Hello Birdman thanks for compilation I realy enjoyed all of them. I realy want to know what your thoughts about new Kenobi show? Of course if you watched it
Honestly, ngl I've watched RotJ a ridiculous amount of times (it's one of my favorites) but that scene where R2 fires the lightsaber to Luke...I always thought R2 just had impeccable aim. It never occurred to me that he used the force to pull it to him (mostly because of how the scene was cut). TIL
I'm willing to blame the writers at CS for Kevin's lines, honestly I mean I'm biased because I like Kevin, but dude is pretty competent when he isn't next to 'theres no gravity in space'
Modern "criticism" of pop culture often reminds me of a quote from Grant Morrison: “Adults...struggle desperately with fiction, demanding constantly that it conform to the rules of everyday life. Adults foolishly demand to know how Superman can possibly fly, or how Batman can possibly run a multibillion-dollar business empire during the day and fight crime at night, when the answer is obvious even to the smallest child: because it's not real.”
It wasn't specifically the dark side it was strong with, the sheer amount of life on the planet caused it to essentially be a force nexus. So much force energy was there that it was impossible to sense him through all of the interference
Like a drop of water in the ocean. Dagobah's natural presence was so strong that Vader would have had to search every cave and corner of the planet to find Yoda. And Vader's suit isn't made for a harsh, moist, and mostly waterbased planet...
This BS right here is why I've started telling people that Cinemasins is a reaction channel: they just watch the movie once, spout whatever thoughts come to their minds, and treat those ideas as god given facts.
It's even worse than that. Remember, something Birdman frequently sins Jeremy for is willfully leaving out or editing scenes to make it seem like his "sins" are well thought out criticisms of these movies that no one else notices, and he does it to give himself credibility as well as views and clout, while in reality he's flat out lying to his audience about what's in the movie in order to support his claims. That's manipulating facts to support baseless complaints and profiting off of it. That's like pouring water on the floor in a supermarket and laying down in it until an employee finds you, then claiming you slipped because the floor was wet and threatening to sue the store to get free stuff. What I'm saying is that Jeremy is practically committing fraud.
In star wars Luke does clearly say the trash monster let him go and disappeared, even as a kid I assumed he escaped into an opening before the compactor started
It wouldn't make sense for there to be massive trash monster in the compactor if there wasn't a place for it to be safe and not get crushed. No matter what it is, nothing would start out that big and if it did start out that big that would mean it would have to have like.....been added intentionally? What would be the point of that other than disposing of it's corpse but like....they didn't make sure it was dead? I figured it was like.....a bottom feeder. The compactor crushes organic waste and then the creature processes it further through digestion
@@thomasb7347 as Callum mentioned, there's a chapter in the Certain Point of View book where it explicitly states that there's a dent big enough for the dianoga to fit into.
@@CLUN_k Yeah no, that's what you figured. Either it was there as an accident and found a hidey hole or it was there to help break things down so they had a hole made for it
You know, I find it interesting that Team Four Star gives a perfect explanation for why someone would program a robot to feel pain. Pain is important for context so that you don't rip yourself apart.
That's precisely why humans have pain-- to tell the brain something detrimental is happening to an extremity and force the body to avoid it if possible.
Also even if the Droids wouldnt feel pain in the traditionol sense, they still would have some kind of warning system so they know "Warning if you proceed with this damage is eminent" so even if they dont feel pain like we do, they have there own forms of pain, so that Sin makes even less sense.
@@neptuneplaneptune3367even if they don't they still have some form of consciousness meaning why the fuck would they want to rip themselves apart? Like they wouldn't just kill themselves or let themselves get ripped apart?
Holding your breath is actually a reflex that is ingrained into pretty much every single mammal alive right now. It’s called the Mammalian Diving Reflex
Yeah it's actually a good way to get children comfortable in water to teach them to swim. You blow into their face which automatically causes them to hold their breath. Then you can safely go under water with them for a brief moment. It's very successful and used in many parent/child swimming lessons.
While what you're saying is true, there's no reason to assume that the evolutionary biology of humans in the Star Wars galaxy is identical to that of humans on Earth, especially knowing there is an incredibly wide variety in the climates of habitable planets. If there have been many generations of humans living on Tatooine (of which 3 are shown just in the prequels and sequels), a planet where they are unlikely to come into contact with enough water to swim in, I would say it's pretty reasonable to assume the MDR has at least been repressed, if not vanished entirely. That being said, I am no biologist, so I welcome someone who knows more about the topic to correct me if I'm wrong.
@@bioplay3287 even if that is true, youre saying that Luke wouldnt know how to hold his breath... just because you have never been underwater, i dont think that means you dont know what holding your breath is. its safe to assume that hes been near a bad smell SOMETIME in his life. Edit: that argument still doesn't make sense since luke wasnt born on tatooine, and he wasnt born by someone living on tatooine. Your argument would make sense if his family had never left tatooine.
"I'm sure showing a scene of torture would negate this film's PG rating." You want to know how right you are? They actually had to get Harison Ford back into the recording studio to record his scream because his first scream was so terrifying, that it threatened the PG rating. That's in the DVD commentary.
I like how Kevin Smith suggests that Captain Antilles would be able to grab Vaders lightsaber and kill him with it, which even without the multiple armed Stormtroopers that Jeremy thinks can’t hit anything because of the memes that came many years after the OG trilogy, would be impossible. Kevin states Vaders ability to choke people with a hand gesture, showing his power, but thinks Vader has no ability to prevent Antilles from killing him with his own weapon.
Antilles would be toyed with worse than Reva, he would probably spend a minute trying to ignite the sabre right before Vader uses the force to pull it from his hands and stabs him with it
Bro, my brain broke after hearing what Kevin Smith said about Luke and Tosche station. My first thought after the shock wore off was "How has that man not been like, canceled out of existence"
Because the cringe sex joke was at the expanse of a white man. So unless my math is wrong, the Right Wing Cancel Culture fools are outnumbered by the liberal wing Cancel culture fools
I used to like CinemaSins a lot, back when they pointed out inconsistencies and actual sins of the movie, it was really interesting and fantastic to watch, and its a shame they have fallen so far.
In order to type faster, we were given blindfolds and told to wear them until we could type the entirety of "A quick brown fox" without mistakes. This allows us to FEEL the keys, know instinctively where they are on the keyboard, which in turn allows us to read while typing, minimizing the mistakes made when typing fast and allowing for things like live dictations and script transference. Blindfolding during training for something that requires non-visual senses is a very legitimate thing to do.
Yeah and there are dozen of martial arts movies where somone is given a blindfold too learn too sharpen his other senses. This is pretty much the same, Obi Wan shutting of Lukes senses so he can learn too let the force guide him.
For me, they had us cover the keyboard so we couldn't see the keys but still feel them. At first it was a latex keyboard condom, but I broke out in hives due to a severe allergy, so they allowed me to switch to a cardboard cover thing that went over my hands and the keyboard itself. Either way, you are absolutely correct. That is how kids learn how to type in computer lab.
@@Shadethewolfy Our typewriters came with hinged covers from the factory. That was a pretty standard feature for professional ones before computers took over.
Getting angry at coincidences in movies is really pathetic ngl,as if the entire story line of most movies don't depend on really convenient events so the movie can happen
@@randomperson093 It's not even a coincidence, the death star had literally jumped to Alderaan specifically to blow it up, why would anyone assume it was far away?
Also with the scene where he claimed the animal wasnt leaving tracks, the animal is quite clearly waving its tail from side to side which would clear some of it's own tracks anyway, they are walking on sand.
I seriously lost all respect for Kevin Smith with this. He was on a downward slope before it, but with this, everything he said just got worse and worse. Little did I know he would continue on that downward slope and still has yet to reach the bottom. He has truly become a trash person ruining as much as he can get a hold of.
@@187btokes "Little did I know he would continue on that downward slope and still has yet to reach the bottom." very much an implication that he saw the original airing.
@@187btokes he never said that he lost all respect for kevin smith after “this” he could heavily imply he was talking about the original video. You sound like jeremy
Kevin Smith is that guy who suddenly got big and forgets why he was popular, or at least appreciated in the first place. He has certain takes on the comic world/ culture, and somehow that makes him a kind of " expert". And Kevin thinks a bit too high of himself. He really isn't that insightful. And often goes for the low hanging fruit.
This channel is savage. It returns dignity to the joy of absorbing fictional tales in the first place. The overall emotions and story and world and imagery and structure and acting and poetic beauty are we watch films, WE DON'T WATCH TO FIND MINOR LITTLE PLOT PROBLEMS. This channel is saving us from the psychopathy of the cinema sins channel and every friend you ever had who interrupts a great movie by saying some variation of, "this would never happen in real life."
Cinemasins used to be a good channel that pointed out actual mistakes and inconsistencies. It was funny to watch once you had already seen the movie and noticed those things yourself, because it had funny commentary to go along with it. It wasn't nitpicking silly stuff or misunderstanding plots. It asked legitimate questions that the movie failed to answer. Also, the videos were typically less than ten minutes long. I would sometimes watch it instead of watching the actual movie, if I had no interest in seeing a film, but wanted to know a little about it (to get spoilers on Fantastic Beasts, for example). Now, it's not even recognizable as the same channel. It became unwatchable.
Here's a quick hot take for Chewie not getting a medal, maybe he refused it because he owes Han a life debt, and considers his actions to belong to Han. Heck, for those in the know, do wookies in general care for medals, maybe something in the warrior code against it?
I was thinking that myself because Zalbbar (sorry if I spelled wrong) owes their life to revan in kotor and when you play the game and finish with helping the republic he doesn’t get a medal for his job because he has a life debt to revan and I felt would see it as a disrespect because he was doing it for revan
Chewie was just a crew member following the orders of his captain here. The medal is for giving those orders and their result, i.e. for doing something above and beyond your job description.
"he could totally still be alive" He is, though. An expanded universe comic actually shows him cutting his way out of the Saarlak. It's really cool. More info about it in the death battle between him and Samus Aran.
RE: 04:30, I love the "Tosche Station" line and how Mark Hamill delivers it. It shows that Luke may live in another galaxy and time, but he's still a typical kid. And that adolescent whine is exactly how 99.9999% of 18-20 years olds speak (including me, once upon a time). As for Kevin Smith, I haven't had much time for him since, like a total weasel, he embraced the ST and said he lied about liking the PT because it was "the only game in town" and, presumably, he wanted to look good in Lucasfilm's eyes. Not much integrity there.
18 to 20 is a fully grown adult. I love the original trilogy, but the tone of voice he used was toddler tier whining. Most children stop whining like that by the time they are ten. Teens have used a huffy tone when they don't want to do chores, and have been known to beg when they want something, but whining? No. Even my millennial children outgrew the whining stage by their teen years. It's a cringey scene, but the movies are still fantastic. They were a part of my childhood, and they were made a long time ago, so there will just be certain things about them that will not translate well to future generations anyway, because they will look hokey.
@@jenx5870 I mean, it's cool that your kids didn't whine as teenagers, but I've certainly known teens (both as a teen myself, and now as an adult) that whine, and much in a similar way. You had a thoughtful answer, but made a sweeping generalization about *all* teens, something you just can't know the entirety of
One thing you missed about the escape pod: The Imperial’s didn’t assume there were droids onboard since they’re forbidden from using them. That’s why C3P0 said, “We’ll be deactivated for sure!” Also, I’m pretty sure they know about the sabotaged tractor beam after the Millennium Falcon escape. Someone would have noticed that shit. Lastly, I can’t believe that you missed the opportunity to call Jeremy, Darth Incestuous.
Yeah I’m sure they knew about the sabotage and were probably either gonna fix it or were attempting to after the escape. Also if I’m not mistaken the empire wasn’t actually trying to recapture leia or capture luke han and chewie. They actually intended to let them leave since they put a tracking device on their ship. They just needed to give them the illusion of trying to stop their escape to hide their true intentions.
when you think about it the force is the greatest plot device in history. nothing is just a conveniece, everything that happened happened because of the force.
And in the Last Airbender, Destiny is a massive plot device but it doesn't ruin the story. Like how awefully convenient that the only thing that survived the fire in the library was a single scrap of paper and the paper just so happened to have a way to stop the fire nation. Destiny or a greater power is an amazing plot device if used correctly like in Star wars or Avatar
The only thing that's more intimidating than a weapon capable of destroying a planet, is the threat or hearing Jeremy laugh, but in all seriousness, a weapon that destroys galaxies is pointless, like you said, but a weapon that destroys solar systems can be useful, but it would wipe out so many planets that the Galaxy would basically be empty, and then we have the same situation with the empire as we do the Romans
Until the Force creates planets of light and dark because... The fucking Force is absolutely powerful despite what the ass sore geeks say. Literally, Vader knows the Force will do anything better than a disco murder ball, parts 1, 2, and 3.
About Captain Antilles, wasn’t Vader interrogating him? Force choking him would not only prevent him from speaking, but prematurely kill him. Vader holds him like that to get clear answers and still restrain him.
About the cutting off of arms; there was a specific line of combat techniques to dismember an opponent, developed by the jedi during battles against the old sith. It's kinda hard to swing a lightsaber without a hand. There were even unique names depending on where on the arm you cut xD
Yeah, I remember this from the companion book on proper Jedi techniques--it had been Dooku's and he had passed it down to Qui Gon, who passed it down to Obi-wan, who passed it down to Anikan, who passed it down to Ashoka and then Luke recovered it and made his own annotations.
@@jordancampbell8597 The book you are referring to is called "The Jedi Path" I have it myself and it actually shows multiple ways to dispatch an opponent all across the body for example the way Obi-wan dispatched Maul on Naboo is actually considered the most barbaric way to do so and is only supposed to be used on droids.
Saying something is "Convenient" when you don't know the alternative is a fallacy. If R2 had been sold to someone else instead of Luke, that other person would have been the protagonist and the story would have continued regardless. Then Jeremy would be saying "Isn't it convenient that R2 got sold to BLANK instead of Luke?" We don't even know which alt would have had a better outcome.
"Isn't it convenient that Bob just so happens to buy R2-D2 and lead him to Obi-Wan who leads them to some kid who's actually the son of the main villain?"
A big reason Stormtroopers seem to have bad aim is cause they’re constantly firing at Plot Armor! If Mando’s armor wasn’t Beskar, how many shots do you think would’ve hit him?
And the fact that with those helmets it's hard to see what you're doing,isn't there a line in the new hope said by luke that goes like "i can't see a thing in this" or something?
To be absolutely fair Anakin was brought in when he was like 7 or 8, which isn't the youngest to be adopted into the Jedi Order but it certainly wasn't the cause of his fall to the dark side in any way. The Jedi themselves were to blame not to mention his grooming by Sidious in his teen and young-adult years, and possibly even since he was first brought in to the order.
I just discovered your channel and went into your back catalog of SW videos. You earned a sub just because of the taser only syphon filter run. That gave me a chuckle and a nostalgia flashback to my taser only run when I was a kid and discovered how funny the taser was.
7:48 Jeremy: "Ah, I see the Death Star has branded their truth serum robots so that all visitors know this isn't some knockoff Death Star shit here." I'm honestly not sure I understand what Jeremy is even talking about in this sin. Is he just referring to the fact that it's a spherical-shaped floating droid? Or is there something about it that I'm not seeing?
Funny note about the escape pod scene...one of the things Disney did after taking over was try to fill in old gaps like this. The reason they didn't destroy the pod just to be safe is because it would lower their 'kill to shot' ratio. Rebel propaganda implied that Imperials can't shoot, so to prove otherwise they instituted the ratio. Only destroyed targets with lide forms aboard count as a kill, unmanned objects are marked as a miss. For the record, the guy who ordered the gunner to hold his fire got away with it, because he knew a girl in the data room who showed him how to bury the fuckup in so much paperwork that it wouldn't be worth investigating.
4:56 Skippy the Jedi Droid (also known as R5-D4) was the only known Force Sensitive Droid. After a run-in with Obi-Wan and some hijinks, he was eventually captured by Jawas and taken by the Lars family. Sensing the power in Luke, Skippy fantasised about so many adventures that could be possible, until sensing something else. That the blue R2 unit lined up nearby had to go with him, for the galaxy as a whole to prosper. R5-D4 then took the decisive action of damaging himself with the Force, in order to make himself unbuyable. Not a convenience, a coincidence. Well, all of that was canon until Disney took over.
@@dominickeijzer5844 Yeah, no shit. That doesn't change the fact that there was never a time when Skippy was canon. It was, at most, an in-universe myth even before Disney.
Skippy wasn't force sensitive. R2-D2 told him about how he had super important Death Star plans, and that he NEEDED to be bought, and asked R5 to sacrifice himself so that the Rebellion could get the plans and save the galaxy.
Of all the solar systems, those with binary suns are more common than singular suns, which are less common than even three sun solar systems. Earth is the odd place, not Tatooine.
Dude you are the Weird Al of reviewing reviewers. You have like an infinite about of other peoples material to rift off of. And yet you make it so damn funny and even better then the original! So good. And wait… why didn’t Chewbacca get a medal?
A book explains the escape pod incident so it’s established that to keep a high accuracy count on imperial records and to not waste ammo imperial gunners are told not to fire on “empty” pods
40:46 When they visit Jaba's palace didnt they have to give up their weapons, cause I remember that and if so then it makes sense as to why Luke would give his lightsaber to R2
6:27 & 10:53 Now, it’s more like *”nine* years ago.” Yes, I realize this wasn’t originally the case. 31:08 I can respect that. 43:08-43:19 This is one of your best comebacks against Jeremy.
⚠️SPOILERS FOR OBI-WAN KENOBI FINALE⚠️ during their final fight of the series, Darth Vader says to Obi-Wan “You… didn’t kill… Anakin Skywalker… I did….” SO that ADDS ON to what Obi-Wan says in the original trilogy… he told Luke the truth… from a certain point of view 😏
I just got done complaining about how people accuse the Storm Troopers of being bad shots in the last video and it's basically the first substantial thing you talk about in this one. Glad someone else said it, too.
15:00 more than this sin, although you are right, placing a blanket on him could also be used to help people experiencing shock. Luke just got into a situation where he had to kill multiple people, probably for the first time in his life, undergo a stressful infiltration mission, and watched his mentor and someone he cared deeply for die in front of him. Leia is not stupid, and could likely tell that Luke was not a seasoned fighter or seasoned anything. That kind of observance and emotional intelligence is a skill she has to have to actually be functional in the rebellion, and she also has multiple moments across many media showing her care for others. I mean her hatred of the injustices of the Empire is literally one of the reasons she is a Rebel. Of course she is gonna give a blanket to comfort someone who just experienced all of the above.
Okay so I just thought this was neat. But once Yoda drops his goofy unassuming guise, he drops his previous speech pattern meaning it was meant to throw you and Luke off. I haven’t seen ESP in a long time so when this happened it totally went over my head! So that’s honestly really cool but it also does make the other media with Yoda weird since he does have the odd speech pattern again (as much as I love it)
39:00 so I'm putting my neck on the chopping block, but here goes: I unironically like the song Jedi Rocks. I grew up on the origanal cut, so my first exposure to Jedi Rocks was as background music for the Mos Eisley map in the old Battlefront II game. I put so many hours playing that stage and Jedi Rocks fills me with nostalgia each time I hear it. Now if only the visuals didn't want to make me claw my eyes out...
The unintentional swapping of "want to" and "make me" paints a funny picture in my head of George Lucas specifically targeting you during his creation of this edit for the special editions.
Way back in the day, there was a short story out there that told how R5-D4 intentionally blew its motivator because R2-D2 was telling him how he had an important mission here, and needed to stay with C3PO.
The bounty hunter on Ord Mantell wasn't necessarily something they just dropped in to Empire, especially if you saw Empire when it first came out. Look up "Rebel Mission on Ord Mantell". It's a Star Wars story record put out in between Star Wars and Empire. It involves the Hunter Han Solo mentions, and is supposed to be a direct tie-in to this scene, according to Wookiepedia. Being a young fan when the original trilogy came out, I had this record and wished I still had it...
To add to the escape pod sins, before R2 and C3PO get in C3PO says droids aren't allowed in escape pods. The empire gunners have no reason to assume there are rule breaking droids when a malfunction is a more likely scenario
I love cinema sins and I love your channel that calls them out too! Should probably add 500 sins for having Kevin Smith completely making their uploaded video for A New Hope pretty much unwatchable. Edit: now that I’m further along in the video, should’ve blasted them with 100 sins for sinning Yoda’s death scene speech!
19:08 Actually, the Imperial-class star destroyers is VERY capable of destroying a planet also (I'll need some correction if a fleet is required__. The turbolaser cannons as I recall, has the same destructive power to a atomic bomb. This particular class, unlike its predecessor the Venator, is equipped to focus on firepower then transporting troops or cargo. That is why just facing a single Imperial-class star destroyer is a suicidal.
Force users can sense other force users. Like that scene where Darth Vader says he senses a presence. He didn't want to bring Darth Vader to him and luke
22:50 id also like to add that military helicopters do this too, to avoid radar and line of sight threats, keeping the mountains as cover. Mountians block radio signal (flying above would give them more chance of contacting him), and the speed they were flying/clothing he wore means it would be hard to see him. Since theyre actively avoiding detection, this is more likley the reasoning
Oh, also, "Jedi Mind Trick" being the same in both languages actually has a different explanation, though yours is a perfectly valid assumption. According to the person who worked on the languages for these films, Huttese is actually a creole - it resulted from multiple languages being spoken in the same space and them simplifying and merging together to make it easier for people who speak different languages to still be able to communicate enough basic concepts to function. That's why all of the huttese words for numbers are the same as galactic basic - for commerce to work, you need to be able communicate numbers, so Huttese incorporated galactic basic numbers because those are more broadly used across the galaxy. Neither explanation is really needed in the scene, but it's neat that they thought about it. This is how supplemental information should work in a story. You don't need to know this information to follow the story, but knowing it adds to your appreciation of the work.
44:26 on a technical sense, before Rey and Kylo Luke trained Leia (I think) so you COULD technically count her as a Jedi, but even then this was before that happened so
10:02 Okay for the people who actually didn't get it the first time like I did, Basically, Jeremy said that the trip to Alderaan was originally meaningless, but coincidentally the Death Star happened to be there. Even though the reason they went to Alderaan in the first place was _because_ the Death Star was there.
Cinema sins gets a lot of stuff wrong in their videos but when the Dinoga attacked neither of you pointed out Luke is literally a moisture farmer his whole life has been farming water and has had experience with water. Good video. :)
One thing I'd like to point out about the whole "how did the emperor know they would get a shuttle and yada yada." He probably didn't know. It doesn't matter how they got there, he simply gave them the information and left it to them to find their own way there. The rebel alliance is more than capable enough to make it to the shield generator on their own. If they weren't then the new Death Star would have been finished and it wouldn't have mattered anyway. He simply would have found another way to lure Luke in. However he'd already forseen Luke come so didn't need another plan because he knew it would work. It's the same thing with most movies with intricate plans that just work out. They probably didn't work perfectly, it's simply that smart people will make contingencies so if something important doesn't happen they can immediately follow up with the next thing. Guy doesn't get on the train, you have a planted taxi to pick him up instead. Or that thing when people complain about them catching the train at the right time to avoid getting caught. They most likely knew the train would be there because trains run on schedules, just buy a minute or two going the long way and you've got a good chance of pulling off the trick. Every plan comes with risks, we just see them work out because then the movie wouldn't happen.
Flipping Jake Skywalker should have trained Grogu because he should have learned that cutting off jedi from love or emotions was what led Anakin to the dark side
So Birdman! If you do an all in one with the spin-off films, Rogue One and Solo, will you add Clone Wars as a bonus as you never covered that one standalone?
Everything Wrong With The Prequels: th-cam.com/video/wlkbPo-P8C0/w-d-xo.html
Patreon: www.patreon.com/Th3Birdman
Twitter: twitter.com/Th3birdman15
Instagram: instagram.com/Th3Birdman15/
Discord Invite Code: nQZRn5m
Subreddit: reddit.com/r/Th3Birdman
Facebook: facebook.com/Th3Birdman15
Found Th3birdman in fortnite
Hello Birdman thanks for compilation I realy enjoyed all of them. I realy want to know what your thoughts about new Kenobi show? Of course if you watched it
Honestly, ngl I've watched RotJ a ridiculous amount of times (it's one of my favorites) but that scene where R2 fires the lightsaber to Luke...I always thought R2 just had impeccable aim. It never occurred to me that he used the force to pull it to him (mostly because of how the scene was cut). TIL
Did you practice doing birdpatine's voice or was it just natural? Either way I love it, and I honestly wish we could hang out.
Keep doing your thing lol
I didn’t think I could dislike Jeremy and Cinema Sins anymore than I did. Then Kevin Smith comes along and proves me wrong.
I'm pretty sure Kevin Smith was the one that made them think it was ok to fill their videos with cringe innuendos. I never forgave him for that.
@@pyronuke4768 oh damn, so we've been hearing about Kevin Smith's girlfriend?
I'm willing to blame the writers at CS for Kevin's lines, honestly
I mean I'm biased because I like Kevin, but dude is pretty competent when he isn't next to 'theres no gravity in space'
I love Kevin Smith, but that was like blending shit with cake.
You should see his He-Man reboot
4:53 “We are now skipping every line involving Kevin Smith”
As you should
Thank the Maker
I'm confused, what did Kevin Smith do?
@@chaos7143 All I remember is that he named his kid after Harley Quinn. I’m not joking.
@@chaos7143 Did you not hear what he said?
@@chaos7143 his sins are not only stupid, but LONG WINDED.
Modern "criticism" of pop culture often reminds me of a quote from Grant Morrison:
“Adults...struggle desperately with fiction, demanding constantly that it conform to the rules of everyday life. Adults foolishly demand to know how Superman can possibly fly, or how Batman can possibly run a multibillion-dollar business empire during the day and fight crime at night, when the answer is obvious even to the smallest child: because it's not real.”
Good quote.
Doesn't take into account bad writing though.
@@mellon3891 Later Hater!!! - Dr.Robotnik
@@sosa8700 Good one, Sosa.
Regarding Batman... he got guys to run his company lol
then there are people mocking padme for dying of heartbreak, despite that actually being possible in real life
Don't forget, Yoda hid on Dagobah BECAUSE the dark side of the Force was strong there, and it effectively cloaked him allowing him to never be found.
It wasn't specifically the dark side it was strong with, the sheer amount of life on the planet caused it to essentially be a force nexus. So much force energy was there that it was impossible to sense him through all of the interference
Like a drop of water in the ocean. Dagobah's natural presence was so strong that Vader would have had to search every cave and corner of the planet to find Yoda.
And Vader's suit isn't made for a harsh, moist, and mostly waterbased planet...
Basically, the genius waves got cancelled out by the morty waves
@@icel8828Perfect description.
complaining about a second deathstar is like saying, "the enemy destroyed my nuke, guess theres no point in building a new one"
ur argument gets uprooted by andor
This BS right here is why I've started telling people that Cinemasins is a reaction channel: they just watch the movie once, spout whatever thoughts come to their minds, and treat those ideas as god given facts.
CinemaSins is a cheap Mystery Science Theatre 3000 ripoff
From some of Jeremy’s comments, I’m not sure they even watch the whole movie.
@@BatFan1 Don't disrespect MST3000 like that.
@@BatFan1 Honestly fans of Cinema Sins might actually like MST
It's even worse than that. Remember, something Birdman frequently sins Jeremy for is willfully leaving out or editing scenes to make it seem like his "sins" are well thought out criticisms of these movies that no one else notices, and he does it to give himself credibility as well as views and clout, while in reality he's flat out lying to his audience about what's in the movie in order to support his claims. That's manipulating facts to support baseless complaints and profiting off of it. That's like pouring water on the floor in a supermarket and laying down in it until an employee finds you, then claiming you slipped because the floor was wet and threatening to sue the store to get free stuff. What I'm saying is that Jeremy is practically committing fraud.
In star wars Luke does clearly say the trash monster let him go and disappeared, even as a kid I assumed he escaped into an opening before the compactor started
It wouldn't make sense for there to be massive trash monster in the compactor if there wasn't a place for it to be safe and not get crushed. No matter what it is, nothing would start out that big and if it did start out that big that would mean it would have to have like.....been added intentionally? What would be the point of that other than disposing of it's corpse but like....they didn't make sure it was dead?
I figured it was like.....a bottom feeder. The compactor crushes organic waste and then the creature processes it further through digestion
In Star Wars a certain point of view there is a chapter about the trash compactor monster
Me too
@@thomasb7347 as Callum mentioned, there's a chapter in the Certain Point of View book where it explicitly states that there's a dent big enough for the dianoga to fit into.
@@CLUN_k Yeah no, that's what you figured. Either it was there as an accident and found a hidey hole or it was there to help break things down so they had a hole made for it
You know, I find it interesting that Team Four Star gives a perfect explanation for why someone would program a robot to feel pain. Pain is important for context so that you don't rip yourself apart.
That's precisely why humans have pain-- to tell the brain something detrimental is happening to an extremity and force the body to avoid it if possible.
Also even if the Droids wouldnt feel pain in the traditionol sense, they still would have some kind of warning system so they know "Warning if you proceed with this damage is eminent" so even if they dont feel pain like we do, they have there own forms of pain, so that Sin makes even less sense.
@@neptuneplaneptune3367even if they don't they still have some form of consciousness meaning why the fuck would they want to rip themselves apart? Like they wouldn't just kill themselves or let themselves get ripped apart?
They explain this exactly like that in the dark tournament arc of yu yu hakusho
"Why would you program a robot to feel pain?"
"So that I can control it."
Holding your breath is actually a reflex that is ingrained into pretty much every single mammal alive right now. It’s called the Mammalian Diving Reflex
Yeah it's actually a good way to get children comfortable in water to teach them to swim. You blow into their face which automatically causes them to hold their breath. Then you can safely go under water with them for a brief moment. It's very successful and used in many parent/child swimming lessons.
While what you're saying is true, there's no reason to assume that the evolutionary biology of humans in the Star Wars galaxy is identical to that of humans on Earth, especially knowing there is an incredibly wide variety in the climates of habitable planets. If there have been many generations of humans living on Tatooine (of which 3 are shown just in the prequels and sequels), a planet where they are unlikely to come into contact with enough water to swim in, I would say it's pretty reasonable to assume the MDR has at least been repressed, if not vanished entirely. That being said, I am no biologist, so I welcome someone who knows more about the topic to correct me if I'm wrong.
@@tgs5725 You need a mint.
@@sosa8700 Good one, Sosa.
@@bioplay3287 even if that is true, youre saying that Luke wouldnt know how to hold his breath... just because you have never been underwater, i dont think that means you dont know what holding your breath is. its safe to assume that hes been near a bad smell SOMETIME in his life.
Edit: that argument still doesn't make sense since luke wasnt born on tatooine, and he wasnt born by someone living on tatooine. Your argument would make sense if his family had never left tatooine.
"I'm sure showing a scene of torture would negate this film's PG rating."
You want to know how right you are? They actually had to get Harison Ford back into the recording studio to record his scream because his first scream was so terrifying, that it threatened the PG rating.
That's in the DVD commentary.
I like how Kevin Smith suggests that Captain Antilles would be able to grab Vaders lightsaber and kill him with it, which even without the multiple armed Stormtroopers that Jeremy thinks can’t hit anything because of the memes that came many years after the OG trilogy, would be impossible. Kevin states Vaders ability to choke people with a hand gesture, showing his power, but thinks Vader has no ability to prevent Antilles from killing him with his own weapon.
Antilles would be toyed with worse than Reva, he would probably spend a minute trying to ignite the sabre right before Vader uses the force to pull it from his hands and stabs him with it
@@Riku-zv5dk I’d like to see him take a swing at Vader then get force choked so hard his body explodes
@@Riku-zv5dk Antilles would then survive and somehow make it to tatoonie :]
Not to mention Vader is physically strong enough to lift him off the ground by his throat. He wouldn’t even need the force, he can just snap his neck.
He should have watched episode 5 where Vader gets hit with a lightsaber and nothing happens to him except he gets angy.
Bro, my brain broke after hearing what Kevin Smith said about Luke and Tosche station. My first thought after the shock wore off was "How has that man not been like, canceled out of existence"
Because the cringe sex joke was at the expanse of a white man. So unless my math is wrong, the Right Wing Cancel Culture fools are outnumbered by the liberal wing Cancel culture fools
Smith's approach is just make the majority of his fanbase slowly lose interest in him.
@@some1namedno1 he has a fanbase?
@@sirshotty7689 There are enough people that enjoy him that they were excited to see him in Lego Batman 3. No I'm not joking.
Even C3PO’s like “WTF?”
I used to like CinemaSins a lot, back when they pointed out inconsistencies and actual sins of the movie, it was really interesting and fantastic to watch, and its a shame they have fallen so far.
You're probably broke smh
Usually that’s what happens when you hit the peak of your career and can just create bs to get easy money
@@Torrent263 the fuck does this even mean?
@@Torrent263 what?
I would suggest TheCanadianLad for a new proximity for what old CinemaSins did.
In order to type faster, we were given blindfolds and told to wear them until we could type the entirety of "A quick brown fox" without mistakes.
This allows us to FEEL the keys, know instinctively where they are on the keyboard, which in turn allows us to read while typing, minimizing the mistakes made when typing fast and allowing for things like live dictations and script transference.
Blindfolding during training for something that requires non-visual senses is a very legitimate thing to do.
Yeah and there are dozen of martial arts movies where somone is given a blindfold too learn too sharpen his other senses. This is pretty much the same, Obi Wan shutting of Lukes senses so he can learn too let the force guide him.
For me, they had us cover the keyboard so we couldn't see the keys but still feel them. At first it was a latex keyboard condom, but I broke out in hives due to a severe allergy, so they allowed me to switch to a cardboard cover thing that went over my hands and the keyboard itself.
Either way, you are absolutely correct. That is how kids learn how to type in computer lab.
@@Shadethewolfy Our typewriters came with hinged covers from the factory. That was a pretty standard feature for professional ones before computers took over.
@@HenryLoenwind That is really cool :D
Being upset at the “coincidence” that the Death Star was near Alderaan is absolutely worth that many sins. Holy shit that had me fuming!
Getting angry at coincidences in movies is really pathetic ngl,as if the entire story line of most movies don't depend on really convenient events so the movie can happen
The death star could move im pretty sure. It even had a hyperdrive
It does since Grand Moff Tarkin says to the Admiral 'set your course for Alderaan.'
that’s like asking why there’s a car crash near traffic
At that point, i would just assume an over-caffeinated 6 year old performed a lobotomy on you
@@randomperson093 It's not even a coincidence, the death star had literally jumped to Alderaan specifically to blow it up, why would anyone assume it was far away?
Honestly, for sinning the "I am your father" scene, it should've been a thousand sins, but I won't question the judgement.
Personally ive always hated Mark Hamill's acting in that particular scene.
If there's anything to sin in that scene is that the stress wasn't on "am"...
Also with the scene where he claimed the animal wasnt leaving tracks, the animal is quite clearly waving its tail from side to side which would clear some of it's own tracks anyway, they are walking on sand.
And you can clearly see the dust coming off the ground when it does it.
I seriously lost all respect for Kevin Smith with this. He was on a downward slope before it, but with this, everything he said just got worse and worse. Little did I know he would continue on that downward slope and still has yet to reach the bottom. He has truly become a trash person ruining as much as he can get a hold of.
You do know he did this like 6 years ago right?
@@187btokes what does the time of release matter? They probably never saw it until this video came out.
@@187btokes "Little did I know he would continue on that downward slope and still has yet to reach the bottom." very much an implication that he saw the original airing.
@@187btokes he never said that he lost all respect for kevin smith after “this” he could heavily imply he was talking about the original video. You sound like jeremy
Kevin Smith is that guy who suddenly got big and forgets why he was popular, or at least appreciated in the first place. He has certain takes on the comic world/ culture, and somehow that makes him a kind of " expert". And Kevin thinks a bit too high of himself. He really isn't that insightful. And often goes for the low hanging fruit.
Real talk you're videos get me through stressful days..when I need a laugh...been a fan 4 years now ..keep the good vibes coming
Good vibes matter!
This channel is savage. It returns dignity to the joy of absorbing fictional tales in the first place. The overall emotions and story and world and imagery and structure and acting and poetic beauty are we watch films, WE DON'T WATCH TO FIND MINOR LITTLE PLOT PROBLEMS. This channel is saving us from the psychopathy of the cinema sins channel and every friend you ever had who interrupts a great movie by saying some variation of, "this would never happen in real life."
Cinemasins used to be a good channel that pointed out actual mistakes and inconsistencies. It was funny to watch once you had already seen the movie and noticed those things yourself, because it had funny commentary to go along with it. It wasn't nitpicking silly stuff or misunderstanding plots. It asked legitimate questions that the movie failed to answer. Also, the videos were typically less than ten minutes long. I would sometimes watch it instead of watching the actual movie, if I had no interest in seeing a film, but wanted to know a little about it (to get spoilers on Fantastic Beasts, for example). Now, it's not even recognizable as the same channel. It became unwatchable.
This and CinemaWins are my new internet movie review fun place
This is such a great video. Used to watch CinemaSins until they stopped giving a fair assessments and wanted the sin counter ridiculously padded out
When did this start? Aren’t these Star Wars videos coming up on a decade old?
@@calebstevens9446 Once there channel got big they started throwing sins at everything.
"This deserves a subscription to my Patreon....Right?" Answer: Absolutely
I’ve been back on a Star Wars binge after playing the Lego Skywalker Saga and watching the Family Guy Star Wars specials, so this is a real treat!
Same but I decided to rewatch all of clone wars so I could watch the final season cause I don’t remember Jack from the first few seasons
I got that game for my birthday recently. I just finished episode 3
Did you remember to watch the Phineas and Ferb version too? Those were the best two episodes of the show imo.
25:32 my favorite “sin” is when Jeremy sins the STORMtroopers for looking like Nazis
Here's a quick hot take for Chewie not getting a medal, maybe he refused it because he owes Han a life debt, and considers his actions to belong to Han. Heck, for those in the know, do wookies in general care for medals, maybe something in the warrior code against it?
I was thinking that myself because Zalbbar (sorry if I spelled wrong) owes their life to revan in kotor and when you play the game and finish with helping the republic he doesn’t get a medal for his job because he has a life debt to revan and I felt would see it as a disrespect because he was doing it for revan
Maybe he is allergic for medals
Chewie was just a crew member following the orders of his captain here. The medal is for giving those orders and their result, i.e. for doing something above and beyond your job description.
"he could totally still be alive"
He is, though. An expanded universe comic actually shows him cutting his way out of the Saarlak. It's really cool. More info about it in the death battle between him and Samus Aran.
RE: 04:30, I love the "Tosche Station" line and how Mark Hamill delivers it. It shows that Luke may live in another galaxy and time, but he's still a typical kid. And that adolescent whine is exactly how 99.9999% of 18-20 years olds speak (including me, once upon a time). As for Kevin Smith, I haven't had much time for him since, like a total weasel, he embraced the ST and said he lied about liking the PT because it was "the only game in town" and, presumably, he wanted to look good in Lucasfilm's eyes. Not much integrity there.
Better than hating the PT then sucking it's dick after the ST.
Just accept your nostalgic delusions, fanboys. Your OT is God now.
It was that I wanna go play with my friends when you parents tell you to stay home. The whininess in Luke's voice was a perfect read for that.
18 to 20 is a fully grown adult. I love the original trilogy, but the tone of voice he used was toddler tier whining. Most children stop whining like that by the time they are ten. Teens have used a huffy tone when they don't want to do chores, and have been known to beg when they want something, but whining? No. Even my millennial children outgrew the whining stage by their teen years. It's a cringey scene, but the movies are still fantastic. They were a part of my childhood, and they were made a long time ago, so there will just be certain things about them that will not translate well to future generations anyway, because they will look hokey.
@@jenx5870 I mean, it's cool that your kids didn't whine as teenagers, but I've certainly known teens (both as a teen myself, and now as an adult) that whine, and much in a similar way. You had a thoughtful answer, but made a sweeping generalization about *all* teens, something you just can't know the entirety of
ST?
PT?
4:20 Sins Hamill’s line and delivery, and then makes an awkward joke. 😬
What a fuckin legend dropping this only a couple days after the prequel video
Well all be had to do was edit his vids together
I’m guessing he’s just doing all of the videos at once but breaking them into three separate vids.
OOOH BABY ITS CHRISTMAS ALREADY
These videos I believe are genuinely helping the discourse and fixing the harm done by Cinemasins “””satire”””
Don't you mean Life Day? It's technically canon thanks to The Mandalorian.
@@luigiboi4244 fun fact: Star Wars is fiction. There’s a bit more to life than letting Star Wars consume you
fun fact: Yoda is also frustrated at teaching Luke because he wanted to train Leia instead, while Obi Wan suggested Luke.
Kinda like anakin, minus the second person of course
One thing you missed about the escape pod: The Imperial’s didn’t assume there were droids onboard since they’re forbidden from using them. That’s why C3P0 said, “We’ll be deactivated for sure!”
Also, I’m pretty sure they know about the sabotaged tractor beam after the Millennium Falcon escape. Someone would have noticed that shit.
Lastly, I can’t believe that you missed the opportunity to call Jeremy, Darth Incestuous.
Yeah I’m sure they knew about the sabotage and were probably either gonna fix it or were attempting to after the escape. Also if I’m not mistaken the empire wasn’t actually trying to recapture leia or capture luke han and chewie. They actually intended to let them leave since they put a tracking device on their ship. They just needed to give them the illusion of trying to stop their escape to hide their true intentions.
I still say they should have shot it - just to be sure. I agree with a lot of this guy's points, but honestly I think at least that one sin is valid.
C3PO even tells R2 that there forbidden to use them.
Day 105 of telling th3birdman I appreciate his content
The pressure is on
Luke having the high ground “Obi-Wan has taught you well”
when you think about it the force is the greatest plot device in history. nothing is just a conveniece, everything that happened happened because of the force.
And in the Last Airbender, Destiny is a massive plot device but it doesn't ruin the story.
Like how awefully convenient that the only thing that survived the fire in the library was a single scrap of paper and the paper just so happened to have a way to stop the fire nation.
Destiny or a greater power is an amazing plot device if used correctly like in Star wars or Avatar
The only thing that's more intimidating than a weapon capable of destroying a planet, is the threat or hearing Jeremy laugh, but in all seriousness, a weapon that destroys galaxies is pointless, like you said, but a weapon that destroys solar systems can be useful, but it would wipe out so many planets that the Galaxy would basically be empty, and then we have the same situation with the empire as we do the Romans
Until the Force creates planets of light and dark because...
The fucking Force is absolutely powerful despite what the ass sore geeks say.
Literally, Vader knows the Force will do anything better than a disco murder ball, parts 1, 2, and 3.
I just wanna appreciate this man's voice acting for a second. Dude's literally just subtle flexing through the whole video
About Captain Antilles, wasn’t Vader interrogating him? Force choking him would not only prevent him from speaking, but prematurely kill him. Vader holds him like that to get clear answers and still restrain him.
I think that went over Jeremey’s head entirely but I also wouldn’t be surprised if he willingly ignored that all together
You do a palpatine voice pretty well, you should do voice acting for other channels too
About the cutting off of arms; there was a specific line of combat techniques to dismember an opponent, developed by the jedi during battles against the old sith. It's kinda hard to swing a lightsaber without a hand. There were even unique names depending on where on the arm you cut xD
Yeah, I remember this from the companion book on proper Jedi techniques--it had been Dooku's and he had passed it down to Qui Gon, who passed it down to Obi-wan, who passed it down to Anikan, who passed it down to Ashoka and then Luke recovered it and made his own annotations.
Neeeeeeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrd!!!!
I'm sorry, I had to, but what you said is very interesting
@@FitzyyLives you're not wrong. I just asked myself a couple of years ago why they always go for the hand, so I looked it up xD
@@jordancampbell8597 The book you are referring to is called "The Jedi Path" I have it myself and it actually shows multiple ways to dispatch an opponent all across the body for example the way Obi-wan dispatched Maul on Naboo is actually considered the most barbaric way to do so and is only supposed to be used on droids.
wasnt there also a banned move between both jedi and sith in which the user would switch off and reignite their saber to wound their opponent?
Love this kind of stuff, Birdman! Makes it really convenient to find. Would love one for Back to the Future!
He already did the whole trilogy. And not far out, one right after the other, in his list of videos they're all next to one another, easy to find.
Definitely one of the most entertaining channels on TH-cam,! Thanks for all the great videos Birdman keep up the great work!!
8:33 I like the silent acknowledgement of the one truly funny joke that Jeremy made. And thanks for shutting Kevin "Weepy" Smith up.
Saying something is "Convenient" when you don't know the alternative is a fallacy. If R2 had been sold to someone else instead of Luke, that other person would have been the protagonist and the story would have continued regardless. Then Jeremy would be saying "Isn't it convenient that R2 got sold to BLANK instead of Luke?" We don't even know which alt would have had a better outcome.
"Isn't it convenient that Bob just so happens to buy R2-D2 and lead him to Obi-Wan who leads them to some kid who's actually the son of the main villain?"
A big reason Stormtroopers seem to have bad aim is cause they’re constantly firing at Plot Armor! If Mando’s armor wasn’t Beskar, how many shots do you think would’ve hit him?
Yeah, kinda hard to hit someone covered head to toe in plot lol
Plus, it’s kind of hard to hit with a helmet that’s obstructing the majority of your eyesight.
And the fact that with those helmets it's hard to see what you're doing,isn't there a line in the new hope said by luke that goes like "i can't see a thing in this" or something?
@@randomperson093 and that line was improvised by Mark Hamill as he couldn’t see a thing out of the helmet he was wearing
To be absolutely fair Anakin was brought in when he was like 7 or 8, which isn't the youngest to be adopted into the Jedi Order but it certainly wasn't the cause of his fall to the dark side in any way. The Jedi themselves were to blame not to mention his grooming by Sidious in his teen and young-adult years, and possibly even since he was first brought in to the order.
24:10 this scene always makes me laugh don’t know why, it feels to me like an snl sketch
43:18 Yes, yes I did, that is why I converted to the Birdman and Cinemawins
Glad I'm not the only one who got a laugh out of "That's bassist."
4:53 "We are now skipping every line that involves Kevin Smith" AS YOU SHOULD
I just discovered your channel and went into your back catalog of SW videos. You earned a sub just because of the taser only syphon filter run. That gave me a chuckle and a nostalgia flashback to my taser only run when I was a kid and discovered how funny the taser was.
38:41 The galaxy far far away, Jeremy? That’s where the story takes place! Far. Far. *whispers* away.
"I understood that reference!"
😆😆😆
@@robertparker6280 And I understood yours. Well played!
7:48
Jeremy: "Ah, I see the Death Star has branded their truth serum robots so that all visitors know this isn't some knockoff Death Star shit here."
I'm honestly not sure I understand what Jeremy is even talking about in this sin. Is he just referring to the fact that it's a spherical-shaped floating droid? Or is there something about it that I'm not seeing?
Me too I don’t get it
Funny note about the escape pod scene...one of the things Disney did after taking over was try to fill in old gaps like this.
The reason they didn't destroy the pod just to be safe is because it would lower their 'kill to shot' ratio. Rebel propaganda implied that Imperials can't shoot, so to prove otherwise they instituted the ratio. Only destroyed targets with lide forms aboard count as a kill, unmanned objects are marked as a miss.
For the record, the guy who ordered the gunner to hold his fire got away with it, because he knew a girl in the data room who showed him how to bury the fuckup in so much paperwork that it wouldn't be worth investigating.
If we make our own version of astro mech droids they're definitely gonna have USB arms lol
Wait... Who DOES tailor the emperor's hoodie? Damn you I'm intrigued now
4:56
Skippy the Jedi Droid (also known as R5-D4) was the only known Force Sensitive Droid. After a run-in with Obi-Wan and some hijinks, he was eventually captured by Jawas and taken by the Lars family. Sensing the power in Luke, Skippy fantasised about so many adventures that could be possible, until sensing something else. That the blue R2 unit lined up nearby had to go with him, for the galaxy as a whole to prosper. R5-D4 then took the decisive action of damaging himself with the Force, in order to make himself unbuyable. Not a convenience, a coincidence.
Well, all of that was canon until Disney took over.
It was never canon.
@@blastification2 Legends was once Canon.
@@dominickeijzer5844 Yeah, no shit. That doesn't change the fact that there was never a time when Skippy was canon. It was, at most, an in-universe myth even before Disney.
@@blastification2 Alright, and your source for that?
Skippy wasn't force sensitive. R2-D2 told him about how he had super important Death Star plans, and that he NEEDED to be bought, and asked R5 to sacrifice himself so that the Rebellion could get the plans and save the galaxy.
Of all the solar systems, those with binary suns are more common than singular suns, which are less common than even three sun solar systems. Earth is the odd place, not Tatooine.
25:05 Also some IRL planes have tow cables, that’s how they tow gliders up into the air. They’ve been doing this since WW2.
Dude you are the Weird Al of reviewing reviewers. You have like an infinite about of other peoples material to rift off of. And yet you make it so damn funny and even better then the original! So good. And wait… why didn’t Chewbacca get a medal?
A book explains the escape pod incident so it’s established that to keep a high accuracy count on imperial records and to not waste ammo imperial gunners are told not to fire on “empty” pods
40:46 When they visit Jaba's palace didnt they have to give up their weapons, cause I remember that and if so then it makes sense as to why Luke would give his lightsaber to R2
34:34 The casual snipe against the Jeremy “CinemaSins” character is so good and on point!
6:27 & 10:53 Now, it’s more like *”nine* years ago.” Yes, I realize this wasn’t originally the case.
31:08 I can respect that.
43:08-43:19 This is one of your best comebacks against Jeremy.
Now that Disney released Kenobi, it does answers some questions and opens up others.
⚠️SPOILERS FOR OBI-WAN KENOBI FINALE⚠️ during their final fight of the series, Darth Vader says to Obi-Wan “You… didn’t kill… Anakin Skywalker… I did….” SO that ADDS ON to what Obi-Wan says in the original trilogy… he told Luke the truth… from a certain point of view 😏
I just got done complaining about how people accuse the Storm Troopers of being bad shots in the last video and it's basically the first substantial thing you talk about in this one.
Glad someone else said it, too.
15:00 more than this sin, although you are right, placing a blanket on him could also be used to help people experiencing shock. Luke just got into a situation where he had to kill multiple people, probably for the first time in his life, undergo a stressful infiltration mission, and watched his mentor and someone he cared deeply for die in front of him.
Leia is not stupid, and could likely tell that Luke was not a seasoned fighter or seasoned anything. That kind of observance and emotional intelligence is a skill she has to have to actually be functional in the rebellion, and she also has multiple moments across many media showing her care for others. I mean her hatred of the injustices of the Empire is literally one of the reasons she is a Rebel. Of course she is gonna give a blanket to comfort someone who just experienced all of the above.
Okay so I just thought this was neat. But once Yoda drops his goofy unassuming guise, he drops his previous speech pattern meaning it was meant to throw you and Luke off. I haven’t seen ESP in a long time so when this happened it totally went over my head! So that’s honestly really cool but it also does make the other media with Yoda weird since he does have the odd speech pattern again (as much as I love it)
The "red droid" is actually revealed Ina comic to be force sensitive and intentionally destructed so R2 could get the message to Old Ben.
That’s non canonical and it wasn’t canon in the legends timeline either
38:21 to 38:29
If this were the early days of Cinemasins Jeremy would’ve pointed out that the hot iron never even touches the droid
39:00 so I'm putting my neck on the chopping block, but here goes: I unironically like the song Jedi Rocks. I grew up on the origanal cut, so my first exposure to Jedi Rocks was as background music for the Mos Eisley map in the old Battlefront II game. I put so many hours playing that stage and Jedi Rocks fills me with nostalgia each time I hear it. Now if only the visuals didn't want to make me claw my eyes out...
The unintentional swapping of "want to" and "make me" paints a funny picture in my head of George Lucas specifically targeting you during his creation of this edit for the special editions.
I don't mind the song either, though the CGI of the special edition is jarring.
Way back in the day, there was a short story out there that told how R5-D4 intentionally blew its motivator because R2-D2 was telling him how he had an important mission here, and needed to stay with C3PO.
The bounty hunter on Ord Mantell wasn't necessarily something they just dropped in to Empire, especially if you saw Empire when it first came out. Look up "Rebel Mission on Ord Mantell". It's a Star Wars story record put out in between Star Wars and Empire. It involves the Hunter Han Solo mentions, and is supposed to be a direct tie-in to this scene, according to Wookiepedia. Being a young fan when the original trilogy came out, I had this record and wished I still had it...
To add to the escape pod sins, before R2 and C3PO get in C3PO says droids aren't allowed in escape pods. The empire gunners have no reason to assume there are rule breaking droids when a malfunction is a more likely scenario
Love how it went from im only talking to some of their mistakes now it’s just their mistakes lol
18:00 You were Birdman long before you started sinning CinemaSins
I love cinema sins and I love your channel that calls them out too! Should probably add 500 sins for having Kevin Smith completely making their uploaded video for A New Hope pretty much unwatchable.
Edit: now that I’m further along in the video, should’ve blasted them with 100 sins for sinning Yoda’s death scene speech!
loved the silent sin removal for bassist joke
19:08
Actually, the Imperial-class star destroyers is VERY capable of destroying a planet also (I'll need some correction if a fleet is required__. The turbolaser cannons as I recall, has the same destructive power to a atomic bomb. This particular class, unlike its predecessor the Venator, is equipped to focus on firepower then transporting troops or cargo. That is why just facing a single Imperial-class star destroyer is a suicidal.
So glad I found this channel. Keep up the good work, bro.
Okay, okay, I'll support you on Patreon
23:52 "Jeremy" probably meant, "why would Vader need a drone report if he had the force guide him to be sure of where the rebels were located?"
There’s one thing I’ve always wondered. Why didn’t Obi Wan not show Luke that he could use the force to show the force was real?
Force users can sense other force users. Like that scene where Darth Vader says he senses a presence. He didn't want to bring Darth Vader to him and luke
22:50 id also like to add that military helicopters do this too, to avoid radar and line of sight threats, keeping the mountains as cover. Mountians block radio signal (flying above would give them more chance of contacting him), and the speed they were flying/clothing he wore means it would be hard to see him. Since theyre actively avoiding detection, this is more likley the reasoning
After you do this with the sequels, can you combine all of them into a 3 hour video?
You know sh*ts going down, when the whole squad is taking shots at Jeremy.
38:23 the actual sin should be that the metal prongs don't actually touch the droid
Oh, also, "Jedi Mind Trick" being the same in both languages actually has a different explanation, though yours is a perfectly valid assumption. According to the person who worked on the languages for these films, Huttese is actually a creole - it resulted from multiple languages being spoken in the same space and them simplifying and merging together to make it easier for people who speak different languages to still be able to communicate enough basic concepts to function. That's why all of the huttese words for numbers are the same as galactic basic - for commerce to work, you need to be able communicate numbers, so Huttese incorporated galactic basic numbers because those are more broadly used across the galaxy.
Neither explanation is really needed in the scene, but it's neat that they thought about it. This is how supplemental information should work in a story. You don't need to know this information to follow the story, but knowing it adds to your appreciation of the work.
44:26 on a technical sense, before Rey and Kylo Luke trained Leia (I think) so you COULD technically count her as a Jedi, but even then this was before that happened so
I thought that was EU canon?
@@windrider2190
Nope
Rise of Skywalker showed us a Jedi leia flashback
& ASHOKA!
10:02 Okay for the people who actually didn't get it the first time like I did,
Basically, Jeremy said that the trip to Alderaan was originally meaningless, but coincidentally the Death Star happened to be there. Even though the reason they went to Alderaan in the first place was _because_ the Death Star was there.
Cinema sins gets a lot of stuff wrong in their videos but when the Dinoga attacked neither of you pointed out Luke is literally a moisture farmer his whole life has been farming water and has had experience with water.
Good video. :)
"Jedi master gets frustrated at obvious questions"
Yoda would be great at everything wrong with cinema sins.
0:30 Ackchyually The Bad Batch gives a canonical reason for why the stormtroopers have bad aim unlike the clonetroopers
Sading "this is the Way" while a Famous Mandalorian is on Screen.
Priceless
One thing I'd like to point out about the whole "how did the emperor know they would get a shuttle and yada yada." He probably didn't know. It doesn't matter how they got there, he simply gave them the information and left it to them to find their own way there. The rebel alliance is more than capable enough to make it to the shield generator on their own. If they weren't then the new Death Star would have been finished and it wouldn't have mattered anyway. He simply would have found another way to lure Luke in. However he'd already forseen Luke come so didn't need another plan because he knew it would work. It's the same thing with most movies with intricate plans that just work out. They probably didn't work perfectly, it's simply that smart people will make contingencies so if something important doesn't happen they can immediately follow up with the next thing. Guy doesn't get on the train, you have a planted taxi to pick him up instead. Or that thing when people complain about them catching the train at the right time to avoid getting caught. They most likely knew the train would be there because trains run on schedules, just buy a minute or two going the long way and you've got a good chance of pulling off the trick. Every plan comes with risks, we just see them work out because then the movie wouldn't happen.
Flipping Jake Skywalker should have trained Grogu because he should have learned that cutting off jedi from love or emotions was what led Anakin to the dark side
So Birdman! If you do an all in one with the spin-off films, Rogue One and Solo, will you add Clone Wars as a bonus as you never covered that one standalone?
I will never ignore that unarmed joke