Rooster Tail VS Panther Martin - Trout Fishing SHOWDOWN!!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ส.ค. 2024
- What's a better trout fishing lure? Is it the Rooster Tail Spinner or the Panther Martin Spinner? In this video Jordan from Addicted Fishing is doing the Rooster Tail vs Panther Martin Showdown! A challenge between the two trout fishing lures to see which one is the best?! Tune into the whole video to see which trout fishing spinner reigns champion!! Thanks so much for watching, be sure to turn on the bell notification because we have a ton more videos coming.
Help Us GROW! 𝗦𝘂𝗯𝘀𝗰𝗿𝗶𝗯𝗲 𝗛𝗘𝗥𝗘: bit.ly/SUBSCRIB...
Purchase Addicted Tackle! bit.ly/addicted...
10% OFF Addicted Site | Use CODE: 10ADX
▶ Discounts for Addicted FANS!
20% OFF Mustad, CODE: ADDICTED20 bit.ly/shop-mu...
20% Off TUFline, CODE: ADDICTED20 bit.ly/buy-tuf...
20% Off Pro Cure, CODE: ADDICTED bit.ly/shop-pr...
5% OFF KONG COOLERS, CODE: ADX bit.ly/31Gq087
▶ Keep Up To Date With Us In REAL TIME!
Follow Us On Instagram: bit.ly/addicted...
▶ Check Out Some Of Our Favorite Videos!
Epic Salmon Fishing - • EPIC Coho Salmon FISHI...
CRAZY Steelhead Fishing - • Multiple 20 Lb STEELHE...
How To Trout Fish - • COMPLETE In Depth Trou...
Steelhead MOVIE - • Addicted Alaska 2 - Al...
How To Fish Trout Magnets - • How To Fish TROUT MAGN...
Mav Collab - • The Fishing Was Tough....
Ace Videos Collab - • Catches & Cooks His FI...
SB Fishing Collab - • You’re Not Going To BE... NW Fishing Secrets Collab - • The Best STEELHEAD FIS...
Rooster Vs Panther - • You’re Not Going To BE...
Addicted AK #1 - • Addicted Alaska 1 - Al...
Lonny Hook Removal - • Fishing Angler Rips 2 ...
How To Fillet Trout - • How To FILLET TROUT Qu...
▶ Product Partners We Support & USE!
Okuma Fishing: bit.ly/okuma-f...
Gerber Fishing: bit.ly/gerber-f...
Yakima Racks: bit.ly/yakima-fish
Brad’s Fishing: bit.ly/brads-f...
Shortbus Flashers: bit.ly/shop-sho...
Tufline: bit.ly/buy-tuf...
Fillet Away: bit.ly/fillet-...
Pro Cure : bit.ly/pro-cur...
Nikwax: bit.ly/nikwax-...
Humminbird: bit.ly/humminb...
Cannon Downriggers: bit.ly/cannon-...
Minn Kota: bit.ly/minn-ko...
▶ EMAIL FOR BUSINESS INQUIRIES: marlin@addicted.fishing
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Thank you so much for watching our content. We appreciate every single one of you that take the time out of your day to click on our video, give it a thumbs up, share it to friends, or any other support you offer. It's MUCH APPRECIATED!! 🙌 𝗛𝗘𝗟𝗣 𝗦𝗣𝗥𝗘𝗔𝗗 𝗧𝗛𝗘 𝗪𝗢𝗥𝗗! Please share this video with your friends, and don’t forget to subscribe with the bell. 🔔
Some of the above links are partner affiliate links.
Some of the above links are paid or sponsored links.
Some of the products promoted in this video are paid product partners.
STAY ADDICTED! 🤘🎣
#roostertail #panthermartin #fishing
Who is going to win... ROOSTER TAIL OR PANTHER MARTIN?!!
Watch more Trout Fishing Videos here: th-cam.com/play/PLlig7tUTrWvaKdCbd8Omfhj7IxuePwqID.html
Thomas vs blue fox next
Black panther Martin for sure in July if your on eastern side.
Addicted Fishing roaster tail
I use panther Martin firetiger color
Rooster tail
Catching any fish in 10 minutes is a success for me haha...
getting a bite every 10m too loool
No kidding, and the roid-infused fish.... the trout i catch are like 2lbs at MAX, not the 6+ pounder here
@legacy378 just read the water and make your first cast really count, don't stand in one place and keep fishing the same spot. If you walk the perimeter as you fish you will have better results. You won't catch fish if you're fishing a spot without fish.
Catching anything in 40 cast is a win for me
Me too.
I have found the Panther Martin to work much better in the fast flowing streams I fish here in Colorado. The spinner blade just seems to work better in the currents than the Rooster Tail. Both seem to work equally well in still water such as ponds and small lakes. My go-to lure is a Panther Martin black body with gold or black blade with dots and feather dressing on the hook. Usually an 1/8 or 1/16 oz for browns, rainbows and brookies.
Agreed same here in Utah
I go with all black and red dots with gold spoon, but the 1/4 one, cast way further and get more ground
Do you use really light line? I have difficult time casting 1/8oz
protip: your phone has a stop watch/ timer
I've always had great success with the Rooster Tail, not so much with the Panther Martin. In my opinion, the Rooster Tail won the challenge! Enjoyed watching!
Whenever I use panther Martin I always outfish everyone else, that being said it probably depends on the area
@@huntercomeford2687 Agreed. If you can't catch fish on a panther anywhere you are doing something wrong with your retrieve.
The pure excitement of Jordan hooking up right at his feet I could watch all day.
Both are great Trout spinners. My favorite Roostertails are black with silver blade and brown with copper blade in 1/16th oz. I like the black body with gold blade in the Panther Martin. Depending on the water depth... I use a few more pauses and twitches to change up the retrieve. Great contest!
I have that exact same rod and had a problem sticking those panther martins into the trout a few weeks ago. I missed so many fish just like Jordan in this video! I think that rod is tippy enough to sling the lure out there but just doesn’t have enough back bone to drive in the hook.
Panther Martin are my personal favorite for trout
Same here. I catch ALOT on the Gunnison rive in Colorado. I use an 18th oz black body with yellow dots. Absolutely love it!!!
Both work well, but I find color to be more important than brand (although I do have a favorite): silver blade when sunny and/or clear water; gold blade when overcast and/or turbid water; black body or solid silver/gold. Pro tip, I add a few red stripes with a Sharpie on the top side of blade for added flare (always have a red Sharpie in my vest).
Going on my 1st fishing trip in a few weeks.. I've been watching your videos all night. You're literally teaching me to fish. Subscribed! Loved this video.
Impressed with the rooster tail, I need to get another one. I caught a big rainbow on the Missouri river in Montana on that same rooster tail. The PM yellow and sliver is my go to lure for trout in lakes all over Montana.
This is great. A buddy and I used to fish together back in the mid 90's. He was all about the Rooster Tail and I only used Panther Martin's. It's funny that we are in 2020 and people are still pitting them head to head.
I'm 70 now and have been using them since the 70's. Fish love em.
@paseey MEPS aguila>rooster tail never used a panther martin just ordered 8 last week I'll come back and update and we'll see if they are better than agilia
@@silvatown7824 try a blue fox or a tassie
@@silvatown7824 what's the update? Its been 10 months!
The black body rooster with silver blade and red tail is tough to beat. I would love to see a test of multiple colors on the same lure.
My dear old dad told me that there's 2 kinds of fishermen those that sharpen their hooks and those that don't
Rooster Tails are my go to for pond bass but my favorite trout lure is a 1/8th oz Kastmaster
nice video. you might to consider getting a file for your hooks. that was a game changer for me. hooks get dull quick and sharpening them every 30 casts or so really increases your bite/hook set ratio.
Lol i cant keep em long enough to get dull
I need to know what pond that is !! Lol, That was a hog trout !!
I really enjoyed your trial... have more of them. Thank you
I’ve always had good luck with roaster tails, one of my go to for trout fishing
I love both of these lures and have a ton of each. If I were forced to pick one....it would be Panther Martin. When the RoosterTails arent working I can always get a bite or two from a Martin.
I catch trout on spinners and spoons, but when people around me are fishing those and also Powerbait and I fish a wooly bugger and/or scud wet fly, I outproduce them with more and bigger catches. A casting bubble with a bobber stop or bead to create a slip rig will permit soft takes to get felt and set if running spin gear, but the most fun and successful is a fly rod from a kayak to get the fly running in a nonshore-ward direction. A really light leader is also very important: 2-4lb test.
Not to mention, the fish almost never swallow a spinner or spoon like they often do with Powerbait. So much better for quick release.
That black and gold panther Martin was absolutely slaying the trout at Navajo lake a couple weekend ago. A day and a half we caught over 100 most caught on the black and gold.
I've fished the blk and yellow panthers and gold or silver blades since I started as a kid. Always crushed em.. hands down for me the lure. Appreciate these fun comparisons!
I am a Wyoming trout fisherman the hook on a roostertail will always fail until you go to 1 8th of ounce or bigger but any size of a panther martin will hook and set always a better hooking lure.
You forgot the legend. The spinner that will literally catch any fish that swims, especially trout.--Mepps! Mepps #2 in silver or gold. Best spinner out there. You can cast them a mile, and you can retrieve them a slow speed and they won't sink. They stay in the stoke zone longer. Legendary design for sure!🤟😜🎣🎣🎣
You're absolutely correct I use maps aguila size 2-4 just ordered 8 panther martins we'll see how they do compared to the great french agilia
Meps for the win, every time. Roostertail is my second choice, PM third.
Absolutely LOVE your enthusiasm Jordan!!! Addicted's videos are good but I look for ones featuring you specifically!
In the last couple of weeks I’ve been lighting them up with a yellow Panther Martin, definitely my favorite lure.
Wonderful place, Nature gives real life
Now **this** is something I've often wondered. 2 absolute classics.
I really like the red and silver with the yellow spots for the panther martins they work really well in my area.
I always use panther martins with feathers. I keep catching big fish.
Little gets pissed when you lose a fish. I’m surprised she doesn’t make you sleep on the floor.
Landed or overall hits, both seemed to just produce! Better keep 'em both handy in the tool kit!
Got my second spring chinook today. Insane day had 6 fish on caught only 1. Man do I love fishing!
There’s nothing better than fishing, even when you don’t catch anything it’s still better than going to the bar because if you catch something at the bar you can’t turn it loose 🤣
Henry Henry that’s the first haha! Gonna have to use that joke sometime man😂
Two of my most favorite lures for trout. Damn you make me want to be out fishing. Thanks.
Haha i can feel his excitement 🤣 im just learning how to fish and mine was a little rainbow trout caught me by surprise i thought it got caught on some weeds but as i reeled i got a fish! That was pretty cool havent caught anything since and ive gone two day in a row 😭 definitely gonna try these lures, powerbait sucked for me 🤣
Welcome to the sport. It's fun.
Black and Brown No# 2 Rooster tails have caught me more trout, bass and crappie than I can remember in 37 years of fishing in all bodies of water.
I think the "hits" he got in the 1st 8 mins were the lure snagging structure 😂
def, watch his other vids. NEVER seen anyone miss so many "bites" in my life
Was thinking the same
I must be old. When did it get fashionable to hold your rod tip so low. My father would’ve worn a groove in the back of my head if I jerked off that many hits.
i dont know if you know but rainbows sometimes swallow and spit out a lure almost immediately, and you may feel it waaay too late
Always love your fishing vids. Very entertaining and educational!
Pistol Pete's & Blue Fox are my favorites. I've caught way more with them.
So the better test would be trolling all 4 in a lake. More controlled conditions, open water, same lines, same depths. Switch rod positions and which lures are on which rods.
Who knows, maybe a cat peed on one reel. The key is to eliminate all confounding variables.
Awesome stuff Jordan. Love using the brown trout rooster tail in 1/6 caught a nice 19” rainbow on it on the river. Thanks again for sharing. Awesome video as always!!
It's all about the tasmanian devil's man! People say they're trolling lures, but i've been using them from the shore for years. Maybe it's time for some Addicted Spinners? ;)
I love both the panther martin and the rooster tail as you do. Like you, the panther martin in black and gold is my absolute go to spinner. I had great fun watching you fish that pond. Keep it up.
Joe's flies are my go to
those things are Trash
@@anneharo001 they motivated me start making my own lures and tie my own flies so I'm biased lol
Grew up using rooster tails since I was a young lad. But I'm a fan of Panther Martin's and Mepps spinners with fly patterns on the hook.
Panther Martin all the way. Yellow with red spots is one of our favorites! Thanks for the awesome content! Watching your channel inspired us to start our channel not long ago and we already have 2 videos out!
Can't decide. Just love the diversity of choices in my box to have my own competitions.
Really my best ones are the ones i find at a spot some chump left behind.🤣🐟🎣
Kastmaster for me 😁
I’ve only ever really caught trout on KM’s😂☠️
A good ole km spoon will kill em
We need an Addicted Shnikees t-shirt!! Lol!! Love it!!
No
Looks like hook upgrades are a good tip. I always like single hooks on my spinners. I feel like they give me a better landing ratio and less snags than trebles.
I've thought about doing that a fee times. Glad you commented on it. Gonna get some single
Hooks tomorrow n try it out.
Few not fee.
this channel is as diverse as fishing tackle im addicted
Really enjoyed anything Addicted Fishing puts out. And I love the competition so much. You guys are awesome. This is what we need now with all of the lockdowns and crap. For me, I like the Mepps spinners but I have caught a lot of trout and warm water species with both the Panther Martin and Rooster Tail. Bass seems to like the Rooster Tail a lot. God bless.
That pink rooster tail in 1/8th ounce is super hard to find. My orders for it keep getting cancelled online. It by far is the best color I’ve used trout fishing.
These lures are very easy to hand make and work just as good as name brand in line spinners.
I like rooster tails but my favorite trout lure is probably the super duper.
My grandma made rooster tails at Yakima Bait for 30 years. She’d always bring home blemishes and I loved fishing with them.
rooster tail, pistol pete flies are my favorite
Beginner questions here so please excuse my ignorance. Are pistol
Pete flies for fly fishing?
I have used panther Martins back beginning of the eighties Fishing the state waterways and I Have wone a lot of contests at Pay lakes I'd have to give Panther Martin Top spot
Gold panther orange fly hook,,,,it's a killing machine.
How are there not more people there? Is this a private lake? This looks like so much fun! Wish we had big lakes stocked with bows like that in MI!
I use to have the same issue with panther martins problems hooking up! Solution change hooks! G-F’s work awesome!
Do a bracket style
Thomas vs blue fox next
If you're just going trout lures
1/4 oz rooster tail is my go-to. After reading the comments, I'll give the panthers a longer try.
Yeah, 1/6 oz mostly for me but I fish 1/4 sometimes. White with silver blade is probably my most consistent color in rivers here in NEPA. White belly with brown top is my second best catching color. 3/4 of my trout are caught on Rooster tails, if using spinning rods. 2 tone spoons are catching up lately though. Also started tying a fly 2' up from the main lure for a teaser. Catching a good handful on them lately. Just started that a month or so ago. I fish teasers for strippers in salt water early and late in the season and decided to try it for trout. Glad i did. I fish mainly rivers.
@@erikvaldur3334 I'll confirm the power of the white rooster tail w/ silver blade. It's not a scientific conclusion, really, but in my recollection, that pattern is more likely than others to trigger a bigger fish. I get browns on 2-tone spoons, not so much rainbows --- (I'm in MA). I mostly fish rivers as well---casting upstream.
rooster tails have got me so many fish this year already, great video as usual.
i love panther Martin's in river s i slay with the black and gold
Torrin Ellis I am a Mepps guy in a river.
@@jimmyc451 solid choice I love them in creeks in the white and red color
I like the mepps but all gold
black and gold dots works great in colorado too
I jus bought a black n gold 1🙏cant wait to use it
Big fan of spinners, I have had great luck with Fireperch pattern RT's. Black with a silver or gold spoon too in streams. I'm convinced trout like crushing that tail giving it an edge. Great video! You got some really great fish on cam.
I really enjoy these head to head lure battles. I wonder what you think would take on the KING of all spoons, “ The ACME Kastmaster” ????
The silver and blue panther Martin is my fav
I was always told Panther Martin spinners are the best and I been using them since 1997. I use 2 PMF SY which is like a rooster tail style spinner. Silver blade with yellow and red rooster tail but it's a Panther Martin. I just caught a brown trout in a lake camping this weekend with it. I don't go fishing a lot but when I do I like using a spinner and I use that spinner.
OK I have not looked at this yet but I say the lures of both should be the same color as different colors work for different things ! Also I have fished with both and as for me I,ll stay with the Rooster Tail and I started fish back in the 50,s when I was a kid I am 71 and a Rooster tail lover ! Now I,ll look at this thing !
Panther Marten is the king of fishing lures!!
Yellow and black bee print rooster tail takes all the cakes in my unprofessional opinion! You guys are the best on TH-cam flat out. Thanks
Been slaying trout for years with my favorite trout killer, the Panther Martin PMR-G. Mostly rivers and streams, but I'll even troll a PM at about 15-20 feet on smaller lakes.
Blue and silver rooster tail is my go to
I'd have to go with the panther Martin only because you're able slow the retrieve way down and the blade keeps spinning
Panther Martin's spinners are better at slower speeds, where a rooster tail will sometimes stop spinning when retrieving at slower speeds. Still hard to beat a rooster tail!
That’s awesome fishing and it’s very awesome the dog know when one is hook based off your energy.
Man guy, I got so excited follow by depression like I was the one fishing on that big girl that chased it in then popped off. Fun video man
I've had good luck with both I keep a good supply of both in my tackle!
Classic old school lures that are proven to catch fish.
Willams wobbler
bee em we use them to troll on lakes
I just fished Bennett and Montock Springs, Missouri. Fly Only regulations may permit a rooster tail with a “single-hook”. Treble hook roosters not permitted. Check your states trout regulations and local marked stream regulations may further restrict lure type and use.
I prefer the panther martin. I went kayak fishing last weekend and more success with this lure than i've had in years!
I've done this exact test over twenty times.
Results: panther Martin is a six to one winner on trout here in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan.
Angle your pole more to the side and
Then when you get a bite your hook set will be a lot better
I think they are both great spinners, but I normally favor the Panthers as well, I like the thump of the blade and the teardrop body profile.
Need a rematch! Next time fish each lure with no time limit until you land a trout, quickest one wins!
That was a massive trout😍
Panther Martin's used too be my go too but in the last few years I've had more luck with rooster tails!!!! Both are good lures!!!
Both are good spinners and both have their time and place.great video keep them coming
i always catch more with the rooster tail, those feathers in the hook make a lot of diference
I’ve modified a few Panther Martin’s with feather trebles. I tie flies, so I already has all the supplies. They’re usually hardier than cheap store bought ones anyway.
I found out that when you loop the "Fisherman"knot, double thru the loop like a Surgeon knot. The hook will never come off.
how do you stop line spinl with panther martin
The panther Martin definitely my go to but damn the rooster tail was attracting way more bites AND it caught two species so I think it won
Best part about every video these guys make is that they show them all not catching fish a lot of the time.
I think you are the winner you got to go fishing 😉💪 my favorite spinner is copper steelhead seem to love it and orange spinners work just as good
i like panther martin better ! Awesome Fishing Video ! I was enjoy so much ~ thank you for share Fishing experience ! Liked !
Can't go wrong with either lure. Another trout slayer is the goofy shaped Super Duper.
Love how stoked you get!
I’m a Rooster tail guy, goes without saying I’m very bummed ! Fun video
Awesome video dude, love your excitement. Panther Martin always good. I've learned some great ideas from these..thanks