Julia Hartley-Brewer Clashes With Ex-Labour Official Over Asylum Seekers!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ย. 2024
- Julia Hartley-Brewer from Talk TV spoke to ex-Labour official Richard Power-Sayeed about immigration. However it seems no matter how many times Julia has it explained to her, she doesn't understand the issue.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @maximilienrobespierre1
Patreon - / maxrobespierre
Amazon - amzn.to/2QoRauj
Facebook: - / maximilienrobespierre1794
Twitch - / max_robespierre
Merch - maximilienrobe...
Twitter - / maxfrobespierre
Buy Me A Coffee - www.buymeacoff...
#immigration
#asylumseekers
#smallboats
Credit: Talk TV
La La La La I don’t want to listen, what a terrible person Heartless Sewer is.
Wouldn't it be cheaper forTalk TV to have no guests and just let Julia rant to camera?
It's a figleaf to stop OFCOM shutting them down
Exactly
It is a way of pushing the talking points into the national conversation..... listen to people in the streets repeat these very lines.
😂😂😂
Give her a mirror and see how long it takes before she pecks her own reflection
Constant onterruptions from HB. Disgusting
When you have nothing substantive to say …interrupt!!
Right-wing debate tactics 101:
When you don't like the answer to your question, speak over the person you asked the question to until they shut up.
Lefty tactics 101 -Keep banging on about immigration while the country goes to shit.
It's so annoying and just plain rude. I hate it when people do this and you do see it a lot with right wing commentators and politicians. Let him finish a damn sentence! And these same people will moan about cancel culture and not being able to speak their 'truth'.
That's why one of the best at debating/being interviewed by right-winger is the American politician Pete Buttegieg. He regularly goes on FOX News and owns them in their home turf, by just not letting them get away with trying to talk over him.
He ignores them, doesn't take the bait, and just keeps making his point.
He doesn't stop when they interrupt and just continues speaking, not giving them a gap and not falling for their misdirects.
Mick Lynch is also good at doing that, although he also has the advantage that he comes across as a 'hard man' so he intimidates them.
Infuriating isn’t it! It just shows she has no interest in actually having a discussion.
@@slavbrav69 Who’s been censored?
She doesn't even listen. She doesn't allow him to speak. Her head is a small box full of nonsense 😔
Forgetting for political reasons or thick. My money's on thick.
Bullying people on the programme does not make her right! Sack her now!
As mince
Thick for sure! But to paraphrase Upton Sinclair: “ it is hard to get someone to understand something, when their salary depends on them not understanding it.
@@MrsGardiner She is doing her job *exactly* as Talk TV intends.
It's a propaganda channel, pure & simple.
Right wing propaganda.
@pollyannakarina Agreed. It isn't she fails to understand. It's more what he's saying runs contrary to what talktv viewers want and need to believe.
The fact she has to argue the point while her guest is speaking just demonstrates how little confidence she actually has in what she’s saying. She knows she can’t rebut what he’s saying, so she shouts over him to prevent her audience hearing it.
Auditory assault and bullying.
Once again showing herself up for the money grabbing TalkTV tripe presenter. The `UK`s very own little Fox News!
@GetGwapThisYear you are absolutely right. It's a classic tactic of the far right.
Hartless-Brewer knows that her arguments are false and don't stand up to scrutiny; but if you say something often enough some people will believe it. That's why she keeps on recycling her discredited claptrap. She's not stupid, she's just heartless.
The Brewer brewing up hate is her mission 🧙
@@kitty16vcat11 Julia Heartless Brewer.
@@timelwell7002 Julia Heartless-B'stard
@@austenkeith8891 heartless-sewer
MAX please don't give that woman a platform to spew her right wing views on us evil and obnoxious person
Credit to Richard for his persistence ❤
Credit to Julia for hers too. She’s fighting the good fight.
@@sg-zd8eb What good fight?
And for his patience. I was pretty much ready to shout for her to shut the f up almost as soon as she started talking over him.
@@user-su3eu4zu9z against people who hate this country and the people in it.
@sg-zd8eb don't b0mb their countries, destabilise their countries or steal their resources and they won't come to your shores. It's that simple!
This rude woman interrupts when the man tries to answer her question. What a terrible example to the young!
Out of interest, do you also comment or roll your eyes at JoBrien’s constant and I mean constant interruptions of the callers to his show? Of course you don’t as he ticks your political box. That’s a weird way of seeing things do you not think?
@@JoBloggs3rd-os6se I object to all interviewers or show hosts who interrupt the replies of their guests. The same applies to company or civil service chiefs who use the same rude technique on their subordinates.
She’s waffling on about it in the Sun, gets paid to do it. Another grifter.
Vile woman
Her head is so full of hate there is no room for facts
Julia HB is insufferable
Imagine being married to her.Hell on earth!!😅😅😅
Insufferable..She should shut up and let someone speak!!!!People should refuse to go on her programme!!!
She may be going through a
midlife crisis.
Whereas Alex is just having a nervous breakdown
That's a nicer word than what I was thinking!
@@user-ln3lh2pz8h She not going through a mid life crisis she has always been a pain!!!
Hartley Brewer asks question then continues to promote her version of reality whilst not letting interviewee answer.
Why is the guest even there? It’s obvious that she’s only interested in hearing her own voice and bullying anyone else who breathes oxygen.
Peculiar Heartless Sewer.
The ONLY time she demonstrated she may have a heart, was in that exchange with Ben Habib when claiming boat migrants deserved to drown in the channel.
😊
😂perfect
unruly Fart-Brewer
What's the limit?
Ignorance is not a motionless state. It is an active accomplishment requiring ever vigilant understanding of what not to know.
👍🤣🤣🤣!
Imagine if all the British boats that went out and colonized the world had been turned away :)
Or Brits who want a better life in Spain, France , The USA , Australia, Canada or New Zealand.
@@scooby1992we colonised 4 of those 6 for precisely that reason…..
It's not like they were welcomed. The natives fought back.
And they left.
@@ImBABYJANEHUDSONthey left Canada, the US, New Zealand and Australia? Those notoriously run & mostly populated by the native pre colonisation population countries…..
The art of a good interview is 90% the interviewee speaking, and 10% the interviewer. Harmless-Brewdog seems to believe the opposite is true.
Julia: Could you explain this to me?
Guest: Yes. Well....
Julia: Sorry, I'm gonna stop you right there
She's the kind of person who you say hello to,and then stand and listen for an hour.
@@Captain-l2p Hi Julia!
Julia: what kind of vile islamist language is that?!
@@Midnyte-l1qnice one.yes,she wouldn't grasp the concept of a friendly greeting.
@@Captain-l2psorry captain, I couldn't stand n listen to her for 5mins, jasus after an hour I'd step out in front of a bus😂
I am so sick of the racist hate in this country.
You and me both Audrey
@@hollies5841 And me!! Its so depressing and disheartening!!
Me at well was out last week with friends and the things he said was disgusting he wood put them in a mosque and set fire to it I now have turned my back on him the evel asterd 😮😮
I’m sick of funding illegal, note the word illegal immigrants. That doesn’t make me racist, it makes me sick of knocking my pan in day in day out to fund them that’s all.
This is why she is on the perennially unpopular Talk TV. Dense!
Breaking News: Global Britain doesn't understand international laws, again!
Whoever winds up that evil robot JHB should lose the key.
Everything winds her up. No key needed.
Julia Hatred-Spewer is a first class example for how stupid people always seem full of confidence while smart people are full of doubts.
You seem confident on that..but I have doubts
Ignorance, blind faith and cowardice is all you need to join the nationalists brexit movement...
The right always say they want a proper conversation on Immigration
When they get the chance they interrupt , talk over any point of view they disagree with and just say the same things
1 - it’s all Men
2 -they are in a safe country (anywhere else in the EU)
I don’t want immigrants in my country isn’t a conversation it’s a statement
But what's the point of a conversation with people who talk rubbish? None of the men crossing in dinghies meets the criteria of refugee status. End of conversation.
Julia has no intention of debating, she is there to perform the old hits to her viewers who are there to hear her Own the libs.
This confirms my initial impression of her. She is dim. She's arguing, but she doesn't actually understand what the discussion is about.
She went to Oxford!
@christinefiedor3518 so did Boris Johnson, doesn't mean he isn't as thick as mince.
@@christinefiedor3518 On a day trip I'm guessing. Clearly not for education but if so then that's wasted money.
@Northstander Great solution. Just make every illegal act legal and there won't be anymore crime.
She doesn't listen - awful woman.
Exactly.. Why bother having guests when you just talk all over them..
She's been grifting off this issue for years!
Brewer doesn't seem to understand we are NOT in the EU and the EU have NO right to stop them anymore than we would be legally able to stop someone stopping off on their way to America from Australia. How STUPID can you be?
She and others were told about this over and over again. But they think they can just break laws and it's fine.
She just wants somebody to shout at. Pointless going on if you wanted a proper debate.
A...She is wrong when she says the British public don't want!!
B...In what way does immigration affect her daily life?
B) It gives her a handy one liner to satisfy the gammonati
It affects her daily life in a huge way. She makes a living out of pushing out her nonsense.
Not in my name. How dare she speak for me.
At every election people voted for less immigration, fact!
She’s not wrong the majority don’t want it!
Why didn’t he say
"You've asked me a question. Have the courtesy to shut up and listen to the answer "
All she was doing was ranting over him, doing herself no favours in the process
Where has she been for the last 14 years while her tory party have been in power causing all this?
You could explain it as many times as you want, they don’t want to get it, it doesn’t fit their narrative.
Whats the point of asking a question, is she constantly talks over his answer?
Because their viewers believe that if you talk over your interlocutor, you own them. Simple bullying. For them it makes her look strong.
@@bobikdylan yes rather than ignorant and bigoted.which she actually is.
She does not even allow her guest to speak!
She presumes she talks for the people...She doesn't !!!!
She talks for the people who were raging 3 weeks ago and have now gone peculiarly quiet and are trying to downplay their rhetoric, realising they’re not the silent majority they thought they were
She does.
@@hamishanderson6738Nope !
@@korolev-musictodriveby6583 just because you're not affected - yet.
@@hamishanderson6738 Affected by what , exactly ? Everyone in Britain is , or is descended from immigrants . Everyone .
‘The Brewer’ doing her job perfectly brewing up hate! 🧙
she doesnt want to listen to the answers
Ex Daily Express journo doing right wing telly. Simplistic ideas for people who don't like to think. Always very pleased with herself. She adds zilch to public debate fully paid up member of Mike Grahams Republic.
The Brewer is perfect for brewing hate! 🧙
Heartless Hartley the Hater.
Julia blames her alarm clock going off on immigrants.
No compassion whatsoever.
Why not interview an Official from the Home Office. And explain why Conservative government. Closed all poinrs of Applications
🇮🇪🇪🇺
Why ask a question whose answer is obvious? It's clear they don't want anyone going to their country, except maybe trillionaires and people with 40 Nobel Prizes. And... I mean... their country, their rules. What bothers about about their whole approach is they keep blaming Europeans for their problems, be it those of us outside of the UK or our fellow Europeans living in the UK.
Good morning Max and all here ☕
She doesn’t need a guest speaker, Dear Julia could just tell her viewer what she thinks 🤦
What a despicable creature!!. That poor man, hats off to him for remaining calm, collected, patient and precise.
Blimey... the, highly logical "la, la, la I'm not listening", approach from this vile woman.
One advantage of having 'safe and legal' routes is that anyone then coming via other routes will in all probability not be granted asylum. They can be rounded up as soon as possible after they reach our waters, processed quickly and deported.
Just as was the case with the recent disturbances, the increased probability of being caught, along with speedy justice, make the most effective deterrents.
As for fixing the problem, which in my eyes is not getting someone else to take them, but making them 'happy' enough in their own country so they stay there. This, unfortunately, usually requires foreign aid.
However, I have heard it said, that it is cheaper to keep someone in their own country than it is to take them in as asylum seekers and process them. It is suggested that even after the misappropriation of much of that aid, the financials are still positive.
Now I do not have the figures to prove or disprove that statement, a statement I hope to be true, but I strongly believe that we should have a serious and open conversation about that as it will be based on facts, some of them uncomfortable ones, rather than ideology rooted falsehoods.
Ideology and bigotry must be replaced with pragmatism, even if that pragmatism leaves a nasty taste behind.
Vile woman. I remember seeing her during the Brexit campaign and thinking she was unhinged. Not surprised she ended up at GBeebies
👏👍 Psst- it's TalkTV !
Its whatever man.
How exactly does this woman know what the British public wants?
She is right, why is she wrong people are concerned what is happening in this country at the end of the day they came here Illegally they should not be here full stop.
Totally stupid to allow more and more people into the Country without the infrastructure to support them.
Absolutely.
Except we need them to build and maintain the infrastructure and supply the shortfall of doctors, nurses, care workers, tradesmen etc. - even crop pickers. Do you see much of that going on without them? They would also be paying taxes which is what is needed in order to afford to fund the infrastructure.
No point getting into an argument with her, as she'd always want to have the last word.
She won't just make sure she has the last word, she'll make sure you can't get in a single word
We live in a world where Jo Cox was shot dead and JHB has millionaire status
She tells people to come and explain something and then doesn't listen anything, the young fit males come first because they are the ones who are fit 'to work,'.
As Max says, people (including experts) have been explaining this to her for years.
They are also the ones who, for example would be most likely to have fallen foul of the Taliban, by helping British troups.
This woman loves the sound of her own voice and thinks that her opinions are are better than anyone else's.
horrible bully. well done this man for responding as best he could with her constantly talking over him.
Your point at around 5.00 is the crux of the whole issue, Max. Britain has a labour shortage. Unless women in this country are going to miraculously start giving birth to fully formed and qualified 18-year-olds during the next year, we are going to have a labour- and a skills-shortage for some time. We need immigration in order to plug those shortages. Without them, prices go up. Dramatically. Too many people just listen to what the populists spout and take it at face value. And her desperate attempt to get the Labour official to give a number of immigrants shows she's not got a credible argument left. But she will continue to shout over him. Because that's what Hartley-Brewer and many other mouthpieces like her do
I thought she wiped the floor with him.
I wonder if this guy was warned the reason he was invited on was not to have a two-way conversation with Heartless-Brute?
I think I'd say nothing and ask her if she has finished shouting and would she like me to respond.
Asks a question then just talks over the guest whenever they try to answer. Not sure why she even bothers having guests on!
British public fed up with the same desperate rhetoric , try and come up with workable answer , same old same old 😢
She’s still peddling the Lump of Labour fallacy!
If Hartlry-Brewer was a refugee and had a choice between staying in Japan or trying to get to New Zealand, I take it she'd settle for Japan.
Standard right wing response. Just shout over the person putting their point across.
How about the next time U.K. soldiers have to go into a conflict zone they take the kids and the mrs, maybe granny too, all this sh*t about why's it mostly young men making the crossing is such a stupid question, of course the fittest and strongest are going to be the ones to make such an arduous journey.
I'm a Spanish Hospital Operating Theatre Practitioner, trained at Guys and St Thomas in London and with over 35 years experience in the field. I would seriously consider returning to UK to practice that now much needed speciality, but they'll have to put my balls in a vise first!
That dreadful woman is talking over him. He is trying to explain and she will not listen.
They say an empty bucket makes the most noise, Brewer proves this point, thick as mince, quite sad really.
I love the way she profers her answer to the question she has just asked when she doesn't like what he's saying, then she asks another question to completely muddy the water!! 🤯
The shouty over Hartley Brewer
It’s impossible to have a reasoned debate with such a person. She talks over people when she disagrees.
The interviewers' GCSE add-on module of "shout the interviewee down until the audience has forgotten what the question was" gold medal goes to...😮
She is financially incentivised to not understand how it works.
She would loose her job if there were safe routes and Labour stopped the boats. She would have nothing to talk about.
They need to pay visa application fees like everyone else. Alot of immigrants do cash jobs. Illegal jobs off the books.
The woman takes the argument away from the question she’s asked because she doesn’t like the fact it’s getting the answer she wanted.
No. She'll never undestand why the demographics of Britain have to be drastically altered.
She knows what she's doing. Her audience would gladly put sea mines in the Channel, and have no interest in listening to reason, law, or compassion.
1. There is a legal means to get to the UK, used by hundreds of thousands of people every year.Why do Albanians pay thousands of Euro's to the 'traffickers' when they could buy a ticket on Ryanair for 45 euro?
2. By definition, anyone coming outside of that legal route is here illegally and should be deported, immediately and with no appeal.
3. According to one UN estimate I saw a few years ago, there were 60 million people wanting to come to the UK. Do you think we should allow all of them to come here?
4. If your answer to 3 is yes, the country is doomed (as Milton Friedman once said, you can either have a welfare state or open borders, you can't have both)
5. If your answer to 3 is no, then you agree with me that there is a limit, we just disagree on what that limit is.
1. Correct, but many are holidaymakers who come for a holiday, some overstay their visa allowance and become illegal, what's your argument?
2. Not entirely true. There is no law to stop people coming over the sea in small boats and applying for asylum.
3. The UN might have said there are 60 million potential asylum seekers around the world, but I don’t recall them saying that they all wanted to come to the UK, have you asked all 60 million if this is true?
4. Considering question 3 is ambiguous and probably not true, then there is no question to answer.
5. What you don’t explain is are you talking asylum seekers or those wishing to apply for residency permits, because there is a big, big, difference. Those applying under normal circumstances as did the 700,000 who were accepted last year can be easily controlled. But asylum seekers are just a few thousand and if accepted under international agreed terms can stay, those not qualifying must leave.
The last government created this situation with Brexit lies on immigration. Demonising a few thousand arriving in blow up boats is a distraction of our real problems, and its not immigration.
In Hateful Spewer’s case it’s not for political reasons, and it might not be because she’s thick, it’s because she’s getting paid handsomely to smother reality with rhetoric and dogma. She’s good at it too, as soon as a truth starts emerging she shouts all over it with these populist soundbites.
How many do we take Max?
We do need to stop this invasion.
She wants to put out all the negative energy about asylum seeks and avoid the positives.
I can't imagine why anyone would be 'desperate to get here' when they know people like Brewer live here... She puts me off and I'm a Brit...
Why does she bother asking questions if she's not going to listen to the answer?
Why is no-one mentioning that in 2050, when I'm 70 there will be the same number of people aged over 65 that between 21 and 65? That's the real issue, not immigration
If I shout louder than you I’m right !
Racists will racist.
We are told the boats are beautiful and a blessing. Why hasn’t she got the memo?
I noticed when he explains calmly and rationally she gets annoyed and shouts over him.
It's funny how much more of a understanding of an issue you learn, from just shutting up, and actively listen to what's being said.
she was really struggling with how reasonable he sounded 😂
*producer in ear* "demand some numbers, he's exposing the lunacy!"
She knows exactly what character she's playing.
Such smug facial expressions from her whilst going on about the right’s favourite topic of the last decade or so and criticising Labour for not having sorted it out in their month and a half of power.