The first tune sounds just like the intro to “Lucy in the sky with diamonds” by The Beatles lol, so that’s the familiarity that you guys are hearing. @4:09 (“Picture yourself in a boat on a river, with tangerine trees and marmalade skies”) Excellent job as usual 🤘
That part where they're literally playing the same song in different rooms with all the changes is just incredible. It must be the magic of the studio.
Listening through Rob's latest video makes this make so much more sense. I'm glad you have a great support system around you Rob and that you were able to get the help you needed.
Fr. It was tough watch knowing what one of your childhood inspirations was going through at the time after he put out his latest video. I'm glad he's doing better as of now
@@Cash_Bright39 it's pretty cool to see young musicians talk about their childhood inspirations being TH-cam Creators. My inspirations were CD's and MTV so the technological differences are crazy to me!
Major props to: *Rob* for pushing through a full day of writing/recording while jet-lagged and dealing with physical issues. *Andrew* for absolutely crushing it and bringing the energy. *Rob Ruccia* for wrangling the chaos into Pro Tools. *The camera men/women and the rest of the crew* for documenting everything and providing excellent feedback and support. I love the heart-to-heart honesty from Rob towards the end. You can really tell that his spirits lifted up a bit for the last 30-minute push. Can't beat that final countdown ending either. All around fantastic work, and thanks for sharing!
The best music in history was all written and created either dead drunk, so stoned space looked small or dead tired. Or all at the same time. So, they were in the bare minimum mindspace to do this.
I had experience with all 3 with some friends we thought we made the next Dark side of the moon. I sounded like a middle school rock band lmao@@enlightendbel
we now know rob was actually going through the crash of a bipolar episode during this which makes the fact he was able to do anything at all kind of incredible.
Hey Rob--just wanted to let you know this series of videos inspired me to do this for my bachelor party a couple years back. We had 5 band dudes and 15 other guys that have never played a lick of music in their life. It was an absolute riot. 11 songs in 3 days, most of them composed and tracked shitfaced hammered. One of the most fun things I have ever done. Thank you for making these every year!
Thanks for being vulnerable in your edit. I have to imagine it sucks to feel less than your best when you're in a place as legendary as that, but the vulnerability in the songs and the video form a piece of art that is raw, relatable, and sometimes uncomfortable - and that does a place like Abbey Road proud.
"It's so beautiful, I'm afraid you're going to damage it" is maybe the most perfect thing any human could possibly have said about the music that Rob and Andrew created in that specific moment. Y'all are so inspirational.
I love how the whole crew were practically having to beg them not to overwork that song as they often tend to do, they really heard the music and knew that the beauty in the rawness was greater than Andrew and Robs need for a "polished" song
And it should be twice as long... Had a blast! I'm really down at the moment, but you guys rock. Gotta pull my instruments out of their boxes and play. Though it reminds me of her. Cathartic? Maybe. Let's see if I can do something with the cajon I built with the kids and a cell phone. And Abby rode is hi-la-ri-ous! Rock on!
Not just art, amazing art! Watching back after watching his BP 1 video, and after knowing at what point he was at in his depression, it is remarkable how much he wrote and how much of it was good! I’ve not gone through that major of depression but I was in something like that and I could never make music that well in that time. I was just too sad to make things
@@redpig6878 I can't even imagine feeling like that. Hearing his story has put a lot into perspective for me. Rob clearly has a lifelong passion and commitment for music, and I'm going to emulate that the best I can!
Rob contributed way more on this album than he probably realised at the time. The most emotional songs on this years album were his. He created the melody for pretty raw and usually is one of my favourite FOO songs. Make it through the night has FOO written all over it and again was Rob's song. They both contributed equally on this album and it shows. You two are musical geniuses and your chemistry together is unlike any other band. Hope Rob gets well soon. Another incredible album.
Right?!? And in a way the roles reversed this time. Rob has the saddest song in Usually. And then Andrew goes hard with Dorian! This whole album sounds so much more mature! I hope whatever Rob is going through dissapears into the oblivion and we can go back go him singing about Greg.
I agree. I think Rob definitely got a bit creatively stuck at times. Like, in the last song they wrote, he was stuck in mellotron mode, when I feel like some distorted power chords would have served that song really well (accompanying the clean guitar). But I think that he still contributed really nice song-skeletons which he was simply overthinking and underestimating. The sunshine one really came alive into something fun when Andrew helped flesh it out with the backup vox and the synth. Plus, Rob's drumming provided a LOT to Andrew's songs.
If I was the producer, I'd be on my knees BEGGING them to leave "Pretty Raw" as just two instruments, no overdubs. They *absolutely* made the right call there. When your song has the crew crying in the studio, you do not change a thing.
@@KingOfTheBeezWhile I understand their thoughts of wanting to add more, the simplicity really adds to the emotion of the song and ultimately it was the best decision to leave it as it is rather than making it too busy
that moment around 45 minutes where they’re just there talking was such a nice moment and i’m so glad it was included in the video. hope you feel better soon rob
Rob, if you're reading this, I just wanna let you know that you and Andrew helped me a lot by making these videos. I really love music but often struggle with coming up with stuff, and your videos help me get rid of thoughts like "it's not good enough" and realize that not everything that I do needs to be profound, and I can just have fun making music. And genuinely, since I've discovered your channel, I started writing more. So thank you!
My mom committed suicide September 1st, 2023. We had her cremated and had her funeral on her birthday, October 2nd. On October 1st, my fiancé left me. I tried to do what my mom did, I was so broken down. On the same day, Rob wrote usually. I’ve never had a song speak to me so much, these past few months have been so hard. I saw the video he made the other day and heard that song for the first time. It made me feel not completely alone for the first time since October for one minute and fifty-four seconds. I played it on a loop after finding it on Spotify for 3 hours straight. I just laid there and cried. I hope one day I can write something as special as that song. I think about suicide every second of every day. I just want to be ok again. That song helps a tiny amount. I hope I can give the world something as beautiful as that song before I go. Thank you, Rob. Thank you for making one minute and fifty-four seconds of life worth living for me.
I cannot imagine what you're going through, but whatever you feel, I hope you are doing alright and things get better. Lean on those who are around you, even if you think you may be a burden or they wouldn't care. You are not a burden, and they care. We usually tend to be too hard on ourselves in those moments.
I'm convinced Rob X Andrew is the best collab to happen to TH-cam. The sheer quantity and quality of the art y'all have been putting out has been a major inspiration to myself and surely thousands of others. Keep doing you, boys! EDIT: Also, HUGE shoutout to Jake. The storytelling through editing in this is so thoughtful and touching. What a talented team!
Andrew is a rare creative fountain. He has that McCartney ability to write a song about anything that's both sophisticated and catchy. Rob is mostly playing support here
@@johnpeace971 Weird that you would bring negativity to one of the most uplifting recurring collabs on youtube. I don't think Andrew would appreciate you talking shit about his friend when they both work their asses off to make music for everyone to enjoy.
@@stockicide I only know Andrew from watching Rob's channel, and Rob even admit's he's creatively blocked. I said nothing disparaging, just pointed out what Rob himself noticed: he was playing supporting musician for Andrew most of the project
I like how Andrew and Rob both were on a different energy level, but they work so well together, that the process just clicked like always. It's beautiful.
Honestly, having that moment towards the end where Rob is feeling discouraged actually elevated this video so much. There's so much that goes into the creative process, and it feels so terrible when you feel like you can't or haven't contributed as much as you could have for reasons beyond your control. I've been there so many times in my life - it becomes a part of your work, and including that moment in the video shows insight and truth into what so many people go through - including musicians like Rob. Hang in there guys!!!
"ugh im so sad. I'm a multi millionaire who gets to make my living doing the thing I love and life is so ugh! I need another 6 month vacation which is something literally zero employees have the luxury of doing in the first world let alone the 3rd world which is currently getting cided but ugghh!! Im just soo sad for no reason hmmph!"
@@SuomiHamalainenYou have no clue what Rob could be going through. Sounds to me like some form of anxiety. Doesn't matter what his income is, his mental health is far important. His fame has nothing to do with this, just because he's a well known musician doesn't mean he isn't human and can't have feelings or health issues. He's a person at the end of the day and he has emotions. The fact that he is one of the most humble guys on the platform as well just makes you look even more muggy. Grow up and get some perspective. Also lose the envy.
@@SuomiHamalainen man what is wrong with you. shit happens in people's lives. im just trying to give some words of encouragement. go outside or learn to laugh or something.
When Rob started talking about his medical situation and lack of presence the last two months I started tearing up. It’s hard to hear that someone you look up to so much can be going through hell and not even know it, it’s even harder to be that exposed and open for the world to see. Thank you Rob for speaking out and bringing attention to male mental health struggles. I hope you start feeling better soon brother! Much love
"Actual sickness" Um mental health is defintally a sickness. Mental hospitals are a thing or it can cause you to have issues due to stress etc@@tjcthulhu
44:40 Andrew nodding and saying "They're harder." felt like such an important thing to say. The fact that he saw Rob struggling, gave him the space to be vulnerable about it and the gave him the validation with just those two words was inspiring. True friend moment.
This is another great offering from the guys. Whether it was the jet lag or life, this seemed more subdued than the usual chaos energy in October 1st or Sonic Boom recording sessions. Edit: Rob's transparency at 45:00 explains it. Hope you get well soon, Rob!
Man, I love Rob sharing his feelings. I'm sure I'm not the only one saying this: you are one of my favourite musicians and an inspiration to learn music. Keep the hard work Rob.
here after seeing Rob's newest video about the health issues. after knowing what he was going through and watching all that they were able to create in this, it's so beautiful and inspiring. I have been through some rough times and health issues over the past few years, but picking up my guitar and making some little melody can be so healing in those times. This whole video is so great to watch, but the moment of "Pretty raw" being developed from 31:40 onward was so moving. When Andrew comes in the with keys and they share that moment together, it is magic.
The fact that in this high stress, very limited time project, they took the time to just talk about how Rob kinda wasn't feeling it HIT. Rough patches suck, and the fact that he was so open about it and they took the time to listen and prop him up is incredible. Maybe, the video was a little lower energy, but the music is still good and they still put together something really special. That's what I love about this band, it is raw, spontaneous creativity with absolutely zero filter, for better or for worse
I feel bad for him. This is the best album they have released in my opinion though. He should not feel any shame for it. Even when feeling low he still made some amazing songs
@@BobectorGamesBobectorI’m sure in retrospect he’ll be proud of the album and tbh there was a point in the video where he started to see how good the music was
@@dylanburton4955 At the end when he's adding the drums to Usually and he just quietly goes "I really like this song" is the sweetest moment for me. It's a great track and I'm glad he knows it
Wow, to think they've only been a band for four-five days and they're already being so emotionally supportive and helpful as they create their opus. Inspirational
31:42 just wanted to bookmark the part where "pretty raw" started coming together. so glad the crew convinced them to leave that song alone. that tune is pure magic.
It broke my heart to see how discouraged you were due to your health situation, Rob. I have dealt with chronic illness for most of my life and while music is often an escape for me, illness can still steal that joy sometimes. Thoughts and prayers are going out to you, my man. You make incredible music and are an inspiration to me and so many others. Thanks for all you do.
Honestly, writing music when you’re not feeling it and dealing with health issues but still getting something of quality finished is a sign of a great musician in my opinion. Get better soon Rob! 💜
Man, after watching rob’s video on what was happening at the time, it really makes you think about why tamara was tearing up to that instrumental track
This is the one. I know y'all joked about this being the "rough album," but this album has felt the most complete of all of them. Every time they showed Rob playing "Pretty Raw" while up in the lounge, I was desperately hoping that he would bring it forward to record, easily my favorite moment on the album (and great editing on the video to foreshadow it!) And really really wonderful to see the support you were receiving from your friends, Rob. Our brains betray us sometimes, making it difficult to see the beauty we create. I hope you see just how much of an impact you've had and continue to have for so many people. Top 3 songs: Usually Pretty Raw Dorian
I cannot express how much I love that Rob and Andrew actually listen to the crew. Like, it's obvious it's their show, but they still listen to the people around them which is lovely.
17:30 the difference between FOO and the Beatles splitting up to worn on different songs is that the Beatles did it because at that point half of the time they couldn't stand to be working on the music together. Rob and Andrew can do it because they have complete trust in eachother to make something good. Even when Rob doesnt trust himself, Andrew trusts him and Rob trusts Andrew.
As someone who has recorded twice this year under the cloud of medical difficulties, Andrew just sitting and reaffirming Rob during the listening made me cry. I've been inspired year after year by both of you and you've made a really difficult stretch of time in my life so much better, thank you both.
Watching this now after the diagnosis reveal feels real different. Some things are just make way more sense than it did. It was obvious Rob wasn’t having great time but now I know what he really felt And so I want to tell you that you did an amazing job. Not just with the album but with yourself. I can’t imagine how hard it was for you to not enjoy the process and not being able to share joy with your friends while thinking you’re done. But I can say for sure you did great as you got through it, and I speak for everyone when I say we appreciate you and everything you do. Thank you for sharing you’re feelings with us. I’m here for you, all of us are Thank you Rob. I know everything’s gonna be alright
Oh man, Rob, I hope you get better soon. Whatever medical stuff you're going through, despite it you two managed to once again create an amazing album in just one day. And what's more, your videos create such an amazingly positive atmosphere within the music making community and you inspire so many people. For that I want to thank you. Best wishes from Germany
Thank you for making "Pretty Raw" instrumental. I almost cried, it's so good. On another note, listening to "Abby Rowed" is the most fun I've had since "I Left My Pants In Chicago"
despite how rob was feeling this time around, i think that "usually" is genuinely my favorite song you guys have ever put out. there's something just so gut punching about how honest it is. rob's lyrics aren't usually all that poetic or flowery but he's so incredibly effective at writing lines that just cut straight through you. as someone who basically finds meaning and purpose in creating art and music, and who's felt that horrible sense of just feeling like you're off and not getting fulfillment out of your art anymore, that song just tore me up. i appreciate his honesty and vulnerability in writing and sharing it, and i really hope his medical troubles clear up. get well soon rob, we love you.
About the 45 minute mark, I’ve had my chronic fatigue syndrome got worse over the last couple years and I really relate. “I’m sorry, I feel like I’m not energetic enough, I hoped I’d be excited more” kind of vibe is my life a lot when I’ve made plans. I know you’ve personally been vague so I’m not going to speculate, but I hope you know we support you taking the time you need for whatever’s going on.
This comment spoke to me. I've only recently faced head-on an ongoing and very long undiagnosed - now diagnosed - chronic fatigue syndrome and brain fog and I resonate with this, the way it challenges my everyday plans and it even makes me question my identity at times due to expectations both my own and other's of me. It feels impossible to get anything done at times. I wish anyone else going through it nothing but the best, your health always comes first. Do what you love, listen to the songs that charge you up, don't forget to feel the sunlight on your skin and look at the colors. You have got this, don't not give up ❤️
This will be drowned out in the thousands of comments on this but as someone who has been following you specifically for a crazy long amount of time now...This was amazing. I hope you didn't force yourself too much Rob, because the final album is honest, beautiful, fun, touching and just amazing. Hope you get better soon. This was a fantastic FOO album.
It's very heartwarming that I wasn't the only one who came back to this video after Rob talked about his issues in the latest video. We love you Rob ❤️
I had to come back to this video for one reason: to hear the greatest compliment any musician could ever receive. "It's so beautiful, I am worried you are going to damage it." As a musician, if I hear that, I would be so floored. I think I'd cry on the spot. Seriously, what other emotion could you wish to convey so perfectly!
32:30 - Geez goosebumps just from the feeling of discovery and beauty. Quite teary eyed actually. 45:00 - Rob, man. Please don't do yourself down. You've both managed to come up with amazing stuff this time around. Nobody can be 100% all the time. 48:00 - Man, tearing up again. This is just pure expression and a wonderful moment.
When Tamara looks up at Rob while they listen to usually at the end of the day, I straight up cried. The love and caring in her eyes just hits me like a truck.
Best album yet. And "Usually" is my favorite First of October song AND it has the deepest line ever, "Usually this would be setting me free." What a gut punch! It goes to show that music sprouts even in pain.
Anybody who expresses themselves artistically as much as Rob did this during this session is an incredible artist. I know he felt like shit and like the creativity wasn’t flowing, but there are two beautiful and expressive tunes on this album that are ALL HIM. He should be proud and I wish him all the best. Often the songs become kind of humorous under the time pressure of this challenge, but he allowed his soul to speak, and I love him for that.
This may sound strange, but I think this album is the most beautiful, brutally honest and perfectly imperfect album you two have written. It really hits me on an emotional level. Thanks Andrew and Rob for keeping it real. ❤
I really love that you guys left in that lengthy discussion of what Rob's going through. You could have just cut it out, but giving us a place in that room is really special (and super Peter Jackson "Get Back" vibes as well). Don't know what it means to Rob to know there's people around the globe rooting for him and keeping him in our minds... but there is.
47:34 I teared up a lot here. Rob sitting there feeling like he hasn't done anything meanwhile Andrew is taking in this awesome song his friend made. Then the pan to Tamara tearing up a bit. It's just such a solid capture of what it's like to be in that depressive mental state where you just feel like you can't do anything right, meanwhile the people who love are looking on trying to remind you of how amazing you really are. I'm really glad Rob was able to get better and I'm thankful he was willing to be vulnerable and tell people about all he went through.
Usually really hits hard, it's so honest and emotional, it's awful to see you struggle with something you're so good at and so clearly love. i hope you get better soon Rob. you're a massive inspiration to me.
Rob i cannot stress this enough, what you accomplished in this record is just awe inspiring. Even with having done it before, even with being sick, you still push through. You are incredibly strong. what you accomplish here is such a catalyst for many, many people to write their own songs. We love you dearly.
I've been going through a lot of stuff in 2023 and I gotta say, "Usually" is my favourite song from this album. You killed it Rob, thank you for writing that, and please remember that we all love you. I wish you all the best.
44:54 Rob praying for you buddy. Your videos have brought much joy to me and many others. Speedy recovery for whatever you’re going through. I appreciate you 👍 🎸
This series has taught me more about being a musician and making music than many years of standard musical education. Thanks you guys for all the inspiration over the years!
Whatever you are going through, Rob, I sincerely wish you the best and that you can overcome all this well! Thank you so much for doing this great project again despite everything! And please don't stress, take all the time you need to get back on your feet, we are always behind you! Lots of love from Germany
Although Andrew and Rob were the sole musicians, it should be noted how much the people around them influenced the final product. This was truly a collective effort.
I mean, Rob Ruccia is basically the third member of the band proper, he's so involved and working his ass off in every one of these. Jake, Tamara, and the other technical/film staff are also wonderful and great consultants and cheerleaders
It seems every year the crew is more involved in the process and it's a beautiful thing. Their input has tons of value. I love the synergy of this whole group.
To me Dorian has a double meaning. I get it’s about Andrew’s kid, but musician Ben Kweller just lost his 16 year old son also named Dorian in a car accident this year. The lyric Andrew screams, to be without you sent chills through my body cause his son who passed was the first thing I thought of.
Here, about 11 months later, Pretty Raw is one of the beautiful songs ever. It is perfect. Rob recently talked about the mental health situation he was going through, especially during this day. In relation to this, during the past year I have occasionally put this song on repeat when I needed help feel my feelings during my own rough times. Also, this is not the first song he’s written that has helped me. Basically what I’m saying is thank you Rob (and Andrew) for continuing sharing what you choose to share. ❤
Keep in mind he made that video after the fact. So, he's had time to reflect on all of this. He seems to be in better shape now, and I do wish him the best with bouncing back from this with better tools and ways to deal with this if this happens again in the future (God willing, never again). But hey, a fresh perspective means a journey into knowing more about mental health and mental health advocacy; It's great to have another force in the world bringing attention to mental illness when so many folks aren't heard.
I commented on Andrew's channel that this album sounded more polished than the previous ones. It's so wild to see the process was MORE chaotic than normal. And Rob, you're an amazing musician and a fantastic top-tier human. I hope you recover quickly from what ails you; please hear us when we say, and know that, however diminished you may feel, your output is still legendary and inspiring.
Thank you for the honest depiction of your experience Rob. This years Album in a Day wasn't fun to watch, it was raw and emotional and had a lasting effect that lead to a really creative afternoon of song writing for me. I watched it on a day when I had every reason to feel happy, but didn't, and this video had a really strong positive impact. The 2023 Album in a Day was creatively inspiring and helped me write a song I'm really proud of! Thank you!
Since Rob put out his video about what health issue he had going on, I have a whole new appreciation for what everyone did and the dynamic they had while doing it. Really cool stuff!
Really want to give Rob a big hug after this. I know he'll get through it, but it's so hard when your brain gets caught in a bad place. For what it's worth I really loved all these songs
I’m so excited to watch this. Last Year was my favorite album so far! Fingers crossed this one tops it Edit: Now that I’m at the end of the video I can confirm this is my new favorite FoO Album! I know Rob wasn’t feeling amazing and was super down on himself for feeling like he wasn’t able to write, but as someone who has chronic pain, and has been struggling with mental health stuff for the last few years, Usually is my favorite song. It makes me cry in the best way. It’s the most relatable song I’ve ever heard. This album has the perfect balance between the silliness and joy that we come to expect from First of October but also it is so real and vulnerable too. Plus I finally got a purely instrumental song! Hope Rob is able to recover from his illness and feel better!
The vulnerability Rob lets out is captivating. Also Tamara's frank response to the instrumental piece, which I admit resonates with me similarly, is just a joy. It's wonderful to witness people being honest.
It's such a beautiful thing to watch two musicians at the top of their craft do their thing. It's like the two of you know a secret language that speaks to our souls.
As a beginner musician, these videos are so inspiring. Yalls raw creativity is so palpable. Not to mention the fantastic production of these videos, the tight edit, and clear vision. Amazing.
Just wanted to put the album titles we didn't use here for posterity:
Here Comes The Fun
October's Garden
Rob, Rob, Andrew and Greg
Abby Rowed
The first tune sounds just like the intro to “Lucy in the sky with diamonds” by The Beatles lol, so that’s the familiarity that you guys are hearing. @4:09 (“Picture yourself in a boat on a river, with tangerine trees and marmalade skies”)
Excellent job as usual 🤘
What is rob rob andrew and greg based on?
@@esa6321their names, Rob is twice because their producers name is Rob too, and then Greg is a reference to their song "Greg!" from their 2021 album
@@noahcasino I mean like what beatles song, because all of the other songs are based on beatles songs, but Rob, Rob, Andrew and Greg is unknown to me.
It's October so ... The fright album
That part where they're literally playing the same song in different rooms with all the changes is just incredible. It must be the magic of the studio.
It's beautiful in a way
These guys are synced up like twins its so cool
Sometimes I would humorously say that things perfectly aligned for something to happen, but in this case, things literally did perfectly align.
I'm pretty sure the producer mentions that the lounge has a mic, and it seems like they have some monitors up there.
literally brought a tear to my eye
Listening through Rob's latest video makes this make so much more sense. I'm glad you have a great support system around you Rob and that you were able to get the help you needed.
Fr. It was tough watch knowing what one of your childhood inspirations was going through at the time after he put out his latest video. I'm glad he's doing better as of now
Context makes things so much more relatable.
Well said! Rob's willingness to be so open about his mental health is inspiring, and puts the music into a new perspective.
@@Cash_Bright39 it's pretty cool to see young musicians talk about their childhood inspirations being TH-cam Creators. My inspirations were CD's and MTV so the technological differences are crazy to me!
Major props to:
*Rob* for pushing through a full day of writing/recording while jet-lagged and dealing with physical issues.
*Andrew* for absolutely crushing it and bringing the energy.
*Rob Ruccia* for wrangling the chaos into Pro Tools.
*The camera men/women and the rest of the crew* for documenting everything and providing excellent feedback and support.
I love the heart-to-heart honesty from Rob towards the end. You can really tell that his spirits lifted up a bit for the last 30-minute push. Can't beat that final countdown ending either. All around fantastic work, and thanks for sharing!
The best music in history was all written and created either dead drunk, so stoned space looked small or dead tired.
Or all at the same time.
So, they were in the bare minimum mindspace to do this.
I had experience with all 3 with some friends we thought we made the next Dark side of the moon. I sounded like a middle school rock band lmao@@enlightendbel
we now know rob was actually going through the crash of a bipolar episode during this which makes the fact he was able to do anything at all kind of incredible.
Man why did this made me tear up 😢 😂
Hey Rob--just wanted to let you know this series of videos inspired me to do this for my bachelor party a couple years back. We had 5 band dudes and 15 other guys that have never played a lick of music in their life. It was an absolute riot. 11 songs in 3 days, most of them composed and tracked shitfaced hammered. One of the most fun things I have ever done. Thank you for making these every year!
How did it turn out? Did you guys manage some coherent songs? Awesome idea
Post it
would love to hear it!!
Wish I had that many friends lol
I want to hear it!
Thanks for being vulnerable in your edit.
I have to imagine it sucks to feel less than your best when you're in a place as legendary as that, but the vulnerability in the songs and the video form a piece of art that is raw, relatable, and sometimes uncomfortable - and that does a place like Abbey Road proud.
I totally agree, I loved the littel quieter moments. Also, selfishly as a fan their exhaustion may have made the best October1 album yet haha
@@space_1073 quite literally their White Album
"It's so beautiful, I'm afraid you're going to damage it" is maybe the most perfect thing any human could possibly have said about the music that Rob and Andrew created in that specific moment. Y'all are so inspirational.
I love how the whole crew were practically having to beg them not to overwork that song as they often tend to do, they really heard the music and knew that the beauty in the rawness was greater than Andrew and Robs need for a "polished" song
And it should be twice as long...
Had a blast!
I'm really down at the moment, but you guys rock. Gotta pull my instruments out of their boxes and play.
Though it reminds me of her.
Cathartic? Maybe.
Let's see if I can do something with the cajon I built with the kids and a cell phone.
And Abby rode is hi-la-ri-ous! Rock on!
Anyone know what kind of guitarlele that was? I didn't even know that was a thing until this video. Now i want one.
@@AchillesWrath1 Yamaha do one for about £75 - worth every penny.
The more I think about it, it's probably one of the most beautiful compliments I have ever heard
That hug break at 9:39 hits different after understanding what rob was going through
The way Rob still manages to make art despite being at his worst is super inspiring. I love what y'all do!
Not just art, amazing art! Watching back after watching his BP 1 video, and after knowing at what point he was at in his depression, it is remarkable how much he wrote and how much of it was good! I’ve not gone through that major of depression but I was in something like that and I could never make music that well in that time. I was just too sad to make things
@@redpig6878 I can't even imagine feeling like that. Hearing his story has put a lot into perspective for me. Rob clearly has a lifelong passion and commitment for music, and I'm going to emulate that the best I can!
@@runforyourstars3600 pretty raw is a classic
Rob contributed way more on this album than he probably realised at the time. The most emotional songs on this years album were his. He created the melody for pretty raw and usually is one of my favourite FOO songs. Make it through the night has FOO written all over it and again was Rob's song. They both contributed equally on this album and it shows. You two are musical geniuses and your chemistry together is unlike any other band. Hope Rob gets well soon. Another incredible album.
Right?!? And in a way the roles reversed this time. Rob has the saddest song in Usually. And then Andrew goes hard with Dorian! This whole album sounds so much more mature! I hope whatever Rob is going through dissapears into the oblivion and we can go back go him singing about Greg.
I agree. I think Rob definitely got a bit creatively stuck at times. Like, in the last song they wrote, he was stuck in mellotron mode, when I feel like some distorted power chords would have served that song really well (accompanying the clean guitar).
But I think that he still contributed really nice song-skeletons which he was simply overthinking and underestimating. The sunshine one really came alive into something fun when Andrew helped flesh it out with the backup vox and the synth.
Plus, Rob's drumming provided a LOT to Andrew's songs.
If I was the producer, I'd be on my knees BEGGING them to leave "Pretty Raw" as just two instruments, no overdubs. They *absolutely* made the right call there. When your song has the crew crying in the studio, you do not change a thing.
Nah let them cook
timestamp ?
No way, I was super excited to hear Rob sing a great sad melody over it.
Around 32:00
@@KingOfTheBeezWhile I understand their thoughts of wanting to add more, the simplicity really adds to the emotion of the song and ultimately it was the best decision to leave it as it is rather than making it too busy
that moment around 45 minutes where they’re just there talking was such a nice moment and i’m so glad it was included in the video. hope you feel better soon rob
Rob, if you're reading this, I just wanna let you know that you and Andrew helped me a lot by making these videos. I really love music but often struggle with coming up with stuff, and your videos help me get rid of thoughts like "it's not good enough" and realize that not everything that I do needs to be profound, and I can just have fun making music. And genuinely, since I've discovered your channel, I started writing more. So thank you!
Yeah, just do it!
I 100% relate to this! These videos always inspire me to go create 😊
Man I feel your point, Have been doing pieces unfinished ideas for 20 years just because of this blaming myself thoughts.
My mom committed suicide September 1st, 2023. We had her cremated and had her funeral on her birthday, October 2nd. On October 1st, my fiancé left me. I tried to do what my mom did, I was so broken down. On the same day, Rob wrote usually. I’ve never had a song speak to me so much, these past few months have been so hard. I saw the video he made the other day and heard that song for the first time. It made me feel not completely alone for the first time since October for one minute and fifty-four seconds. I played it on a loop after finding it on Spotify for 3 hours straight. I just laid there and cried. I hope one day I can write something as special as that song. I think about suicide every second of every day. I just want to be ok again. That song helps a tiny amount. I hope I can give the world something as beautiful as that song before I go. Thank you, Rob. Thank you for making one minute and fifty-four seconds of life worth living for me.
I cannot imagine what you're going through, but whatever you feel, I hope you are doing alright and things get better. Lean on those who are around you, even if you think you may be a burden or they wouldn't care. You are not a burden, and they care. We usually tend to be too hard on ourselves in those moments.
I'm convinced Rob X Andrew is the best collab to happen to TH-cam. The sheer quantity and quality of the art y'all have been putting out has been a major inspiration to myself and surely thousands of others. Keep doing you, boys!
EDIT: Also, HUGE shoutout to Jake. The storytelling through editing in this is so thoughtful and touching. What a talented team!
Andrew is a rare creative fountain. He has that McCartney ability to write a song about anything that's both sophisticated and catchy. Rob is mostly playing support here
@@johnpeace971 Weird that you would bring negativity to one of the most uplifting recurring collabs on youtube. I don't think Andrew would appreciate you talking shit about his friend when they both work their asses off to make music for everyone to enjoy.
@@stockicide I only know Andrew from watching Rob's channel, and Rob even admit's he's creatively blocked. I said nothing disparaging, just pointed out what Rob himself noticed: he was playing supporting musician for Andrew most of the project
I like how Andrew and Rob both were on a different energy level, but they work so well together, that the process just clicked like always. It's beautiful.
Honestly, having that moment towards the end where Rob is feeling discouraged actually elevated this video so much. There's so much that goes into the creative process, and it feels so terrible when you feel like you can't or haven't contributed as much as you could have for reasons beyond your control. I've been there so many times in my life - it becomes a part of your work, and including that moment in the video shows insight and truth into what so many people go through - including musicians like Rob. Hang in there guys!!!
"ugh im so sad. I'm a multi millionaire who gets to make my living doing the thing I love and life is so ugh! I need another 6 month vacation which is something literally zero employees have the luxury of doing in the first world let alone the 3rd world which is currently getting cided but ugghh!! Im just soo sad for no reason hmmph!"
I don’t think music youtubers are millionaries
@@SuomiHamalainenYou have no clue what Rob could be going through. Sounds to me like some form of anxiety. Doesn't matter what his income is, his mental health is far important. His fame has nothing to do with this, just because he's a well known musician doesn't mean he isn't human and can't have feelings or health issues. He's a person at the end of the day and he has emotions. The fact that he is one of the most humble guys on the platform as well just makes you look even more muggy. Grow up and get some perspective. Also lose the envy.
@@penguinexpress12 even more popular bands arent making much. highly doubt rob is a millionaire, let alone a multi-millionaire
@@SuomiHamalainen man what is wrong with you. shit happens in people's lives. im just trying to give some words of encouragement. go outside or learn to laugh or something.
When Rob started talking about his medical situation and lack of presence the last two months I started tearing up. It’s hard to hear that someone you look up to so much can be going through hell and not even know it, it’s even harder to be that exposed and open for the world to see. Thank you Rob for speaking out and bringing attention to male mental health struggles. I hope you start feeling better soon brother! Much love
it might be an actual sickness. he said he went to the hospital
Men's mental health is important, but he's talking about a physical sickness that he has.
"Actual sickness" Um mental health is defintally a sickness. Mental hospitals are a thing or it can cause you to have issues due to stress etc@@tjcthulhu
@@twojointsjay7330it appears that was not the case based on the new videos context
This makes so much more sense after watching Robs BP 1 vid. I’m really happy he got through this stuff.
44:40 Andrew nodding and saying "They're harder." felt like such an important thing to say. The fact that he saw Rob struggling, gave him the space to be vulnerable about it and the gave him the validation with just those two words was inspiring. True friend moment.
he said "it's been harder?" as a rhetorical question
lmao it's not that deep man
@@x_tal. 😭
+
This is another great offering from the guys. Whether it was the jet lag or life, this seemed more subdued than the usual chaos energy in October 1st or Sonic Boom recording sessions.
Edit: Rob's transparency at 45:00 explains it. Hope you get well soon, Rob!
Man, I love Rob sharing his feelings. I'm sure I'm not the only one saying this: you are one of my favourite musicians and an inspiration to learn music. Keep the hard work Rob.
The way you guys supported each other even when tired, frustrated, and discouraged was a privilege to watch. Thank you for another great album!
Whole new level of respect for everyone there.
here after seeing Rob's newest video about the health issues. after knowing what he was going through and watching all that they were able to create in this, it's so beautiful and inspiring. I have been through some rough times and health issues over the past few years, but picking up my guitar and making some little melody can be so healing in those times. This whole video is so great to watch, but the moment of "Pretty raw" being developed from 31:40 onward was so moving. When Andrew comes in the with keys and they share that moment together, it is magic.
And that is the moment where they stop working separately. Was such a nice moment.
The fact that in this high stress, very limited time project, they took the time to just talk about how Rob kinda wasn't feeling it HIT. Rough patches suck, and the fact that he was so open about it and they took the time to listen and prop him up is incredible. Maybe, the video was a little lower energy, but the music is still good and they still put together something really special. That's what I love about this band, it is raw, spontaneous creativity with absolutely zero filter, for better or for worse
I feel bad for him. This is the best album they have released in my opinion though. He should not feel any shame for it. Even when feeling low he still made some amazing songs
@@BobectorGamesBobectorI’m sure in retrospect he’ll be proud of the album and tbh there was a point in the video where he started to see how good the music was
@@dylanburton4955 At the end when he's adding the drums to Usually and he just quietly goes "I really like this song" is the sweetest moment for me. It's a great track and I'm glad he knows it
❤❤❤ wishing Rob the best in overcoming it
The amount of talent in that room is insane. You and Andrew and engineer Rob are on just a whole different level of excellence, year-after-year.
100% agree - just in awe of the range of skills, fluidity, crazy creativity and synchronicity between these 3.
All of Rob’s contributions were amazing and I hope that he knows that and doesn’t let it get to him!
16:28 just goes to show how incredibly synched these two are. How similar their wavelengths are. Finding friends like them is a BLESSING!
Wow, to think they've only been a band for four-five days and they're already being so emotionally supportive and helpful as they create their opus. Inspirational
31:42
just wanted to bookmark the part where "pretty raw" started coming together. so glad the crew convinced them to leave that song alone. that tune is pure magic.
I am SO glad they left it alone. It was flawless.
Actually at 23:48 he plays a bit of it
I wish we could've seen what the chefs were cooking up. Lots of potential lost
@@KingOfTheBeez L take
@@KingOfTheBeezNah, the track would have ended up been unnecessarily busy and is the one song where they didn’t need to add a bunch more instruments
It broke my heart to see how discouraged you were due to your health situation, Rob. I have dealt with chronic illness for most of my life and while music is often an escape for me, illness can still steal that joy sometimes. Thoughts and prayers are going out to you, my man. You make incredible music and are an inspiration to me and so many others. Thanks for all you do.
Honestly, writing music when you’re not feeling it and dealing with health issues but still getting something of quality finished is a sign of a great musician in my opinion. Get better soon Rob! 💜
33:00 Big hugs to Tamara tearing up. And thanks for keeping Rob safe through all of what he’s been going through.
Man, after watching rob’s video on what was happening at the time, it really makes you think about why tamara was tearing up to that instrumental track
51:46 There's something so wholesome and pure about the way Rob says, "I like this song. I like it."
To see how far you two have gone is absolutely amazing, I love First Of October
OMG every time FOO gets together it saves my whole year❤❤❤❤❤
Wait is the FOO that Dave Grohl is Fighting! ?
@@timington87
F. First
O. Of
O. October
@@timington87He is probably jealous that he hasn't ever created an entire album in one day...
@@InventorZahranwait, so maybe next year they can record the FOO album on the Foo's "Studio 606"?
@@ThunderExpress Yes, record the FOO on the Foo!
What's next? Playing Strad (from the Minecraft soundtrack) on a Stradivarius?
This is the one. I know y'all joked about this being the "rough album," but this album has felt the most complete of all of them.
Every time they showed Rob playing "Pretty Raw" while up in the lounge, I was desperately hoping that he would bring it forward to record, easily my favorite moment on the album (and great editing on the video to foreshadow it!)
And really really wonderful to see the support you were receiving from your friends, Rob. Our brains betray us sometimes, making it difficult to see the beauty we create. I hope you see just how much of an impact you've had and continue to have for so many people.
Top 3 songs:
Usually
Pretty Raw
Dorian
I cannot express how much I love that Rob and Andrew actually listen to the crew. Like, it's obvious it's their show, but they still listen to the people around them which is lovely.
17:30 the difference between FOO and the Beatles splitting up to worn on different songs is that the Beatles did it because at that point half of the time they couldn't stand to be working on the music together.
Rob and Andrew can do it because they have complete trust in eachother to make something good. Even when Rob doesnt trust himself, Andrew trusts him and Rob trusts Andrew.
Rob saying he felt like he didn't do much even though they just recorded an entire album in a day hit me right in the feels.
It’s very relateable, I’ve had the same thoughts when making music with others
As someone who has recorded twice this year under the cloud of medical difficulties, Andrew just sitting and reaffirming Rob during the listening made me cry. I've been inspired year after year by both of you and you've made a really difficult stretch of time in my life so much better, thank you both.
Watching this now after the diagnosis reveal feels real different. Some things are just make way more sense than it did. It was obvious Rob wasn’t having great time but now I know what he really felt
And so I want to tell you that you did an amazing job. Not just with the album but with yourself. I can’t imagine how hard it was for you to not enjoy the process and not being able to share joy with your friends while thinking you’re done. But I can say for sure you did great as you got through it, and I speak for everyone when I say we appreciate you and everything you do. Thank you for sharing you’re feelings with us. I’m here for you, all of us are
Thank you Rob. I know everything’s gonna be alright
You recorded a WHOLE ALBUM in a DAY in ABBEY ROAD STUDIOS. Saying you didn’t do much is an INSANE UNDERSTATEMENT
Oh man, Rob, I hope you get better soon. Whatever medical stuff you're going through, despite it you two managed to once again create an amazing album in just one day. And what's more, your videos create such an amazingly positive atmosphere within the music making community and you inspire so many people. For that I want to thank you. Best wishes from Germany
Thank you for making "Pretty Raw" instrumental. I almost cried, it's so good.
On another note, listening to "Abby Rowed" is the most fun I've had since "I Left My Pants In Chicago"
despite how rob was feeling this time around, i think that "usually" is genuinely my favorite song you guys have ever put out. there's something just so gut punching about how honest it is. rob's lyrics aren't usually all that poetic or flowery but he's so incredibly effective at writing lines that just cut straight through you. as someone who basically finds meaning and purpose in creating art and music, and who's felt that horrible sense of just feeling like you're off and not getting fulfillment out of your art anymore, that song just tore me up. i appreciate his honesty and vulnerability in writing and sharing it, and i really hope his medical troubles clear up. get well soon rob, we love you.
His instinct for speeding the song up during the interludes was right on.
Everytime he breaths in he feels pain in his chest from sadness. I've been there, i am so happy you got through this, you are loved.
Watching this after Robs newest video is so eye-opening to how important mental health is.
I live with mental health challenges. Some months are impossible
@@chrisparker5278 And despite the impossibility, you're still here. You got this.
About the 45 minute mark, I’ve had my chronic fatigue syndrome got worse over the last couple years and I really relate. “I’m sorry, I feel like I’m not energetic enough, I hoped I’d be excited more” kind of vibe is my life a lot when I’ve made plans. I know you’ve personally been vague so I’m not going to speculate, but I hope you know we support you taking the time you need for whatever’s going on.
This comment spoke to me. I've only recently faced head-on an ongoing and very long undiagnosed - now diagnosed - chronic fatigue syndrome and brain fog and I resonate with this, the way it challenges my everyday plans and it even makes me question my identity at times due to expectations both my own and other's of me. It feels impossible to get anything done at times. I wish anyone else going through it nothing but the best, your health always comes first. Do what you love, listen to the songs that charge you up, don't forget to feel the sunlight on your skin and look at the colors. You have got this, don't not give up ❤️
With how much Andrew focuses on synths and production, it's so easy to forget that he's a good guitar player.
His whammy pedal solo on one of the other FOO albums was insane
I’ve been waiting so long for this. I love it. Thank you sir Rob and Sir Andrew for yet another record.
It's a little-known fact that playing an awesome set at Abbey Road Studios makes you officially knighted.
By far the most cohesive first of October album. Sorry to see you so down Rob. Commendable tenacity to power through. Much love
This will be drowned out in the thousands of comments on this but as someone who has been following you specifically for a crazy long amount of time now...This was amazing. I hope you didn't force yourself too much Rob, because the final album is honest, beautiful, fun, touching and just amazing. Hope you get better soon. This was a fantastic FOO album.
you just shot me back to 2012, when his vlogs were kicking up
Credit to the lady exuding such positive energy and light all the way through without ever being annoying. She's a keeper!
Who is it
@@shable1436 If you're talking about the one in the very brightly colored outfit her name is Sophie and she runs Rob's social media.
@@LeonardChurch33 and the other woman with dark hair and the blue top is Rob's girlfriend/wife, I'm spacing out on the name at the moment
Yes and her outfit was so cool! Gotta bring some psychedelic color to Abbey Road of all places 🥹
@@penguinpower314 Tamara Chambers, his wife
Rob, Andrew, thank you guys for being YOU. Doing this project every year is such a treat for us, you guys are the best!
This is fantastic! Abby Rowed, Whitney Cheered! 🎉
Cameron weird
And Briwu loved!
davedave commented 🎉
Sophie cried
Clever!
It's very heartwarming that I wasn't the only one who came back to this video after Rob talked about his issues in the latest video.
We love you Rob ❤️
I had to come back to this video for one reason: to hear the greatest compliment any musician could ever receive. "It's so beautiful, I am worried you are going to damage it." As a musician, if I hear that, I would be so floored. I think I'd cry on the spot. Seriously, what other emotion could you wish to convey so perfectly!
32:30 - Geez goosebumps just from the feeling of discovery and beauty. Quite teary eyed actually.
45:00 - Rob, man. Please don't do yourself down. You've both managed to come up with amazing stuff this time around. Nobody can be 100% all the time.
48:00 - Man, tearing up again. This is just pure expression and a wonderful moment.
When Tamara looks up at Rob while they listen to usually at the end of the day, I straight up cried. The love and caring in her eyes just hits me like a truck.
Best album yet. And "Usually" is my favorite First of October song AND it has the deepest line ever, "Usually this would be setting me free." What a gut punch! It goes to show that music sprouts even in pain.
Anybody who expresses themselves artistically as much as Rob did this during this session is an incredible artist. I know he felt like shit and like the creativity wasn’t flowing, but there are two beautiful and expressive tunes on this album that are ALL HIM. He should be proud and I wish him all the best. Often the songs become kind of humorous under the time pressure of this challenge, but he allowed his soul to speak, and I love him for that.
Coming back after watching the video about Rob's bipolar makes everything here hit so much harder
Shame you're feeling unwell/were feeling unwell at the time, Rob. You pulled through like a champ, I think you wrote some amazing songs!
This may sound strange, but I think this album is the most beautiful, brutally honest and perfectly imperfect album you two have written. It really hits me on an emotional level. Thanks Andrew and Rob for keeping it real. ❤
I really love that you guys left in that lengthy discussion of what Rob's going through. You could have just cut it out, but giving us a place in that room is really special (and super Peter Jackson "Get Back" vibes as well).
Don't know what it means to Rob to know there's people around the globe rooting for him and keeping him in our minds... but there is.
47:34 I teared up a lot here. Rob sitting there feeling like he hasn't done anything meanwhile Andrew is taking in this awesome song his friend made. Then the pan to Tamara tearing up a bit. It's just such a solid capture of what it's like to be in that depressive mental state where you just feel like you can't do anything right, meanwhile the people who love are looking on trying to remind you of how amazing you really are. I'm really glad Rob was able to get better and I'm thankful he was willing to be vulnerable and tell people about all he went through.
I almost teared up listening to Andrew's response on Rob's confession.
Every man needs an Andrew in their life.
Andrew, Rob and the whole team are so badass for pulling this off every year. Plus with Sonic Boom these days we're just so spoiled! Love you guys!
Usually really hits hard, it's so honest and emotional, it's awful to see you struggle with something you're so good at and so clearly love. i hope you get better soon Rob. you're a massive inspiration to me.
Rob i cannot stress this enough, what you accomplished in this record is just awe inspiring. Even with having done it before, even with being sick, you still push through. You are incredibly strong. what you accomplish here is such a catalyst for many, many people to write their own songs. We love you dearly.
I've been going through a lot of stuff in 2023 and I gotta say, "Usually" is my favourite song from this album. You killed it Rob, thank you for writing that, and please remember that we all love you. I wish you all the best.
44:54 Rob praying for you buddy. Your videos have brought much joy to me and many others. Speedy recovery for whatever you’re going through. I appreciate you 👍 🎸
This series has taught me more about being a musician and making music than many years of standard musical education. Thanks you guys for all the inspiration over the years!
Rob, it's ok not to be over-excited all the time, you brought an unexpected approach this year and it was very good!
*WE LOVE YOU.*
we love you rob
Whatever you are going through, Rob, I sincerely wish you the best and that you can overcome all this well! Thank you so much for doing this great project again despite everything! And please don't stress, take all the time you need to get back on your feet, we are always behind you!
Lots of love from Germany
Although Andrew and Rob were the sole musicians, it should be noted how much the people around them influenced the final product. This was truly a collective effort.
I mean, Rob Ruccia is basically the third member of the band proper, he's so involved and working his ass off in every one of these. Jake, Tamara, and the other technical/film staff are also wonderful and great consultants and cheerleaders
Dude, the crew coming in clutch with the lyrics help. I want a crew tunes episode, let them pull the strings while you guys play!
It seems every year the crew is more involved in the process and it's a beautiful thing. Their input has tons of value. I love the synergy of this whole group.
Truly, FOO has at least 6 members
To me Dorian has a double meaning. I get it’s about Andrew’s kid, but musician Ben Kweller just lost his 16 year old son also named Dorian in a car accident this year. The lyric Andrew screams, to be without you sent chills through my body cause his son who passed was the first thing I thought of.
Oh man, that really puts the song in a whole different context. That is so tragic.
I hope whatever medical thing Rob's going through turns out okay :/
What do you mean?
@@joshdame9623 He mentions around the 15-minute mark he hasn't played because he took some time for himself and medical stuff
Ball cancer from the massive riffs that shake the balls for the past 20 some years...
Probably. I'm not a lawyer.
@@DustinPlatt Don't say that, you could be a lawyer.
45:00@@joshdame9623
Here, about 11 months later, Pretty Raw is one of the beautiful songs ever. It is perfect. Rob recently talked about the mental health situation he was going through, especially during this day. In relation to this, during the past year I have occasionally put this song on repeat when I needed help feel my feelings during my own rough times. Also, this is not the first song he’s written that has helped me. Basically what I’m saying is thank you Rob (and Andrew) for continuing sharing what you choose to share. ❤
watching this after robs new video gives me a different view of this. hope he’s alright
Yeah same
Keep in mind he made that video after the fact. So, he's had time to reflect on all of this. He seems to be in better shape now, and I do wish him the best with bouncing back from this with better tools and ways to deal with this if this happens again in the future (God willing, never again). But hey, a fresh perspective means a journey into knowing more about mental health and mental health advocacy; It's great to have another force in the world bringing attention to mental illness when so many folks aren't heard.
Man, I really hope Rob and Andrew are okay. Both are dealing with a lot and still gave us these songs. Really incredible.
I commented on Andrew's channel that this album sounded more polished than the previous ones. It's so wild to see the process was MORE chaotic than normal.
And Rob, you're an amazing musician and a fantastic top-tier human. I hope you recover quickly from what ails you; please hear us when we say, and know that, however diminished you may feel, your output is still legendary and inspiring.
More chaos for a more polished album is just the magic of the Beatles permeating the studio.
Thank you for the honest depiction of your experience Rob. This years Album in a Day wasn't fun to watch, it was raw and emotional and had a lasting effect that lead to a really creative afternoon of song writing for me. I watched it on a day when I had every reason to feel happy, but didn't, and this video had a really strong positive impact.
The 2023 Album in a Day was creatively inspiring and helped me write a song I'm really proud of! Thank you!
Since Rob put out his video about what health issue he had going on, I have a whole new appreciation for what everyone did and the dynamic they had while doing it. Really cool stuff!
Really want to give Rob a big hug after this. I know he'll get through it, but it's so hard when your brain gets caught in a bad place. For what it's worth I really loved all these songs
Hug break
Being a massive Beatles fan, this is such a amazing treat!
I’m so excited to watch this. Last Year was my favorite album so far! Fingers crossed this one tops it
Edit: Now that I’m at the end of the video I can confirm this is my new favorite FoO Album! I know Rob wasn’t feeling amazing and was super down on himself for feeling like he wasn’t able to write, but as someone who has chronic pain, and has been struggling with mental health stuff for the last few years, Usually is my favorite song. It makes me cry in the best way. It’s the most relatable song I’ve ever heard.
This album has the perfect balance between the silliness and joy that we come to expect from First of October but also it is so real and vulnerable too. Plus I finally got a purely instrumental song!
Hope Rob is able to recover from his illness and feel better!
Even if you dont feel it in the moment, the music you guys put out means a lot. You bring a great gift here for a lot of people
Rob using his signature guitar in this studio with the Beatles instruments on the tracks too is a flex
The vulnerability Rob lets out is captivating. Also Tamara's frank response to the instrumental piece, which I admit resonates with me similarly, is just a joy. It's wonderful to witness people being honest.
It's such a beautiful thing to watch two musicians at the top of their craft do their thing. It's like the two of you know a secret language that speaks to our souls.
As a beginner musician, these videos are so inspiring. Yalls raw creativity is so palpable. Not to mention the fantastic production of these videos, the tight edit, and clear vision. Amazing.
You’ve gotta be kidding me! Rob, Andrew, you’ve outdone yourselves!!!
32:07 the part where Pretty Raw comes together is great. Everyone's reaction to it is so perfect.
This video is so much different after watching Rob's newest video