"Linguistic Fanaticism Dangerous":Madras HC Asks Modi Govt Not To Use Hindi In Communication With TN
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ย. 2021
- "Recently, the Madras High Court bench was hearing a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) petition filed by Lok Sabha Member of Parliament from Madurai, Su Venkatesan. He had apparently, made a representation to the Central govt in English but he received a reply in Hindi. Following this, he moved to the Madras High Court. Venkatesan told the Court that he had written back to the Union government, calling for the reply to be sent again in English.
However, upon failing to receive any response to this additional communication, he moved the Court. His petition had urged the Court to direct the use of English in all communications between the Central government and the State of Tamil Nadu.
Appearing for the Centre, Assistant Solicitor General L Victoria Gowri further submitted that the reply to Venkatesan had been inadvertently written in Hindi. There was no intention on the part of the Central government to violate any provision of the Official Languages Act, 1963 or Rules. Before the High Court, the Central government admitted that there was a mandate to use English in communications between the Centre and States that have not adopted Hindi as their official language.
#TamilNadu #MadrasHC #HindiImposition #Madras #AntiHindiProtest #SuVenkatesan #MinistryofHomeAffairs
To Join HW Membership Program: hwnews.in/subscribe
To Join TH-cam Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Download the HW News Network free app available on Android and iOS: onelink.to/bpk42n
For NEWS and POLITICAL updates in English. Send us a ‘Hi’ on our Whatsapp Number - 9820918578
#HWNewsEnglish #HwLatestNews
For advertising related queries write to us at sales@hwnews.in
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
Don't impose any language ....respect every language , every culture, every religion..unity in diversity is our beauty
Totally agree with your view.
👍👍 absolutely ✔️
Bro the modi govt only communicated they didnt impose any language
@@shivamanibalaji7151 that indirectly implies pushing a language. Tamil Nadu will be forced to learn Hindi to understand what is being communicated. Idk why this is so difficult for you to understand.
@@shivamanibalaji7151 hello dear brother. If Modi govt wants to communicate, he has to reply in the very same language and not in a languahe which he desires.
Even our courts in South India are so independent, well done Madras High Court.
What what is so independent in this
@@shivamanibalaji7151 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@EverywhereInfonetagree plenty of work to be done.
@@shivamanibalaji7151 Because supreme Court is slave of modi govt.
@Krishna Rajagopalan ya our courts still rot, change in India is not possible
I always believe that Tamil Nadu will save India from hegemony and linguistic suppression. It can be considered as a checks and balance situation in the system. Thank you TN
Sure bro, we Tamilians always stand with the oppressed clause in whatever kind. It's inherit in our blood.
A M E N
God Bless You For Noble Views and Hope it transpires and materialises,
Thanks Bro ❤
The useless fellow modi wants to show tamilnadu Punjab and kashmir are terrorist state even though both punjab and tamilnadu are doing their best . tamil income 65% have been taken as cst by union gov .
@@rmazim500 on
I m a keralite. Tamil is a very old language in the world. So do respect the language.
This is not just about goodness of Tamil, It's about forcing down Hindi on other states. Every state is proud of their language but they failed to combat Hindi imposition like how how TN did.
The South states need to team up to have one common language for the South. Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam. These are few of the main languages. You cannot expect every Indian to learn every language. We should have one for North/Central (Hindi), something for South and something for North East.
@@ShibasisPatnaik We are ok with English for communication. let's not complicate more than that. TN is not asking Centre to communicate in Tamil.
Not just tamil.. Every language
Hindi is the most foreign influenced language, and they are talking about Bharat culture
@@ShibasisPatnaik that by itself is imposing a language on someone. I'm a Tamil but let my neighbour brothers speak their own language. No culture or language deserve to die.
Once Mr. Mulayam Singh Yadav, then CM of UP, written some official letter in Hindi to then CM of Kerala Mr. EK Nayanar and EK Nayanar replied in Malayalam.
Haha ...savage 👍
Tit for tat.
That was the super one
Should be, even an MP have spoken in the parliament in malayalam
@@David-js4ib Now parliament members can speak in any of 22 languages given and need to give 24 hours advance notice.
Mother Tongue + English = Global formula
No, just because english is the most easiest and boring language
@@eropoe6032 Hindi is more boring to me
👏👍
Don't call it central government actually It's a union government
So, you are from the Tamil speaking province of the Indian subcontinent?
@@madhu3074 what we follow is a federal system, not a central power which has all the powers vested on it. In a federal system there is a concept of states and union where powers have been divided between them. For example currently the defence is under union while the law and order comes under state. The best way of a federalism is something like USA where states almost enjoy autonomy.
Note that USA follows federal system and they have states and not call them province.
Words like "federal", "union", etc are all in the constitution and not something that has been called out now.
@@RaviShankar-et3xc USA and India are not the same. In USA for eg you have state specific laws and in India you do not. There is only one law.
@@virtuosowins wow man how naive you are. Do you know anything about state powers, union powers and concurrent powers? Union government has no right to involve in the law and order of a state since that power comes under state. Each state has its own police department. Same way state has no powers in the foreign affairs and defence since it comes under union laws. And there are certain laws which is shared by both union and states which is known as concurrent powers. India and America both follow the same federal setup. In India its people like you who are so naive who don't know what our constitution says and thinks that union government is the sole central power of India. And who ever comes to power in the union takes advantage of the people's lack of understanding and tries to project as the only power house of India.
@@virtuosowins states can create its own laws. Like the meat ban, alcohol prohibition, free electricity, etc
States has many powers man but whoever comes to power in Delhi either BJP or Congress, they all try to take away state powers one by one. For example, education was under state powers all these years but at last few years under BJP, the states started to lose that and it went under union. Like NEET exams have been imposed on all states even though some states don't want it.
Well done Madras HC.
Thanks Ms. Arti. Well presented.
Earlier I was also thinking what was the problem in adopting Hindi as an official language. Now I understood the danger. Tamilnadu is standing for the Southern states.
If Hindi become the national langauge other language speaking people will become the second class citizens
Not only for southern states but also for different languages around India.
They are standing for their own political benefit. In Bengaluru and may parts of Karnataka, many adamant Tamilians (and people from other states) don't speak Kannada saying Bengaluru is a cosmopolitan city and we speak Tamil (or their mother tongue) and care a shit about the local language and culture. This language politics once started will not stop at Hindi, but will come back in circle to hunt down any other language that tries to sample local language and culture in a state. Only time will tell where this politics will take us.
We are still mentally colonised. We'll speak English but not the language which belong here. This lack of unity got us colonised.
@@akashbharati858 100% true. There is no harm in learning and speaking Hindi along with ones mother tongue. It is the regional politics in the name of language and state that the political parties play to divide us and grab power. There is no such thing as Dravidian or sotheren states. Each state is trying to step-over other to prove that they are better than the rest. Regional and language politics must be crushed, especially the leftist DMK and opportunist Shiv Sena goons.
And don't impose hindi on us punjabi's
Dear Punjabi's we tamils are with you
Your language is close to Hindi. If you feel like this, think about us Tamils who are not even closely related.
Shudh hindi defines india we are proud hindi should be made compulsory in all states as third language
@@bhargajavarao8614 odipoda dalda mandaiyaa 😄😄 Tamilnadu la vanthu itha soli paaru... Odavittu adipanunga ..
Ketta pasanga da 🔥
We are with you brother.
I am really impressed with Madras High Court for always standing with the interest of the State. It gives a great feeling that justice prevails in Tamil Nadu. Eagerly looking forward for justice by CJI in Rafael, Pegasus, Farmers Bill, Article 370 , Nation is burning with ND Modi abysmal Governance.
Yep, all the verdict on the said issues were delivered. It seems that you waiting for tamil copy.
Why the fuk© you are worried about articles 370.
Farm bill got activated in Tamilnadu assembly by DMK GOVERNMENT, YESTERDAY . EVERY BJP MEMBERS IN TAMILNADU, IS IN BACK BURN NOW 😆
This is important to all non hindi speaking states
@@cgpraveen4420 opposition fir the sake of opposition, no brains thats why
Tamil, Malayalam, Telugu, Kannada, Bengali, Punjabi, Odiya,..... cannot have inferior status to Hindi, which is the language in the states of the Hindi belt. We are all proud of our own languages and cultures and will not accept the domination of Hindi.
HINDI WILL RULE! ❤️
It's not domination it's a common sense that you can't adopt English as official language...India has diversified language and linguistics you need one official language to communicate with other state govt every state can't hire multiple language translators but it's more viable that every state can hire hindi translator ... I still question the common sense of person who gave this judgement I want to ask him should every state govt hire tamil, malyalam, Punjabi , haryanvi, sindhi,telugu, gujrati, chattisgarhi,oriya,kannad language translator or its better that every state must hire hindi typist and translator
@@akanksharoy7047 Beautiful reply!
@@akshaybhati Hindi is shit
@@akanksharoy7047 first understand the issue and then reply
Most of the people up north and west still think Hindi is the national language, maybe it’s time Tamil Nadu started a campaign to showcase its history .
Hey even here people thought like this. But there is no official language and even north and in west they don't have their mother tongue as hindi. West has most diverse language in india. In rajasthan alone you will have 100's of dialects. They say every 5 kms there will be slight variation in language.
And gujarat people say gujrati. I know english,hindi,tamil,(forgot kanada),marwadi. And I can say that
what you said is right.
Example Dravidian script were found in Indus valley civilization. So we all are actually one. We lived together. 👍
But That same link language can be hindi, why people don't oppose English.As if english is our mother tongue and our parents and locals can understand English and read and write it.Because without that they can't get jobs or money. Yeah I know imposing hindi is not right. Even I don't like it. But then how will people here learn it. Because it's necessary to connect indians.Even so called South india can't communicate to their neighbouring states as language differs.(kanada to tamil etc) English is only spoken by very few young people. Even that's is not their mother tongue. It's all politics. If we all know Hindi then you can understand everything in north india and it's politics. And this is not liked by other politicians here. They want you to be secluded.And use their owned media and serve information what they like in their language about north india. Even gujarat people speak Gujarati and Punjab people speak punjabi . So there also each and every person has their own mother tongue. Hindi isn't their mother tongue. But they learn all three languages. (English ,hindi and their mother tongue) So I think to connect to world English is needed,to connect to india (Hindi )and to state is their respective mother tongue.
What do you think.
@@human6729 north india should learn to converse in English. Simple.
Learn english so that the north can learn something about administration from the south.
What is Hindi ? In which geography Hindi belongs? Not only western India, even north ,central and east India have at least 29 / 30 schedule
Languages is recognised by our Constitution. But we are talking about not-existing_Hindi _ myth.
Even in Bihar there is bhozpuri, Maithili, Magdhy where a long traditional presents of poetic and prosiac works exist with much glory . Even Marathi Gujarati is for gotten by bjp _ shivsena and other ruling clicks. But our Hindi _ Hindu vakats are chanting for there majoritorian autocratic power.
@@narendharkumar3 it will take 2 to 3 generations to make every person in india understand english. Even a local from Karnataka can't understand anything tamil nadu as they know only kanada. Leave other languages. All this north ,east etc is different matter even in so called south there is so much diversity.
thats is what I am saying. People are ready to study foreign language.and are ready to be dominated by their language and culture. Wear like them ,have songs like them,eat like them etc.
The language of such people who looted everything even temples made famines, killed and raped , religious conversion and made our country a big zero till 1947. 🤣 Nice I like the way you think. 🤣
And just to have connection with everybody in india who aren't ready because in everyplace it's used. If you want to understand politics of whole india and parliament etc. you require it. Orelse you will depend on local channels owned by government and then you will get information what they like to give it to you. In ancient times people used to learn several languages to be in connection throughout the nation. Now I don't know what is happening.
Give me a better idea to unite india. After mandarin,hindi and urdu is second most spoken language then comes english. That too because of india. Otherwise English is nothing.
Samething are english speaking even burdened learning second language leave third language. And in north I think you haven't visited. Native Hindi speaking states aren't there. Example in gujarat it's gujrati and Punjab it's punjabi and Bihar there are five local languages and it goes on. So if you are in gujrat you are burdened with third language. They learn English,hindi and gujrati. So sir 🙏
@@human6729 If the Hindi speaking people had stopped excessive breeding, it would have been like any other local language.
Frankly, being a Hindi speaker, I don't see why it needs to be imposed on others. English is fine. Language at the end is just a means for communication, if South doesn't want Hindi, then we shouldn't force them on it. India isn't so shallow as to need a European style forced assimilation to maintain unity.
That's the most sane comment about the issue. Why union govt has to take a side with just 1 language to its own advantage at the expense of other languages. Because of Hindi many local spoken languages and culture died in North India. If only one language can unite India then we will be totally fragile by the anger from imposition but when we embrace our differences then we are bonded by mutual respect which will be harder to break. Same kind of flower doesn't make a garden beautiful.
It's really high time to break UP into three different states and cut down their loksabha seats from 85 to 60...why UP is always the deciding factor in case who will run the country...
How former CM Mr.Annadurai has faced the UN and his education and intelligence is quite far. When in UN some one asked him after he ended his speech "can you tell a word with out a,b,c. He immediately replied tell numeral from one to hundred. That is his proficiency in English.
A grandeur methamorphic words, few people can understand it...
Annadurai would easily win any political debate in English hands down even in today's standards. That was the level of proficiency he had.
Using a word thrice consecutively...
"No sentence ends with 'because' because, because is a conjunction." - Arigner C.N.Anna Durai.
English is a language not a knowledge
@@bestquotes2765 Well, that's your Level of knowledge to acknowledge or don't. You need basic to Knowledge to Understand and Practice any Language. 👍🏽
Even Nehru couldn't impose Hindi on Tamil Nadu, Modi is nothing compared to him. Tamils will never allow imposition of Hindi, Tamil language and culture is much older and rich than Hindi !
But you will speak English, coz it belongs to our colonisers. This lack of unity got us colonised and we are still mentally colonised
Will you learn to speak and write Tamizh???... It doesn't belong to the colonizers!!!... You won't i am sure even though it is native language. English is the default language which brought education to the masses for the first time in our nation, it may be the language of the invaders but we as a nation benefited from learning it. We would have never become the world's back office but for learning English!
@@akashbharati858 The only way you can impose language on someone is if they travel to another state to work. But the problem with that is south indians can learn north languages easily but its pretty difficult for northies to learn any south language fluently !
If any body dare to say that english is a colonial language then you must know that hindi is a foreign(colonial gov-modi gov) to us.we will never support hindi and modi. Tamil vellum.
@Akash Bharati English is almost a global language which is spoken not only in England but also in Australia, America and many other places, 🤡
North should learn from TN - court judgments, movies, state govt policies etc...we need urgently a non- Hindi prime minister
Bro dont speak something irrelevant
@JEET P. V. Narasimha Rao was south indian and also PM between 1991 to 1996
@JEET acha in tn hindus dont have unity what u say about that brahmins are never respected what learning
Deve Gowda🙂
@JEET sir for that he or she must have an appeal in india. For that we need more unity in the nation.
As Telugu, a respect to Tamilnadu standing for us. Thanks TN. Implementing RSS agenda won't work. Annadurai nailed it; respect.
I support judgement of madras high court
I bengali and I feel tamil people do wright thing.
Yeah, people didn't forget what happened when they tried to teach urdu to east bengalis 😅. Same will happen again.
@@abhignanm7630 to kisne bola waha urdu use nhi karte?😆😂😂😂
@@anubhavsays ??
@@NegetiveRizz ??
@@anubhavsays kaha urdu use ho raha hai Bengal main ???
Tamilnadu is the pioneer to oppose the stupidities imposed by Central government. Earlier Hindi. Now opposing NEET.
Neet is stupid you say?
@@satvikkeshtwal9566 Yes NEET as some flaws
@@oursoils2405 nothing us perfect.. but it fulfills it's aim which was to save college and student money as they won't be required to fill every individual form
@@satvikkeshtwal9566 nothing perfect means? who's interest it was saving, please see the ground reality
@@oursoils2405 NEET is a boon for the children who can afford coaching institutes but most of the families in india are middle class and for them 2 lakhs per year is a big thing
Congratulations Tamilnadu!
Tamil language is older than Sanskrit should be respected
Old is gold 🥇🏅💛🏆
@Ashish Mishra who is speaking Sanskrit??!! is there any good literature in Sanskrit!!!?? it is nowhere, Can anyone communicate in Sanskrit with the people of India???!!! now Tamil is still alive and tamil is spoken now in Europe, Singapore, Malaysia, Mauritius, Srilanka even in Canada!
@@yogendranbaptist3300 yes, currently seven villages in south exists that communicate in sanskrit, speaks sanskrit, write and does many thing in sanskrit... There are many literature, writing, and documents in sanskrit that exists but are not made public in order to research and proper documentation, once it is well prepared then it will be made public...
@@anu3798 sanskrit is dead language dont talk about it
It destroy the North India languages
@@hariharanharan5218 not entirely.. In cbse board schools, and also in private medium schools sanskrit are still taught, also in maharashtra a sanskrit institute is established few years back..
I love how Mr Annadurai was forced to compare Hindi to rats and crows!! To the North - we are Dravidians and we were here before India was and very before you nomads wandered into the North!! Do not underestimate us!? Do not look down on us!! We are proud Dravidians!!
Actually we are a mixed race. Everyone of us have both Aryan as well as Dravidian DNA. We got mixed during the IVC before migrating to other parts of India. Only in the past 1000 years we stopped mingling due to the caste system. So don't assume that the dark skins are Dravidians and light skins are Aryans.
@@mkrishnaraj1 ur saying tamil & brahmic dialetic in one of comment.here u says mixed dna..actually who are u,wat u know about tamilians..just dnt bluff just like tat..
We can point out easily ur mixed so u takes aryan with tamilians..
Cows ate enough to compare these aryans
why at all the need for a national language. Unity in diversity has always been our motto. All are free to speak any language without any imposition
Agree.
How to talk then if state donot interact how development will happen?
That same link language can be hindi, why people don't oppose English.Because without that they can't get jobs or money. Yeah I know imposing hindi is not right. Even I don't like it. But then how will people here learn it. Because it's necessary to connect indians.Even so called South india can't communicate to their neighbouring states as language differs. English is only spoken by very few young people. Even that's is not their mother tongue. It's all politics. If we all know Hindi then you can understand everything in north india and it's politics. And this is not liked by other politicians here. They want you to be secluded.And use their owned media and serve information what they like in their language about north india. Even gujarat people speak Gujarati and Punjab people speak punjabi . So there also each and every person has their own mother tongue. Hindi isn't their mother tongue. But they learn all three languages. (English ,hindi and their mother tongue) So I think to connect to world English is needed,to connect to india (Hindi )and to state is their respective mother tongue.
What do you think.
@@human6729 Can hindi speakers learn any of other languages like Tamil, Telugu, Kannada or Malayalam. Learning hindi or english both have same difficulties for non hindi speakers. Then why should I learn additional language on top of native language and English?
@@human6729 English is a foreign language that has no cultural significance to Indians meaning it can be a neutral language that everyone can use without any reservations .
செந்தமிழ் நாடெனும் போதினிலே இன்பத் தேன் வந்து பாயுது காதினிலே. தமிழ் எங்கள் உயிருக்கு நேர்.
We Tamils are ready to learn Hindi. But don't impose it on us, by making us learn it, don't erase our identity, our culture, our practices and don't impose your Vedic Religion, Caste System and Religious fanaticism here on us.
Good
😊👍
It is also happening in maharashtra, we are ready to learn hindi but they are forcing language. due to this culture of marathi language and existance is in danger.
Why cant northies learn tamil?
@@kamartaj3010 I think they are waiting for the North Indians to learn Tamil first.
as a hindi speaking north indian, i am in full support of rhe madras high court and tamil nadu
This language problem is not only in the Southern but also in the Easter & Northeastern states.
Hindi will be spread if a talent person like our taminadu c.m stalin could be indian P.M
Modi is worest
stalin us best
Modi is selling all union gov property
tamilnadu c.m will earn state gov property .
Yes this sentiment is in Maharashtra as well
@@arunachalam1996 no sir. Only a person like daya maran can become CM..You know our MK sent Daya to cabinet and said clearly to ppl who complained that he is sending his relatives and all. because he knows hindi only he was made a minister.
Stalin will send our udhay anna.
Yeah ,but the problem is the other states they didn't opppose strongly ..other states must come together to fight against.shame on Indians they always ask me being an Indian why don't you speak Hindi ..
@@hulu8022 Bangalore is a typical example.
Even in IT offices , non hindi speakers are cornered.Am not blaming every hindi speakers but majority of them thinks that you are not a capable person if you dont speak hindi.. I dont understand what kind of nonnsense is this.
Though there are good mannered hindi people are present, its these arrogant crooks making noise & weaken the diversity.
Mr.S.Venkatesan has done a great job.HC has given a just judgment. Both are thankful in protecting our regional and linguistic minority rights
I am from Maharashtra ,
I love marathi , tamil,hindi , telugu and more language but I always hate to monopoly of language specially hindi .
Shri Annadurai's quote at the end of the video is superb!
I was going to post the same comment you posted 😎 we didn't choose majority for them why should we do for Language
not cheeeri, its Thiru, we meanTHEEEERUUU!!
Use Thiru not Shri
@@avinash601111004 Yes, agreed
@@reganjoans Yes, agreed 👍
Every one's mother tongue is the binding factor for that person. And what is the point of Hindi being imposed on others. It's a language used in one state UP. Each state has its own language and every one is proud of their own. Hats off to the court for giving such positive judgement. And Tamil is the most poetic and oldest language in the world.
Please respect every regional languages, Every language had own sentiments.. Beauty of the india is different languages, different religions and different cultures..
Agree.
Please continue to remain more humble like this, we respect every district language including including ongole fraudulent chinnamelam's original mother tongue which is never tamil.
Tell me then why we need English to communicate with rest of states.. we accept English to communicate but not Hindi.. which is our Indian language.
@@AmitYadav-fc1dj why not you accept Tamil, Kannada,Malayalam to communicate.
If you don't accept then accepts others right not to accept.
We Kolhanians love and support to all Tamils !
A direct slam on the face of Hindi chauvinists, on Hindi imposition.
What C N. Annadurai a.k.a. Anna had the fitting answer, why not the national bird a crow as it's seen North, South, East and West? Why not the national animal rat as it's found every corner. A fitting answer to the unlettered Amit Shah who argues Hindi is spoken by a majority.
Nice ❤️
Anna ku kusumbu 😂
So tell me how u communicate to rest of the states .. seriously u are ready to accept ENGLISH but not ur own country language ... And by saying these type of words u insulting Hindi which is another people mother tongue .. let me tell u GUJARATI is a mother tongue of modi .. not hindi .. requesting u don't think as political way, just think for ur country .. language barrier is the major problem to communicate with another states..
@@AmitYadav-fc1dj
Mr. Yadav :
...may be you're young or do not know the veridical facts what really did happen before dividing the states as for easy administration : eminent linguistics of the 1940 s had wanted almost straight lines ( exactly as in the US ) to divide disregarding the division on the basis of language but the less - visionaries and the Hindi chauvinists ( including the chameleon Rajaji ) Nehru & Patel wanted states on the basis of language. The ulterior motive of Hindi imposition is coming true which certainly would disintegrate unity, in the future.
Do not blabber Mr. Yadav.
Weldon,... Tamilanda..... we south Indians support this move 👍
Udane started off tamilanda..myruda nnu.,.. nee ellaam than tn maanatha vangureenga.. be humble be inclusive... It's true that all languages are equal in our federal republic... But for someone's action romba peethakkadhe...😏..modhalla unga oorla nadakkira female infantide, varadakshinai kodumai , jaathi veriyellam niruthi kaattungada ... Appo othukkarom ...😤
@@tinklingcrystals6489 first can you all four south indian states people understand each other languages. Like kanada people know telugu, malayalam and tamil?
bro as if in north india everybody speaks hindi. No. There also same thing as tamil nadu. States have their mother tongue. Gujarat people speak gujrati ,punjab people punjabi,and it goes on.
And Dravidian script was found in Indus valley civilization. And venkateshwara suprabhatam ( kousaliya Subraja rama etc hymn )which is performed in temples in south india and people show their prayers is in sanskrit.even tamil words are there in Korean and in sanskrit etc. So it needs a deep analysis and research. So we have lost our culture our identity of being a spiritual country who was in search of truth and this kept us united.
@@tinklingcrystals6489 പോടാ....പു
@@tinklingcrystals6489 yen da unnaku erithu sollu un appan vadaka na
@@human6729 half bake dnt blabber wat u know,wat they taught u..while speaking to tamilians speak with evidences..tamilians speaks only by evidences..why ur north gov is afraid of tamilians & unity of south indians..bcoz they know very well south indians are inter linked with north indian states..TN will come to power to rule india
Just because modi cannot speak English
the rest of the English speaking states need not follow that, the solution will be,
for one man Modi should attempt to learn English, instead of millions in southern states should learn Hindhisend a good English teacher to New Delhi
😂😂😂
😆
😂😂👏👏 well said
True
😅😅😅
When most of india voted for modi , tamil nadu said no . When most of india was ok for hindi imposition, tamil nadu said no.
What about islamic Madrsha's uses Urdu aren't they disrespact local languages ?
@@smartbaba1321 they do , but have you seen any order from center to state in urdhu. If it come we will raise for that occasion also.
Also if they try to impose urdhu we will say no to that .
Most of India was OK with Hindu imposition?? Wher do u get ur facts from?? Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Entire North East, Telangana, Punjab, Kashmir, Tamil Nadu , Lakshwadeep Have Opposed...
Kerala also Voted NO.....to BJP
Your pronunciation of 'Thamizh' (instead of Tamil) is highly appreciated Mam...Thanks...
Good judgement. Long live Tamil. Respect all the languages.
Excellent finishing by using Annadurai words. Tamilan da...
I consider this judgement as a hottest & prompt slap on the face of Modi & his group for their excessive arrogance in various ways. A party is elected by people to exercise governance absorbing the likes & dislikes of the people who voted them to power. But these fellows are doing just the opposite. .
Your thoughts are rotten and the arrogance of tamil is clearly seen. He is PM for entire India not just Hindi land. The way you expressed shows the disconnect. You should think one more time. Agreed that one should respect each others language.
@@cgpraveen4420 We have a law enacted by the union Government that TN is exempted from Hindi. We got that law after losing around 500 lives.
Court had given verdict on the basis of THAT LAW.
A PM has to abide the law of the land, which he has not.
There are plenty of such instances, Tamil was removed ine ATM, bank challans, union Government forms etc.,
@@369Thinkandgrow my support is with you.
@@cgpraveen4420 - We must expect our law makers to act as per constitution, Failing which it is our duty to call out in strongest words possible to behave. Else their arrogance will harm more to the country.
@@jtselvan9352 I agree with you, but there is always a better way to express the same. And Hindi is not a foreign language. We can protest for our identity and culture, it is our right as well.
I would like to give the same reply which Mr Annadurai give into the union government
It is very unfortunate the leaders from north India have no capacity to understand
Hindi won't be unifying language but will make non-hindi speaking Indians second class citizens.
@@EverywhereInfonet yeah we will oppose even more than this in comming years
Tamil language is the mother of all languages in the universe!!!!
This is foolishness. Tamil is the least modified version of dhimidaka which is mother to 4 languages telugu malayalam tamil and kannada.
@@pjroy5052 i m sorry. What sangi?
@@ripsanskrit3609 iam sorry have some job stop spamming
What bullshit are you talking?
Yes tamilian language is oldest than sanskrit.....thirsty modi bhakts don't like this history fact
All languages in India, must be respected 🇮🇳🙏
"All living language "
How can Hindi be great than Tamil when Tamil is the oldest language in the world. More than 5000 years old and the Dravidian culture the best polite one in the world. The truth is that Hindi is an artificially created language, and is not the common man's language, even in the so-called Hindi-speaking belt of India. The language of the common man in the cities of the Hindi-speaking belt is not Hindi but Hindustani or Khadiboli (in rural areas, there are a large number of different dialects e.g., Avadhi, Brijbhasha, Bhojpuri, Maithili, Maghai, Mewari, Marwari, many of which Hindustani speakers will not even understand).
To explain the difference between Hindi and Hindustani, we may take a simple example. In Hindustani, we say Udhar dekhiye (look there). But for the same in Hindi, we say Udhar avlokan keejiye. Now, the common man will never say avlokan, and will always say dekhiye.
Up to 1947, Urdu was the language of the educated class of all communities in large parts of India, whether they were Hindu, Muslim, Sikh and other communities, while Hindustani was the language of the uneducated common man (in urban areas).
The British rulers artificially created Hindi through their agents like Bhartendu Harishchandra, as part of their divide-and-rule policy, and propagated the claim that Hindi is the language of Hindus, while Urdu is the language of Muslims (though, as mentioned previously, Urdu was the common language of both Hindus and Muslims among the educated class up to 1947).
To create this artificial language, what the Hindi bigots (who were objectively British agents) did was to hatefully replace Persian or Arabic words, which had entered common usage, by Sanskrit words, which were not in common usage (and so were difficult to understand).
💯💯
exactly
Half of the words in Tamil are imaginary. For that matter Telugu is far better language than Tamil. Telugu has the largest word set.
What is your reference that Tamil is 5000 year old language? I note that this claim is being repeated ad nauseum by many people.
@@cgpraveen4420 The carbon dating of the latest finding, was 1200 BC (Done at USA- announced by the CM on 8.9.21).
Most of the pot writings, marked after the pot is burnt. Means it's written by the end user, a common man(not by the Potter), which means common people were literate in Tamil language.
We are discussing Hindi imposition here, Why you need to compare it with Telugu?
We miss scholars like Annadurai in TN politics now. He had marvellous knowledge in both Tamil and English. His use of 'Because' three times in a row is a famous one too. No wonder he is fondly called Arignar Anna by us Tamils.
👍👍👍
👍👍👍
Salute to Madras High court for standing by the state's interest.
All south Indians are very proud of their mother tongue ......I hate hindi I don't like Hindi...I choose only English and my mother tongue malayalam 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Leave India then...
India is Hindi and Hindi is India
@@kingnole4237with out southindia , real india is not existed........
@@kingnole4237 If we had made a country only consisting of hindi speaking population, it would be so bad that even African countries are much better. I mean, only somewhat devoloper states in the region (gujrat,punjab) also don't speak Hindi.
@@kingnole4237 Only reason South Indian states decided to join India was the cultural brotherhood it felt towards rest of India, and then leaders decided to respect the diversity of languages. Has it been some nutjobs like you in the leadership, it's pretty evident that South Indians wouldn't bat an eye to create an independent state.
@@kingnole4237 then you go to Pakistan because they speak Hindi and separate Hindi speaking land from rest of non hindi speaking language states like dravidam ( Tamilnadu, Andra, Telangana, Kerala and Karnataka) and our neighbours who are proud of their languages like Maharashtra, orisa, Bengal and punjabi.
Most expressive language of the world, your expression and meaning are same in most of Tamil languages, as a south Indian we are proud of Tamil language," Kopam" (angry) "sirippu "(smile) expression are realistic 👍🙏
I am from kerala ...I like this most ancient living language in the world ...
கோபம் வடமொழி. தமிழில் சினம்
@@HighlifeC எந்த வடமொழி சகோ, ஹிந்தியில் "குஸ்ஸா". வேறு எந்த வடமொழி. எனக்கு தெரிந்த வரையில் ஒரு சாதியின் பெயர் கோபா (யாதவர்) என்று கூறுவர்.
@@geminira4743 நான் சொன்னது முற்றிலும் சரி இல்லை.. மன்னிக்கவும்.
//இப்பொழுது கோபம் என்ற சொல்லாட்சியைப் பயன்படுத்துகின்றோம் அல்லவா? அச்சொல்லுக்கு பல பெயர்கள் சங்க இலக்கியத்தில் காணப்பெறுகின்றன.கோபம் என்னும் சொல் சங்க நூல்களில் இந்திரகோபப் பூச்சிகளைக் குறிதனவே ஒழிய சினம் என்பதைக் குறிக்கவில்லை.பிற்காலத்தில் தான் சினம் என்பதற்கு கோவம் கோபம்,என்ற சொல்லட்சிகள் வழக்கில் வந்தன.
கோபம் என்பதே சரியான சொல்வழக்கு.அனால் பேச்சு வழக்கில் கோவம் என்று கூறுகின்றோம்.
சினம் குறித்த சொற்கள்....என்று தேடவும். மேலதிக தகவலுக்கு
Try learning Tamil Literature. You will be amazed how these people could have thought 2000 years ago.
HC is right , Hindi is not the National Language but official Language . Imposing Hindi against the federal structure of India.
no it is national language
but not only hindi there are 22 official language
according to constitution all are same
hindi is not superior
@@kedar_official2890 no yar.. hindi is not a national language..
It's in law.. read tat articles given by court
Our beloved Anna's quote is timely and logical.
👍👍👍
தமிழ் வெல்க. Win Tamil...We do respect all other languages. Don't impose any
I don't understand what u mean by imposing? Did any one from centre told you to abandon tamil and take up hindi next day.
@@Abhi-kt4sh Yes they said that; without knowing please don't talk
@@Arjun-di7bi get me the proof if u have such and pls don't spread rubbish lies .
@@Abhi-kt4sh there is a saying in Tamil "adika adika ammiyum nagarum" which roughly means "even big stones can be moved with many small pushes" that how small small pushes of one language may lead to extinction of another language. now government will reply in Hindi, next day it will expect us to reply in Hindi, next week ask us to speak in Hindi, next month English will be removed saying "you understand Hindi right ,then why english" and then ask us to learn Hindi first, next year use of mother tongue in public places will be reduced saying "you know Hindi right", in next 5 years there will be no use of mother tongue in common places, in a decade there will be no languages.
If you say this won't happen see the situation of native UP and Bihar Languages.
@@logeswaran1823 my friend, your concerns are just assumptions.
In bihar everybody accepts hindi as a common language at the same time their affiliation towards bhojpuri is never at loggerheads. They even have bhojpuri film industry as such.
There is also a saying in tamil "பிறர் மீது சேறு பூசுபவன் தன் மீது அதிகம் பூசிக்கொள்வான்".
So don't hate other languages just embrace it with love while keeping your culture intact.
Excellent judgement by the High court of Chennai. The central government BJP should learn english to be able to communicate with other states.
When Nehru could not impose Hindi inspite of sending Army to Tamil Nadu how the heck Modi can do it.
Why godi media not shouting deshbakti.
This is colonial hangover. Love for foreign language is a matter of shame.
@@cgpraveen4420 This is love for our own language and our identity Mr. Praveen.
@@cgpraveen4420 Love to save your own mother tongue, but still operate with the lingua franca of the world in order to be competitive surpasses everything else. Live and let live is the motto!
@@cgpraveen4420 Ok, we have colonial hangover. Let it be.
Please be enlightened to know that you are in Persian+Urdu hangover.
Besides, You have expressed your thoughts in that colonial language.
@@meetvino I do agree, but I feel sick for the love of foreign language. I am live example, though I am maharastrian Born in Kannada land, and brought up in Telugu speaking land. Now I am not good in any of these languages expect English. I feel ashamed. Now tell me what is right.
Annadurai, has given a fitting reply.
Language is a means of communication.
Yet again you guys have done a great job in talking this issue when the so called national media fails
Only Kannada(main language) & English(link language) in karnataka. Foot to Hindi.
Next to Tamils, Kannadigas are the people proud of their language. Others should also follow that and kick Hindi from their respective states.
@@mkrishnaraj1 Mohan Anna kick nu solla vendam, hindi namma mozhiya Vida rombha chinna karu... atha vekka vendiya edathila vappom.. kick nu bad uh solla vendam!!
dude speak whatever language you want but respect every language. you want to oppose hindi kudos to u !! people in the north really don't give a damn about you speaking hindi or not . My point is atleast respect the language spoken by crores of people of your own country. We love languages from south,west,east.
@@siyachauhan7331 Before commenting on an issue, get some knowledge on that topic. We won't be discussing about Hindi if it is not imposed on us. Have you seen anyone discussing/hating any other N. Indian languages?
India as a country exists only in the past 75 years. Hindi is as alien as English to us.
Have you questioned why Hindi become the most spoken language in India? For the past 50 years the Southern states started family planning and have only two kids. The Hindi speaking belt keep breeding without any control which increased their population. Looks like you missed the final comment by Mr. Annadurai. If we go by the same logic of Hindi being majority spoken language and should be the National language, then crow should be our National Bird and rat should be our National Animal.
@@siyachauhan7331 we dravidians don’t give a damn about what these hindi belt thinks and does.
We don’t even know what ur PM says on stage
But we pay our tax money and u people live with it and u should feel ashamed for it.
U people impose it and when it comes to us we will kick or do anything with it
Even as someone not from TN, I agree with TN's stand. First, the law is there (though point 3 is nonsensical). Second, it makes no sense for Centre to communicate with a State in a language the state may not understand. I believe there are advantages to having a common national language, but seems the issue has not been addressed correctly historically as well. The ending was hilarious though 😁
Though it sounds hilarious It is the famous quote of "Aringnar" Anna made in the Indian parliament in 1965 reflecting the sentiments of the people of non Hindi speaking states.
World's oldest Language is Tamil Not Sanskrit . Be proud in Tamil language.👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
I think both have common basis that is sign language. 🤣Sorry for that.
I think both are pretty old . It's tough to say which was oldest.
And Dravidian script was found in Indus valley civilization.
TN will teach hindiya true democracy and will lead it in right secular socio-economic justice path
Now Imran say Tamil Hindus are good and Northern Hindus are bed.... But Quran speaks same for infidel i.e who worships other god. To convert of kill... Don't you try to divide us Hindus and other Indians Dharms.
Btw where in the world and how many muslim majority country habe True democracy.... State of democracy over their is shadowed by Sharia laws.... Seem derogatory comparing Ind with those.
@@jaynitpethani2266 don't imply religion with culture, civilization and ethnicity.come out of your religious fanatism open your mind otherwise you will not understand what i say stop follow everything blindly
Nowadays it's become a usual practice for pur beloved govt. to get slamming from the honorable courts pertaining to the matter of civil rights.
But their skin is too thick!!
Thick Skinned having a skin akin to a Rhinoceros.
@@rmazim500 Even the Rhinoceros skin is thin compared to that of the fanatics ruling our Nation
TN leads Anna's footsteps, in a bi-lingual stance, as usual, well summarized!
Great leaders in history always respected regional sovereignty, our National building father were able see unity in diversity ,but now fanatics rule is dragging our Nation towards doom
So well put.
If a coward and traitor as EPS has the spine to resist the union government in the language issues, how much more are to expected from a government both strong and brave as well. As Stalin told once, imposing Hindi will have the impact as like stirring hornet's nest.
Central govt should think more on development instead of thinking on cows ,, language and regional culture
It is because of English that several crores of Indians are getting jobs. Thanks for bringing out the truth how Tamils intelligently retained English for the whole country.
Super judgement
Thanks Madras HC for taking a stand
-from all non hindi speaking states.
Tamil is mother language of all Indian languages including sanskrit...🤗
Just like the Hindi Language Should Not be Imposed on Any Other State Similarly BJP Rule Should Not be Imposed on Any Non Hindi State. Non Hindi States will Definitely Free Themselves of the BJP party and Not only Hasten their Progress in Every Sphere of Development but Also Free Themselves From The Shackles of Religion Being the Most Divisive Factor LeadingReaping Hatred Among Human Beings n Neighbours ! Do not Neglect this at Any Cost !!!
Why bro you want to convert more hindus to Christianity ??
Off course their main motto
But we'll speak English. Language of our colonisers. We are mentally colonised and this lack of unity got us colonised
All this when we have a prime minister who sounds like a kindergarten student when he attempts to speak in Hindi...Dolaaaan Trump🤣🤣
Yep. That's why he is PM and you are passing out in you tube.
@@cgpraveen4420 every one is/was not a ruler.
He just came bec of religious riots .. if religion is not his key point, he will never be a PM
@@naankadavul5136 well replied to this Chu. Fellow.. modi is mass murderer ...he is murderer HM haram pandya .... Modi is modern India's NERO .. HC Gujarat....
@@naankadavul5136 I am not a kindergarten student ,don't try to teach me. It's your perception, keep it with you.
@@RakeshGupta-qu9yj tu hoga chu Mai nahi. Agar g me dum he to Supreme Court ka verdict ko challenge kar. Y'a chup Betga chu.
Excellent push back by m TN highcourt. HC court really understands the ligustic culture of TN very well. Thanks for all HC judges to push back.
Save Media, save Judiciary, save democracy, save the Nation
Yes Save from who and what? RSS-BJP?
Ok. So vote BJP only...
@@amitpadhye7509 BJP has already divided the country based on religion. Now they will divide based on language by imposing Hindi.
Save this nation by boycotting bjp rss...
"Common Crow Vs peacock and rat Vs Tiger...." Awesome Logic!! Superb rebuttal...!! Simply Genius!! Permanently recorded in Indian history...
CN Annadural deserves a Parliamentary Standing Ovation...👏👏👏👏🎉🎉🎉
This is a good judgement!
What if center communicates to UP govt in Tamil? Will UP readily accept it???
I'm from Tamil Nadu. I feel how effectively Europe is functioning? People speak French in France, Italian in Italy, Dutch in the Netherlands, and so on. All together they are the "European Union" of multiple nations in Europe. In India, we are 28 states who have our language and governing in our mother tongue. Which sole country has this wonder in a single country? We should feel proud of how organically India is made of diversity. If India Focuses on infrastructure development and poverty eradication. Every other problem will fall in its place.
Bonus info : Tamil is also an official language in Sri Lanka, Singapore and has significant numbers of speakers in Malaysia, Mauritius, Fiji, and South Africa. Singapore and Sri Lanka still uses Tamil language in their currency bills.
Annadurai's Quote is awesome. He still lives by his words even after so many years.
After watching this video, I would say then, every Indian should be grateful to the DMK party of Tamilnadu. Because, if at all, they did not protest back in 1965, we could not have caught up with Computer era which started in 1980s. Imagine, what we would be doing without being one of the leading countries in computer field and moreover, nobody would have gone out of India for Jobs.
@Paul Dr: Thank the 1920s Justice party of Madras Presidency. Read about it. That presidency was there in 5-7 languages of regions from Odiya, Telugu, Tamil, Malayalam, Kannada, Tulu & Konkan but never imposed Tamil or Telugu or any one language on other regional people. Interesting facts are there.
Indian Union must remain diversed.
Diversity is a gift from GOD. Every nation within India must be given equality. European Union is a way forward for Indian model. Decentralize everything except for Currency and SECURITY.
Said it right . The India should be the Federation of Nations
Yes, the Modi Government or any other Central Governments should not impose Hindi on Southern Indian States. The Madras HC is right in their judgement against Linguistic Fanaticism.
Centre should start celebrating Hindi and Indian languages day respecting our constitution, instead of celebrating only' Hindi Day' which is not acceptable to non Hindi states all over India.
Granpa Modi will do it,if his 'religious politics' didn't work again.You know,playing using sentiments...Failing to win is nearly impossible.
Anna is a great politician n thinker. We need to respect all or keep crow n rat as suggested …..
Hindi people also respect respect South Indians, but these Hindi Politicians want to Impose Hindi upon South Indians and create hatred among Indians and play their dirty politics.
Keep your language with you..... This is great "TAMIL NADU" hindi will be abolished from our mother land Tamil Nadu
You are not a tamizhian Muslim so just shut up minorities in Tamilnadu have destroyed real tamizh culture by dk dmk really once you people are thrown out tamizhnadu will be heaven hindi tamizh indian languages we are proud of it
@@bhargajavarao8614 Idiot I embraced Islam my mother tongue and land is Tamil....
@@bhargajavarao8614 My Tamil Muslim brothers are Tamilians. Will support everyone who speaks Tamil, we are proud of our language identity. Tamil will be here for millions of years to come. Get lost Hindi boy.
@@bhargajavarao8614 middle finger for you dear brother
@@muhammadaltamizh3338 So you learn quran in Tamil or english right..
It is very difficult to open a SB account in a Natinalised bank because the five page forn has only English and Hindi that too in very small letters to limit the pages.
People often forget the reason behind the formation of Bangladesh out of East Pakistan, People who think one language should rule over others should revisit the formation of Bangladesh. We dont want anything like that happening in our land.
YES THE PREVIOUS CREATION OF A NATION UNDER RELIGIOUS HOMOGENITY COULD NOT BE DIGESTED BY BENGALIS ESPECIALLY THE DOMINATION OF PEOPLE SPEAKING SOME OTHER LANGUAGE HENCE THEY WANTED A LINGUISTIC BASED NATION. GENERALLY ALL OVER THE WORLD DEMOCRATICALLY FUNCTIONING NATION STATES HAVE BEEN FORMED BASED THE IDENTITY OF LANGUAGE. COLLAPSE OF SOVIET UNION IS AN APT EXAMPLE. THERE MAY BE SOME EXCEPTIONS.
PM Nehru had to put out numerous fires, often times compromising or softening his own stand. In many cases his word was what tided over situations before a more formal and permanent solution could be had. Contemporary leaders would be well advised not to lit fires extinguished by those who came before them. The language question in India has been satisfactorily resolved to preserve peace.
I think you are andbhakt
You better write in Hindi,your english here makes no sense 😅 😝
Tamil is the Oldest Language in the Subcontinent. The Number System of Harappan Civilization is Very Close to the Signs available on the Iron Age Pottery from Tamil Nadu. Language of Yamnaya Invaders will Never Replace Our Mother Tongue. 😡☝
Well english is already replacing it 😂😂😂😂😂
@@jonron3805 Nan thamizhil mozhindhal vilangumaa da unakku ? Thee chhollai payanpaduthuvatharkul odividu !! Vanthutan Velakkenna !!
Mani sir avanidathil thamizhil pesungal, payan odiduvaan ... I just want to see whether those vocal elites are really talented to comprehend our conversations in our tongue!!
@@samuelvijayakumar1871 Ben chole teri moul ke de rahi nani polebe coged.
I bet you did not understand this ...now bugger off
@@samuelvijayakumar1871 avanidathil hindi pesungal, payan odiduvaan. Pirikkamal onraka velai ceyya karrkkollunkal
Let it be known that Hindi is not Rashtra Bhasha of our country. It's propoganda
I love the kind of journalism you do.. keep up the good work
India is a union of states. So every state must be given respect and equality. I'm really waiting for that hindi speaking community in the Parliament to speak in english. From now everyone will understand what people are speaking in parliament.
Where does this concept of one nation one blah blah blah derived from!?
Even in the constitution we have clear words, Union of states. Throw away this concept. At this age of high technical & manpower what is that thing which forbids you from communicating with each state in their respective languages.
It is not just enough if you are wearing there native dresses and posing. You have to look into their lifestyle in the true sense.
With duty comes responsibility.
I appreciate you dear admin for presenting this topic.
Great going Aarti! Appreciate your "to the point" journalism.
Kannada,telugu, malayalam, tamil are older than hindi. Respect your elders.we will decide if we want hindi or not .not u mr modi and shah
That finishing quote though...a light-hearted Delight! 😄
Perarignar Anna...Legend has it that he was always oozing with Charisma!
🖤♥️🖤♥️
Forget about bringing it down, The great Dravidian wall, can never even be touched by any Horned Devil...Be it a Union Ruling Bald Beardo or his Sidekick, Bald Fatso or any Bald Buffoon wearing Saffron.
Respect every language! Don't make us stand up against yours...
Yours Sincerely,
A Dravidian Stock
A tamil automan obviously talk to a North Indian traveller in English with the amount of language that he knows knowing that he doesn't speak tamil. But educated bureaucrats don't know to communicate in English to a state that don't speak hindi. தமிழன் don't speak hindi even if he knows.
South knows good English ... Seems this is the only states fighting for their rights