Hailey goes from delicate and innocent to full vamp in half of a phrase.... Then the innocence is back - for a moment. I guarantee that, once you hear this performance you'll never forget it.
I heard this reaction a little over a year ago. I was 'making the rounds' after stumbling upon this jewel. I'm going back around to some of my "go-to" reactors (like you) as well as finding "new" reactions that I haven't heard before. I never tire of this song. I don't know that I would call PMJ or Haley my "very favorites," but THIS performance?? This is one of my very favorite performances by any artist from any genre from any era. Yes. High praise. Phenomenal! And YOU... great reaction!!
They hadn't even planned to record this. They had recorded some other things on a day off while on tour. This arrangement had been made for another singer initially but she really liked it so Scott asked if they should try it. This was the first and only take they recorded 🤯
Yeah right. Let's request a reaction to a music video that features an oversized big oaf of a clown and where there is nothing whatsoever remarkable about either of their vocals. Not to mention that about half the population has a fear for clowns and especially when they are as big and ugly as Puddles Pity Party. Some of you people must have been dropped on your head at some point in your life .
I've listened to Haley sing this at least 25 times and I love all her music not just PMJ she is a vocal master , so when I saw you were reacting to this I thought, OH this really going to be fun to watch and you didn't disappoint , thumbs up to you 👍 again
The PMJ version of "Dream On" by Morgan James is also outstanding. And, if you want a hilarious one, Aubrey Logan and PMJ did a cover of "Ice, Ice, Baby" that is surprisingly good!
Why do you Morgan James fans always hijack and commandeer Haley Reinhart music videos to beg reactors to please react to Morgan James? Let Morgan James generate her own music reactions.
@@theblackdog2399 seems to me that all reactors are reacting to suggestions ..... God gave it to you - use it ...... Have a Blessed New Year ....... just sayin'
That's one of the things I love about PMJ! They can take even the most annoying of songs,rework it, and create an absolutely fun and incredible version
Thanks for the concise reaction. This rendition is on my daily Spotify playlist. Haley surprised us recently with a cover of Don't Speak by No Doubt. A must react.
Yea, what is it about some artists giving some of their greatest performances when they are 'a bit off, or under the weather?' Within Temptation's Sharon Den Adel and their Rotterdam concert was the greatest live performance in my life to date! Sharon's"Somewhere" was great of itself, but with Anneke...out of this world!
@@JenniferGlatzhofer Yep that is documented fact. As you can see, this is one straight take. It is the first and only take. As with all PMJ videos there are no overdubs or other post production funny business. Post consists of mixing and mastering, nothing more, and most emphatically NO pitch correction (aka autotune) is used. Source: several recorded interviews of, and one book by, Scott Bradlee (the arranger/producer/pianist).
Rumors abound of Haley not feeling well or being sick. The fact is that Haley had a busy tour schedule with PMJ, and on their day off they decided to record 3 videos. Those videos were All About That Bass, Style and Creep. Guess what, Haley sang in all 3 of them. Here's the official video recounting the events as per Scott Bradlee. th-cam.com/video/MskKSH1Kf4U/w-d-xo.html
I think Haley is amazing and I don't know why she isn't more widely celebrated. The only possible issue one could have of this performance is that it was more of an exhibition of jazzy vocal technique than an accurate interpretation of the meaning of the song. She packed in so much, each time through the chorus was distinctly different and everything she did was flawless. Her vocals when not with PMJ are not so over the top and I probably prefer them, but there is no denying the brilliance of this performance.
Haley is not more celebrated because for years already, she has been refusing to sign a record deal with a big major record label. Hence, no record deal, no mass exposure, i.e., she isn't permitted to perform on network TV and her music isn't permitted to be played on the radio airways. The result is she always remains very obscure and in which also means her career also remains very mediocre at the same time, relative to her world-class level of talent.
@@theblackdog2399 I suppose she has her reasons, but between her and the teenager Angelina Jordan they occupy a style of music which I guess you could call jazzy pop that I really like where there is no one else to compete at their level. It takes a lot of skill and feel for music that very few can aspire to.
@@robertvirnig638 Haley's reason, as she has expressed is fear. In addition, Haley doesn't occupy any genre of music. As Haley sings any and all genres of music excellently, and no, Angelina Jordan is not close to being in the same league with Haley Reinhart as a vocalist, a songwriter, a performer, or with respect to their looks. Try again. As Haley Reinhart is a world class talent and Angelina is definitely not.
@@theblackdog2399 I don't know why you felt the need to bash on someone just because I mentioned them, and I wholesale disagree with you about Angelina being a world-class talent. I agree that there probably isn't another singer as sexy as Haley as sensuality permeates everything she does from her looks, singing style, movements, etc. Haley's songwriting is very good and some of her songs would be on the charts if she didn't have this thing about producers. Also, her technical ability is absolutely unrivaled. But you are comparing a 30 something-year-old woman's abilities and accomplishments to those of a teenage girl. What Angelina can do is emotionally connect to a song and provide just the right embellishments to convey the meaning of a song rather than just try to bedazzle the audience with vocal gymnastics. In this song "Creep" Haley is just showing off, little of what she is doing has anything at all with the meaning of the song. Haley can do things that Angelina hasn't yet attempted at 15 but everything AJ does is excellent and she has time to develop further. As far as songwriting, Angelina's limited youthful attempts thus far are good and I'll withhold any real critique for when her first album comes out probably sometime in the upcoming year. In the end, each artist is unique and you do not have to cut down one to acknowledge the abilities of another.
@@theblackdog2399 Your character is demonstrated for all to see by your own words and attitude so I won't respond in kind. I doubt if either of these artists would want to be associated with your negativity.
Great Post, Jennifer. And it is hard to forget or not know if you have reacted to this video. Once you see it, it is ALWAYS in your head. Haley Reinhart is JESSICA RABBIT reincarnated. How her and Angelina Jordan did not win American Idol and Got Talent Champions tourney, I'll never know. This is an AMAZING video. Thank you for sharing with us. Have a Happy New Year.
What a great reaction! You really need to check out....they did a no doubt cover of "Don't speak" they had Haley back after 6 years......... and it is phenomenal.
I'm so glad that you finally got to this song, Haley is absolutely fabulous in the delivery of this song. There are many different covers of this song, done by many great artists, but this version is my favorite. Haley, with PMJ, makes this song hers. Just fabulous.
@@LonesomeTwin The audio flat out sucks dude and it's not my fault. As I had nothing to do with it. You suggest reactors to react to shitty music videos or lame performances and you are only hurting the artists. I mean, it's common sense. You know what that is?
Thank you for reacting to this absolutely fabulous rendition of Creep by Haley Reinhart ! She is a such a great singer with so much vocal abilities ! Loved the video with Postmodern Jukebox ! They are such intensely talented musicians ! Haley paints such a rich vocal canvas with a variety of textures and colours throughout the song ! It was truly magnificent ! Thank you as always Jenn for your informative analysis and comments ! You're the best and wishing you a happy happy 2022 ! 🎊🎊🤗👍🇨🇦❤️❤️
nice reaction and breakdown jennifer (and great accent)... this maybe one of the best covers ever done. haley reinhart especially with postmodern jukebox is incredible. all the other haley/pmj ones are great also: "all about the bass", "habits", "black hole sun", "mad world", "seven nations army", "oops i did it again", "lovefool" and the very recent "don't speak" . i think what is so phenomenal about haley is not just her amazing silk to sandpaper voice but also her character and soul that she puts into the performances. even when she uses very little acrobatics, her pure raw soft voice is amazing like in the intro of "creep". you see this even more in her solo platinum cover of "can't help falling in love" for the extra gum commercial which is truly stunning and frequently described as what love sounds like here: th-cam.com/video/_uNpEbt7w_o/w-d-xo.html
It was so interesting to hear your analysis of this world-class performance. Haley is amazing! The emotional journey here reminds me of Shoshana Bean singing Make It Rain at The Theatre At Ace Hotel. As a music theater nerd, you may have already heard it, but if not, it would make a great reaction video. Shoshana pours out every drop of her soul onto the stage in a catharsis of pain and hope that must be experienced to be believed.
I recommend a singer called Diana Navarro. With the song "El perdón" she is very versatile and sings different styles of music with incredible melismas. And with a very personal voice.
I never tire of watching this performance. Absolutely love Haley's voice. Such an awesome reaction too, Jen, as usual. I agree with Jim, you ought to give this song a try yourself. You possess an equally awesome voice and I think you'd give us a great rendition as well! I do hope you enjoyed a wonderful Christmas, wish you a fantastic new year and am curious and looking forward to whatever new surprises you have in store for this channel going forward. Take care and once again Happy New Year! 🥳
I noticed I kept coming back to your videos so.. I did the only right thing to do, I just subbed to your channel. Thanks for your reactions and you are fun to watch.
I remember seeing Haley Reinhart in American Idol along with their basses Casey Abrams and I remember she always had that growl and raspy in her singing voice. She has grown so much since that show. She's such an incredible singer! There are some runs that she did in this video are like "Woah I've never heard anyone do that before." Happy New Year! I'm glad to be part of your subscribers. All thanks to Kellie (Kelxsings) for bringing me here from your collab song You Love Who You Love with her. It's been 9 months since I've become one of your subscribers. Great channel! I know I'm not a singer just a guitar player, but I love how you analyze singers by pausing and going over what they did there. You sure know what you're talking about.😁 I can't wait for next year. I can't wait to see what singers you're going to go over next. Have a great New Year, Jennifer!
Thank you Kevin! I’ve loved reading your comments 😊 and agree with the runs we heard in this video. Out of this WORLD! Looking forward to what’s in store for the new year 😊
is that a 1970's over stuffed, tweed like material couch!!?? LOL! Love it! I think I had the same style of couch growing in up in 80's n 90's central California!!
B-E-A-utiful and great reaction Jennifer, as always enjoy listening and watching. Arm movement we call jazz hands. :) Please incorporate her version of "Don't Speak' originally by No Doubt. Haley does a fanatastic job. Happy New Year!!!
Her vocal toolkit is astounding with what all she can do. love the geek out!! I really enjoy you technical break down. I really enjoy Haley's physical presentation(yes she is pretty) but the physical movements she uses to create mood or emphasis. Really got a kick out of your facial expressions as well. Totally Enjoyable reaction!
That was a cool and amusing and, more to the point, an erudite reaction to and analysis of what has become a phenomenon.You clearly know what you're talking about, and you now have my attention ... And my subscription. Good work!
This performance is a total classic for the hall of fame, for the ages,:for the history books... Just put it right there alongside of "I put a spell on you", performance by Angelina Jordan... But this one was live, full take recorded.... Sure there's some post production balancing and such but, This is it !!!
This is the fourth (fifth?) of your reaction videos I've watched, in short order. Subscribed on the second (though I was pretty sure I would after the first), and by now you're knocking on the door of the top tier of vocal-coach reactors (for me). Keep up the good work, and I'll keep watching.
I have been waiting for you to do a video about this performance. I was amused watching you squirm around jumping out of your skin with things to say not wanting to keep pausing every 10 seconds. You are very entertaining in your videos and they always leave me feeling happy inside. I love this performance, the 40's, jazzy, smoky nightclub feel of it is vastly different from the original, and that helps this cover stand on its own as a cover should. Haley did a superb job with this song. I remember the first time I saw her do this I was amazed at how versatile she can be. This song was also the very first time I ever heard of her, or Post Modern Jukebox, or her singing. What a great way to be introduced to a performer. Have a Happy and safe New Year celebration, all the best wishes to you and yours for the new year and beyond. Thank you for sharing your knowledge in such an informative and entertaining way, and for your efforts making these great videos!
Hi Jennifer, thanks for your reaction. Haley is so bad ass that she was not feeling well but she went ahead and recorded this and did it in one take. Please react to Haley and BMJ Cover of no doubt. Post modern jukebox post modern jukebox no doubt don’t speak. Haley is phenomenal she is Jessica rabbit a run for her money. Please react to this song, You’re absolutely gorgeous, Hi from Texas.
I always enjoy your informative and entertaining reactions. I'm Canadian and I'm in love with your accent. I could listen to you just read a phone book (if you remember what those are). Happy New Year. Cheers.
I don't know what it is, but, I adore you. Even before singing. I do love to hear you talk about the particulars of singing. What a beauty you are though. Super eyes. Haley doesn't look like a creep.
Hi Jennifer, now this is a nice surprise for the new year, can't believe you didn't react on this one before... tastes may be different, but for me Haley is the greatest voice they have over in the US! (I don't count Angelina even if she's currently living in LA...). Didn't watch your reaction yet and may leave another comment after, just wanted to say how much I'm looking forward to this right now as I generally appreciate your reactions and I deeply love Haley, so this will be great and I'm happy to discover it on the last day of the year... thanks for reacting, more Haley anytime for me please! - Happy new year Jennifer, happy new year everyone! ❤️ Go...!
... you really made my day, Jennifer! Can't get any better than finding someone who really can appreciate, and express and explain what's going on, even already knows and loves Haley, but, very strange indeed, does not know this performance... this is like winning the jackpot for me, and on the last game of the year... 😬 - For me this one was actually my first encounter with Haley about one year ago, and you may try to imagine what an impression that made on someone not knowing all of her AGT renditions yet, not her originals, not the magic things she did in Semmering, Austria recording direct to vinyl with the great Simon Peres Orchestra, nothing... - I was completely blown away 🌀... so, this being your first time featuring PMJ on your channel, but having listened some privately and knowing Haley, do you know her other breathtaking collaborations with Scott Bradlee and his fabulous band, like Seven Nation Army, Black Hole Sun, Oops I Did It Again, Habits, All About That Bass and more...? If not you need to react on all of these, please! Thanks again for reacting! - My goals for 22? More Haley into my life! - That's not enough? - It is! Simple vision board, as Oscar Wilde is said to have put it: "I'm a man of simple tastes. I'm easily satisfied with the very best...". Watching you reacting on Haley really fulfills all my needs! Period. Guten Rutsch!
Ah thank you!! Yeah she’s fab and I’ve been listening to her album now ahah!! I know some of her songs she’s done with PMJ so will try and find one I don’t know 😊 all the best for 2022!
@@JenniferGlatzhofer , thanks a lot, if you find one Haley / PMJ you don't know yet the new year will start as good for me as the old one finished! And if you don't find one, it may start even better, because then you might react on the video outtake of her recording the soundtrack for "An Impossible Project" at the abandoned Semmering Grand Hotel, great scenery, great recordings! One video is on her channel, I'll link that one below, it is a live version of her original "Don't Know How To Love You" dedicated to Etta James (this is also the second track of her video recording at Chess records with her Dad on guitar...great as well) with full orchestra. She recorded some more songs for that soundtrack ("No Regrets" - English version of "Je ne regrette rien" and "I'm A Fool To Love You", but those are hidden, I will tell you where to find them once you reacted on "Don't Know How To Love You"... Enjoy, see you in 22! th-cam.com/video/fbEW8BrNctI/w-d-xo.html
Kudos to whoever did this arrangement! 💯 Haley has such an amazing voice! She totally killed this one! 🤯 This is my very favorite Haley / PMJ collab! 💖🔥🤯. If you didn't already, please check their "Seven Nation Army" and "All About That Bass", with Morgan James on the latter, another beautiful voice beast! 😍💯🎶 Thanks for a wonderful reaction, Jennifer! 💗 and Happy New Year! ☃
When I first heard this, several years ago now, I had to go back and listen again ... and again ... and again ... ☺ I'm expecting comments on how 'she was sick' the day this was 'done in one take' ... So here's a link to the real story:- The Story Behind 'Creep' - Stories from "Outside The Jukebox" : th-cam.com/video/MskKSH1Kf4U/w-d-xo.html
@@JenniferGlatzhofer in addition to scott's "creep" background, there is also some additional history on haley and "creep" from #1 fan haleyTusk (even has a color pic of her from that day) here: th-cam.com/video/eVASTaIoTYw/w-d-xo.html
Haley is by far the best vocalist to have ever performed with PMJ. If you liked "Creep", then you will love reacting to "Seven Nation Army" and "Oops, I Did It Again", which are her next two most popular PMJ music videos. Nonetheless, her newest PMJ music video recorded only a few months ago, which is a cover of No Doubt's "Don't Speak" is absolutely spectacular to say the least.
@@theblackdog2399 a/ You seem confused by the meaning of "former" and "latter". b/ You seem to be confused by people who have differing tastes from you* - while it's not to "my" personal tastes, I don't have a problem with others liking it - why do you have a problem with those that don't care for it? FWIW, it's about the only track of Miss Haley's I'd pass on. *When you grow up you'll realise that some things you liked as a child will no longer be as appealing when you're an adult. You'll also be less likely to use terms like "piss poor" to describe other people's preferences - most people learn manners after being thumped a few times.
Have you ever heard Linda Rondstadt singing a duet with Aaron Neville titled Don't Know Much? So many great Linda Rondstadt songs from the 70's and 80's.
Fun or truely no fun fact I was reading somewhere...She had a flu on this recording and on my opinion this makes this recording so special and unique so so much... Great reaction🤩🤩🤩
Jennifer, if you are a vocal coach, and you heard this song by her before, there's no friggin way that you would have ever forgotten....it's one of the greatest song performances EVER !!!! People like you would never forget this performance....PERIOD !!!! One small constructive criticism....there is no question that you are incredibly knowledgeable in understanding music and more than likely a terrific vocal coach, BUT when you stretch a 5 minute song into over 21 minutes of conversation, it distracts from the original video. I would suspect that 98% of your audience (a large following, deservedly so) does not need such extend "lessons" on the singers vocals. I DO LIKE YOUR REACTIONS !!
Sorry to disagree, but there are too many reactors that waste our time with their lack of musical knowledge. The better reactors elaborate on their knowledge, and I'm sure the majority of the people appreciate that. The longest reaction of Haley's Creep on TH-cam lasted over 30 minutes. Loved every minute of it.
Thank you Jeff 😊 I know my videos aren’t for everyone but I honestly love talking about the voice and I know people do enjoy that element too. So if it’s not for you, skip or move on! Totally fine but I won’t be changing my approach 😊
When you 1st heard Haley, was it when she was on American Idol in 2012 I think. That's when she rocked the stage with some old classics from the 70's and mix in more current songs from that time when she was on Idol. It's a shame she won't get her just due, because she won't sign to a poor contract with any major label. She wants to do it her way, and rather stay away from the controlling big Labels. She deserves to be a super star in my opinion. She's on that level.
LOVE Haley!!!! Amazing vocalist- I highly recommend checking out 15 year old Daneliya Tuleshova- She won The Voice Kids- Ukraine at age 10. Her blind audition was a cover of Demi Lovato's Stone Cold- She is 15 now. Her most recent amazing covers include Bird's Not About Angels, Aurora's Runaway and Lady Gaga's Shallow
I love this reaction. Haley is amazing. I have every song she has published. So I had this thought. Crazy… but it would be fun to see you react to metal. Maybe “Forest” by System of a Down
What do I want out of 2022? Health and it would be great if our governments were NOT so crazy. I can dream can't I? We will see. I enjoy your channel girl. Thank you! Stay safe. Please continue to teach us and open our eyes. Take care. May God bless you and yours. What can I say other than Haley is one heck of a singer. Playful, yes! Old time style well done. Warms my heart.
Hailey goes from delicate and innocent to full vamp in half of a phrase.... Then the innocence is back - for a moment. I guarantee that, once you hear this performance you'll never forget it.
Oh for sure!
I heard this reaction a little over a year ago. I was 'making the rounds' after stumbling upon this jewel. I'm going back around to some of my "go-to" reactors (like you) as well as finding "new" reactions that I haven't heard before. I never tire of this song. I don't know that I would call PMJ or Haley my "very favorites," but THIS performance?? This is one of my very favorite performances by any artist from any genre from any era. Yes. High praise. Phenomenal! And YOU... great reaction!!
They hadn't even planned to record this. They had recorded some other things on a day off while on tour. This arrangement had been made for another singer initially but she really liked it so Scott asked if they should try it. This was the first and only take they recorded 🤯
love when people say i don`t know if i`ve heard this before, if they say this they haven`t because nobody would forget Haley singing it.
So happy to finally react and breakdown this performance and WOW! Just incredible! Happy last video of 2021!! See you in the New Year :)
... as I already said in to longer original comments...: BIG ❤️! Happy new year EVERYONE! See you...
I would have to argue that this is one of her best, if not the best, piece she has recorded.
Agree, but I cherish a soft spot for "Don't Speak" too.
The PMJ rendition of Haley and Puddles doing Mad World is also so much fun!
Yeah right. Let's request a reaction to a music video that features an oversized big oaf of a clown and where there is nothing whatsoever remarkable about either of their vocals. Not to mention that about half the population has a fear for clowns and especially when they are as big and ugly as Puddles Pity Party. Some of you people must have been dropped on your head at some point in your life .
@@theblackdog2399 Rough life, or just a rough day?
Love it!
Had to smile when you you said you didn't remember if you had heard this. This is one you can't forget.
Haha definitely
I've listened to Haley sing this at least 25 times and I love all her music not just PMJ she is a vocal master , so when I saw you were reacting to this I thought, OH this really going to be fun to watch and you didn't disappoint , thumbs up to you 👍 again
Ah thank you!
The PMJ version of "Dream On" by Morgan James is also outstanding. And, if you want a hilarious one, Aubrey Logan and PMJ did a cover of "Ice, Ice, Baby" that is surprisingly good!
Yes Please - Morgan James doing Aerosmith's "Dream On" ........ also, her take on "Angel from Montgomery" is quite fascinating ........ Thanks
Why do you Morgan James fans always hijack and commandeer Haley Reinhart music videos to beg reactors to please react to Morgan James? Let Morgan James generate her own music reactions.
@@theblackdog2399 seems to me that all reactors are reacting to suggestions ..... God gave it to you - use it ...... Have a Blessed New Year ....... just sayin'
Aubrey also does a fantastic 'Hammer Time ' jazz style....
That's one of the things I love about PMJ! They can take even the most annoying of songs,rework it, and create an absolutely fun and incredible version
Haley blows my mind.
Thanks for the concise reaction.
This rendition is on my daily Spotify playlist.
Haley surprised us recently with a cover of Don't Speak by No Doubt. A must react.
I read that she had just sung an entire set on stage BEFORE recording this, AND had a cold (!!) Amazing talent.
Well, at least she was warmed up...😬
@@rogercline5377 - Great Observation ! ! ! Made me laugh out-loud ! Thanks !
Yea, what is it about some artists giving some of their greatest performances when they are 'a bit off, or under the weather?' Within Temptation's Sharon Den Adel and their Rotterdam concert was the greatest live performance in my life to date! Sharon's"Somewhere" was great of itself, but with Anneke...out of this world!
she was just very tired
And they recorded this in 1 shot
I've read that Haley was not feeling well that day and had to be talked into trying "just one take." And then she delivered this. Awe-inspiring.
Oh wow!!
@@JenniferGlatzhofer Yep that is documented fact. As you can see, this is one straight take. It is the first and only take. As with all PMJ videos there are no overdubs or other post production funny business. Post consists of mixing and mastering, nothing more, and most emphatically NO pitch correction (aka autotune) is used. Source: several recorded interviews of, and one book by, Scott Bradlee (the arranger/producer/pianist).
Rumors abound of Haley not feeling well or being sick.
The fact is that Haley had a busy tour schedule with PMJ, and on their day off they decided to record 3 videos. Those videos were All About That Bass, Style and Creep. Guess what, Haley sang in all 3 of them.
Here's the official video recounting the events as per Scott Bradlee.
th-cam.com/video/MskKSH1Kf4U/w-d-xo.html
I think Haley is amazing and I don't know why she isn't more widely celebrated. The only possible issue one could have of this performance is that it was more of an exhibition of jazzy vocal technique than an accurate interpretation of the meaning of the song. She packed in so much, each time through the chorus was distinctly different and everything she did was flawless. Her vocals when not with PMJ are not so over the top and I probably prefer them, but there is no denying the brilliance of this performance.
Haley is not more celebrated because for years already, she has been refusing to sign a record deal with a big major record label. Hence, no record deal, no mass exposure, i.e., she isn't permitted to perform on network TV and her music isn't permitted to be played on the radio airways. The result is she always remains very obscure and in which also means her career also remains very mediocre at the same time, relative to her world-class level of talent.
@@theblackdog2399 I suppose she has her reasons, but between her and the teenager Angelina Jordan they occupy a style of music which I guess you could call jazzy pop that I really like where there is no one else to compete at their level. It takes a lot of skill and feel for music that very few can aspire to.
@@robertvirnig638 Haley's reason, as she has expressed is fear.
In addition, Haley doesn't occupy any genre of music. As Haley sings any and all genres of music excellently, and no, Angelina Jordan is not close to being in the same league with Haley Reinhart as a vocalist, a songwriter, a performer, or with respect to their looks. Try again. As Haley Reinhart is a world class talent and Angelina is definitely not.
@@theblackdog2399 I don't know why you felt the need to bash on someone just because I mentioned them, and I wholesale disagree with you about Angelina being a world-class talent. I agree that there probably isn't another singer as sexy as Haley as sensuality permeates everything she does from her looks, singing style, movements, etc. Haley's songwriting is very good and some of her songs would be on the charts if she didn't have this thing about producers. Also, her technical ability is absolutely unrivaled. But you are comparing a 30 something-year-old woman's abilities and accomplishments to those of a teenage girl. What Angelina can do is emotionally connect to a song and provide just the right embellishments to convey the meaning of a song rather than just try to bedazzle the audience with vocal gymnastics. In this song "Creep" Haley is just showing off, little of what she is doing has anything at all with the meaning of the song. Haley can do things that Angelina hasn't yet attempted at 15 but everything AJ does is excellent and she has time to develop further. As far as songwriting, Angelina's limited youthful attempts thus far are good and I'll withhold any real critique for when her first album comes out probably sometime in the upcoming year. In the end, each artist is unique and you do not have to cut down one to acknowledge the abilities of another.
@@theblackdog2399 Your character is demonstrated for all to see by your own words and attitude so I won't respond in kind. I doubt if either of these artists would want to be associated with your negativity.
thanks for doing Haley justice.
Great Post, Jennifer. And it is hard to forget or not know if you have reacted to this video. Once you see it, it is ALWAYS in your head. Haley Reinhart is JESSICA RABBIT reincarnated. How her and Angelina Jordan did not win American Idol and Got Talent Champions tourney, I'll never know. This is an AMAZING video. Thank you for sharing with us. Have a Happy New Year.
What a great reaction! You really need to check out....they did a no doubt cover of "Don't speak" they had Haley back after 6 years......... and it is phenomenal.
Great! Thank you 😁
@@JenniferGlatzhofer , forgot to mention this one... 😁
I'm so glad that you finally got to this song, Haley is absolutely fabulous in the delivery of this song. There are many different covers of this song, done by many great artists, but this version is my favorite. Haley, with PMJ, makes this song hers. Just fabulous.
Haley sure does bring a big bag of vocal tricks and goodies and general awesomeness to this performance. Masterful interpretation.
You might enjoy listening to Haley and Morgan James singing “Dear Prudence” sitting bare foot on a couch.
I doubt it. The audio sucks.
@@theblackdog2399 Your glass never comes close to being half full does it?
@@LonesomeTwin The audio flat out sucks dude and it's not my fault. As I had nothing to do with it. You suggest reactors to react to shitty music videos or lame performances and you are only hurting the artists. I mean, it's common sense. You know what that is?
You really have to also check her cover of "Seven Nation Army" by The White Stripes
Her voice gives me the chills 😍
Oh same 😍
Thank you for reacting to this absolutely fabulous rendition of Creep by Haley Reinhart ! She is a such a great singer with so much vocal abilities ! Loved the video with Postmodern Jukebox ! They are such intensely talented musicians ! Haley paints such a rich vocal canvas with a variety of textures and colours throughout the song ! It was truly magnificent ! Thank you as always Jenn for your informative analysis and comments ! You're the best and wishing you a happy happy 2022 ! 🎊🎊🤗👍🇨🇦❤️❤️
Such a great version, really enjoyed it 😁 wishing you a very Happy New Year too!
nice reaction and breakdown jennifer (and great accent)... this maybe one of the best covers ever done. haley reinhart especially with postmodern jukebox is incredible. all the other haley/pmj ones are great also: "all about the bass", "habits", "black hole sun", "mad world", "seven nations army", "oops i did it again", "lovefool" and the very recent "don't speak" . i think what is so phenomenal about haley is not just her amazing silk to sandpaper voice but also her character and soul that she puts into the performances. even when she uses very little acrobatics, her pure raw soft voice is amazing like in the intro of "creep". you see this even more in her solo platinum cover of "can't help falling in love" for the extra gum commercial which is truly stunning and frequently described as what love sounds like here: th-cam.com/video/_uNpEbt7w_o/w-d-xo.html
She really uses her voice well and plays around with it! Love it😁
It was so interesting to hear your analysis of this world-class performance. Haley is amazing! The emotional journey here reminds me of Shoshana Bean singing Make It Rain at The Theatre At Ace Hotel. As a music theater nerd, you may have already heard it, but if not, it would make a great reaction video. Shoshana pours out every drop of her soul onto the stage in a catharsis of pain and hope that must be experienced to be believed.
Thank you!! And yes, I must revisit Shoshana Bean! 😊
@@JenniferGlatzhofer , Make It Rain is hilarious!
The stars aligned ! WOW !.GOD BLESS AMERICA !!!
You're my new favorite music reactor and love your own voice!
“That ending fully deserved” yesss it ended as it should have 🎉
I recommend a singer called Diana Navarro. With the song "El perdón" she is very versatile and sings different styles of music with incredible melismas. And with a very personal voice.
gift + hard work = gemstone Thanks Gennifer for your great breakdown
I never tire of watching this performance. Absolutely love Haley's voice. Such an awesome reaction too, Jen, as usual. I agree with Jim, you ought to give this song a try yourself. You possess an equally awesome voice and I think you'd give us a great rendition as well! I do hope you enjoyed a wonderful Christmas, wish you a fantastic new year and am curious and looking forward to whatever new surprises you have in store for this channel going forward. Take care and once again Happy New Year! 🥳
Thank you!! Definitely something to think about 😁 hope you had a lovely Christmas and Happy New Year! See you then 👋🏼
I noticed I kept coming back to your videos so.. I did the only right thing to do, I just subbed to your channel. Thanks for your reactions and you are fun to watch.
Thanks for supporting 😊
As long as we make it out of 2022 alive, I'll be happy.
I remember seeing Haley Reinhart in American Idol along with their basses Casey Abrams and I remember she always had that growl and raspy in her singing voice. She has grown so much since that show. She's such an incredible singer! There are some runs that she did in this video are like "Woah I've never heard anyone do that before."
Happy New Year! I'm glad to be part of your subscribers. All thanks to Kellie (Kelxsings) for bringing me here from your collab song You Love Who You Love with her. It's been 9 months since I've become one of your subscribers. Great channel! I know I'm not a singer just a guitar player, but I love how you analyze singers by pausing and going over what they did there. You sure know what you're talking about.😁 I can't wait for next year. I can't wait to see what singers you're going to go over next. Have a great New Year, Jennifer!
Thank you Kevin! I’ve loved reading your comments 😊 and agree with the runs we heard in this video. Out of this WORLD! Looking forward to what’s in store for the new year 😊
is that a 1970's over stuffed, tweed like material couch!!?? LOL! Love it! I think I had the same style of couch growing in up in 80's n 90's central California!!
B-E-A-utiful and great reaction Jennifer, as always enjoy listening and watching. Arm movement we call jazz hands. :)
Please incorporate her version of "Don't Speak' originally by No Doubt. Haley does a fanatastic job. Happy New Year!!!
Haley is remarkable! Love her.
Her vocal toolkit is astounding with what all she can do. love the geek out!! I really enjoy you technical break down. I really enjoy Haley's physical presentation(yes she is pretty) but the physical movements she uses to create mood or emphasis. Really got a kick out of your facial expressions as well. Totally Enjoyable reaction!
Ah thank you!
Loving reaction... thank you !..
Happy new year. Hope you had a great Christmas. Thanks for sharing.
Be sure to check out PMJ Morgan James "Dream On" and Haley's current PMJ song "Don't Speak"...
That was a cool and amusing and, more to the point, an erudite reaction to and analysis of what has become a phenomenon.You clearly know what you're talking about, and you now have my attention ... And my subscription. Good work!
Ah thanks so much!
This performance is a total classic for the hall of fame, for the ages,:for the history books...
Just put it right there alongside of "I put a spell on you", performance by Angelina Jordan... But this one was live, full take recorded.... Sure there's some post production balancing and such but, This is it !!!
so since spiderman is going crazy how about the Micheal Buble version of the spiderman theme song . it so much fun
Scott's ( the pianist ) arrangement is straight outta' 1950's Tin Pan Alley and the jazz clubs of that period......just a great performance.....
Have a good 2022, Jennifer! 😘
Thank you! And you 😁
Again, I must say I just love watching you react. It's so fun!
Of course, Haley is amazing!
This is the fourth (fifth?) of your reaction videos I've watched, in short order. Subscribed on the second (though I was pretty sure I would after the first), and by now you're knocking on the door of the top tier of vocal-coach reactors (for me). Keep up the good work, and I'll keep watching.
Ah thank you very much 😊
I have been waiting for you to do a video about this performance. I was amused watching you squirm around jumping out of your skin with things to say not wanting to keep pausing every 10 seconds. You are very entertaining in your videos and they always leave me feeling happy inside. I love this performance, the 40's, jazzy, smoky nightclub feel of it is vastly different from the original, and that helps this cover stand on its own as a cover should. Haley did a superb job with this song. I remember the first time I saw her do this I was amazed at how versatile she can be. This song was also the very first time I ever heard of her, or Post Modern Jukebox, or her singing. What a great way to be introduced to a performer. Have a Happy and safe New Year celebration, all the best wishes to you and yours for the new year and beyond. Thank you for sharing your knowledge in such an informative and entertaining way, and for your efforts making these great videos!
Thank you so much for your kind words!! Absolutely loved watching this performance and talking about 😊
Don't forget that on the same day, Haley sang lead in All About That Bass and sang backup in Style.
Haley is a beast, in a good way.
Hi Jennifer, thanks for your reaction. Haley is so bad ass that she was not feeling well but she went ahead and recorded this and did it in one take. Please react to Haley and BMJ Cover of no doubt. Post modern jukebox post modern jukebox no doubt don’t speak. Haley is phenomenal she is Jessica rabbit a run for her money. Please react to this song, You’re absolutely gorgeous, Hi from Texas.
I always enjoy your informative and entertaining reactions. I'm Canadian and I'm in love with your accent. I could listen to you just read a phone book (if you remember what those are). Happy New Year. Cheers.
Hahaha oh wow! Thanks 😁 happy new year!
She was sick and didn’t think she could do this and they did this in one take.
Vocal gymnastics
I love your energy. Great Reaction
I don't know what it is, but, I adore you. Even before singing. I do love to hear you talk about the particulars of singing. What a beauty you are though. Super eyes. Haley doesn't look like a creep.
Hi Jennifer, now this is a nice surprise for the new year, can't believe you didn't react on this one before... tastes may be different, but for me Haley is the greatest voice they have over in the US! (I don't count Angelina even if she's currently living in LA...). Didn't watch your reaction yet and may leave another comment after, just wanted to say how much I'm looking forward to this right now as I generally appreciate your reactions and I deeply love Haley, so this will be great and I'm happy to discover it on the last day of the year... thanks for reacting, more Haley anytime for me please! - Happy new year Jennifer, happy new year everyone! ❤️ Go...!
... you really made my day, Jennifer! Can't get any better than finding someone who really can appreciate, and express and explain what's going on, even already knows and loves Haley, but, very strange indeed, does not know this performance... this is like winning the jackpot for me, and on the last game of the year... 😬 - For me this one was actually my first encounter with Haley about one year ago, and you may try to imagine what an impression that made on someone not knowing all of her AGT renditions yet, not her originals, not the magic things she did in Semmering, Austria recording direct to vinyl with the great Simon Peres Orchestra, nothing... - I was completely blown away 🌀... so, this being your first time featuring PMJ on your channel, but having listened some privately and knowing Haley, do you know her other breathtaking collaborations with Scott Bradlee and his fabulous band, like Seven Nation Army, Black Hole Sun, Oops I Did It Again, Habits, All About That Bass and more...? If not you need to react on all of these, please! Thanks again for reacting! - My goals for 22? More Haley into my life! - That's not enough? - It is! Simple vision board, as Oscar Wilde is said to have put it: "I'm a man of simple tastes. I'm easily satisfied with the very best...". Watching you reacting on Haley really fulfills all my needs! Period. Guten Rutsch!
Ah thank you!! Yeah she’s fab and I’ve been listening to her album now ahah!! I know some of her songs she’s done with PMJ so will try and find one I don’t know 😊 all the best for 2022!
@@JenniferGlatzhofer , thanks a lot, if you find one Haley / PMJ you don't know yet the new year will start as good for me as the old one finished! And if you don't find one, it may start even better, because then you might react on the video outtake of her recording the soundtrack for "An Impossible Project" at the abandoned Semmering Grand Hotel, great scenery, great recordings! One video is on her channel, I'll link that one below, it is a live version of her original "Don't Know How To Love You" dedicated to Etta James (this is also the second track of her video recording at Chess records with her Dad on guitar...great as well) with full orchestra. She recorded some more songs for that soundtrack ("No Regrets" - English version of "Je ne regrette rien" and "I'm A Fool To Love You", but those are hidden, I will tell you where to find them once you reacted on "Don't Know How To Love You"... Enjoy, see you in 22!
th-cam.com/video/fbEW8BrNctI/w-d-xo.html
Tnx!- Always subscribe to Haley fans. Good reaction!
Kudos to whoever did this arrangement! 💯 Haley has such an amazing voice! She totally killed this one! 🤯
This is my very favorite Haley / PMJ collab! 💖🔥🤯. If you didn't already, please check their "Seven Nation Army" and "All About That Bass", with Morgan James on the latter, another beautiful voice beast! 😍💯🎶
Thanks for a wonderful reaction, Jennifer! 💗 and Happy New Year! ☃
Ah thank you!
Scott Bradlee is the talent behind all of Postmodern Jukebox arrangements.
Thanks, Jeff!
How you don't have north of 100k subscribers ... I just don't understand. Wish the best for you in 2022.
Ah thank you! We’re going to get there ahah 🙌🏼
Once you've watched this performance you're not likely to forget it!
True true ahah!
When I first heard this, several years ago now, I had to go back and listen again ... and again ... and again ... ☺
I'm expecting comments on how 'she was sick' the day this was 'done in one take' ... So here's a link to the real story:-
The Story Behind 'Creep' - Stories from "Outside The Jukebox" : th-cam.com/video/MskKSH1Kf4U/w-d-xo.html
Ooh thank you so much! I’ve listened to it so many times already 😱
Glad you put it out there.
I'm sick and tired of arguing that point.
@@JenniferGlatzhofer in addition to scott's "creep" background, there is also some additional history on haley and "creep" from #1 fan haleyTusk (even has a color pic of her from that day) here: th-cam.com/video/eVASTaIoTYw/w-d-xo.html
Try Beth Hart and Joe Bonamassa I'll Take Care of You (live in Beacon Theatre from NY) will be a Good start for 2022. Success!
Haley has an ear-catching voice and an eye-catching style,if you know what I mean, and I think you do.
Haley is by far the best vocalist to have ever performed with PMJ. If you liked "Creep", then you will love reacting to "Seven Nation Army" and "Oops, I Did It Again", which are her next two most popular PMJ music videos. Nonetheless, her newest PMJ music video recorded only a few months ago, which is a cover of No Doubt's "Don't Speak" is absolutely spectacular to say the least.
Yup, definitely the former, the latter is more a question of taste, though - rather less keen on it, myself.
@@gordowg1wg145 You have piss poor taste if you don't like The former's just as much as the latter.
@@theblackdog2399
a/ You seem confused by the meaning of "former" and "latter".
b/ You seem to be confused by people who have differing tastes from you* - while it's not to "my" personal tastes, I don't have a problem with others liking it - why do you have a problem with those that don't care for it? FWIW, it's about the only track of Miss Haley's I'd pass on.
*When you grow up you'll realise that some things you liked as a child will no longer be as appealing when you're an adult. You'll also be less likely to use terms like "piss poor" to describe other people's preferences - most people learn manners after being thumped a few times.
Have you ever heard Linda Rondstadt singing a duet with Aaron Neville titled Don't Know Much? So many great Linda Rondstadt songs from the 70's and 80's.
Now listen to PMJ accompanying Morgan James singing Dream On
PMJ Morgan James - Dream On
i think haley knows and uses every vocal "trick" during this song
If You havent already ... plz react to PMJ/ Morgan James cover of Aerosmith's Dream on OR Take me to Church by Hozier...
I agree with the “Ice, Ice baby” vid shout out, very clever and entertaining 👍
She's pretty much using every trick in the book in this song.
If you dig this, you may want to check out the duet she did with Jeff Goldblum (yes, the actor). It's simply a blast!
😱 this I’ve got to see!
Not a duet per se. Jeff Goldbloom has a Jazz orchestra. Great rendition of My Baby Just Cares for Me.
th-cam.com/video/3ipXA9lJzc0/w-d-xo.html
you have done a nice job with your channel Jennifer with your reactions ... have enjoyed it ...
Ah thanks 😁
My equal favourite PMJ performance. The other is Dream On with Morgan James
Hailey sings, 7 armies Nation very well too
Try PMJ with Haley/Puddles doing "Mad World". Really interesting!
you should give a listen to "Don't Speak"
Please react to Haley's cover of 7 Nation Army, its awesome. I've heard many covers of Freak and this is the best one.
Fun or truely no fun fact I was reading somewhere...She had a flu on this recording and on my opinion this makes this recording so special and unique so so much...
Great reaction🤩🤩🤩
she was just very tired
saludos desde mex bonita reacciom
Give a listen to Haley and Puddles Pity Party (the singing clown) covering Mad World.
Jennifer, if you are a vocal coach, and you heard this song by her before, there's no friggin way that you would have ever forgotten....it's one of the greatest song performances EVER !!!! People like you would never forget this performance....PERIOD !!!!
One small constructive criticism....there is no question that you are incredibly knowledgeable in understanding music and more than likely a terrific vocal coach, BUT when you stretch a 5 minute song into over 21 minutes of conversation, it distracts from the original video. I would suspect that 98% of your audience (a large following, deservedly so) does not need such extend "lessons" on the singers vocals. I DO LIKE YOUR REACTIONS !!
Sorry to disagree, but there are too many reactors that waste our time with their lack of musical knowledge.
The better reactors elaborate on their knowledge, and I'm sure the majority of the people appreciate that.
The longest reaction of Haley's Creep on TH-cam lasted over 30 minutes. Loved every minute of it.
Thank you Jeff 😊 I know my videos aren’t for everyone but I honestly love talking about the voice and I know people do enjoy that element too. So if it’s not for you, skip or move on! Totally fine but I won’t be changing my approach 😊
When you 1st heard Haley, was it when she was on American Idol in 2012 I think. That's when she rocked the stage with some old classics from the 70's and mix in more current songs from that time when she was on Idol. It's a shame she won't get her just due, because she won't sign to a poor contract with any major label. She wants to do it her way, and rather stay away from the controlling big Labels. She deserves to be a super star in my opinion. She's on that level.
LOVE Haley!!!! Amazing vocalist- I highly recommend checking out 15 year old Daneliya Tuleshova- She won The Voice Kids- Ukraine at age 10. Her blind audition was a cover of Demi Lovato's Stone Cold- She is 15 now. Her most recent amazing covers include Bird's Not About Angels, Aurora's Runaway and Lady Gaga's Shallow
please react to Haley Reinhart & Morgan James accoustic version of Dear Prudence by the Beatles. Amazing!!
Hello 🌲🎄 Happy New Year 🎄❤️
I love this reaction. Haley is amazing. I have every song she has published. So I had this thought. Crazy… but it would be fun to see you react to metal. Maybe “Forest” by System of a Down
Thank you! Ooh ok 😊
Haley’s alphabet consists of 26 vowels 😎 There’s no “a” in “here” except in Haleyland.
Have you ever listened to KZ Tandingan? I think you might dig her, especially her duet of 'Feeling Good' with Jaya ;)
What do I want out of 2022? Health and it would be great if our governments were NOT so crazy. I can dream can't I? We will see. I enjoy your channel girl. Thank you! Stay safe. Please continue to teach us and open our eyes. Take care. May God bless you and yours. What can I say other than Haley is one heck of a singer. Playful, yes! Old time style well done. Warms my heart.
This rendition of Creep is unforgettable...so you would have remembered, right ?
Tour de force vocal performance
Listen to Haley's original song "lay It Down" It is really amazing...
Do you want to hear a totaly great version of Creep, watch the voice kids germany 2019, mimi and josefine, they won.. Watch the 12 minutes version...
Haley's version is in a totally different league.
It's a masterpiece.
😍
nice observation. we love you. will wach U. Be nice.
I have a feeling that if you had seen this before it would have left an impression . . . no?
did you hear her "Seven Nation Army" cover?
L O V E H A L E Y ! ..... just saying .....