Why the Ride of the Rohirrim was a Tactical Disaster! (And How to Fix It) DOCUMENTARY
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ค. 2024
- A history documentary on the tactical disaster that is The Ride of the Rohirrim. Improve your career using my code Invicta for 30% off on all their programs! Sign up for a FREE TripleTen career consultation with my link: get.tripleten.com/Invicta
The documentary begins with a review of the Ride of the Rohirrim as portrayed in Peter Jackson's Movie, The Return of the King, and in Tolkien's original book. We then pick apart the film's depiction frame by frame with all the flaws in the Army of Rohan's charge at the Battle of Pelennor Fields. Then we delve into the history of cavalry in combat for a better understanding of how such forces actually behaved in the past. We then finally use this knowledge to reconstruct the Army of Rohan and the Battle of Pelennor Fields in Unreal Engine 5 as it should have been.
You can check out 3D reconstructions of historical armies in our True Size series:
True Size of a Byzantine Army • True Size of a Byzanti...
True Size of a Samurai Army • True Size of a Samurai...
True Size of a US Rifle Company (1944) • How the US Goes to War...
True Size of a Spartan Army • Spartan Organization, ...
True Size of a Mongol Army • True Size of a Mongol ...
True Size of a Roman Legion • True Size of a Roman L...
Timestamps:
00:00 Intro
01:49 Depiction in the Film
04:59 Sponsor
06:32 Tactical Issues
12:20 Historical Organization
16:40 Historical Formations
21:43 Historical Combat
28:55 Revised Army Model
30:35 Unreal Army
32:22 Revised Attack Model
34:05 Unreal Attack
#history
#documentary
#lordoftherings
![[TH] VCT Pacific Stage 2 - Week 4 Day 3 // GEN vs TS | PRX vs ZETA](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nspkjQuZve0/mqdefault.jpg)
What other Hollywood battles would you want to see re-designed in Unreal Engine? Improve your career using my code Invicta for 30% off on all their programs! Sign up for a FREE TripleTen career consultation with my link: get.tripleten.com/Invicta
I say the most "modern" / sci-fi settings fails because of range,
Even at the battle of Jutland enemies was just an black blob at an distance unless viewed by powerful binoculars, the larges was the range finders for the main guns linked to analogue fire control computers and 10 km was short range.
However this is not kinematic so you go age of sail as in star trek.
Star wars get some credit for an WW 2 style there the capital ships stays away but fighters go in close.
Please make a video about battle of the teutoburg forest🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
I'm sorry, but this not another reason why I won't fully commit to subscribing to you.
This just seems like yet another dick move made by a know it all historian who hates that people like fantasy and such more than their precious history.
I mean, the freaking Polish king Jan Sobieski led the largest cavalry charge in history, of 20,000 horsemen, 5,000 of which were the Polish Winged Hussars, straight at the Ottoman army that greatly outnumbered them, and yet I don't see you or anyone else disputing that.
And let's not pretend that the it was some night attack that caught the vast majority of the Ottomans sleeping or something, they were facing the incoming Christian forces.
HELMS DEEP!!!! Battle of Helm's Deep, This might be to big but part 1 and part 2 with the reinforcements with the rohirrim.
@@nightlyknight7970
Don't encourage this kind of crap, as it's just stupid bullshit that's trying to pretty much talk down to people who like fantasy stuff.
And I don't think that the hill the Rohirrim charge down in The Two Towers was actually supposed to have been as steep as it was in the movie, which was clearly just done for dramatic effect.
The Ride worked because those orcs were trained by Ratbag.
Imagine if those Orcs were the ones from Warcraft and led by Thrall with spellcasters and magic users.
Hey mam ratbag was a hero he was looked up to....by ratbag
@@highlightboy23 If they had been trained by Garl Iron Skull, the Orcs would have mopped the floor.
@@vitorpereira9515 still, they had no answer to the ethereal army of Aragorn that wiped them off. That is why I brought up Warcraft Orcs because they had access to spells and magic and Thrall is a very powerful shaman, probably a top tier spellcaster in his world and had tonnes of experience in dealing with otherworldy threats.
😂
King Theoden slander shan´t be tolerated
For it to be slander, what was said must be false. Where was the lie?
What can men do against such reckless hate?
Where is the horn and the rider?
Arise! Arise! Riders of theoden!
King Noob
I trust in the good King Theoden
@@HistoryDose Orome would have smiled at their bravery
@@HistoryDose make videos on Tolkien please
The amount of passion you have when saying "we'll agree they deserve to be squashed by the momakil" is so brilliant and lets us know what you truly think 😂😂
Yeah, he's totally not being salty and biased at all.
Honestly, the fact he bothered to make this video at all makes it seem like he's just jealous that more people tend to like fantasy more than history.
And I don't think he's going to mention what the Ride of the Rohirrim is based off of, which was the Great Siege of Vienna in 1683, in which the real King Theoden, Jan Sobieski led the largest cavalry charge in history, which had 20,000 horsemen, 5,000 of which were his Polish Winged Hussars, which he led from the front, straight into the Ottoman forces.
@@chubbyninja89 You didn't watch it did you?
@@Bananasqwe
No, because when he starts out all but saying that the scene in question is in incredibly stupid and all, I'm not going to feel too inclined to want to listen to whatever petty drivel might have to say after that.
But I know that people like *you* would no doubt be total hypocrites and not watch the entire video if someone else made a video titled "Cry more History Nerds!" or something like that, that basically mocks the fact that "historians" and such are constantly getting mad and all over movie scenes and such.
Don't try to lie and say you would absolutely watch the entirety of such a video, because I know far too many people these days are willing to try to have double standards about things they like.
I mean, they were chanting “Death!” They knew they likely weren’t surviving lol. Also, they state in the movie multiple times that they know they are riding to their dooms.
The best way to decrease the chance of doom is to not die instantly by piling all the horses up in a big heap. Even if the battle was a lost cause you might want to "take as many of them with me as I can" but you can't do that on a full frontal cavalry charge.
@@Pangora2 Agree the depth of the formation is just not realistic. Frontal charges, however, are. Not necessarily a GOOD IDEA, but did happen a lot, especially in the high middle ages.
They only start chanting 'Death' in the books when Theoden has died, and that is the exact point things goes to shit for the Rohirrim, because they charge mindlessly back into battle led by a grieving Éomer that thinks both his adoptive father and his sister have died.
@@damonhawkes2057 Yeah you just need trained warhorses. Even at Waterloo with Ney’s botched cavalry charge while the British infantry did come out on top relatively handily, it was by no means easy for them either. They were surrounded by thick smoke, having to stand on corpses of fallen infantry men from gunfire from horseback, and they dealt with cavalrymen who charged them straight on. The charge wasn’t organized as the squares supported each other well with musketry firing close range volleys which broke up the charge and many of the cavalrymen lost heart and veered off but we are told some infantry were still sabers and lanced from a direct charge.
I actually struggle to find any accounts of horses getting scared and refusing to engage because of spears. Evidently they were trained to ignore such fears. Modern horses would get scared by spears but not trained warhorses. The riders themselves are usually the ones who have to get the warhorses to not charge so it is usually the riders decision unless the horse is just poorly trained. Interestingly enough in the Napoleonic period lancers were regarded as a potential counter to squares so there is this too. It seems even a square formation with braced infantry could be overcome by frontal charges. I think it is only once you start talking about flat out pikes that a frontal charge starts becoming more impossible. You really need a very long pike to stop incoming horsemen reliably.
This is not to say that frontal charging is always the best tactic, clearly flanking and “scooping” were probably done more often as a frontal charge is a gamble and a successful charge has to result in the cavalry continuing to move so frontal charges can be the most difficult to pull off. But it is evident that a frontal charge can work very reliably especially against low quality infantry. And I haven’t found any evidence for scared horses. That is why if a charge fails, the casualties for horses are always so high.
@@brianhobaugh ok but even if you actually WANTED to die, you could use some form of strategy in order to take more orcs with you
Tactically there were a couple of hobbits, and once an army has hobbits, its over
and one woman
there was 1 hobbit for the battle, 1 for the siege and 1 Woman
Well said! Those 2 gigachads brought both Isengard and Mordor down, while their friends sneak around like a fool.
Imagine if Pippin was the one pimpin the party. He would make those wraiths his b*tches, sweet talk them to carry him to Mordor, and toss the ring into the volcano for him.
Tactical Hobbit Strike is an essential component to the SAD doctrine (Sauron's Assured Destruction).
@@solocanaanite4655 one woman to kill the undead wizard king, one hobbit to kill the oliphaunts.
Yea, I know, it is not in the book. But Tolkien spared us the gruesome real events on Pelennor Fields. When the halbling went through the trunk into each oliphaunts skull, stab inside like a berserker. When the oliphaunts falls dead to the ground, the air from the lungs pushed the halfling out, to continue his murderous work.
the real reason why they massed the troops up in the film was because it would have taken another hour for theoden to deliver his speach if it was a 2km long front line.
Heh, they could bunch up like that for speech then spread out as they advance and charge.
@@linming5610by the time they finally spread out the orc would’ve probably scouted them out
“I think he said blessed are the cheese makers”
Historically, they’d have guys up and down the line repeating the speech.
Considering the context of the battle, Theoden was doing pretty good since the orcs were caught off guard by the heavy cavalry charge. Mumakil did the same to Theoden, caught them by surprise n he reacted in the moment
Imagine getting caught by surprise by building sized animals on a flat field with ankle height grass 💀💀💀
@@SimonMorealworked for Hannibal i guess
Yes, the orcs only expected a siege, there weren't supposed to be any cavalry charges. Except for some brawling and infighting it was probably every orcs first real battle. They might never have a cavalry charge and not been trained to use spears and pikes well.
Cinematically it looks like an unstoppable force, so everyone starts running. Even if you kill a dozen it doesn't seem to matter. A wide line of only 6 horses deep is easily killed if you have unlimited depth infantry.
I'd expect thin deep parallel lines 3*50? Doing most damage and keeping momentum. Like each pierces and is followed by 50 drive by attacks. So the engagement surface is on the sides of each unit. With lots of space (50-100 orcs wide) in between most of the orc will do nothing but watch as they hear people getting butchered left and right.
The piercing lines can then slowly turn and move around keeping the pace while a unit behind them pierces a different chaotic part. It does need some training and coordination so as not to bump into each other or shift like schools of fish/flocks of birds.
@@teambellavsteamalice In the books at least the orcs would have been familiar with cavalry due to Gondor mounting a cavalry charge to delay the enemy's advance upon the city. Unlike in the movie this was not a pointless charge and it actually had some effect.
@@oscarandreas1431Hannibal crossed through mountains considered completely uninhabitable, that is why he shocked the Romans. If he had elephants that were ten times larger and advancing towards a Roman army across a flat plain, nobody would have been caught off guard
It was always my understanding that Theoden showed up, saw that Minas Tirith had basically already fallen and just decided to go out in a blaze of glory rather than run away back to Rohan to cower in his slowly crumbling forts. The ride of the Rohirrim wasn't supposed to be a tactical engagement, it was basically just suicide by combat. Hence why Theoden didn't really make any actual plan.
He was in that mood since Helm's Deep ride out.
@@josephmclaughlin8645 That is exactly what Theoden was thinking. Seeing what he thought was a conquered Gondor he knew the war was lost. His only choice was go out in glory quickly or die a slow death later trying to defend his keep against an unbeatable foe.
There's a reason the battle cry wasn't about saving Gondor
The battle cry was DEATH
He saw the fight, thought 'well, we're boned. Lets go out killing some fuckers. GO!'
That's not what happens in the books. This occurs in the movies because Peter Jackson is ignoring any actual tactics and just going for the rule of cool.
Its cool in the movie, thanks for mentioning the book is different, I will start reading it, Yup I never read it lol
I think the literal book reasoning behind the charge at the Battle of Pelennor Field is facing the inevitability of death bravely. You don’t yell “Death” three times before doing something if you’re looking for a positive outcome (usually) 😊
In the books they don't yell death at that charge. They yell death after Eomer learns of Eowyn's death and leads them into mumakil and haradrim forces. During initial charge, they sing instead
@@konstantinriumin2657 was the charge against the Haradrim during the battle of Pelennor? I haven’t read the books since I was in my early 20s. There’s brain damage and time between me and the details.
@@ronniegonzalez8622They charged against the army besieging Minas Tirith, which primarily was made up of Orcs/Uruks, with contingents from Harad and the Easterlings
You dont shout DEATH DEATH DEATH! when you get in your car to drive to work every day? Just me? Is that why I get those weird looks?
In that case, shouldn't you use the tactics that have the greatest chance of inflicting the most damage on the enemy?
In the books it is described quite differently.
With Theodén's forces kind of sneaking in with the help of people from the mountain.
And they then actually charge in single groups (because they split up before) it is upon a totally surprised enemy that has no time to from ranks and from mutliple directions at once.
Bret Deveraux breaks it down quite good in his Collection of Unmitigated Pedantry
Yes, the first Mordor troops were caught completely by surprise, and while I think some of their regiments formed up they didn't have anything like the time they needed to form a continuous defense line which is what they would have needed against a massed cavalry charge.
Faborite line "had this been historic, theyd have taken a historic whuppin"
Should’ve played the Ride of the Rohirrim in Third Age: Total War smhmh.
Can't get 6000 riders in, let alone 100k opposition
Divide and Conquer is more Updated and better then TATW, also Dawnless Days (Attila mod version) is coming along nicely
I love this! Using fiction to teach IRL history/military is a great idea.
Whatever IRL lessons are learnt, doesn't make the scene any less stunning and impactful and epic, AND we get to learn something new ❤
That's my approach on this. I really just wanted to talk about the historical use of cavalry but using a fantasy battle everyone is familiar with helps better illustrate a lot of the points.
@@InvictaHistory Can you make a video if the Eastern Romans won at 1453 siege. With the siege won Constantine XI asked for crusade to recapture lost lands which the Pope agreed to. Romans re control all of Greece once again and holded the Ottomans off. Would the Romans joined WW1 and WW2? Would they kick their Emperor like everyone else after WW1? What would the Romans soilders look like and the people? As we know the Romans are very good people to adopted to things and make it better?
Any war movie where the two armies charged into each other at full speed is probably wrong. Some of these ancient style battles took all day to fight, and you can't do that if your most courageous men run into a wall of wood and steel in the first light of dawn.
The only war I can think of where this would be true is Pharnaces of Bosporus against Ceasar where there was one battle, the battle of Zela. Which probably still took hours.
@@sirjmo And we can cite the Gauls assaults where they do run in full speed to close the distance. Romans were known to shield bash and stab.
Though as with what we're saying if they do run into full speed they had a reason for it. War movies just think it is that in all cases, when it would look closer to riot police charging down protesters. Of that we have many examples and if the other side was at all similarly equipped would go on for some timr
@@Pangora2 most filmmakers' greatest experience with melee combat is middle school playground fights. That's all they know, and that's all they represent on screen
You guys need to stop being jealous that people tend to like fantasy more than history. It just makes you all look incredibly petty.
I mean, the true King Theoden, Jan Sobieski led the largest cavalry charge in history, which was 20,000 horsemen, 5,000 of which were his Polish Winged Hussars, which he led from the front, straight into the Ottoman forces, which still greatly outnumbered them.
Yet I don't see Invicta or any of you guys mentioning that little fact.
@@chubbyninja89 The cavalry charge took place over 12 hours after the battle started, after a preliminary probe of 120 horses found out what spot they should charge into.
History is great and I'd be honored to be among their ranks. All the fictional stories are just watered down versions of things that already happened.
I think the most shocking thing about this video, is that people are coming to a history channel and telling you not to view it through a historical lens. it would be like going to a hospital and complaining everyone is so concerned about health.
Although I’m not sure how well it would go when viewing fantasy through a historical lens, since it’s not a 1 to 1 internal system.
@@DakkogiRauru23I don't know but there's no dragons, mythical creatures, besides fellbeasts and mumakil, or magic involved in the scene. It's mostly horses and humans, or humanoid species fighting, which we have historical reference of how it's conducted, I don't really know why we shouldn't consult history for this. The scene doesn't have that much magic. So yeah, it's still generally realistic in a sense that we can explain it with our real life physics or history.
@@linming5610 Based on how the humans and horses of Rohan are portrayed in the film, they do not act like real world horses or people physiologically. Rohirric horses in the film seem to be impervious to spear walls, for example, and aren’t limited by any mass of infantry when charging.
@@DakkogiRauru23we aren't talking about horses here. We are talking command and control of cavalry. This idea can still be roughly imported to fantasy settings.
@@linming5610 Command and control of cavalry, which includes knowing the physical traits of the steeds employed. You should know as a history enthusiasts that different cultures used different breeds of horses in their wars and to varying effects. And if the Rohirric horse itself is so powerful that it can trample scores-deep ranks, then that mount is considered a top-of-the-line weapon and is extremely valuable to an army.
And based on their performance against the Mordor host, the horses on their own have proven to be devastating weapons with hides impregnable by infantry weaponry.
Fun fact: The winged hussars in many battles (including the relief of Vienna) were riding with relatively big gabs between them and were closing them only were they were really close to the enemy, which extrapolates the point, that you need to have gaps between cavalary.
they were charging against ranged firepower, those gaps are for avoiding ranged fire mostly, arrows dont have that stomp/penetration power, if your armored enough your impervious to arrow fire.
This type of slander is unforgiveable.
Haha I feel as though I blasphemed with this one but it's something that's increasingly bugged me as we've been reconstructing ancient armies in Unreal Engine. (Love your content by the way!)
@@InvictaHistory Okay, it might be slightly forgivable. Fan of yours too!
Wow! I didn't realise how much respect this channel got in the community, this is the fourth creator channel I've seen commenting.
It's really heart warming seeing some of my favourite channels all in one place. 🙂
To be fair in the Movie the Orcs where panicking and routing before Thedoens riders, it was not until the Haradarian where in positioned and advanced that it was stopped and even then the Rohirrim where seeming to hold their own until the Witch King took out Théoden King.
Also Théoden had to take action fast in the film, he saw in the movie the city was breached and the first two levels at least where in flames and overrun, he likely took this charge option to quickly draw attention away from Minis Tirith of the Mordor Army and give the defenders some relief from the hordes. He had to act or lose the City and the initiative, the Mordor Army was massive in the film dwarfing it's book counterpart even in scale and the book army was a large army. Likely if Théoden had wasted time the Witch King or his sub commanders would have used the time to adapt the army formation and units to counter the Rohirrim and cut them off from any chance of reaching the city.
As to why they charge the Elephants in the film, it's likely done by Théoden just to keep his men moving and maintain the momentum, he took action rather than do nothing at all.
Let's also not forget the big factor in the room now, the presence of the Witch King and his Nazgul who are bringing dread and terror to the Battlefield by the sheer presence. This is likely why the men are so clung together to keep each inspired and not given into to fear as Gandalf said once. The Mordor was not going to break not until the Witch King was defeated, Sauron's grip on it through fear was too strong through the Witch King for that happen.
In the Book the Rohirrim flattened the Easterling and Harad cavalry and nearly created a route of the Orc body of the Army until the Witch King took out Théoden and the Harad oliphants countered the Rohirrim. Then Aragorn returned with the southern fiefdoms troops of Gondor, his Arnorian rangers, Gimli and Legolas and Elrond's sons. The Gondorians in the book still held the whole city minus some parts of the first wall, they sallied out to meet the Rohirrim and fight alongside them. The book battle was more like a real life battle and had more correct tactics for both sides.
I will say though if you must change the very fundamentals of the Rohirrim then your no longer creating a better scenario for them, but instead just replacing them with another force in reality. I don't think the revised version of the Rohirrim would win either, Mordor's army was in formations as well in the Film and had the manpower to counter the Rohirrim even this revised version of it. Don't forget the Mordor forces also where locked in fear of the Witch King and so weren't going to flee until he was taken out or their army was nearly wiped out. I dare say likely this more spread out Rohirrim force would be in time encircled and forced into pockets and slowly destroyed separated from each others support.
I'm sure the cavalry would have been advancing in formation, so it wouldn't take as long to deploy as you think. I'm also certain that the Rohirrim have the morale and training to utilize small unit tactics effectively. There's a reason so much was said about the depth of the formation not being as important for cavalry, the revised formation allows for the same effect of a heavy cavalry charge, since horses don't push like men do, but the difference is that instead of only advancing across a 400 meter front, it's over a mile wide and has better maneuverability and morale. Time wouldn't be an issue because the units would join the battle as they arrive since they're moving in formation, and thus instead of a single doomed charge you'll have four which are just as powerful, with better C&C and higher morale, with the first charge arriving at exactly the same time as the charge arrived in the movie. This also means that instead of the orcs focusing their entire attention on a single front, they'll have to divide their forces, so even if some of the revised units just arrive at the battle and stand there, they're effectively multiplying the effect of the horsemen who are attacking. This charge didn't HAVE to be a suicide charge.
This is a good rebuttal
Finally, the deep lore
When your enemy is immortal and rides... basically a dragon. Morale of riding 15 deep makes more sense.
@@mikeg8564 morale is not going to be a problem for an army that is doing a "suicide charge" though.. so there's no need for a fifteen deep formation that adds zero benefits and at the same time reduces your frontage and effectiveness. For all we know, Tolkein probably wrote this blunder on purpose to highlight the panic of the moment.
It always bugged me that when Aragorn saw the 10,000 Uruk hai marching towards Helms deep that the riders of Rohan did not harass that army using horse archers with hit and run tactics and ambush tactics. Yet they just let a slowly moving Phalanx lumber its way to siege helms deep. A real missed opportunity by Theoden.
A few issues with this
. We DO see banners. Both during and before the charge. Theoden and the people he talked to are commanding the formations, and they also make use of horns to communicate orders.
. Frontal charges aren't this super insane borderline blasphemous idea that a lot of people seem to believe. Obviously they aren't the smartest thing in most situations, but they were most definitely used in a plethora of situations in history. The battle of Montgisard for example where Baldwin defeated Saladin ended in a charge against Saladins forces and despite being greatly outnumbered Baldwin won.
. You contradict yourself when talking about the units being way too deep where you say that units in the back aren't doing anything then later when talking about formations you say they help force the line through. Ultimately this was the goal of the rohirrim (movie wise, not sure about the book), because...
. The entire goal was to force a rout. 1. Orcs and especially goblins are cowardly. And 2. If they didn't rout humanity would lose. They were too outnumbered, the orcs had already taken most of the city, the white wizard was defeated, there were numerous nazgul, and humanity for all respects and purposes was defeated. If Saurons army didn't run than humanity was doomed anyway. They were 6 thousand against whatever was left of the 100+ thousand orcs. Thats why they chanted "death". Because 1. Sauron and/or morgoth convinced man that death was bad when in reality it was a gift from Eru, and they no longer feared it. And 2. Its almost certainly what they were riding towards regardless what tactic they used. You either tried to force a rout in a final hail mary, or you actually try to take on a hundred thousand orcs with only six thousand cavalry.
Actually montgisard like i mentioned is a perfect example here. The orcs outside the city were disorganized, had unfavorable terrain, were tired from all the marching and fighting, and so on. And like montgisard the rohirrim really didn't have much in their favor aside from "God's on our side."
. You ask "how are you going to reform, how are you going to move, really you can only go in one direction". Thats actually the point for them. I want you to think about qhat happens to many of your army wings with thousand of arrows going their way. If you were an orc you'd be a lot less terrified of a bunch of small groups of cavalry and much more terrified seeing the "massive blob" so to speak.
If this was something like 6K rohirrim vs 30k orcs i could see it. But again... This was over one hundred thousand, not even including the reinforcements rohan would've believed were coming from the sea, the easterlings, or the mumakil. Also the wring wraiths. We saw what they could do to units even outside of formations. If they were to attack a massive blob there'd be thousands of spears waiting for them as opposed, lets say, 30.
Good vid regardless.
Edit: "Only the bravest and most well trained horses would ever charge headfirst into spears"
Sir this is Rohan.
Edit 2: also the army of the dead thing isnt as impressive as people seem to think. This is unrelated to the video, but they used to worship sauron (or morgoth i forget) so if aragorn were to keep them its entirely possible, if not likely, that sauron would've corrupted them. And thats assuming that the guys literally called "the oath breakers" decided to just go along with whatever aragorn said anyways.
@@spiffygonzales5160 Oh great example with Battle of Montsigard. On related note, sometimes I do think if the French is so obsessed with their cavalry charge but they do have score a lot of decisive victories thanks to cavalry like on Battle of Patay, Battle of Eylau
Yeah this is good stuff. I am always annoyed at clickbait like this. Rohan are the horelords not horse novices. Also this is an army shouting "Death" they clearly are aiming for that brutal likely, unsurvivable relief for their allies.
fr, the horses didn't flinch when they saw the Mumakil, real horses are scared of regular elphants, this are the most trained horses that can possibly be.
The Battle of Montgisard is not comparable to how Peter Jackson depicted this. At Montgisard, the Muslims were not already engaged in battle in packed ranks of spears like at Pelennor Fields. They were dispersed to forage and were taken by surprise. Some didn't even have their weapons when Baldwin appeared. They had to scramble to put up a disorganized resistance when they thought they were going to spend the day basically grocery shopping and stealing from the locals.
And the knights at Montgisard certainly were not bunched together in a Hollywood blob the way PJ shows the Rohirrim. They would have operated like Invicta describes, being more spread out to take advantage of their maneuverability and maximize the effect of their numbers.
As for saying that the orcs were on unfavorable terrain, I don't know what you mean by that. It's a field. And PJ doesn't have the Rohirrim make use of the flexibility of cavalry that an open field should afford them, which is the point of the video.
@@Yusuf1187
My comparison for montisgard was only meant to show that an inferior cavalry force could win a full frontal charge against superior numbers
The impression I got from the books was that the 6000 Rohirrim were able to make a successful flank attack and surprise the orcs, and that the movie changed it up to try and make that seem like a separate, more dynamic battle. Either way, this is a nifty little formation, I like the looks of it.
In the books there definitely are officers and banners used by the Rohirrim. They also do not charge a line of braced spears. And while there are no definite unit sizes given we can assume them to be a lot smaller than in the movie from some of the descriptions of the battle. The battle unfolds roughly like this:
- Rohan bypasses the blocking force of Orcs with help from local tribesmen.
- They attack the main army of Mordor in multiple columns and destroy the Orcs on the northern half of the battlefield through their surprise attack in the flank.
The Haradrim cavalry tries to meet them head on but are defeated because the Rohirrim have longer lances with Theoden killing the Haradrim chieftain.
- The charge stops because the army has reached the northern city walls.
- The Witch King kills Theoden and is slain by Eowyn. Eomer takes command and rallies the force for a second charge which manages to drive deep wedges into the enemy frontline, but gets halted by the Mumakil.
- The Rohirrim are driven back and partially encircled and prepare to make a dismounted shield wall on a hill for their final stand.
- Aragorn arrives with strong reinforcements from southern Gondor and attacks the army of Mordor in the rear.
- The army of Mordor is crushed between a Hammer (Aragorn) and Anvil (Rohan and the forces from Minas Tirith).
Overall a tactically much more sound battle than the one in the movie.
An important distinction in the books is the terrain: instead of an open field and a single mass of enemy forces, book Rohirrim showed up to many scattered units of enemies mixed up in farms, smaller hamlets, and hedges.
Between the noise and orc distraction upon the walls, it's not crazy that the Rohirrim, moving in a few smaller bands, were able to deliver a hefty punch before the orcs could retaliate.
My critiques aside, I love your content, and am eagerly awaiting the next Tyranid video. Cheers Invicta. 😊
Edited: I jumped the gun, posting less than three minutes into the video, before you mentioned the Rammas Echor. Though I'd still consider the film and book terrain different enough that you can't consider them the same. Dr. Konijnendijk wasn't on hand to teach the orcs ditches.
Are you comparing the books as well or just going over the movie scenes? Because there is already a whole series of articles that compares the books and the movies, done by A Collection of Unmitigated Pedantry. It is very interesting, and if anybody else in this comment section is interested in learning about the differences of what Peter Jackson did and how Tolkien actually wrote things, and both compared to real military tactics and historical realism, I'd recommend the read.
What's it called. Because in the books it's somewhat different. Not mention there was a large contingent of men from the east fighting for sauron. And if I remember correctly the soldiers of Gondor sally out during the charge.
@@etheu9sby292 just look for the siege of Gondor and Collection of Unmitigated Pedantry. He also covers Helms Deep.
A "spear" may also be used to refer to a unit as a "lance" was. It could mean 3-5 men for each spear/lance. No matter what Tolkien had in mind, it sounds like the siege of Vienna in 1683. There an 18,000 strong cavalry charge led by 3,000 Polish Winged Hussars hit the Turks, though they were in a checkerboard pattern of squares, not a blob. They cut their way through 50,000 Turks, fought off counter attacks, and made it all the way to the Turkish camp. ”It was like a flood of black pitch pouring downhill, crushing and burning everything in its way” - Ottoman observer describes the attack of the relief army.
You're a brave man having a crack at the ride of the Rohirrim
The sad thing is that the "Ride of the Rohirrim" was ultimately unnecessary.
Aragorns ghost buddies (in the movie) cleared out the entire battlefield in like 5 minutes, remember?
Aragorn wanted to secure the throne by gutting the only other human kingdom left standing and whose king also wasn't completely on his side. Note the only member of the fellowship to die was the one who didn't fully support Aragorn's ascension.
@@voice_of_terra7228 total bull
The ghosts are one of the worst decisions ever put to film.
Only in the Film, in the Book the ride did enough damage to allow Aragorn to arrive with the Southern Gondor units.
Ghost buddies 😂 best description!
Love the tactical review and your changes but no matter what you have to admit, the Charge of the Rohirrim is the coolest scene ever (regardless of realism)
Legolas skating down stairs on shield begs to differ
Seems like a lot of y'all would benefit from reading the book, its MUCH more tactically sound, if I recall it involves 3 divisions and an envelopment + the Southrons actually counter-charge Rohan with their cavalry and there's a cavalry battle. Very cool
If you see in the book perspective
The rohirim charge is a suprise attack and a tactical genius as the western part of gonder were guarded by thousands of orcs with wood spikes in the road in case rohan came to aid they hide from the forest and the drudein told a secret passage so the horse masters can ride safety to the passage without orcs notice.
As they ride safety out to the forest they took the enemies of Mordor by suprise and the enemy eventually don't have time to reform a line.
To this day the most effective use of cavalry in practice I have ever seen was in this game called Mount&Blade in an online server with real players as seen from the perspective of the opposing force infantryman.
These quite small groups of cavalrymen 10-20 men each, hit the infantry formation at a glancing charge like you showed in the example in this video. Never in a direct charge, if the swing connected or it did not they rode on regardless.
High speed, hit and run. As the first group of riders retreated to regroup for another charge some distance away, the second group was already in the process of conducting their own charge. And they just rotated like this until they dwindled the enemy numbers down so much they basically just cleaned up the survivors.
From the perspective of the enemy infantryman (already occupied with dealing with enemy infantry as well) this meant a high speed deadly cavalry charge coming from a random direction every 15- 25 seconds that was extremely hard to counter. Even if that particular charge did not result in any kills, the disruption it caused in the infantry formation made them much much less effective in the battlefield.
How historically accurate this tactic would be I have absolutely no idea, but it worked like a charm in the game.
It is how I commanded my cavalry in the game, and how the bot commanders used them in the sequel -Bannerlord. So not only could you use these tactics, but have them used against you! They are quite effective. Especially if your horses and riders have good armour. I always purchase full mail barding if I intend on forcing my poor horses into the charge.
This video can be summarized in "longher>thicker"
It wouldn’t be as epic if they did something like a Parthian shot a feigned retreat or a cantabrian circle. And it wouldn’t be true to the Rohirrims style of warfare. But it might be more tactically viable.
I'd say the formation is most akin to medieval knights because the Rohirrim have an Anglican culture so it's supposed to feel very British. The battle I'd say is more akin to elite medieval knights fighting a force of poorly trained troops that lack experience fighting cavalry. Due to the terrain of Ithilin I'd say that Gondor seldom deployed cavalry against Mordor due to the trees making it difficult for cavalry to be deployed and if they ever were it was in relatively low amounts meaning that facing horses was likely a new experience for the orcs. Judging by the fact that most orcs wielded a spear of some sort I'd guess that they aren't particularly well trained because spears are relatively easy to use. I'd say the only advantage that the orcs had would be their mass because the horses as you said would have trouble barreling through the line due to the sheer number of men, but the orc commander also made a mistake with his formation and seemed to have packed his men too tight meaning the back ranks have to swing their spears, polarms, etc down instead of holding it there. Rohan on the other hand was an elite force led by their king using heavy armour. I say elite because Theoden chose these men to sneak around the mordor forces also they are well experienced fighting orcs with not only better weapons and heavier armour perfectly tailored to fighting cavalry i.e. Isenguard. I do agree that Rohan could've done must more damage had they decided to spread their formation out further, but the Rohirrim troops were just far more elite, better trained, more experienced, and more motivated to fight. I also want to bring up the fact that Rohirrim horses are all war horses and even if they weren't they charged downhill meaning they were going too fast to stop and on top of that the spears were short meaning that it would've been difficult to spot the spears until the horses got too close for them to stop.
29:05 the revised army now using meters instead of Imperial units makes this much more professional already!
I like this a lot better actually. It would make them feel so much smarter to be spread out wide and attack in a pair of echelons.
The first echelon is the lighter cavalry. They ride up at a gallop, surprisingly close, then at a horn signal, launch a wave of arrows and javelins into the orcs, devastating those first ranks of spears, then wheeling and disappearing through lannes in the oncoming second echelon which is the lancers.
Now as the orcs are reeling and disordered, the lancers close ranks and punch through in huge flying V Formations, shattering the orcs unit cohesion entirely while the lighter echelon has turned again, out handaxes and swords to clean up the stragglers.
Given the wide variety between the full-time horsemen of the army and the part-time militia cavalry types Rohan fields, that would be a very appropriate minimaxing of their options. It also fits with his 2-up/2-back layout, which is flexible and has reserves. Basically a square brigade.
20:47 in late medieval times, i understand cavalry was supposed to touch each other, specifically heavy armoured knights. They fought knee to knee, in a tight formation
Well this take on it makes me pretty sad. That was one of my favorite scenes from the trilogy😅
facts
It's still one of the finest pieces of cinema ever.
As some people pointed out, is it tactically sound? No. Does it make sense within the context of the story? Yes. Seeing Minas Tirith had (seemingly) basically fallen already, it was a suicide charge to go out in a blaze of glory (hence chanting "death" in Theoden's speech). Also, full frontal charges into infantry was done, even if not always a good idea. There's a difference between something being a bad strategy and something being unrealistic. Bad strategies happened a lot lol. In the middle ages, frontal charges by formations of knights (armed nobles, not professional soldiers trained together for years) happened more than they probably should have. Agincourt being a great example of this going very badly...
But as I've said in other comments yeah the formation depth is not realistic no matter how you slice it, but oh well it did look pretty sick.
@@damonhawkes2057 Not to me, I saw in theatre the day it came out and the complete lack of tactical realism between this scene, the Black Gate and a couple of others were just unnecessary blemishes in an otherwise excellent adaptation. All he needed was to hire someone that had half a clue, you can do epic battles without going total cringe.
Interesting video, but I am rather disappointed you mainly addressed the movie and failed to give Tolkien the credit he deserved.
It would have been great to give a shoutout to his army structure which features 120-rider Eöreds, which would correspond somewhat with the historical strategy you sought to highlight.
These riders may have not been able to spread out early, due to the details of their approach in the books, but I do believe it is implied that they did spread out once reaching the outer wall, and once the battle was engaged, and the eöred commanders were all given substantial autonomy in the field.
I know your main focus was to dispel cinematic myths about warfare, but the organization of Rohan‘s military is quite interesting and well done by talking and deserved some talk.
Really cool idea to reconstruct this but damn the screen tearing is driving me mad
I'll try and fix the capture next time around
Imagine if movie makers would put in just a little bit of work into realism, how much more interesting and dramatic these type of movies could be
@@jlih6271 the problem is that real-life battles lasted for hours, often an entire day, and this is hard to translate into film. It’s better and easier to simply send two armies running like mad men towards one another (even though this would be stupid in done in reality).
@licmir3663 no one is expecting 100% realism. I'm talking about the sub minimal research it would take to get the small details right. You could appease a whole mass of people with nerdy little details
The Winged Hussars charge in Vienna proves its possible 😂
If you had actually watched the movie, where Invicta described all the differences between the rohirim blob and the long line of winged hussars, you wouldn't sound like a total idiot
@@X.Y.Z.07 The charge during the siege of Vienna would've looked different. He's not criticising the idea of charging a besieging army but rather how its portrayed in the movie.
Dude we’re talking 18000 men, the ottomans were practically beaten at that point too.
Dude, I just watched return of the king yesterday twice. The extended version. Great 4th of July.
I saw an interesting reddit post about the charge and how it was suicidal, but theoretically could have done a lot of damage anyway. To make a long story short, the devastation wrought by a heavy cavalry charge on an unprepared and ill-managed infantry force is solid, and the army of mordor was unorganized and spread out, especially in the book. With so many client forces under lesser commanders all moving and trying to get to the city and kinda doing their own thing, the cavalry *could* crush individual forces and cause mass panic/confusion. Still not tactically sound, and it takes the intervention of The One himself to make it work, but i thought the argument ghe person made was fairly well-reasoned and fascinating
Of course we know that in the book there is a lot more actual tactics being used. Not detailed or fully explained but more sensible e.g. they are moving around farmyards and the like. They also acknowledge that they will need to wait to see the enemy for more detailed plans than "this is your objective overall".
But lets be fair, proper tactics do not make quite so glorious cinema.
They market that this is glorious so this kind of scene is glorious. For me, I find complex maneuvers and tactics more appealing than blobs of men charging and brawling.
@@linming5610 Thats Just you and I prefer the charge scene its better for film Making moment.
In defense of the movie's case.
1.- Their priority was not to more efficiently win the battle, they were in a clock to safe Gondor, you said it yourself, flying took you a while to cross the 2 kilometers, how much time it would've taken them to take positions? even organized they are still 6 thousands souls, organizing them would take such a long time that Gandalf would've probably get killed by the time they began their assault. And even after attacking the orc army outside of the city, how much time would it take for any of the riders to enter the city? just more time given to the orcs to kill even more Gondorians.
2.- Since they were pressed by urgency they knew it was a suicidal task, a charge so dense that most likely would've pressured the riders in front to continue charging because otherwise they would've been trampled by their own, combine this with an army of cowardly, small and unorganized orcs, add also the presence of the King Theoden. We saw the result, many of the orcs were already trying to flee before Rohan even made contact. The riders weren't facing an opposing force, they were trampling fleeing children.
3.- I firmly believe that magic had something to do with this. As I understand magic in the Lord of the Rings world, has to do with two things: spirit (will) and chanting (using words, music and songs). The fact of having king Theoden and the complete Rohirrim chant and roar together in a charge focused on death and ruin would give power to them, their horses and their endeavour.
So yes, tactically it was doomed to fail, but in context their bravery and union changed the scales and fate.
Pretty much my impression of why Peter Jackson had made it this way. Coolness and theatrics are factors of the depiction, but the very context of the situation depicted would essentially make the charge far more sensible as you add point number three.
Also, the being depicted that small essentially made that charge an actual sound tactic in LOTRs fantasy world because the horses, especially if given the "buffs," can easily trampled such opponents.
Moreso, the orcs were not in a position to reorganise, or it was just "too little too late" for the orcs to do a proper counter because of the charge itself. They even tried to attempt deterring the charge with arrow fire but only in a few times because panic was setting in on them. They are routed (in a flank), and they know it.
I think we can all agree though.... still better than game of thrones "long night" so called "tactics"
Biggest disaster was charging head on into war elephants
They think they have enough Anti-Large stat 😂
I love how the charge at helms deep is just so unrealistic that it doesnt even deserve a discussion lol.
Incredible! Thanks for creating this.
You are the best kind of nerd. I *love* these kinds of discussions - this is what being a LotR fan is all about!
I remember watching that scene as a kid and was thinking "why didn't those orcs put up a wall of spears? are they stupid?"
From a combat standpoint the diamond formation, spearhead formation or any similar formations do not work.
A formation is not one solid element to benefit from physics, aerodynamics for arrows.
It is a combination of elements and the guy that occupies the spearhead is just dead.
It's not like the shock is absorbed by the units behind him.
I love this style of video! Please keep it up!
In the book they charge because they think they are going to lose and all die. So king Theoden basically decides to go out like s gangsta. Alos there is a massive wall that surroundes the farm land outside the city called the Rammas Echor so it covered the advance of the Rohirrim and they charged through multiple breaches in the wall. They took the orcs by surprise
I love this in depth look at the charge. I cant wait for more!
Do you want to ride a unicorn or a Pegasus?
Yes
You are kinda forgetting several parts:
1 The part where the Orcs hate and fear the sun, and are not expecting it to come out for the siege.
2 The part where the Orcs have a blocking army in position to prevent the Rohirrim from aiding Miras Tirith. The Rohirrim bypass this army and appear with no warning.
3 The part where Orcs hate and fear horses.
There is no doubt that the orcs would break. But I do agree that they would want to be more effective.
Timing matters too, because Theoden arrived basically undetected, giving him a massive advantage. The hours it takes to reposition and organise the riders will allow Mordor to calm down, react and handily defeat the charge with a cloud of heavy infantry. A bad charge in the perfect moment will have the best effect, especially with the high average skill of the riders, as they don't require a huge amount of tactical and organisational management to just stay coherent as a unit.
"it's beautifull, but it's no war" a french general said that while watching the charge of the light brigade in Balaclava. It applies here as well.
Amazing video yet again!
Great video!
Don't know enough about the Teutonic or Winged Hursar enough to comment, but the suggested unit formation seemed to be too 1-sided on Cataphracts but lacking horse archery or medium armoured cavalry to follow through.
Thinking along the line of Chinese / Mongol cavalry, Cataphracts only account for a fraction of the total force. Take the Sui Cavalry as example, 1 of the richest cavalry force in Chinese history, I recall only 1/8 were Heavy. Rest being light / archery for scouting and flanking purpose, and the rest were medium armoured (being cheaper, more affordable) for general purpose including follow through. The Gin cavalry, with their famous Iron Buda force, actually composed a unit size of 20 Cataphracts supported by 30 Archers to form a basic unit of 50, and their Iron Buda force were a few thousand out of a total cavalry army of ten of thousands.
So, if I am allowed to re-size your 6000 troopers, I would say 1000 being horse archery in the front, harrasing enemy like skirmishing troops, then pull back for the main attack of iron fist Cataphracts to charge, say around 1000, then follow by medium cavalry of lancers to follow through / capture flags / kill generals.
Whether they are being deployed left right centre is a different argument.
This is amazing! Way to go guys!
27:21 All the Roel Konijnendijk fans are pleased.
This is a good critique of the movie charge. The Charge of the Rohirrim in the book is much more tactical. It’s not deeply elaborated on, but little mentions of different leaders and their men going different directions and taking on separate areas of the battlefield prove that Prof. Tolkien knew what he was doing. One unit rode to the right along the wall of Minas Tirith. Another rode straight for the orcs attacking the gate. One rode to the far left and encircled. One unit rode through the catapults and slew their operators and drove them into the fire trenches. The king and his men pierced straight through the heart of the orc army until he reached a unit of Southron cavalry who thought they could take him on and died in the attempt.
Ultimately the charge did fail in its ultimate goal. It did not completely break the lines of Mordor. There were so many orcs and men in Mordor’s army that the Rohirrim only routed about half of them. They actually dismounted and formed a ring shield wall; preparing for a fight to the death when they saw the Corsair ships coming. But the ships were full of Gondorian soldiers instead of pirates. Thus Aragorn saved the day.
So like I said… good critique of the film. You are right about that. But that’s not the real Ride of the Rohirrim. The real one is so much better. Although it still failed.
Read this first in 1969 and thought Tolkien had cribbed from King Sobieski's homework including sneaking through the woods to achieve tactical surprise.
You realize how tactically unsound the ride of the Rohirrim is when you attempt to replicate it yourself in Battle for Middle Earth...
Invicta will now always be known as Unreal's base template model on a Pegasus for me 😂
Gotta love that scale! I watch battlefield documentaries often with my friends and sometimes they're like "why didn't they just send some units to the flank that's being overrun?". Well, because it takes time to get a messenger on horseback from that flank to your command post, probably 1-2 kilometers away, and then again even more time to organize your reserves and send them over that same distance. It would probably take at least half an hour to get your reserves where they need to go, which is a VERY long time if that flank has been surrounded.
I’ve come up with a design that might solve some of the main issues with the Rohirrim’s tactics seen in the movies. Here’s my take on the fix:
**Concept Overview:**
The proposed harness system aims to enhance cavalry charges, similar to the "Ride of the Rohirrim" from *The Lord of the Rings*. By mechanically connecting warhorses, the formation maintains momentum, overcoming typical challenges where front ranks stall and hinder those behind. The design integrates a traditional leather and rope harness with a retractable metal harness system, which can be properly spaced and locked in place for stability and effectiveness.
**Harness Design Breakdown:**
1. **Traditional Leather and Rope Hauling Harness**:
- **Leather Straps**: Secure harness to each horse, providing comfort and stability.
- **Rope Connections**: Reinforce structure and distribute load evenly.
2. **Metal Retractable Harness**:
- **Metal Construction**: Foldable and retractable for flexibility and strength.
- **Attachment Points**: Connect to the traditional harness for added stability.
- **Pin-Lock Mechanism**: Locks the harness in place once properly spaced, ensuring a stable and unified formation.
- **Friction Lock Release**: Incorporates a mechanism where significant downward stress (such as a horse falling) causes the pin to pop out, releasing the harness to prevent the formation from getting hindered from “dead weight”
- **Structural Connections**: Ensure unified movement and maintain momentum.
- **Segment Coverage**: Covers horses' hindquarters, front quarters, and sides, allowing attachment to other horses on any flank in the formation.
**Implementation in Battle:**
- **Unified Charge**: Prevents stalls, ensuring continuous push.
- **Increased Force**: Connected horses provide a powerful and unstoppable force against enemy lines.
- **Tactical Advantage**: Mitigates issues in traditional cavalry charges, ensuring all horses contribute effectively.
By using this harness system, the cavalry charge would be more effective, maintaining its momentum and delivering a significant impact on the battlefield.
If anyone has any questions on the design please feel free to ask
If one horse fell, the whole line would be impeded and fall down.... That is why 4 horse chariots (harnessed together much like what you say) depended on the chariot archer/spear thrower shooting from a distance but could not wade into contact, hence chariots became completely obsolete once the foot stirrup was invented. The horses have to keep their own rhythm and ability to maneuver or they bind and fall down. One thing I would add to the scene is chest protection to the horses, and pointier less deep lines with breathing spaces between and behind the points. 6 deep and 12 wide chevrons-triangles at most maybe.
Cool. Thanks for sharing.
thanks for video
Great video mate.
This reminded me of the game Battle for Middle Earth (RTS). They overpowered the charge mechanics for horse and warg riders, but even in that game the calvary needed to keep moving and charge again from the back or sides.
Beautifully done. I knew watching the charge in the theater the tactics were dumb. Still one of my favorite scenes ever.
We must agree, though, that the films did a tactical disservice; a glorious one, but a misshap nonetheless. In the book, surprise, surprise, it is better thought out.
I have to pick upon the "loss of unit cohesion" point, especially the mention of horses not keeping lines and breaking formation essentially. It might have been true in early formations but at most since XIV century cavalry unit horses were trained specifically for keeping in line with each other, not speeding up to their full speed nor falling behind for whatever reason they encounter. Up to XVIII century we got such absurd situations of Turks relating their impression of winged hussar charges that the horses kept in perfect lines, didnt flinch at being shot at by guns and rifles, didnt stop or break formation even when their rider was shot off, didnt stop charging when a cannonball took one of the horses legs. I know this example is quite extreme, but you can at least expect horses of a rider nation to keep in line during initial charge.
This also considers the next point, which is charging head on against braced spears. Winged hussars did it a lot, with losses, not too drastic tho, because then it comes to the lenght of your stick. If your lance is longer (up to 9m for hussars) than, say, Sweedish pikeman's pike (up to 7m) you are pretty much fine for retaliation since the pikeman who tries to stop you has a lance in his torso for a fraction of second that flings him back quite badly, removing a lot of oomph from the pike now unbraced and falling, flinching or just rising by too strong of a grip of falling pikeman. The insane training of the horses ment that they didnt bother with charging head on into the sides of wagons even, you can do that with animal training, it happened before. About going into ranks of infantry: since none guy with spear wants to be trampled, there happened sort of symbiotic decision between horsemen and infantry: the weakest or targeted infantrymen were making some sort of corridors between ranks of infantry with both sides trying to strike at passing horses (even with long thick stick its not this easy to stop half a ton of speeding animal, often armoured, even if you killed the horse, you still have half a ton of meat flung at your face - one of the reasons why even pikes broke before charges so often) while, since horsemen due to "honors" (and not at all due to most rich guy being in front because he can afford best armour for himself and his horse) had their best, most armoured in the front to open up the formation, then to stream into them and use sabres, swords, maces and so on instead of lances, to strike at the mentioned corridor left and right as often as possible.
The "on the move" section seems to confirm my statement: the later periods of horseman use in combat, the napoleonic for example, they travel side by side to reinforce (and brag for any watchers from enemy) the training of the horses, that the horse HAS TO see its mates along himself all the time and its fine. This part of the horse training is especially crucial in charges to break the enemy formation (that is rectangular shape of formation), not to create a breach in line.
The one huge aspect of the battle you missed almost completely is morale, but its hard to gauge how much an orc would be willing to die for Sauron nor how much a Rohirrim would be willing to give for relief of an ally in a very important war, so I kinda get it why you dodged this. Morale always was the name of the game with cav charges, most succesfull units in history took half of their success from enemy knowing how mad, ruthless and deadly they were, nevermind facts, they often ran away before melee (that also includes aforementioned winged hussars but many cases of medieval knights use too)
Other than that: amazing job, deep analisys, superb knowledge :)
In the books there definitely are officers and banners used by the Rohirrim. They also do not charge a line of braced spears. And while there are no definite unit sizes given we can assume them to be a lot smaller than in the movie from some of the descriptions of the battle.
The charge of the rohirrim was inspired from the charge of the polish winged hussars outside the walls of Vienna in 1683. That charge successfully broke the ottoman lines and routed the entire ottoman army.
I think that the movie did a good job of showing the Orcs wavering, and when the charge comes you can see several running away before the charge hits. The orcs are in full route as the riders cut through them and yes it is chaotic but it's fox hunt before the Eles come into the picture. Btw, love the chants of the Haradrim and their horns might be my favorite.
It is a tactical disaster. Rohan was losing the battle, had no chance of winning as they knew they didn't have enough men to begin with, and would have been destroyed if it wasn't for Aragorn coming to save them.
Fun fact, Theoden is in his 70s in the battle.
Fantastic video!!
Three thumbs up!
Excellent video 👍 Thank you 💜
The thin spread out formation is also a lot less vulnerable to missile fire as opposed to a dense blob.
I love Tolkien and LOTR movies so I absolutely enjoy all sort of deep dives!
Also, I love these "true size" analysis. I always scratch my head when in books they say "army 10 000 strong marching/camping" etc, I cannot picture it in my head.
Guys, awesome video thanks ❤
I don't have the time to watch the entire thing right now but I hope this takes into consideration that the orks were armed with scrap. You can even see an orc using a fork tied to a stick as a spear if I recall correctly
True.
They had no pikes, and few spears worthy of the name.
Virtually nothing to resist a charge.
@@patrickkenyon2326 ypu clearly are blind as you can clearly see spears and pikes in the moviea used by the orcs
Very nice video about the charge of the Rohirrim!
I imagined that the depth also allowed for shifting the front infantry troops to the back, so they can rest during engagement. Or if someone falls someone takes their place and hopefully the injured gets treatment. Though it would need incredible training and discipline.
It is kinda funny to imagine a veteran of World War One writing a cavalry charge like this.
The thing is, Tolkien did not write this. This was Peter Jackson's work, and in the context of the film this is actually plausible adding extra mechanics like the morale boost due to charging on mass while the enemy is still very disorganized. The size of the orcs in the film made a trampling charge not only possible but highly effective. All of the Rohirrim's horses are selected as such because they are bred as war horses.
The charge in the film does work, but it will only work for the film's context. Invicta was just a bit technical on this, which is good considering he did preface this would not be very good IRL.
I'll just say this again, Tolkien did not write this, and it was Peter Jackson who made this the ideal depiction in a cinema perspective and even the plausibility still works only if given the parameters of the film's fantasy world is used during the situation.
I didn’t think the formation change would do anything but honestly when at the end you compared them and pointed out what was likely going on I got anxious just thinking of being in the big blob and got an immediate morale boost thinking of the more realistic one. Like holy crap that one just feels more in control more able to improvise or adapt to the situation. Not gonna lie I’d love to see a full recreation of what could have happened with the revised army. Nothing against the original because it’s cinematic af and I’ll still get that adrenaline pump but oh man that could still be a really badass scene.
You missed a huge benefit to the blob. More people can hear Théoden's badass speech for +100% to all stats.
I also find it interesting how modern tactics have not strayed nearly as far from historic tactics as many tend to believe.
Yes, maneuver is faster now, weapons range is much farther and lethal, but the underlying strategies are relatively unchanged. They may appear very fifferent at the micro level, but zoom out and the organization and distribution of various capabilities are much the same.
Substitute cavalry for army aviation, dragoons for mechanized infantry, light infantry for special forces, etc. Their purposes and placement on the battlefield would be recognizeable to any Napoleonic or American Civil War general.
So cool to see. Would be great to see one of these videos on the Carolean army of Charles XII, especially since they had unusual cavalry tactics.
book Theoden was a bit more tactful in his attack. Movie Theoden did give some of the same orders but in the end Rohirrim just ended up staying in one blob when Book Rohirrim had at least divided their force into three different groups, and then wisely didn't charge the mumlaks but attacked on foot with archers.
I agree about the folly of the formation in depth for cavalry.
That said, the horses of Rohan are supposed to be a superior, hardier breed than real life horses, hence why they could get away with the blob charge. Just my thoughts.
Good breakdown. Really sinks in just how small of a force Theoden had. Balls of steel!
Theoden knew the whole thing was going to fail, remember before Aragon left for his quest, Theoden said they didn't have enough men or horses but they also had no time left to wait for a few thousand more riders to arrive. Also stretching the line of medium tribal cavalry not all armed with lances or heavily armored would have weakened what shock value they had. The best bet was a concentrated charge to make it to the gates and hopefully have the citadel troops attack. The entire thing wasn't a grand plan to victory, it was a desperate attempt for the last few organised armies to try and survive
😊 Thank you for your analysis of cavalry formation.