Khloe Bell Brooke already slept with Nathan back in the day. She betrayed Peyton first even if Peyton didn't know at the time.. Yet she had the guts to treat Peyton badly when Peyton told her she likes Lucas. And BTW.. Peyton never slept with Lucas.
Chukwuchebeanyi Onuorah one Peyton and Nathan were broken up Lucas WAS Brooke’s boyfriend both times Peyton kissed him and two just because she didn’t sleep with him she still kissed him knowing he was her best friends boyfriend and she would have slept with him luke was the one that stopped it because the necklace Brooke gave him got caught in her hair .
Khloe Bell Well.. Peyton and Nathan broke up and made up all the time and. Brooke knew that, so It didn't give her the right to sleep with Nathan. Plus I feel like the main point was that Brooke KNEW Peyton and Lucas liked each other and she still went after him.. It's funny how people tend to call Peyton a bitch because of what she did and forgetting that brooke went after the guy she knew her best friend liked.. I think that's super wrong of her. What Peyton did was equally uncool.. But brooke was wrong first by sleeping with Nate and second by going after Lucas knowing he and her best friend had feelings for each other.. I'm just saying for someone that had wronged her best friend like that, she shouldn't have treated Peyton the way she did after she found out about her and Lucas..
Chukwuchebeanyi Onuorah they were broken up it doesn’t matter they did it all the time Brooke and Lucas weren’t liking doesn’t mean together and Brooke asked Peyton and she said to go for it
yeah especially for a boyfriend she knew liked his bestfriend at first but thats not the point she didnt deserve the cheating on season 1 but she was such an hypocrite on how she acted towards brooke when she sept with Nathan back then I didnt like her in high school but she has the greatest development of the show
Yeah that's what I said. People ay that this whole sex tape thing was a way to make Peyton look innocent, but to me she already was. I mean I know she and Lucas sneaking behind Brooke's back was a mistake, but Brooke knew that they were into each other when she steeped in. So I think this sex tape thing was necessary. I mean it shows how much of a dick Nathan was to do that to his girlfriend's best friend and it shows how much Brook has come from that. I mean the way the writers wrote Brook this season was so unbelievably cruel. The joke about her mother really hit home for me. Like This girl is supposed to be her best friend and she would use that against her. I don;t care how mad she was, you NEVER say say something like that to anyone, let alone your fucking best friend. Brooke was so fake.
Brooke was wrong for the mom thing but she did nothing wrong in season 1. Lucas and Peyton may have liked each other, but Brooke liked Lucas since 1x03 and Peyton had already rejected him. She asked Peyton again and again and again if it was okay and she said yes. And Brooke really liked Lucas. He was the first guy to treat her like a person instead of a sex object. If Peyton wanted him then she should've said something. But the honesty thing was different in season 1 and season 3. In season 3, Brucas was already together and had been together for months before Peyton confessed and after having already had an affair with her boyfriend in season 1, she should have known that it wouldn't go over well. What was the point of telling? Unlike in season 1, they're already together so it's not like she could just step back and let you have her boyfriend. What was supposed to happen?
What? Peyton liked Lucas since the pilot. Lucas told Peyton her art mattered at the end of 1x02, so if you are implying that Brooke liked him first, then that's just wrong. Peyton rejected him not because she didn't like him, but because she got scared. If Brooke had to keep asking Peyton if she was okay with it, it's a good indicator that she had an idea that Peyton had feelings for Lucas. Peyton did nothing immoral in season 3. Perhaps it was inadvisable to tell Brooke, but she was being honest. Plus, it's not like Brooke and Lucas were a great couple to begin with. They were always heading for a breakup.
Peyton and Brooke owned the show and their friendship was epic. What went down with them was always rectified because they loved each other. I could care less about the times they were fighting-these gals were real and when Peyton left Brooke had no one to play off as the others were boors compared to this perfect pairing. Sophia and Hilarie are friends in real life-no surprise!!
That’s true. She didn’t even mention the kiss she just Brooke she loved Lucas. Peyton was honest with her and Brooke was never honest with Peyton. No wonder Brooke and Rachel ended up friends because both of them had a tendency to be bitches not only to each other but towards other problems people they cared about and loved.
4:28 "OMG She cares. She cares" lol adorbs. I love these two my favorite brOTP till this day. No matter what they went through friends forever. #breyton
this is so amazing. brooke and peyton are so unbelievable and the situation between peyton and brooke are so emotional it seems real and thats the way i love every situation with them
When it comes to boys, both girls messed up so it's not hard to list their faults. However, at this point, their fight is about honesty. Peyton never wanted to mess up their friendship again so she decided to be honest about her feelings for Lucas. Brooke cut her off because of this and was really mean to her. Then Peyton discovers that Brooke had not been honest about sleeping with Nathan 2 years before. Peyton has a right to be mad - her best friend turned out to have double standards, thus undermining the friendship.
lmao why would u stay friends with someone that tells you they have feelings for your boyfriend. brooke cutting peyton off and being mean to her was completely justified. it’s funny how y’all are acting like u wouldn’t do the same thing irl if ur best friend went after your boyfriend twice
I’ve always sided with Peyton. She’s been through more than what somebody her age had to go through. It was always Brooke who was escalating things and hurting others.
@@xshewritesinblacknwhitexKaren deserved better as Dan walked out on her abandoning the child he fathered. Keith was in love with her and she knew he was the right person
When Brooke insulting Peyton two dead mothers she was more of a bad friend than what Peyton did. Yeah she kissed Lucas twice when Brooke was with him, but what Brooke did was way worse. She did sleep with Nathan right when Peyton broke up with him and she insulted her mothers..so Brooke never had the right to be mad at Peyton in the first place
Katie12886 Not to mention one of the times Peyton kissed Lucas was when she was shot, dying, and though she would die! Personally, I'd want to say i wouldn't, but, honestly, tho, while I'd probably be a bit mad, I could let that one go considering the circumstances! Plus Peyton was damn there crucified, for being honest, while brook looked dead in her eyes and never said a thing!
Katie Weckwerth RIGHT! 😂😂😂 Then brook had the darn nerve to say it meant nothing, same person who said a freaking KISS ALWAYS MEANS SOMETHING! Goodness I miss the logic of this show! Miss everything to be honest!
What happened with Brooke and Nathan really did mean nothing. In season 1, they didn't talk, they didn't hang out, Pathan was broken up at the time, and they were drunk! Season 1, Peyton and Lucas kissed multiple times, spent time together, talked to each other, etc, and he was planning to be with her behind Brooke's back. In season 3, Lucas said the kiss meant nothing, but just the night before Peyton revealed she had feelings for Lucas. So obviously the kiss meant something. And then when you think about all the stuff that happened in season 3 (The going off on the trip to find Peyton's mom alone after they got together, the walking in on them in bed together, the recycled letter,) and then add in a secret kiss. It taints everything and makes it suspicious. Was it just the one kiss in the library? Was it a repeat of what happened last year? Was her best friend and boyfriend playing her like a fool again? And then look at how quickly they got back together after the break up. I'd be pissed too. The dead mom's thing was wrong and Brooke should have apologized, but what happened with Nathan really was nothing. Meaningless sex one time vs. Emotional affair that goes on for weeks with kissing? Sorry, Leyton was still worse than Brathan. Not that it matters anymore, Leyton got married and had a baby and Naley stayed married and had two children. Nathan and Brooke's sex tape actually meant nothing in the scheme of things. It was just a plot device to level the playing field so Breyton could be friends again.
Maria What?? Literally Brooke asked Peyton MULTIPLE times if she liked Lucas and she said no! Brooke was a different person back then but she changed.. then Peyton litteraly backstabbed Brooke with Lucas while they were together 2 TIMES! Peyton was always whining and Brooke was there for her always. Peyton sucked!
Elijah Gilbert What?? Literally Brooke asked Peyton MULTIPLE times if she liked Lucas and she said no! Brooke was a different person back then but she changed.. then Peyton litteraly backstabbed Brooke with Lucas while they were together 2 TIMES! Peyton was always whining and Brooke was there for her always. Peyton sucked!
4 ปีที่แล้ว +1
A A A A Brooke really was not the kind of person as she seemed and she always made everything about her. People who defend Brooke so much make her seem like she’s all that when she ain’t acting like the world revolves around her. She knew Peyton liked Lucas even when she couldn’t opened up right away to how she felt which was her problem, as she always managed to show it at the very last minute. Brooke has been messing guys way before she even met Lucas and she even admitted she she was aback in high school. It’s like she meant to turn him down cause while they were having their makeout session he was really letting out how much he felt towards her and she felt like she’d be in a lot of pressure knowing how committed he was and she was scared for a moment assuming that if he was able to rush into their relationship so quickly. And you think it’s okay for girl to make a move on guy knowing her friend was in love with by taking him to a bar to seduce him to get in his pants? Lucas only got with Brooke cause he figured he’d take a chance as he felt like he had gotten his hopes up when he didn’t really know Brooke at all plus all she wanted was to have sex as she kept throwing herself at him which was ridiculous lol. You really cracked me up on this lol 😂
Brooke is forever my favourite character in everyway but peytons right here. She always had a hard life and yh she shouldn't of cheated with Lucas twice but brooke should never of made fun of her mum.
Sorry but I can't understand why so many people side with Brooke. Brooke knew since season 1 that Peyton has feelings for Lucas and vice versa. Well, Brooke was chasing Lucas but Lucas was really clear, that he wants Peyton. So your Brucas fans should rewatch Season 1. It was always Leyton and not Brucas. Brucas was just because Chad and Sophia had a relationship. Lucas told Peyton, that Brooke is nice, but she is not her. Plus Brooke accused Peyton of being so mean, but she was never ever nice to her for example the thing with Nathan and hooking up with Lucas knowing that your best friend secretly likes him. So who's the wrong person... not Peyton. Peyton was not honest in season 1, but she learned from her mistakes... not Brooke. End of story
Lilly Wild Peyton was the wrong person sometimes too. Sometimes it was Brooke. There isn’t a single bad or good guy. Both learned and grew up eventually.
Both of them were wrong. There’s not right side. Growing is realizing that Lucas was a red flag all along. Also I feel like one of the main reasons why people tend to flock towards Brooke is because she’s unapologetic bitchy whereas Peyton is the “not like the other girls” trope. She feels like she’s better than every other girl around her because she has a unique music taste. And shames them for liking girly stuff (ie her newspaper column.) Same thing with Lucas he has this complex because he reads books written by old dead white guys.
This sums up exactly why I am always Team Peyton... Brooke hooked up with Nathan when they were together, then she went after Lucas knowing full well that Peyton was in love with him, and then being so cruel to Peyton for simply being honest with her... Brooke was awful until season 5.
Kingi Wingi Well Peyton and Nathan weren’t together but yeah don’t go after your friends man together or not. Also you’re right about Brooke being cruel in season 4. It’s her worst season.
@@melaniedownes1752how should she have known when Lucas was the one pursuing a relationship with her the 2nd time around? Peyton kept telling Brooke she was okay with them dating and didn’t have feelings for Lucas anymore how was Brooke supposed to read her mind?
I never got the ‘either time you went after him.’ Peyton only really ‘went after him’, in season one. The kiss during 3x16 shouldn’t even count because Peyton was losing a lot of blood and could have died. She follows it with ‘Just in case you can’t keep your promise.’ After that all she did was told Brooke the truth about her feelings and was willing to bury them for Brooke.
Plus after Brooke fount out about it she said a kiss always means something yet she told Peyton sex with Nathan meant nothing !!!! Classic Brooke no rules apply to her
@@fatimekaba3205 You're joking right? There is literally nothing more intimate than penetrating someone or having someone inside of you lmfao Not to mention sex carries the risk of STDs, Babies, etc.. So yes, Sex is infinitely more serious in everyway than a kiss.
I don't feel sorry for Brooke. She knew right from the start that they love eachother. Besides, Brooke slept with Peyton's boyfriend. She kissed Pete when he was dating Peyton. She knew Peyton was attacked and almost raped and never even called her. Instead she made fun of Peyton's mothers more than once and she never apologized for that. She really made Peyton feel like crap and Peyton didn't deserve that. I know she saved Peyton's life in season 4, but i really didn't like highschool Brooke.
No she didn’t because she asked Peyton before if it was fine with her to say Lucas and she said yes and Brooke kissed Pete because she thought she was dreaming Peyton deserved that except for the joke about her dead moms
no she didn't, brooke didn't know they loved each other because Lucas and Peyton barely knew each other. Nathan and Peyton had broken up and Brooke was really drunk. She thought she was dreaming when she kissed pete. Peyton went behind brookes back TWICE by cheating with lucas, if the libary kiss meant nothing they should've told her. Peyton never gave a fuck about Brookes feelings. in new york, brooke openly admits to her mum she would drop everything for Lucas and when he tried to hook up with her she walked away. Brooke deserved better.
@@fatimekaba3205 Brooke: ,,Show us how you really feel. Kiss Lucas". Lucas: ,,I loved you since the first time I saw you". I guess you should watch the show again.
@@fatimekaba3205 Well, Peyton was in love with him all the time, she decided to ignore it so long because she did not want to hurt Brooke. Lucas become her husbund, the love of her life, I would say you're right if it was just a fling, but it is your choice to support whoever you want.
Let’s all agree that BOTH Peyton and Brooke have done pretty shitty things to each other. Peyton should never have punched Brooke. Brooke should never have slept with Nathan. Peyton shouldn’t have gone after Lucas when Brucas were together. Brooke should never have gone after Lucas in S1 when she knew Peyton liked him. Let’s all just agree they done both shitty things and move on.
Brooke had a right to be angry, but she carried it on way too long, and going after Peyton's mother was way out of line. After the video, you realize Brooke knew she was no more perfect, but completely disregarded that.
I love how everyone said Brooke knew peyton had a thing for Lucas but they forget how in the beginning of the show Brooke was in Lucas car topless in episode 2 or 3 but peyton was dating Nate so she also liked him before she told peyton but Brooke asked peyton if she was over Lucas. Brooke asked her many many times if she was over him and she even said she wasn’t she would back off if she was...but right when brooke and Lucas were dating PETYON kissed Lucas multiple times and wasn’t there for her when lucas and Brooke broke up. They were so close to having sex but Lucas brung up the necklace. If you call Brooke a bad friend remember to bring up peyton too. Peyton always says Brooke is her best friend but stills cheats with Lucas she even said Brooke would come over her house every single day when her mom died yes Brooke cross the line and I will never agree with her with that line. Brooke said in later seasons she has always been insecure how do you think she felt when she found out the guy she LOVED was sneaking behind her back with her best friend since preschool. Brooke and peyton have done horrible think to each other
Peyton’s anger is all about Lucas. She took so much shit and guilt for being in love with Lucas and acting on those feelings when Brooke has done worst but acted like Peyton broke their friendship in a way Brooke had never done lol also Peyton broke her own heart by ending things with Lucas after the affair and made the sacrifice for the sake of Brooke and had to carry that pain of letting him go due to thinking she betrayed Brooke. I truly believe if Peyton had known about it she wouldn’t have ended things with Lucas
In this episode, I think that Peyton has the right to be mad about Brooke's joke but in regard to Brooke sleeping with Nathan, I am on Brookes side. Peyton literally had an affair with Brooke's boyfriend and then after Lucas and Brooke got back together she kissed him and said that she has feelings for him. Just because she was honest about it doesn't make it okay, plus Peyton never really loved Nathan but Brooke loved Lucas and Peyton knew that yet she still snuck around with him. In my opinion, sneaking around with your best friends boyfriend whom she loves is worse than having a pointless drunken one night stand with a guy that your best friend just broke up with and doesn't really love. Also, Peyton using the whole honesty thing against Brooke is trash, I mean the way she says it makes it sound like Brooke had no reason to be mad when she literally told her that she had feelings for her boyfriend who had cheated on her with Peyton in the past, like seriously how did Peyton think she was going to react. So while the whole mother death joke was cruel and wrong of Brooke you can't ignore how Peyton treated Brooke like trash at times
As much as I loved Brooke at times... yeah, Brooke SO had that punching coming. I sided with Peyton through and through on this one. Brooke made fun of her MOM'S DEATH just to HURT her simply because she confessed to still having feelings for Luke. Feelings she offered to bury for the sake of their friendship. Yet none of that mattered to Brooke whatsoever and she put Peyton through emotional hell. (Although that kiss during the shooting shouldn't count. Come on, Peyton was literally DYING FROM A GUNSHOT WOUND. I'd let that go!) And considering she went after her boyfriend's brief ex without ever telling her about it and even made a tape JUST because she was in the mood for a hook up... yeah, Brooke had NO GROUNDS for making Peyton feel like crap. She wasn't that great of a friend either. Brooke was wrong here.
Y G Well Brooke wasn’t the worst hands down as an undeniable fact. Some see her as the worst others Peyton. It’s just a perspective thing. If anyone was worse with cheating it was Peyton though which is why Brooke was the victim at that point.
By the way when did Brooke cry with Peytons mother? Peyton said Brooke knew her? Could somebody please help me out here. Any insight would be wonderful.
Brooke found out about leyton and obviously really thought that peyton was not gonna find out about Nathan and brooke. Karma. And by the way, Nathan, WHY IN THE HECK DO U STILL HAVE THE TAPE WHEN U ARE A MARRIED MAN NOW?!
It's the PRINCIPLE! Peyton and Nathan may have broken up, but Brooke even says that all Peyton and Nathan did was break up and get back together.... But the fact she still felt the need to keep that a secret, is terrible. Haley and Lucas were intermingling with the popular kids, amongst Brooke Nathan and Peyton... for years, Brooke kept that to herself. Yet could shame Peyton into feeling like a whore for actually following her heart, when Brooke knew that too... Atleast Peyton had the conviction to know what she was doing was wrong and broke it off with Lucas the first time, because the first time they did have a little affair, the 2nd time, a kiss. A KISS, with a delirious Peyton fading in and out of consciousness.
She asked Peyton if she was okay with it first of all and Peyton continued to push Lucas away at the beginning and re assure her that she had no feelings for him. She had her chance and he was the first person Brooke truly let in and they both broke her heart not once but twice and that’s truly fucked up.
If your best friend is into somebody, even if she is in a relationship with someone else, even if she pretends not to be interested, you just know it, you just feel it. Brooke knew.
Peyton and Brooke’s friendship was just toxic they both liked the same guy who was a jerk and don’t get me wrong what Peyton did was bad but what Brooke did was worse, made fun of her friend’s mom’s death was brutal
What brook said about Peytons mom was messed up nearly unforgivable but brook had a point about Peyton going after Lucas while she was dating him and Nathan and Peyton weren't together
Peyton was upset about the fact that Brooke went on and on about how she ruined our friendship and tell us out Brooke did it a lot sooner when she slept with her boyfriend! Also, she made fun of a two dead moms not good look for Brooke season four was not her that season.
Wow a whole episode about this betrayal! They made a big deal of Brooke mistake white Nathan and Peyton weren’t even together. But they never talked about it that Peyton betrayed Brooke twice with her current boyfriend! The writer really favors Peyton!!
I really like Peyton ended her why do I care this has been one of the worst years of my life and I needed my best friend more than ever and you cut me out because I was honest with you but you were never ever honest with me you made fun of my mom's death Brooke you knew her you cried me when she died but instead you use her as a joke for punchline you're right she's dead father was saying so are you😮 that was so powerful Peyton and so right
In all honesty though, Brooke and Nathan was a one time thing with no feelings... Peyton and Lucas snuck around behind Brooke’s back for a while and then she kissed Lucas AGAIN when brooke and Lucas were back together so Peyton had no right to be angry about the tape sorry not sorry
She had every right. You act like Brooke was a saint 😂 Brooke was a rich bitch who never owed up to her mistakes. She was a whore. A sex tape that she made with a guy who was dating her friend is a lot worse than kissing someone because you think you’re gonna die.
Hated that they added in the sex tape to try and even the playing score between Brooke and Peyton and make Peyton’s betrayals seem less than they were. Brooke despite her insecurities and party ways had always been a loyal friend. Very out of character.
Bradley Lyman "Peyton's betrayal" that's laughable Are y'all forgetting that Brooke knew that Lucas and Peyton liked each other. (Remember the episode she dared Peyton to show Lucas how she really she feels and Peyton kissed Lucas?) Brooke knew. She knew her best friend liked this guy even though Peyton didn't want to open up her heart. She knew and she still went after Lucas. And Peyton does a similar thing, y'all say she's the wrong one? Lol Peyton didn't even sleep with Lucas. Brooke screwed peyton's boyfriend back in the days, yet treated her so badly when she found out about her and Lucas. Brooke was always the wrong one.
Chukwuchebeanyi Onuorah Peyton was wrong as well. Brooke slept with Nathan after Peyton broke up with him. That’s wrong. Peyton got with Lucas while Brooke was with him. That’s wrong as well probably more wrong.
Team Brooke: Brooke and Peyton start hating each other because Peyton tells Brooke that she still had feelings for Lucas, Brooke's then boyfriend. In the episode Some You Give Away, Brooke tells Lucas to tell Peyton he loves her. This shows that Brooke still cares for Peyton. and in the episode after Brooke consoles Peyton because Lucas is in the hospital, Peyton tells her she wants to be back to best friends like before and Brooke says that like before is gone. They then agree not to be enemies. But at a party at Nathan's house when Brooke is coming to mend things once and for all with Peyton, a tape gets put in the TV of Brooke and Nathan having sex while Nathan and Peyton were still dating. Peyton is furious and punches Brooke in retaliation, giving her a black eye. The day before prom Peyton and Brooke have a physical fight after Peyton catches Brooke egging her house. Peyton tackles Brooke and the two fight on the ground. Peyton finally stands up and told her that she was always honest with Brooke, and Brooke never was with her because she had never revealed her hookup with Nathan yet still was angry at Peyton for all that happened with her and Lucas. Peyton also said how it hurt that Brooke used her mom's death as a punchline to hurt her after consoling her throughout it. Peyton ends it by saying that Brooke is dead to her, leaving Brooke shattered. It later turns out to be untrue as Peyton cares enough to be mean to Brooke by writing Whore on her prom dress in light-revealing ink. After Brooke comes to find Peyton when she doesn't show up for prom she finds that "Psycho Derek" has came back and is holding Peyton hostage in the basement. He ties Brooke up too. Derek is about to kill Brooke but Peyton convinces him to let her do it. It looks like Peyton is about to kill her but she instead stabs Derek in the shoulder. Peyton gets away then Derek tackles her in her room. Brooke ends up saving her and together they fight Derek until they eventually cause him to fall unconscious. At the end of the season Peyton gets a music internship in Los Angeles and decides to go and spend the summer with Brooke there.
These are two people who clearly outgrew their friendship but tried to remain friends. Peyton was constantly a shitty friend to Brooke & Brooke had her moments too. I was glad when Peyton left so the real/true friendship of Brook & Hayley could blossom.
Brooke: goes after Lucas in season 1 despite knowing Peyton’s feelings for him, sleeps with Nathan when him and Peyton were only broken up for 5 secs, acts like a hypocrite and overreacts when Peyton tells her feelings about Lucas even tho she was being honest with her, calls Peyton’s dead mom a whore, was busy whining about her boy drama like always when Peyton was dealing with so many real life issues... Peyton: makes a mistake kissing Lucas in season 1, never went further but even so, felt guilty apologized multiple times, only kissed him a second time bc she thought she was dying, was honest about her feelings for Lucas with Brooke, never went after him even when he was no longer with Brooke, even tried helping him get back with Brooke, was there for Brooke when her parents weren’t, was patient with her when Brooke was throwing a tantrum and insulted her dead mom... But yea of course Peyton was “constantly a shitty friend” lmao ok I liked Brooke and Haley better too but the reason behind Peyton and Brooke having a toxic friendship was Brooke not Peyton. If she had liked Nathan, she would’ve ruined her friendship with Haley too. Kind of ironic cuz her motto was “ hoes over bros”
Peyton was justified because all those years ago and she gave her a lot of crap about Lucas I really like this episode because the truth was revealed finally😮🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
I'm watching season 1 on Netflix, and boy, Peyton's actress is terrible. I was so shocked because I remember seeing this scene and crying my eyes out because she was so believable here, so I had to find it, and I'm glad to see I was right. She was amazing in that scene. I guess she improved a lot over the years.
Peyton had no right to get so angry she stole Luke from her twice while they were dating......so it's OK when she has feelings for her best friend's boyfriend and secretly has an affair with him while the two are dating but wrong if Brooke sleeps with Nathan when they had broken up..... Hated Peyton from day 1
I don't know why but the part where Peyton is telling Brooke how awful her life had been for the past year and about how Brooke made a crappy joke about her mother's death, just made me sad. I hated when they fought. A guy should have never been able to get between them but it happened. Unfortunately it wasn't 'hoes over bros' to them.
Brooke slept with Nathan...when Peyton and Nathan had broken up...both of them were drunk...none of them remembers it due to the alcohol(it's evident when the video shows up both look surprised)but that doesn't mean brooke was right.she was wrong.but that was a different brooke..mean, selfish and only wanting sex not love... that's why she went after Lucas even after knowing Peyton liked him even though she said she didn't want anything serious with lucas.but brooke got her comeuppance when Leyton had an affair behind her back.brooke loved Lucas but still he cheated and broke up with her without telling her about the cheating.even Peyton hid the cheating thing even though she ended the affair .in my opinion both were wrong .but the second time around it was Peyton"s fault .
I know Brooke was angry at Peyton because she cheated with Lucas two times but Peyton is in the right about Brooke' jokes about Peyton' mom but Brooke was right about Peyton not being perfect.
I kind of feel bad for Peyton but the way she acted made me not feel as bad for her. It would be a lot easier to root for her if she stopped acting so innocent. Like what Brooke did was worse than what she did when it was the other way around. But Brooke's jokes about her mom were messed up as Hell.
Everyone keeps talking how flawless Nathan and Brooke are over Lucas and Peyton but they keep forgetting about how much of a scumbag Nathan was between season 1-3 and how much of a hypocrite Brooke was!
"She cares.. She cares!!" in classic Peyton manner, she still shows her love for Brooke despite what she's done. Their friendship was everything.
What Brook said about Peyton's mom is so unforgivable. I mean she not only says it once, but she jokes about it twice!!!!!
brianna williams yeah but Peyton messed with Lucas for the second time while he was with Brooke yeah it was a low blow but it was justified
Khloe Bell
Brooke already slept with Nathan back in the day. She betrayed Peyton first even if Peyton didn't know at the time.. Yet she had the guts to treat Peyton badly when Peyton told her she likes Lucas.
And BTW.. Peyton never slept with Lucas.
Chukwuchebeanyi Onuorah one Peyton and Nathan were broken up Lucas WAS Brooke’s boyfriend both times Peyton kissed him and two just because she didn’t sleep with him she still kissed him knowing he was her best friends boyfriend and she would have slept with him luke was the one that stopped it because the necklace Brooke gave him got caught in her hair .
Khloe Bell
Well.. Peyton and Nathan broke up and made up all the time and. Brooke knew that, so It didn't give her the right to sleep with Nathan. Plus I feel like the main point was that Brooke KNEW Peyton and Lucas liked each other and she still went after him.. It's funny how people tend to call Peyton a bitch because of what she did and forgetting that brooke went after the guy she knew her best friend liked.. I think that's super wrong of her.
What Peyton did was equally uncool.. But brooke was wrong first by sleeping with Nate and second by going after Lucas knowing he and her best friend had feelings for each other..
I'm just saying for someone that had wronged her best friend like that, she shouldn't have treated Peyton the way she did after she found out about her and Lucas..
Chukwuchebeanyi Onuorah they were broken up it doesn’t matter they did it all the time Brooke and Lucas weren’t liking doesn’t mean together and Brooke asked Peyton and she said to go for it
I know Brook was angry at Peyton But Making a joke about her dead mother crosses the Line
yeah especially for a boyfriend she knew liked his bestfriend at first but thats not the point she didnt deserve the cheating on season 1 but she was such an hypocrite on how she acted towards brooke when she sept with Nathan back then I didnt like her in high school but she has the greatest development of the show
Yeah that's what I said. People ay that this whole sex tape thing was a way to make Peyton look innocent, but to me she already was. I mean I know she and Lucas sneaking behind Brooke's back was a mistake, but Brooke knew that they were into each other when she steeped in. So I think this sex tape thing was necessary. I mean it shows how much of a dick Nathan was to do that to his girlfriend's best friend and it shows how much Brook has come from that. I mean the way the writers wrote Brook this season was so unbelievably cruel. The joke about her mother really hit home for me. Like This girl is supposed to be her best friend and she would use that against her. I don;t care how mad she was, you NEVER say say something like that to anyone, let alone your fucking best friend. Brooke was so fake.
Brooke was wrong for the mom thing but she did nothing wrong in season 1.
Lucas and Peyton may have liked each other, but Brooke liked Lucas since 1x03 and Peyton had already rejected him.
She asked Peyton again and again and again if it was okay and she said yes. And Brooke really liked Lucas. He was the first guy to treat her like a person instead of a sex object. If Peyton wanted him then she should've said something.
But the honesty thing was different in season 1 and season 3. In season 3, Brucas was already together and had been together for months before Peyton confessed and after having already had an affair with her boyfriend in season 1, she should have known that it wouldn't go over well.
What was the point of telling?
Unlike in season 1, they're already together so it's not like she could just step back and let you have her boyfriend.
What was supposed to happen?
What? Peyton liked Lucas since the pilot. Lucas told Peyton her art mattered at the end of 1x02, so if you are implying that Brooke liked him first, then that's just wrong. Peyton rejected him not because she didn't like him, but because she got scared. If Brooke had to keep asking Peyton if she was okay with it, it's a good indicator that she had an idea that Peyton had feelings for Lucas.
Peyton did nothing immoral in season 3. Perhaps it was inadvisable to tell Brooke, but she was being honest. Plus, it's not like Brooke and Lucas were a great couple to begin with. They were always heading for a breakup.
E
Hilarie Burton absolutely kills me in this scene. Cue the waterworks!
Peyton and Brooke owned the show and their friendship was epic. What went down with them was always rectified because they loved each other. I could care less about the times they were fighting-these gals were real and when Peyton left Brooke had no one to play off as the others were boors compared to this perfect pairing. Sophia and Hilarie are friends in real life-no surprise!!
Up until season 6 ended. Haley and Brooke's friendship after season 6 was just as epic
Such emotion in this scene but Peyton was at least honest with Brooke but she never was with her
That’s true. She didn’t even mention the kiss she just Brooke she loved Lucas. Peyton was honest with her and Brooke was never honest with Peyton. No wonder Brooke and Rachel ended up friends because both of them had a tendency to be bitches not only to each other but towards other problems people they cared about and loved.
4:28 "OMG She cares. She cares" lol adorbs. I love these two my favorite brOTP till this day. No matter what they went through friends forever. #breyton
"So go naked think of all the time you are gonna save hooking up with someone else's boyfriend" iconic😂
She is the last person that should be saying that though haha
Payton is the last person to talk like 😒
@@23louuu but she didn’t sleep with Lucas. That’s the difference. Brooke actually slept with Nathan.
@@xshewritesinblacknwhitex but they snuck around and feelings were involved which I think is worse
Besides isn't Brooke a Tramp
She's always been an amazing actress.
hilaries delivery of "you made fun of my moms death brooke" is fucking incredible
this scene is hilarie’s best acting of the whole series. always makes me tear up
OPEN UP PEYTON!
Or what? You’ll huff and puff and blow my house down?
Me: classic line
this is so amazing. brooke and peyton are so unbelievable
and the situation between peyton and brooke are so emotional
it seems real and thats the way i love every situation with them
Smiley Miley
looove their script and how they delivered it!!! OTH is my life
When it comes to boys, both girls messed up so it's not hard to list their faults. However, at this point, their fight is about honesty. Peyton never wanted to mess up their friendship again so she decided to be honest about her feelings for Lucas. Brooke cut her off because of this and was really mean to her. Then Peyton discovers that Brooke had not been honest about sleeping with Nathan 2 years before. Peyton has a right to be mad - her best friend turned out to have double standards, thus undermining the friendship.
And she never told Brooke that she kissed Lucas the first time and Peyton broke up with Nathan that’s not the same
lmao why would u stay friends with someone that tells you they have feelings for your boyfriend. brooke cutting peyton off and being mean to her was completely justified. it’s funny how y’all are acting like u wouldn’t do the same thing irl if ur best friend went after your boyfriend twice
Yes and no it wasn't Peyton that told Brooke about the kiss in the library it was lucas
@@vicky-ee1ie but the part about Peytons moms death went too far
We also would drip a friend if they slept with our ex two mins after we broke up 🙄
This scene was deep. This whole show is just one big poetry book.
Yeah that does cross the line. I would never stay friends with someone who would make fun of my mother's death.
No matter how many times I see that fight scene I cry. Great acting on Hilarie’s part!
I just hate that Brooke is making excuses and keeps blaming Peyton!!!!
Destiny Murray
I swear..
Soo annoying
That was the theme of Brooke blame Peyton or lucas
Screw Payton, Brook never needed her drama or fake friendship anyway
Well Peyton sleeps with her ex boyfriend's brother
@@ElKamaleon777 this is so random lol. nathan and peyton were together long before lucas even talked to peyton
I’ve always sided with Peyton. She’s been through more than what somebody her age had to go through. It was always Brooke who was escalating things and hurting others.
Well Peyton sleeps with her ex boyfriend's brother
I’m on brookes side
@@ElKamaleon777 so did Karen but we don’t talk about that now do we?
@@ElKamaleon777Her relationship with Nathan was crap as he was a prick who didn’t treat her right at all as even he cheated on her.
@@xshewritesinblacknwhitexKaren deserved better as Dan walked out on her abandoning the child he fathered. Keith was in love with her and she knew he was the right person
I love Brooke's little fit at 2:50 😂
I think she was just struggling to get up ^^
OMG TELL HER PEYTON TELL HER I love how she smack that door on her face
When Brooke insulting Peyton two dead mothers she was more of a bad friend than what Peyton did. Yeah she kissed Lucas twice when Brooke was with him, but what Brooke did was way worse. She did sleep with Nathan right when Peyton broke up with him and she insulted her mothers..so Brooke never had the right to be mad at Peyton in the first place
Katie12886 Also Brooke knew Peyton had a thing with Lucas and still dated Lucas
Katie12886 Not to mention one of the times Peyton kissed Lucas was when she was shot, dying, and though she would die! Personally, I'd want to say i wouldn't, but, honestly, tho, while I'd probably be a bit mad, I could let that one go considering the circumstances! Plus Peyton was damn there crucified, for being honest, while brook looked dead in her eyes and never said a thing!
Agent Sasha PREACH!!!!😁😁
Katie Weckwerth RIGHT! 😂😂😂 Then brook had the darn nerve to say it meant nothing, same person who said a freaking KISS ALWAYS MEANS SOMETHING!
Goodness I miss the logic of this show! Miss everything to be honest!
What happened with Brooke and Nathan really did mean nothing.
In season 1, they didn't talk, they didn't hang out, Pathan was broken up at the time, and they were drunk!
Season 1, Peyton and Lucas kissed multiple times, spent time together, talked to each other, etc, and he was planning to be with her behind Brooke's back.
In season 3, Lucas said the kiss meant nothing, but just the night before Peyton revealed she had feelings for Lucas. So obviously the kiss meant something. And then when you think about all the stuff that happened in season 3 (The going off on the trip to find Peyton's mom alone after they got together, the walking in on them in bed together, the recycled letter,) and then add in a secret kiss. It taints everything and makes it suspicious.
Was it just the one kiss in the library? Was it a repeat of what happened last year? Was her best friend and boyfriend playing her like a fool again?
And then look at how quickly they got back together after the break up.
I'd be pissed too.
The dead mom's thing was wrong and Brooke should have apologized, but what happened with Nathan really was nothing.
Meaningless sex one time vs. Emotional affair that goes on for weeks with kissing?
Sorry, Leyton was still worse than Brathan.
Not that it matters anymore, Leyton got married and had a baby and Naley stayed married and had two children.
Nathan and Brooke's sex tape actually meant nothing in the scheme of things. It was just a plot device to level the playing field so Breyton could be friends again.
i seriously love sophia's acting
Plus Brooke knew Peyton and Lucas liked each other in season 1 yet she went after Lucas
Right? And everyone seems to forget this fact, she backstabbed Peyton first!
Thank you yes!
Maria What?? Literally Brooke asked Peyton MULTIPLE times if she liked Lucas and she said no! Brooke was a different person back then but she changed.. then Peyton litteraly backstabbed Brooke with Lucas while they were together 2 TIMES! Peyton was always whining and Brooke was there for her always. Peyton sucked!
Elijah Gilbert
What?? Literally Brooke asked Peyton MULTIPLE times if she liked Lucas and she said no! Brooke was a different person back then but she changed.. then Peyton litteraly backstabbed Brooke with Lucas while they were together 2 TIMES! Peyton was always whining and Brooke was there for her always. Peyton sucked!
A A A A Brooke really was not the kind of person as she seemed and she always made everything about her. People who defend Brooke so much make her seem like she’s all that when she ain’t acting like the world revolves around her. She knew Peyton liked Lucas even when she couldn’t opened up right away to how she felt which was her problem, as she always managed to show it at the very last minute. Brooke has been messing guys way before she even met Lucas and she even admitted she she was aback in high school. It’s like she meant to turn him down cause while they were having their makeout session he was really letting out how much he felt towards her and she felt like she’d be in a lot of pressure knowing how committed he was and she was scared for a moment assuming that if he was able to rush into their relationship so quickly. And you think it’s okay for girl to make a move on guy knowing her friend was in love with by taking him to a bar to seduce him to get in his pants? Lucas only got with Brooke cause he figured he’d take a chance as he felt like he had gotten his hopes up when he didn’t really know Brooke at all plus all she wanted was to have sex as she kept throwing herself at him which was ridiculous lol. You really cracked me up on this lol 😂
I think they both made a lot of mistakes but I'm glad their friendship came out stronger in the end.
Peyton was always right!! Love this show so much
0:20 HILARIOUS. BUST OUT LAUGHING SO HARD
I never got when Brooke says here's a pic of you and Lucas on my birthday why didn't Peyton say we were trying to do something for your birthday
I wondered the same thing
Brooke is forever my favourite character in everyway but peytons right here. She always had a hard life and yh she shouldn't of cheated with Lucas twice but brooke should never of made fun of her mum.
Peyton is the most underrated character on OTH
I swear brooke is so cute when shes egging her house 😂
The beautiful 🌹blond hair girl is 👍👍
Sorry but I can't understand why so many people side with Brooke. Brooke knew since season 1 that Peyton has feelings for Lucas and vice versa. Well, Brooke was chasing Lucas but Lucas was really clear, that he wants Peyton. So your Brucas fans should rewatch Season 1. It was always Leyton and not Brucas. Brucas was just because Chad and Sophia had a relationship. Lucas told Peyton, that Brooke is nice, but she is not her. Plus Brooke accused Peyton of being so mean, but she was never ever nice to her for example the thing with Nathan and hooking up with Lucas knowing that your best friend secretly likes him. So who's the wrong person... not Peyton. Peyton was not honest in season 1, but she learned from her mistakes... not Brooke. End of story
Lilly Wild Peyton was the wrong person sometimes too. Sometimes it was Brooke. There isn’t a single bad or good guy. Both learned and grew up eventually.
Exactly and Brooke is a bitch and not a good friend. Especially what she did was not nice!
Both of them were wrong. There’s not right side. Growing is realizing that Lucas was a red flag all along. Also I feel like one of the main reasons why people tend to flock towards Brooke is because she’s unapologetic bitchy whereas Peyton is the “not like the other girls” trope. She feels like she’s better than every other girl around her because she has a unique music taste. And shames them for liking girly stuff (ie her newspaper column.) Same thing with Lucas he has this complex because he reads books written by old dead white guys.
Lucas was pursuing Brooke in seasons 2-3 so no it wasn’t always clear that he wanted Peyton
@@HazelAmarieit’s like Lucas only went for Brooke because Peyton wasn’t an option. He cheated on Brooke in season 3 too
Just think about how great of a friendship they have irl
This sums up exactly why I am always Team Peyton... Brooke hooked up with Nathan when they were together, then she went after Lucas knowing full well that Peyton was in love with him, and then being so cruel to Peyton for simply being honest with her... Brooke was awful until season 5.
Kingi Wingi Well Peyton and Nathan weren’t together but yeah don’t go after your friends man together or not. Also you’re right about Brooke being cruel in season 4. It’s her worst season.
Nis Pouncy they literally broke up 5 SECONDS before they hooked up so cut that shit
@@Mh-xe1zh and he didn’t have a girlfriend at that time even if broke up soon so you do that
I always hated Brooke because she was petty and she deserves to be alone as well. Lucas always had a crush on Peyton so Brooke should’ve known too
@@melaniedownes1752how should she have known when Lucas was the one pursuing a relationship with her the 2nd time around?
Peyton kept telling Brooke she was okay with them dating and didn’t have feelings for Lucas anymore how was Brooke supposed to read her mind?
I never got the ‘either time you went after him.’ Peyton only really ‘went after him’, in season one. The kiss during 3x16 shouldn’t even count because Peyton was losing a lot of blood and could have died. She follows it with ‘Just in case you can’t keep your promise.’ After that all she did was told Brooke the truth about her feelings and was willing to bury them for Brooke.
Plus after Brooke fount out about it she said a kiss always means something yet she told Peyton sex with Nathan meant nothing !!!! Classic Brooke no rules apply to her
@@ndubankulukusa2228 because sex and a kiss are different
@@fatimekaba3205 Yes, sex is far more serious in literally every possible way.
@@onebuffalo5402 no it’s not one bit
@@fatimekaba3205 You're joking right? There is literally nothing more intimate than penetrating someone or having someone inside of you lmfao
Not to mention sex carries the risk of STDs, Babies, etc..
So yes, Sex is infinitely more serious in everyway than a kiss.
We all know the true friendship of the show is Lucas and Haley...
Lucas & Haley’s friendship was pure🥹
I don't feel sorry for Brooke. She knew right from the start that they love eachother. Besides, Brooke slept with Peyton's boyfriend. She kissed Pete when he was dating Peyton. She knew Peyton was attacked and almost raped and never even called her. Instead she made fun of Peyton's mothers more than once and she never apologized for that. She really made Peyton feel like crap and Peyton didn't deserve that. I know she saved Peyton's life in season 4, but i really didn't like highschool Brooke.
No she didn’t because she asked Peyton before if it was fine with her to say Lucas and she said yes and Brooke kissed Pete because she thought she was dreaming Peyton deserved that except for the joke about her dead moms
no she didn't, brooke didn't know they loved each other because Lucas and Peyton barely knew each other. Nathan and Peyton had broken up and Brooke was really drunk. She thought she was dreaming when she kissed pete. Peyton went behind brookes back TWICE by cheating with lucas, if the libary kiss meant nothing they should've told her. Peyton never gave a fuck about Brookes feelings. in new york, brooke openly admits to her mum she would drop everything for Lucas and when he tried to hook up with her she walked away. Brooke deserved better.
@@fatimekaba3205 Brooke: ,,Show us how you really feel. Kiss Lucas".
Lucas: ,,I loved you since the first time I saw you".
I guess you should watch the show again.
@@istinaistina5700 and Lucas wanted to be with Brooke after Peyton said he didn’t want Lucas so I don’t need to but thank you
@@fatimekaba3205 Well, Peyton was in love with him all the time, she decided to ignore it so long because she did not want to hurt Brooke. Lucas become her husbund, the love of her life, I would say you're right if it was just a fling, but it is your choice to support whoever you want.
0:11-0:12 that death stare from Peyton. If I was Brooke I would run for my fuckin life. Usain Bolt style 🤣😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😅 Peyton and Haley James Scott reaction. Dammmm Brooks took that punch 🤛 really hard.
0:55 or what? You'll huff and puff and blow my house down?
Hilarious
Let’s all agree that BOTH Peyton and Brooke have done pretty shitty things to each other. Peyton should never have punched Brooke. Brooke should never have slept with Nathan. Peyton shouldn’t have gone after Lucas when Brucas were together. Brooke should never have gone after Lucas in S1 when she knew Peyton liked him.
Let’s all just agree they done both shitty things and move on.
0:11-0:12 Run for your life Brooke, that is a DEATH STARE from Peyton.
Duck. Duck. Duck...Bitch! LMFAO
God I hated High School Brooke and Brucas... Adult Brooke is awesome and Brulian is perfect ❤️
ew.
High school Brooke was annoying af and brucas was the worst ship on that show. Glad she had a character development and got her happy ending though
Yes!!
N H ayee someone with brain cells
Taken from One Tree Hill: The Complete Fourth Season 2007 DVD.
(C)2007 Warner Bros Entertainment, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
I still to this day crack up when Peyton socks Brooke.
Ngl, that scene always makes me cry
I once was in Peyton's shoes
It still hurts
Brooke had a right to be angry, but she carried it on way too long, and going after Peyton's mother was way out of line. After the video, you realize Brooke knew she was no more perfect, but completely disregarded that.
I love how everyone said Brooke knew peyton had a thing for Lucas but they forget how in the beginning of the show Brooke was in Lucas car topless in episode 2 or 3 but peyton was dating Nate so she also liked him before she told peyton but Brooke asked peyton if she was over Lucas. Brooke asked her many many times if she was over him and she even said she wasn’t she would back off if she was...but right when brooke and Lucas were dating PETYON kissed Lucas multiple times and wasn’t there for her when lucas and Brooke broke up. They were so close to having sex but Lucas brung up the necklace. If you call Brooke a bad friend remember to bring up peyton too. Peyton always says Brooke is her best friend but stills cheats with Lucas she even said Brooke would come over her house every single day when her mom died yes Brooke cross the line and I will never agree with her with that line. Brooke said in later seasons she has always been insecure how do you think she felt when she found out the guy she LOVED was sneaking behind her back with her best friend since preschool. Brooke and peyton have done horrible think to each other
Peyton’s anger is all about Lucas. She took so much shit and guilt for being in love with Lucas and acting on those feelings when Brooke has done worst but acted like Peyton broke their friendship in a way Brooke had never done lol also Peyton broke her own heart by ending things with Lucas after the affair and made the sacrifice for the sake of Brooke and had to carry that pain of letting him go due to thinking she betrayed Brooke. I truly believe if Peyton had known about it she wouldn’t have ended things with Lucas
In this episode, I think that Peyton has the right to be mad about Brooke's joke but in regard to Brooke sleeping with Nathan, I am on Brookes side. Peyton literally had an affair with Brooke's boyfriend and then after Lucas and Brooke got back together she kissed him and said that she has feelings for him. Just because she was honest about it doesn't make it okay, plus Peyton never really loved Nathan but Brooke loved Lucas and Peyton knew that yet she still snuck around with him. In my opinion, sneaking around with your best friends boyfriend whom she loves is worse than having a pointless drunken one night stand with a guy that your best friend just broke up with and doesn't really love. Also, Peyton using the whole honesty thing against Brooke is trash, I mean the way she says it makes it sound like Brooke had no reason to be mad when she literally told her that she had feelings for her boyfriend who had cheated on her with Peyton in the past, like seriously how did Peyton think she was going to react.
So while the whole mother death joke was cruel and wrong of Brooke you can't ignore how Peyton treated Brooke like trash at times
As much as I loved Brooke at times... yeah, Brooke SO had that punching coming. I sided with Peyton through and through on this one. Brooke made fun of her MOM'S DEATH just to HURT her simply because she confessed to still having feelings for Luke. Feelings she offered to bury for the sake of their friendship. Yet none of that mattered to Brooke whatsoever and she put Peyton through emotional hell. (Although that kiss during the shooting shouldn't count. Come on, Peyton was literally DYING FROM A GUNSHOT WOUND. I'd let that go!) And considering she went after her boyfriend's brief ex without ever telling her about it and even made a tape JUST because she was in the mood for a hook up... yeah, Brooke had NO GROUNDS for making Peyton feel like crap. She wasn't that great of a friend either. Brooke was wrong here.
I can’t believe some people still think Brooke was the victim throughout the show smh they both did bad stuff but Brooke did worse hands down
Y G exactly I never understood this either!
Y G Well Brooke wasn’t the worst hands down as an undeniable fact. Some see her as the worst others Peyton. It’s just a perspective thing. If anyone was worse with cheating it was Peyton though which is why Brooke was the victim at that point.
The person who caused the reconciliation between Brooke and Peyton was psycho Derek, real name Ian.
i felt that.
whats the piano in the background please at 1:40? i need it :)
Brooke got mad for Peyton KISSING Lucas but it was okay for her to sleep with Nathan after they recently broke up.
3:10 song ? Pleaseee
By the way when did Brooke cry with Peytons mother? Peyton said Brooke knew her? Could somebody please help me out here. Any insight would be wonderful.
Brooke found out about leyton and obviously really thought that peyton was not gonna find out about Nathan and brooke. Karma. And by the way, Nathan, WHY IN THE HECK DO U STILL HAVE THE TAPE WHEN U ARE A MARRIED MAN NOW?!
It's the PRINCIPLE! Peyton and Nathan may have broken up, but Brooke even says that all Peyton and Nathan did was break up and get back together.... But the fact she still felt the need to keep that a secret, is terrible. Haley and Lucas were intermingling with the popular kids, amongst Brooke Nathan and Peyton... for years, Brooke kept that to herself. Yet could shame Peyton into feeling like a whore for actually following her heart, when Brooke knew that too... Atleast Peyton had the conviction to know what she was doing was wrong and broke it off with Lucas the first time, because the first time they did have a little affair, the 2nd time, a kiss. A KISS, with a delirious Peyton fading in and out of consciousness.
She asked Peyton if she was okay with it first of all and Peyton continued to push Lucas away at the beginning and re assure her that she had no feelings for him. She had her chance and he was the first person Brooke truly let in and they both broke her heart not once but twice and that’s truly fucked up.
If your best friend is into somebody, even if she is in a relationship with someone else, even if she pretends not to be interested, you just know it, you just feel it. Brooke knew.
Everyone knew she just didn’t think it was real
Peyton and Brooke’s friendship was just toxic they both liked the same guy who was a jerk and don’t get me wrong what Peyton did was bad but what Brooke did was worse, made fun of her friend’s mom’s death was brutal
This is hilarious 🤣 🤣🤣🤣
in which episode Brooke made fun out of Peyton's mum?
4x09. When the girls played each other's role in the car.
oh right i forgot peyton was the only one who had bad things happened to her or who had feelings
Brooke always gonna be my girl
What brook said about Peytons mom was messed up nearly unforgivable but brook had a point about Peyton going after Lucas while she was dating him and Nathan and Peyton weren't together
So what they got back together and Brooke knew they were back together. She was a whore and she was a narcissistic bitch who had that punch coming.
That's exactly why I stay to myself, forget that bull sh**t!.
And derek is watching Them 2:20
Y’all forgetting Lucas and Peyton had a whole secret relationship behind brookes back season 1? Cool
Peyton was upset about the fact that Brooke went on and on about how she ruined our friendship and tell us out Brooke did it a lot sooner when she slept with her boyfriend! Also, she made fun of a two dead moms not good look for Brooke season four was not her that season.
A I love Brooke she was always my favourite in the show she is so funny and she is so nise and funny
Wow a whole episode about this betrayal! They made a big deal of Brooke mistake white Nathan and Peyton weren’t even together. But they never talked about it that Peyton betrayed Brooke twice with her current boyfriend! The writer really favors Peyton!!
I really like Peyton ended her why do I care this has been one of the worst years of my life and I needed my best friend more than ever and you cut me out because I was honest with you but you were never ever honest with me you made fun of my mom's death Brooke you knew her you cried me when she died but instead you use her as a joke for punchline you're right she's dead father was saying so are you😮 that was so powerful Peyton and so right
In all honesty though, Brooke and Nathan was a one time thing with no feelings... Peyton and Lucas snuck around behind Brooke’s back for a while and then she kissed Lucas AGAIN when brooke and Lucas were back together so Peyton had no right to be angry about the tape sorry not sorry
She had every right. You act like Brooke was a saint 😂 Brooke was a rich bitch who never owed up to her mistakes. She was a whore. A sex tape that she made with a guy who was dating her friend is a lot worse than kissing someone because you think you’re gonna die.
Duck, duck, duck, bitch😂
Hated that they added in the sex tape to try and even the playing score between Brooke and Peyton and make Peyton’s betrayals seem less than they were. Brooke despite her insecurities and party ways had always been a loyal friend. Very out of character.
Bradley Lyman
"Peyton's betrayal" that's laughable
Are y'all forgetting that Brooke knew that Lucas and Peyton liked each other. (Remember the episode she dared Peyton to show Lucas how she really she feels and Peyton kissed Lucas?) Brooke knew. She knew her best friend liked this guy even though Peyton didn't want to open up her heart. She knew and she still went after Lucas. And Peyton does a similar thing, y'all say she's the wrong one? Lol
Peyton didn't even sleep with Lucas. Brooke screwed peyton's boyfriend back in the days, yet treated her so badly when she found out about her and Lucas. Brooke was always the wrong one.
Chukwuchebeanyi Onuorah Peyton was wrong as well. Brooke slept with Nathan after Peyton broke up with him. That’s wrong. Peyton got with Lucas while Brooke was with him. That’s wrong as well probably more wrong.
1x07 alone contradicts the whole Brooke was always a loyal friend argument.
Totally agree.
I can't believe the writers tried to make us think these two were ever friends.
Team Brooke: Brooke and Peyton start hating each other because Peyton tells Brooke that she still had feelings for Lucas, Brooke's then boyfriend. In the episode Some You Give Away, Brooke tells Lucas to tell Peyton he loves her. This shows that Brooke still cares for Peyton. and in the episode after Brooke consoles Peyton because Lucas is in the hospital, Peyton tells her she wants to be back to best friends like before and Brooke says that like before is gone. They then agree not to be enemies. But at a party at Nathan's house when Brooke is coming to mend things once and for all with Peyton, a tape gets put in the TV of Brooke and Nathan having sex while Nathan and Peyton were still dating. Peyton is furious and punches Brooke in retaliation, giving her a black eye. The day before prom Peyton and Brooke have a physical fight after Peyton catches Brooke egging her house. Peyton tackles Brooke and the two fight on the ground. Peyton finally stands up and told her that she was always honest with Brooke, and Brooke never was with her because she had never revealed her hookup with Nathan yet still was angry at Peyton for all that happened with her and Lucas. Peyton also said how it hurt that Brooke used her mom's death as a punchline to hurt her after consoling her throughout it. Peyton ends it by saying that Brooke is dead to her, leaving Brooke shattered. It later turns out to be untrue as Peyton cares enough to be mean to Brooke by writing Whore on her prom dress in light-revealing ink. After Brooke comes to find Peyton when she doesn't show up for prom she finds that "Psycho Derek" has came back and is holding Peyton hostage in the basement. He ties Brooke up too. Derek is about to kill Brooke but Peyton convinces him to let her do it. It looks like Peyton is about to kill her but she instead stabs Derek in the shoulder. Peyton gets away then Derek tackles her in her room. Brooke ends up saving her and together they fight Derek until they eventually cause him to fall unconscious. At the end of the season Peyton gets a music internship in Los Angeles and decides to go and spend the summer with Brooke there.
God they really needed someone to say "I've had it with both of you! Now both of you miserable beings are going to sit in this room and work it out!"
These are two people who clearly outgrew their friendship but tried to remain friends. Peyton was constantly a shitty friend to Brooke & Brooke had her moments too. I was glad when Peyton left so the real/true friendship of Brook & Hayley could blossom.
Brooke: goes after Lucas in season 1 despite knowing Peyton’s feelings for him, sleeps with Nathan when him and Peyton were only broken up for 5 secs, acts like a hypocrite and overreacts when Peyton tells her feelings about Lucas even tho she was being honest with her, calls Peyton’s dead mom a whore, was busy whining about her boy drama like always when Peyton was dealing with so many real life issues...
Peyton: makes a mistake kissing Lucas in season 1, never went further but even so, felt guilty apologized multiple times, only kissed him a second time bc she thought she was dying, was honest about her feelings for Lucas with Brooke, never went after him even when he was no longer with Brooke, even tried helping him get back with Brooke, was there for Brooke when her parents weren’t, was patient with her when Brooke was throwing a tantrum and insulted her dead mom...
But yea of course Peyton was “constantly a shitty friend” lmao ok
I liked Brooke and Haley better too but the reason behind Peyton and Brooke having a toxic friendship was Brooke not Peyton. If she had liked Nathan, she would’ve ruined her friendship with Haley too. Kind of ironic cuz her motto was “ hoes over bros”
Radmuseum you said what had to be said😌
Radmuseum period
Peyton was justified because all those years ago and she gave her a lot of crap about Lucas I really like this episode because the truth was revealed finally😮🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Brooke was the wrong one.. Period
Chukwuchebeanyi Onuorah Definitely In season 4 for being cruel to Peyton.
I'm watching season 1 on Netflix, and boy, Peyton's actress is terrible. I was so shocked because I remember seeing this scene and crying my eyes out because she was so believable here, so I had to find it, and I'm glad to see I was right. She was amazing in that scene. I guess she improved a lot over the years.
BYE 0:16
*Brooke:*
Peyton had no right to get so angry she stole Luke from her twice while they were dating......so it's OK when she has feelings for her best friend's boyfriend and secretly has an affair with him while the two are dating but wrong if Brooke sleeps with Nathan when they had broken up..... Hated Peyton from day 1
Brooke talked about her dead mothers, that’s just cold especially because Brooke Knew her mother.
Brooke was being a total hypocrite. I mean if roles were reversed she would have been furious
It’s not the same situation
@@jasonmoukala8909yes it is.
@@madisonvanessaroccoa-teller no it’s not
@@jasonmoukala8909 yes it is
@@madisonvanessaroccoa-teller no it’s not
1:15 + 1:46 + 2:20
I don't know why but the part where Peyton is telling Brooke how awful her life had been for the past year and about how Brooke made a crappy joke about her mother's death, just made me sad. I hated when they fought. A guy should have never been able to get between them but it happened. Unfortunately it wasn't 'hoes over bros' to them.
Brooke slept with Nathan...when Peyton and Nathan had broken up...both of them were drunk...none of them remembers it due to the alcohol(it's evident when the video shows up both look surprised)but that doesn't mean brooke was right.she was wrong.but that was a different brooke..mean, selfish and only wanting sex not love... that's why she went after Lucas even after knowing Peyton liked him even though she said she didn't want anything serious with lucas.but brooke got her comeuppance when Leyton had an affair behind her back.brooke loved Lucas but still he cheated and broke up with her without telling her about the cheating.even Peyton hid the cheating thing even though she ended the affair .in my opinion both were wrong .but the second time around it was Peyton"s fault .
I know Brooke was angry at Peyton because she cheated with Lucas two times but Peyton is in the right about Brooke' jokes about Peyton' mom but Brooke was right about Peyton not being perfect.
Wasn't talking to you.
Peyton Sawyer: You're describing your life with every guy in Tree Hill
I kind of feel bad for Peyton but the way she acted made me not feel as bad for her. It would be a lot easier to root for her if she stopped acting so innocent. Like what Brooke did was worse than what she did when it was the other way around. But Brooke's jokes about her mom were messed up as Hell.
peyton the eternal victim .... oh pleaaaseeeee!!!!!!!
C'est un peut normal elle lui pique sont mec.Julien
Everyone keeps talking how flawless Nathan and Brooke are over Lucas and Peyton but they keep forgetting about how much of a scumbag Nathan was between season 1-3 and how much of a hypocrite Brooke was!
Or its just that her vision has recently improved..