You wanna know something that is even more tragic that most don't know when it comes to this AU? Most don't realize that Futaba is Wakaba's mother in this AU
They call kids who lose their parent/parents orphans to show the pain they went through. But there is nothing to call a parent who loses a child, because nothing can describe the pain.
@@bla5t3rproductions41 Mourning. Dude, mourning. Full of grief and agony and sorrow; a pit full of spikes tipped with depressants and tranquilizers. A yearning of wanting to fall from a great height. Does that suffice?
Persona 4 was about facing yourself Persona 5 was about clearing distortion Hopefully Persona 6 will be about overcoming depression so we can have more scenes like this
I... yeah, I kinda agree with Sojiro. Yes, you want to help them... but at what cost would that come? The Meta-verse is unknown in a lot of ways to them, so they don't have any idea what would happen if they tried using on someone who actively WANTS it to be used on them. Now, in the original Persona 5 I'm betting there wasn't much conflict. They didn't really know Futaba that well at that point, so they don't exactly have too much to lose and possibly a lot to gain. But here... the script has been flipped, they had possibly a lot to lose and little to gain. Futaba could have lost herself in the Change Of Heart and could have never gone back to normal. Sojiro here had a lot to lose, he's been there for a long long time... five years with a person that goes through that kind of thing changes someone greatly. His fear is completely and utterly justified, it could go wrong if they don't have a guarantee that things will work out. All of that aside, this is some brilliant writing right here. I could tell Sojiro was serious about the situation and the words fit the context here, the voice acting is amazing (I saw Revtrosity in the credits there, one of my favorite voice actors on the internet honestly) and in general, the scene did have those Persona Vibes that I've come to love. Well done guys... well done.
It's especially poignant in this AU. Morgana isn't around. The Phantom Thieves don't have a resident to help them. To my knowledge anyway. The official webcomic only has 3 chapters and is in desperate need of updating.
What I love most, other than the voice acting, is that it shows a side of Sojiro that we barely see. Rage is a wonderful emotion in writing when used right, especially in normally relaxed or level-headed characters
@@Nitram4392 It's on twitter Old pages: twitter.com/i/events/982871512389640194 Newer pages: twitter.com/i/events/1250221212170694656 It also is on webtoon www.webtoons.com/en/challenge/adult-confidant-au/list?title_no=393408
the emotion expressed in this was portrayed very well, I felt the yelling, and sadness in both their voices, and you can feel the tension build up as if you were there watching Sojiro and Sadayo talking face to face. This was special, and really did give life to the comic so, thank you for another amazing comic dub! (Edited since I didn't get my thoughts out properly, this is much better lmao)
After seeing this comic, if we don’t eventually end up with a Royal-Story Arc where Wakaba comes back to life and becomes their Violet, I’ll be surprised/disappointed
But because Shido is CLEARLY the asshole and everyone knows he’s an asshole jock, I wonder how his story would parallel Akechi’s (at worst, if he’s still alive in the final stages after Sojiro’s arrest, Masayoshi may just end up becoming a prisoner and that this AU’s Goro could fill in the Sae role alongside Makoto seeing as how he’s a nice guy here and not as unstable as his canon self)
@@gusionpaxley9063 From what I remember, AU Goro is idealistic but soft hearted, rendering him as an ineffective politician similar to canon Yoshida. AU Shido saw Goro’s soft hearted ness as weakness so basically wanted to be the opposite since he’s still interest in politics.
I know that this is “piggeybacking” off of the premise of the base game. But the subtle change that they add of the PT being cautious of who’s heart they change because they don’t know if the change of hearts make their targets actually aware of their actions and change accordingly or makes them become mindlessly apologetic for what they done while not actually learning a lesson makes the writing for this comic a 10/10 Also I like sojiro more than joker because they make him a character with flaws but the obvious reason is joker is a silent protag written by a corporate writing staff and teen sojiro is written by a committed fan
@@Omnidapt oh? Then, considering the context of the video... is Sojiro the father? That’s kind of a weird change to the dynamic, if so, but it paid off regardless.
Wakaba and Sojiro were childhood friends. Futaba is Wakaba's mother. From what I understand Sojiro's parents helped drive Wakaba to some outing and something caused an accident. They all died; I can't remember if Sojiro was in the car too and survived or if he learned after the fact, but regardless Futaba fought to attain legal guardianship of Sojiro afterward.
Raw emotion from anyone would make people cower away but raw emotion from a friend who is usually calm, collected and keeps their cool hits in an entirely different way
This was a really good comic dub I almost shed a tear of how sad it was where them to argue. Great job on your work I hope you and your team continue to do great things
I will not lie this was probably my favorite one so far. The pure emotion, the sadness, and anger but the caring as well. HOT DAM did you guys do it well.
This was amazing on all ends. The voices, the emotion in the writing. The characters personalities showing through. The music. Actually fantastic. Makes me want this to be the game since nothing really like this come up in og persona 5. Or royal. There are deep thoughts and two ideals clashing but never something that hits this close and hurts someone so much to the point of refusal. (No sai and ockomera (sorry i don't remember how to spell it I'll fix it later) don't count since both mako and haru knew that they're love ones needed this. And the third semester is more about never having hard ships there out right facing something like this) this makes me wish we got a modern persona game where the main was this emotionally attached to someone
The voice acting is so good i’m actually getting goosebumps😭 Thankyou so much for make Scruffyturtles’ masterpiece come to life like this! you guys have really outdone yourselves for this scene👏🏻
These comics are amazing! I feel like they're on par with (or heck even better than) regular P5. I hope this becomes an actual comic or even miniseries. Awesome job to everyone involved!
AGH SH[]T I just realized that Wakaba replaced Futaba, who replaced Sojiro, who replaced Ren. That leaves Ren replacing Wakaba, WHO IS DEAD! REN IS DEAD! SH[]T!
@@myschnozhurts1522 oh, i don't know how i missed that detail at 1:03. Guess i was so shocked by my own assumption that i stopped paying attention. Oh well...
Is the implication that Kawakami dated Kamoshida and he was absuvie in this AU? Because that's interesting as fuck. Same with the implications with Wakaba.
Sorry I'm a dumb. But what is Sojiro's and Futaba's relationship in this AU? Is Sojiro's Futaba's adoptive son or is it more a Joker/Sojiro relationship from the original game? Again this AU is pretty good. But I'm just confused on their relationship here
@@paddythelegend1671 legally changed their surname if I remember the story correctly. So after wakaba death she changed surname to sojiro to feel close or something.
So I’m a little confused... what’s sojiros relationship with futaba in this? I know futaba is wakabas mother in this so is sojiro under probation as well just like Akira?
Ok so I’ve been watching random videos of this and what I’ve gathered so far is that instead of the mc’s we have in p5 we have the adult confidants and things as the phantom thieves (sojiro isstead of ren, wakaba instead of futaba) is this correct?
Why isn’t there a full on Fanfic of this AU I mean come one I want to see all the alter Phantom thiefs in a Fanfic to see their character development and more but nope there’s none of that.
They got sojiro's parental instincts in him
Indeed
You wanna know something that is even more tragic that most don't know when it comes to this AU? Most don't realize that Futaba is Wakaba's mother in this AU
And that Wakaba and Sojiro were in love with one another.
Well, implied anyways.
They call kids who lose their parent/parents orphans to show the pain they went through.
But there is nothing to call a parent who loses a child, because nothing can describe the pain.
@@bla5t3rproductions41
Mourning.
Dude, mourning.
Full of grief and agony and sorrow; a pit full of spikes tipped with depressants and tranquilizers.
A yearning of wanting to fall from a great height.
Does that suffice?
@@johnsonbaroncaveler6634 I believe so. Nice profile pic btw
wait what
Won’t lie, this is probably one of my best performances so far. Pleasure as always to work with Reincarnation Dubs!
Thank you so much for voice acting Sojiro! You did so well!
Good work my man. Chills.
That… you really express Sojiro’s rage at possibly hurting his step-mother. It was completely believable. You really can act.
@@WriterKing92
internal turmoil.
Nicely done
I've loved sojiro before...but hot damn. I never thought making the adults the phantom thieves would b this good
It’s so good that even The 4th Snake recommends this. (And he’s known for criticizing a lotta things)
flirty asshole in the outside, caring leader in the inside
Persona 4 was about facing yourself
Persona 5 was about clearing distortion
Hopefully Persona 6 will be about overcoming depression so we can have more scenes like this
Persona 3 basically did that
Persona 3 already covered that
@@DC_.0611 that was more overcoming the fear of death
@Moses Simmons that’s why I said basically
No It's More Like Overcoming Tragedy and the fear of death
I... yeah, I kinda agree with Sojiro. Yes, you want to help them... but at what cost would that come? The Meta-verse is unknown in a lot of ways to them, so they don't have any idea what would happen if they tried using on someone who actively WANTS it to be used on them.
Now, in the original Persona 5 I'm betting there wasn't much conflict. They didn't really know Futaba that well at that point, so they don't exactly have too much to lose and possibly a lot to gain.
But here... the script has been flipped, they had possibly a lot to lose and little to gain. Futaba could have lost herself in the Change Of Heart and could have never gone back to normal. Sojiro here had a lot to lose, he's been there for a long long time... five years with a person that goes through that kind of thing changes someone greatly.
His fear is completely and utterly justified, it could go wrong if they don't have a guarantee that things will work out.
All of that aside, this is some brilliant writing right here. I could tell Sojiro was serious about the situation and the words fit the context here, the voice acting is amazing (I saw Revtrosity in the credits there, one of my favorite voice actors on the internet honestly) and in general, the scene did have those Persona Vibes that I've come to love.
Well done guys... well done.
It's especially poignant in this AU.
Morgana isn't around. The Phantom Thieves don't have a resident to help them. To my knowledge anyway. The official webcomic only has 3 chapters and is in desperate need of updating.
What I love most, other than the voice acting, is that it shows a side of Sojiro that we barely see. Rage is a wonderful emotion in writing when used right, especially in normally relaxed or level-headed characters
Kawakami: We have to change Futaba’s heart.
Sojiro: *TRIGGERED*
I read the comic but this still hurts so bad to hear it voice acted, it's like a movie.
Could you tell me where I can read the comic, please?
@@Nitram4392 It's on twitter
Old pages: twitter.com/i/events/982871512389640194
Newer pages: twitter.com/i/events/1250221212170694656
It also is on webtoon
www.webtoons.com/en/challenge/adult-confidant-au/list?title_no=393408
Christ i hope sojiros va's vocal cords are ok
If it's who I think, he's fine. He's screamed much worse.XD
@@Cronomancer
heheheh
Flowey saying a lot of things.
Don’t worry. Shouting is my specialty. :)
@@Revtrosity Oh hey. Speak of the devil. XD
So how them vocal chords?
@@Revtrosity oh shit! Glad you're ok dude. I can barely raise my voice without getting a sore throat. Thats really impressive!!
Hoo boy that was deeper than i expected
the emotion expressed in this was portrayed very well, I felt the yelling, and sadness in both their voices, and you can feel the tension build up as if you were there watching Sojiro and Sadayo talking face to face. This was special, and really did give life to the comic so, thank you for another amazing comic dub!
(Edited since I didn't get my thoughts out properly, this is much better lmao)
After seeing this comic, if we don’t eventually end up with a Royal-Story Arc where Wakaba comes back to life and becomes their Violet, I’ll be surprised/disappointed
Dude... I am hoping the story-writer sees this because that has SO MUCH potential!
I think it was confirmed by the Author that the Violet of their group is Maruki
Actually, Maruki is their equivalent to Violet. I’m assuming that Ren will be this AU’s Maruki
But because Shido is CLEARLY the asshole and everyone knows he’s an asshole jock, I wonder how his story would parallel Akechi’s (at worst, if he’s still alive in the final stages after Sojiro’s arrest, Masayoshi may just end up becoming a prisoner and that this AU’s Goro could fill in the Sae role alongside Makoto seeing as how he’s a nice guy here and not as unstable as his canon self)
@@gusionpaxley9063
From what I remember, AU Goro is idealistic but soft hearted, rendering him as an ineffective politician similar to canon Yoshida. AU Shido saw Goro’s soft hearted ness as weakness so basically wanted to be the opposite since he’s still interest in politics.
The Voice acting is always on point in this channel. Gotta love it!
Why is this so good, like honestly that performance of Sojiro's was so entrancing, it was so natural, great job.
That got real, really quick.
I know that this is “piggeybacking” off of the premise of the base game. But the subtle change that they add of the PT being cautious of who’s heart they change because they don’t know if the change of hearts make their targets actually aware of their actions and change accordingly or makes them become mindlessly apologetic for what they done while not actually learning a lesson makes the writing for this comic a 10/10
Also I like sojiro more than joker because they make him a character with flaws but the obvious reason is joker is a silent protag written by a corporate writing staff and teen sojiro is written by a committed fan
I’m going to guess something along the lines that wakaba is The child of Futaba in this universe?
Yes, she is.
@@Omnidapt oh? Then, considering the context of the video... is Sojiro the father? That’s kind of a weird change to the dynamic, if so, but it paid off regardless.
@@funnycat9962 no, he had a crush in Wakaba
@@funnycat9962 No, because it's an age-swap AU, Sojiro was Wakaba's childhood friend.
Wakaba and Sojiro were childhood friends. Futaba is Wakaba's mother. From what I understand Sojiro's parents helped drive Wakaba to some outing and something caused an accident. They all died; I can't remember if Sojiro was in the car too and survived or if he learned after the fact, but regardless Futaba fought to attain legal guardianship of Sojiro afterward.
Raw emotion from anyone would make people cower away but raw emotion from a friend who is usually calm, collected and keeps their cool hits in an entirely different way
I love it when the mc shows how they really feel ti a character that's giving them crap
This was a really good comic dub I almost shed a tear of how sad it was where them to argue. Great job on your work I hope you and your team continue to do great things
I love how Revtrosity voices Sojiro
I will not lie this was probably my favorite one so far. The pure emotion, the sadness, and anger but the caring as well. HOT DAM did you guys do it well.
Give that man his freaking Oscar.
There is a quiet nirvana that lies between regret and redemption
Well, dang. This was amazing.
This hit me in ways that not even the original P5 managed to hit me... Amazing stuff and I can't wait to see this fleshed out...
Props to whoever did Sojiro’s voice, because that was some amazing voice acting.
Great dub! Awesome as always! ✌️
Performance so good it made me tear up
This is a beautiful masterpiece of emotion and raw talent I can only express how much satisfaction I got out of watching it.
This was amazing on all ends. The voices, the emotion in the writing. The characters personalities showing through. The music. Actually fantastic. Makes me want this to be the game since nothing really like this come up in og persona 5. Or royal. There are deep thoughts and two ideals clashing but never something that hits this close and hurts someone so much to the point of refusal. (No sai and ockomera (sorry i don't remember how to spell it I'll fix it later) don't count since both mako and haru knew that they're love ones needed this. And the third semester is more about never having hard ships there out right facing something like this) this makes me wish we got a modern persona game where the main was this emotionally attached to someone
Real talk I got some “I’m not Her” vibes. Well done
Holy shit this was sad but good
I DIDN'T EXPECT TO CRY TODAY THO????
Keeping up the phantom theives tradition of yelling about how they are the phantom theives in relatively public areas
Even in an AU Wakaba can't catch a break...
I love this so much...very emotional...I felt that...awesome job!
actually got chills, this is a fantastic performance!
MY HEART.
The voice acting is so good i’m actually getting goosebumps😭
Thankyou so much for make Scruffyturtles’ masterpiece come to life like this! you guys have really outdone yourselves for this scene👏🏻
Beautiful
This is brilliant
These comics are amazing! I feel like they're on par with (or heck even better than) regular P5. I hope this becomes an actual comic or even miniseries. Awesome job to everyone involved!
Hoo Boi... Scared the horse shit out of me
Groovy.
This made me cry these voice actors and the comic is so good
Holy shit this is much better than I would have expected. Great job with the voices they were on point!
Sogiro is basically serious Markiplier in this, change my mind
I'm going to be honest I've never seen sajiro mad before in my entire life
The only thing that could be better is seeing them in there phantom thief outfits. I imagine sojiro having something like og jokers.
You don't even need to read who's Sojiro va is. You can tell just by hearing him scream and that is fact
Definitely not a "HOO BOI!" moment.
This makes me wish for Persona 4 Verison of this
AGH SH[]T
I just realized that Wakaba replaced Futaba, who replaced Sojiro, who replaced Ren.
That leaves Ren replacing Wakaba, WHO IS DEAD!
REN IS DEAD!
SH[]T!
No, wakeba is dead, the child died instead of the mother.
The roles were reversed, but the outcome stayed the same
@@myschnozhurts1522 oh, i don't know how i missed that detail at 1:03. Guess i was so shocked by my own assumption that i stopped paying attention. Oh well...
D*mn, I don't I've ever heard Rev shout for that long.
WOW this is fantastic, i love it.
There aren’t any oder Words to describe it, Great Job
I wonder if Sae would go through this in the AU when they'll try to change Makoto's heart.
Oof, my eyes are stinging with tears that was intense!!
You almost made me cry got me on the first half not gonna lie
That escalated quickly.
props to the va
he did really great
Is the implication that Kawakami dated Kamoshida and he was absuvie in this AU? Because that's interesting as fuck. Same with the implications with Wakaba.
I saw this one on Twitter.
When I saw this here today...
OH.
SHIT.
0:39 Kawakami isn't a Phantom Thieve ¦v
This was sad 😢
If only he knew, or if the team said screw it and did it anyway
As if the normal phantom thieves, but damn this is awesome!
This has made my brain hurt
Meanwhile: The Phantom Thieves already changed her heart
That from 0 to 100 real fast
Sojiro needs to lay off the cigs
Whoa not expecting that
Fuck, the emotion...
Whoa I got chills 😨
the thumbnail really looked like a smash ball idk why i thought this was gonna be about ssbu 😳
100/10
I have to say it :')
Kawakami is best girl in the original and in the AU
DAMN!
There's triggered and then there is this.
I ducking cried
Adult Khalil
Nice Voice acting
My friend is one of the V.A’s
remember this, if this AU were the actual game you'd 100% be able to date Futaba!
till we meet again!
Ship them, like a Commodore
Such a shame that alot of this artist's content will be harder to find when Twitter inevitably bites the dust.
Will the pancake boi be back too?
SANS!?
Sorry I'm a dumb. But what is Sojiro's and Futaba's relationship in this AU? Is Sojiro's Futaba's adoptive son or is it more a Joker/Sojiro relationship from the original game? Again this AU is pretty good. But I'm just confused on their relationship here
In this, I think Futaba is meant to be Wakabas mom and Sojiro and Wakaba are childhood friends. But I could be wrong I’m pretty new to this AU
@@rickw9291 But her last name is still Sakura right? How does that work?
@@paddythelegend1671 legally changed their surname if I remember the story correctly. So after wakaba death she changed surname to sojiro to feel close or something.
Why does I hear sojiro ad markiplier?? And this is quite sad
So I’m a little confused... what’s sojiros relationship with futaba in this? I know futaba is wakabas mother in this so is sojiro under probation as well just like Akira?
Basically sojrao and futaba swapped roles kinda but not interly
Ngl but if they would it futaba wouldn't be a hard confidant to get
Wait, Kamoshida is aadult in this au too?
No. He's just the star player on the volleyball team.
Whoever plays Sojiro needs an Oscar
Much thankies
Wait there more
Ok so I’ve been watching random videos of this and what I’ve gathered so far is that instead of the mc’s we have in p5 we have the adult confidants and things as the phantom thieves (sojiro isstead of ren, wakaba instead of futaba) is this correct?
Close, though I think they implied Wakaba, while indeed would have been age swapped, still died with Futaba grown and alive
Revtrosity?
I don't mean any disrespect, but what happened to Andre?
美味しそう what happened
...
Why isn’t there a full on Fanfic of this AU I mean come one I want to see all the alter Phantom thiefs in a Fanfic to see their character development and more but nope there’s none of that.