Just because you hit high notes doesn't mean you're a great singer. I can hit really high notes but I sound like a dying cat! Lol...Justin has a really unique angel voice that you really can't find in anyone else. No hate on you or Zayn (he's kinda cool actually), that's just my opinion.
+Mrs.Bieber/JazzyGamer/JazzyFlutist you are just a dying fan you don;t know what is singing If you think justin can sing ask him to sing one high note from you and i
+Mrs.Bieber/JazzyGamer/JazzyFlutist Yes singing in high notes does mean you can sing, But if you sounded bad you arent singing the notes properly, theres a difference between singing in note and just singing. I think Zayns got that unique voice with his high notes.
And, so is the rest of 1D can sing better than JB. Not just Zayn, sorry but its the truth. Every member of 1D sings better than Bieber please...Hahaha!
***** im a belieber as well, but this is what u wrote "no it's not lmfao, he can do it so he does it. zayn probably cant, why not do flashy vocal runs..justin does plenty of songs where he doesnt do those. however if he wants to do it he can, lots of r and b singers do that..are you saying they all have trouble keeping on key? ...lmfao" Btw i copied and pasted this.
Why did you not show any of Zayn live high notes ? You have loads on youtube. Its not even a competition here, Zayn is leagues in front of Justin vocally live and thats not only high notes. Zayn has an amazing vocal range, Justin is not even close.
It's obvious to me that Zayn masters high notes better than Justin. He's just singing loudly, even his voice is shaking. Zayn knows how to go high enough with his voice instead of just rising the volume.
There's no comparison zayn won that contest I'm a belieber but they have TOTALLY different voices zayn's voice IS SO MUCH higher than Justin zayn can hit high notes Justin can too but his voice deepened and now he focuses on more on holding the note and the vibration it's just beautiful, he fills his song with compassion and you can tell how much he loves what he does you can tell that he sings with love❤️
it's Zayn! I listened to some of JB's solos and he was a bit extra, like he was trying to do something new with his voice. but Zayn sings his high notes like it's nothing to him. yes, he may not be able to sing low sometimes, but hey, he can still do them blessed up high notes that can open the gates to music heaven😍 comment if you are on the Zquad side or the beliber side!
Lol anyone who is saying Justin is lying to themselves. Vocal ability, it's just a fact that Zayn has the widest range. People think Zayn can't sing low notes, but he can 100%. His first solo in "Strong" is A2. Justin Bieber's lowest note is C3. And I don't know why people say "Just because you can hit high notes doesn't mean you're a good singer" like ugh....yes it does? Lmao. I'd love to see Justin Bieber try Zayn's high note in the Antwerp performance of "Rock Me". Now in my opinion, even the sound of Zayn's voice just sounds better. His voice is very very pretty, soothing, and just unique. His chorus in "Right Now", for example, is amazing. It's just so soothing, like I listen to it and I just RELAX. It's really beautiful, and the only reason it's 1D's best song is because Zayn makes it that way. Other good examples of this is his solo in "Half A Heart" and his bridge solo in "Strong". There's no one that sounds like him. Justin, IMO has a very generic voice and there's nothing special to it. It just overall lacks individuality, imo. Disclaimer: this isn't saying Justin isn't talented. He is. Zayn's just got a better voice.
+Madison G Also, just wanted to say - Zayn was just born to sing. He did covers before he auditioned to X-Factor that were very good, which you can look up. And then there's this video from the early days of 1D: vine.co/v/eXhAY1TwzB7 - I think the tidal explains all, lol. Zayn's just been always able to effortlessly sing high notes and that just means he was born to sing. Obviously, his voice has matured and gotten stronger from that vine, and it can only get stronger.
***** How does Justin do more with his voice than Zayn, when Zayn has a larger range and a distinct tone? Justin never pushes his voice like Zayn does (for example, his Rock Me high note in Antwerp) and Justin has little to no individuality in his voice and sounds like every mediocre young white boy artist. Justin ALWAYS plays it safe vocally. I'm sorry but it is just a fact that Zayn is a better singer.
I would go with zayn cuz he's voice is the best compare to justin's voice...Zayn can hit hight notes too...His hight note feel like heaven...I would rate zayn 100%...And for justin 35%....
Maz Amd It's a no brainer between Zayn and Liam to me. He's just so versatile. One of the really good baritones in pop music nowadays. Liam/Zayn>Justin>Harry>Niall>Louis.
Jackie Campbell lol r u serious!!?? if u like 1D it doesn't mean u have to insult justins voice and yeah just watch this video again u will realize justins high notes was all live just some of them was studio Version and Zayn's high notes was all studio version and in studio u can record ur voice and fix it.. so no more hate plz My opinion is they r all AMZING :D ... and u know what im a blieberboy and directionerboy
Sam Emogak I agree with not insulting Justin's voice, but as for the live versus studio, Zayn kills the live versions and Justin wouldn't have stood a chance if it was a live version contest. It wouldn't be a competition. Zayn slays those notes. So I for one am glad that Zayn's high notes weren't live, otherwise I'd feel bad for Justin in this competition.
Sam Emogak wow .. zayn can sing or i mean one direction can hit the high notes in their live performances .. just compare justin's voice to them .. then you can see the differences .. im sorry for justin but one direction can sing better than him .. i really dont understand what kind of voice justin have ..
Wow lol, it's super easy to tell who is a fan of who because you can't even say one is better than the other. They're both amazing at what they do. I'm a dude and I have more JB and 1D music than any other artists. JB is kind of like the more flashy and natural one with his voice, while Zayn has the more powerful and majestic voice which he got through vocal lessons. JB focuses more on the riffs and runs in his music. Zayn focused on producing the powerful voice for 1D when he was in it. I don't think you can say one is better than the other because they both have a different style. I personally just enjoy Zayn's style because the falsetto is what I can do as well. Also, Harry and Liam are pretty good singers, Louis and Niall are alright singers, but Justin and Zayn are above all of them. I would seriously love for Bieber and Zayn to collaborate and make a song sometime.
I agree with everything that you say except when you called Justin the natural one i mean Jb is a great singer but he forces it too much when he sings and he overdoes it a bit whereas zayn his talent is so natural. Watch him sing live its so effortless to him and he sounds amazing. Also Zayn AND Justin bieber have vocal coaches so thats not an advantage for Zayn. Every singer has one lol not just Zayn :)
Liz L I just mean Zayn was trained when he was younger. Justin didn't really do that, he just naturally had that voice. Notice from the very early videos of him.
omgsh the Moments one 😍😍😍 I LOVE THIS SONG!!!! and not to be mean to JB fans but your not really basing it off the voice just of what you like. I bet the whole time through Zayn you were like This is fake well then go see him Live
Why compare the King to bieber? Lol Zayn is EXTREMELY TALENTED. LIKE OMG HIS VOCALS MAKE ME TINGLE ALL OVER AND JUST UGH KILLLLLSSS!!! One thing I know, Zayn's music will be AMAZAYN!!!!
+alexis mcgowan ok.. But both of them have a kind of good voice in a different way.. Sorry English is not my first language.. But you got the meaning right..?
Zayn malik is in fact hotter and a better singer. Zayn sings 10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000% better than Justin Bever
zayn always...... whenever justin is doing high notes, he seems to be struggling with it. but zayn, does it so coolly. moreover zayn being the king of high notes, there is a different kind of energy in his high notes, which is not there in justin's voice. like if you agree???
Zayn is obviously the king of high notes!
But Justin is AWESOME too
Catherine Dalin Styles Thanks for being nice ;)
Catherine Dalin Styles I think Mitch from Pentatonix is a high note king... but yeah between these two, they both good, but Zayn wins
It's true that Zayn is the king of high notes, but JB isn't awsome!!!
whtever :P
@@emmakaroliina4505 ayyy come after 5 years pls
Zayn won in my opinion. He is the King of high notes. Imagine only his high notes on his new amd first album!!! I would faint...
***** YASSSS!
zayn always because he is the king of high notes
Just because you hit high notes doesn't mean you're a great singer. I can hit really high notes but I sound like a dying cat! Lol...Justin has a really unique angel voice that you really can't find in anyone else. No hate on you or Zayn (he's kinda cool actually), that's just my opinion.
+Mrs.Bieber/JazzyGamer/JazzyFlutist YOUR RIGHT
thats great
+Mrs.Bieber/JazzyGamer/JazzyFlutist you are just a dying fan you don;t know what is singing
If you think justin can sing ask him to sing one high note from you and i
+Mrs.Bieber/JazzyGamer/JazzyFlutist Yes singing in high notes does mean you can sing, But if you sounded bad you arent singing the notes properly, theres a difference between singing in note and just singing. I think Zayns got that unique voice with his high notes.
Zayn is way better. 100% Zayn. xx
And, so is the rest of 1D can sing better than JB.
Not just Zayn, sorry but its the truth.
Every member of 1D sings better than Bieber please...Hahaha!
Yes
Mickey Horan 1d asf lol i guess she has hearing problems cuz they are wayyyyyy better
Mickey Hood Zayn !!!
Justin Bieber
Zayn 10000000000000%
more like 100000000000000000000000000000000000000%
zayn. definitely. Justin focuses on vibrating his voice.
If he didn't vibrate his voice he would go off key. That's his unique way of not going off key.
JB
***** im a belieber as well, but this is what u wrote
"no it's not lmfao, he can do it so he does it. zayn probably cant, why not do flashy vocal runs..justin does plenty of songs where he doesnt do those. however if he wants to do it he can, lots of r and b singers do that..are you saying they all have trouble keeping on key? ...lmfao"
Btw i copied and pasted this.
***** sorry😔
Zayn scores Bc he is amazing and he can really hit that high note
I really want Zayn and Justin Bieber to collab holy shit
That would be sick!
True
of course it's zayn and omg my favorite high note from him is his "You and I" it brings me chills every time I hear it 😍
Zayn, absolutely Zayn!
Why did you not show any of Zayn live high notes ? You have loads on youtube. Its not even a competition here, Zayn is leagues in front of Justin vocally live and thats not only high notes. Zayn has an amazing vocal range, Justin is not even close.
Zayn hands down, but I still like Justin's voice tbh
ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN !!!!!!
Zayn all the way
Zayn Malik wins because he is king of high notes...
There shouldn't even be a comparison lol
Justin is just too much unlike Zayn who has real talent in his voice
Zayn's the king
It's obvious to me that Zayn masters high notes better than Justin. He's just singing loudly, even his voice is shaking. Zayn knows how to go high enough with his voice instead of just rising the volume.
zayn love
zayn
ZAYN BY FAR!!!
There's no comparison zayn won that contest I'm a belieber but they have TOTALLY different voices zayn's voice IS SO MUCH higher than Justin zayn can hit high notes Justin can too but his voice deepened and now he focuses on more on holding the note and the vibration it's just beautiful, he fills his song with compassion and you can tell how much he loves what he does you can tell that he sings with love❤️
it's Zayn! I listened to some of JB's solos and he was a bit extra, like he was trying to do something new with his voice. but Zayn sings his high notes like it's nothing to him. yes, he may not be able to sing low sometimes, but hey, he can still do them blessed up high notes that can open the gates to music heaven😍 comment if you are on the Zquad side or the beliber side!
Zquad🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
ZAYN COURSE 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😘😘😘😘😘😚😘
ZAAAAYYYYNNNN
9:37 NIALL´S LAUGH OOOOOOOOOOOOOOMMMMMMMMMMMMGGGGGGGG!!!!!
Zayn 100% his voice is amazing!!
Lol anyone who is saying Justin is lying to themselves. Vocal ability, it's just a fact that Zayn has the widest range. People think Zayn can't sing low notes, but he can 100%. His first solo in "Strong" is A2. Justin Bieber's lowest note is C3. And I don't know why people say "Just because you can hit high notes doesn't mean you're a good singer" like ugh....yes it does? Lmao. I'd love to see Justin Bieber try Zayn's high note in the Antwerp performance of "Rock Me".
Now in my opinion, even the sound of Zayn's voice just sounds better. His voice is very very pretty, soothing, and just unique. His chorus in "Right Now", for example, is amazing. It's just so soothing, like I listen to it and I just RELAX. It's really beautiful, and the only reason it's 1D's best song is because Zayn makes it that way. Other good examples of this is his solo in "Half A Heart" and his bridge solo in "Strong". There's no one that sounds like him. Justin, IMO has a very generic voice and there's nothing special to it. It just overall lacks individuality, imo.
Disclaimer: this isn't saying Justin isn't talented. He is. Zayn's just got a better voice.
+Madison G Also, just wanted to say - Zayn was just born to sing. He did covers before he auditioned to X-Factor that were very good, which you can look up. And then there's this video from the early days of 1D: vine.co/v/eXhAY1TwzB7 - I think the tidal explains all, lol. Zayn's just been always able to effortlessly sing high notes and that just means he was born to sing. Obviously, his voice has matured and gotten stronger from that vine, and it can only get stronger.
***** How does Justin do more with his voice than Zayn, when Zayn has a larger range and a distinct tone? Justin never pushes his voice like Zayn does (for example, his Rock Me high note in Antwerp) and Justin has little to no individuality in his voice and sounds like every mediocre young white boy artist. Justin ALWAYS plays it safe vocally. I'm sorry but it is just a fact that Zayn is a better singer.
zayn is better than justin
+Madison G Zayn Is 100% better
+Chad Ingram he does. zayn has a special voice I am not saying JB can't sing bc he can just I don't like his high notes zayn is better
zayn malik has the most highest notes
definitely 100% zayn.....luv u zayn...even if u r not there in the band...we'll miss u
Zayn Malik!!
Love you xx
Omg of course zayn! Why would anyone choose Justin bieber over the world wide sweetheart?(zayn)
you know what im saying how they could pick Justin when theres a much better,cuter,sexier boy which is zayn malik my fav
i agree zayn wins
yeah
I would go with zayn cuz he's voice is the best compare to justin's voice...Zayn can hit hight notes too...His hight note feel like heaven...I would rate zayn 100%...And for justin 35%....
It goes like this: Zayn > Justin > Harry > Liam > Niall > Louis
Maz Amd Exactly!!
Maz Amd It's a no brainer between Zayn and Liam to me. He's just so versatile. One of the really good baritones in pop music nowadays. Liam/Zayn>Justin>Harry>Niall>Louis.
Maz Amd NOPE Zayn > Harry > Louis > Liam > Niall > Justin
MissNess1D Louis better than Liam?
Gee what's in your head.
***** Technique wise, yeah Liam is just supperior. But I don't see how Niall could possibly be better developed than Justin.
It's more like Justin Bieber Vs God
ZAYN❤ZAYN❤ZAYN EL MEJOR😍
My GREATEST SINGER ZAYN....bcz HIS high notes lives in my heart n it touches very closely....I can't live without U ....U r my ZAYNdagi...
zayn malik
!!!!!
DJMALIK
ZAYN ZAYN
Obviously zayn the legend from 1D💜
I love u so much zayn💜💜
Zayn is better than justin
Zayn 100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000%
Definitivamente Zayn Malik
He has crown of high notes...😇👍
Definitely Zyan because he has a higher voice then Justin Bieber
false, and having a high voice does not make you a better singer
Zayn Malik is totally the winner on this :3
OMG!
Bieber can't sing better than 1D period.
Zayn, Liam, Harry even Niall Louis can sing better than Bieber.
Please...
I know right :)
Jackie Campbell lol r u serious!!?? if u like 1D it doesn't mean u have to insult justins voice and yeah just watch this video again u will realize justins high notes was all live just some of them was studio Version and Zayn's high notes was all studio version and in studio u can record ur voice and fix it.. so no more hate plz My opinion is they r all AMZING :D ... and u know what im a blieberboy and directionerboy
Sam Emogak I agree with not insulting Justin's voice, but as for the live versus studio, Zayn kills the live versions and Justin wouldn't have stood a chance if it was a live version contest. It wouldn't be a competition. Zayn slays those notes. So I for one am glad that Zayn's high notes weren't live, otherwise I'd feel bad for Justin in this competition.
Sam Emogak wow .. zayn can sing or i mean one direction can hit the high notes in their live performances .. just compare justin's voice to them .. then you can see the differences .. im sorry for justin but one direction can sing better than him .. i really dont understand what kind of voice justin have ..
harryLyn Styles well, maybe u don't like Justin thats why but actually idc i like both of them ..
Zayn team all day
Obviously Zayn, Justin will never be able to hit those high notes like Zayn!! Loveyou Zayn;)
Zayn's vocals are much better! I have nothing against Justin's vocals because he is also a great singer, but overall Zayn has it
On 11:52 omg!!!! Zayn😍
ZAYN all the way ! Justin is awesome singer but he doesn't high not just falsettos zayn does both
zayn :) XD
I love zayn a lot and want him in 1d but that's his choice and no matter what I will always support him all the way xxx I'm in the zquad
Zayn
ZAYN MALIK IS THE BEST
Justin be like:
-yeEeeEeeeeeEEeeEEEEah, yeah, yeah, yeah...
- woooOOOooooOOOoaaaaAAaaAAAAAaaaahhhh...
- uuuuUUUUuhhh, yeeaaahh, yeah...
Zayn is better.
Wow lol, it's super easy to tell who is a fan of who because you can't even say one is better than the other. They're both amazing at what they do.
I'm a dude and I have more JB and 1D music than any other artists. JB is kind of like the more flashy and natural one with his voice, while Zayn has the more powerful and majestic voice which he got through vocal lessons. JB focuses more on the riffs and runs in his music. Zayn focused on producing the powerful voice for 1D when he was in it. I don't think you can say one is better than the other because they both have a different style. I personally just enjoy Zayn's style because the falsetto is what I can do as well.
Also, Harry and Liam are pretty good singers, Louis and Niall are alright singers, but Justin and Zayn are above all of them. I would seriously love for Bieber and Zayn to collaborate and make a song sometime.
I agree with everything that you say except when you called Justin the natural one i mean Jb is a great singer but he forces it too much when he sings and he overdoes it a bit whereas zayn his talent is so natural. Watch him sing live its so effortless to him and he sounds amazing. Also Zayn AND Justin bieber have vocal coaches so thats not an advantage for Zayn. Every singer has one lol not just Zayn :)
Liz L I just mean Zayn was trained when he was younger. Justin didn't really do that, he just naturally had that voice. Notice from the very early videos of him.
Just look at his wonderful eyes 11:00...they are perfect like crystals 😍❤
*skips all of JB's parts*
oops
+GamerKitten :3 i'd do that!
+GamerKitten :3 me too lol. Just came gere for zayn
did the same !! lmao
lmao
GamerKitten :3 same
ZAYN OF COURSE!! god 😠💗❤️
Zayn is the master of echos
echo echo echo
Zayn wins
zayn malik my sweetheart ofc
ZAYN♥
ONLY ZAYN !!!!!
JB is awesome, but Zayn win this easily. 🙌🙌♥️♥️🔥
Zayn Duhhh
zayn malik totally kicked justin's ass
thats why he left the band ...
probably......:/
Agree
Diana Mitkova nope he didnt justin ha sweat voice zayn doesnt
.............ok u know better
Zayn is better, I don t think something bad about Justin, but I don t like his music. Zayn is my favourite, I think best boy/singer
Asia Smolková 👏👏👌
Zayn is king
ALL HALE ZAYN JAVADD MALIK
Zayn is the best.Zayn is the perfect guy.His looks,his voice,his smile,the way he looks every thing is the best.
Zayyyyn
No one can sings like HIM....No one deserves comparison with HIM...
uhh I'm not a fan of either
but because of Zayns high note in You And I beats all of Beiber brought together
Zaynnnnnnnnn
9.37 i hear Niall laugh ha ha ha ha !!!!
i nkow right
*know sorry
omgsh the Moments one 😍😍😍 I LOVE THIS SONG!!!! and not to be mean to JB fans but your not really basing it off the voice just of what you like. I bet the whole time through Zayn you were like This is fake well then go see him Live
Zayn!!!!!!! Love u!!!!!!
Definitely Zayn Malik😍😍😍
Include zayn's live high notes (rock me, you and I,best song ever)there're mind blowing 🤯🎶😀👌
Everyone has to use lot of energy to take high notes but Zayn never use even half of the energy everyone else use. His high notez are smooth.😗
Why compare the King to bieber? Lol
Zayn is EXTREMELY TALENTED. LIKE OMG HIS VOCALS MAKE ME TINGLE ALL OVER AND JUST UGH KILLLLLSSS!!!
One thing I know, Zayn's music will be AMAZAYN!!!!
Both, but Zayn has got a hottest voice...
I love both .
Zayn Malik for sure all the way :*
Zayn anyday!!! Xxx
I think that for me Zayn wins
Zayn start's at 6:57
ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN ZAYN
Oh yes definately this video will be in my recomendation after 6 years
Zayn note in you and I won the entire battle😂
I'm voting for my bro Zayn,of course (Y)
bieber of course. And.. his videos are in live, no recorded... It´s so much better!
no its not for your information look I know your giving your own opinions but zayn voice is wayyyyyyyy much better then justin
Belieber BBOY lmfao wtf.
not tryna start a fight but go listen to zayns live high notes...voice too powerfull
ReeseAdventures i´m agree with u, but i like the bieber´s voice so much more :)
***** lmao boyband. enough said. Justin is talented and so is zany. but Bieber is better
Can't we agree they both have talent? I love both of them, and personally like JBs voice better, but I think they are both talented.
come on you guys know that zayn has the best voice in the frekin world! AND IT'S AMAZING!😁
Zayn❤ Zayn❤ Zayn❤ Zayn❤❤❤❤
zayn has the best high note period.
Justin look like he be struggling as for Zayn he does it like it's nothing
lies
+Jokoya look at his face
+alexis mcgowan they didn't show us Zayn singing live like justin did.. I go for justin
+brahim salki I've seen him sing and he doesn't look like he's struggling
+alexis mcgowan ok.. But both of them have a kind of good voice in a different way.. Sorry English is not my first language.. But you got the meaning right..?
zayn in you and i highnotes is the best!!!
Zayn malik is in fact hotter and a better singer. Zayn sings
10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000% better than Justin Bever
+Hannah Hobbs its bieber! LLN
+VickyF Sison its zayn!!!
i mean its bieber not bever and i vote for zayn too
Okay first of all, i love the both of them, i really really do. But, i do think Zayn held it way better tham Justin. Again, no hate.
1.
zayn
zayn always...... whenever justin is doing high notes, he seems to be struggling with it. but zayn, does it so coolly. moreover zayn being the king of high notes, there is a different kind of energy in his high notes, which is not there in justin's voice. like if you agree???