Download PDFs, Mind maps and Prelims Booster Notes of all the modern history videos from Bookstawa app [Android link] - play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=co.loki.ylnop1 Bookstawa app [IOS link] - apps.apple.com/in/app/myinstitute/id1472483563 ORG Code - YLNOP
It was also belived that Gandhi could have stopped Bhagat singh's capital punishment if he insisted but we know bhagat's ideology didnt go in line with satyagraha. Anyhow Bhagat singh was very crucial initiator for Congress to declear Purna swaraj in 1930 instead of being moderate.
@@silentknight4783 कहा लेखा या कहा पढ़ा भाई तूने की गांधी ने कोशिश की थी शहीद भगत सिंह जी की फांसी रोकने की । इरविन ने खुद अपनी किताब में लिखा है गांधी ने कभी इस बारे में कुछ कहा ही नहीं गांधी ने केवल ये बोला कि जिनपे हिंसा का केस नहीं है उनको आजाद करो
Bhaii tum bahut accha kaam kr rahe ho...tumhari ye mhnat sbse alag aur unique bnati h tumhare channel ko...easy to understand history...logo ko unki bhasa m history samjha rahe ho...keep it up...u will get million subscriber very soon....
Sir , please continue to make more videos. You are elaborating very easily, those complicated matters. Basically how the constitutional developments were being done through various acts. .....If you could make separate videos between the relationship of this constitutional developments with main articles in constitution.....it will help a lot.
The issue of whether Mahatma Gandhi specifically requested the commutation of Bhagat Singh, Rajguru, and Sukhdev's death sentences during the negotiations with Lord Irwin is indeed a matter of historical debate. Lord Irwin, in his communications and reports, mentioned that Gandhi did not explicitly demand the commutation of their sentences during their talks. This has led to speculation and criticism regarding Gandhi's role and actions during that period. Gandhi himself, in his writings and speeches, indicated that he was concerned about the fate of Bhagat Singh and his comrades and did make efforts to appeal to the British authorities, though he may not have made it a central point of his negotiations with Irwin. Gandhi was aware of the popularity and influence of Bhagat Singh, particularly among the youth, and understood the impact their execution would have on the Indian populace. The exact details of the discussions between Gandhi and Irwin are not fully documented, and much of what is known comes from personal letters, public statements, and memoirs. Consequently, differing interpretations and reports exist regarding the extent to which Gandhi pressed the issue during the pact negotiations.
Mujhe history padhna bilkul bhi psnd nhi hai but kal mera exam hai iss liye padhna pad raha hai aur sab kuch aache se samjh aa gya hai sir aap bahut aacha samjhte ho such me sir you are great teacher ❤
Sir please continue this vdo making session on indian history. These videos are so helpful for students who believe in vocal study .. The way you elaborate the topic is just wow!
saw all of your videos on polity and modern history...your style of teaching is awesome love all o your videos....eagerly waiting for your upcoming videos
it was told in a documentry by britishers that gandhi never tried to save bhagat singh & raj guru , even britishers were ready to pardon them but gandhhiiii never struggled to ask even once ...
Gandhiji was not in a position to ask for their release. Meaning , britishers were above Gandhiji by law. And gandhiji was in a state that either he could have "asked " to save the three heroes , and risk the lives of the thousands of prisoners in the prison at the time of civil disobedience. So he couldn't ask for their release too, as he already knew he was not in that position. And talking about the british documentary, those firangis have always played by Divide and Rule funda...right??!
Yhi time tha jb bhagat Singh ko chhorne ke liye irvin ke samne condition lga skte the Gandhi ji Lekin unfortunately irvin ne chota chota churan de krr kam bna liya
your videos regarding history and your explanation of each and every topic + your way of teaching is remarkable, I would really inform each and every member of my surrounding to subscribe your channel and like your videos.................................THANK YOU you really developed my interest in history...............................................
Actually Gandhi ji proposed a term that britisher released all the political prisoners and Irwin agreed on that but when people talked about Bhagat Singh's release, irwin said that he is not a political prisoners but a criminal prisoners so he will not be released.
Gandhi Ji ne Aise Casual Request Nehi kiya tha Bhagat Singh,Sukhdev And Rajguru ke liye Irwin se... Unho ne Kahi Dafa Bich Bich Me Hand letter and amane samne kahi bar request kiya tha Desperately...
Bhai apki saare video bahut achi hai but gandhi kabhi nhi chahata tha ki bhagat sinfh rajguru aur sukhdev kabhi bhi jail se nikle pai Kyuki nehru gandhi aur baki congress party meh bohut se wakil thy but vo chahite nhi thy kyuki congress aur gandhi k popularity kam ho jati fir
Simply I catch point here if thousands people were following Gandhi ji Gandhi ji can easily can stop death sentence of bhagat singh by disagreement with Irwin.
It is not so easy to believe that Gandhi could not stop the british from hanging Bhagat Singh and others. He was probably the most powerful Indian at the time. The fact is somehow indigestible. A man who could convince the british to give up salt tax that funded 45% of British revenue, was not successful in carrying this out? This area of study is left in grey and it's high time that we should be told the truth.
Gandhi ji ne to koshish ki thi bhagat singh ke faasi bachane ki lekin Irwin hi nahi maana ...fir bhi log gandhi ko kyu koste hai ki vo rok sakta tha lekin roka nahi??
Download PDFs, Mind maps and Prelims Booster Notes of all the modern history videos from
Bookstawa app [Android link] - play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=co.loki.ylnop1
Bookstawa app [IOS link] - apps.apple.com/in/app/myinstitute/id1472483563 ORG Code - YLNOP
plz make video on karanchi session
Sir please make a video on Gandhi yug
kya membership join karne k liye payment ka card ke alawa aur koi option h kya ?? like paytm aur direct account no please👍🏻
6pppp
Mujhe Simon commission ki report bhut funny lagi😂😂...superb sir...for the best explanation
It was also belived that Gandhi could have stopped Bhagat singh's capital punishment if he insisted but we know bhagat's ideology didnt go in line with satyagraha.
Anyhow Bhagat singh was very crucial initiator for Congress to declear Purna swaraj in 1930 instead of being moderate.
@@silentknight4783 कहा लेखा या कहा पढ़ा भाई तूने की गांधी ने कोशिश की थी शहीद भगत सिंह जी की फांसी रोकने की । इरविन ने खुद अपनी किताब में लिखा है गांधी ने कभी इस बारे में कुछ कहा ही नहीं गांधी ने केवल ये बोला कि जिनपे हिंसा का केस नहीं है उनको आजाद करो
@@silentknight4783 maine kb bola autobiography
@@silentknight4783 rukk ja
@@silentknight4783 ab dek aur muhh band rakna
@@silentknight4783 aurr sunn jo insann ye bolre hai ek barr Google kr lena unke bare mai prof. Kapil kapoor
3:32 Lord Irwin MC tha...... RIP Bhagat Singh ❤
Bhaii tum bahut accha kaam kr rahe ho...tumhari ye mhnat sbse alag aur unique bnati h tumhare channel ko...easy to understand history...logo ko unki bhasa m history samjha rahe ho...keep it up...u will get million subscriber very soon....
Thanks Sourav
Sir , please continue to make more videos. You are elaborating very easily, those complicated matters. Basically how the constitutional developments were being done through various acts. .....If you could make separate videos between the relationship of this constitutional developments with main articles in constitution.....it will help a lot.
The issue of whether Mahatma Gandhi specifically requested the commutation of Bhagat Singh, Rajguru, and Sukhdev's death sentences during the negotiations with Lord Irwin is indeed a matter of historical debate.
Lord Irwin, in his communications and reports, mentioned that Gandhi did not explicitly demand the commutation of their sentences during their talks. This has led to speculation and criticism regarding Gandhi's role and actions during that period.
Gandhi himself, in his writings and speeches, indicated that he was concerned about the fate of Bhagat Singh and his comrades and did make efforts to appeal to the British authorities, though he may not have made it a central point of his negotiations with Irwin. Gandhi was aware of the popularity and influence of Bhagat Singh, particularly among the youth, and understood the impact their execution would have on the Indian populace.
The exact details of the discussions between Gandhi and Irwin are not fully documented, and much of what is known comes from personal letters, public statements, and memoirs. Consequently, differing interpretations and reports exist regarding the extent to which Gandhi pressed the issue during the pact negotiations.
my interest in history increased thanks to ur interesting videos
Dislikers r definitely the 'rishtedars'!😂
And u r
@OOSM LIFE Tu godse ki najayaj aulad 🤣
@@Aamin__Shaikh_hanfi bhut hard!😂
@OOSM LIFE ofcourse Sir, vo to national father h, infact aap lucky h agar aap bhi unki aulad h! Haa aapka gussa hona jayaz h, if u r not his child...😐
@@shrutidadhich9813 😉
Mujhe history padhna bilkul bhi psnd nhi hai but kal mera exam hai iss liye padhna pad raha hai aur sab kuch aache se samjh aa gya hai sir aap bahut aacha samjhte ho such me sir you are great teacher ❤
Sheeps shit was put on 1st round Table depicting simons report🤣😂😂😂 dint expect that.
Sir please continue this vdo making session on indian history. These videos are so helpful for students who believe in vocal study .. The way you elaborate the topic is just wow!
Yes, sure
Yes sir plz continue videos on polity 🙏🏻🙏🏻
@@Bookstawa did u make videos on Pakistan history
I hold masters in Modern History still unknown to facts provided by bookstawa 👍🧿
Thank you so much sir it's very helpful video
Most welcome
Essay to understand very Good work and helpful...🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍😄😄😄😄
Thanks
Do continue... Bro... Very benificial
thanks
saw all of your videos on polity and modern history...your style of teaching is awesome love all o your videos....eagerly waiting for your upcoming videos
I wait for the last point,. and u mentioned it. The execution of Bhagat Singh, Sukdev, Rajguru
So simple to understand, bundle of thanks
Hats off to you for giving factual information about our history unlike some people.
it was told in a documentry by britishers that gandhi never tried to save bhagat singh & raj guru , even britishers were ready to pardon them but gandhhiiii never struggled to ask even once ...
Gandhiji was not in a position to ask for their release. Meaning , britishers were above Gandhiji by law. And gandhiji was in a state that either he could have "asked " to save the three heroes , and risk the lives of the thousands of prisoners in the prison at the time of civil disobedience.
So he couldn't ask for their release too, as he already knew he was not in that position.
And talking about the british documentary, those firangis have always played by Divide and Rule funda...right??!
Bro kl preboard hai nearly aapki saari videos dekh chukaa hu
Thanks a lot for a great information..
Best of luck for your exam ... share these videos with your friends as well
@@Bookstawa sure bro and thanks again
👍
@@ffnatik9708 bro pehele se he padai chalu kar diya kar....
This channel deserve more subscribe 👍❤️❤️
bhai mere 12k subscribers...well done...you're going to be unstoppable Now enjoy your earns😘😘😘😘
Thanks Man
What 12k or 40
@@tentenben1085 mere bhai wo 1 month phle ka comment h
Thanks sir
Nice laughing of that sheep so interesting and nice teaching
Sir this is the best explaination
This is very helpful. Video
Yhi time tha jb bhagat Singh ko chhorne ke liye irvin ke samne condition lga skte the Gandhi ji
Lekin unfortunately irvin ne chota chota churan de krr kam bna liya
Thank you
your videos regarding history and your explanation of each and every topic + your way of teaching is remarkable, I would really inform each and every member of my surrounding to subscribe your channel and like your videos.................................THANK YOU
you really developed my interest in history...............................................
Glad to know that Tanyashvi. You are most welcome
Best explanation sir...plz keep it up👍 and koi bg music ni h ye bot acchi baat h usse disturbance hota h😇
In a gentle way you can shake the world
Why did he request for Bhagat Singh? He could have make it a mandatory point to release bhagat Singh for ending civil disobedience movement
Actually Gandhi ji proposed a term that britisher released all the political prisoners and Irwin agreed on that but when people talked about Bhagat Singh's release, irwin said that he is not a political prisoners but a criminal prisoners so he will not be released.
😊 thank you Sir 🙏
Really it's amazing 😍....sir 👏👏👏👏...
3:31 At this moment gandhi should have rejected the hole proposal!!
Sir these videos are really helpful especially for the batch of 2020-21 because those online classes were sooooo confusing
Nice sir ,webSite kab banayi apne
Last week
Gandhi Ji ne Aise Casual Request Nehi kiya tha Bhagat Singh,Sukhdev And Rajguru ke liye Irwin se... Unho ne Kahi Dafa Bich Bich Me Hand letter and amane samne kahi bar request kiya tha Desperately...
Bhai apki saare video bahut achi hai but gandhi kabhi nhi chahata tha ki bhagat sinfh rajguru aur sukhdev kabhi bhi jail se nikle pai
Kyuki nehru gandhi aur baki congress party meh bohut se wakil thy but vo chahite nhi thy kyuki congress aur gandhi k popularity kam ho jati fir
Simple and direct...very helpful ....The only distraction is the background bollywood music and dialogue...✌️🙏👍
I agree
Sir, you denote complicated matter in a simply way thank dear...
Very nice and helpful videos
thank you sir ,excellent class
how can some one dislike these videos, unacademy vaale ho kya bhai ?
😂😂😂😂
@@kattarhindu5334 haha
hahah
Your videos are amazing💕👀❤
Now I'm history lover only for this channel ❤️❤️
This is very good explanation now this ch is my fav chapter
Nice method of teaching
Sir kya Gandhi ji ne bhagat Singh ,sukhdev ,rajguru ki fasi rukwane ki baat sach me ki thi ??Gandhi irwin pact me??
Didi nhi ki thi ye video wala jhooth bol raha hai
Gandhi ne tu udham singh ji ku mad man keh diya tha jab udham singh ne 31 years baad jallianwala bagh ka badla liya tha 😤
Ki thi baat ... vo maane nhi the .. aue Bhagat singh proved accused the ...
Andbhakt ko dhyan ni dena
Very nice 👌 👌 👌 👌
Sir pls make a video on Gandhi yug
Simply I catch point here if thousands people were following Gandhi ji
Gandhi ji can easily can stop death sentence of bhagat singh by disagreement with Irwin.
Sir civies ka bhi banaye na video PLZZ 🙏 my paper is coming soon in 20 Feb
Mahatma Gandhi did talk about saving Bhagat singh and friends with Irwin
Love you bhaiya
full support from us
Great 👍sir
It is not so easy to believe that Gandhi could not stop the british from hanging Bhagat Singh and others. He was probably the most powerful Indian at the time. The fact is somehow indigestible. A man who could convince the british to give up salt tax that funded 45% of British revenue, was not successful in carrying this out? This area of study is left in grey and it's high time that we should be told the truth.
Gandhi ji ne to koshish ki thi bhagat singh ke faasi bachane ki lekin Irwin hi nahi maana ...fir bhi log gandhi ko kyu koste hai ki vo rok sakta tha lekin roka nahi??
Please make a video in alipore compiracy case 1908
Sir u r literally the second copy of khan sirr !!
Thank you so much sir .., Aaj exam hae 🤕 Very nice explanations
Most important video
Thank you so much.
Informative
Awesome sir best video on this chapter
Thanks Paras
Sir.mera kl history ka paper h
Thank you mujhe pura smjh aa gya
Thanks once again
Make videos on dynasties
Thank you so much sir 🥰❣️🙏
Hi kya aap mere friend banogi
Aakansha chaudhary
Does the taxes on salt are reduced or not after the agreement of Gandhi &Irwin pact
it was abolished..
Thank you.
So nice of you and your videos literally increasing the knowledge
Awesomesauce🌟
0:28 report file 😆😆
😀
Nice Simmon report🤣🤣
i liked simon commission report in this viedo 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
All serious teachings couldn't make me understand any better than this short bakwaas video😁 Grateful.
Sir thanks alot for your hardwork😀😍😚😙
You’re welcome
Good job Bhai or videos banao
3:35 Gandhi Baghat Singh ke fasi rukwane ki bath kiiii
Thanks bhai
Thank you sir jiiiiii 🙏💓
Sir what was agreement of Gandhi Irwin pact
Best ... seems like am watching a web series ❤😅
best for upsc revison
Best series on Morden history i ever seen👏👏👏
Sir plzz it's a request please make a video on World history
Thnku sir😎👍❤️
Excellent
Upsc pre (2020) question no. 77
Video is perfect but here Gandhi didn't asked Erwan to relese bjagath Singh & two other persons ..... It is a black mark for gandhi...
Nice
Thanks
Nice explaination sir
very good and funny way of teaching
Tomorrow is my pre boards sst exam of class 10 and am here watching this vdo and leaning 🙂
Thank u very usefullo
Superb
The great explanation ever seen
Very good
Thanks Anup
Did England regretted for jallianwallah Bagh mascare till now ???