Watch: Congress MP Shashi Tharoor Exclusive On US' Deportation Of Indians | Beyond The Headline
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.พ. 2025
- In this edition of Beyond The Headline, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor has joined anchor Sneha Koshy for an exclusive discussion on the US' deportation of Indians. Shashi Tharoor says “If there are more people sent back, it is because more people are going, people are looking for a better life, US is a magnet for people looking for a better life..”
This comes as US military aircraft carrying 104 alleged illegal Indian immigrants landed in Amritsar on Wednesday. The flight from San Antonio, Texas, included deportees from Punjab (30), Haryana and Gujarat (33 each), Maharashtra and Uttar Pradesh (3 each), and Chandigarh (2), according to sources cited by PTI. Footage showed a US military C-17 aircraft arriving at Shri Guru Ramdas Ji International Airport around 1:30 PM, where the deported individuals disembarked. Watch the full discussion to know more and follow Mirror Now for the latest updates.
.
#shashitharoor #exclusive #donaldtrump #deportaion #india #us #unitedstates #pmmodi #deported #narendramodi #indiausties #indiausrelation #englishnews #latestnews #beyondtheheadline #mirrornow
SUBSCRIBE NOW | bit.ly/Subscri...
For More Updates ► www.mirrornowne...
Like us on Facebook ► / mirrornow
Follow us on Twitter ► / mirrornow
Follow us on Instagram ► / mirrornow_in
Subscribe to our other network channels:
Times Now Navbharat: bit.ly/Subscri...
Zoom: bit.ly/Subscri...
Times Now: bit.ly/Subscri...
ET Now: bit.ly/Subscri...
TN+: bit.ly/Subscri...
If you have done some thing illegal then you will be dealt the same way...
@kishan5481 u r AB ...insensitive be it this case or deaths in mahakumb.
Columbians are also sent back but they were taken with respect.
How do indians expect any better if citizens like you are there
Mr Trump is great and must do that
Modi ne Ind8a ki ijjat mitti me mila diya lekin yeh chamcho aur paid media channel uski g*** chat rahe rahe hain abhi tak... Sabhi Indians ko beijjati tareeke se wapas bheja Trump ne... Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂
Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂 America Jane Wale Indians ko beijjati karke wapis Modi k pass bhej diya Trump ... Trump ne Modi ko bol diya rakh liyo tumhare criminals ko khud ki country me... Vade hokar yeh India me politicians banenge 😂
These are criminals as per US law and got correct treatment.
Yeah sure
Modi ne Ind8a ki ijjat mitti me mila diya lekin yeh chamcho aur paid media channel uski g*** chat rahe rahe hain abhi tak... Sabhi Indians ko beijjati tareeke se wapas bheja Trump ne... Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂
That means the world has got a message that India has full of criminals and US will shame the criminals of India
Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂 America Jane Wale Indians ko beijjati karke wapis Modi k pass bhej diya Trump ... Trump ne Modi ko bol diya rakh liyo tumhare criminals ko khud ki country me... Bade hokar yeh criminals India me politicians banenge 😂
These GREEDY people want more ...
.at any cost... VERY UNFORTUNATE These people getting bad name for the country
Every country has the right to deport illegal immigrants who dont have the valid documents required.
I believe they were handicuffed not as an insult but to ensure the safety Of the Pilot & Cabin crew
except India else it would have also deported rohingyas and kangladeshis
My friend Dolund Trump 😂😂😂
Many children and women.... were they really a threat to 45 officials?? Haha
and even the men with no crime records ....
AB accept it was to show insult
Modi ne Ind8a ki ijjat mitti me mila diya lekin yeh chamcho aur paid media channel uski g*** chat rahe rahe hain abhi tak... Sabhi Indians ko beijjati tareeke se wapas bheja Trump ne... Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂
Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂 America Jane Wale Indians ko beijjati karke wapis Modi k pass bhej diya Trump ... Trump ne Modi ko bol diya rakh liyo tumhare criminals ko khud ki country me... Bade hokar yeh criminals India me politicians banenge 😂
What if they retaliate without a handcuff
Mr. Tharoor, these guys are not from poor families that they went donke route spending
lakhs of rupees knowing well the risks invoived. So, blaming the government not creating conducive environment in India is not a valid case for argument. They broke all the laws and they paid a price for it.
Also US has not adopted this particular way of expulsion only for India. It applied to all illegal immigrants from all countries. So, being a learned person you are, please do not politicise this issue. If posssible, argue for implementing same rule in india against all illegals. We will save lot of resources of this country. Humble request as you are the only one person who spoke sensibly in this topic. Jai Hind.
Many more gujrati Hero are coming back to Bharat Mahan
@@AsifAnsari-vn5bh kemcho? Majamaa 🤣😂
Dear Mirror now, why is opposition party asked instead Ruling party. Let Modi also say !!
Tharoor is Christian. He has control over America.
He wants to the ball in the opposition court.
@@johagaming2288 Don't defend Tharoor just because he's a closet Christian..
Modi ne Ind8a ki ijjat mitti me mila diya lekin yeh chamcho aur paid media channel uski g*** chat rahe rahe hain abhi tak... Sabhi Indians ko beijjati tareeke se wapas bheja Trump ne... Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂
As per reports if Columbia did not allow US military aircraft to land on its soil and instead it sent its civilian aircraft..whers "viswaguru" And viksit bharat hiding ?shame! 2:28
Whats the shame? Next you will want band Baja
They are criminals this respect is enough
Congressi. 😂😂😂
We are not a drug Barron power
Sabhi criminal Indians ko beijjati tareeke se wapas bheja Trump ne... Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂
per Modi and team , Everything in India is so good , then why people risking their life to get out of the heaven Modi created?
Sabhi Indians ko beijjati tareeke se wapas bheja Trump ne... Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂
In India we don't accept candidate from other district in election how can U S A
Sasi Tharur always a gentle man.
Not only Indians but illegal immigration of other countries are also deported in the same way😮
Why handcuff??
I think it's because they wanted to send a stern message to all the countries, in deterring future illegal migrants / ghuspeTiyaan.
To give a message to the world that that Modi has no aukat in front of Trump ... Trump shamed those Indians openly and loudly
Thank God and Indian government relations with US for sending illegal through their military plane to their destination. Would india do this for illegal rohingiyas and kangladeshi ?
@diasagnello
Good relations?? Is this the way of good relations??
Don't forget no invitation
Rohingyas and illegal Bangladeshis should immediately be deported. Only talk is happening so far.
They can just walk back 🤷🏻♂️ like USA and Mexico or USA and Canada
Sabhi Indians ko beijjati tareeke se wapas bheja Trump ne... Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂
@@amitm1993 that's way you people called illiterate😂
SASHI THAROOR IS NOT CONCERNED ABOUT THE PHYSICAL SAFETY OF ESCORTING US SOLDIERS AND PLANE CREW.
They are criminals! Respect for these illegal immigrants! What’s he talking about?
Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂 America Jane Wale Indians ko beijjati karke wapis Modi k pass bhej diya Trump ... Trump ne Modi ko bol diya rakh liyo tumhare criminals ko khud ki country me... Vade hokar yeh India me politicians banenge 😂
Thanks Modi and BJP for making India so great that people want to escape their own country however possible. 🤭🤭
Trump using military planes is something similar to Modi's Surgical Strikes ?😂😢😅
Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂
@amitm1993
If you can understand English, why not write the comment in English ?
@@josephandrews5467 my wish bro
@@amitm1993
I take it that you are ridiculing Modi .
@@josephandrews5467 If you are an Indian then you should learn Hindi. It'll help you connect with the majority of people as hindi is the most spoken language in India.
What I was saying is - Trump showed Modi who is the boss. He kind of shamed the Indians by sending them back with chains n handcuffs. And Modi govt still behaving like a masseur of USA.
Sending a military plane to a sovereign country ? Sure they must have got clearance, but why could we not sent a air India flight to bring them
They will not treat criminals like achievers 😂.
Good last note, sashi
Mr. Tharoor unnecessarily brought the "Amritkal" issue here. Many of these guys would have entered USA even before NDA rule.
Moreover how does 'Amritkal' apply to traitors who ran away from their own country hoping to become criminal patriots of USA
How many zeros are to be added to the counts mentioned???
On a US aircraft, you are on US territories so don't spill crocodile tears over a non-issue. You can try to cross into N Korea or China and try to preach them.
Why all this noise now? What respect for illegal immigrants? What have your Govts done to send back B'deshi & Rohingyas illegals from India?
These guys were shackled, being criminals. They could have attacked the crew & guards.
Ok India can send their flights and collect them…
He is a cartoon , let him fix kerela first
Why the majority of them northern Indians Gujarat Punjab even after southern states tax money is given to them
LOL South Indian money given to Gujarat and Punjab? 😂
Go see a Doctor or you are Smoking something 🤣
This guy was in US for so many years writing column after column but not a squeak on this matter! Their pasports should be cancelled permanentlY!FUTTHER SAME TREATMENT TO ILLEGAL ENTRIES IN INDIA!😮🌚🌚🌚🌚🌚
How about SHUTTING UP THE TALK and start taking action to clean the country forst and then give better jobs to people?!! You guys keep on.talking... thats all you politicians do.
Petion VishwaGuru. Their Govt is responsible. Don't bark up the wrong tree
Stay home and develop your own country stopthe brain drain
While small countries like Columbia refused US military air raft in their countries, Spineless Govt allowing US military aircraft to their country for immigrants deportation, moreover hand cuffed and chained. Atleast they and their are not criminals. They have not got very little time to sale their properties and bank balances with them.
This is highly deplorable, be they are Gujrathis,Hariaynas or Punjabis ,As they are all Indians.
NOPE THEY RE ALLOWED IT
@@sanjibranjanmaity652 They may be small but you should be mindful that Colombia and nation supplies almost the entire narcotics drug demand in USA isn’t this essential for them
🤪
Why doesn’t India bring back its citizens?
US is not same as India given shelter to rohngias and Bangladeshi and even citizenship to them by Muslims of India 😂🎉
The deported illegals are not poor people, in fact they spend a fortune to become illegals in the US. The Govt of India & the Rohingya sympathizing opposition should be proud of them & reward n recognise these lion hearts for their over whelming act of bravery & national pride.
40 hours in military aircraft, both hands and legs chained? That was extreme my dear Trump.
what is he preaching ?,drama is going on directed by Trump
But not in this manner, madam. It is humiliating
😂😂😂
It’s not humiliating to have citizens who illegally immigrated to USA. If they go to US illegally, they are liable to USlaw and procedures. No sympathy here. We should deport Rohingyas and illegal Bangladeshis…
No respect for Indian accept it we are 3 class.
DO NOT WORRY 2 CRORE ILLEGALLY BANGLADESHI WILL BE DEPORTED ASAP
IND ARE LOW ON CONFIDENCE AND CANNOT SPEAK IF YOU WANT REPECT DEMAND RESPECT
Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂 America Jane Wale Indians ko beijjati karke wapis Modi k pass bhej diya Trump
@@amitm1993 LOL IND IS NOT KANGLU ILLEGAL ARE CRIMINAL.
Appreciate Shashi Tharoor . Very matured response , instead of raising political issues. Wish we can use his skill, maturity and diplomacy as an opposition leader
Praising a dumb statement talks highly about your level of understanding
Trump ne message de diya ki Modi ki koi aukat nahi hai uske samne 😂 America Jane Wale Indians ko beijjati karke wapis Modi k pass bhej diya Trump
@@amitm1993 wah!!! Kya baat Kahi hai. Sahi kahan hai. Waise sahi raaste jaane waale kitne wapas aaye?
Why Indians expect lenient action from USA that too illegally stayed . America is not following Hinduism to accommodate specially those purposely entered their country. So no need to follow " Lokaa Samasta Sukhino Bhavanthu".
So as per him they shouldn't create ruckus over Bangladeshi deportation
Unemployment problem
7:46 MIGA
Shashiji, you know about US very well. Illegals are criminals and how can you expect criminals will be treated with respect? Your mind got corrupted with RaGa association, unfortunately. As they say, one has to bark when acting as dog. Please be sensible as you know the laws of western countries
Are there illegal chinese immigrants in US ? Will US treat them as they treated Indians.
Issue not worth debating. Illegal cannot be proved legal . Don't expect america to feed them biriyani , dru-gs , mobiles , massage parlour like how india jail does to criminals
It is the old proverb made new: tresspassers will be prosecuted"...
No one from Pakistan, their migrants are well educated and legal, same from Afghanistan, they are well educated and highly skilled, WTF
These r common people not criminals
They went on look out for better livelihood
Poor states in north gujarat, haryana, punjab and UP rajastsn like these people r from should create jobs
You are forgetting one word here...they are ILLEGAL immigrants. They are breaking laws here.
Illigal immigrants means fraudsters who entered America without proper documented papers.
Entering a country illegally is a criminal offence and hence they are criminals. Get well soon and clear up your mind
Gujarat, Haryana, Punjab, poor states 😂🤣
Keep smoking what you are smoking.. you seem quite high 😂
Irrespective India make more employment opportunity or no people wanted to migrate will continue migrate legally or illegally as it says ‘grass is greener on the other side… The first thing to know is that migration is not a problem to be solved in fact, it is a powerful driver of sustainable development, for migrants and their communities. It brings significant benefits in the form of skills, strengthening the labor force, investment and cultural diversity, among others.
It's time into introspect and evaluate the claims used to be deliberately tweeted since 2014 that the power of Indian passport has gone up.😂😂😂😂
it has surely gone up else we wouldn't have 6 crore rohingyas and kangladeshis in India
I think you think ,they think.😅😅😅😅😅
Why all these fuss about the carrier. You are in the control tower last 50 more years. Why you did not make India attractive for its own citizen. Hypocrite.
yes Mr Tharoor , just not they are doing well , but the price each individual pays to border security patrol is huge to enter USA…. So those USA gov employees also earning well …
Here is no any real reaction on Shashi tharur. All are against Indian immigrants.....
dream of a borderless world is over.
Vijay mallya should be goven as much pain as he gave our agencies by fleeing away to another country.
All the expenses incurred by the government/banks on his case should be recovered before granting any refund if there is any.
Trump was playing to the gallery.
Very bad 🤷🏻♂️ the south of India is deprived in this also . There is no representation even in this deportation despite so many South Indians working there 😂😂😂😂😂 . We demand fair representation and a fair trial in this also 🤪. May be trumps work is still in progress 🤔
Amenesry cant run infinite
It is only fair from our side pay the fare before they comment.
Indian RSS Hero are back 😂😂😂😂
Handcuffs was a show off amarican power on indian
Such a stupid question & a stupid answer - handcuffed?; Security & safety takes priority! They may be illegal but they are the citizens of India & the US returns all of them without harming them.
Its people like this who dontnhave enough respect for their own country they just do unundignified things
How stupid of you Mr Tharor to say that ”some of them were handcuffed as some reports have alleged.”
Banal discussion silly discussion...
This is an insult to India.... but sanghis cannot accept that
Sanghies are junkies mostly Hindus suffering inferiority complex after generations of foreign domination.
Tharoor, after all. The guy is pure hot air. 😂😂
Tharoor ur absolutely right, each govt going for cost control, modi govt bhoja kam ho gaya, BJP, unable to take control, interested in wipe out congress.
USAID is also stopping Rahul's funding. 😢
'Why not Tharoor Joins BJP, And serve country. 😡He should use his Brilliance to Nation.
Tharoor has said it in a college inauguration speech. He was first approached by the BJP and he declined because it is a fascist party. He was later approached by CPIM/CPI. He declined that also as the communists had a record of rejecting new technologies and automation. Then he joined the grand old party. :)
@rajValath it means he want to waste time himself. He don't want to anything , except blaming on others
@@Om-qy9mr He is the most liked politician by the khaki or saffron chaddis. Our complaint is that he is not worth the cheap level of Indian politics, specially after 2014. Kejriwal is the opposite type and suited for the stinking Indian politics. Sashi should have continued in his work of speeches for 50000 dollar per speech.
They broke the law American is right nonesence talk
Ghar waapsi in Ram Rajaya!
@AliAkbar haha
Haha numbers me ab politics. People forget one fact. All these people were our future AI coders and ethical hackers. Ther were pro. They wanted to give somethjng to humanity by paying 40lakhs illegally.
Blah blah blah blah blah blah😂
Your english is much better then Shashi
So, skilled will go off too..
Mr Tharoor"s some answers are contra.He is supposed to be knowing all the Laws in U S A .Even for a small traffic offence The police will hand cuff you and make you sit in their car and start questioning you and make a report on the sport.Here these people have illeagally entered their country.Is it not crime?He repeatedly said "from the prosperous " Gujarath.I can understand that it is a taunt for Modi Yes Gujarathis are ,Majority are well off.But they want to do business in U S(easier than in India) and earn more.what is wrong in that.,but going by wrong method is illegal. why ; Punjab is very wealthy state .why are they going there that too illegally.He was telling some of them are doing well.The Bangaladessis in India are doing well Illegals.Will we accept them?Tharoor should not talk like "pappu".You are a different class
Ahmedabad is a primitive terrible place. Gujaratis are leaving because of that. Not just making money.
What an insult to India! Why India is not sending a passenger flight to bring the deportees? Even a small country like Columbia objected America's inhuman and humiliating treatment to the deportees and sent their own airforce plane. Surprising!
Why Indian taxpayer should burden themselves for illegal act?
@@prakashanand5344what about kumbh snan, media, foreign visits advertisements...I hope u know it's your money
No need to help criminals
@@prakashanand5344Congressis are sending their own planes.
@prakashanand5344 They were also taxpayers and contributed to India's economy before going to US. Trump wants to show the whole world that he ia an Emperor and he has the final word in everything. The spineless India govt had no courage to open their mouth. That is the truth
Handcuffs for a innocent person who have not committed any crime or done wrong is inhuman keep dis in mind.....btw anyone has a right to migrate or move wherever dey want to live life safely...very sad the treatment dey got while deportation
They did commit the crime of entering a foreign nation without permission. Will you ever allow a stranger to enter and live in your house, without your permission? Why the double standard?
They sneaked in to US its a crime..
What you say in this illegal immigrants some of them or deadly terrorist or criminals
@@cker1924 I agree ....but its a inhumane to handcuff ...same goes to mental hospitals where they tie patients hands ..hope u know this also is inhumane
Indians are leaving because India doesn’t have a proper job or proper income for living.
Mr . Tharoor I respect you because you have good brain 🧠 and ability to understand for the needs of average citizens of India. Please do something, develop opportunities like productivity means factories.
We have sources there intelligent people there. Try to keep people over there. Its shameful that our people have to go out side for living.
Example is Not many Americans going out side like Indians.
If America can do same we India can do that too.
That's a load of shit I am 62I still work to earn a living in India . Quick rich will mean illegal way of earn
Usa na la Lee indian ki
Trump is Trump
He is pseudo English.
These are Gujaratis Sangees . This shows how weak and scared Modani is in front of the world . India is very poor with very weak economy ... !🤣🤣🤣😛😛😛😋 Jai Sri Ram ... Jai Sri EVM !
How come you know who they support? Stop bullshitting
So any person who goes to usa illegally supports bjp and who goes legally do not support bjp? Such a moron you are.
By that logic china is more richer than india still many chinese go to usa illegally.
@ Correct , but Trump do not have the balls to sent them back to China with handcuffs and chained legs on U.S Hercules aircraft . That's the difference bro!
50% business controlled by China in America .
Modi is very weak in the world