants others to do something
She is interrupting him so much and not letting him to complete his talk.
She wants to make her Marxist jihadi points and he is just a prop.
She quit speaking only when Devdutt answered her questions on janitorial worker cleaning the gutter. His reply was that her great grand children will be doing the same when this worker’s great grand kids will be ruling! Karmic cycle!
Bal kapali maya
His comment on Central Characters of Ramayana & Mahabharata is very good !
Thank you Algebra for providing us such insightful narrative.
ha ha the host is really smart. she insisted on pushing the "Leadership" argument in ram's context, and was planning to get modi in to show how he is not going with the hindu teachings - and how the hindus should then realize modi is going against hindu values, but devdutt didn't fall into the trap. lol
Also whats the use of rejecting Hinduism on stage when the host didn't believe in Hinduism in the first place? being born and believe are two different things. clearly she admits she doesn't know Hinduism as well and rejected it - 55:43... weird, unless i haven't understood it correctly.
Mr.Devdhath, I am from Kerala,I respect you a lot and love you,
As a Hindu I have been listening your luctures very carefully,so informative presentation.Thank you very much.Keep it up.
Anticipating more words from you about our great culture and Sanadhana Dharma.
You have not heard him carefully, listen to his lectures once again, mai his time I am sure you will understand his motives and what garbage he is giving out..
th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
@Amadeus I think half learned knowledge is always dangerous and Sanatana Dharma for sure there are more learned people than him.
Just watch this he is not the person you think th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
EPICS and HISTORY is not MYTH my dear Shoma Chaudhary
Is it not a shame , that the anchor doesnot know anything about her religion and culture. These liberals think its a great thing to demean your culture and religion but she should know that every indian is very proud of their culture and religion and the rise of right in india is due to suppression of hindu culture and religion by the congress regime because most Indians are very religious no matter how educated or modern he or she might be .Indians are coming back to their culture and religion.Yes there might be some who may be wayward but majority are rooted to their culture and religion.
well around 55:43 she says she rejects hinduism.
Hindus reject her .
Maybe she thinks it’s cool and trendy to be ignorant regarding her own culture. Weirdly enough, you will never find educated Europeans who she emulates who are proud of and rejoice in their ignorance. Did she need a mr patnaik to inform her about bal buddhi vidya Delhi mohi, strength and wisdom.
She just asked some questions whats wrong in that
why does she have to talk about the 'political right' in every video and attack the current govt.? getting really irritating and hope she shuts up. seems like that's the only agenda behind every discussion.
Sneha Rao true I agree...
Yeah she is doing this in every interview of hers whichever field that person belongs to
because she used to work in thekla and Vajpaiye did things to thelka that no editor in thelka can appreciate. So obviously she have reservations with the BJP now.
In Democracy it is considered normal.
Reflex action, my dear. Why does a crow caw? Why does a dog bark? Why does a donkey bray? Because that is the nature of these animals so is true of a Marxist jihadi. Marxists have no brains but they are against the main stream religion -- in India, Hinduism. And they are so messed up in their heads that if they are against Hinduism, they have to be for jihadi Islam. So these pseudos are always for the left and after the right.
Infinite Wisdom well said... It's their innate predisposition...
In the end he give the answer of savage controversy
to understand mythology, not as religion but as 'vocabulary' that can be applied to every aspect of both our outer and inner lives (1:30), is so liberating for those of us who grew up with literal, dogmatic and moralistic interpretations of ancient stories and symbols, that left little room for critically questioning, courageously challenging, and creatively re-interpreting ancient mythologies in relation to our own lived experiences, as people of different genders, cultures, classes and (so called) races.
to understand any character in mythology one must approach it not only intellectually, but also emotionally and from a sensual and aesthetic angle... from an evolutionarily point of view, intellect is a defense mechanism we have created to cope with our emotions (8:15)
She doesn't even know what is the difference between Varana and Jatti there is no justification repeating caste a Portuguese distinction created by the Portuguese to confuse the idea of the two. Krsna reject Jatti but Varana is part of civilization and are all equally important.
Very true
Shame on the anchor. She takes pride in not knowing about Lord Hanuman. Shame on her parenting. Such anchor should not be encouraged nor watched.
Some hindus feel pride in demeaning their own cultural icons ..
Everyone has religious freedom which gives them the right to accept or reject religious idols. No one can force anyone to follow something just because it's dear to them. If you want your religious freedom to be respected you gotta respect others' too. Period.
@@NidzShah-ps6kr Let me put it this way, your freedom of expression stops at my nose. My religious freedom doesnt give me the right to insult others 'idols'. My religious freedom doesnt give me the right to comment on religious practices and customs of others. You might not respect Shri Hanuman ji...doesnt mean that you can waltz in and disrespect him. If you do there will be repercussions from those who respect Him. And if one wants to play the secular hindu card....then also one doesnt have the right to comment upon others religious beliefs. Or demean them. Hindus are passive so one can get away with it, Imagine saying that about muhammad or calling Jesus ianappropriately in a majority Islamic or Christian country...! Me thinks respect as far as sickular libtards are concerned stems from fear of repercussions , not a genuine interest in the high moral ground.
@@piyushdas079 well, not knowing or being disinterested or being critical or agnostic of any religious idol does not equate to disrespecting them. The term "disrespect" - and the flimsy whataboutism that goes with it - is an easy resort of the obstinate ultra-right who can't stomach that your-way-is-not-the-highway and that there are many ways to understand something. Me thinks that the aforementioned obstinacy makes you want other people to respect your sentiments while you can plough straight through their rationality by the threat of repercussions. And "sikular libtards" (which, I must say are convenient choice words pulled out of a hat by supposedly passive folks) ain't lynching poor people or blowing themselves up on busses. (For all you know I could be a right-wing progressive). As far as criticising, the followers of the abrahamic faiths is concerned, I don't see their ultra-right being any less coo-coo. You make the mistake of thinking YOU have a moral high ground to THEM in the eyes of the "sikular libtards" you're flouting.
@@NidzShah-ps6kr Lady, if I dont know enough about a religion or a practice I would desist from discussing it. secondly . lynching isnt the prerogative of the ultra -right and since ultra right is as inventive as sickular liberals ..i think both stand on the same moral plate. The point I made is not about new fangled words, but the effectiveness of abrahmic religions in imposing an effective fear psychosis which prevents the so called 'rationals' from 'discussing' it. I have no idea which ideology you subscribe to, neither is it my business. I dont claim any high moral ground, neither do I cede the high moral ground to the sickular liberals. I am yet to see an open national debate on abrahmic practices which leads me to believe that the sickular liberal is just scared to touch upon Islam but is free to berate hindus ....which is convenient. The selective debate and disrespect only strengthens the view that Sickular liberals are just a bunch of snowflakes who have a very convenient moral goalpost.
I remember some muslim missionaries came to our neighbours house who was a hindu. And after a while there was a crowd gathered and I listened to the neighbour saying we don't want any conversion, we have our hanuman ji with us which is sufficient, maybe your god is need of some people that's why you are doing this. And that made me so proud
This woman needs to calm down! She wont let the man finish his sentence :/
When you have intellectual bankruptcy.. Anchor every time couldn't peddle her cheap agenda... Moving on is logical choice :)
Very nice. Thanks for sharing this. I got goosebumps at various explanations.
Dialogs at 37:15 and 41:00, I found were what I had been looking for so long.
Dats true bcz anchor typ ppl cn nly recognize kings.. wat Hanuman was/is/will be.. is beyond ur understanding.. Hanuman ji is d power source who is so controlled, calm n simple dat who doesn't crave for glory. He, the beholder of Superpower, avatar of Shiva, bhakt of Vishnu and most of all the beholder of the Highest Knowledge. And watever he did is for a purpose. Not to glorify himself. HE HAS NO SELF.
the guy at the end literally said "the anchor is being her typical self again" "yeh fir aise kar rahi hai" that was my favourite part!
The host is clearly biased to her sense of what is 'bad' in the society. Pointing towards a perticular religion without the complete knowledge of the same. Worst discussion I have seen involving Devdutt Pattnaik.
5 minutes into this & I can already sense that the host is acting as a speed bump rather than a facilitator!
This talk from Devdutt was amazing. Gives me a new understanding on mythology...🤘Awesome.
th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
Please watch this video, he is fake, please don’t believe him or follow him..he is just trying to be famous by giving wrong details on Gitaji..
@@priyak3107 Yeah right believe a random youtube comment instead of a credible mythologist/scholar/author whose books I've personally read...no thanks
@@rockybalboa1465 I didn’t ask you to believe me, I shared a video which is of a well renowned personality, who lived in US for 50 years, has interviewed many eminent personalities..Check him out and then decide, I am not against Devdut but you need to understand what he is trying to preach..
@@priyak3107 Ohhh so he lived in US for 50 years and I should be impressed cuz he has interviewed people LOL...no thanks pls do your marketing on some other comment who might be ignorant enough to fall for it...🤑🤣👋🏼bye now
Someone should write "My jesus" and "My mohammad" so people will know how flawed "my" interpretations can go if you just put your interpretations are totally disconnected with the source
That's your assumption!
There are many books which have people's interpretation of Jesus.
This lady is really really cringeworthy.
Devdutt really beautifully rebutted Shoma
When a person ask a question for a question ...tht shows he has no answer .. Loved the anchors sharp point .. Sharpness hurt ..
this anchor is rubbishly intellectual. these people like her simply defy knowingly.
I looked at the title and thought - "Oh! I know the meaning of Hanuman Chalisa. What special Devdutt Pattanaik has to explain.". I could have easily ignored the video and moved on. But the decision of watching it was worth it. Suggestion : changing the title to a something more relative will give more people chance to watch it. Thanks for sharing.
Was it necessary to keep calling Hanuman a myth!!? Does that make you intellectual, Madame
I think that believing in past karmas gives you the power to accept the horrifying situations you are in right now. When you know that you are in a horrifying situation and you will never get out of that situation, there can be a great solace in strong acceptance of your situation.
So what does that help in
So , according to him Indian puranas and Itihasas are all imaginations . No wonder why dumb self proclaimed intellectuals love him so much. I have no problem with this man or his interpretations but he needs to sit and talk with other saints and well read or realized persons of the country. We believe knowledge or interpretation skills should be appreciated but only if it is verified , testified and challenged. It won't happen if devdutt continues to waste time giving interviews to idiotic people . He is too focused on fame and money and that's why he is content with dumb Bollywood bimbos appreciating him and some self proclaimed liberals calling him for interviews . He is wasting his talent . I am not saying that he is the most intelligent person in the country but he could still contribute to the field of knowledge and interpretation of ancient Indian scriptures much more than what he is currently doing trying to cater to a particular elite group of people. And this group of people have actually no interest in the Indian traditions . They just show off because suddenly they realised that there is a new found awareness about the ancient Indian culture and traditions recently which they never thought will ever happen. So , they are trying desperately to fit into the narrative somewhere because they can see before their eyes the changing trends , the shifting balances . He will do more disservice to our culture if he continues to give too much importance to this elite group of vultures.
This man is indeed a left-funded vulture. Watch this to gain more insight into what he is doing: th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
well said
Excellent session ❤❤❤
In south India, they call Hanuman Anjanaye, because mother was Anjana.
Thank you for the real camera recording...
Excellent and enlightening.. I have read this book. A must read one. 👏🏻👏🏻
th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
No he is not worth your appreciation.. please understand he is wrong absolutely.
Just watch this he is not the person you think th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
Congressi man put to manipulate narratives
Its not Hanuman, its "Lord Hanumanji" and same with "Lord Ram".
"lord"?? भगवन हनुमानजी
Gods in Hinduism are often addressed in Ekavachana. Because we aren't afraid of them but rather love them.
@Renjith Kannen but respect should be given therefore....
@Renjith Kannen That's what we address our gods personally but publicly we should say in due respect their names
+rep for the guy in the end. most important question unanswered. The moksha
What i don’t understand is how in the hell only Hindu gods are myth and all other have video proof that they existed.
cuz hinduism is the oldest religion. The last remnant of ancient Hinduism is the proof ( i.e.in the Indus valley civilization) which is about 2000 years older than the birth of Jesus Christ. And there too we can only find the proof of worshippers (Shiv linga) So say Ramayana supposedly happened 5000 years before that and according to shiv purana, Shiva existed around 12000 years before that.
But Scientist says that humans didn't exist at that time.
, So no one knows about the origin of Hinduism.And there are 300 million gods and godessess
He knows every mythology around the world
Jai Rajputana
Please watch this.. th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
I have to admit that Devdutt dodged the question on karma. Rest of the talk was quite informative.
For your information ma'am, Devdatt named his book as My Hanuman chalisa and not My Hanuman as you mentioned in the beginning
Definitely she doesnt understand hinduism but talks like an expert
Why are they calling ramayan as a mythology .........
It's a part of history of this land .
I so agree, if only most Hindus know how far Lord Rama travelled & I wouldn't use d word conquered but similar & left his influence from Burma thru Thailand to Bali. As I visited Bangkok it brought tears of pride to my eyes to see d story of krishna unfold in sculptures at d Airport. To see Lord Ram's Ayodhya (d old City of Ayutthaya) replicated there made me even more proud. Their culture has been so influenced by our Indian King that even their King carries his name as part of their lineage as well d custom of touching an elder or guru's feet. Hindus could want no further legacy than this proof of existence to this day.
th-cam.com/video/LfORjgKrIec/w-d-xo.html
Is it "my-thology" or "mithology"- I believe it's the 2nd one. Sorry, not able to write the phonetics representation in my ipad😐
You pray a dead man on a wooden cross or what
Lol
Devdutt ji is absolutely correct
She is probably more of an interviewee and not an interviewer... maybe this experience helped her realize that too...
Stop calling the reality myth. Ramayan is no myth.
You can always prove it.
Archelogical (dwarka city/ram setu), historical/mathematical (time taken to travel from ayodhya to rameshwaram/tip of south india = 21 days by foot matching with today's google maps) records suggest Ramanyan or Mahabharata being a reality 10000 years back and this cycle of creation and destruction is part of the karmic cycle. We are on the ascending curve from destruction to creation in the current time and such hinduism concepts will play a major catalyst in showing the world the right direction, leaving the choice to them (no force).
@Vasu Srivastava searched.
@dukkar123 googled
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The west seems more interested in our mythology than we are. We have to start having pride of our own culture and the wonderful religion we are part of that has several things to teach the modern society today but we don’t even know we have this diamond of a knowledge with us. What a pity
Understanding and imbibing is more important than pride.
But Nonliving things also have hunger for example salt NaCl means sodium and Chloride two different elements.
when Sodium chloride is formed when sodium atoms interact with chlorine atoms. When this occurs, sodium will donate an electron (which is a negatively-charged particle) to chlorine. This makes sodium slightly positive and chlorine slightly negative. ... So chlorine complete it's octane .
don't you think this is a hunger of chlorine.
where is the conscious desire for one to have a relation with the other? Emotion.
No sodium will not die if it doesnt get Chloride.
Devdutt Pattanaik is Awesome!!!
The reply given by Shri Patnaik to the 1st question of why Lord Hanuman is worshipped so much misses the point. The majority of the people look up to Hanuman to give them the strength and the confidence to live life. We all look for someone on whom we can rest our fears and lovingly think of them to derive confidence. It is not due to ignorance as the speaker says it. Many of the points in his narration/explanation are also not correct. Lord Hanuman isy, but a Vanara. Vanaras are another variation of human beings who existed in the times of Lord Rama. He is right in saying that we should look at this question not intellectually but with an emotional mindset. Great speech. These are my views.
Discussing hanumanjji with the label of glenlivet in the background....but hanumanji still has his blessings over all...that’s why we love hanumanji...
The moderator (talking about sewage worker) should know.
() Everyone carries in their prized proud possession of physical body, the original sewage system which is the source of the city sewage drainage system, which is maintained in good repairs by sewage workers.
Devdutt is persuasive as always. He's however being interviewed by an anchor educated and trained in English and thus working through the English vocabulary to understand a world so different from the West. Indian mythology requires some basic training in Sanskrit or any native Indian language to first appreciate its uniqueness and then assimilate it. Devdutt is rightly bringing in a vocabulary that underscores the nuances and is legitimately credited by the anchor for it.
This woman is the perfect example of empty vessel that sounds much.
Algebra, please refrain from conducting sessions with anchors who don't stand on the podium with an open mind. It's very irritating watching her interrupt Devdutt. He was trying to base his argument on some premises, which she clearly didn't want to listen to.
If she has a problem with Hindu ideologies, don't ask her to interview Hindu mythologists from now on.
#BharatRatna4RatanTata
Devdutt Pattnaik, the guy who does not even know basic Indian languages is no decoding the Hanuman Chalisa for us with his distorted and ignorant mindset.
52:55 big slappp She Run way cowrdly
Mahabharata and Ramayana have actually happened. There is no doubt about that. Just like how World War 1 and 2 have happened. We do not doubt their happening. Only thing is that there are many metaphors in the story of Ramayana and Mahabharata that make us believe that they have not happened. The so called Guru is a crap. He has mocked at your question. Ravana with 10 heads is a metaphor. And Ravana is part of Ramayana and not Mahabharata. His 10 heads is not a biological reality. Otherwise, Dr. Rama and Dr. Richard Dawkins will never agree to it. Even in our existing world there are cases of boys or girls with two heads. And in biology it is a deformity and not a boon. So, definitely, Ravana with 10 heads is not a biological reality. What it actually means is that he was not trustworthy. He was not consistent with his honesty. Just like how we make different faces in different situations. We have one face for a father, one for a mother, one for a boss, one for a wife and another for a girlfriend, etc. He was cunning. He was not honest even with his own family members. The whole story of Ramayana depicts his real character. Ravana as a 10 headed monster is a metaphor and a symbolic way to express his character. Thanks :)
I am impressed with the way he delivers his talks. But still I have a question in my mind - Is Devdutt a brillant writer or the corruptor of Hindu Mythology?
Have you done similar analysis for other religions ?
very well explained... by devdutt.
I LOVE HANUMAN THATIS I Have personally praman
Very good conversation
devdutt was trying to make it samvaad(conversation) but she was trying to make it vivad(argument). :-)
Schooled by devdutt
Shoma ma'am I can give you answer for your unanswered one.
Regarding karma caste God and yourself
Excellent explanation of the Hindu narrative!!!
As said by devdut in this video, never judge a person with your limited knowledge. Same goes with me too :-) as I too have not read the hindu scripture. So, I now know what is my Karma (action=read and understand scriptures) in order to comment/judge a person's works.
'Caste system' itself is a western construct which had perfectly reasonable origins. It got abused and now has taken a negative connotation. Everyone can make a change by choosing the Vishnu method. Good work by Shoma by and large. Jay Vijay got repeated and she allowed Dev to digress. There was very little hanuman chalisa in the end.
❤
Thats what i called a raita hinduism
This lady is overburdened with preposed agendas which corrupted the whole idea of the interview with such a hugly concieved knowledged personality.
Finally😅🙄. They took so long to upload this😑🙄.
According to me journalist desperately want to show their intellect power,may be for the dominance in their professional carrier or their ideology.It is the reality of most of the Journalist.
Without depravation, opportunity is missed to extend ones positive Karmas! If all are equal and previlleged, where is the need for compassion or charity!? So, inequality is also a reality that brings the question of - to be Indra, Vishnu or Shiva in one's own reaction!
I'm watching this 4 years late.. and it's really sad that people are still questioning Sanatan Dharma as a contradiction between Theory and practical..
Ultimately the world is one stage.. and faith acts as a tool to clear out anxiety when you get stage fright..
I mean why are people still not moving on..
90 percent comments: hate towards the anchor
Remaining 10 percent: praise about the book and author
Legend has it that the anchor's brain is still busy digesting Devdutt Pattanaik's logic.
Excellent! Devdatta plz write book on Mahabharat with your brilliant view
I mean another big book then before
Please watch this... th-cam.com/video/vtkMFLuOa3M/w-d-xo.html
I was just waiting for this!!!!!
Banner on both sides have some people's name in bold and big size, observe it and you will understand 😂😂😂
We want our own education system based on our way of perpetual life away from Western thoughts