What's more interesting about that encounter is that when you go fishing with Jack at the end of Ch. 2, if you already had that encounter beforehand, Jack will say thanks to Arthur for his new clothes! Insane amount of details in this game! Here's a link to a video I made about it. th-cam.com/video/igrdw8an1NE/w-d-xo.html
I guess my game glitched, and i couldn't see the chain. I was looking for it so long. If you stay there for too long, that boy will lose hope and start to cry, saying, "I'm never getting out of here, right?" And i shot nearby his leg thinking therell be chain. Instead, he got shot. My last save file was back in Chapter 2, so i couldn't load it up. Even tho i wanted to. But anyway, i shot the gunsmith and robbed all the ammo. My honor fell faster than Dutch did in RDR1.
I honestly kinda felt bad for when he told his story about his son, later I was sitting there for like 5 minutes hoping I get higher honor for “ comforting him “
I ignored him accidentally more than 3 times , when I find he deceased and gone to confront gunsmith at "chapter 4" , I know it was too late , there are no option to check his basement so i killed him
It doesn't make sense for the boy to die since the gunsmith held him there because he reminded him of his son. If you threaten the gunsmith go down the stairs and then leave, the next day the boy would be dead. The reason why he was being kept there was because of the gunsmith's grief so i don't really understand why the boy is deceased.
That gunsmith always grossed me out. Yes it is sad what happened to his son but he has a grown man dressed as a sailor and chained to the bed which is concerning because if his son survived would he have done the same to him
He had me the first time I just freed the kid and left but after seeing him dead after the 3rd day completely changed my mind about him. The guy is a liar and a sicko! That’s why the liar on the wall is written. It was all a farce for his sick perversion
@theoutsiderjess4869 If the Gunsmith at Rhodes "grossed you out" I can't wait to hear how the Butcher at Rhodes and the "meat" that he sells will/does make you feel 😮😁😅
I wanted to loot the room first before I free the chained guy but when I was doing it, the guy just started crying thinking I won't help him so I shot the chains first. Luckily, the outcome plays the same from there.
I absolutely LOVE the content! He's one of my biggest inspirations, no matter what the internet clowns think with their reddit beards who wanna try and spread false rumors about my opinions of him. However, I'm on board with the majority when I say the A.I. Voiceover gotta go. IDK why he doesn't give his own voiceovers a try, I'd love for him to try that over his current methods. But if this is what makes him happy then I say keep it! I still watch his videos every now and then either way. But the Kifflom girl, I won't lie, is really CRINGE /: She can hit the road! lol
Hey I have a question I killed the guy who Owns that store active saving That guy being held prisonal. And he comes back. How is that possible to do I killed him. Can someone explain that
In my 20th play through Abigail asks Arthur for money to buy Jack new clothes, this game has so many secrets left.
What's more interesting about that encounter is that when you go fishing with Jack at the end of Ch. 2, if you already had that encounter beforehand, Jack will say thanks to Arthur for his new clothes! Insane amount of details in this game! Here's a link to a video I made about it. th-cam.com/video/igrdw8an1NE/w-d-xo.html
Arthur - "You should really get out more" 😭 lol 😂
Only Arthur will joke in a moment of crisis
@@RDBTheRedDeath
Lol
@@RDBTheRedDeath hes the best😂
“Hey, we’ve all kidnapped someone.”
“We have?”
“No! Of course not!”
Made me snort
LMFAO
Gunsmith *talks about his son's death*
Me who only triggered the encounter to get the Lancaster = oh no! anyway
Lmao
Did you do this before Micah gives you one
@@theoutsiderjess1869 in my first playthrough I got it from micah but then a year later I replayed the game but I got it from the gunsmith
I guess my game glitched, and i couldn't see the chain. I was looking for it so long. If you stay there for too long, that boy will lose hope and start to cry, saying, "I'm never getting out of here, right?" And i shot nearby his leg thinking therell be chain. Instead, he got shot. My last save file was back in Chapter 2, so i couldn't load it up. Even tho i wanted to. But anyway, i shot the gunsmith and robbed all the ammo. My honor fell faster than Dutch did in RDR1.
8:51 that actually made me tear up
Honestly, same. Incredible how such a minor encounter in this game can evoke such strong emotions. A masterfully written game
@@RDBTheRedDeath in chapter 6 when u talk to mickey (the homeless veteran in valentine) really made me cry inside
I honestly kinda felt bad for when he told his story about his son, later I was sitting there for like 5 minutes hoping I get higher honor for “ comforting him “
Idk how I feel about him anymore now knowing that he kills the poor guy
Arthur’s the type of guy to find the whole gang and then see Colm and go “ well, I’ll leave you be”
I ignored him accidentally more than 3 times , when I find he deceased and gone to confront gunsmith at "chapter 4" , I know it was too late , there are no option to check his basement so i killed him
7:57 this is fucked up but, the transition with the music killed me😂
Lmao
It doesn't make sense for the boy to die since the gunsmith held him there because he reminded him of his son. If you threaten the gunsmith go down the stairs and then leave, the next day the boy would be dead. The reason why he was being kept there was because of the gunsmith's grief so i don't really understand why the boy is deceased.
maybe he took his own life
5:32 So what happens if you just leave at this point? IE take the rifle and loot etc but leave the gunsmith alive and the dude chained up.
Despawn
The first time i played i rejected helping him because i was scared of robberies in this game at the time. I didnt know he died if you dont help him
What’s something you’ve just discovered in RDR2 that really impressed you?
Wtf never heard of that@@Magnum-man
Shooting bear traps to set them off is a good one lol
That if you shoot moonshine destilles hot smoke will come out and hurt you
@@Magnum-manvery nice
@@danim8414youre a man of patience
After he dies from you abandoning him, can you still go down to the basement?
No, it will no longer give you the option to threaten mr feeney to open the door
That gunsmith always grossed me out. Yes it is sad what happened to his son but he has a grown man dressed as a sailor and chained to the bed which is concerning because if his son survived would he have done the same to him
He had me the first time I just freed the kid and left but after seeing him dead after the 3rd day completely changed my mind about him. The guy is a liar and a sicko! That’s why the liar on the wall is written. It was all a farce for his sick perversion
@theoutsiderjess4869 If the Gunsmith at Rhodes "grossed you out" I can't wait to hear how the Butcher at Rhodes and the "meat" that he sells will/does make you feel 😮😁😅
What happens if you go Down to the basement, hear some dialog and then just walk out without freeing or kill anybody? 🤔
Despawn /:
How does Arthur chug a bottle of whiskey in .2 seconds
Its not really that hard
You hadda try to kidnap the young man after freeing him to check his pockets… maybe he was hiding some letters or something like that
I was waiting for a mission to find the gunsmith's son. I felt really bad for him.
I wanted to loot the room first before I free the chained guy but when I was doing it, the guy just started crying thinking I won't help him so I shot the chains first. Luckily, the outcome plays the same from there.
I just started RDR2 and got this. I know the scenes emotional and all but I burst out laughing with the way he said the recoil killed the boy
I’ve learned so much about the game from you and I thank you for it, but sadly I’m on the epilogue ☹️
I’m glad to hear that! Happy I could help the experience better!
lol the end “We do” idk why I thought that was funny
Because you bear my children and I am the King around these parts!!!! Love you lol
Does anything change when you abandon him as Arthur and then go back to save him as John?
Beautiful game as always
Love your videos
Thank you very much
i just have flashing ? mark near basement and i cant even rob the gunsmith
Poor feller
Great vid
Thanks, how's your brother Clive?
Hey @RedsDeadBaby, you know who the strange man is right? The youtube channel? I wanna know your thoughts on the ai voice and the kifflom girl.
I absolutely LOVE the content! He's one of my biggest inspirations, no matter what the internet clowns think with their reddit beards who wanna try and spread false rumors about my opinions of him. However, I'm on board with the majority when I say the A.I. Voiceover gotta go. IDK why he doesn't give his own voiceovers a try, I'd love for him to try that over his current methods. But if this is what makes him happy then I say keep it! I still watch his videos every now and then either way. But the Kifflom girl, I won't lie, is really CRINGE /: She can hit the road! lol
what is the soundtracks name in the background ?
how do you get that angle from aming a gun in first person
Hey I have a question I killed the guy who Owns that store active saving That guy being held prisonal. And he comes back. How is that possible to do I killed him. Can someone explain that
Not sure I understand? You mean you killed the gunsmith and then came back and he’s still there or how do you mean?
Yes
I remember executing the gunsmith and robbing his store after he told me about his son's death.
😳
In my case i killed him so he Did not have to suffer but normally in Rdr2 Im the most sadistic and vicious player ever
I robbed his store didnt bother killing him because Im doing a good playthrough
Can you still confront the gunsmith if the boah died?
Unfortunately, no :(
What happens if you let the kid die and then confront the gunsmith
Why did bro shoot him there 💀🙏
Can I play this mission with John?
Man this beautiful game really gives me hope for the quality of gta 6 😭
Very excited myself for what they are planning
Tbf i think red dead 2 was basically a little test for them
I think it will be more like gta5 than rdr2
I really hope its goona be good
HELL YEAH REd dea d BABY
atleast you dont have an ai voiceover :')
I love strange man! I think he’s just trying something new. I’m PRAYING someone else hasn’t taken over his channel :,(