Israelis Are Not 'Indigenous' (and other ridiculous pro-Israel arguments)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ต.ค. 2024
- Showing that Zionism is in fact a colonial endeavour, & refuting other dumb pro-Israel stuff
Support me on Patreon: / badempanada
Twitch stream: / badempanada
Follow my Instagram: / badempanada
Become a member on TH-cam: www.youtube.co...
One-time donations: ko-fi.com/BadE...
Second Channel: / @badempanadalive
Sources:
[1] www.thedailyvo...
[2] mondoweiss.net...
[3] www.cjpme.org/...
[4] www.middleeast...
[5] Memory at the Surface: Colonial Forgetting in Postcolonial France, Abdelmajid Hannoum.
[6] pop.education....
[7] www.jewishvirt...
[8] Zionism and Imperialism: The Historical Origins, Abdul-Wahab Kayyali.
[9] archive.org/de...
[10] www.gutenberg....
[11] archive.org/de...
[12] www.jewishvirt...
[13] www.marxists.o...
[14] www.un.org/esa...
[15] www.ilo.org/gl...
[16] pdcrodas.webs....
[17] The Rhetoric of Romanità: Representations of Caesar in Fascist Theatre, Jane Dunnett.
[18] lawoffice.org....
[19] lawoffice.org....
[20] pubmed.ncbi.nl...
[21] Jewish and Middle Eastern non-Jewish populations share a common pool of Y-chromosome biallelic haplotypes, M. F. Hammer, et al.
[22] www.sciencedir...
[23] The Persistence of the Palestinian Question, Joseph Massad.
[24] www.dohainstit...
Israel
Palestine
Palestinian
Israeli
Indigenous
Colonialism
Colonial
Native
Herzl
Brilliant video, absolutely excellent work.
Like every Hakim and Bad Empanada video. Always amazing.
Yall should collaborate
❤
Deprogram collab when??
Hakim AND BadEmpanada?! In the same comment section? What is this a crossover episode?
He literally said" If I dont steal it, someone else will"...outstandingly horrific. I really didnt expect him to be so casual and honest about it.
I know because they mostly always deny it
@@IslenoGutierrez that idiot probably had no idea he was being filmed
@@joelbedulla4 Probably. I’m sure his brethren gave him hell for it after they saw him admitting to it, which they always deny and try to make themselves the victims.
I just found it amazing that he's an anti vaccine guy named Fauci, lmao
I wouldn’t call him “honest”, honest etymologically relates to being honourable, so if anything this man is being blatant, shameless, overt, flagrant and reprehensible
proof(of colonization by Israel):
David Ben Gurion, quoted on pp 91-2 of Chomsky's Fateful Triangle, which appears in Simha Flapan's "Zionism and the Palestinians pp 141-2 citing a 1938 speech.
"Let us not ignore the truth among ourselves ... politically we are the aggressors and they defend themselves... The country is theirs, because they inhabit it, whereas we want to come here and settle down, and in their view we want to take away from them their country."
Yitzhak Rabin, leaked censored version of Rabin memoirs, published in the New York Times, 23 October 1979.
"We walked outside, Ben-Gurion accompanying us. Allon repeated his question, What is to be done with the Palestinian population?' Ben-Gurion waved his hand in a gesture which said 'Drive them out!"
Moshe Dayan, April 1969, Ha'aretz; quoted in Edward Said, 'Zionism from the Standpoint of Its Victims', Social Text, Volume 1, 1979, 7-58.
"Jewish villages were built in the place of Arab villages. You do not even know the names of these Arab villages, and I do not blame you because geography books no longer exist. Not only do the books not exist, the Arab villages are not there either. Nahlal arose in the place of Mahlul; Kibbutz Gvat in the place of Jibta; Kibbutz Sarid in the place of Huneifis; and Kefar Yehushua in the place of Tal al-Shuman. There is not a single place built in this country that did not have a former Arab population."
David Ben-Gurion (Quoted on pp 855-56 in Shabtai Teveth's Ben-Gurion in a slightly different translation).
"If I knew that it was possible to save all the children of Germany by transporting them to England, and only half by transferring them to the Land of Israel, I would choose the latter, for before us lies not only the numbers of these children but the historical reckoning of the people of Israel."
Vladimir (Ze’ev) Jabotinsky
Jabotinsky helped lead Revisionist Zionist Movement which eventually evolved into the post-1948 Herut Party and eventually the Likud Party. His Secretary, a historian Benzion Netanyahu is the father of Binyamin Netanyahu. Benzion’s final book, The Founding Fathers of Zionism, described Israel as a country that-like America-was built on the intellectual foundations of its founders: Leo Pinsker, Theodor Herzl, Max Nordau, Israel Zangwill, and Ze’ev Jabotinsky.
Jabotinsky also set up the party's youth movement, Betar, which was characterized by militaristic, almost fascist, appearance including dark brown uniforms. Jabotinsky admired Mussolini. His movement repeatedly sought affiliation with and assistance from Rome.
In his IRON WALL article that was published in Ha'aretz Daily in 1923. He stated:
".... Settlement can thus develop under the protection of a force that is not dependent on the local population, behind an IRON WALL which they will be powerless to break down. ....a voluntary agreement is just not possible. As long as the Arabs preserve a gleam of hope that they will succeed in getting rid of us, nothing in the world can cause them to relinquish this hope, precisely because they are not a rubble but a living people. And a living people will be ready to yield on such fateful issues only when they give up all hope of getting rid of the Alien Settlers. Only then will extremist groups with their slogan 'No, never' lose their influence, and only then their influence be transferred to more moderate groups. And only then will the moderates offer suggestions for compromise. Then only will they begin bargaining with us on practical matters, such as guarantees against PUSHING THEM OUT, and equality of civil, and national rights."
"Eliminate the Diaspora, or the Diaspora will surely eliminate you." (From "Tisha B'av 1937").
“the source of national feeling … lies in a man’s blood … in his racio-physical type, and in that alone … a man’s spiritual outlooks are primarily determined by his physical structure … For that reason we do not believe in spiritual assimilation. It is inconceivable, from the physical point of view, that a Jew born to a family of pure Jewish blood … can become adapted to the spiritual outlooks of a German or a Frenchman … He maybe wholly imbued with that German fluid but the nucleus of his spiritual structure will always remain Jewish”
“A Jew brought up among Germans may assume German custom, German words. He may be wholly imbued with that German fluid but the nucleus of his spiritual structure will always remain Jewish, because his blood, his body, his physical-racial type are Jewish. ... It is impossible for a man to become assimilated with people whose blood is different from his own. In order to become assimilated, he must change his body, he must become one of them, in blood. ... There can be no assimilation as long as there is no mixed marriage. ... An increase in the number of mixed marriages is the only sure and infallible means for the destruction of nationality as such. ... A preservation of national integrity is impossible except by a preservation of racial purity, and for that purpose we are in need of a territory of our own where our people will constitute the overwhelming majority”
He stated in 1923:
"The Arabs loved their country as much as the Jews did. Instinctively, they understood Zionist aspirations very well, and their decision to resist them was only natural ..... There was no misunderstanding between Jew and Arab, but a natural conflict. .... No Agreement was possible with the Palestinian Arab; they would accept Zionism only when they found themselves up against an 'iron wall,' when they realize they had no alternative but to accept Jewish settlement." (America And The Founding Of Israel, p.90)”
Arthur Ruppin :
He headed the Jewish Agency between 1933 and 1935, ‘The Father of Jewish settlement in Palestine’ and helped to settle the large numbers of Jewish immigrants.
"This very likeness to the Asiatic peoples, from whom they have been separated for 2000 years, shows that the Jews have remained unchanged, and that in the Jews of today we may say we may have the same people who fought victoriously under King David, who repented their misdeeds under Ezra and Nehemiah, died fighting for freedom under Bar-Kokhba, were the great carriers of trade under between Europe and the Orient in the early Middle Ages….Thus the Jews have not only preserved their great natural racial gifts, but through a long process of selection these gifts have become strengthened. The terrible conditions under which the Jews lived during the last 500 years necessitated a bitter struggle for life in which only the cleverest and strongest survived… The result is that in the Jew of today, we have what is in some respects a particular valuable human type. Other nations may have other points of superiority, but in respect of intellectual gifts the Jews can scarcely be surpassed by any nation.” (The Invention of the Jewish People, Shlomo Sand)
“I do not believe in the TRANSFER of an individual. I believe in the TRANSFER of entire villages.” (The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited, Benny Morris)
What ‘The Father’ had in mind? Arthur Ruppin (1876-1943), cultural identity, weltanschauung and action
What ‘The Father’ had in mind? Arthur Ruppin (1876-1943), cultural identity, weltanschauung and action
www.academia.edu/1250457/What_The_Father_had_in_mind_Arthur_Ruppin_1876_1943_cultural_identity_weltanschauung_and_action
“Ruppin’s constant aspiration for racial purity in the Jews emerged from within the scientific and medical discourse which praised racial purity”
More recently:
Ariel Sharon, Israeli Foreign Minister, addressing a meeting of the Tsomet Party, Agence France Presse, Nov. 15, 1998.
"Everybody has to move, run and grab as many (Palestinian) hilltops as they can to enlarge the (Jewish) settlements because everything we take now will stay ours...Everything we don't grab will go to them."
original post: www.quora.com/Is-Israel-colonizing-Palestine
@@-MO22
Zionism is man-made movement and militant and dangerous in every way.
Great work
@-MO22
In the Book of Deuteronomy, God put the Children of Israel out of Canaan Land because of their disobedience to him and his Covenant.
They began worshipping strange and pagan gods and even put their children through the fire sacrificing them to the pagan god Molech.
God of Israel became angry and GOD plucked the Israelites off the land and uprooted them and then God scattered them to the uttermost parts of the Earth.
Now, I want to make this point. God scattered his people all over the world.
The Eastern European Jews who emigrated to Palestine around 1917 and especially 1940s wants the world to believe that they alone are the chosen ones of the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
No way! They moved throughout the Middle East, Africa, Spain, Greece, Italy, all over the world.
The Israelites were of olive to dark skinned people. God's people are red, yellow, brown, and Black. But the Eastern European Jews especially it's founder Theodur Herzl and David Ben Gurion sold this lie that Jews are only European and white skinned people. Theodur Herzl even said in his writings that "HE", not GOD, wanted to EUROPEANIZE PALESTINE.
Theodur Herzl wanted to change the semitic people and culture of the Arab/Palestinians already inhabiting the Land of Palestine for centuries.
God didn't send or return those Jews to Palestine. It was the desires of a man who mission was for Jews and Jews alone to have a homeland of their own. But how do you go to a place already occupied and take it and make it your State?
Also, God scattered his people all over the Earth, so where were the Asian Jews, the African Jews,
the Yeminite Jews, the Iraqi Jews, the Iranian Jews and so forth.
Theodur Herzl's Zionist ideology was a Supremist Nationalist ideology for Jews, white skinned European Jews.
Rich Jews like the Rothschilds helped the Zionist movement and rich Jewish donors and organizations in Europe and America helped that movement.
They didn't Jews from other locations and countries being a part of the Zionist movement to move to Palestine and make a Homeland.
They had considered Argentina and Uganda but decided on making Palestine their homeland knowing that the Arab/Palestinians were living there and the majority population among a small amount of Jews and Muslims who by the way got along together back then until these European Jews arrived.
The Palestinians welcomed the European Jews but then they became suspicious and angry when too many of the Jews continuously moved to Palestine and were taking over the land.
They wanted the immigration of Jews to be restricted.
The Arab/Palestinians eventually went to war with them but lost and the Jews tool more land.
You see, that was the plan all along, to take the land.
Eventually, the Jews from Europe that had emigrated there out the Indigenous Arab/Palestinian people in a open-air prison for years.
When Hamas attacked the Jews on October 7th, and took hostages also American people, the government has been on a genocidal rampage against the Palestinian people, men, women, babies and children.
Netanyahu and his extremist Likud cabinet have not retrieved many of the hostages.
Now, Israel government is fighting with Yemen, Lebanon and Iran.
Fighting with Iran has been Netanyahu's dream and he is taking every advantage to get AMERICA involved with his wars.
Netanyahu demands money from America and weapons as if they are the 51st State of America.
We have problems in AMERICA and our legislators talking about doing away with Social Security because the funds are depleting. Well STOP giving Israel our taxpayer's dollars of
$ 3.6 billion dollars each year.
America gave them more billions of dollars recently and $ 26 billion dollars worth of weapons.
Meanwhile, we have American people needing affordable housing and the homeless problem is rampant. There are many people in AMERICA still food deprived. Our education system could use our taxpayer's dollars to get books for the children and math and science programs and tutoring. The teachers need school supplies.
Our Government wants to cut Food Stamps, Medicare, Medicare, and other benefits that really helps the American people and the government is giving our money to Israel and for what?
That is their homeland so they need to protect themselves and why are the American people subsidizing their citizens livelihoods?
The Israeli government only cares about Jewish people and causes and damn be anyone else. Yes, they accept our billions of dollars and so yes I have a stake in this.
I don't consent to my tax dollars going to Israel for them to not spend it on Christians or other people.
America have you lost it.
They don't have our interest at hand. They use us because we're dumb.
America is giving Israel billions of dollars because it's something over there they want.
Israel is not our friend and a bad ally who does bad things and doesn't listen to word order or behavior.
America needs help, but look our money is going to Israel and helping them when they are the problem and have been ever since they emigrated from Eastern European countries via the Zionists Project.
They have cause the chaos there. America should not funding this evil regime.
This was a very helpful and clear video; I think there are a lot of people who need to see this video right now, so I hope it gets a lot of attention.
@ashproductions
People need to REPENT and turn to God and read the Bible.
i know its cliche to call things "orwellian"
but spining israelis as an "indigenous people" and zionism "decolonization" truly is orwellian in the most literal sense
It's certainly doublethink
Literally the work of the Ministry of Truth
THIS
this is, literally, 1984.
@@yeetgrenade7492 it's 2022 gawd!
As a Palestinian that is unable to visit his home country, I really appreciate the effort you put into making this video to educate others
@@1995yuda nice try schlomo
@@1995yuda Here we can see a zionist clown. 🤡
it's something that isnt talked about at all, even actively opposed in the US. Shits sus lol
@@levand3673 u so believe yourself, there is no digging artifacts that show it belongs to Jewish/ isrealite u go ahead and give me a name of a ruler of old Israel!? !.
How is it yours as well?
I don't believe u as well, same your words against u, at least the original Palestinians didn't occupy the land and took it by force, to this days they still killing and taking lands saying they own thousands of years ago, there is no event in history that say they been forced to leave it.
So don't lecture me about artifacts and history because to this day there isn't a true proof of those claims.
All fake to justify thier doings also there is letters that recently reviled from British royals and some leaders in Middle East and generals in the British occupation army.... that there were many countries chosen as suggestions for occupation and possibility of making a Jewish pure country.... If I remember correctly the country was chosen first was Ethiopia then they settled down on Palestine because they could make a religious and owned claims. A justification for the occupation in the eye of the world and more Even thier Jewish true man of faith are against occupation, honestly the truth is out there for whoever truly wants it, if u can't see it then it your problem.
@@levand3673 I honestly don't know why you want to make the truth more harder to see but, first your argument or even so called evidence are totally wrong and weak, if u want to go back in history let me start by telling u who the true owners of the land are, they called Canaan before jewish or any others they were the first ppl to live there and then Jewish and Arab.. Are thier descendants, Palestine was a mixed region with many religious groups since a long time so don't try to make it yours based on a coin or anything, throughout history itself there was many many changes, u can't say it jewish land alone because there was ppl living their before them and till today there are Christians and Muslims and more...
From the other side the religious side those u call king David.... Solomon were prophets that tried to show u the true way but u stubborn and u didn't even follow them and made your religion full of corruption and twists.... I don't really want to dive more because it not our topic.
Anyway let even say your ppl lived there thousand of years ago and definitely with different races... But let say u truly lived there, why have u left? Did someone forced u to leave? Wasn't that the holy land why didn't your ancestors fight for it and kept it? Was it empty after your ppl left??
I read some history and found out that probably the roman were the ones that kicked the Jewish out of Jerusalem.
So your ppl left and scattered around the world and left other ppl fight over that land? Is that it and when they get it your ppl return to claim thier old land? Is this is your holy story???!
Make no sense.
Even so.... this days your ppl the Jewish in Israel are still kicking Palestinians ppl out of thier homes, let me ask u this I don't know from where u are or where u are but let say u now in your home which u get from your father and before it your grandfather...and now I come knocking at your door with an army behind me saying get out this land is owned by my ancestors from thousands years ago and u must leave buddy go there is a huge desert there live in it., what will be your reaction what will be your feelings and answer when u see me grabbing your wife and baby kid and throwing them out in the street? Be honest what will be your reaction.
Based on your arguments black American ppl should go back and claim thier land in Africa, I should look my origins and go claim the land my ancestors lived on i have rights as well maybe it Palestine itself....
Come on stop taking ppl as fools, Are u mad are u ppl crazy, what the hell is wrong with u, and u come telling me they found a stupid coin with a stupid language written on it, seriously do u have a brain? Are u even count as human beings.
Seriously as much as lower humans can get Israelies will be always the lowest. No matter how rich u get and no matter how power and support at your back, corruption and injustice will never last forever just remember even huge empires has fallen.
Nothing stay forever, and always good will win.
"If I don't steal it, someone else will."
America FUK YEAH.
Jacob from New York
Did you try to steal a person's dream/nightmare again?
Jews in a nutshell
Nazis: if we didn't persecute Jews, someone else would have.
My father lives in Palestine. He's a doctor.
I live in Belgium and cannot visit my father in Palestine like my Ukrainian collegue and friend that can visit his parents and vice versa because they live in Israel....
Fck this world for real!
Is your father okay??
@@fucchan_xo Since yesterday no more contact....
@@fucchan_xo Just got a hold of him. He is ok. But Israeli govt has sealed everything off. They can't go anywhere. Maybe just to get water and bread.
@@shoedil812 🫂
@@fucchan_xo May the Lord bless you.
It would be funny if France invaded Southern England with the justification that it was Norman land they were taken back from Danish occupation.
Angloids are not british
@@filipzietek5146 The English are a very funny example for him to use, given that the British isles *do* have indigenous peoples who were displaced and colonized by the Anglo-Saxons.
@@arachnofiend2859 English people are genetically two-thirds indigenous. At most, they're a third Anglo-Saxon. The Saxons mostly moved in at the top of an existing feudal system. Back then, when you conquered a kingdom, you didn't kill the locals, because they were a resource. A marvelous example of this was the 10,000-year-old Cheddar Man. An analysis of his DNA revealed that one of his direct descendants was living a few kilometres from where he was found, and teaching history, of all things.
Two thirds, one third, a quarter, a tablespoon or a teaspoon. Such measurements are for baking cakes, not identifying human beings. The universe cares neither for you nor your identity.
@@danteskl720 true that. And it can be taken to ridiculous extremes, like Apartheid racial classification and blood quanta in North America. It's an attempt to apply the scientific method to something that's inherently non-scientific.
The most ridiculous thing about this indigenous argument is that Ben Gurion regarded the Palestinians as being descended partially from the Jews that stayed after the Roman expulsion. Though when that fact became too inconvenient it was dropped and the Palestinians became the scary arab invaders
A lot of the earliest Zionist “heroes” (by all means these men are vile monsters) viewed it that way. To the point M*she Dayan at times recommended intermarriage.
I like how the implication is that Jews can only get along with Jews . Pretty effed up jussayin
Also there is no evidence that all Jews especially the farmers left during that period you listed outside of religion. Besides the fact you are an unhinged zealot you clearly did not watch the video.
Also one more question Himyarite kingdom? That’s how the Yemeni community actually became Jewish was a mass conversion but the Yemeni Jewish kingdom known as the himyarites. The most basic of searches can dismantle your bullshit set up. Pathetic Zionist.
@@Rita1984 by this logic (that i dont support), arabs have at least an equal claim to the land, because theyre "fellow indigenous people". the israeli state remains a jewish-supremacist state, at the expense of the Palestinians
I love the New Yorker in Israel saying “if I don’t steal your house, someone else will”. That really solves the issue for this Palestinian you stole the home of.
This is also the same thing anyone benefiting from an exploitative system says to justify what they do..
@@stephenkolostyak4087So why was the Palestinian woman saying that it'd been her home?
because she made the mistake of thinking he could be reasoned with.@@winesap2
maybe it's fake news@@winesap2
I don't think we are supposed to count on one single American to solve the problem in that land.
@@winesap2 She'd literally lived in it. Her family had to move into the house next door owned by their extended family. The woman is the twin sister of Muhammad El-Kurd their story is well documented and they have been very active against the occupation since childhood in terms of recording the circumstances.
This aged well.
Of course. It's truth.
And vice versa.
Like a good pile of bullshit
I think this rhetoric is on the up now too. Especially seen as they’re basically about to take Gaza, they can say it was theirs in the first place
This truth will always aged finer than wine 🍷
Oh wow the Liberia/Israel connection makes perfect sense. Not just from being colonial states, but also in how they were supported by the countries that originally oppressed them because those countries didn't feeling like reckoning with their own racism, so they sent the oppressed people somewhere else.
Hi there! Would just like to add that many indigenous to Liberia are actually still there and currently outnumber those of America-Liberian ancestry. Bassa, Kru, and Gola are still spoken and passed down languages with the second having 300,000 documented speakers to date. So to be clear, the ACS didn’t exactly send us packing
Jews were not "sent" to Israel. The British actually didn't let many Jews migrate to Israel and as a result Jews that could've survived the Holocaust died. Jews fought for Israel and won, without the help of non-Jews. Get over it. Israel is necessary for the survival of the Jewish people. The biggest difference between Jews and blacks is that people weren't trying to genocide African Americans.
@@dgtor_official”ohhh I like your accent, where you from😮😮””
@@BrokenSoldier1515 ?
@@dgtor_official
It's an old vine by Jay Versace.
Repeat a LIE often enough and it becomes ISRAEL.
i should Rename Israel = Isralie
ironic how that is a quote by a Nazi, Joseph Goebbels.
IsReal
Isnt it funny how israel has these words in its name: a lie, lies, liar, liars
@@jessicaferrari3987a real lie for sure😊
The audacity of that Ukrainian guy from New York stealing someone's else land!!
wait, converts can move to Israel & get free houses?
So if I convingly pretend to believe, my 100% european ass could in theory get the house of some Palestinian grandma? Well, if I was an uncrupulous asshole without morals, I would start learning Hebrew right now.
It's not as simple as that apparently. They have a Conversion Authority which reviews every case, and apparently it's fairly strict in how it evaluates conversions as genuine and valid.
That said, it seems to be easier for people from first world Western countries than from elsewhere.
YES. this is true basically.
Not if you're Ethiopian.
@Goozero1 Wrong. If You have Jewish DNA you get Automatic Citizenship....even the Ethopians have it. They have 20% Jewish DNA.
@teamtriss Nope. Automatics Citizenship goes to the People who have Jewish DNA. The Converts have to go through Rigorous conversion laws to get land. Rabbis don't like to even perform Marriages much anymore without DNA proving that they are Jews by DNA.
In Aotearoa (New Zealand", we use the term "ahi kaa" to determine who are the most likely to have ownership of the land by who could keep the "home fires burning," so to speak. If people move away from the land for 2,000 years, could they claim "ahi kaa?"
🥝🇳🇿
im honestly suprised that yt even allowed this to come up in my suggestions. the truth is dangerous, especially now.
Not enough people make the Liberia analogy but it’s perfect for this situation
Not enough people really know anything about Liberia period.
@@cryptbeast3222 Not enough people know anything about Africa
@@abetheconservationist595 Well they did sell their own, if a rebellion sprung up for example, the captives would likely find themselves enslaved if they survived. The same thing happened in Europe, and pretty much anywhere in the world. Nations weren't really a thing, everything was just property, including people. Slavery was just a thing that existed back then. Also there is a huge push by "African Nationalists" to try and promote the idea of an "African culture" and "African History" and so on. So you can't really blame people who don't care enough to look into even their own history (the vast majority of people) for just listening to what "Africans" tell them. I put Africans in quotes because there is no pan-African identity, like you said it's very vast, and has so many different cultures, and ethnic groups, with their own history.
Well... I have to finish the video but Liberia was a place to drop off all former slaves so they wouldn't live in the USA and I guess they were also expecting to gain influence in Africa (as far as I know) I know former slaves thought they were more civilized than the natives and established a colony rule but... the white man is to blame for that.
@@firstnamelastname7079 I wish I could give this one million likes
The other issue Israelis don’t seem to understand is that the population in that part of the world has gone from the tens of thousands to the tens of millions and there just isn’t room for millions to come from other parts of the world to live in a desert. But a biblical story that says this is your homeland doesn’t give people from all over the world property rights to a place they’ve never lived, no matter what their bloodline.
@@constantineblyuz5786 Look at the size of America and Europe. Is there not enough land there aswell? Also, I didn't know getting your house stolen, being oppressed and having to go through tens of checkpoints just to visit your family are enjoyable civil rights...
@@constantineblyuz5786 watch the video in its entirety. And please stop spouting sourceless BS please. "Palestine wasn't developed before colonization".
Like fr, where's the sources?
@@kucingcat8687 "I made it the fuck up"
@@constantineblyuz5786
Yeah you just forgot the ethnic cleansing of 1948.
@@constantineblyuz5786Great justification for Zionists going into Palestine from other parts of the world and removing 750,000 people from their land and homes by killing them and forcing them out with the goal of making room for their "new country". Then with those that were left they kept pushing them into smaller and smaller territory by stealing their homes and giving them to people from places like New York who wanted to go back to "their homeland" they'd never even been to.
Indigenous is whoever was living there when a colonial power came in an moved them off their land. A work of fiction doesn't give people the right to claim ownership of any part of the world. But Hasidic Jews are opposed to Zionism and they are the ones who take the Torah most seriously and literally. Zionists just make stuff up that wasn't even in their religious texts so they can justify colonialism.
Obviously anyone rational knows who the indigenous ones are but breaking it down in this much bulletproof detail takes major skills
Yeah those Arabs are definitely native to that piece of land that is not in Arabia.
@hj-ls8pc Cope.
@@hj-ls8pcshowing your ignorance
@@roselee4445 I am factually correct
@@roselee4445 next you will tell me the Arabs are native to Morocco as well. Actually brain dead and don’t know history.
Its amazing you point out the Liberia analogy. I, being fully aware of African history, had always found the parallels between Israel and Liberia striking. I pointed out as much on twitter to an Israeli defender.
At what time does he mention this? I seem to have missed it.
@@Tetragrammaton22 He says it towards the end of the video
@@Tetragrammaton22 35:10
@@СвятославСоколов-х2м
1. Liberia took care of that itself.
2. Liberia is no longer a slave state.
3. No one is calling for the destruction of Israel buddy, just the decolonisation of Israel and the abolition of Palestinian oppression.
@@RK-cj4oc It means an end to the oppression of Palestinians and an alignment of institutions and structures to fulfil this purpose. The details of decolonisation ought to follow this logic.
Ain’t no way I got an ad from the Israeli Foreign Affairs Ministry on this video 💀💀
Propaganda workin overtime 💀
I'm getting them all the time now
Colonizers are working overtime
The miracle US tax payer dollars 💸
hasbara workers screaming, crying and throwing up at the sight of this video 🫣🤧
For all those “October 7” folks: look at the date on this video. And look back farther…. This is a loooonnng history.
If you need a good history lesson, I recommend seeking Gabor Mate’s discussions about this. Or any if the many Jewish supporters of Palestinians.
I know he is controversial but Norman Finkelstein too.
@@notimportant123 Ilan Pappé, Noam Chomsky, Avi Shlaim, there are many. And those are just Israelis.
@@er... you might have meant to reply to OP? But thank you!! Love Chomsky.
@@notimportant123 Oops, yeah....well both actually.
Ilan Pappé, Noam Chomsky, Avi Shlaim, there are many. And those are just the Israelis.
Omg!! Throughout this whole Israel/ Palestine conflict and learning more about it. The resemblance to the colonization of Liberia was all I could think about. And what happened there? The indigenous people revolted and Liberia has never been the same sense. It was that same logic that brought AA settlers there. The white population wanted to get rid of their freed slaves. So of course America endorsed them migrating, even furthering the lie that they deserved the land. 35:25 it’s disgusting. #freepalestine.
WOW THEY BEEN EVERYWHERE THESE COLONISTS & IMPERIALISTS.
I AM LOST FOR WORDS ANOUT TGESE OPPRESSORS. IT JUST MAKES ONE VOMIT.
My son goes to Catholic school, so I've had to counter the indoctrination he gets about the Palestine-Israel conflict for the past year. Which wasn't as hard as I thought it would be. I just explained it to him in terms of settler colonialism, comparing it to manifest destiny and lebensraum, and he pretty much understood right away.
And then for extra measure, to give him more context, I lent him my copy of _The Hundred Years War On Palestine._ So now he's better equipped to push back on all the propaganda.
@@ViraL_FootprinT.ex.egood job. Also try to learn the difference between a conflict and a one sided genocide. There is no conflict. Just full blown terrorism from israel
@@mahermosally6691 what are you even talking about terrorist organization called HAMAS attacked Israel 70 years ago there was UN treaty that split the borders evenly between palestine and israel but the palestinias didn't accepted it and waged a war on Israel you're not better than jews you're just playing poor victim card like them jews
If Palestine is free the world is Free ❤
This aged like the finest wine. Keep up the great work!
As an egyptian whose grandfather was a war veteran of all the 3 wars we fought against Israel, I'm extremely happy to see non arabs bring attention to this
Actual VETS GOOD
First time on leftist internet / breadtube?
@@MultiSciGeek wtf are you talking about lmao
Hopefully we'll go to war again and get rid of the virus once and for all this time.
Arab countries kiss 🇮🇱 ass though
I'from Brazil🔰, #FreeFreePALESTINE of NaZionist "We know too well that our freedom is incomplete
without the FREEDOM of the PALESTINIANS." - Nelson Mandela 🍉🕊✌💪❤
Isn't Cecil Rhodes where they got the name for Rhodesia? Yeah, you guys pretty much PERFECTED the art of bloody colonialism.
Rhodes is still here today with DeBeers controlling diamond markets. There are no diamonds in holland and belgium
"you guys" who?
@@mariaplochocki9393 Zionists.
Simply Excellent !!!!. I apologize I can't contribute monetarily. I am colonized and rather poor. But, send you my respect and admiration for your work.
As a person of Greek heritage, I am so glad you mentioned the Greek Turkish question.
Hey I’m not Greek, but I do think it’s about time you reclaimed your rightful territory.
@@detrockcity3 It was hugely majority Greek, expelling small numbers to an exiting country. They didn't sneak in any settlers against international, which when I personally started pivoting away from Zionism.
Kurdistan, Greece and Armenia = Turkey
Make Istanbul Constantinople Again.
@@MarkConway73 it is not ur bussines irish
Thank you *so much* for making this video! I thought I knew a lot on this subject, and that there wasn't much that new that I'd learn from this, and I was *very wrong!* I learned *a lot* from this video, and I even finally learned the truth about Liberia, which was a blind spot for me before tonight. So, thank you, thank you, thank you!
False equivalencies is the bread and butter of Israel.
Israeli-born geneticist Dr. According to Eran Elhaik's latest genetic research, today's Israelis are descended from the Caspian Khazar Turks, not from the Middle East.
@@bumingokturk7870 Yes - it is great to listen to him. Also Shlomo Sand - The Invention of the Jewish People.
Revising history is their bread and butter too.
@@bumingokturk7870oof
Pillpull, projection, inversion and sophistry too
Was literally just thinking about the history of Liberia in the 35-minute mark (worth noting that the creation of Liberia was literally a product of the "American Colonization Society"). Excellent video.
See you forgetting that those people that returned there was originally stolen from that area and their great grand children returned to that area less then 100-150 yrs later with the oppressors culture and government not their grandparents culture
@@charlemeH The ACS literally carved up a state, called it "Liberia", and then dumped American freemen there, regardless of the origin of their ancestors. The freemen had internalised the racial ideology of America, and reproduced the racial hierarchy of American society in Liberia. Liberia never even had a dark-skinned African leader from its genesis until 1980. The country is very much a product of settler-colonialism.
@Videogamestashbox Your comment is interesting because it seems to downplay the various wars, ethnic cleansing and effectively slavery that took place in Liberia. Your claim that there was no "intifada" is similarly absurd on its face - since the kind of oppression the Americo-Liberians would do would surely generate resistance from the various communities that they trampled underfoot.
I'm not sure why you are invested in objecting to Liberia's comparison to Israel as a settler-colony. Perhaps the comparisons to South West Africa (Namibia) or Rhodesia are more comfortable for you. The point of comparison of Liberia and Israel is to make a comparison of them as *settler-colonies*.
Didn’t the United States create Liberia, then repatriated people of African descent to the colony to blend with those who were never enslaved? As for Israel, it’s the Zionist who created Israel, after being promised a “homeland” out of Palestine. Palestine was never a colony of Britain, only an area controlled after defeating the Ottomans.
@@Afriboy10
That's not actually true, most of the leaders of liberia were dark skinned before 1980
As a Mexican I’ve heard this story before.
It’s European colonization 100%.
@@BioChemistryWizard My dna test says I aint no coloniser.
israelis are not from europe. they invaded europe in the middle ages and took advantage of the indiginous people there too. they were expelled from european nations over 100 times during the medieval period.
@@josephdeneka666wtf r u talking bout? They didn't invade Europe in the Middle Ages. Jewish migration to Europe began as early as the first millennium BC and continued for some centuries after that
Blah blah blah. Next you will say they are all 'white' as if that means something. What would 'brown' cover if we ran around saying that? So ridiculous. You know nothing of indigenous people of the world. You probably equate the term 'indigenous' to 'non-white' 'non-Europeans.'
Nice way of not supporting just even one tiny piece of the world for Jews. Blame the white people! Yay. That settles that! Spare us.
@MiloCarrete In what sense? Please explain!
I see some angry Ben Shapiros in the comments lol. Looks like the facts didn't care about their feelings.
The title of this video isn't quite accurate either. Jews are indigenous to the area when it was called Canaan. Esau settled in the land of Canaan with 2 Canaanite women, and became what's known as Edom, but they are pretending to be Israelites.
@@weseeucommies8402they are called jewish palestinians. It is not the case for ashkenazi jewish people though, as stated in video
I never held a strong view on the subject, but you have brought my position to a very real place.. thanks for the education.
"The Case Against Israel" Michael Neumann - every paragraph footnoted. Similar to this video in that the actual words of the early Zionists are cited.
"western commie" lemme guess ur part of the lgbtq
Same for me here
Well thats sad because this is extremely biased against Israel and the struggle of Jewish people for sovereignty. Zionism, no matter what justifications, exists because of thousands of years of oppression of Jews in every country they have lived. No matter what you say, the Jewish people overwhelmingly will die for their native homeland.
If you cannot acknowledge this, then you should prepare to see mass deaths in the news for the next century.
It's funny because the idea of tracing lineage back to ancient Israel excludes lots of people like Ethiopian jews and Hellenic Jews and their descendants. Also if you go back thousands of years you get to most people's common ancestors. It's possible that there are more non- jews descended from Ancient Israel.
It also excludes Yemeni Jews. Also this ignores the fact Ethiopian and Yemeni Jews practice Judaism similar to an actual indigenous group in Palestine, Samaritans. A lot of people in Nablus are acknowledged by Samiritans as most likely having Samiritan ancestry but converted to Islam or Christianity with time.
@@vannakinder352 it doesn't change that Israel is the ancestral homeland for the Jewish people
@@woobiefuntime and the Palestinians
Ancient Israelites also weren't native to Palestine, they expelled the native Canaanites and took over their land.
@@mxkinist I'd argue they are just Cannanites that became culturally distinct.
Most enlightening video on this issue I’ve seen. Brilliant. Really appreciate the time and effort you put into pulling together all the threads.
Well thats sad because this is extremely biased against Israel and the struggle of Jewish people for sovereignty. Zionism, no matter what justifications, exists because of thousands of years of oppression of Jews in every country they have lived. No matter what you say, the Jewish people overwhelmingly will die for their native homeland.
If you cannot acknowledge this, then you should prepare to see mass deaths in the news for the next century.
Blessed TH-cam recommended! This video has never been more relevant!
“The Balfour Declaration” explains clearly who spearheaded Israel and why England felt indebted to assist.
@@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0in a letter they said dear lord Rothschild
Bla bla bla bla bla bla bla
Bla bla bla bla bla bla bla
Give us money and we will create a country for jews after taking lands from the ottomans.
@@closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0A Rothschild family member wrote a letter to the Birtian colonists at the time. Since the Rothschild family is a banking family and is extremely influential with the funds they have, requested a sponsership from Britian in their support to colonize Palestine for the sole purpose of a Jewish state.
@@ODEelephantNope, you're wrong. In fact much earlier, the mufti of jerusalem literally met with h*tler to discuss exterminating all jews. Look at the founding dates of israeli cities, many were founded before the 1900s, look at the pictures you'll only see jews and druze people.
@@Nicolas-ir9xy Isreal did not exist in 1900's. What are you even on about so you are saying the belfour declaration never occured?
@@ODEelephant yeah ask yourself that question why it’s not shown in this video, because Jews was always living in those lands, and they will attack by Arabs even back, then I’m talking about 1910s 1920s before creating Jewish state.
And you’re right Israel did not exist in 1900s , so do Palestine.
My ancestors come from Ireland, thus using the Israeli model I'm allowed to take a random Irishmans house whenever i want.
Yes and I can kick a Scottish family out of their home. And the Italians can have England.
No one has claim to land. It gets conquered and if you want it back you have to take it back. The Jews owned it first going way way back, but people only care about that history with other areas like America should be the natives instead and so on
@@Captain_Brown_BeardNo they didn’t. it belonged to the canaanites. Jews didn’t even exist back then
Some of my ancestors were Huguenots who were driven out of France so according to Zionist logic I can go to France and demand a house 😅
My ancestry traces all the way back to the many Saxon tribes actually, so by their logic, I have the right to take some lands from England
I feel like this goes hand in hand with the idea of "oh, these natives conquered these other natives, so what we do to them is restorative justice" . It's an attempt to ignore the colonial system and deflect the argument
Especially when it comes to Israel who claims to be Jewish (which they're not, they're Zionists pretending to be jews), but then somehow cannot take criticism and call everyone antisemitic if they tried, it's getting quite ridiculous.
P.S: still don't know how's the state of Israel through the new world order (BRICS), just asking ofc.
Colonization is not a problem because all people are guilty but how you treat the native is the problem. The oppression and apartheid system in place makes it utterly unjustifiable
@@sunset2.00There would be no oppression and apartheid state if there was no colonization though. Israel has to go
Excellent analysis video. Thank for this.
This was excellent information. Thanks!
Since there are no bookmarks
What does indigenous mean:
13:24
Very informative. thank you. In particular I wasn't aware how deeply the early zionists (that had been instrumental in the formation of Israel) were influenced by & had internalized the rationale and dynamics of colonialism, and how eagerly they craved to be an outpost for western colonial projects. Far from being indigenous or emancipatory, this makes them second in command to the oppressive European colonial powers, Also very tragic to see the dwindling territory of the Palestinians over the last 60 years.
Ancient Israel , Jeruselum is fact so not sure what this bs is.
@@olecranonrebellion9976 you high?
That does not make a lot of sense. So what if there were some Jews there and so what if the Palestinians were a tribe?. Modern Israel is a settler colony with folks of European descent coming from all over the world (even New York and even converts from South Africa) who have been systematically ethnic-cleansing the Palestinians. Whatever role the British had to play , Israel is just the same or worse, and there is no justification for its apartheid and occupation. If the settlers need a ethno-religious state for themselves, they should find an uninhabited place, not repeat the crimes of their former European oppressors.@@constantineblyuz5786
BTW: Your American friends love you so much. Why don't the settlers carve out a peace of land from the mid-west, Dakota, Idaho, Vermont or some evangelically minded area in the US. I am sure they will be happy to oblige.
@@constantineblyuz5786 have you watch the entire video?
OH YES. IT WAS ALL A HUGE PROJECT COOKED UP BETWEEN FDR; WINSTON CHURCHILL; STALIN AND THE ZIONISTS + AS YOU KNOW, THE HIGH RANKING FASCIST NAZIS WHO HOPPED OF TO THE USA. ...... THAT WAS NEVER ENDED AND WAS PLANNED, AS ARE MOST WARS, METICULOUSLY,
SHAME WE HAVE SUCH DOWN-TRODDEN, FAIRLY UNEDUCATED AND SERVILE POPULATIONS. TOO LATE NOW. THE WORLD IS TEETERING ..... GOING, GOING, ....... GONE ????
9
I never really understood what indigenous meant and no one truly explained it to me as clearly as you have. It's crazy that so many people gloss over it.
Indigenous means who settled the land first what is so hard to understand about that? You have murdering, raping Dutch thieves in sub-Saharan Alkebulan who are trying to claim that they are indigenous. They are not nor will they ever be indigenous.
Great video however one thing I would like to add is that using the oppression(or perceived oppression) of your people as justification for your oppression of another group of people is a fairly common mindset to have, For instance a big part of why apartheid lasted for so long is because the Afrikaners saw themselves as a threatened people thanks in no small part to the oppression they faced at the hands of the British(things like the boer war atrocities and the banning of the Dutch language), a big part why the Spanish and Portuguese empires were as deeply theocratic as they were is because of the reactionary sediment developed amongst the regions Christian population during the hundreds of years of Islamic rule they were subjected to, hell even the Nazis themselves have used the idea(no matter how nonsensical) that white people are oppressed at the hands of some Jewish shadow government to justify their ideology so it makes sense that Zionists would use the holocaust as justification for the crimes against the Palestinians or more explicitly as justification for the idea that the only way for the Jewish people to secure the safety of themselves and their children is by ensuring the existence of a Jewish ethnostate
You did a great job laying out all the facts and citing your sources. Love it!
Excellent video essay, thank you
Whether your indigenous or not... Surely everyone can agree that starving children is wrong...
@@mitzitheman8214
Cutting off running water, where's the excuse for that?
Getting the VISIT TEL AVIV ads with rainbow colored lettering before and during this video was just *chef's kiss*.
Wonder if one day America will decide that England is their historic indigenous homeland and decide to retake it
A very great point!
nah even the english weren't originally from britain.
Such an informative video thank you
It's akin to my showing up and squatting at the apartment I was evicted from 40 years ago with a letter of recommendation from some rando and a book that I myself wrote that states that my God promised this apartment to me 100 years ago. Yes, it really IS that absurd
@randomname9291 that represents a small % of the situation my friend. And IF that were the case, Izzy wouldn't need the whole God-promise, ancestral ties argument. Besides, what's happening now and for well over a decade has nothing to do with either. Izzys been quite vocal and undeniably clear as to their intentions. Not that this wasn't the case even 80 years ago after all
@randomname9291 Anecdotal though it may be; I've been having these "debates" for well over 30 years. Every single solitary Jew that I have ever spoken to, online and IRL, has always lead off with God and Birthright, then ancestral ties. Always.
love it,,spot on...
Funny how so many "indigenous" Israelis resemble Eastern Europeans.
It's just so uncanny. 😇
mostly polish, austrian and germans.
vid aged like fine wine...
Been telling similar stuff to people years back before even this vid, but it seems more relevant that ever
When one group of people believes they are chosen by god..and there is a land of milk and honey promised to them…then all rational thought goes out the window
I've never heard any Israeli claim they're "god's chosen people". Many Israelis including myself don't believe in god in the first place, so you're yapping nonsense
@@SilverJyan that’s like your opinion man
@@SilverJyanEither way it doesn't matter most of them are Zionist and by their standards they should give their land to Iran because that was historically Canaanites land and the Canaanites are from Iran so they should give their land to Iran.
@@SilverJyan If many Israelis, like yourself, don't believe in god...why then are you lot trying to lay claim to Al Aqsa mosque and deprive the local indigenous muslims from frequenting it as they wish???
@@myblighters two gross lies in one sentence. Bravo. Any shred of proof we do that? Or that Muslims are indigenous to the land and not barbarous Imperialist from the Arabian desert who claimed a foriegn land as their own and another's holy grounds as their own?
Crazy that this came out 2 years ago. Thank you.
“This is our ancestors home”
> gets sun burn
Lmao there are plenty of syrians that look more europeans that the israelis.
Looool
@Nicolas-ir9xy Yeah, I'm sure a Syrian looks more like a european than an actual German.
LMAO
@@raam1666I have a Syrian friend and he literally looks white
Thank you for this video, great work! Watching from Brazil
If the UK government accept's Israel's right to recreate ancient Judea, then it must also accept that Britain should still be part of the Roman Empire and the UK should not exist. I rest my case.
That doesn't make sense at all.
@@nikolamilicevic1040 I sympathise with your point of view. I think the UK is like the old Austro-Hungarian Empire, with England effectively ruling the Welsh, Scottish and Irish nations because of its bigger population and history of conquest. Since Brexit, I joined the Scottish Nationalists even though I'm English myself.
@@chilesai1117 I was joking a bit, but just because Judea existed in that area 2000 years ago doesn't mean the Jews have a right to create a Jewish state where the Palestinians live.
@@chilesai1117 didn't Roman empire rule Britannia 2000 year ago.
If we are accepting Jewish claim because rule that land 2500 years ago then why Rome
@@chilesai1117 That's the point.
I love seeing so many americans in support of palestine in the comments. So many americans seem to lack any empathy and seem ready to get on their knees for israel but the ones here have their head and heart in the right place.
Plus i dont understand the high support from america for israel, do average americans really not know about the israeli attack on the uss liberty?
So my dad supports Israel but he’s blatantly honest as to why he does.
He sees Iran as a legitimate threat to America in the future and he thinks that Israel being there is a means to stop Iran in its plan to destroy America.
Pretty conspiracy theoryish but that’s just what he believes.
He doesn’t support what Israel is doing he just thinks that the survival of Israel as a state holds more importance than how they conduct themselves.
If he would actually take the time to look into it and have a convo with me I know he would quickly see that Israel can’t be trusted by the US that they truly are not our ally I know he would change his mind quickly but he’s not open to the prospect of changing his mind like many other Americans.
He’s older so you have to think about what he was raised up on.
He was raised up on the idea that Israel is an arm of the United States in the Middle East and the thing that keeps the United States safe, not from Muslims but from like I said Iran, and these radical forces (that the US government is single handedly responsible for creating) but in short it’s just alot of brainwashing to make Israel as important as the US in the minds of many Americans.
@@ChristianGeske-yn3mr
Israel's main problem is with the Palestinians not Iran. Media exaggerates Iran's role in the conflict when Iranians are bunch of fanatical Persians living far away from Palestine/Israel.
🇵🇸Free Free Palestine🇵🇸
@@mr.biscuits2160 ...to the head...
never
And in twenty years time , Isreal descendants will be telling Palenstine descendants to, "Get over it already"
Just as American colonial descendants tell Natives and Black descendants.
@@Midnight_Metro Because they know they benefit from it. We still never recieved those 40 acres and a mule nor do they acknowledge the "Dowes Roll" passed by US congress. It was a bill that forced darker colored aboriginals from claiming land and compensation as natives because they resembled "escaped slaves"... my man literally the only reason reservations exist is because white congressman said they could. The black natives congregated to spain. I put that on my life, i literally been learning this shit.
Im not saying all white people are bad... but the majority rules. In one year we spend more money than the entirety of Mexico combined(black people) if congress reinstated indigenous rights to "black" people. We could cripple the entirety of America in one year. Thats why they refuse to pay us. White people know this.. its the exact reason why they claim they are natives as well. We need real representatives. Go to school... we gone get our money, mark my words. We gone get our money.
Yep! White american neoliberals LOVE the "get over it already," "we're tired of hearing about it" "i never did anything bad" retorts. This is all through education and media brainwashing to protect the image of colonization.
It's funny how they are trying to say they are indigenous when Palestinians have DNA descended from the ancient canaanites who were the real indigenous people of the Levant.
@@oltimos8888 No
@@oltimos8888 You can never convince me to believe a white european or a black african to be native of the land just because they follow a religion. Like it or not Palestinians are native.
@@oltimos8888 You can repeat the same lie over and over again, it doesn't make it true. The Palestinian people today are native to the land no matter what they were called or what religion they followed back then.
@@oltimos8888 Jews (people who follow a religion) are not all from the same race no matter what lies the zionists try to spread.
@@oltimos8888 Thats just zionist propaganda.
Excellent video! Well done
Found your channel thanks to this comment, so cheers to that.
I need the algorithm to send this video to every one.
That is brilliant research and analysis. The best academic breakdown of settler colonialism in the Israeli context, perhaps that I have ever heard. Thank you from Australia also.
Thank you. I'm vegan and I remember a few years ago hearing all about how Tel Aviv is the new vegan mecca and all vegans need to go there because its the vegan capital of the world now, lol. So the propaganda definitely reached its target audience tho I didn't think much about it at the time
I don’t trust most tourism websites that rank cities. My example is with pink washing Cuba has the most progressive laws for gay family’s and some of the most celebrated queer culture but they never crack these lists of gay friendly cities (subjective as the experience for queer people differs drastically depending on who you are) but Tel Aviv (which is one of the most segregated and unequal cities of the settler state) is ranked really high due mainly to advertising.There is no special queer culture just queer presence which also exists in a highly touristy areas in China, Turkey, and Botswana (three countries who have a push and pull/polarizing view of queer rights). Good thing now is you start to see through it, that ability is useful not just for the Palestinian struggle but other struggles that are washed away by advertising.
There is a fairly large church I went to as a child and teenager in Livermore, CA. To their credit, they actually had a Palestinian Christian onstage to talk about the living conditions he was subjected to. A lot of the congregation did not take kindly to having their preconceived notions so directly challenged. It definitely opened my mind. Israel has access to the US’ technology and budget, and they have deployed it successfully.
what did he say to debunk that Tel Aviv is the vegan capital?? It literally is the city with the most vegan restaurants compared to its size.
@@TheKeendark if you call Israel, being the vegan capital, propaganda.. but it's the truth!... Then it's not propaganda! Propaganda is saying Israel is the best at something, when it isn't true.
You can imagine whatever murder you want to.. his statement is still wrong.
If anything you are doing the same thing you blame Israel of doing. You are saying that, Israel is doing something wrong (in your opinion).. so we should ignore all the good stuff and focus only on that.
@@Abilliph well, it’s not the vegan capital because there is no such thing. it’s just a way of saying “this is the place to be if you’re vegan”. clearly, it’s promotion. it’s trying to sell tel aviv and israel to vegans, a younger generation, progressives. people who are actually more likely to be against israel
great video. definitely needed in this current time
Little did we know, my friend. One year later this video is more relevant than ever
Zionists are complete parrots. They can't stop repeating the same arguments all the time.
@@ivanj.conway9919 I am not sure if you even watched the video or not, even if their ancestors lived in that land it isn't an excuse to push out hundreds of thousands of people, that's the same as taking someone's house and your excuse is that your grandfather lived in that house long ago, also you say that there were jews in palestine before Zionism and you are correct but they were a minority that coexisted with rest of the population, if that is your excuse that there was a jewish minority then by that logic anybody can invade anybody because there is a minority of all races and religions everywhere,
Also saying that they colonized palestine because they were discriminated against, by that logic africans could invade and kill and push out people because they themselves were oppressed and it isn't a combination of all of the above because two wrongs don't make a right.
@@raniaelsayed5683one info jews and Muslim and Christian live liké brothers in Palestine éven they babysite eachother children yes other Guy IS wrong
@@raniaelsayed5683 Well thats sad because this is extremely biased against Israel and the struggle of Jewish people for sovereignty. Zionism, no matter what justifications, exists because of thousands of years of oppression of Jews in every country they have lived. No matter what you say, the Jewish people overwhelmingly will die for their native homeland.
If you cannot acknowledge this, then you should prepare to see mass deaths in the news for the next century.
Any arguments now that stem from this discussion, I want them to just simply play this video lol
I was thinking the same thing...I don't see how droping a 30+ minute video link into an argument is going to help anything though, I was already considering it lol
@@ashproductionsi know this is a late comment, but i recommend writing down the most important points made in this video so you can easily have a rebuttal to the zionists you encounter
The level of research in this is outstanding. Well done.
So what you're saying is that there is a chance Israel is rightfully Albanian land
Israel is Serbia….
@@waynesmith7746 Serbia is Pashalik of Ioannina
All land is Guatemala
I'd say British, since they took it from the Turks.
Alright guys, stop fighting.
The entirety of Europe is Roman.
Best video on this issue so far, calling it what it is, funny how these colonialists used to be proud of their acts in the past, but now acting like we've forgotten who they are 😂
as an algerian man , this sum it up perfectly with no dispute , and i hope palestinians make it like we did in '62
the future has no place for a 'palestine'
Spoken like a true Algerian. Have you read your holy book, the Torah?
@@BR-KK
Pretty sure he's holy book isn't torah😂
@@arhamakhyar3088 I don’t believe the Quran either 😜
@@chungusultimateIt does 😘 Palestine will be freed
This is AMAZING and it aged INCREDIBLY well!!
Palestinian ancestors were Semitic Jews who converted into Islam in the 7th century.
Wdym before, Palestinian Christian still exist sadly majority are in diaspora (mainly in South America). I keep having to check comments to correct people on this (I’m not saying it to be mean more so shocked).
@@vannakinder352 no wonder why football is the game there 🔥
@@vannakinder352 the old testament literally calls arabs "wild as donkeys", good on those who converted to islam
@@mr.biscuits2160 based on factuality lol
"actually the white Israelis are native to this land since 150 trillion years ago!" based on the Israeli government
In another timeline we would be saying Free Madagascar
Exactly
I didn’t know Liberia’s history. That’s an interesting parallel.
The video points out a recurring tendency of Israel defenders (seen recently in France when some parliament members faced huge backlash for using the word "Apartheid") − describe how wonderful, democratic and egalitarian the State of Israel is, and talk about anything _except_ colonization. And yeah, if you ignore the colonization, Israel looks no different from your average, liberal European democracy. That’s precisely why so many people are willing to ignore it I think.
In truth, it is the antithesis of each of those words..a theocratic , murderous, colonial dictatorship!!
How narcissistic are they to delude themselves into thinking they're 'god's chosen people'?
Kicked out of 109 countries for “no reason at all”
Ironically most Zionists don't even believe in God.
It's called racism
this was eye opening, thank you very much for your research and hard work!
Upvoted after 2 minutes in video...i might even subscribe. Good video. Good sourcing. Solid reasoning and argumentation. Engaging examples.
I want to add a bit of correction on the last part, or more asking for a correction on my interpretation. Would the Puritans coming to North America from Britain to “escape persecution” count as an example of the scenario at 35:07? Either way they were both used to justify genocide but I want clarity there.
No because it was a later feature. They didn't come there to kill . And the Jews have a claim on that land going back thousands of years. And I doubt that anyone would have let them settle elsewhere
Your videos are always so brilliant. ❤
Fantastic work as always! You are one of the only monotone creators that makes content interesting and informative enough to attentively enjoy.
Based underhanded complement giver.
This is more relevant than ever, thanks for this eye opening video. I subscribed immediately!
Brilliant evisceration of one of the most absurd claims I've ever heard. Kudos to you good sir.
As a roman Catholic do i have land rights in Rome/Italy?
Seeing Israelis call themselves Indigenous is deeply insulting. There's a reason why we Native Americans are pro-Palestine.
Very educational, and well put together.
Aged like fine wine
Even more so after a year. Perfectly put
This is actually such a well made video thank you so much❤❤❤
The number of people who are jerkung off to the question of descent and bllod quanta is disturbing. Did yall not watch the video? Blood is only tangentially, and a distant second order factor, to indigineity. Indigeneity is a social relation based upon recent, and ongoing, setteler colonial action of an imperial power.
Thank you
They told me it started Oct 7. But this was uploaded a year prior! Liar!
started 76 years ago :)
When I first saw the Palestinine-Israel map timeline from 1945, I felt like something was off. Like if Isreal was just created 70 years ago on top of an islamic nation, wouldn't it make Isreal NOT an indigenous and naturally occuring state? I mean there was the "Kingdom of Israel" but it collapsed 1200 years earlier. I'm glad someone had a depth explanation on this.
Israel is a white settler colonialist project
@@constantineblyuz5786 pure nonsense. DNA shows that the Palestinians are descended from the Canaanites.
@@constantineblyuz5786 Wow. Thats a tough mental gymnastic you did there. There was no Islamic nation, yes but both the Ottoman and British Empire are not real or what? The British promised Palestine independence after WW1 but Antisemitism towards European Jews became so bad they came as migrants to Palestine (and were happily accepted). You probably know that, tho
2000 years ago
True I want to say that Palestinians are Christians Muslims Jews and atheists. It's just a country with it's people 🌺
We didn't all drink the Kool-Aid. Some of us support the local Palestinians and do our best to educate anybody who will listen.
Ow Yeah!
This is so greatly great ❤ thank you for the great research, we've been witnessing in eye and soul all that injustice of the world and mouth shutting, so we lean more towards what we experienced and see to prove our cause. This is so informative and logically consructed , I can't thank you enough