The bass in this song is so simple but gets me every time. Perfect tone, feel, complement to the rest of the music. Also, this was the best Manson lineup - hands down.
His performances are so powerful... I was at this tour in Minnesota. It was one of the best concert experiences of my entire life.... I wish that I was good enough.... then I'd know that I am not alone... MM.
You left this comment eight years ago, but I hope you’re alive, healthy (or somewhere near it), and happy (or somewhere near it). And I hope you know now that you are good enough.
from Portrait to Holy Wood, there's one song per album he played live. in cronological order: Down in the park, Dried up..., Coma White, In the Shadows of the valley...
This is the very best of my MM songs. This song is wicked, it make me cry as often as I play it since 2002 till date. I can never get tired of this song. 'I wish that I could be the king, then I know that I am not alone'.wicked. .
Holy shit!... Okay, so half way through, the weed kicked in, and that was the most beautiful intense thing I've ever seen. The last two minutes absolutely blew my mind
This video just took me back to my teenage years and the very feeling i used to feel when listening to this song. Still a very powerful one, even after all these years...
My favorite Manson song. I'm so happy to see that it has actually been played live, even if I'll never get the chance to see it. I'm really glad I stumbled on this video, I watch it so much.
The best and most dramatic track on that CD, and possibly my favorite song he ever sang, that and The Last day on earth, The reflecting God, and Sweet Dreams, anyway, This is an excellent performance! Manson's perfect vocals on this track. Thanks for posting this, I don't think they played this track very much during that tour, Great Song! When was this recoded? do you have the whole concert? if so, please post it.
***** I made the comment 3 months ago, and I stand by my opinion that this was one of the best songs they ever wrote, and this live version shows just how great his live vocals used to be, it's sad that he cant sustain a change in pitch very long now a days (live), but he's still the greatest performer of experimental Hard Rock/industrial Rock In my opinion.
I love this song, the lyrics are so well written, I actually feel worthless at times, but it's true that there are others who feel the same, so I'm not alone
I never tire of watching this video because this song is just amazing . So emotional and deepness. This day was just the best version of this song. I heard in Hiroshima concert this version of In the shadow of the valley of death" but no as emotional and deep than this video. The notes of the keyboard is just perfect on this video, in Hiroshima the version was a little bit different. For me Sweet dreams Live 1997 and this song on this video: this is MANSON !!!!
Хотелось бы сказать пару слов... Я из России, очень хорошо видно, что песня описывает через мелодию домашнее насилие. Оно распространено, как мне кажется, в каждой стране - буквально та часть, где начинается разъёб очень хорошо демонстрирует весь пиздец происходящего, будто пьяный отец начинает пиздится с женой, когда на это смотрит лирический герой (вероятно подросток, которым можете быть вы на месте главного героя). Я был бы рад оказаться на концерте Мэнсона, когда он находился ещё на пике популярности, будем честны - тухляк сейчас и старпёр какой-то на сцене сверкает. Я уважаю Мэнсона за то, что он даёт возможность быть услышанным (по крайней мере в раннем творчестве это очень ярко выражается) в своих работах и это live-версия буквально вдохновляет меня самого делать также - это то, что вдохновит каждого) Thank you for this video, thank you from Russia;)
this is such a great performance , of my favourite aong. such a shame he does not perform it more often, yet the rarity makes it the more special to me.
Ok guys I think we all love this song am I right? Well we should demand for Manson to play songs like coma white and speed of pain an man that you fear and more live!!!! Who's with me?
"We have no future" in this song is also in The Death Song ( "We've got no future" ) but from a different point of view. Half the song from this album are from the point of view of HOLY WOOD.
#marilynmanson, this song is killing me 💔 every time. I will always stand by you. I want you back. #marilynmansonuncancelled #marilynmansonisinnocent #justiceformarilynmanson
![Marilyn Manson - "Apple Of Sodom" [Live]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BjpwmyysSl0/mqdefault.jpg)
It's really hard for me not to cry listening to this
The perfect song to listen too while driving around on a gloomy fall day.
Rainy days hit with this
The speed of pain listen
this song is magic... like man that you fear and the speed of pain!
The bass in this song is so simple but gets me every time. Perfect tone, feel, complement to the rest of the music. Also, this was the best Manson lineup - hands down.
This album and tour really was his finest hour. He never really regained that energy and drive after this era. The lineup was perfect too
Wish they would play this more often
Yes me too
His performances are so powerful... I was at this tour in Minnesota. It was one of the best concert experiences of my entire life.... I wish that I was good enough.... then I'd know that I am not alone... MM.
You left this comment eight years ago, but I hope you’re alive, healthy (or somewhere near it), and happy (or somewhere near it). And I hope you know now that you are good enough.
She put no seeds in me :( LMFAOO
3:44 that scream is so powerfuĺl ..
I never knew they played this song live. Also have never seen Manson with a guitar during a performance. I wish he would do more of this stuff now.
He “played” guitar a lot during the Dead to the World tour, I think mostly during the song Dried up, Tied and Dead to the World
Yeah manson uses a guitar as a prop, just like stilts.
from Portrait to Holy Wood, there's one song per album he played live. in cronological order: Down in the park, Dried up..., Coma White, In the Shadows of the valley...
And played guitar on Minute of Decay live on the DTTW Tour.
We have no future... Heaven wasn't made for meeeeee!
+Leandro California
oooh yo so rebellious.....
VALHALLA FTW!!
I admit I used google to see what Valhalla meant haha
Leandro California
OMG I am truly sorry you have suffered for long being so unaware of what Valhalla is..
i always feel worthless... this song gets me to my guts..
This is the very best of my MM songs. This song is wicked, it make me cry as often as I play it since 2002 till date. I can never get tired of this song. 'I wish that I could be the king, then I know that I am not alone'.wicked. .
You're god damn right right my dear friend
This song almost brings me to tears, it's so beautiful
this song is magic...
"And I wish that I
Could be the king
Then I'd know that I am not alone"
manson is so unique
I would much rather hear this song at a Manson concert instead of Rock Is Dead, Disposable Teens, or (m)OBSCENE...
+Joey Yoshimasu Kamiya
But (m)OBSCENE is fun.... hehehe
true. nowaday his setlist are quite boring. I miss this song and Man that you fear so muchhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
Along with Disassociative it would be much better
Joseph Kamiya me to
Yeah he doesn't change it up much
Holy shit!... Okay, so half way through, the weed kicked in, and that was the most beautiful intense thing I've ever seen. The last two minutes absolutely blew my mind
What a beautiful performance, personel.
i love how when manson stops playing the guitar his part still keeps going
this one is by far my favorite marylin manson song.
👍
Why doesn't he play this live again? Beautiful..
This video just took me back to my teenage years and the very feeling i used to feel when listening to this song. Still a very powerful one, even after all these years...
Same here
My favorite Manson song. I'm so happy to see that it has actually been played live, even if I'll never get the chance to see it. I'm really glad I stumbled on this video, I watch it so much.
Great singer and performer one of the best 💙
MANSON FOR PRESIDENT!
Wow. Manson with a guitar, never seen this.
holywod is the best cd
Ber Tii Berti 89 Holy Wood*
Hard not to cry his songs tell stories and there wonderful
No pensé que sonara tan genial en vivo. Grande el reverendo
The best and most dramatic track on that CD, and possibly my favorite song he ever sang, that and The Last day on earth, The reflecting God, and Sweet Dreams, anyway, This is an excellent performance! Manson's perfect vocals on this track. Thanks for posting this, I don't think they played this track very much during that tour, Great Song! When was this recoded? do you have the whole concert? if so, please post it.
This was in 2001. Fucking amazing, right?! Even better than the (already beautiful) album version.
***** I made the comment 3 months ago, and I stand by my opinion that this was one of the best songs they ever wrote, and this live version shows just how great his live vocals used to be, it's sad that he cant sustain a change in pitch very long now a days (live), but he's still the greatest performer of experimental Hard Rock/industrial Rock In my opinion.
Lamb of God is another great one
Yes this is amazeing
Stockholm, Sweden in 2001
Shit, I'm actually crying
The chemistry of the band during this performance is simply astounding. Every note is on point and it hits each emotion...
Still amazing in 2022🤘#istandwithmarilynmanson
I'm here to agree🤘
Этот трек стал вечным
I love this song, the lyrics are so well written, I actually feel worthless at times, but it's true that there are others who feel the same, so I'm not alone
one of the best manson performances ever!
Luv MM. Seen him live 25 times
This and leave a scar are my favorite.
This live is GOLD
This Performance give me power in my darkest moments 🖤
I never tire of watching this video because this song is just amazing . So emotional and deepness. This day was just the best version of this song. I heard in Hiroshima concert this version of In the shadow of the valley of death" but no as emotional and deep than this video. The notes of the keyboard is just perfect on this video, in Hiroshima the version was a little bit different. For me Sweet dreams Live 1997 and this song on this video: this is MANSON !!!!
Totally agree with you....
its so beautiful 💔💔💔😭😭😭
The is the apex and peak of MM the band.
Who knew a slow song would be one of his best. Fuck I love this song and god eat god
Хотелось бы сказать пару слов...
Я из России, очень хорошо видно, что песня описывает через мелодию домашнее насилие. Оно распространено, как мне кажется, в каждой стране - буквально та часть, где начинается разъёб очень хорошо демонстрирует весь пиздец происходящего, будто пьяный отец начинает пиздится с женой, когда на это смотрит лирический герой (вероятно подросток, которым можете быть вы на месте главного героя). Я был бы рад оказаться на концерте Мэнсона, когда он находился ещё на пике популярности, будем честны - тухляк сейчас и старпёр какой-то на сцене сверкает. Я уважаю Мэнсона за то, что он даёт возможность быть услышанным (по крайней мере в раннем творчестве это очень ярко выражается) в своих работах и это live-версия буквально вдохновляет меня самого делать также - это то, что вдохновит каждого)
Thank you for this video, thank you from Russia;)
this is such a great performance , of my favourite aong. such a shame he does not perform it more often, yet the rarity makes it the more special to me.
12 veces cantado en vivo
9/12 en vivo encontrado
3:42 the growl in his voice is just wow
Ok guys I think we all love this song am I right? Well we should demand for Manson to play songs like coma white and speed of pain an man that you fear and more live!!!! Who's with me?
lovestospooge646 omg please
this is why i love this band.
this song is so beautiul, real art.
Ugh what I would give to see them perform this live.
I can't stop listening to this
Life and death concentrated in a song
#marilynmanson, this evening...my sadness is eating this song..again and again 😥🥀
"We have no future" in this song is also in The Death Song ( "We've got no future" ) but from a different point of view. Half the song from this album are from the point of view of HOLY WOOD.
This song is sooo beautiful
One of my favorites from Holy Wood
i think i just found my favorite song of him :)
It's amazing. Holy Wood really was something
DAM I LOVE A POETIC HEAVY METAL SONG!!! thanks Mr Manson
i love john 5 head banging
This is so beautiful wow
I love the way Manson walks 💗 i love his walk his legs are so cute 😘☀️(4:02)
She put the seeds in me...plant this dying tree...she's a burning string.. im just the ashes. I totally relate.
very underestimated and underrated song imo
I’m speechless it’s so good
I fucking love this song:) It's so beautiful... It's the most beautiful song ever written on history.
#marilynmanson, this song is killing me 💔 every time. I will always stand by you. I want you back.
#marilynmansonuncancelled
#marilynmansonisinnocent
#justiceformarilynmanson
It's now.
@@SAAB4LIFE-u5p i know 😍
Superb live rendition
A true jewel
As emotional as it can get..wow
One if his best performances
the best line-up...
damn, live version is so impressive, damn, \m/
2:41 - check out the sneaky band tech in the background
magic.
#marilynmanson with this song my heart💔 breaks ❤🔥🔥
BEST SONG EVER!
So amazing.
still the king
que buena rola y que buena mas en vivo gracias por subirlo ....espero alguien tenga mas fragmentos de este concierto
awesome 🖤.From Kurdistan.
wish i was there
so sad and beautifull.all words in this song is truth.love MM
God Like.
of course. he played it from times to times. heard that he played on some songs on this current tour, from natchkabarett forum.
What a song
Wow I've never heard this live! This is beautiful, didn't he also play coma white with a guitar at one show?
guys..this is an amazing performance!!!
awesome song
#marilynmanson...but you are a King. Trust me 🔥❤🥀
#marilynmanson, how could a person say that don't loves you? In my opinion it's impossible ❤🥀
He should do more ballads
#marilynmanson you're not alone ❤🔥🔥
mano que pedrada
she's the burning string, im just the ashes...
great song!
MM is awesome!
Great quality
Beautiful 🥰🥰
awesome!!!!
*Perfect*:________) One of my fav.songs from Manson..I prefer this one than the original one, from the Holy Wood Album...it is so beautiful..
thank you! i enjoyed this never seen it live before.
omg, whas this is SWEDEN?? Fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck that I am so young, everything seems to be so fun back in these days!!! Oh, I really love him!
Good (and easy) song to play on acoustic guitar when you're feeling low.
Amazing!