I am from General Caste and I don't have any problem in reservation to SC/ST/OBC or to Anyone who deserve because they fight from the whole society to get a breath even.
I am brahmin and proud of that. But i respect all my dalit brothers and sisters. The main problem is that dalits didn't get education during those days. Education only can change everything.
@@Admirable582 bhai kese nukri nhi paoga konsi nukri ki baat kr rhe ho bhai pdhna sbhi ko pdta he agr kisi ko iit me jana ho to bohot zada mhnt krna pdta he ha 5_10% ka frk pdta he bs cutt of me aur sirf 25 22 % pure college me sc honga
@@abhijithjith3821yes yes when its comes to reservation it is very diplomatic but when it is comes to untouchablity you don't get any questions.. waa re wahh
@Only Tech🤣🤣mst joke mra hai tune pandit ko log 56 bhog lagate hai krya kram M dahej ki tarh truck bhr k daan dete hai Aur ek baat aur bro hamare gaon m pandit dakshina bhi lete hai, Ghr bi lete hai, Aur Mnpasand khana bhi
There are only 2% government jobs but almost all good professional courses' seats are covered by reservation. So by virtue of the college tag a person with lesser marks/aptitude will still land up in a better job.
What non-sense. U get reservation only till u enter a university. Exams are written by those ppl like all the others. Apart from govt jobs, there is no reservation anywhere else.
@@ajayws1377 IIT , ,AIIMS,IIMs (TOP COLLEGES) have 60% reservation TOP COMPANIES HIRE STUDENTS FROM IITs not LPU . WE HAVE 3-4 GOOD PRIVATE INSTITUTES IN INDIA . BITS PILANI(only private institute in top 10) IS NOT AS GOOD AS TOP 7 IITs as far as placements are concerned .. we have many shitty institutes in India .. Even if we BUILD 100 NEW IITs , COMPANIES LIKE AMAZON,GOOGLE,FACEBOOK,MICROSOFT WOULD NOT HIRE STUDENTS FROM EVERY IIT . Top companies do not have the time to interview students from every college .. OBC and EWS reservation is vote bank politics .. Ambedkar suggested 25% reservation for SC /ST . Sons and daughters of bureaucrats , govt. officers (3rd generation ) should not benefit from these policies .. They should be able to clear general cutoff . Dalits who drop out of school need help . NO ONE TALKS ABOUT THEM .Ensure free education for Dalits in schools ( 12th grade ) so that they don't dropout . Actually ensure school kids don't drop out because of money . College admissions should be on merit . Now don't give me ''Its a representation logic ''' Whats the point of representing sons and daughters of beneficiaries through quota when they had all the money to join top coaching institutes and clear the general cutoff. We are just representing few Uplifted families and their kids now . Affirmative action in USA is not as pathetic as reservation policy in India .. People who were never victims pretend to be victims .. Its a psychological problem now . ps: I'm against women's reservation bill ..
@@kamalkumar7978 for this first caste based reservation should be ended Instead give reservation to poor people. all the deprived people of st/sc would be covered
Apni badi badi cars par likhwaate hai Brahamand, Shatriye....ye bhi band hona chahiye...aap savarn hai iska ye matlab nhi hota aap khaas hai baaki sbse
Pahli baat unki marzi h car me Kya likhe SC St wale v likh Skte h . And mere dost v SC ST Maine insult nhi kiya Jo dusro ko caste ke basis pe insult krte h aur saazza sbko milta h
@@Bhakti_singh.21kviews aapne kitni gaadiyo par dalit,chamar yaa aur kch likha dekha hai...aajke samaj ne inshabdo ko gaali bana diya hai....saza ki baat mat kijiye aaj bhi honour killings bahut ho rhe hai kitno ko saza mili hai...aur rahi baat aap sc st ki insult nhi krte.. Aap insult kar bhi nhi skte...aapko itna haq hai bhi nhi
Tumhe ye knowledge lag Raha hai kyo. Ki tum bhi st SC hoge bro neutral hoke Socho agar Kisi padhe likhe parivar ko reservation mile vo Accha hai ya kisis Garib ke parivar ko
Indian govt. Provides reservations for IIM, IIT, AIIMS etc. Like Higher education. But didn't provide Primary health and education, so lower castes can't go to DPS or any other International schools, so their basics are poor even if they get into higher institutions they are dropping out
Reservation should me made only on basis of economic conditions but not on casts it only provokes the new generation of unreserved category , otherwise cast discrimination is dying
What do u mean to say? still I hav 1 question...suppose I want to fill up a application form of govt job. If I hav a reservation then I get many facilities such as no money to form fill up, age relaxation, travel allowance, and also reserved seat. but a middle class general student cant even get one of the following facilities. why man why? we r general student means we have lots of money? a sc/st student hav minimum 6/7 govt job exams per month because they hav no need of fees to fill up..but for middle class general student, we think many many times to fill up the form after all its about Rs. 500/1000 /1500 to fill up the form. No I hav no any anger with anyone because I m general & I hav capability to compete with anyone...magar mujhe exam me bathne to do...exam me bathne ke liye hi lagega 500/1000/1500...I m not rich in born...Kanhaiya kumar ji justify me...
ठीक है भाई, तुझे पैसे ज्यादा देने नहीं पड़ रहे, बस उन्हें पैसे कम देने पड़ रहे है | इसमें न तेरा फायदा है ना नुक्सान | हा sc/st का फायदा है | भाई किसी और का फायदा हो रहा है तो हम उस पर क्यों दुःख मनाये, हमको क्या लेना देना |(दुसरो का सुख देख कर क्यों रोये) तुम रोज 5रू. की चाय पिते हो, कोई दुःख नहीं | अगर एक दिन चाय वाले ने किसी को free मे चाय दे दी, तो तुम दुखी हो रहे हो की उसको free मे चाय मिल गई | ये क्या बात हुई | वैसे भी भारत मे sc/st संस्थाए है जो सरकार को पैसा देती है | सरकार को पुरे 500/1000/1500 ही मिलते है | Don't worry.
Ashok Arya ok just one answer I need to know that is, if there is a general student but he/she is not rich and can't afford for competitive and entrance exams, what should he/she do ? And if u support this caste system then r u ready to face too the discrimination and untouchability practices from general people ? If you are very rich and have got eligibility to afford a lots of opportunities and scopes to build your career, still is it fair to use your caste certificate card to get the advantage which is meant for poor persons ? Would u still call your country a secular nation ?
@@ashokarya5661 problem is not only exam fees but also opportunity ! say 1 lakh people applying for 100 positions , 40 general category positions are contested by 1 lakh people , but 28 by around 40000, and 15 by around 20000 , 10 by 18000, 7 by 10000, tho kisko milne ka chance adhik he? General wale ka fategi kisi aur ka nahin ! 40000, 20000, 10000 us 1 lakh mein bhi hoga dekh lena!
Only 3.5 % market job is reserved for all people including unreserved. Rest 96.5 % job is open to all people. So , keep that reservation for benefits of enjoying various people work together at least in government jobs. Other than govt ,remaining 96.5 % open to all. Even if education and nutrition made available equally to every child, let’s support reservation for various culture people work together. u pls propose for reservation in central govt jobs based on languages. Then , u may see real pluralism of India.
जय भीम जय भारत जय मुलनिवासी आर्थिक आधार पर रिजर्वेशन देने से गरीब sc, st, obc के अति पिछड़े झुग्गी झोंपड़ियाँ में रहने वाले अति गरीब विद्यार्थीयों को लाभ होगा,
Reservation is giving on the basis of caste but why still we are getting scholarship on exam fees and education fees on the basis of Caste if you giving jobs on reservation okay no prblm but why reservation on scholarship
ar un bacho se bhi pch jinhe same school mai jkr bhi sth bethne nhi diya jata ar bacho ke sth up bihar mai ek din apna naam se Agarwal htkr bhangi lga liyo tujhe pta lg jayega
@@Ragnar-xk4bc yeh reservation tumhe hamesha bhangi bane rehne dega..kabhi aage nahi badne dega...kyunki yeh gap ko bada raha hai....mere dost ka naam arvind gautam...toh mujhe mat gyaan de..main Agra se hu...iss bewakoof ki baate mat suno..yeh sirf baat raha hai hume..
@@nikhilagarwal4438phli baat to mai bhangi nhi hu ar na apne aap ko kisi se chota mnta hu pr jis din desh se jati khtm krne ki baat kroge na us din mai reservation ka khud virodh krunga agr bina caste khtm kre reservation khtm kiya to shyd backward class ko uska representative na mil paye jaise supreme court mai ek bhi obc sc st judge nhi hai
@@nikhilagarwal4438 ar backward class ke logo ko aaj bhi mandir mai nhi jane diya jta agr koi apni shadi mai ghodi pr bethne pr goli mr di jati hai ye bhi reservation ki vjh se hai ? agr tumne 70 saal jati khtm krne ki baat kri hoti to aaj reservation hi khtm ho gya hota ar tu hoga Agra se tera dost kn hai mujhe usse mtlb nhi pr jo aise incidents hote hai uska bhi utna hi virodh kiya kro jitna reservation ka krte ho
@@Ragnar-xk4bc bhai hum bhi toh wahi keh rahe haireservation koi raasta nahi hai casteism ko khatam karne ke liye ....sirf education se khatam ho sakta hai....reservation se sirf nafrat bad rahi hai....aur kanahiya kumar jaise log iska faayda utha rahe hai....
@@xrxnpop1222 That's not our problems. It's problems of hindusim then. If u feel inferior or u treat as lower class tgen change ur religion . Problems khatam. JEE/NEET/UPSC/STATE EXAM main gen catogory sc se 120 jada marks lekar bhi seat nahi mil rahi hai. Aur inko caihe e reservation. Haha
Reservation is given to uplift ppl of socially backward castes. Even if the upper caste ppl are in less number compared to the lower caste ppl in over all population .. look at the world around u . In every high positions of the society there u can find only a few lower caste ppl, majority are upperclass ppl. Y so?? Inorder to bring lower class ppl to stand with the upperclass ppl in all aspects reservation is given. And it is necessary to achieve equality. That is why reservation quotas are given in exams like these ok.
Reservation low casts valliki kavali antaru kada asulu casts aaa teasvochu kada appudu chappu poor ke kavali chuduvokataniki help 👍👍not reservation students should develop 👍then india can develop 👍
Vse to government bolti he kye hme accha doctors or minded ainsan chaia too aune me yea khana chata huu kye Sc or st ke neet exam 200hoe or general vla ke 500 hoe too bhi phala SC ST phala latte he .aune phala doctor banaia jte he .hb200marks or 500marks ka difference too dakho doctor kaa sahi gyan kisme hooga?
Bhai, training toh ek jaisi hogi na, Aur Company toh Eligible ko job degi na.. Aur Kanhaiya sir ne kya bola suna nahi, Ki 98% jobs Private hain.. Toh wahan toh nahi chalta na Reservation,phir kaise kehte ho ki Reservation se talent kharab ho rha hai.
@@vivekkoul5479 toh itni cutt off jti h ...toh seedha khatm kr do na reservation smjh aa jyega ki 20-30 number mei bhi kitni rank chli jyi...fir kyu rote ho reservation k liye jb sbki cutt off barabar h toh
If reservation is due to casteism then, casteism is variable throughout the nation then why not reservation. If a SC student from a village where casteism exists gets a job though reservation it would be correct but if a sc student living in an urban city where casteism has no place why he should have that privilage that should only be given to village one and why in equal quantity
Then people should create another solution . Instead of pointing out reservation, find another solution to caste discrimination. Reservation was made because of it. People only think about outputs with no outcomes. Reservation should be removed ,but first do we have any other solution to remove casteism.
Do you really think that there is no discrimination in urban areas if you think so just check the matrimonial section in the newspaper and ask many people about it you would find it out easily
@Only Tech well if you want then it's good but what i meant was many parents force their offspring to marry a person of their own community even if the child is liking someone else
@Only Tech anyways man i can't reply or explain a lot coz i am not in the situation right now so try to understand it and don't reply until it's too necessary to talk about
Wah kya baat hain. 2 percent hain kyunki 90% jobs agriculture, labourers aur service industry (waiters etc) ye log kar rahe hain. Ab kya kheti mein bhi reservation chahiye? Dhang ki jobs India mein 5% hi hain. Usme se 2% mein reservation aur baaki mein ghusne ke liye IIT ya IIM jaha alag reservation laga hua hain. Sale kuch bacha hain jaha reservation nahi hain? Agar private jobs mein reservation nahi hain, toh IIMs mein bhi nahi hona chahiye na. Sale chootiye statistics bhaunkne se pehle dimaag lagaya kar.
@@yashyete883 par woh government jobs toh nahi hain na. Tab 2% hi kaise hue government jobs. Aur army bhi toh government ke andar hain. Waha lagwa ke dikha reservation.
@@yashyete883 TOH BHAI YE KANHAIYA HI NHI KOI EK DRAFT BANAYE TO RATIONALISE RESERVATION. JO yahi caste wale ek hi pariwaar ke 100 logo ko reservation milta hai galat hai to ye ek draft banaye taki jab hum ye soch bhi paaye ki khi reservation flaw free rahe gaareeb ko mile na ki iss kanahiya ke baache .
Reservation was given for representation of specific community, it's high time to review reservation system. And all the premier private jobs are filled by reservation, talk about entry in IIT,IIM,LAW ,AIMS etc.
Yes 90% of People who Do Toilet Cleaning Work Belongs to Sc/st Community Me Myself Belong To SC community And My Family Right From My grand Father To My Father we Use To Clean Toilets of Public
Beta tum log general ke paison pe upar aate ho iit mein sc st ko 3000 fees air general ko 2800000. Humari fees ke paison se tumhe padhaya jaa raha hai.
@@GamingZone-ql4fi General walo ne Sc St ke paise bhi to apne pass rakhe hue h .. Jo property pure 90% sc st ke pass h .. Utni hi aur uss se jyada property 10%general ke pass h ..
Inequality ashe hui ki jaab ek 90 percent wali ki naukri nahi lagi jinse itni mehnat ki aur ek 60 percent ki lagi jisne mazak mai saal kaa diyaa yaha hui hai baat
@abhishek mohapatra oye, you talking about fair chance and equality and then you still talk about how reserved category people are dumb and they get admitted to jobs and colleges because of reservations. Let me tell you. First you go and look at the college admission list, the person who got reserved seat must also have high marks to get the seat. So in the category list too only learner and capable are selected. You are just biased and selfish and talking hypocrisy nothing else. I'm SC I got 91.5% for tenth 88 for twelwth, 92.5% for degree( college first rank) 88.5% for MSc ( college second rank) got admission for PhD with JRF. But for all these admissions I got seat under SC reservation. And the other one who got the other seat out of the two seats for SC ( he was topper in his college). So I don't know how reservation is unfair? Actually this society is unfair, because you so called general categories have this thought that people who get researved seats are unworthy, dumb and stupid. Do first change your attitude then we will discuss about other things!!!!!!!
@@radheyshyamsharma6598 you general category represent about 23% of indian population and rest of the 55% of seats are reserved for general category that is you enjoy more than 2x times your population percentage. When about 16.6% is SC and only get 15% reserved seats and 8.5% of ST population get only 7.5%reservation then rest 43% OBC gets only about 22% reservation seats. Actually you are sitting on the 55% seats for only 23% of you guys. Tell me what are you bickering about. And since your reservation percentage double your population represent you won't get higher cutt off.
@abhishek mohapatra you general category represent about 23% of indian population and rest of the 55% of seats are reserved for general category that is you enjoy more than 2x times your population percentage. When about 16.6% is SC and only get 15% reserved seats and 8.5% of ST population get only 7.5%reservation then rest 43% OBC gets only about 22% reservation seats. Actually you are sitting on the 55% seats for only 23% of you guys. Tell me what are you bickering about. And since your reservation percentage is double your population representation you won't get higher cutt off.
Root cause is casteism. "Every action has an equal and opposite reaction". Once there was a time when there were no access of education,clean water, higher job to such people. There were practice of untouchability and discrimination on the basis of caste etc. Now also in many region, it is practiced. I myself can see this in my society. In rural areas it happens at extream level. B. R Ambedakar had reached higher position on his own while going through inequality and exploitation. He had a very tough time to even access the education and then he used such power to bring revolution against inequality on the basis of caste. Demolish inequality on the basis of caste, then demolish reservation. It is illogical to discriminate on the basis of caste. Why certain group of people is called "lower caste" or "upper caste" just because their ancestors were engaged in certain job.
Thats why we have police and judiciary sister . Why he is not talking about the biggest problem which is enforcement of democracy and judiciary . Haar gya hu main aise student neta dekh ke. Fir kuch young environmentalists aaynge aur Aarey ko bachaynge kisse?? 100 % electric metro se . Y don't they sit on a dharna for charging station and Electronic vehicle in mumabi. And every hotels and residents should have rain water harvesting and solid waste management with water waste management . Why not 😔😔.
Mam apne newton ke law ko galat interpret kiya hai usme hai na opposite reaction to jo bura karega to uska opposite to achha hua na . WAISE BHI APKE BABA SAHEB AMBEDKAR KA EDUCATION KA INTZAM UNHE ENGLAND BHEJNE KA KAM EK BRAHMAN NE HI KIYA THA JINHONE AMBEDKAR APNA TITLE UNKO DIYA. 😎😎😎😎 U R REALLY LIKE MY SCHOOL TEACHER STUPID
right, i belongs to a sc caste .i do not want reservation but stoping practice of untouchabilty and discrimination,hate negative mindset towards our category.
@@nareshbhoina4308 bro you take reservation or not... Judgement of people are on the basis of caste only they do say they aren't castic but that not true.... Caste will never leave caste is important to them to gain pride and respect.... Only thing you can do is to work hard and get big marks
M govt clg m hu...mere+2 m 86% tha last seat thi... mereko hta kr 75% wali ldki ko lia gya...mai general hu ..uski wajah se mereko 1 saal baad admission lena pda..ab meri class m 90 % bache SC he...and unmese 75 %bht acche background se aate h ..wo scholarship se iPhone lete h ...jbki humko pura saal kaam krke % maintain krni hoti...esa kyu?
Nobody cares about general category. Just answer one question, who in this world would let go the benefits even if they are rich. Only reservation for poor SC/ST students should be there.
मैं एक DHEEWAR जाति OBC श्रेणी हिंदू था लेकिन, लेकिन 12 वीं कक्षा में उच्च जाति के हिन्दू ने मेरे साथ बहुत भेदभाव किया जो मुझे बहुत आहत करता है, तब मैंने महसूस किया, कैसे mere अनुसूचित जाति और अनुसूचित जनजाति और ओबीसी जाति के भाई aur beheno के परिवार ko सामना करना पड़ा। मैंने अपना धर्म बदलकर ISAI धर्म कर लिया . Jab jab hindu tutega tab tab hinduo ka naash hoga.
Saalo tum logo or Karan hamara Hindu dharm barbaad ho Raha hai sirf kuch paiso ke liye dusre dharm ko apna Lete ho Hindu ho to raho na bhim rao abmedkar ne dharm Nahi badla tha wo ahinsa se lade the
@Rishy Singh reservation is not the method of removing caste system reservation tmh itna strong bnata hai (financialy socialy )ke tm us discrimination ko face kr sko
Yup reservation should be on the basis of economic background so that these caste supremacists will still be respected for their caste and also they dont have any financial worries to educate their children.
Why can't the government remove reservation to those who, though are from backward castes, belong to a well to do family ??? It's easy to find out using their tax returns and it is well to do because the father has already availed the benefit of reservation. If a person whose father is a having a plum job that earns him more than 20 lakhs per annum, then does this person still need reservation ??? So simple solution for the benefit of the really poor people who are from backward castes, the reservation must not be applicable for anyone whose father has already availed the benefit of reservation and can now support his son. This way, the marginalized person can really benefit. Reservation can be there but to only those that really need it.
Only 3.5 % market job is reserved for all people including unreserved. Rest 96.5 % job is open to all people. So , keep that reservation for benefits of enjoying various people work together at least in government jobs. Other than govt ,remaining 96.5 % open to all. Even if education and nutrition made available equally to every child, let’s support reservation for various culture people work together. u pls propose for reservation in central govt jobs based on languages. Then , u may see real pluralism of India.
If this so called reservation continues, do not expect the deserving and talented candidates to stay in this country and ask them to serve on the name of "patriotism" despite of this discriminatory system. Do not blame them for leaving n working in other countries and calling them anti patriots. Keeping increasing the quota, it's 60 percent today, tomorrow it will be 70 and one day no jobs would be left for the deserving. Keep bringing amendments that drown this country's economy and deceleration.
desh ko barbad karke chodega reservation. Mere gali me sab Sc St ke ghar wale Govt. job me hain and unke bete bhi.. mere number jyada h fir bhi Private collage se graduation kr rha hu and economically weaker bhi hu. Time aayga sabka badla lia jaiya.. kab tak yeh log reservation ke aad me chup ke sab kuch le painge.. and one more thing IT'S high time to treat differently i honestly never did it with my friends but how could they expect us to treat them in the same way when they are getting perks from government. .. me toh nhi karunga abse kabhi kabhi..
@@shreyanshpareek7876 bahut bura haal hai bhai ..abhi hum kuch bi bolenge .comment karenge toh .wo bolenge hamko pichale 5000 saalse shoshan kiya tha.mandir jane diya etc...mera dost log SC aur ST ka hai saare govt medical collge pad rah hai aur wo amir bi hai ..mujhe dekhe haste hai ..
and if reservation is discontinued then do expect 'one' India as different caste groups will naturally want to have their own development and own land because of high disparity in government functioning.
Yes it's better for government to make a fund for general candidates who want to leave the country because if reservation , government fails to provide seats to general candidates and also creates discrimination
Resevation rhe likin etna Jayda nhi general toh maara jaa rha hai 70% category reserve 30% bas unreserved hai 30 % jurm kar rha hai sabka uper Aur dsri baat shaddi jisko nhi karni hai dsri caste wah nhi kar RHA hai everyone has the liberty to choose their life how they want to live Girls ko reservations dena chahiye
SC/ST : why are the sellout and greedy general category talented people leaving the country ??!? Also SC/ST : We are completely entitled to reservation because of a 130 year old system and our learning power is affected by our caste.
@@MrCooldude987Thats not our problem! And it's very less in today's date. While doing reservation nobody thought about it's I'll effects, if it was meant for overall development of society, why the hell it's still there? After about 30-40 yrs of bringing reservation into picture, govt passes a bill in parliament to carry it on, this is where we mess up. Why the hell people in today's gen are able to exercise the benefits of something which should've been exercised by their elders/ancestors? Reservation was not meant to give somebody an additional advantage, it was to make the society compatible from all aspects. But none of the governments analysed where is the flaw! Many deserving people were left behind, are being left behind, will be leaving behind. 😑
@@dhananjaya.gujarathi664 manisha balmiki!!!!! first of all get up and move to western up and tell the people there u belong to any sc caste u wil know what we go thorough ur daily life.....its not u who has been told by his teacher that u r not capable enough to learn because u were born to clean the sewage....
@@HimanshuKumar-ee5lu That will not be the scenario if everyone gets into fair competition, obviously when you get something by reservation and you've not worked it out as per it's requirement, understanding, you'll face challenges.
@@dhananjaya.gujarathi664 sir this is not like we are given reservation before exam we also came same as u but after math of exams and selection process shows us benefits and also just go to western up have a nice vlog on yt if u are soo adjured to making comments and mention urself as an sc ot st....u will know what i am saying....definitely u would not be same if womens of ur house would never be allowed to cover their upper body or ue ears and eyes would be melted if u listens to any sacred poety sang in name of god....if u have not suffered then democracy may allows u but not a well educated HUMAN...
Most of the reserved students end up dropping out becoz of the difficulty in coping with better students in prestigious universities. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit. Same Dalits would have gotten degrees in less prestigious colleges
Bro...the main reason behind the college dropouts of backward caste is that 85% of them belong to rural hindi medium backward govt schools.....If they are given proper guidance and counselling in the prestigious colleges ,they would perform much better than GC students
@@arpitmandawat563 yeah. Like 85% of backward caste reside in northern states where hindi is spoken? I live in a state where backward castes even in English medium schools still have poor results. Care to explain me why?? In us state California, removed reservation (affirmative action) and results were that the oppressed groups had 55% increase in graduation. Turns out more people of oppressed groups were graduating without reservation.
@@stallonegodinho6296 Bro...I don't know about California so I'll not speak about it....But don't you think casteism is still iving in one form or another...Seeing some rich people doesn't define the whole community...Firstly we should abolish caste system from the mindset of the people. Than the reservation should be removed instantly and should be done on economic basis (I also want Economic Reservation lol)...And I live in a hindi speaking rural are So i wrote it just to give a better look to my answer.... PS:- I am a Rajput (General Cat guy)
@@arpitmandawat563 Caste system is abolished. Look at the constitution of India. Also reservation was never to eliminate the caste system. The reservation was kept for 10 years. And it was continued for vote bank politics. It's been 70years since independence. Yet caste continues, so it's clear that reservation on caste can't eliminate caste. Why support a failed system which is exploited by politicians for vote banks??? There's no need for economic reservation. Becoz brilliant people from poor background don't need reservation, they need financial support.
Aur vohi log amir hai socho country me gareeb aur in 5-10 % amir ke bich kitna difference hai aur yr hi 5-10% ki vajah se gdp hamara accha hai aur hame lagta he ke hamare desh se garibi dur ho rhi hai😅😂
JEE main me agar SC/ST walo ko sirph caste ke base per hi kam marks per badhiya branch milegi toh ghatiya quality ke hi engineer niklenge toh sooch lo desh ka kya hoga ?
i agree with you .. engineering and b schools /professional schools should never have reservations .. its just stupid .. fees should be waived off only for the poor . i scored 90 percentile in CAT and I''ll be trying again next year .. CAT ,JEE cutoff is ridiculous for SC/ST/OBC .
SC Category people thinking only for Reservation. Reservation is temporary not permanent. SC Category people treated badly in British India by Hindu Dharma not by Royals. For suffering of SC Category why Royals are Punished or Discriminated ? Royals have not made Castism & Hindu Legislation/Laws. Who made/written Castism is not important but who implementing this Hindu Legislation/Laws is important question.
Before discussion on Reservation every Indian should know the facts about Reservation that RESERVATION IS ACTUALLY substitute & REPLACEMENT of INDIAN CONSTITUTION. Why need to know this ? Because when Indian constitution not implemented & we are not having rights according to Indian Constitution since 1950 so Court has no right to punish anybody. Instead of Indian constitution our country is run by Hindu Legislation/Laws of Castism. So How can Court of India give justice according to Indian constitution ?
Caste main wajah hai discrimination ki.. and caste is is based on work and who can get the education.. or hazaro sal tak yehi kiya or ab economic basis pe solution cahte hai.. they don't want to solve the caste problem or issi se or jant jalta hai.. they want to eliminate the solution itself... Koi sense hai.. ikka dukka case hota hai jaha lower caste wale ki background achi ho.. per kya discrimination caste k basis pe hota hai? Yes hota hai or economic basis pe bhi hota hai.. the funny part is u can always improve ur economy but u can't improve ur caste..
Yah it is very big problem St vaalo ka selection 58 pe General vaalo ka 78 pe It is real experience of exam Esa nhi hai ki mai Ese hi bol rhe hai Ye ekdam Galt hai
@@doctorwithdreams4037 oh yeah? Do you have any scientific evidence? What about BR Ambedkar? What about former president K R Narayan? What about Narendra Jadhav? What about Satyendra Murli? What about Pa. Ranjith? What about president Ramnath Kovind? What about Namdeo Dashal? And many more. They are all belonging to backward classes.. They are all prime examples of what backward people can do when given the opportunity and support that they deserve. Intelligence doesn't come from caste you 'the one that lack both intelligence and common sense' !!
🙏 ek baar padho ..I am studying MBBS .i belong to lingayat caste ..i dont get any benefit from government .I got this seat after repeating one yr ..studied day n night .i got 977 rank in Karnataka cet.but i have friends who belong to ST and SC caste their rank was 8000.9000.11000.and they got seat in medical college (govt)...and they also get scholarship up to 50,000₹ every year and books, laptop, and again reservation in PG seat ....where one of my religion friend who also dropped a yr with me secured 3500 rank .yet he did not get seat even in private college also ..he was desperate to become doctor .now plzz whoever reading this belonging to any caste give the reason why we should suffer ..do u think there are no poor people in our caste ........ doctor must have the passion to save patient ,he should have sufficient knowledge .he should not fall behind money....if you make someday doctor who do not deserve.. he will kill the patient ..and it is happening ..dont think becoming doctor is too easy ...you will be beaten in public.., in hospitals...u read it everyday in news agar ek engineer galti kiya toh chalta hai .magar ek doctor ka galti bahut keemthi hai..aap hi samjho ..kisko doctor banna chahiye .. ye reservation sirf padahyi me kyn, Acting,business,dancing,singing, cricket,sports,aur saare kshetrome kyn nahi..sirf education me kyun hai...politics me toh hai..woh alag baat ..reservation should be made in everything not only in making doctor or etc... .passing in MBBS is very easier than getting seat in competitive exam..any one can pass ...only thing is u have to get seat ..in private college it is still worst .. the college management allows you to copy openly .they use Bluetooth devices to copy ..everyone in college knows that ..but since students gave them huge donation in crores and lacks they dont say anything to them ...even in Govt college University exams you write anything ..all ramayana and mahabharat story in paper ..they pass you blindly ..getting a UG and PG seat is very very very difficult my friend ..out of 6laks of students appearing in NEET exams only few thousands seats are allowed .for that competition is huge ..especially if one belongs to general category...
@@NoneNone-og2th abe nahi tumhe milna chahiye reservation hum bade log hai thoda bohout to chote logo ko uthana chahiye aisa tumhare bolne ke tarike se lag raha hai
Why do everybody take this 2% govt job to justify the caste base reservation.. But why don't they take in count the reservation in Education sector(like IIT, NIT AIIMs etc). A candidate getting admission in these institutes on Caste bases and geeting private jobs on that basis should also be added to those 2% jobs on reservation.
oye, you talking about fair chance and equality and then you still talk about how reserved category people are dumb and they get admitted to jobs and colleges because of reservations. Let me tell you. First you go and look at the college admission list, the person who got reserved seat must also have high marks to get the seat. So in the category list too only learner and capable are selected. You are just biased and selfish and talking hypocrisy nothing else. I'm SC I got 91.5% for tenth 88 for twelwth, 92.5% for degree( college first rank) 88.5% for MSc ( college second rank) got admission for PhD with JRF. But for all these admissions I got seat under SC reservation. And the other one who got the other seat out of the two seats for SC ( he was topper in his college). So I don't know how reservation is unfair? Actually this society is unfair, because you so called general categories have this thought that people who get researved seats are unworthy, dumb and stupid. Do first change your attitude then we will discuss about other things!!!!!!!
@@mrudhulamohank328 if you guys are worthy by marks then why to use reservation in this case? who is stopping you get good marks and get opportunity by only ability not reservation
@@robmoody4710 bhaiiii chodo wo sab caste dicrimination to nahi par discrimination to usa me bhi colour ko lekar origin ko lekar par wahan reservation nahi laga aur talent ke dum par oppurtunities mili isliye usa aaj superpower hai lalu yadav bolta hai ki reservation hum kabhi hatne nahi denge aakhri tak rahega isse kya dikhta hai
arey bhau 2% ki baat to krdi but engineering colleges , medical Colleges ke admission me jo reservation lgta hai main problem to vo bhi hai sir. or to or scholarship me bhi reservation lgta hai . Ab to promotion me bhi reservation ki baat chal rhi hai..
Remove Cast Based Discrimination then Remove Reservation . We are suppressed & harrassed by Upper Caste PPL so these people want to harrass us at the same time want our reservation to be ended. Wao !
Kuch Bhi Ho Successful To General Me Sa Obc Me We hi Hope Hai Inhe Kitni Bhi Reservation MilJaye Sunder Pichai Google Seo Hai Vo General Me Atte Hai.Brahmin Hai
Kanhaiya Kumar is not Martin Luther actually he is Martin Chutad of India 😂 he is just Communist who openly support Communism & that's why he lost the election against BJP😁
I want to abolish reservation. If the living conditions of dalit is bad, it show how much ineffective reservation is after this much year . if discrimination is done against Dalits, is not solved by reservation, but by putting laws against such people who discrimination . Weather such laws exist ,or is it strong? After civil rights movement progress amoung black is not solve by reservation, but through laws which take strong action against people who discrimate.
Mai lower category se mujhe resvestion h...Maine entrance exam qualify kiya...lekin Mai tb pareshan ho gyi jb mujhe log Kahne lage ki tmko pta h general wale Kitna mehnat krte h..ha Maine mna nhi kiya ki wo mehnat krte h....pr wo nhi jante ki resvestion kyu h...jis Tarah se us din mujhse wo log bahas kr rhe the mai akele kya hi bolti😣...Mai bs unhe bolna chahti thi phle resvestion ko smjho phir bahas kro
Me bolu reservation kyu he.. .....bas us lavde ke wajah se jo likh ke bhool gya kah band karna he. Us saale ne carodo ki life barbad kardi. Me uske photo se gaand saaf karta hu.
Discrimination ha to reservation bhi hona chahiye ,mere ek dost ko chamar chamar bola karte the sab school me , mujhe matlab nahi pata tha . Discrimination haaaa. Hatao usko pehle.
@@Mayank-to4tv correct bro, he is not some God that he is 100 percent right, he is manipulating a simple theory of economic based reservation to sewage workers and 2 time ki roti and all.
@@_prashthink what happens agar iske Jaise log India ke prime minister ban Gaye I think Modi ne gen ews laa Kar bahut Accha Kiya right now he is in congress
Reservation honi bhi chahiye to sirf unke liye jinko unki jarurat hai by caste nhi kyunki ab hamre desh mai sirf sc st obc hi nhi balki general ki kai family hai jinki family background kamjor hai lekin phir bhi unke bache padh kar acha marks late hai lekin reservation ke karan unke merit ko nagarandaaz kar diya jata hai
इसलिए आरक्षण economic status देख कर दिया जाना चाहिए ताकि जो गरीब का बच्चा हो उसे मिले चाहे वो किसी भी जाति का हो। जो sc/st obc के गरीब लोग है वो वैसे ही आ जाएंगे।
oye, you talking about fair chance and equality and then you still talk about how reserved category people are dumb and they get admitted to jobs and colleges because of reservations. Let me tell you. First you go and look at the college admission list, the person who got reserved seat must also have high marks to get the seat. So in the category list too only learner and capable are selected. You are just biased and selfish and talking hypocrisy nothing else. I'm SC I got 91.5% for tenth 88 for twelwth, 92.5% for degree( college first rank) 88.5% for MSc ( college second rank) got admission for PhD with JRF. But for all these admissions I got seat under SC reservation. And the other one who got the other seat out of the two seats for SC ( he was topper in his college). So I don't know how reservation is unfair? Actually this society is unfair, because you so called general categories have this thought that people who get researved seats are unworthy, dumb and stupid. Do first change your attitude then we will discuss about other things!!!!!!!
First off all i am 14 years old and i am only giving my opinion i am not saying that reservation is bad i am only saying that reservation by caste is bad i am saying that all the people whethther sc st obc general should enjoy reservation if they really need it. If my opinion hurts you i apologize
@@Ayushkumar-du2pl you general category represent about 23% of indian population and rest of the 55% of seats are reserved for general category that is you enjoy more than 2x times your population percentage. When about 16.6% is SC and only get 15% reserved seats and 8.5% of ST population get only 7.5%reservation then rest 43% OBC gets only about 22% reservation seats. Actually you are sitting on the 55% seats for only 23% of you guys. Tell me what are you bickering about. And since your reservation percentage double your population represent you won't get higher cutt off. So reservation system is based on population ratio. And if you are educated and wise and rational and know some biostatistics, this is a fair and square system except you guys get more that is double your population size ( 23% population) that is 55% of the seats. So you guys are at advantage. I don't know why you are bickering about. If Govt jobs and education opportunities are not reserved according to the demography and different castes and races are not included then that is the hinderance of equality.
Many semi-literates are commending this tragic comedy, why are you talking about 'aprathyaksh ' reservation? I personally don't have a caste , many are there who don't take forward their caste name and they are left in the race alone while for some it is booked? why should anyone who respects equality , be punished by diminished probability ? I don't see people the way my forefathers have seen ! just Imagine saying indians must fight for reservation in 100m event in olympics to win it! how foolish? Just because people from one ethnic origin are winning it doesn't mean 100 m event medals are reserved for them, they get it by hardwork like, are chinese protesting for wanting of first place NO, just because they're numerically superior (bahujan) NO, they work through it. just by preventing zealous, equality oriented credible , general category candidates for making others enter just because they are from some politico-caste is like making jamaicans/medal winning ethnic racers stand 50 m back , making them handicap and run in the 100 m event in Olympics. Look at his political tactics he clearly talks sociological aspects alone, doesn't care to look at how it worked? Reservation is a failure, but what has been there let it be there , instead we must strongly oppose casteism , discrimination bring behavioral change, give them economic benefits, BEWARE TOMORROW general category will become discriminated , eye for an eye is never a solution. Those winning olympics today esp. running , were descendants of mistreated ethnic race, but they rose above it to become an inspiration to all. Then , when you come into Job perspective there is no high no low, all are same, you have to serve INDIANS not your caste!!! Reservation in education to an extent is understandable , but in jobs NO Saying why Ambani's son is rich is like asking how eaglets have the luck of flying, blaming the cause for the effect is perpetual you keep on blaming till you find it has no meaning. Reservation has made us lose the most valuable Human Capital to USA and Europe! 50% open means 50% opportunity to all , not General alone, please leave it alone (now it is 40.5%) Jobs need to be created not stolen. Sanitation job also has dignity like any other job don't say it is lesser. Temple pujaris are related to religion , govt jobs are not!
@Crimson Sash I have had no privileges , infact my caste (general) suffered at the hands of brahmins ,but still we believed in hardwork to become Diwans, PM of Cochin etc. I studied in govt school and my father started as a clerk in govt (cracked the exam through hardwork) with a house full of sisters, brothers who couldn't be employed (reservation) , errands in his house made him indebted and it led to full of financial problems myriad!!
No body arguing not to have Caste based reservation But Care should be taken not to provide for unreasonable, excessive or extravagant reservation, for that would, by eliminating general competition in a large field and by creating wide-spread dissatisfaction amongst the equal righted citizens, materially affect efficiency. Therefore beyond the permissible and legitimate limits of 50% would be liable to be challenged as a fraud on the Constitution. Note : Maratha reservation struck down for above reason. Now Reservation is for Vote politics. Politicians give reservation for Votes but Court thinks, they are monitoring Constitution which is only meant for Social equality of casts. We Stuck between Devil and Sea.
There are alot of loop holes which kanhaiya is not saying!! If a new born baby is struggling with a life threatening disease, or is born conjoint, or born differently abled is that also a reservation!! There's a difference between Rajneeti and Dharam Raj. Rajneeti can't be done on Siddhant!!
Giving Reservation to any of the caste is not a solution to the cruelty of Indian Hindu Culture But treating every human & woman equally is the solution. If Indian Dharma or politics order to cut down genitals of any woman or girl then cut down EVERY Indian girl & women's genitals. Treating everyone equally is the solution. Everybody have right to live their life with human dignity. And if not then treat everyone equally. Our human body is the greatest Gift of God so Destroying human body in inhuman ways(cruelty) is INSULT OF THE CREATOR OF UNIVERSE/GOD. Praising creation of God is the greatest way of worshipping God.
same as saying one religion terrorised and converted all other so all those where descendants of those affected should treat the descendants of that religion similarly! how rubbish! Period! Gandhiji taught us tolerance not revenge
@@Anirban_Biswas. a lot of rich guys in lower castes. Why give them reservation. We want caste + economy based reservation. The rich lower caste can afford to study for government job 15 hrs a day. The poor lower caste guy can only study after coming from work. He said reservtion is flawed but he didn't say what the flaw is. Then he supported caste reservation just like the other Neta's .
@@abhijithjith3821 justify kaise karega tu? Kaun garib or kaun amir?? Abhi bhi samaj me inequality hai or jab tak yeh rahega tab tak caste reservation rahna chahiye..
Reservation will create more caste disparity .Just look the statistics of top colleges iit,iim,du etc where sucide,mental harassment,college dropout are most observe in reserved caste people. Modi government should now eliminate this spoon feeding for our nation development.I want to ask him will he go to a sc doctor or a top degree,highly skilled gc doctor in emergency offcourse it is obvious he will go to gc. Reservation is making them more lazy,incompetetive and uneconomical Just imagine if the government funding used in more better place like rural hospital,free education till 12th to all category, sports, research etc then truly we will be a self dependent indian
Irradicate surname..and caste issues will be gone for ever... Let there be no banias, Patel, Chamaar , thakur , pandit etc...and stop dynaty legacy of jobs . Encourage inter-caste and inter-religious marriages to happen... If such a society comes to exist the issue of reservations will never arise....
@@archanasingh6078 ha bhai mai bhi yhi sochta hu bhai pls subscribe kro hum future me fight krenge against reservation agar mere subscriber jyada rhe to kuch ho sakta hai
I am from General Caste and I don't have any problem in reservation to SC/ST/OBC or to Anyone who deserve because they fight from the whole society to get a breath even.
Tabhi mujhe Bharat randistan me nahi rehna
@@anjimaarmyofficersdaughter6087 😂
@@MemesthanTH-cam kon ho
@@anjimaarmyofficersdaughter6087 bhai mae general hu😭
@@MemesthanTH-cam 😓😓😓so bad..... Me too........
I am brahmin and proud of that. But i respect all my dalit brothers and sisters.
The main problem is that dalits didn't get education during those days. Education only can change everything.
Sharm hai aap hi log ke vagh se hum barbad hai
Sorry
Aap naukari nahi payengi lekin ek dalit payega
@@Admirable582 bhai kese nukri nhi paoga konsi nukri ki baat kr rhe ho bhai pdhna sbhi ko pdta he agr kisi ko iit me jana ho to bohot zada mhnt krna pdta he ha 5_10% ka frk pdta he bs cutt of me aur sirf 25 22 % pure college me sc honga
@Arjun Chauhan I think cuz he let them to have their rights that's why they say jai bhim
@Shepherd boy Chandragupt Maurya History and Recalling Ancestors (im not brahmin)
This guy is so matured to become a proper student politician
Hope soon he gets more popular & becomes a true ruler
Whn a sc/st wants to marry a bramin ,than speak about equlity
Yess Pls do elaborate
Kya bolna cha rahe ho.
Or bahan kaun brahmin baap apni beti ko kushi kushi st/SC do dega
Ur r a dumbass girl
Right
The Way u answer ❤️ The Way,How YOU React AND RESPONSE.❤️ SUPER SIR THIR IS LOT TO LEARN FROM YOU
His answer was very bad.His answer was very diplomatic.
@@abhijithjith3821 exactly those who r from mainly General category ..can understand this 💔
@@abhijithjith3821yes yes when its comes to reservation it is very diplomatic but when it is comes to untouchablity you don't get any questions.. waa re wahh
2 marks wala k government Jobs milni chiya !!!! Sahi !!! Bilkul sahi !!
@@codex7446 lol
@Only Tech🤣🤣mst joke mra hai tune pandit ko log 56 bhog lagate hai krya kram M dahej ki tarh truck bhr k daan dete hai
Aur ek baat aur bro hamare gaon m pandit dakshina bhi lete hai,
Ghr bi lete hai,
Aur Mnpasand khana bhi
@@jhonnybaba1729 us daan k alawa koi dusra income source nhi hota......
@@thecosmicprisi5236 Ho Skta hai brother bande p depend krta hai
@@thecosmicprisi5236 toh mt bulaya kro pandit ko pooja karne k liye…..koi jabardasti bolta h kya bulane k liye?
There are only 2% government jobs but almost all good professional courses' seats are covered by reservation.
So by virtue of the college tag a person with lesser marks/aptitude will still land up in a better job.
i know .. i will be appearing for CAT this year .. i need a 98 percentile in order to get shortlisted for interviews ..
What non-sense. U get reservation only till u enter a university. Exams are written by those ppl like all the others.
Apart from govt jobs, there is no reservation anywhere else.
@@ajayws1377 IIT , ,AIIMS,IIMs (TOP COLLEGES) have 60% reservation
TOP COMPANIES HIRE STUDENTS FROM IITs not LPU . WE HAVE 3-4 GOOD PRIVATE INSTITUTES IN INDIA .
BITS PILANI(only private institute in top 10) IS NOT AS GOOD AS TOP 7 IITs as far as placements are concerned .. we have many shitty institutes in India .. Even if we BUILD 100 NEW IITs , COMPANIES LIKE AMAZON,GOOGLE,FACEBOOK,MICROSOFT WOULD NOT HIRE STUDENTS FROM EVERY IIT . Top companies do not have the time to interview students from every college ..
OBC and EWS reservation is vote bank politics .. Ambedkar suggested 25% reservation for SC /ST .
Sons and daughters of bureaucrats , govt. officers (3rd generation ) should not benefit from these policies .. They should be able to clear general cutoff .
Dalits who drop out of school need help . NO ONE TALKS ABOUT THEM .Ensure free education for Dalits in schools ( 12th grade ) so that they don't dropout . Actually ensure school kids don't drop out because of money . College admissions should be on merit .
Now don't give me ''Its a representation logic ''' Whats the point of representing sons and daughters of beneficiaries through quota when they had all the money to join top coaching institutes and clear the general cutoff.
We are just representing few Uplifted families and their kids now .
Affirmative action in USA is not as pathetic as reservation policy in India ..
People who were never victims pretend to be victims .. Its a psychological problem now .
ps: I'm against women's reservation bill ..
Just end castism permanently.
@@kamalkumar7978 for this first caste based reservation should be ended
Instead give reservation to poor people. all the deprived people of st/sc would be covered
Agar reservation surname(caste) dekhkar nahin karna chahiye to discrimination kyun surname(caste) dekhkar karte ho. 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Apni badi badi cars par likhwaate hai Brahamand, Shatriye....ye bhi band hona chahiye...aap savarn hai iska ye matlab nhi hota aap khaas hai baaki sbse
@@nakul3752 Bilkul Nakul ji Bilkul
Pahli baat unki marzi h car me Kya likhe SC St wale v likh Skte h . And mere dost v SC ST Maine insult nhi kiya Jo dusro ko caste ke basis pe insult krte h aur saazza sbko milta h
@@Bhakti_singh.21kviews aapne kitni gaadiyo par dalit,chamar yaa aur kch likha dekha hai...aajke samaj ne inshabdo ko gaali bana diya hai....saza ki baat mat kijiye aaj bhi honour killings bahut ho rhe hai kitno ko saza mili hai...aur rahi baat aap sc st ki insult nhi krte..
Aap insult kar bhi nhi skte...aapko itna haq hai bhi nhi
@@Bhakti_singh.21kviews aap koi ehsaan nhi kr rhe hai unpar insult na karke.
Super bro I love youre knowledge
Tumhe ye knowledge lag Raha hai kyo. Ki tum bhi st SC hoge bro neutral hoke Socho agar Kisi padhe likhe parivar ko reservation mile vo Accha hai ya kisis Garib ke parivar ko
Indian govt. Provides reservations for IIM, IIT, AIIMS etc. Like Higher education. But didn't provide Primary health and education, so lower castes can't go to DPS or any other International schools, so their basics are poor even if they get into higher institutions they are dropping out
Casteism khtam krne ka ek way...inko hospitals n schools m bhi reservation wale doctors n teachers milne chaiye...dekhe kitne agree hote
Ekdum sahi, gen wale to sirf apni ma ch*dne ke liye hai
@@doctorwithdreams4037 ha be tum sab tik tok banane aur khairat lutne mein
@@MrX-il2jt Don't fight with SC/ST , Because they have no respect in today's time. they are neech jaat
Isiliye aaj india me itna severe he covid
@@asmitojha3448 😂🤣 asli neech jat to teri h aryan ki aulad sale , nikal hamare bharat desh se sale chor , bheekmange ,bhagwan ke nam par khate h 🤣
Reservation should me made only on basis of economic conditions but not on casts it only provokes the new generation of unreserved category , otherwise cast discrimination is dying
What do u mean to say? still I hav 1 question...suppose I want to fill up a application form of govt job. If I hav a reservation then I get many facilities such as no money to form fill up, age relaxation, travel allowance, and also reserved seat. but a middle class general student cant even get one of the following facilities. why man why? we r general student means we have lots of money? a sc/st student hav minimum 6/7 govt job exams per month because they hav no need of fees to fill up..but for middle class general student, we think many many times to fill up the form after all its about Rs. 500/1000 /1500 to fill up the form. No I hav no any anger with anyone because I m general & I hav capability to compete with anyone...magar mujhe exam me bathne to do...exam me bathne ke liye hi lagega 500/1000/1500...I m not rich in born...Kanhaiya kumar ji justify me...
ठीक है भाई, तुझे पैसे ज्यादा देने नहीं पड़ रहे, बस उन्हें पैसे कम देने पड़ रहे है | इसमें न तेरा फायदा है ना नुक्सान | हा sc/st का फायदा है | भाई किसी और का फायदा हो रहा है तो हम उस पर क्यों दुःख मनाये, हमको क्या लेना देना |(दुसरो का सुख देख कर क्यों रोये)
तुम रोज 5रू. की चाय पिते हो, कोई दुःख नहीं | अगर एक दिन चाय वाले ने किसी को free मे चाय दे दी, तो तुम दुखी हो रहे हो की उसको free मे चाय मिल गई | ये क्या बात हुई |
वैसे भी भारत मे sc/st संस्थाए है जो सरकार को पैसा देती है | सरकार को पुरे 500/1000/1500 ही मिलते है | Don't worry.
Ashok Arya bhai 5 ki chai use free m milegi.. Muje koi dikkat ni h... But sbko baat te baat te hi chai khtm ho jaae.. To gussa ni aega ky?
Ashok Arya ok just one answer I need to know that is, if there is a general student but he/she is not rich and can't afford for competitive and entrance exams, what should he/she do ? And if u support this caste system then r u ready to face too the discrimination and untouchability practices from general people ? If you are very rich and have got eligibility to afford a lots of opportunities and scopes to build your career, still is it fair to use your caste certificate card to get the advantage which is meant for poor persons ? Would u still call your country a secular nation ?
@@ashokarya5661 problem is not only exam fees but also opportunity ! say 1 lakh people applying for 100 positions , 40 general category positions are contested by 1 lakh people , but 28 by around 40000, and 15 by around 20000 , 10 by 18000, 7 by 10000, tho kisko milne ka chance adhik he? General wale ka fategi kisi aur ka nahin ! 40000, 20000, 10000 us 1 lakh mein bhi hoga dekh lena!
Only 3.5 % market job is reserved for all people including unreserved. Rest 96.5 % job is open to all people. So , keep that reservation for benefits of enjoying various people work together at least in government jobs. Other than govt ,remaining 96.5 % open to all.
Even if education and nutrition made available equally to every child, let’s support reservation for various culture people work together.
u pls propose for reservation in central govt jobs based on languages. Then , u may see real pluralism of India.
जय भीम जय भारत जय मुलनिवासी आर्थिक आधार पर रिजर्वेशन देने से गरीब sc, st, obc के अति पिछड़े झुग्गी झोंपड़ियाँ में रहने वाले अति गरीब विद्यार्थीयों को लाभ होगा,
Reservation is giving on the basis of caste but why still we are getting scholarship on exam fees and education fees on the basis of Caste if you giving jobs on reservation okay no prblm but why reservation on scholarship
Go to there homes and See them they are able to pay the fees or not
@@jhonnybaba1729 yeah more then 12l per annum
Ik a lot of people are poor but u can see that even in gen
Income certificate dikhana pdta h Bhai scholarship ke liye bhi
@@jhonnybaba1729 stfu no one in my friend circle , nor in my town are that poor.
And not all general category ctzens are rich..
Aur sahab jara puchiye un bachon se jo JEE mains ke exam main apne doston se 50 marks jyada laane ke baad bhi...advanceain nahi beht paata ..
ar un bacho se bhi pch jinhe same school mai jkr bhi sth bethne nhi diya jata ar bacho ke sth up bihar mai
ek din apna naam se Agarwal htkr bhangi lga liyo tujhe pta lg jayega
@@Ragnar-xk4bc yeh reservation tumhe hamesha bhangi bane rehne dega..kabhi aage nahi badne dega...kyunki yeh gap ko bada raha hai....mere dost ka naam arvind gautam...toh mujhe mat gyaan de..main Agra se hu...iss bewakoof ki baate mat suno..yeh sirf baat raha hai hume..
@@nikhilagarwal4438phli baat to mai bhangi nhi hu ar na apne aap ko kisi se chota mnta hu pr jis din desh se jati khtm krne ki baat kroge na us din mai reservation ka khud virodh krunga
agr bina caste khtm kre reservation khtm kiya to shyd backward class ko uska representative na mil paye jaise supreme court mai ek bhi obc sc st judge nhi hai
@@nikhilagarwal4438 ar backward class ke logo ko aaj bhi mandir mai nhi jane diya jta agr koi apni shadi mai ghodi pr bethne pr goli mr di jati hai ye bhi reservation ki vjh se hai ?
agr tumne 70 saal jati khtm krne ki baat kri hoti to aaj reservation hi khtm ho gya hota
ar tu hoga Agra se tera dost kn hai mujhe usse mtlb nhi pr jo aise incidents hote hai uska bhi utna hi virodh kiya kro jitna reservation ka krte ho
@@Ragnar-xk4bc bhai hum bhi toh wahi keh rahe haireservation koi raasta nahi hai casteism ko khatam karne ke liye ....sirf education se khatam ho sakta hai....reservation se sirf nafrat bad rahi hai....aur kanahiya kumar jaise log iska faayda utha rahe hai....
In competitive exam such as UPSC ,NEET .......... etc .Why every one is not given equal opportunity?
In society why everyone not get same respect?
@@xrxnpop1222 Respect will not come itself,but have to earn it.
@@xrxnpop1222 That's not our problems. It's problems of hindusim then.
If u feel inferior or u treat as lower class tgen change ur religion .
Problems khatam.
JEE/NEET/UPSC/STATE EXAM main gen catogory sc se 120 jada marks lekar bhi seat nahi mil rahi hai.
Aur inko caihe e reservation. Haha
@@bappyroy6488 toh reservation thik hi hai🤣
Reservation is given to uplift ppl of socially backward castes. Even if the upper caste ppl are in less number compared to the lower caste ppl in over all population .. look at the world around u . In every high positions of the society there u can find only a few lower caste ppl, majority are upperclass ppl. Y so??
Inorder to bring lower class ppl to stand with the upperclass ppl in all aspects reservation is given. And it is necessary to achieve equality.
That is why reservation quotas are given in exams like these ok.
సమాధానం అదిరిపోయింది... రిజర్వేషన్ పోవాలంటే కులం అనే పదమే కనబడకూడదు..... Great Answer SIR
Reservation low casts valliki kavali antaru kada asulu casts aaa teasvochu kada appudu chappu poor ke kavali chuduvokataniki help 👍👍not reservation students should develop 👍then india can develop 👍
Jai bhiim
Bhai ye bhim kb se sc st ya obc ho gye??
Vse to government bolti he kye hme accha doctors or minded ainsan chaia too aune me yea khana chata huu kye Sc or st ke neet exam 200hoe or general vla ke 500 hoe too bhi phala SC ST phala latte he .aune phala doctor banaia jte he .hb200marks or 500marks ka difference too dakho doctor kaa sahi gyan kisme hooga?
Government school dek lo shab
Bhai, training toh ek jaisi hogi na,
Aur Company toh Eligible ko job degi na..
Aur Kanhaiya sir ne kya bola suna nahi,
Ki 98% jobs Private hain..
Toh wahan toh nahi chalta na Reservation,phir kaise kehte ho ki Reservation se talent kharab ho rha hai.
@@vivekkoul5479 toh itni cutt off jti h ...toh seedha khatm kr do na reservation smjh aa jyega ki 20-30 number mei bhi kitni rank chli jyi...fir kyu rote ho reservation k liye jb sbki cutt off barabar h toh
@@vivekkoul5479 barabar kaha aayi tum 400 laake jab general mei 600 jati hai
@@vivekkoul5479 tumhara bhi to reservation hai tum to support karoge halaki obc mei kuch khass fayeda nahi hota but ye galat hai
What is muslim brotherhood and why it is pinned in top right corner
kya malum
If reservation is due to casteism then, casteism is variable throughout the nation then why not reservation. If a SC student from a village where casteism exists gets a job though reservation it would be correct but if a sc student living in an urban city where casteism has no place why he should have that privilage that should only be given to village one and why in equal quantity
Yes you are right.
Then people should create another solution .
Instead of pointing out reservation, find another solution to caste discrimination.
Reservation was made because of it.
People only think about outputs with no outcomes.
Reservation should be removed
,but first do we have any other solution to remove casteism.
Do you really think that there is no discrimination in urban areas if you think so just check the matrimonial section in the newspaper and ask many people about it you would find it out easily
@Only Tech well if you want then it's good but what i meant was many parents force their offspring to marry a person of their own community even if the child is liking someone else
@Only Tech anyways man i can't reply or explain a lot coz i am not in the situation right now so try to understand it and don't reply until it's too necessary to talk about
There is only 2% government jobs in india .. Reservation is only in government sector..
Wah kya baat hain. 2 percent hain kyunki 90% jobs agriculture, labourers aur service industry (waiters etc) ye log kar rahe hain. Ab kya kheti mein bhi reservation chahiye?
Dhang ki jobs India mein 5% hi hain. Usme se 2% mein reservation aur baaki mein ghusne ke liye IIT ya IIM jaha alag reservation laga hua hain. Sale kuch bacha hain jaha reservation nahi hain? Agar private jobs mein reservation nahi hain, toh IIMs mein bhi nahi hona chahiye na. Sale chootiye statistics bhaunkne se pehle dimaag lagaya kar.
@@Aryan-sf5kx IIM is government funded institute isliye waha reservation hai .
@@yashyete883 par woh government jobs toh nahi hain na. Tab 2% hi kaise hue government jobs. Aur army bhi toh government ke andar hain. Waha lagwa ke dikha reservation.
Our education institutions jaise ki AIIMS,govt college,kam fees,elections ka kya aur private job koi nhi karna chahta
@@yashyete883 TOH BHAI YE KANHAIYA HI NHI KOI EK DRAFT BANAYE TO RATIONALISE RESERVATION. JO yahi caste wale ek hi pariwaar ke 100 logo ko reservation milta hai galat hai to ye ek draft banaye taki jab hum ye soch bhi paaye ki khi reservation flaw free rahe gaareeb ko mile na ki iss kanahiya ke baache .
Reservation was given for representation of specific community, it's high time to review reservation system.
And all the premier private jobs are filled by reservation, talk about entry in IIT,IIM,LAW ,AIMS etc.
Lekin -3 marks wale ko physics ka lecturer Banana bhi to thik ni h na...
kh bn gya -3 no. pe dikha fir bolio ek exam dikha diyo jisme general or obc sc ki cutoff mai zyada frk ho
@@Ragnar-xk4bc iit jee mains
@@Ragnar-xk4bc are humko na samjao
Reservation ki lie hi inequality hain
Jaruri thodi na hai ki 3 hi marks ho
Thanks a lot sir
Yes 90% of People who Do Toilet Cleaning Work Belongs to Sc/st Community Me Myself Belong To SC community And My Family Right From My grand Father To My Father we Use To Clean Toilets of Public
Ha toh karo padhai.. Do exams.. Karo business chalu. Kisine roka hai..
@@mukeshsingh-mm5ey m
You are rajput and belongs to SC community
Wowww dude
Beta tum log general ke paison pe upar aate ho iit mein sc st ko 3000 fees air general ko 2800000. Humari fees ke paison se tumhe padhaya jaa raha hai.
@@GamingZone-ql4fi General walo ne Sc St ke paise bhi to apne pass rakhe hue h .. Jo property pure 90% sc st ke pass h ..
Utni hi aur uss se jyada property 10%general ke pass h ..
I’m black, I’m discriminated. I also want Reservations.
Anyway, a Naxali never be student leader.
Ambani ke bete ki jagah Rajeev Gandhi ke bete ka bhi example chalta.
Sahi baat hai bhai
Inequality ashe hui ki jaab ek 90 percent wali ki naukri nahi lagi jinse itni mehnat ki aur ek 60 percent ki lagi jisne mazak mai saal kaa diyaa yaha hui hai baat
Yeah...true
@abhishek mohapatra pata nhi to neet ki cuttoff dekho du ki dekho
@abhishek mohapatra oye, you talking about fair chance and equality and then you still talk about how reserved category people are dumb and they get admitted to jobs and colleges because of reservations.
Let me tell you. First you go and look at the college admission list, the person who got reserved seat must also have high marks to get the seat. So in the category list too only learner and capable are selected.
You are just biased and selfish and talking hypocrisy nothing else. I'm SC I got 91.5% for tenth 88 for twelwth, 92.5% for degree( college first rank) 88.5% for MSc ( college second rank) got admission for PhD with JRF.
But for all these admissions I got seat under SC reservation. And the other one who got the other seat out of the two seats for SC ( he was topper in his college). So I don't know how reservation is unfair?
Actually this society is unfair, because you so called general categories have this thought that people who get researved seats are unworthy, dumb and stupid. Do first change your attitude then we will discuss about other things!!!!!!!
@@radheyshyamsharma6598 you general category represent about 23% of indian population and rest of the 55% of seats are reserved for general category that is you enjoy more than 2x times your population percentage. When about 16.6% is SC and only get 15% reserved seats and 8.5% of ST population get only 7.5%reservation then rest 43% OBC gets only about 22% reservation seats. Actually you are sitting on the 55% seats for only 23% of you guys. Tell me what are you bickering about. And since your reservation percentage double your population represent you won't get higher cutt off.
@abhishek mohapatra you general category represent about 23% of indian population and rest of the 55% of seats are reserved for general category that is you enjoy more than 2x times your population percentage. When about 16.6% is SC and only get 15% reserved seats and 8.5% of ST population get only 7.5%reservation then rest 43% OBC gets only about 22% reservation seats. Actually you are sitting on the 55% seats for only 23% of you guys. Tell me what are you bickering about. And since your reservation percentage is double your population representation you won't get higher cutt off.
Super Sir
This reply jitters all haters.
Root cause is casteism. "Every action has an equal and opposite reaction". Once there was a time when there were no access of education,clean water, higher job to such people. There were practice of untouchability and discrimination on the basis of caste etc. Now also in many region, it is practiced. I myself can see this in my society. In rural areas it happens at extream level.
B. R Ambedakar had reached higher position on his own while going through inequality and exploitation. He had a very tough time to even access the education and then he used such power to bring revolution against inequality on the basis of caste.
Demolish inequality on the basis of caste, then demolish reservation. It is illogical to discriminate on the basis of caste. Why certain group of people is called "lower caste" or "upper caste" just because their ancestors were engaged in certain job.
Thats why we have police and judiciary sister . Why he is not talking about the biggest problem which is enforcement of democracy and judiciary . Haar gya hu main aise student neta dekh ke.
Fir kuch young environmentalists aaynge aur Aarey ko bachaynge kisse?? 100 % electric metro se . Y don't they sit on a dharna for charging station and Electronic vehicle in mumabi. And every hotels and residents should have rain water harvesting and solid waste management with water waste management . Why not 😔😔.
Mam apne newton ke law ko galat interpret kiya hai usme hai na opposite reaction to jo bura karega to uska opposite to achha hua na .
WAISE BHI APKE BABA SAHEB AMBEDKAR KA EDUCATION KA INTZAM UNHE ENGLAND BHEJNE KA KAM EK BRAHMAN NE HI KIYA THA JINHONE AMBEDKAR APNA TITLE UNKO DIYA.
😎😎😎😎 U R REALLY LIKE MY SCHOOL TEACHER STUPID
right, i belongs to a sc caste .i do not want reservation but stoping practice of untouchabilty and discrimination,hate negative mindset towards our category.
@@MrX-il2jt isi liye tumhare piche jhadoo Nahi bandha, isi liye tumhare gle mein mtka Nahi h , isi liye tumhare pdne pr akhe Nahi nikalte , isiliye , tumhare kano mein chillar pighla Nahi dalte , isi liye tumhare parchayi pdne pr tumhari honour killing Nahi Hoti , opposite reaction hi h bhai
@@nareshbhoina4308 bro you take reservation or not... Judgement of people are on the basis of caste only they do say they aren't castic but that not true.... Caste will never leave caste is important to them to gain pride and respect.... Only thing you can do is to work hard and get big marks
Great Answer
good kumar
Lawra anser
@@debabratamishra4376 hn teri answer* ki spelling dekh ke lag raha tu kitna padha likha h 😂🤣
M govt clg m hu...mere+2 m 86% tha last seat thi... mereko hta kr 75% wali ldki ko lia gya...mai general hu ..uski wajah se mereko 1 saal baad admission lena pda..ab meri class m 90 % bache SC he...and unmese 75 %bht acche background se aate h ..wo scholarship se iPhone lete h ...jbki humko pura saal kaam krke % maintain krni hoti...esa kyu?
Nobody cares about general category. Just answer one question, who in this world would let go the benefits even if they are rich. Only reservation for poor SC/ST students should be there.
मैं एक DHEEWAR जाति OBC श्रेणी हिंदू था लेकिन,
लेकिन 12 वीं कक्षा में उच्च जाति के हिन्दू ने मेरे साथ बहुत भेदभाव किया जो मुझे बहुत आहत करता है, तब मैंने महसूस किया, कैसे mere अनुसूचित जाति और अनुसूचित जनजाति और ओबीसी जाति के भाई aur beheno के परिवार ko सामना करना पड़ा।
मैंने अपना धर्म बदलकर ISAI धर्म कर लिया .
Jab jab hindu tutega tab tab hinduo ka naash hoga.
Saalo tum logo or Karan hamara Hindu dharm barbaad ho Raha hai sirf kuch paiso ke liye dusre dharm ko apna Lete ho Hindu ho to raho na bhim rao abmedkar ne dharm Nahi badla tha wo ahinsa se lade the
@@Mayank-to4tv nahi jaativaad ki vajha se ho raha hai ye sab.
@@Siddharth-uo6zw jaativad ab khatm ho gaya hai agar hota to aaj bhi school me alag line lagti
@@Mayank-to4tv fir tum kahoge humme bhi reservation chahiye 😁😂
@@Siddharth-uo6zw Nahi Bhai ham chahte hai ki ye Jo reservation hai vo aadmi ke economical condition per lage na ki uske sername
reser vation should be on economical background....ameer toh sc st bhi hota hai!!!!
@Rishy Singh reservation is not the method of removing caste system reservation tmh itna strong bnata hai (financialy socialy )ke tm us discrimination ko face kr sko
Aur bhai SEWER SAAF karne wala bhi toh sc st ka hota hai...
Yup reservation should be on the basis of economic background so that these caste supremacists will still be respected for their caste and also they dont have any financial worries to educate their children.
@@thorxn1382 toh uss sewer saaf karne wale ko puch padai kiv nahi kia....
@@thorxn1382 general me bi he sewer saaf karne wala
nice..
big fan of you sir । reservation par bhot accha answer bola sir
Why can't the government remove reservation to those who, though are from backward castes, belong to a well to do family ??? It's easy to find out using their tax returns and it is well to do because the father has already availed the benefit of reservation. If a person whose father is a having a plum job that earns him more than 20 lakhs per annum, then does this person still need reservation ??? So simple solution for the benefit of the really poor people who are from backward castes, the reservation must not be applicable for anyone whose father has already availed the benefit of reservation and can now support his son. This way, the marginalized person can really benefit. Reservation can be there but to only those that really need it.
Only 3.5 % market job is reserved for all people including unreserved. Rest 96.5 % job is open to all people. So , keep that reservation for benefits of enjoying various people work together at least in government jobs. Other than govt ,remaining 96.5 % open to all.
Even if education and nutrition made available equally to every child, let’s support reservation for various culture people work together.
u pls propose for reservation in central govt jobs based on languages. Then , u may see real pluralism of India.
@CarryMinati ✔︎ vo khud ki capability ke dum par hai Aaj kon rokta hai sc/st walo ko padne se competition fight karne se...
Exactly
@@winvictorywin5612 fir colleges me kyu h reservation? sirf jobs me rakho
@@Sanjay-ub7eq
It’s okey. How will u create eligible candidate for the respective field jobs ?
If this so called reservation continues, do not expect the deserving and talented candidates to stay in this country and ask them to serve on the name of "patriotism"
despite of this discriminatory system. Do not blame them for leaving n working in other countries and calling them anti patriots.
Keeping increasing the quota, it's 60 percent today, tomorrow it will be 70 and one day no jobs would be left for the deserving. Keep bringing amendments that drown this country's economy and deceleration.
desh ko barbad karke chodega reservation. Mere gali me sab Sc St ke ghar wale Govt. job me hain and unke bete bhi.. mere number jyada h fir bhi Private collage se graduation kr rha hu and economically weaker bhi hu. Time aayga sabka badla lia jaiya.. kab tak yeh log reservation ke aad me chup ke sab kuch le painge.. and one more thing IT'S high time to treat differently i honestly never did it with my friends but how could they expect us to treat them in the same way when they are getting perks from government. .. me toh nhi karunga abse kabhi kabhi..
@@shreyanshpareek7876 bahut bura haal hai bhai ..abhi hum kuch bi bolenge .comment karenge toh .wo bolenge hamko pichale 5000 saalse shoshan kiya tha.mandir jane diya etc...mera dost log SC aur ST ka hai saare govt medical collge pad rah hai aur wo amir bi hai ..mujhe dekhe haste hai ..
and if reservation is discontinued then do expect 'one' India as different caste groups will naturally want to have their own development and own land because of high disparity in government functioning.
Yes it's better for government to make a fund for general candidates who want to leave the country because if reservation , government fails to provide seats to general candidates and also creates discrimination
And then they say, there are a lot of 'unemployed people' in India.
Resevation rhe likin etna Jayda nhi general toh maara jaa rha hai 70% category reserve 30% bas unreserved hai 30 % jurm kar rha hai sabka uper
Aur dsri baat shaddi jisko nhi karni hai dsri caste wah nhi kar RHA hai everyone has the liberty to choose their life how they want to live
Girls ko reservations dena chahiye
E sirf kagzo M hai Reality kuch aur hai bhi
excellent speech
Bhai tu hame missed call de 8670453012
@@debabratamishra4376 kyu 🤣🤣
Sir ne ekdam sahi jawab diya hai
Bhaiya their should be reservation in politics and Army but I am less educated infront of you but I also know the things very well
SC/ST : why are the sellout and greedy general category talented people leaving the country ??!?
Also SC/ST : We are completely entitled to reservation because of a 130 year old system and our learning power is affected by our caste.
First end discrimination by upper caste to lower caste. Then talk about ending reservation.
@@MrCooldude987Thats not our problem! And it's very less in today's date. While doing reservation nobody thought about it's I'll effects, if it was meant for overall development of society, why the hell it's still there? After about 30-40 yrs of bringing reservation into picture, govt passes a bill in parliament to carry it on, this is where we mess up. Why the hell people in today's gen are able to exercise the benefits of something which should've been exercised by their elders/ancestors? Reservation was not meant to give somebody an additional advantage, it was to make the society compatible from all aspects. But none of the governments analysed where is the flaw! Many deserving people were left behind, are being left behind, will be leaving behind. 😑
@@dhananjaya.gujarathi664 manisha balmiki!!!!! first of all get up and move to western up and tell the people there u belong to any sc caste u wil know what we go thorough ur daily life.....its not u who has been told by his teacher that u r not capable enough to learn because u were born to clean the sewage....
@@HimanshuKumar-ee5lu That will not be the scenario if everyone gets into fair competition, obviously when you get something by reservation and you've not worked it out as per it's requirement, understanding, you'll face challenges.
@@dhananjaya.gujarathi664 sir this is not like we are given reservation before exam we also came same as u but after math of exams and selection process shows us benefits and also just go to western up have a nice vlog on yt if u are soo adjured to making comments and mention urself as an sc ot st....u will know what i am saying....definitely u would not be same if womens of ur house would never be allowed to cover their upper body or ue ears and eyes would be melted if u listens to any sacred poety sang in name of god....if u have not suffered then democracy may allows u but not a well educated HUMAN...
❤️
Thank you SIR for answering them.
Most of the reserved students end up dropping out becoz of the difficulty in coping with better students in prestigious universities. So the result is that we have more dalit drop outs. Reservation is actually anti dalit. Same Dalits would have gotten degrees in less prestigious colleges
Bro...the main reason behind the college dropouts of backward caste is that 85% of them belong to rural hindi medium backward govt schools.....If they are given proper guidance and counselling in the prestigious colleges ,they would perform much better than GC students
@@arpitmandawat563 yeah. Like 85% of backward caste reside in northern states where hindi is spoken?
I live in a state where backward castes even in English medium schools still have poor results. Care to explain me why??
In us state California, removed reservation (affirmative action) and results were that the oppressed groups had 55% increase in graduation. Turns out more people of oppressed groups were graduating without reservation.
@@stallonegodinho6296 Bro...I don't know about California so I'll not speak about it....But don't you think casteism is still iving in one form or another...Seeing some rich people doesn't define the whole community...Firstly we should abolish caste system from the mindset of the people. Than the reservation should be removed instantly and should be done on economic basis (I also want Economic Reservation lol)...And I live in a hindi speaking rural are So i wrote it just to give a better look to my answer....
PS:- I am a Rajput (General Cat guy)
@@arpitmandawat563 Caste system is abolished. Look at the constitution of India. Also reservation was never to eliminate the caste system. The reservation was kept for 10 years. And it was continued for vote bank politics. It's been 70years since independence. Yet caste continues, so it's clear that reservation on caste can't eliminate caste. Why support a failed system which is exploited by politicians for vote banks???
There's no need for economic reservation. Becoz brilliant people from poor background don't need reservation, they need financial support.
@@arpitmandawat563 How can reservation remove caste discrimination? I never got a satisfactory answer for this.
Samay badal gya hai, System v badalni chahiye... Agar kisi ko 2 ghanta kaam kr ke pure din ka Paisa mile toh wo mehnat ku krega??
Kitne log aise hai jo 2 hr ka kam karke pure dinka paisa milte hai only 5-10 % 😂😅
Aur vohi log amir hai socho country me gareeb aur in 5-10 % amir ke bich kitna difference hai aur yr hi 5-10% ki vajah se gdp hamara accha hai aur hame lagta he ke hamare desh se garibi dur ho rhi hai😅😂
He is right...I agree with Kanhaiya sir...
U better nit na with reservation
Excellent
You explained very well💯
JEE main me agar SC/ST walo ko sirph caste ke base per hi kam marks per badhiya branch milegi toh ghatiya quality ke hi engineer niklenge toh sooch lo desh ka kya hoga ?
Bilkul sir
i agree with you .. engineering and b schools /professional schools should never have reservations .. its just stupid .. fees should be waived off only for the poor . i scored 90 percentile in CAT and I''ll be trying again next year .. CAT ,JEE cutoff is ridiculous for SC/ST/OBC .
Apni bakwaas band kar
SC Category people thinking only for Reservation. Reservation is temporary not permanent. SC Category people treated badly in British India by Hindu Dharma not by Royals. For suffering of SC Category why Royals are Punished or Discriminated ? Royals have not made Castism & Hindu Legislation/Laws. Who made/written Castism is not important but who implementing this Hindu Legislation/Laws is important question.
Before discussion on Reservation every Indian should know the facts about Reservation that RESERVATION IS ACTUALLY substitute & REPLACEMENT of INDIAN CONSTITUTION. Why need to know this ? Because when Indian constitution not implemented & we are not having rights according to Indian Constitution since 1950 so Court has no right to punish anybody. Instead of Indian constitution our country is run by Hindu Legislation/Laws of Castism. So How can Court of India give justice according to Indian constitution ?
best reply ever seen i m proud of you you are supporting for equilty
Economy based kyu nhi reservation caste based kyu cast wise hi discrimination ho rha h avv v aur phle v hota tha
Caste main wajah hai discrimination ki.. and caste is is based on work and who can get the education.. or hazaro sal tak yehi kiya or ab economic basis pe solution cahte hai.. they don't want to solve the caste problem or issi se or jant jalta hai.. they want to eliminate the solution itself... Koi sense hai.. ikka dukka case hota hai jaha lower caste wale ki background achi ho.. per kya discrimination caste k basis pe hota hai? Yes hota hai or economic basis pe bhi hota hai.. the funny part is u can always improve ur economy but u can't improve ur caste..
Kanhaiya you are a hero of nation
Yah it is very big problem
St vaalo ka selection 58 pe
General vaalo ka 78 pe
It is real experience of exam
Esa nhi hai ki mai Ese hi bol rhe hai
Ye ekdam Galt hai
Sit kiska Jada he
@@sanjubarman7360 bhai inko ye baat kabhi nhi samaj ayegi ye lodu hai aur inki jalti hai jab koi sc st stable ho jata hai ya padd likh jaata hai
Legend nhi tu tu chuti... hai jo baat nhi samaj para kk ki
CA m to koi reservation nhi h...fir sirf general wale hi kyu hote h...
That's because they descriminate against the backward classes.
Because gen caste is more intelligent
@@doctorwithdreams4037 oh yeah? Do you have any scientific evidence?
What about BR Ambedkar? What about former president K R Narayan? What about Narendra Jadhav? What about Satyendra Murli? What about Pa. Ranjith? What about president Ramnath Kovind? What about Namdeo Dashal? And many more. They are all belonging to backward classes.. They are all prime examples of what backward people can do when given the opportunity and support that they deserve.
Intelligence doesn't come from caste you 'the one that lack both intelligence and common sense' !!
Who told you there are no CA who belongs to backward classes? Go get proper evidence to support your statement. Otherwise it's just a fallacy.
@@mrudhulamohank328 then why you need reservation agar tum kisi se kam nahi ho to
🙏 ek baar padho ..I am studying MBBS .i belong to lingayat caste ..i dont get any benefit from government .I got this seat after repeating one yr ..studied day n night .i got 977 rank in Karnataka cet.but i have friends who belong to ST and SC caste their rank was 8000.9000.11000.and they got seat in medical college (govt)...and they also get scholarship up to 50,000₹ every year and books, laptop, and again reservation in PG seat ....where one of my religion friend who also dropped a yr with me secured 3500 rank .yet he did not get seat even in private college also ..he was desperate to become doctor .now plzz whoever reading this belonging to any caste give the reason why we should suffer ..do u think there are no poor people in our caste ........
doctor must have the passion to save patient ,he should have sufficient knowledge .he should not fall behind money....if you make someday doctor who do not deserve.. he will kill the patient ..and it is happening ..dont think becoming doctor is too easy ...you will be beaten in public.., in hospitals...u read it everyday in news
agar ek engineer galti kiya toh chalta hai .magar ek doctor ka galti bahut keemthi hai..aap hi samjho ..kisko doctor banna chahiye ..
ye reservation sirf padahyi me kyn, Acting,business,dancing,singing, cricket,sports,aur saare kshetrome kyn nahi..sirf education me kyun hai...politics me toh hai..woh alag baat ..reservation should be made in everything not only in making doctor or etc...
.passing in MBBS is very easier than getting seat in competitive exam..any one can pass ...only thing is u have to get seat ..in private college it is still worst .. the college management allows you to copy openly .they use Bluetooth devices to copy ..everyone in college knows that ..but since students gave them huge donation in crores and lacks they dont say anything to them ...even in Govt college University exams you write anything ..all ramayana and mahabharat story in paper ..they pass you blindly ..getting a UG and PG seat is very very very difficult my friend ..out of 6laks of students appearing in NEET exams only few thousands seats are allowed .for that competition is huge ..especially if one belongs to general category...
Even i can understand 8k sc guy gets RV 🤣 in kcet
@@invincibleh3117 RV banglore 😀what to do bro fucked up system .
@Nand Kishore yes state rank
@Nand Kishore. back in 2015 ..KA CET
What about private college doctors jinko 140 marks mein doctor banta hai kya wo doctor banne ke layak hai.
Nice Kanhaiya Kumar 🙏
Sahi baat hai yaar🙂...
Kanhiya sir ek debate mere saath bhi mai apko btana chata hu reservation kyu nhi hona chaiye
Education me koi reservation nehi. Aap log resevation system karke scheduled caste ko dushre caste se aalagh kar rahe ho.
Aise soch vale jarur politics me hona chahiye
Ye ground zero me jake kuch Dekhe nhi h.....upar upar se bol raha h......grow up .......see the reality and accept the reality
...
Thanks so much sir outstanding analysis speech.
Reservation is reason for backward of our country
And bhramwad is the reason for minorities backward ......3000 salo se gulami karwa k acche position me pahuche ho
@@NoneNone-og2th abe nahi tumhe milna chahiye reservation hum bade log hai thoda bohout to chote logo ko uthana chahiye aisa tumhare bolne ke tarike se lag raha hai
@@indeshwarmishra3481 Abe reservation is for representation not to end poverty .....go get yourself a brain
hum to maang hi nahi rahe hum to kah rahe hai hatana chahiye
@@NoneNone-og2th bhaiii uss time bhi kai minorities the jo apne dam par padhe likhe aur kai brahmins se aage nikle to ye rona mat gaao
Why do everybody take this 2% govt job to justify the caste base reservation..
But why don't they take in count the reservation in Education sector(like IIT, NIT AIIMs etc).
A candidate getting admission in these institutes on Caste bases and geeting private jobs on that basis should also be added to those 2% jobs on reservation.
oye, you talking about fair chance and equality and then you still talk about how reserved category people are dumb and they get admitted to jobs and colleges because of reservations.
Let me tell you. First you go and look at the college admission list, the person who got reserved seat must also have high marks to get the seat. So in the category list too only learner and capable are selected.
You are just biased and selfish and talking hypocrisy nothing else. I'm SC I got 91.5% for tenth 88 for twelwth, 92.5% for degree( college first rank) 88.5% for MSc ( college second rank) got admission for PhD with JRF.
But for all these admissions I got seat under SC reservation. And the other one who got the other seat out of the two seats for SC ( he was topper in his college). So I don't know how reservation is unfair?
Actually this society is unfair, because you so called general categories have this thought that people who get researved seats are unworthy, dumb and stupid. Do first change your attitude then we will discuss about other things!!!!!!!
@@mrudhulamohank328 if you guys are worthy by marks then why to use reservation in this case? who is stopping you get good marks and get opportunity by only ability not reservation
@@pratik_404notfound nabi kar sakte bhaiii kabhi dekha hai jee ka topper koi sc ya st ho jisne ek baar me crack kiya ho
@@indeshwarmishra3481 Watch yogendra yadav why reservation is necessary
@@robmoody4710 bhaiiii chodo wo sab caste dicrimination to nahi par discrimination to usa me bhi colour ko lekar origin ko lekar par wahan reservation nahi laga aur talent ke dum par oppurtunities mili isliye usa aaj superpower hai
lalu yadav bolta hai ki reservation hum kabhi hatne nahi denge aakhri tak rahega isse kya dikhta hai
arey bhau 2% ki baat to krdi but engineering colleges , medical Colleges ke admission me jo reservation lgta hai main problem to vo bhi hai sir.
or to or scholarship me bhi reservation lgta hai . Ab to promotion me bhi reservation ki baat chal rhi hai..
Bhai... Survey kro aap pehley caste k basis pr... Ki konsi caste k kitne employees h... Govt
Osm
Kyaa banda h yar ye.. Hats off❤️👍
Remove Cast Based Discrimination then Remove Reservation . We are suppressed & harrassed by Upper Caste PPL so these people want to harrass us at the same time want our reservation to be ended. Wao !
Kuch Bhi Ho Successful To General Me Sa Obc Me We hi Hope Hai Inhe Kitni Bhi Reservation MilJaye Sunder Pichai Google Seo Hai Vo
General Me Atte Hai.Brahmin Hai
Bhaiya ap to king Martin Luther 🤠 he hamri modern society k liye
Kanhaiya Kumar is not Martin Luther actually he is Martin Chutad of India 😂
he is just Communist who openly support Communism & that's why he lost the election against BJP😁
@@sairaj3052 sahi baat kehdi dost😁
@@sairaj3052 communism bhi nhi aati chutiye ko...
@@anjaan2128 😂😂👍
Those who want to abolish reservation based on caste! Try to live a life of dalit in villages for one month!
I want to abolish reservation. If the living conditions of dalit is bad, it show how much ineffective reservation is after this much year . if discrimination is done against Dalits, is not solved by reservation, but by putting laws against such people who discrimination . Weather such laws exist ,or is it strong? After civil rights movement progress amoung black is not solve by reservation, but through laws which take strong action against people who discrimate.
In my opinion I believe st sc obc deserve minimum 50 percent reservation forever
Great
Mai lower category se mujhe resvestion h...Maine entrance exam qualify kiya...lekin Mai tb pareshan ho gyi jb mujhe log Kahne lage ki tmko pta h general wale Kitna mehnat krte h..ha Maine mna nhi kiya ki wo mehnat krte h....pr wo nhi jante ki resvestion kyu h...jis Tarah se us din mujhse wo log bahas kr rhe the mai akele kya hi bolti😣...Mai bs unhe bolna chahti thi phle resvestion ko smjho phir bahas kro
Me bolu reservation kyu he.. .....bas us lavde ke wajah se jo likh ke bhool gya kah band karna he. Us saale ne carodo ki life barbad kardi. Me uske photo se gaand saaf karta hu.
Discrimination ha to reservation bhi hona chahiye ,mere ek dost ko chamar chamar bola karte the sab school me , mujhe matlab nahi pata tha . Discrimination haaaa. Hatao usko pehle.
Fan ho gya yrr inke knowledge ka....
Bro his knowledge is not correct tried to understand deeply research about this topic
@@Mayank-to4tv correct bro, he is not some God that he is 100 percent right, he is manipulating a simple theory of economic based reservation to sewage workers and 2 time ki roti and all.
@@_prashthink what happens agar iske Jaise log India ke prime minister ban Gaye I think Modi ne gen ews laa Kar bahut Accha Kiya right now he is in congress
Reservation honi bhi chahiye to sirf unke liye jinko unki jarurat hai by caste nhi kyunki ab hamre desh mai sirf sc st obc hi nhi balki general ki kai family hai jinki family background kamjor hai lekin phir bhi unke bache padh kar acha marks late hai lekin reservation ke karan unke merit ko nagarandaaz kar diya jata hai
इसलिए आरक्षण economic status देख कर दिया जाना चाहिए ताकि जो गरीब का बच्चा हो उसे मिले चाहे वो किसी भी जाति
का हो। जो sc/st obc के गरीब लोग है वो वैसे
ही आ जाएंगे।
oye, you talking about fair chance and equality and then you still talk about how reserved category people are dumb and they get admitted to jobs and colleges because of reservations.
Let me tell you. First you go and look at the college admission list, the person who got reserved seat must also have high marks to get the seat. So in the category list too only learner and capable are selected.
You are just biased and selfish and talking hypocrisy nothing else. I'm SC I got 91.5% for tenth 88 for twelwth, 92.5% for degree( college first rank) 88.5% for MSc ( college second rank) got admission for PhD with JRF.
But for all these admissions I got seat under SC reservation. And the other one who got the other seat out of the two seats for SC ( he was topper in his college). So I don't know how reservation is unfair?
Actually this society is unfair, because you so called general categories have this thought that people who get researved seats are unworthy, dumb and stupid. Do first change your attitude then we will discuss about other things!!!!!!!
First off all i am 14 years old and i am only giving my opinion i am not saying that reservation is bad i am only saying that reservation by caste is bad i am saying that all the people whethther sc st obc general should enjoy reservation if they really need it. If my opinion hurts you i apologize
Reservation hame aapko sabhi ko milni chahiye agar hame uske sahi me zarorat ho not by caste
@@Ayushkumar-du2pl you general category represent about 23% of indian population and rest of the 55% of seats are reserved for general category that is you enjoy more than 2x times your population percentage. When about 16.6% is SC and only get 15% reserved seats and 8.5% of ST population get only 7.5%reservation then rest 43% OBC gets only about 22% reservation seats. Actually you are sitting on the 55% seats for only 23% of you guys. Tell me what are you bickering about. And since your reservation percentage double your population represent you won't get higher cutt off.
So reservation system is based on population ratio. And if you are educated and wise and rational and know some biostatistics, this is a fair and square system except you guys get more that is double your population size ( 23% population) that is 55% of the seats. So you guys are at advantage. I don't know why you are bickering about. If Govt jobs and education opportunities are not reserved according to the demography and different castes and races are not included then that is the hinderance of equality.
Many semi-literates are commending this tragic comedy, why are you talking about 'aprathyaksh ' reservation?
I personally don't have a caste , many are there who don't take forward their caste name and they are left in the race alone while for some it is booked? why should anyone who respects equality , be punished by diminished probability ? I don't see people the way my forefathers have seen ! just Imagine saying indians must fight for reservation in 100m event in olympics to win it! how foolish?
Just because people from one ethnic origin are winning it doesn't mean 100 m event medals are reserved for them, they get it by hardwork like, are chinese protesting for wanting of first place NO, just because they're numerically superior (bahujan) NO, they work through it.
just by preventing zealous, equality oriented credible , general category candidates for making others enter just
because they are from some politico-caste is like making jamaicans/medal winning ethnic racers stand 50 m back , making them handicap and run in the 100 m event in Olympics.
Look at his political tactics he clearly talks sociological aspects alone, doesn't care to look at how it worked?
Reservation is a failure, but what has been there let it be there , instead we must strongly oppose casteism , discrimination bring behavioral change, give them economic benefits, BEWARE TOMORROW general category will become discriminated , eye for an eye is never a solution.
Those winning olympics today esp. running , were descendants of mistreated ethnic race, but they rose above it to become an inspiration to all.
Then , when you come into Job perspective there is no high no low, all are same, you have to serve INDIANS not your caste!!!
Reservation in education to an extent is understandable , but in jobs NO
Saying why Ambani's son is rich is like asking how eaglets have the luck of flying, blaming the cause for the effect is perpetual you keep on blaming till you find it has no meaning.
Reservation has made us lose the most valuable Human Capital to USA and Europe!
50% open means 50% opportunity to all , not General alone, please leave it alone (now it is 40.5%)
Jobs need to be created not stolen.
Sanitation job also has dignity like any other job don't say it is lesser.
Temple pujaris are related to religion , govt jobs are not!
@Crimson Sash I have had no privileges , infact my caste (general) suffered at the hands of brahmins ,but still we believed in hardwork to become Diwans, PM of Cochin etc. I studied in govt school and my father started as a clerk in govt (cracked the exam through hardwork) with a house full of sisters, brothers who couldn't be employed (reservation) , errands in his house made him indebted and it led to full of financial problems myriad!!
Very brilliant answer
Kanahya =chuthya
.
No body arguing not to have Caste based reservation But Care should be
taken not to provide for unreasonable,
excessive or extravagant reservation, for that
would, by eliminating general competition in a
large field and by creating wide-spread
dissatisfaction amongst the equal righted citizens,
materially affect efficiency. Therefore beyond the permissible and legitimate
limits of 50% would be liable to be challenged as a fraud on the Constitution.
Note : Maratha reservation struck down for above reason.
Now Reservation is for Vote politics. Politicians give reservation for Votes but Court thinks, they are monitoring Constitution which is only meant for Social equality of casts. We Stuck between Devil and Sea.
There are alot of loop holes which kanhaiya is not saying!!
If a new born baby is struggling with a life threatening disease, or is born conjoint, or born differently abled is that also a reservation!!
There's a difference between Rajneeti and Dharam Raj. Rajneeti can't be done on Siddhant!!
Salute u sir
Outstanding thinking, sir ji
Giving Reservation to any of the caste is not a solution to the cruelty of Indian Hindu Culture But treating every human & woman equally is the solution. If Indian Dharma or politics order to cut down genitals of any woman or girl then cut down EVERY Indian girl & women's genitals. Treating everyone equally is the solution. Everybody have right to live their life with human dignity. And if not then treat everyone equally. Our human body is the greatest Gift of God so Destroying human body in inhuman ways(cruelty) is INSULT OF THE CREATOR OF UNIVERSE/GOD. Praising creation of God is the greatest way of worshipping God.
My response to question on reservation is; the opression happened on the basis of surname hence reservation is based on surname. Period
same as saying one religion terrorised and converted all other so all those where descendants of those affected should treat the descendants of that religion similarly! how rubbish! Period! Gandhiji taught us tolerance not revenge
Ha to Victoria desh loot ke gayi jaa Elisabeth, Charles,Kate Middleton ko bandi bana la
tera channel mai sab excellent answers hai...
I like him but yeh answer galat hai
@@abhijithjith3821 kyun galat hai bhai?
@@Anirban_Biswas. a lot of rich guys in lower castes. Why give them reservation. We want caste + economy based reservation. The rich lower caste can afford to study for government job 15 hrs a day. The poor lower caste guy can only study after coming from work. He said reservtion is flawed but he didn't say what the flaw is. Then he supported caste reservation just like the other Neta's .
@@abhijithjith3821 justify kaise karega tu? Kaun garib or kaun amir?? Abhi bhi samaj me inequality hai or jab tak yeh rahega tab tak caste reservation rahna chahiye..
@@Anirban_Biswas. bhai i said caste and income based reservation. Varna sab rich lower caste leke jayega. Main bhi obc hu.
Love your answer ♥️♥️♥️
Reservation will create more caste disparity .Just look the statistics of top colleges iit,iim,du etc where sucide,mental harassment,college dropout are most observe in reserved caste people.
Modi government should now eliminate this spoon feeding for our nation development.I want to ask him will he go to a sc doctor or a top degree,highly skilled gc doctor in emergency offcourse it is obvious he will go to gc.
Reservation is making them more lazy,incompetetive and uneconomical
Just imagine if the government funding used in more better place like rural hospital,free education till 12th to all category, sports, research etc then truly we will be a self dependent indian
Irradicate surname..and caste issues will be gone for ever...
Let there be no banias, Patel, Chamaar , thakur , pandit etc...and stop dynaty legacy of jobs .
Encourage inter-caste and inter-religious marriages to happen...
If such a society comes to exist the issue of reservations will never arise....
It's like curing irritation in the eye by plucking out your eyes, good luck
If don't know the cure just let the way it is..
Does any one speak on management quota and degrees bought by money..
Reservation band karo ,nahi to pure general wale ,foreign shift hogainge ,to caste wale kya karenge sab ek line pe aa gainge
I am general category.Please yar mera channel subscribe kardo we will fight against reservation.🚩
@@kashmirtellerking827 yes reservation band karna hoga warna mai foreign shift ho jaounga
@@archanasingh6078 ha bhai mai bhi yhi sochta hu bhai pls subscribe kro hum future me fight krenge against reservation agar mere subscriber jyada rhe to kuch ho sakta hai
@Akash KumarCHUP!!!
@Akash Kumar America me inko koi job nai dega. Padai me to 0 hai ye log.
Reservation should be based on 𝙀𝙘𝙤𝙣𝙤𝙢𝙞𝙘 𝘾𝙤𝙣𝙙𝙞𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣𝙨
𝙉𝙤𝙩 𝙤𝙣 𝙘𝙖𝙨𝙩𝙚
𝘼 𝙎𝘾, 𝙎𝙏 𝙊𝙍 𝙊𝘽𝘾 𝙘𝙖𝙣 𝙗𝙚 𝙖 𝙗𝙞𝙡𝙡𝙞𝙤𝙣𝙖𝙞𝙧𝙚..𝙨𝙝𝙤𝙪𝙡𝙙 𝙩𝙝𝙚𝙮 𝙗𝙚 𝙜𝙞𝙫𝙚𝙣 𝙧𝙚𝙨𝙚𝙧𝙫𝙖𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣 𝙛𝙖𝙘𝙞𝙡𝙞𝙩𝙮?????
Sir hum aapte sath hai
Very great answer