NETAJI SUBASH CHANDRA BOSE Reaction! | What Schools don't teach you about India's Real Hero!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- Reaction Gear: amzn.to/2QgTwk2 (affiliate link)
____________________
Intro music by DAVIS
TH-cam - bit.ly/30OK7RR
Spotify - spoti.fi/2I3vRvE
iTunes: apple.co/2KnvgYN
SoundCloud: / unofficialdavis
Facebook: / unofficialdavis
Twitter: / unofficialdavis
Instagram: / unofficialdavis
___
Jamazing Patrons of September: Krishna Venkataraman, Avijit Singh, Madhan, Riju Mahna, Pankaj Goel, Elisha Mittal and Gaurav Kolarkar!
Be a patron for Jaby and support more videos like this!
/ jabykoay
___________________________________________________
Original Upload Link:
• Netaji Subash Chandra ...
___________________________________________________
SOCIAL MEDIA:
~STEPH SABRAW~
Instagram: @StephSabraw
TH-cam: @TheWhirlGirls
~ACHARA KIRK~
Twitter & Instagram: @AcharaKirk
/ achara
~JABY KOAY~
TH-cam, Twitter, Instagram: @jabykoay
~VEERENDRA CHOWDARY~
Veerendra Chowdary created the opening animation.
Twitter: @NameisVeeru
~MOOSA RAZA~
Moosa Raza created additional background animation.
Instagram: @syedraza7
Twitter: @MoosaRaza27
___________________________________________________
Jaby WEST:
/ getjaby
Jaby ASIA:
/ jabytv
JABY KOAY'S SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
• JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
Click here to subscribe and know when the next video drops:
www.youtube.com...
Thanks for watching!!!
__________________________________________________
Credit of my favorite movie reviews song:
Highlight Reel Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons...
Intro song: Hudson Stanton (looks more like Nick Jonas than me)
TH-cam: / hudson12311
Insta: / hudsonstantonmusic
Thank you for your kind words Achara and Steph :)
Means a lot :)
Also my name is Ganesh
Ganesh, incredible work man. What I like about you is when I watch your videos I don't see an agenda. Pure information narrated as it is.
Ganesh if you want to learn more about Netaji and his life after death
Kindly watch Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur Ghose works and their books on netaji especially Conundrum.
Your work is amazing!
Brilliant work Ganesh!
Your videos on West Bengal are lit, need more
If Western people think that approaching Hitler was wrong, please remember that Indians see the Brits as way worse at genocide in India (read Jallianwala Bagh massacre, great Bengal famine). Thus, to us Hitler, British raj, Portuguese occupation (the Portuguese need separate videos) were all the same. Again, the notion of western problems aren't India's problems can be applied here.
Jaishankar
These western people know nothing about what Indians have gone through nd think approaching Hitler is wrong as if we care for what he did , lmao ,nobody in the world cared for us at that time why we have to hold the flag of humanity every time when nobody did that for us .
For me britishers are worse than Hitler, Hitler atleast had a motive because Germany was humiliated so badly during ww1 so his narcissist approach atleast had some brain cells used , meanwhile what britishers did was out of pure greed nd self fishness. Not saying what Hitler did is right .
There are literally more of them
At that time no one knew about hitler genocide of jews
@@prabhatsingh5234 today many know. But the atrocities of the British are not well known as much as holocaust. The world needs to know that Brits were no different from Hitler in many ways.
Proud to be the grandson of an INA veteran. Glad that their stories are being told.
Massive respect to your grandfather who fought for the indipendence of our mother land. Nethaji Subhash Chandra Bose should be the father of our nation not British agent Gandhi. If INA won the war India wouldn't have been divided into two
@@chinazieswillstartww3253 Namskar and Thank you. He finally came back to India as a penniless refugee. The only memory he had with him of INA was the patta of his uniform. Long after, once mom asked him why he never applied for freedom fighter pension. He replied, "Babu, pension ke liye thode lada tha"
Our generation owes a lot to men and women like them.
heyyy damnnn mad respect brother
@@agnivachat17 Thank you :)
respect for him !!
One individual may die for an idea, but that idea will, after his death, incarnate itself in a thousand lives. :- NETAJI SUBASH CHANDRA BOSE
Gandhi was a British agent, how many knows he when Gandhi was in Africa he wanted to fight from British Army side, but British army denied and asked to help their wounded soldiers, later British army awarded him as Sargent in British army. For many years no one knows what he was doing in Africa and how he suddenly landed in India, and why he & Nehru always get special treatment from Brishers like 3 start Jail while other kept in very drastic situation.Gandhi was the first person who killed democracy when in Congress presidential election Subhash chandra bose got 12 vote and Nehru got just 3 vote despite Gandhi made Nehru as congress president.
@Velichayshiy lider Hey Man.. You admire Nethaji. We all do. But That doesn't necessarily mean you should hate all other freedom fighters. What propaganda are you trying to impose repetitively with just this one comment by Bhim ji, who himself said that he was an opponent. If you truly admired Nethaji, you wouldn't try to defame others as Nethaji himself didn't defame any other freedom fighters just because their ideologies differed. Let's keep their Pride intact in International Platforms. If We, ourselves, defame our Indian Freedom Fighters, Westerners take happiness in it.
@@kapiljain905 What a Clown you are!! It's evident from your comment that you are a student of SMU - Social Media University. Educate yourself first and then Educate us. Don't demean our great Leaders using your mini Brain in front of the West. 🤬
wasnt he a fascist ?
also he supported hitler's views
Freedom is not given , it's taken .
- Nethaji Subash chandra Bose.
Jai hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
BOSE
NOT BOSH...
@@vamshivemula tq.
Jai Hind❤
People think Gandhi got us freedom lol
Not taken. Correct term would be "won".
"তোমরা আমাকে রক্ত দাও আমি তোমাদের স্বাধীনতা দেব" - Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose
100% ঠিক ❤️❤️
Se ekai ekta sena chilo
নেতাজি ❤
"You give me blood , I will give you freedom"
-Neetaji Subash Chandra Bose .
The man , the myth , the legend .
We all love him , respect him . Founder of Azad Hind Fauj or Indian National army. One of the best and biggest reason of Indian Independence.
@nothing nothing 'Violent' is a subjective term. If you fight an animal that is attacking your family, are you being 'violent'? Netaji was a hero, more than gandhi could ever hope to be, get that very clear in your head.
@nothing nothing And A Only Reason For India's Freedom 🇮🇳
@nothing nothing yes nobody is comparable to gandhi in bhadwagiri
@nothing nothing Such a pessimistic human you are. Also, since you didn't get it, the 'animal' in my sentence referred to the british. And there is nothing inhumane in fighting your oppressors with violence. Even our ancient texts outline this fact - "Ahimsa parmo dharma, dharmo himsa tathaiva cha" meaning "Non violence is supreme, but violence committed in the protection of dharma (duty, responsibilty) is even more supreme".
@nothing nothing
Think deeply....
A day , your mother was killed in front of you , coz u only request him not to kill but don't force him to stop...
That's your thinking.....
Dr. BR Ambedkar once said that Gandhi got a lot of respect in foreign countries than in India.
Because a lot of books were published about Gandhi, a lot of documentaries were published by the movie makers, by the media, by authors and by the Indian government of that time, moreover people in India give a lot of respect to Netaji. Netaji lives in the hearts of Indian people. Netaji is Emotion ❤️😌🙏
Yes many more haven’t introduced or any major books have written about them so they are not very known to western world.
Legends never die.
They become a part of you .❤️
@@Pk_1911 yes govt should also promote others region of India's Freedom fighters by build statue as well.. there are so many things happened during independence process not only Gandhi andolan..
@Velichayshiy lider Better source than Internet needed in the age of Deepfakes and AI.
@Velichayshiy lider was just saying good sources needed. So, cite the sources, otherwise you sound like a fool.
I’m a Malaysian Indian but you have no idea how proud and goosebumps this video makes me. Till date my grandmother used to tell me the story of unseen HERO Subash Chandra Boss. She has seen the struggles and sacrifices of her father, my great grandfather who also there in Indian Army at Singapore with Nethaji. I am so proud to be Indian no matter where I am & so blessed to know the story from my great grandfather and grandmother❤❤
You will tell this story to your friends and also to the children of your family
Well said brother/ sis
Yes here many have his photo of him till now
One name a thousand words
Thankful to your great grandfather 🤍 He made a great contribution to set us free 🛐 bow down to the unsung heros about whom we are not taught. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
It's such an honour to be named after one of Netaji's commanders.
Jai Hind Jai Bharat
great
I know a Shahnawaz living in my locality, having a Pakistani flag hoisted high in his backyard. We need true Indians like you brother. Take love.
This is lovely Shahnawaz. Jai hind 🇮🇳
@@agnibhubijali jhooth
@@agnibhubijali Why is he able to do that in your locality? Why is he not in Jail yet?
My Great Grandfather was in Azaad Hind Fauj and were also put to jail for several years in andaman and Nicobar islands and the family thought he dies until he came home one day. Proud of him 💪
We all greatfull to you're grand father.
Thank you sir
Salute to your GREAT GRAND FATHER & acknowledge my respect to your bloodline !!
And let me tell you on thing that because of his sacrifices we are living a comfortable life as we were allotted a petrol pump in 1993 and were also given agricultural land too. 🙂
No one cares.we live 2022 not 1920 anymore.get a job.
Netaji is the only reason why India got freedom ❤️
Whenever I listen about Netaji i feel even more proud Bcz my Grandfather was a soldier in Indian National Army of Netaji and for 7 yrs he didnt come back home cz he was captured. One of my grandfather (grandpa's brother) who faced trials at Red fort. His mother always waited for his son till her last breath as he couldnt see his dead body. 💔 And after all the sacrifice they teach us the nonsense non violent movement. HUH
Right sister....NON SENSE NON VIOLENT MOVEMENT. Had there not been the fauj and Netaji, we would still be licking and cleaning Brits shoes.
So true!
Salute to your GRANDFATHER & Pranam to your bloodline !!..
OM SHANTI for Him
JAI HIND SAB JI
@@agnibhubijali that’s an assumption Gandhi ji had an impact
Legends say that Bose didn't die in that plane crash..it was faked for the British and he worked in shadows as "Gumnami Baba" he made significant plays for independence..the whole show Achara mentioned is about that..there is even a temple of Netaji Subash Chandra Bose In Japan and people can visit..He is respected highly there ❤️
Legends nhi conspiracy theorist bolte h usko...
Unke bachho ne saf gumnami baba k naam se mana kr rkha h
These gossip mills about netaji not dying and being gumnami baba is an insult to him and moreover what is the purpose behind being annonymous when he would have served the nation in the limelight better
@@akscs373 unke bache nai bus ek beti thi aur zara background check krna vo kin logo ke sath thi wahi log jisne history book se ye chapter hataya aur hamesha se netaji ki biwi unke sath thi unki beti unke sath nai thi
@@amithanda4934 it's not an insult just watch anuj dhar about subhash chandra bose he will explain u with proves what he was and what he did
@@amithanda4934 because he supported the *wrong* (obv he didn't know what Hitler was upto or what he has done) side in the ww2 so he had to keep himself hidden otherwise he would have been publicly hanged as nehru was very close with the British , nd there were no reports of a plane crash in Taiwan either nd the ashes of netaji never were never checked through a DNA test so all these makes me think that he didn't die in 1945.
U only think why nehru had such great relationships with Britishshers even tho they made us go through so much including him.
Just an FYI, 25 lakh is not 250,000 its actually 2.5 million.
You guys are doing great work by reacting to these videos as it helps us Indians to understand what narrative you have in your head, what is taught to you.
Kudos to you guys!
Netaji said, 'Give me blood and i will give you FREEDOM'.... the actual first Prime Minister of INDIA....the father of 'Azad Hind Fauj'....
+1
😂
It's Patel the first and real PM... Netaji is and was the warrior... Not leader
Well said
@@manannaik1341 he was a great leader too.
Had his work been recognised by the Indian Government that ruled India post-1947, people in India would’ve questioned the significance of Gandhi in India and the credit that he is normally given which would make it difficult for them to rule India the way they wished to. Also, Nehru and other Congress leaders were in one way or the other intimated by Netaji in the first place because he overthrew even Gandhi’s popularity in 1939 when he won the election against a Gandhi backed candidate.
But we should remember gandhiji had nothing to do with it. It was a political agenda of Congress. Right? Gandhiji is rightfully respected and wrongfully used as a political weapon.
Just go and check it out. Netaji overthrew gandhi backed candidate. And have u considered to find who backed netaji at that election. It was Nehru. Netaji's name was presented by nehru. Go get some knowledge over all these things.
Absolutely irrelevant facts. Netaji was liked by them but obviously their ideologies didn't match at some point leading to two different sides. We needed both people
Gandhi was simply an agent put in by Britishers to delay independence as much as as possible(at least delay till world war 2 finishes) , which btw happened
@@Shiva-zj6od and who was nehru. Was he more popular than Bose. It's like saying Modi is backed by Pragya Singh, umaa bharti, etc. And that's why Modi won the election.
I am glad My dad taught me this history (before our school tried to brainwash me) when I was very young, I still remember We had 5 framed photos(wallpaper) of NetaJi with his quote in our home.
Subhash Chandra Bose not a ordinary freedom fighter
He is an EMOTION
Netaji's ideology was in complete contrast to Gandhi ji's teachings
Therefore, in order to elevate Gandhi ji's image, it was essential to dilute the impact that Netaji had in our freedom struggle
INC (ruling party at that time) was the primary reason for this bcoz they drafted history in a way that would strengthen their political image
Gandhi ji was the primary representative of INC so he became the lead protagonist of their story
Netaji went against Gandhi ji & hence he was left out of the narrative
The more one learns about Gandhi ji, the more they realize that the history taught to us hasn't been very transparent
@nothing nothing I agree with you on violence not being a good way to revolt, it is the way India got Indepedence which should be thaught irrespective of consequences. Moreover, death of bose is not that straight as you think.
Gandhi on other hand really had a long vision of getting independence through non violence and non co-operation which atleast this case was not successfull as we will never be able to realise the scenario of non violent independence which we already got. However, teachings of Gandhi is still relevant and prevelant in current society
@nothing nothing and everything gandhi did made India weaker, his movements were failure ...Netaji and INA's threat made the British leave India ...
Dont let the gandhians brainwash yourself .... When someone is torturing your motherland, killing your brothers, violence is the only way of resistance... Those roundtable conference are nothing but some dumb propaganda events
I love it when people don't read their text books in school and then come up with long conspiracy theories on Bose being left out of the narrative.
@nothing nothing violence worked in many countries to get freedom! USA itself! So, that time Bose didn’t feel non violence moments would give freedom. What he did is nothing wrong. And what Gandhi did was nothing wrong either. And we got freedom not because of ONLY Gandhi’s movements. There were multiple reasons why Brit decided to leave India.
Netaji espoused for a socialist fascist regime. A blend of both the extremes. That's not what the indian leaders had in mind , idolising him might have created its own problems in post independence home rule. Netaji was a patriot no doubt about that.
Netaji subhas chandra bose is 1st pm of Undivided India 🇮🇳
*"Give me blood, and I shall give you freedom"*
- Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose
Don't worry, we bengali people know that our Rabindranath Thakur made a song dedicated to Netaji that is now recognized as our National Anthem.
So even if you don't talk about our Gumnami Baba, he will always be remembered through our National Anthem.
Glad u said - 'rabindranath Thakur' and not 'Tagore'
The song has nothing to do with S. C. Bose. It was written as a "Brahmo" hymn and talks about "pluralism" in India.
Netaji is our real hero not Gandhi. 🙏
Not savarkar also😂, Gandhi was the man organized all classes of indians against Britain. Remember when gandhi come to India there is few english learned high class people in freedom movement 🇮🇳
Netaji gave Gandhi the title "Father of Nation" fyi
@@Sandrocottus-ly padhai kar le bhai March me exam hai whatsapp University se padh ke kuch nhi hoga
@@sarasmishra821 Now i understood who studying in WhatsApp University 😂
I think you should react to *Gumnaami* which is a Bengali film dealing with his life and subsequent theories about his "death".
His efforts have always been hidden in our school textbooks and media. As someone whose family lived briefly in his neighbourhood, I'm shocked that I learnt about his awesomeness in 9th Standard.
Did you know that after he met Hitler personally, he was part of a Japanese submarine crew who outsmarted a British submarine to get him to Japan?
Now tell me, where in our history textbooks have you heard of this?
I wanted to recommend it and u did it for me thanks..
I would recommend seeing Anuj Dhar discussion in this topic. He has dedicated his life in deciphering these mysteries and bringing out the reality. They are much factual than the movie gumnaami.
I personally remember reading it in our class 10 ICSE History/Civics book, and the same in NCERT for competitives, so I always find it weird to believe when people say that the textbooks don't have these information.
History books mostly cover history revolving around Delhi like the Mughal history and the contribution of Congress and Gandhi. Netaji barely receives a few pages with all these crucial information being missing. That needs to change.
@@spiritual-Aatma Mughal History isn't even there after class 7/8, with 8 dedicated to the latter Mughals, Marathas, and the entry and rise of the EIC. Netaji is covered in 10, and further more in +2. All the information in this video (and much more about INA) are definitely covered by class 10.
My Eyes are literally filled with tear. Such a Legend Neta ji Subhash Chandra Bose 🙏🏻. Legends never die. Ghandhi was nothing in front of him. 😔
Gandhi and the inc gave the idea of an independent idea they created movements across india for more than half a century of India. Countless inc members spent decades of their lives in jails in inhumane conditions. Giving your lifetime for a country has to have enough merit as giving your life for your country. Freedom struggle is not about a single person. Read so your mind opens.
@@Techfollowme INC was a party of elites who used common people for their political gains
@@Techfollowme yes, they did.. but that doesn't mean every one else didn't struggle of freedom. According to me, credit should be given where credit is due...
Bose and 3 military commanders are the real Hero’s of United India (Every independent country in subcontinent).
Freedom is not given, it is taken
- netaji shubhash chandra bose
They didnt mentioned in book so i studied about him myself,
Can you please tell the title book or other resource you use to study about him
they did... you just a poor reader... and that can be seen from the grammatical error in your sentence.. "didnt mentioned..........",,,,,,hahahhaha
@@vishalahuja2136 lol go and read history ncert book then say idiot and stop judging on the basis of english lol
@@vishalahuja2136 if for you, english is only way to prove someone can read or write then you are still under colonial mentality where people are judged not on the basis of knowledge but on the basis of how good english they speak
@@vishalahuja2136 British spotted 😂😂
SALUTE to all our Freedom fighters , who sacrificed themselves for our Country... Jai HIND 🇮🇳
Also recently the statue of Honourable Subhash Chandra Bose ( India Gate ) was Inaugurated by PM Modi
Gandhi did nothing for India's independence. But the Indian National Congress has highlighted Gandhi as the main figure of India's independence. Indian national congress never gave any honor to those who actually fought and martyred for India's freedom.
+1
+2
@@pulkitkaushik Har comment ke niche jaake plus 1 likh deta hu, leftists mujhe award denge🤡
No one highlighted Gandhi's or Nehru's struggle against the British. This is a well known fact. Go and learn about role of RSS in supporting British. Do a fact check on some fac t checking websites..... before posting and believing juvenile thoughts
Cry more 🤣🤣
Sardar Patel, Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and Bhagat Singh were some of the pioneers of our freedom struggle.
But the politics involved, followed by congress rule of india for 50 years changed what we know in history (only Gandhi ji and Nehru).
@@meinmovingimage3193 who taught you bhagat singh valued nehru actions the same book which taught you nehru and gandhi were the real hero , bhagat singh and netaji only supported nehru and gandhi just because they are also fighting and a large number of people were with them just for the sake of this they didnt say any bad thing about them you can read j d kriplani book about gandhi you will know how secular and good he was and google who j d kriplani was and there is video on beerbicep podcast channel too see that too and read lord mountbatten book and a letter written by him and you will know the real truth its a fact history was erased from our textbooks whether it is independence history or any other we all read about mughal empire have you ever read about maratha empire ??
@@niteshchandwani1809 Bhagatsingh and Gandhi/Nehru had mutual respect for each other.
@@Pk_1911 i know i told you the reason too but bhagat singh and netaji never valueed or justified their actions
@@niteshchandwani1809 they had differences in their thoughts, the way they were working. Doesn’t mean they didn’t value each other’s.
@@Pk_1911 here from value means they dont support their actions like netaji used to say azadi mangi nahi jati chhini jati hai
"Tum mujhe khoon do, mai tumhe azaadi dunga" meaning "Give me blood, I will give you freedom". These words are still enough to boil my blood & fight for the sovereignty of Mother India. Thank you Netaji for this luxury called freedom ❤
Yep... There are many untold story of freedom fighters from every state.. even here in NE india,lots of freedom fighters that we know is not even mention 1 in indian freedom fighters there is also women war with British.. but no one remember brave women names.. so sad😔 he even mention when bringing soldiers to Imphal (capital of Manipur) lots of freedom fighter from manipur never even mention
Hey I recently have started knowing about north eastern kingdoms, tribals and freedom fighters. And thanks to internet and recent news of celebration Rani gaidinilui ( sorry for wrong spellings), and many such people. Even Odia freedom fighters.
You know what even in Maharashtra there are many people I had no idea of their extent of contribution. Shahu maharaj was most iconic among them. Lahu ji salve… many many more.
Also I think travelling and seeing say museums or statues will help knowing more.
Celebrating subash Chandra Bose as freedom fighter is difficult from here the beginning, East Indian company was afraid of subash his point of view was different from Gandhi ,Nehru and other congressman at that time.he thought Armed revolution will bring freedom more faster then Policy of non-violence.Subash traveled Russia and Germany to get armed support.He lived in shadows for most his life his After culcata province Madaras province supported subash.
+1
Gandhi and Nehru their goals were never to free India
@@manannaik1341 Aacha.....aur kya kya sika hai tumne WhatsApp par.
@@praveenpillay4329 WhatsApp se yeh sikha ki hum free hue Indian Navy mutiny se.. navy got inspired from Bose..
@@praveenpillay4329 Aur tune kya sikha hai Lund University se Bdsk. Kahin tu voh Gandhi ki nazais aulad toh nahi har comments section me ja kar jaise hag raha hai. Hahaha
There is a book about Netaji by Shoilen Roy. It's called, "Aami Shubhash Bolchhi." This is Shubhash Speaking. At the end of the book, two men close to this man sat in a room. One was on his death bed. The other one had been with Shubhash in his last moment. The dying man said, "Is Shubhash actually dead?" The other man said, "I am a soldier. I cannot go against orders."
Colonel Habib ur Rahman
Ik right as a Bengali if I didn't knew about netaji I would have felt ashamed thank God I do know both the types of freedom fighters
14:46 Answer to your question Achara Simple reason, history is written by winners. Congress under leadership of Nehru, who considered Netaji as his strongest competitor for PM post, wrote history. So Gandhi, Nehru dominated Congress ousted Netaji from party in 1939. Nehru understood Netaji is more God gifted that attracted people to accept him as leader. Hence he hated and opposed Netaji throughout his life. Britishers found Nehru to be their more trust worthy, ready to provide them support with common wealth status and continuing massive economic trade relations. Gandhi and Patel were already side stepped. Jawaharlal was doing all negotiations with Mountbatten. During this period he was continuously doing propaganda against Netaji. If you are dreamy and believe in the Utopian concept of non-violence, for you Gandhi is better. If you believe that, ‘big problems can be solved only by iron and blood’ and have realistic views about life, for you Netaji is better. However, one point is very clear that Netaji never involved himself in dirty politics which Gandhi did in 1938 and 1939. He literally harassed Netaji that made Netaji leave INC.
And people think because of Gandhi we got independence 🤣🤣🤣🤣
People don't think, it was spoonfed to us since first day of school.
@@pulkitkaushik salt march se independence 😂
He played his part,but it was a small part but people's thinks he has done everything.
The real first prime minister of India 🇮🇳🚩
The Most Iconic Line of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose which he said in that Famous Speech Was..
"Tum mjhe khoon do, Mai tumhe Ajaadi dunga"
Means
"You Give me Your Blood, I'll give you Freedom"
Very deep Meaning.. In my Younger Days I misunderstood That Line in a negative way ..but as I grow up.. This line Seems to be the most Powerfull line to say To any rebellion..
Proud to be an Indian 🇮🇳🇮🇳 proud to be an Bengali ❤❤❤❤
We, the Tamil people served our Nethaji 's military.
He should have translated Netaji's iconic dialogue in English also so that they could have understand the depth of that sentence. It translate as “Give me your blood and I will give you freedom!”.♥️
Thank youu! I was looking for the same
I didn't know about you but I have learnt about him a lot by the books from my saink school . I was always fascinated about him and dressed like him on the indipendence day in my school . He was a real hero and no one can forget him.. 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
99% of Indians don't study in "Sainik school". So we did not learn about him. Don't act elite.
@@moviemarvel7450 99% indians do not get into saink school so he can act elite
Since its sainik school,you got the chance to learn about him.Its not the same with the others.I laugh when they showcase a stooge like Gandhi as some god sent Leader but doesn't even mention the fighter who fought by being at the front lines.
Subash chandra bose is a soldier and our bad luck,we got Gandhi and nehru as politicians and that too after independence
sanik schools follow the cbse syllabus and cbse is dominant one so its baseless that anyone haven't learned about neta ji now a days its the political propoganda only.... borrowing Congress leaders who haven't got place in post independence india and place them against gandhi and nehru and sad is that who are doing so don't have the leader of their own ideology to show
@@vaibhavshukla6705 I am from cbse school and I have never read about Netaji Subhas Chandra bose's rebellion. Yes they list his name in books but that's it. Even mass m*trderers like Ali Brothers are shown as freedom fighters in cbse books. So what's your point?
We....Proud Him Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose 🇮🇳🇮🇳💪💪❤️❤️😘😘💪💪💪💪
Maybe, I was 13-14 years' old when in school we were taught about both Gandhiji and Netaji. But even at that age from the limited knowledge somehow I knew that violent Britishers needed people like Netaji and Sardar Bhagat Singh ji. I do respect Gandhiji but my love is more towards Netaji and Sardar Bhagat Singh ji. 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
We differentiate them extremists and moderates extremists is so negative connotation
It's general
A stranger is slapping you and you just give your other cheek to take another, why wouldn't he take another chance?
I actually doubt that Gandhi was even considered a threat by British
And the fact that he was made famous is just to cover the armed movements that were happening so that all indians do not revolt at one
Gandhi's contribution to India's Independence was just as much as a firefly contributes to day time light.
Such a foolish comment.....the world wouldn't have acknowledged Gandhi just just being a Firefly, and Bose himself was a Congressman before he created the Azad Hind Fauj ....the only change was the path he took. You should do a fact check (there are n number of fact checking websites) before believing any lies propagated by this good for nothing Government.
FAXXXX
+1
mc gandhi
Reality
Tell and fight for the true hero of India. To remember him, we need him everywhere in the Indian States and in our heart. Develop true patriotism for my India, my Bharat.🙏
This chapter of Indian Independence history is kept secret because the Britishers left India in the hands of Gandhi's government which dont want the Indian citizen's to question the signification of the non voilence movements and the contribution of gandhi. It's very clear that we got independence due to the azad hind fauj of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose but the gandhiji and his government wanted us to believe that we got independence only because of the gandhiji and his non voilence moments. If people come to know that Netaji bose gave us the independence then there will be no place for the so called father of Nation in the history of independent india.
Yes this is the need of the hour. Honour to the actual legends should be restored and those made unnecessary fathers should be brought down to their actual posts.
First go and learn your history and then talk about changing history. ....
@@praveenpillay4329 who said about changing history ? what's taught isn't history. History is facts which isn't being taught.
@@praveenpillay4329 What history?, manipulated propaganda written by CONgress's Marxist historians?
@@pulkitkaushik You talked about restoring. Yes, definitely, history of RSS who worked for the British should also be taught in the school....Lies propagated through WhatsApp chats or nowadays tv news is not history. Do a fact check on things before believing in them. There are n number of fact checking websites.....do it.
@@praveenpillay4329 First you go and research. Textbooks are not the books written by people who saw independence. Expand your knowledge and don't be a textbook worm. Lack of knowledge makes you write these comments 😂
If you ever want to know who was the earliest giga Chad Sigma of India just remember the name Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose
He was the most instrumental in us getting Independence and he was the one to be our Prime Minister but we all know what happened!
+1
+1
+1
@@pulkitkaushik Bot cool lagta he na ye plus 1 likhna, jese ki bot bade intellectual class ban gye ho🤡☕
@@shodhitgoyal6539 +1
You should watch more videos about Netaji especially from Anuj Dhar, Avijit Chavda and Chandrachur Ghose. You will get to know tons about the repressed history about the Independence of India.
Anuj Dhar and Chandrachur sir should be given recognition for what they have done to spread authentic history
@@Chanakya831 100%
Mahatma Gandu and Bhosdiwale chacha Nehru these both had hardly anything to do with freedom. Most of the Congress party workers were actually the bootlickers of the Britishers at that time. All they wanted was power and fame.
Not just them we Indians should also learn about the true untold history of our country..
The one thing about netaji is everyone knows him as netaji which actually means Respected leader in english, which hasn't changed yet, people love him he was the perfect personification of the rebellion/struggle/cause , to the western audience he tried every way before approaching hitler, it was his last resort.
i always love to see steph ...she is really involved and relatable.
Believe me or not... My late father used to tell me the story of Netaji..even his mystery death. I was little boy when he told me.. but surprisingly no history text book never tell us these story.. it just came to us through people to people contact..
Here is fun fact for you and @Achara @Steph Netaji didn't die back then. He lived very long almost invisible and died a few years ago. Probably lived a 100 years or so and my family people have seen and met him once and many people too say so who lived in that area he lived unknown to others
@@greatsukhad It's arguable and will remain a mystery forever
In the opening remarks by Steph Sabraw after the video, she got it absolutely right & that is precisely the reason why it is not taught but it should be taught because it is an integral part of our independence.
If Indians kept followed Gandhi then we would have still cleaning toilets in Britishers houses. Due to Netaji we won independence
+1
We would have given whole India to Pakistan and he would have asked us to keep a long fast and die in the form of non violent protests against god knows who.
Facts , like I always wondered how can non violent struggle lead to freedom when the person u r fighting against r anything but human
The goosebump making call for freedom was " Give me blood, I will give you freedom" ( Tum mujhe khhun do, mai tumhe ajadi dunga)
A little correction, the INA was formed by an indian rebel Rasbhari Bose who escaped to japan from India , he handed over the charge of the army to Netaji when Netaji came to Japan as he( Rasbihari bose) became old.
It's not taught bcz at that time everyone was not so much literate so all congressmen divert the independence toward Gandhi like we got independence just bcz NCM, QIM and many other movements but that's not true.
By the time 1944 Britishers are at upper hand so they were looking forward to rule India for next 100 years but after that what happened you all see in this video.
The point is Netaji requested Gandhi to launch civil disobedience movement at the time when world war just started bcz at that time both russia and Germany was heading toward England and on the other side japan was thrashing USA and british army in Asia but Gandhi said that we can't launch CDM at this time bcz democracy is in favour of British ( 🤔 idk which democracy he was talking about) that's why netaji leave congress and head to seek freedom alone.
As congress was no longer the party of selflessness rather it became the hunger for power so think about it, if you teach about Netaji and many other freedom fighters then how will you get the votes and how will you(congress) rule India.
Isn't it logical?
That's enough, i have more to say but i don't think people are interested in reading so many lines.
🙏
17:44 Netaji didn't know about the Holocaust then!! But when he came to know about it... He did make statements against the Nazis and did not collaborate with them!! He just went to Hitler because he thought Germany could help hin in the war against British!! He did not had to give or take anything from Hitler beyond that point!!
Neharu Gandhi were the pupet of British Empire.
+1
the famous qoute by netaji that he speaks about than speaks it in hindi without explaining it.
netaji spoke to the masses "tum muje khoon do, mein tumhein azadi dunga"
it means, "you give me your blood, and i will get u freedom"
which means struggle and fight and even lay down ur lives for the country , i will be leading and i shall make sure freedom is granted
The real hero of India Netaji Shubash Chandra Bose ki jai
Beloved and admirer of murderous totalitarian thugs everywhere, Bose ji ki jai
Anuj Dhar has dedicated his life to unravel Netaji's death mystery. React to some of his videos as well.
My grandfather was in Azad Hind Sena, My grandma who is 92 now still receives pension.
Netaji is not just a freedom fighter but the real father of nation and a emotion within people
FYI for people outside india. 25 lakhs means 2.5 million Indian soldiers on frontline in British army
I have mad respect for him... He was really unsung legend 🙏🏽
As an Indian I think it was delibratly covered up as M K Gandhi narrative was peace and harmoney and that Indians learned that way. Voilence is not the answer to everthing. we need to understand the true value of power and only a country that aqquires power thru struggle and hard work will understand the value and truness of power.
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose was a legend, is a legend and will always be one..... If it was his way we could have get the freedom with actual fighting not overnight through the radio...... This man had that capacity..... ❤️
I am from the same city where Netaji was born. Infact, we went to the same school as well. His legacy will live on ❤️
Are u from Cuttack?
@@narayanpatro4588 yup
Netaji Was Such A Man of Balance.....he had the extreme and crazy love for motherland that he was ready to do any sacrifice for its freedom but at the same time he had the qualities of a nerd diplomat to use his emotions,logic and negotiation wisely.
Netaji was a pain in ass of Brits and they could never imagine that a brown indian could sit with Adolf Hitler. We Respect and try to follow the values of Gandhiji but we keep those guys in heart who turned the RED color of this soil into DARK RED..
The Gandhi is child in front of "S C Bose"
A greatest visionary BHARATIYA leader. Have a good day.
There are also other freedom fighters like Veer Savarkar, Lala Lajpat Rai, Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, Rajguru, Rani Laxmi Bai, Mangal Pandey and many others. These heroes helped India in gaining independence from British. Salute to those heroes.
lol savarkar was poop
Now some chamcha will come and say savarkar a freedom fighter hahahaha😑.
@@shodhitgoyal6539 savarkar hinduvaadi the isliye congressi jalte hai 😂
@@vimdhayakjigulambipurwale1917 doesn't matter if someone follows congress or not.any smart perso. Who knows and understands history knows Savarkar was just a pathetic idiot and extremist.Only religious illiterates and extremists of today idolize him lol
@shodit goyal savarkar headed and supervised the manufacturing of bombs to fight against the British before his arrest.
I feel so proud when this channel picks up videos from channels like Think School and India in pixels to be following Jaby since the days of discovery😍
I hold master degree in History but i never came across any history book with so much details about INA. In almost every Indiana history book there are hardly 1 or 2 pages on INA.
On the question "Why is this not taught in our schools?"... well its because although Bose himself was a Congressman and a President at that, after him, the successors (our 1st Prime Minister Nehru) were closer to British royalty than to Indians and Bose... and Bose had ideological conflict with Gandhi too - the spiritual guru of Indian Congress. Although Bose himself used to love Gandhi dearly on a personal level. So till very recently the Indian Congress had been non-committal about discarding British theory that Bose was a terrorist. Just now, as they are facing oblivion from Indian political landscape, they are warming upto Bose
gtfo of here with your rss propaganda man 😂
I think every school teaches about SC Bose... I don't know from which school you studied 🤣🤣
@@shreysingh9273 your school taught you that azad hind fauz commanders were made to face public trials which led to public discontent and subsequently independence? great school yours..
@@snehp8426 Public discontent due to trials of Azad Hind fauj commanders did not lead to our independence. From where did you get this info??🤣🤣🤣
@@shreysingh9273 perhaps you didnt watch this video itself. he is exactly saying that. their very public trials led to indian soldiers and public discontent
When we say our modern history books are full of nehru Gandhi and congress,we are termed as bjp supporters 😀.
Netaji subhash Chandra bose❣
even bjp is supporting Gandhi more than congress
@@Chanakya831 They just support his contribution to our struggle , they dont worship or do propaganda on gandhi unlike CONgress
@@shodhitgoyal6539 which struggle? kindly enlighten me
@@Chanakya831 Gandhis charkha tactics surely did not help in india's freedom but his ideals were not bad either, it did create a sense of unity among all indians and that is no less a feat
@@shodhitgoyal6539 MKG was thrown out of train in 1893/94 and returned back to India in 1915, why it took him 21 years to return to his own country?
there is much to found about this man which can be highly uncomfortable
Savarkar, Clement Atlee and Ambedkar all acknowledged that Bose's and his INA were one of the most important factors for freedom
Big salute.... thank you for reacting on this 🙏
Already know the story of our Netaji, still watching the video because Netaji’s story gives me goose bumps even if I hear it again and again…. Jai hind!
9:47 For those who do not understand hindi
"Tum Mujhe Khoon Do, Main Tumhe Azaadi Doonga"...
Give me your blood, and I shall give you your freedom ....
That Stirring, Rallying Clarion Call that Set Millions of Indians on the path to freedom....
India's first Education Minister was Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, who was a Maulana (Islamic Theologian/Teacher) by profession. He was born in Mecca, self taught with no formal education. His father was an Afghan. Hope that answers a lot of things.
He was puppet minister of Congress party
So what he's a patriot thats why he fought for india
@@NTIS-DHARMIK nice joke 😂😂
People who are afraid of using their name on public forum 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 telling about history 😂😂😂😂😂 good joke..
what’s app se bahar niklo aur padhaai karo
Only bcz of him we are independent ❤️❤️🇮🇳🇮🇳
I share my birthday with India's independence: 15th August. As a bengali, and being born on that day, I grew up learning and reading about him. To the point that I would only research about him 24x7 at an unhealthy level.
I still keep my research going about what happened to netaji cause the claims about the plane crash is very sketchy based on shady evidence.
Once upon a time, a God gifted son of Mother India was born who is (as we never recall him as a past) Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. He was given the honorific title of 'Netaji' in Germany in 1942 by Indian Soldiers of the Indian Legion and officials of the Special Bureau for India. He was the Real Hero to fight for India's freedom. He inspired whole Indians by his encouraging speeches like "Give me blood, I will give you freedom."; " One individual may die for an idea, but that idea will, after his death, incarnate itself in a thousand lives." and many more. He is always our true hero but Nehru rule after independence spoiled his history from the world & prioritised Gandhi much more than our beloved Netaji. We love our Netaji the most and consider him as the real 'Father of Nation'. ❤
Great, he was honored by the Nazis. You should be really proud of that…🙄
@@1080lights Read books and history buddy u will be enlightened.. The enemy of my enemy is my friend.
We all talk bout Nazis and the holocaust (which is one of the most horrible thing that's part of human history)
However what Brits and indians forces serving Britishers did to indian civilians was nothing less then a genocide which has been whitewashed with the help of so called Gandhi and Nehru. He ws trying to get help from Germany Japan Russia who were against Britishers for freedom of India.
@@prachishinde5654 U look away from the education. If its all whitewasged then how come shashi Tharoor was able to present that astonishing speech in britain itself. Quit reading whatsapp and educate yourself. Britishers and nazis both were wrong. Read history and read how britishers are shown wrong.
@@prachishinde5654 Good reply bro 👍
@@Shiva-zj6od Basically, Netaji had to choose between two monsters and he chose the one which would give freedom to his motherland.
My gods :
parameshwar
Shivaji Maharaj
Subash Chandra Bose
I am Bengali staying in Pune, Maharashtra. Both Netaji and Shivaji Maharaj are emotions to me.
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi nice🙂👍
Netaji is like the dark Knight of India. He is the hero which India deserves but not the one it needs right now. Hopefully the younger generation appreciates him more!!
Well said man! 👏
It needs now if you doesn't know your history than shame on you.
I’m sure they decided to hide this part of the history because India wanted to promote itself as a peaceful and that non violence(Gandhiji’s ideology) is the right path. It feels Netaji’s and his armies sacrifice was robbed but if we see the bigger picture, India being a country with so much diversity it needed an ideology to imprint on the civilians(which if I were a leader and had to look for the bigger picture might take the step considering the circumstances).
You guys must react to Byju's 'Azadi - A Tribute To India’s Great Freedom Fighters'. They have very well summarized the major events from 1857 to 1947.
স্বাধীনতা কেউ দেয় না, অর্জন করে নিতে হয়।
- নেতাজি সুভাষ চন্দ্র বসু ❤️
Actually he didn't die in crash.... He was alive and lived his life as a Saint, people calledhim GUMNAMI BABA.
You can watch the episode dedicated to Netaji on 'The Ranveer Show' podcast
There should not be photo of only Mohandas Gandhi on indian currency,
There should be different freedom fighters and great people photos on every different note of our currency
For e.g)
Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose
Maharana Pratap
Bhagat singh
Dr.APJ Abdul Kalam
Sardar Vallabhai Patel
And many more(etc)🙏
My excitement while watching this is on another level.
Subhash chandra bose is truly father of nation. We Indians support him more than gandhiji
Checkout the movie ....... GUMNAAMI to know Netaji's life after the so called Plane Crash of 1945. Do a reaction plz....
Most of us Indians who have read a bit of history actually know this part, but simultaneously there was a lot other things happening and the school textbooks were more focussed on the other stuff
SC Bose was a visionary leader with a left wing ideology and believed that India should not immediately become a democracy after independence. For some time he believed there should be an autocracy rule coz the challenges that our country would face post independence were immense and somebody should set the things in order before we could transition to democracy.
Seeing China’s growth and India’s growth that might have been a better alternative path that our leaders could have taken.
And also he was the first person to call Gandhiji as “FAther of the Nation” despite his ideological differnces with him.
Subhas bose was never in communist mindset, he always believed in democracy, Congress on the other hand have left wing mindset.
Left wing really?😂, he was a true patriot and narionalist nothing else. Yes he did beleive that india should remain am autocracy for the first initial years to set the country in order, and i fully agree with that. With a iron fisted autocrat like netaji at the helm of india , china would not have dared attack us.
@@shodhitgoyal6539 Swami Vivekananda and Netaji would make India Officially Hindu Rastra, that would solve many conflicts a clear powerful leader is much better than bunch of weak people thinking that they can control this country , this is what happening today everyone thinks they can be PM. These were strategy of Brits they always make things worse for others.
@@shodhitgoyal6539 yes he was a person with left wing ideology as written in history books n if you want i can quote numerous sources… also he was a true patriot and nationalist as you pointed out…. We Indians really need to understand the difference between left& right ideologies …
@@Sachu785I did not see in his autobiography him mentioning himself as left leaning, but the difference is todays left is more anti national on so many topics than how left is supossed to be. In america left is patriotic, in china all are communists /capitalists but patriots of chinese national interests, in russia there is no left all are communist narionalists of mother russia only in india the communists and leftists work in anti india activities , they are mercenaries who will switch sides for money and good opportunities .
thnk u for the reaction on bose Babu I'm proud to be a Bangali 🤗
Joy bangla
if Bose came into light , Gandhi won't be more hero
"Give me blood and I will give you freedom." Quote that Steph & Achara want to know about.
2.5 million is 25 lakhs. 1 lakh is 100,000 🔥 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Gandhi's birthday is declared as national holiday in India and in all our history lessons we are taught that he's the reason that we have freedom from British but we only have a page or 2 about Netaji's army or his movement