Great demo. Thank you! Just one guy's opinion here, but aside from the iconic tone and projection of this guitar, if you are primarily an electric guitar player, or switch back and forth frequently, you will instantly fall in love with the feel of the J-45. The short scale length and neck profile is almost identical to a Les Paul. I think the Gibson SG's neck has a slightly thinner profile, but still, the J-45 will immediately feel comfortable for you.
I just tried a J45 Standard at my local Guitar Center. It was beautiful and surpassed my expectations in playability and sound. My dream guitar! I need to save up 💰. Love Martin guitars too.
I was dead set on a Martin as well but fell in love with the Taylor Grand Orchestra I use for leading worship. I want another tool of similar caliber and the J45 is at the top of my list.
Amazing demo. Been looking to upgrade my current main guitar and this one of the best sounding guitar demos I've ever heard, this model just shot to the top of my list. It's not just the guitar though, very clean playing and awesome recording setup, sounds like a million bucks.
This clown literally just strummed open chords the entire time like all lazy, boring CCM players do. “Excellent chops” lmao. Dudes “excellent chops” are about existent as his imaginary friend, God-that is not at all.
I am very blessed to have a J-45 Standard myself a 2021 edition as my daily player. Aside from the J-45 I also have a Martin and another Gibson . All three lovely Guitars. Excellent choice as I would find it very hard to part with my 45…. This guitar hits and checks all of the boxes for me ….
For sure, it’s one of my favorites. I went with a D18, as I find that it’s a bit louder, and has a bit more bass, but I would still be happy with a J45, if I went that route. I owned a Rosewood Martin before this one, and for me, mahogany is the way to go
Backstory....Martins are too expensive so I tried other guitars and bought an even more expensive guitar. That being said, I have a Martin GC-MMV (GC Exclusive poor mans D28) and a 000-15. A J-45 has always held a special place in my heart and will probably be my next guitar.
My main acoustic is a bourgeois but I’ve been hunting for the right Gibson to compliment it. My friend has a ringer of a J-45 and I’ve struggled to find another that’s like it. But the J-45 is a classic and incredible acoustic! Great job and tones on the video!
I bought one of these back in 2012 so around the same time as you. Like you, I had originally thought about a Martin (specifically a D-28) but in the end preferred the more balanced tone of the Gibson. I also tried a Hummingbird but although it sounded very nice, it was quite a bit more expensive. I'm very pleased with my J-45. I'd be interested to know what type of strings you use (manufacturer, type and gauge). I think mine came with a set of Gibson 12s but I'm currently using D'Addario Phosphor Bronze Custom Lights (11-52).
Love the tone... I have a J-45 and SJ-200 that I love, but your 45 has a much warmer tone than mine... What strings are you using and any eq on this video?
Thanks for the video. I'm about to buy one of these, but I am wondering about the neck shape. Gibson says it's a slim taper. Do you know how that would compare to a Taylor Grand Auditorium guitar? If not, can you just talk in general about the playability of the neck? I am homebound so I can't play it ahead of time, so it's a little scary. I bought my Taylor sight unseen and I liked it. Love my Taylor, but I want this one too since it has a warmer sound.
Thanks for checking out the video! I haven’t played a ton of Taylors but I would say the neck is kind of middle of the road. I don’t know that I would call it slim but it’s not super beefy either. I think it feels great though. I don’t like necks to be too slim or too thick so this works great for me. I think if you are going for a warmer sound - you can’t go wrong with this guitar.
Thank you for this great video review. What a nice sounding guitar. I think I have made up my mind. I too had my mind set on a Martin before he3aring this J45. Nice playin as well.
I have a J45 and love the sound but I can’t get use to the size. I have a Taylor GS Mini that I play all the time and it’s much more manageable, size wise……I was thinking about getting a J45 studio. Anyone got any suggestions? Thx.
I love how so many people say they've tried a bunch of guitars, and their "bunch" is always and only a Taylor, Martin, or Gibson....I guess a bunch means three??? I personally try as many as I kind find, and that's usually a minimum of eight or ten different makers, and interestingly enough, regardless of price, the only American made guitar I played that I felt was worth the price ( and bought ) was a 2017 Breedlove Oregon, and a Collings I was considering but I bought a Boucher over that, and zero regrets. I have 28 guitars, 3 made in Japan, 2 made in Spain, 1 in the U.S.A., and the rest are all Canadian. I've played $7000 Martins, Taylors, and Gibsons that sounded like shit, can't say I've played anything Canadian, Japanese, or Spanish for between $600 to $2000 that DON'T sound good, and also better than almost anything I've tried regardless of price from Taylor, martin, Fender, and Gibson. As for what kind of music you play, that doesn't matter at all really, you should be able to play any style on a good guitar, and I doubt anyone can really tell what guitar was used on a recording simply with their ear. Seems a lot of people like to get swayed by who plays what. Most good musicians play what their sponsors give them, and they'll sound good on any guitar that's well made with good materials.
I currently have a beautiful 2012 custom built Taylor that I bought 10 yrs ago in 2014. I too lead worship and am now in the market for a nice new guitar. I thought I would like a Martin D18 so I tried one as well as the J45 but I always like the sound and feel of the J45 the best. My Taylor is also a mahogany back and sides. I will try a Martin D35 but I'm thinking I will be coming home with a Gibson J45. How do you like the onboard pick up system? I really like the sound of my Taylor unplugged but not a fan of it plugged in due to the ES1 system. Really nice playing. It sounds really nice and nicely done on the Matt Redmond song. We play that one at church also. God bless you. 😊
Thanks so much! This J45 has the LR Baggs Element which I really like. The newer versions of the J45 may come with a different pickup system but I like the Element a lot.
I had opportunity to acquire a 2014 Martin hd28v. I had it cleaned up, setup, new strings and a K&K pickup installed in it and as much as I tried, I did not like it. Especially since I had to sing over the mids of the Martin so I sold it. I've since ordered a 2019 J45 vintage sunburst from a store I really like. They said they would reimburse me if I didn't like it after I tried it. I really hope I like it. It will be used to worship Jesus. God bless and thanks for posting.
Hi there, silly question you might think, but which particular model and colour is the one you use in your demo? I've been looking at some in the Gibson range advertised as J45 Montana.
I was thinking about a J45, I think they’re awesome, I went with the Martin D-18. I think I would’ve been happy with the Gibson as well, but I don’t regret my decision, The 18 is such a canon, and it’s so warm and powerful. It’s louder than the Gibson, and it has a lot of bass and power. I don’t have to try to sell the guitar, everybody already knows how good it is already, and they’re right. Same the J 45 though
The Lord Jesus bless you with this guitar and many more good things too. I’m trying to decide between J45 and D18. Leaning towards the Gibson , very hard to say
Cant ever go wrong with a J-45.. I'm sure so many players know of the "Very Stale, Mediocre" few years Gibson recently went through..as far as Acoustics, like 2014-2017 (ish) not saying all guitars from those years are bad, they just had a negative reputation of their Acoustics become very hit or miss.. Ive only ever played Gibson Acoustics, (other than in 2017 I bought a Martin D-35) and I'm so Glad Gibson is BACK!! Theres no question Martin makes incredible guitars.. For me, the tone my ear craves and is the best for me, will always be Gibsons.. Again, just my opinion and by no means is this a insult on Martins or folks who play Martins, ive always felt Gibsons especially a J45, is much more diverse than Martins. Taking nothing away from Martin, they obviously make incredible guitars.. lol My current weapon of choice is my 2012 Gibson Advanced Jumbo.. Anyway, wow sorry this comment become way to long. Lol Your J45 sounds amazing my man!! 🤘
I kind of get where you’re coming from actually, my dad has a Gibson hummingbird, so painfully beautiful. It’s just so good looking. I have a D-18! It’s genuinely fantastic. I mean seriously it’s just so good. Playing both back to back, it’s really hard to choose because they’re different, I find that the Martin projects, better, and sort of sounds better on paper, If there was a mathematical way to compare the sound, the Martin would be mathematically better. It just has more. But for whatever reason, even though the Gibson isn’t as initially impressive to listen to, I just prefer it, and I like it more. I like the sound more. It’s more soft, but it’s just so beautiful.
D'Addario phosphor bronze custom light (11's) sound just as good as the 12's and a bit easier on your fingers and the guitar's neck. You don't need the 12's unless you insist on maximum volume and like to strum really hard. I even keep a set of the 10's on one guitar for playing quietly at home, very easy on the fingers. D'Addario's just seem to have the best balance between warm and bright. And don't waste money on Elixirs or any other coated strings, just keep a clean guitar cloth handy and wipe your strings occasionally while you play, and especially when you're done.
I owned a Gibson J45 bought it new 1973, played it for 25 years top cracked sold it 1995, 1995 bought Martin D35 played it until 2023, bought a Gibson J35 in 2014 played it until 2023 also, traded them 2024 for a new Martin HD28 1935, Love it..
I played 6 guitars today at GC - D18, ,28, 35, HD28, and a used J45 as well as a new J45 Standard in vintage sunburst. I ruled out the used J45 - too many issues. The new J45 was warm, like you said. I ruled out the D18. Now it comes down to rosewood vs. mahogany. I’m still contemplating.
I’ve played the hummingbird, J45, D18 etc. they’re all different but great. I had a rosewood Martin for a minute, I sold it and went for the D18. I don’t regret it at all. To my ears, I’m happy with it, and I would consider keeping it for life, as my main. I think I would go mahogany instead of Rosewood, that’s what I’ve learned, but that’s just my opinion. Rosewood is more impressive when you compare them back to back, but it gets more annoying to listen to quickly, as the sound is complex, and you hear a lot more treble as well. It’s not something I would wanna keep long-term. Just my opinion
I feel like mahogany is just easier to live with long-term, and works for everything perfectly. I would go with the D18, J45, or the hummingbird. The hummingbird is best of the three in my opinion, but not in every way, the Martin wins with playability, if you get one that’s set up well. They’re all different
I wound up buying a J45 in vintage sunburst. I love it. I have owned a Martin DCPA4R for 8 years. To my ears, I like the J45 more, so much so that I don’t even play the Martin anymore.
@@gzackerman I played a martin for so long that my ears got sick of the sound. Literally. Taylors are too bright and exhaust my brain. Gibson is too expensive. The Eastmen E1SS is the answer. For $579, its a slope shoulder that chimes like the J45 - for 579!
Timestamp, 7:00 Not sure if you're playing something from Kristian Stanfill lol but it sounds like it.. Especially being Kristian plays a awesome J45 for so many years..I cant place my finger on which song it sounds like off the top of my head, lol "Always" or "one thing remains".. lol 🤘
I have a 2020 j-45 which came with the lr baggs vtc pickup which sux. I like everything about the guitar but that. As much as the guitar costs it should have a darn good pickup. I do have a couple martins with pickups but both have a mic you can blend with the under saddle. The j-45 is a great guitar and a good companion for my martins. Hd-28 and d-35.
jimmycollette9209 - the K&K Pure Mini passive under the bridge pickup has a great reputation for producing sound more accurately than many expensive pickups that have mics. Plus it can be bought new for about $109. Many folks have found they don't even need the external K&K Pure Preamp. But if you decide to get the external K&K Pure Preamp you can get it new for about $112. The K&K tech team in Oregon is excellent for answering questions. And the installation manual shows consumers how they can install the Pure Mini themselves.
That's all a matter of personal preference. I love the J 45 as well but to my ear my Gibson Songwriter sounds better! Others will say the D28 and so on!
These are nice guitars...problem is Gibson automatically installs electronics and that awful strap pin on the neck...when I requested Boseman leave these two things off...they said it would need to go through Gibson's custom shop [$$$]... maybe this is why Gibson is in so much trouble...
Yea prices have gone way up since I bought this guitar. It was over 12 years ago and I got it on sale. It was still expensive at the time but all I was saying is that I had my heart set on certain high end Martins and I realized I really liked the J45 and hadn't considered it. I was then able to get it at a lot lower price than those Martins.
This was over 10 years ago so I’m sure prices are different now. Not sure what they go for now but at the time I was looking at getting an OM28 or 00028
D28 at my local GC is $3199.00. J45 was 2999.00. D18 is $2799.00. Prices November 10, 2024. Was never able to bond with my 2023 Martin D28, so I sold it a few months ago. Tried a new D18 & J45 today at my GC. J45 Standard will be my next guitar.
I played a Martin for so long that my ears got sick of the sound. Literally. Taylors are too bright and exhaust my brain. Gibson is too expensive. The Eastmen E1SS is the answer. For $579, its a slope shoulder that chimes like the J45 - for 579!
@@54tristin A Gibson or Martin or Taylor is an investment. A Yamaha is by far the best affordable guitar that will play and sound great for years and you probably won't ever need to sell it anyway.
Having played many of these, I could be said that the comparable Martins and Taylor’s are also overpriced and inconsistent. I agree that the special individual J-45’s are wonderful. In my view, they are a unique voice from the others. A little more rock n roll. In the past I played a Gibson Hummingbird that had all of the bass and treble response of a piano without losing clarity. Once upon a time, Tacoma made solid wood acoustic guitars at an affordable price that I easily compared to Martins and Taylor’s. If you’re spending serious money……always play it first. I think it’s great when someone shares the story and sound of one of their favorite guitars!
@@mikechivy I only play Gibson Acoustics, so I'm 100% a Gibson "Fan Boy" lol.. Many know of the recent years that Gibson was struggling and they gained a bit of a negative reputation for putting out Mediocre, Hit and Miss, Acoustics.. That reputation will probably stick with them forever according to some folks.. lol don't get me wrong it's okay for someone to have a different opinion as me amd other Gibson players lol, All that to say, since about 2017 or '18, Gibson has corrected what many have heard or experienced with Gibson Acoustics.. My opinion based on what I hear when listening to their Guitars now. Sorry for the long explanation lol, as a Gibson supporter and player, I often get attacked in some comment sections because I Love Gibsons.. lol it's cool though 😂🤘
Great demo. Thank you! Just one guy's opinion here, but aside from the iconic tone and projection of this guitar, if you are primarily an electric guitar player, or switch back and forth frequently, you will instantly fall in love with the feel of the J-45. The short scale length and neck profile is almost identical to a Les Paul. I think the Gibson SG's neck has a slightly thinner profile, but still, the J-45 will immediately feel comfortable for you.
I just tried a J45 Standard at my local Guitar Center. It was beautiful and surpassed my expectations in playability and sound. My dream guitar! I need to save up 💰. Love Martin guitars too.
Min 6:20, bless the Lord oh my soul, great version of one of my favourite worship songs, played with my favourite guitar. Thank you for this video!
I was dead set on a Martin as well but fell in love with the Taylor Grand Orchestra I use for leading worship. I want another tool of similar caliber and the J45 is at the top of my list.
I love my J-45. I fell in love with its sound the first time i tried it
Very nice! I have one from 2009 and 2023! They are great.
Amazing demo. Been looking to upgrade my current main guitar and this one of the best sounding guitar demos I've ever heard, this model just shot to the top of my list. It's not just the guitar though, very clean playing and awesome recording setup, sounds like a million bucks.
Congrats! I have one J45 year 2011. I love this guitar, It’s simply the best acoustic guitar.
McCambria, specifically what model of 2011 J45 do you have?
@@LoneTinaja 2011
@@McCambira Wouldn't the actual model be called Standard or Studio, not 2011?
@LoneTinaja
I would venture the Standard going by the video. But his post was confusing at best
Nicely done, excellent chops...love my J 45
Thanks!
This clown literally just strummed open chords the entire time like all lazy, boring CCM players do. “Excellent chops” lmao. Dudes “excellent chops” are about existent as his imaginary friend, God-that is not at all.
I am very blessed to have a J-45 Standard myself a 2021 edition as my daily player. Aside from the J-45 I also have a Martin and another Gibson . All three lovely Guitars.
Excellent choice as I would find it very hard to part with my 45…. This guitar hits and checks all of the boxes for me ….
For sure, it’s one of my favorites.
I went with a D18, as I find that it’s a bit louder, and has a bit more bass, but I would still be happy with a J45, if I went that route. I owned a Rosewood Martin before this one, and for me, mahogany is the way to go
Backstory....Martins are too expensive so I tried other guitars and bought an even more expensive guitar. That being said, I have a Martin GC-MMV (GC Exclusive poor mans D28) and a 000-15. A J-45 has always held a special place in my heart and will probably be my next guitar.
My main acoustic is a bourgeois but I’ve been hunting for the right Gibson to compliment it. My friend has a ringer of a J-45 and I’ve struggled to find another that’s like it. But the J-45 is a classic and incredible acoustic! Great job and tones on the video!
Thank you!
Just order a j45 standard. You won’t regret it
@@richardlucascronley5128unless you do regret it. They’re very hit and mid
That particular guitar all things being equal, listening to it on my iPad is the best sounding one I’ve heard so far.
Such a great sounding acoustic I'm jealous
I just strummed and played around with one of these yesterday and now I’m obsessed and need to get one.
my J-45 was born in Bozeman in 2003. She's the love of my life!
I think matt Redman has that same guitar only with LR baggs pickup in it. I want to know what strings he uses to get the close tone
I bought one of these back in 2012 so around the same time as you. Like you, I had originally thought about a Martin (specifically a D-28) but in the end preferred the more balanced tone of the Gibson. I also tried a Hummingbird but although it sounded very nice, it was quite a bit more expensive. I'm very pleased with my J-45. I'd be interested to know what type of strings you use (manufacturer, type and gauge). I think mine came with a set of Gibson 12s but I'm currently using D'Addario Phosphor Bronze Custom Lights (11-52).
I usually use Elixir Phosphor Bronze Mediums or Martin Lifespan Phosphor Bronze Mediums.
Love the tone... I have a J-45 and SJ-200 that I love, but your 45 has a much warmer tone than mine... What strings are you using and any eq on this video?
Phosphore Bronze.... not 80 20
Thanks for the video. I'm about to buy one of these, but I am wondering about the neck shape. Gibson says it's a slim taper. Do you know how that would compare to a Taylor Grand Auditorium guitar? If not, can you just talk in general about the playability of the neck? I am homebound so I can't play it ahead of time, so it's a little scary. I bought my Taylor sight unseen and I liked it. Love my Taylor, but I want this one too since it has a warmer sound.
Thanks for checking out the video! I haven’t played a ton of Taylors but I would say the neck is kind of middle of the road. I don’t know that I would call it slim but it’s not super beefy either. I think it feels great though. I don’t like necks to be too slim or too thick so this works great for me. I think if you are going for a warmer sound - you can’t go wrong with this guitar.
Always been a Martin guy, but really love the tone of these j45s
I tried the j-45 i really like the sound of it but end up getting the taylor 224ce dlx which is my dream guitar
Thank you for this great video review. What a nice sounding guitar. I think I have made up my mind. I too had my mind set on a Martin before he3aring this J45. Nice playin as well.
what year of manufacture of this guitar please?
I believe it is a 2011
@@sundaytone thank you very much. It's a wonderful guitar. I have the same and I think that's a 2014
It would be nice if you could compare 100% LR Baggs vs. 100% mic'd since you probably won't be able to mix a mic'd channel in a live setting.
I have a J45 and love the sound but I can’t get use to the size. I have a Taylor GS Mini that I play all the time and it’s much more manageable, size wise……I was thinking about getting a J45 studio. Anyone got any suggestions? Thx.
I love how so many people say they've tried a bunch of guitars, and their "bunch" is always and only a Taylor, Martin, or Gibson....I guess a bunch means three??? I personally try as many as I kind find, and that's usually a minimum of eight or ten different makers, and interestingly enough, regardless of price, the only American made guitar I played that I felt was worth the price ( and bought ) was a 2017 Breedlove Oregon, and a Collings I was considering but I bought a Boucher over that, and zero regrets. I have 28 guitars, 3 made in Japan, 2 made in Spain, 1 in the U.S.A., and the rest are all Canadian. I've played $7000 Martins, Taylors, and Gibsons that sounded like shit, can't say I've played anything Canadian, Japanese, or Spanish for between $600 to $2000 that DON'T sound good, and also better than almost anything I've tried regardless of price from Taylor, martin, Fender, and Gibson. As for what kind of music you play, that doesn't matter at all really, you should be able to play any style on a good guitar, and I doubt anyone can really tell what guitar was used on a recording simply with their ear. Seems a lot of people like to get swayed by who plays what. Most good musicians play what their sponsors give them, and they'll sound good on any guitar that's well made with good materials.
I currently have a beautiful 2012 custom built Taylor that I bought 10 yrs ago in 2014. I too lead worship and am now in the market for a nice new guitar. I thought I would like a Martin D18 so I tried one as well as the J45 but I always like the sound and feel of the J45 the best. My Taylor is also a mahogany back and sides. I will try a Martin D35 but I'm thinking I will be coming home with a Gibson J45. How do you like the onboard pick up system? I really like the sound of my Taylor unplugged but not a fan of it plugged in due to the ES1 system. Really nice playing. It sounds really nice and nicely done on the Matt Redmond song. We play that one at church also. God bless you. 😊
Thanks so much! This J45 has the LR Baggs Element which I really like. The newer versions of the J45 may come with a different pickup system but I like the Element a lot.
I had opportunity to acquire a 2014 Martin hd28v. I had it cleaned up, setup, new strings and a K&K pickup installed in it and as much as I tried, I did not like it. Especially since I had to sing over the mids of the Martin so I sold it. I've since ordered a 2019 J45 vintage sunburst from a store I really like. They said they would reimburse me if I didn't like it after I tried it. I really hope I like it. It will be used to worship Jesus. God bless and thanks for posting.
I absolutely love my J-45 but have found it’s very particular about what strings you use. What strings are you using in this video.
Hi there, silly question you might think, but which particular model and colour is the one you use in your demo? I've been looking at some in the Gibson range advertised as J45 Montana.
Sounds and looks awesome! may i know what strings are you using on it?
Thank you! Yea I have Elixir 80/20 Mediums on it right now.
Nice playing!
I was thinking about a J45, I think they’re awesome, I went with the Martin D-18. I think I would’ve been happy with the Gibson as well, but I don’t regret my decision, The 18 is such a canon, and it’s so warm and powerful. It’s louder than the Gibson, and it has a lot of bass and power.
I don’t have to try to sell the guitar, everybody already knows how good it is already, and they’re right. Same the J 45 though
Bless the Lord 0 my soul 🙏
Fantastic playing.
I still play my 1971 D-18 but the woody tone of the J-45 is nice.
Great sounding guitar,
Just bought a Martin OM-28. The J-45 is next !!!
Thats a killer tone my friend.
The Lord Jesus bless you with this guitar and many more good things too. I’m trying to decide between J45 and D18. Leaning towards the Gibson , very hard to say
Cant ever go wrong with a J-45.. I'm sure so many players know of the "Very Stale, Mediocre" few years Gibson recently went through..as far as Acoustics, like 2014-2017 (ish) not saying all guitars from those years are bad, they just had a negative reputation of their Acoustics become very hit or miss..
Ive only ever played Gibson Acoustics, (other than in 2017 I bought a Martin D-35) and I'm so Glad Gibson is BACK!! Theres no question Martin makes incredible guitars.. For me, the tone my ear craves and is the best for me, will always be Gibsons.. Again, just my opinion and by no means is this a insult on Martins or folks who play Martins, ive always felt Gibsons especially a J45, is much more diverse than Martins. Taking nothing away from Martin, they obviously make incredible guitars.. lol My current weapon of choice is my 2012 Gibson Advanced Jumbo.. Anyway, wow sorry this comment become way to long. Lol Your J45 sounds amazing my man!! 🤘
I kind of get where you’re coming from actually, my dad has a Gibson hummingbird, so painfully beautiful. It’s just so good looking.
I have a D-18! It’s genuinely fantastic. I mean seriously it’s just so good.
Playing both back to back, it’s really hard to choose because they’re different, I find that the Martin projects, better, and sort of sounds better on paper,
If there was a mathematical way to compare the sound, the Martin would be mathematically better. It just has more.
But for whatever reason, even though the Gibson isn’t as initially impressive to listen to, I just prefer it, and I like it more. I like the sound more. It’s more soft, but it’s just so beautiful.
Hello from Finland, what brand of strings you have on it. Best regards.
Just got one and the strings are getting ready to swap. What’s the best option in everyone’s opinion?
D'Addario phosphor bronze custom light (11's) sound just as good as the 12's and a bit easier on your fingers and the guitar's neck. You don't need the 12's unless you insist on maximum volume and like to strum really hard. I even keep a set of the 10's on one guitar for playing quietly at home, very easy on the fingers. D'Addario's just seem to have the best balance between warm and bright. And don't waste money on Elixirs or any other coated strings, just keep a clean guitar cloth handy and wipe your strings occasionally while you play, and especially when you're done.
I owned a Gibson J45 bought it new 1973, played it for 25 years top cracked sold it 1995, 1995 bought Martin D35 played it until 2023, bought a Gibson J35 in 2014 played it until 2023 also, traded them 2024 for a new Martin HD28 1935, Love it..
I played 6 guitars today at GC - D18, ,28, 35, HD28, and a used J45 as well as a new J45 Standard in vintage sunburst. I ruled out the used J45 - too many issues. The new J45 was warm, like you said. I ruled out the D18. Now it comes down to rosewood vs. mahogany. I’m still contemplating.
I’ve played the hummingbird, J45, D18 etc. they’re all different but great.
I had a rosewood Martin for a minute, I sold it and went for the D18. I don’t regret it at all. To my ears, I’m happy with it, and I would consider keeping it for life, as my main.
I think I would go mahogany instead of Rosewood, that’s what I’ve learned, but that’s just my opinion.
Rosewood is more impressive when you compare them back to back, but it gets more annoying to listen to quickly, as the sound is complex, and you hear a lot more treble as well. It’s not something I would wanna keep long-term.
Just my opinion
I feel like mahogany is just easier to live with long-term, and works for everything perfectly.
I would go with the D18, J45, or the hummingbird.
The hummingbird is best of the three in my opinion, but not in every way, the Martin wins with playability, if you get one that’s set up well.
They’re all different
I wound up buying a J45 in vintage sunburst. I love it. I have owned a Martin DCPA4R for 8 years. To my ears, I like the J45 more, so much so that I don’t even play the Martin anymore.
@@gzackerman I played a martin for so long that my ears got sick of the sound. Literally. Taylors are too bright and exhaust my brain. Gibson is too expensive. The Eastmen E1SS is the answer. For $579, its a slope shoulder that chimes like the J45 - for 579!
Martin d28 is the daddy. Unbeatable sound.
What string is used?
Great video !!!! 🔥🔥 I love J45
They're just so pretty, and sound amazing 😊
Timestamp, 7:00
Not sure if you're playing something from Kristian Stanfill lol but it sounds like it.. Especially being Kristian plays a awesome J45 for so many years..I cant place my finger on which song it sounds like off the top of my head, lol "Always" or "one thing remains".. lol 🤘
I love the tone and looks of the J45 but it’s too big for me. Nice review 👍🏻
The best acoustic out there!
Man that guitar sounds great , i want one bad but $ 3,000 is a lot of money for me , i should just get it and be done with it.
I have a 2020 j-45 which came with the lr baggs vtc pickup which sux. I like everything about the guitar but that. As much as the guitar costs it should have a darn good pickup. I do have a couple martins with pickups but both have a mic you can blend with the under saddle. The j-45 is a great guitar and a good companion for my martins. Hd-28 and d-35.
jimmycollette9209 - the K&K Pure Mini passive under the bridge pickup has a great reputation for producing sound more accurately than many expensive pickups that have mics. Plus it can be bought new for about $109. Many folks have found they don't even need the external K&K Pure Preamp. But if you decide to get the external K&K Pure Preamp you can get it new for about $112. The K&K tech team in Oregon is excellent for answering questions. And the installation manual shows consumers how they can install the Pure Mini themselves.
@@LoneTinaja thanks for the info. Will keep it in mind.
No acoustic sound better than a j45.
Apart from d18.
That's all a matter of personal preference. I love the J 45 as well but to my ear my Gibson Songwriter sounds better! Others will say the D28 and so on!
Apart from the D18-28 I agree
You obviously never played a D18. It sounds 10 times better.
I have one,it is great but all my Martins are better😉
Good review just wish we could hear the acoustic sound more and not the pickup.
These are nice guitars...problem is Gibson automatically installs electronics and that awful strap pin on the neck...when I requested Boseman leave these two things off...they said it would need to go through Gibson's custom shop [$$$]... maybe this is why Gibson is in so much trouble...
The J45 is a dream guitar , saying it is inexpensive is completely wrong this is a pretty expensive guitar
Yea prices have gone way up since I bought this guitar. It was over 12 years ago and I got it on sale. It was still expensive at the time but all I was saying is that I had my heart set on certain high end Martins and I realized I really liked the J45 and hadn't considered it. I was then able to get it at a lot lower price than those Martins.
Dig it
I thought people that played worship music used Taylor.
😂
Martin D 18 D28 both are cheaper than j45 what the hell are you talking
This was over 10 years ago so I’m sure prices are different now. Not sure what they go for now but at the time I was looking at getting an OM28 or 00028
D28 at my local GC is $3199.00. J45 was 2999.00. D18 is $2799.00. Prices November 10, 2024. Was never able to bond with my 2023 Martin D28, so I sold it a few months ago. Tried a new D18 & J45 today at my GC. J45 Standard will be my next guitar.
@@lilycat1694 why do you choose J45 over D18 ? Any specific reason?
I played a Martin for so long that my ears got sick of the sound. Literally. Taylors are too bright and exhaust my brain. Gibson is too expensive. The Eastmen E1SS is the answer. For $579, its a slope shoulder that chimes like the J45 - for 579!
Neck too fat for me.. I have a Southern Jumbo and it has a slimmer neck
Yamaha’s FGX5 sounds just as good and plays as good. Half the price! Yamaha is massively underrated
Maybe I don’t know but when time to resell it, you’ll get most of your money back on the Gibson and the Yamaha will take a beating
@@54tristin A Gibson or Martin or Taylor is an investment. A Yamaha is by far the best affordable guitar that will play and sound great for years and you probably won't ever need to sell it anyway.
@@54tristinyou won’t want to sell the Yamaha, so I wouldn’t worry about that
I love it, except for the huge, gaudy, ugly Grover tuning machines. To me, they scream out, "change me, change me".
Wildly overpriced and very inconsistent. Great ones are great, but such a crapshoot you have to play before you buy.
Yea you definitely need to play them to find the right one. I think they cost a bit more now but I think this one sounds great and is worth it to me.
Having played many of these, I could be said that the comparable Martins and Taylor’s are also overpriced and inconsistent. I agree that the special individual J-45’s are wonderful. In my view, they are a unique voice from the others. A little more rock n roll. In the past I played a Gibson Hummingbird that had all of the bass and treble response of a piano without losing clarity. Once upon a time, Tacoma made solid wood acoustic guitars at an affordable price that I easily compared to Martins and Taylor’s. If you’re spending serious money……always play it first. I think it’s great when someone shares the story and sound of one of their favorite guitars!
I think that narrative is massively overplayed. In recent years, they pretty much all sound fantastic.
@@mikechivy I only play Gibson Acoustics, so I'm 100% a Gibson "Fan Boy" lol.. Many know of the recent years that Gibson was struggling and they gained a bit of a negative reputation for putting out Mediocre, Hit and Miss, Acoustics.. That reputation will probably stick with them forever according to some folks.. lol don't get me wrong it's okay for someone to have a different opinion as me amd other Gibson players lol,
All that to say,
since about 2017 or '18, Gibson has corrected what many have heard or experienced with Gibson Acoustics.. My opinion based on what I hear when listening to their Guitars now. Sorry for the long explanation lol, as a Gibson supporter and player, I often get attacked in some comment sections because I Love Gibsons.. lol it's cool though 😂🤘
Nonsense. It's 2023 - give your head a shake.
i cant get into the inflated price "just because"
Der Pick Up Klang ist überhaupt nicht schön... klingt einfach nicht gut, irgendwie "Plastik", eindeutig unnatürlich verfremdend.
Never buy a sloped shoulder. Makes you look like a poor cowboy with the strap around the headstock… 🤠
Just have a strap pin installed at the neck heel.
Amazing video, stunning guitar sound and look
Thank you!