The verses of Quran being quoted simply mean that it's good to wear it. If we see, for the things that are prohibited in the Quran, there are then warnings given about hell and how's theyll be punished. This surah was revealed because the Muslim women at that time were being harassed. If Allah dislike women not wearing hijab that much then he'd also write that he curses those women or something along the lines of that
Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning): “O Prophet! Tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to draw their cloaks (veils) all over their bodies (i.e. screen themselves completely except the eyes or one eye to see the way). That will be better, that they should be known (as free respectable women) so as not to be annoyed. And Allaah is Ever Oft‑Forgiving, Most Merciful” [al-Ahzaab 33:59] Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: “Allaah commanded the believing women, if they go out of their houses for some need, to cover their faces from the top of their heads with their jilbaabs, and to leave one eye showing.”
@@ashley_brown6106 i think you need to see the surveys held by your father countries that how islam's order to khimaar for women protect them from harrasment.I think people like you and Mr.Ghamidi can do anything to get certificate from west that they are liberalised nation.
اَلنُّوْر: 24 آیت :31 وَ قُلْ لِّلْمُؤْمِنٰتِ یَغْضُضْنَ مِنْ اَبْصَارِهِنَّ وَ یَحْفَظْنَ فُرُوْجَهُنَّ وَ لَا یُبْدِیْنَ زِیْنَتَهُنَّ اِلَّا مَا ظَهَرَ مِنْهَا وَ لْیَضْرِبْنَ بِخُمُرِهِنَّ عَلٰى جُیُوْبِهِنَّ۪-وَ لَا یُبْدِیْنَ زِیْنَتَهُنَّ اِلَّا لِبُعُوْلَتِهِنَّ اَوْ اٰبَآىٕهِنَّ اَوْ اٰبَآءِ بُعُوْلَتِهِنَّ اَوْ اَبْنَآىٕهِنَّ اَوْ اَبْنَآءِ بُعُوْلَتِهِنَّ اَوْ اِخْوَانِهِنَّ اَوْ بَنِیْۤ اِخْوَانِهِنَّ اَوْ بَنِیْۤ اَخَوٰتِهِنَّ اَوْ نِسَآىٕهِنَّ اَوْ مَا مَلَكَتْ اَیْمَانُهُنَّ اَوِ التّٰبِعِیْنَ غَیْرِ اُولِی الْاِرْبَةِ مِنَ الرِّجَالِ اَوِ الطِّفْلِ الَّذِیْنَ لَمْ یَظْهَرُوْا عَلٰى عَوْرٰتِ النِّسَآءِ۪-وَ لَا یَضْرِبْنَ بِاَرْجُلِهِنَّ لِیُعْلَمَ مَا یُخْفِیْنَ مِنْ زِیْنَتِهِنَّؕ-وَ تُوْبُوْۤا اِلَى اللّٰهِ جَمِیْعًا اَیُّهَ الْمُؤْمِنُوْنَ لَعَلَّكُمْ تُفْلِحُوْنَ(۳۱) اور مسلمان عورتوں کو حکم دو کہ وہ اپنی نگاہیں کچھ نیچی رکھیں اور اپنی پارسائی کی حفاظت کریں اور اپنی زینت نہ دکھائیں مگر جتنا (بدن کاحصہ) خود ہی ظاہر ہے اور وہ اپنے دوپٹے اپنے گریبانوں پر ڈالے رکھیں اور اپنی زینت ظاہر نہ کریں مگر اپنے شوہروں پر یا اپنے باپ یا شوہروں کے باپ یا اپنے بیٹوں یا شوہروں کے بیٹے یا اپنے بھائیوں یا اپنے بھتیجوں یا اپنے بھانجوں یا اپنی (مسلمان) عورتوں یا اپنی کنیزوں پر جو ان کی ملکیت ہوں یامردوں میں سے وہ نوکر جو شہوت والے نہ ہوں یا وہ بچے جنہیں عورتوں کی شرم کی چیزوں کی خبر نہیں اور زمین پر اپنے پاؤں اس لئے زور سے نہ ماریں کہ ان کی اس زینت کا پتہ چل جائے جو انہوں نے چھپائی ہوئی ہے اور اے مسلمانو! تم سب اللہ کی طرف توبہ کرو اس امید پر کہ تم فلاح پاؤ۔
Does Allah command it Yes or No. There no middle way going into it especially if its mentioned in quran. More focus should be on the meaning of aayat and context. No need to rationalizing this with biases first. Rationalizing is the second step not the first. Text is the first step sir.
Aur kya logic hai jab aaraish zabaish kare tab haath aur head cover kare. Yeh kahan likha hai . Sir sirf aapka opinion sunne nahi aaye hai quran aur hadees se islamic answer sunne aaye hai phir opinion. Jo jab convenient ho woh baat kyun karen. Aur yeh kaunn decide karega ab exposure zyada ho raha hai. Aap apne intelligence pe sab chod rahe hai par Allah ki intelligence aur hukm pe kam focus kar rahe hai. Hamari judgement society ke standard ke saath change hoti hai. American school main shorts pehenna decent aur modest hota hai . Par woh point nahi hai . Point quran aur hadees ka hai.
So why are you watching this short clip. Ghamdi saab has full lecture going into full detail and depth. Why not watch those rather than commenting and criticising?
@@naumankhan422 but the question still stands, have you watched the lectures that are available on TH-cam and on the site, before coming and "critiquing" him.
To bhai ye apka masla hai ... Ap abhi tk kyu nhi samajh paye???? Kisko blame kar rhe hai isper jakar samajhiye Alhamdulillah aj to sab kuch available hai
And tell the believing women to reduce [some] of their vision and guard their private parts and not expose their adornment except that which [necessarily] appears thereof and to wrap [a portion of] their headcovers over their chests and not expose their adornment except to their husbands, their fathers, their husbands' fathers, their sons, their husbands' sons, their brothers, their brothers' sons, their sisters' sons, their women, that which their right hands possess, or those male attendants having no physical desire, or children who are not yet aware of the private aspects of women. And let them not stamp their feet to make known what they conceal of their adornment. And turn to Allah in repentance, all of you, O believers, that you might succeed. The Glorious Qur'an Surah Ahzab : 31
@CookieDough My dear Cookie, 1. The word '*Hijab*' is not present in Quran; but the words '*jilbab*'(www.google.com/search?q=jilbab&oq=jilbab&aqs=chrome..69i57&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8) , '*khimar*'(www.google.com/search?q=khimar&oq=khimar&aqs=chrome..69i57&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8) and others; Altogether the meaning is '*Covering*' or '*Curtain*' in such a way that only face, wrists and feet are exposed. 2. The Quran itself cannot be taken as full understanding of manners. So, hadith must also be taken into consideration. There ample of hadith which relates to the above explanation of '*jilbab*' and/or '*khimar*'. Besides that, we must also take the life sahaba (The companions of Prophet swt) if one cannot understand. The above are the metrics based on which the society norms are established. The modern word is '*Hijab*' which simply mean '*dresscode*'. So, there are several implementations of hijab ranging from Turkey and Azerbaijan in Caucasus, Saudi and others in Arab, Pakistan, India and others in South Asia, and many more regions as per their understands. 3.If you think the meaning only *covering* but no head cover or any other then a women can hide only vagina and show everything else. In hotels, at home, office, schools and also on streets; one can even forget clothes to wear and think of hijab as a psychological covering, Ultimately promote nude culture. in short, don't fool yourself!
@Ali Siddiqui tum kafir banjao to behtr hai bhai...Parda farz hai Ghamdi kon hota hai ye kehne wala..hamare nabi(صل الله وعليه وسلم)ne jab farma diya to baat khatam...Fatima(رضى الله عنها) ne farmaya jb mera janaza uthe to raat ko uthaya jaye takai meri mayyat pr bhi kisi gheir mard ki nazar na pare..(mafhoom)...aur tum Log kehte ho parda farz nhi..wah wah ye deen tmhre baap ka nhi samjh ii
Mashallah Allah has blessed us with a great scholar Ghamdi saab. Everything he says is backed up with so much information and knowledge from Quran. The Quran is such a beautiful book the perfect guide for all Muslim ummah. Islam itself is such a simple and idealistic religion that has been distorted by so many of many of our traditional scholars who boil it all down to their own satisfaction and desires backed up by nothing but their stupid and non sensible idiocracies. May Allah guide everybody to the straight path. AMEEN
Ghamidi sahab magribiyat or liberalism k manhaj se bht mar-oob nazar aate hain. Unhune insanu k banaye huye human rights charter k mutabiq deen ko samajhne ki koshish ki hai jaise... Unke bht se arguments qabil qadr hain lekin pardah, nizam-e riyasat-e islami, nuzool e Isa AS, aur hadees ki hasiyat ko leke woh bht kamzor ladi pe khade hain... Women empowerment k naam pe jo be pardagi feli hui hai Ghamidi sahab usko silently endorse karte nazar aate hain... Unki majlis main nange sir auraten hoti hain... Kaash ki woh unko kam se kam ye bolte ki iss cheez main zabardasti agar nahi ki jasakti lekin pardah baharhal aik bht bada hukum hai shariat ka jiski hukme udooli aik gunah hai. Lekin afsoos... Libaeralism ki fikar se mar-oob loug Ghamidi sahab ko hujjat mante hain... I would recommend such liberal muslims who want to stay at the boundary for protecting their dunya, to watch Mohammad Hijab's philosophical deconstruction of liberalism. Liberalism is like religion. A muslim can not be liberal. He can only be a muslim. However, that doesn't mean a muslim has to be intolerant. Islam has better moral guidelines for co-existence than Liberalism. Lakum deenukum wa lia deen.
@@sophosalpha A muslim who decides to follow the path of Allah in a righteous way, and has a strong understanding of the principles and fundamentals of Islam and doesn't like to blindly follow the teaching of others without analysing for themselves what is right and wrong is not a person following a liberist path. I am sorry but if you want to label someone liberist and following maghrib propaganda for understanding and implementing guidance of Allah swt.tallah should point a finger at themselves rather than others. When you dont agree with someone and their teaching you do not need to go against them in a comment section just ignore them but if you really care about the fact that so many people follow Ghamdi saabs teachings then you confront him and seek out what it is that bothers you so much about his ways. If you have enough confidence and want to prove him wrong ( which he is completely open to) then go through his lectures do your research, find out what it is that you are labelling liberism and then confront him. Trolling people and putting irrelevant and unwanted reply is not the solution.
@@honey0331 I have watched all his lectures on TH-cam. I have not trolled him. Don't you see i use Ghamidi Sahab. I didn't use abusive words. ! What makes you think I am trolling him. If you have read Quran and Hadith, you can't deny that Ghamidi sahab is very selective in taking hadith. He says darul ulooms and madrassahs teach terrorism. He ,being well versed in social science, ignores politics and blames religion and madrassahs. Let me give you an example. In India, despite a strong anti-muslim propaganda done by hindu right wing outfits against islam and frequent killings of muslims, we don't see madrassah students waging jihad!!!. Even in Kashmir, no local madrassah students have joined militancy! Most militants in Kashmir are university and college passouts!! Ghamidi sahab's allegations on madrassah's are baseless. You must read Robert Pape on how terrorism is linked to politics of occupation. In Pakistan, it was the combined political manipulation of madrassahs by State along with US and Saudi Arabia to fight Afghan jihad which lead to where you are now. Madrassahs per se had nothing to do with jihad or terrorism whatever you want to call it. Another thing that is worth mentioning is the ideology of groups like Al Qaeda and ISIS. That ideology is denounced by all muslim scholars. First and foremost by Arab salafis like those following Baaz and Uthaymen who are thought to be advocates of the stictest version of Islam(salafism)!!. The point is such violent groups have risen more because of oil based American interventions in the middle east and occupation of Palestine by Israel. You see Politics! But Ghamidi sahab gives convenient answers and blames madrassahs which is preposterous.
Which Ayath of the Quran and Hadith did he quote then in this video??? Answer: None. You can reject ALLAH's Word Of Quran and accept his words in this video . But, if ypu accept his words then surely you will answer to ALLAH
nice explained but against the concept of Quran. if you believe that Quran is a historical book then you will have this meaning ...."ager koi kerly to achi baat hai wagerna lazmi nahi hai"
@@ScienceadobyDrEishal thora sa khud bhi research kerlaty ap to achi baat hoti Her bt scholers ki ankh band ker kay nahi manni chaheay thora khud bhi quran khol k perhna chaheay kay Allah n rasool kay kia ahkamaat han Quran me Allah surah ahzab ayat 59 me fermata hay اے نبی! اپنی بیبیوں اور صاحبزادیوں اور مسلمانوں کی عورتوں سے فرما دو کہ اپنی چادروں کا ایک حصہ اپنے منہ پر ڈالے رہیں یہ اس سے نزدیک تر ہے کہ ان کی پہچان ہو تو ستائی نہ جائیں اور اللہ بخشنے والا مہربان ہے ،
@@easyartwithfizza257 different scholars have translated it differently. When you read the English translation, there is no mention of covering the face. It talks about how Muslim women should cover their chest (which is common sense). Again, you need to read multiple translations.
That is exactly what Quran says... Do not show yourself to the world with "makeup" or jewlery.... but quran clearly sets the minimum requirements for all muslims men & women equally. We tend to wrongly misunderstand sorah Ahzab (ayat 59) that was for a particular event and for particular individuals not for the general public......... Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
Ghamdi shab Allah apko salamt rakha ap ikhtilaf Ray ko bht Acha andz ma address krta magr Hazrat prda orat k lia farz e aein ha, surah ehzab ma tamam muslman Orton ko prda k hukam h akhr ya kesa mumkin, us dor ki Orton k lia ya tha or ajj ni, dunia ki behtreen Orton na dunia k behtreen mrdon(shaba) sa prda kia to ajj k mashra ghan hr traf fitna prda kesa farz ni hoga??? App apna ik bayan ma frma rha tha k chand obashon ki wjah sa us time hukam aya to kia ajj dunia sa Sara obash khtm ho ga hn??? Rie bt apka is muwaquf ko appreciate krna ki to hr Wo Mard orat Jo prda sa rah e farar hasal krna chata Wo zarur apka is muwaquf ki taied krn ga.... Ghan bhe orat Mard k azadana ikhtilat hoga whan ya sb hoga Jo ajjj hmara mashra ma ho rha
اَلْاَحْزَاب: 33 آیت 59 یٰۤاَیُّهَا النَّبِیُّ قُلْ لِّاَزْوَاجِكَ وَ بَنٰتِكَ وَ نِسَآءِ الْمُؤْمِنِیْنَ یُدْنِیْنَ عَلَیْهِنَّ مِنْ جَلَابِیْبِهِنَّؕ-ذٰلِكَ اَدْنٰۤى اَنْ یُّعْرَفْنَ فَلَا یُؤْذَیْنَؕ-وَ كَانَ اللّٰهُ غَفُوْرًا رَّحِیْمًا(۵۹) اے نبی!اپنی بیویوں اور اپنی صاحبزادیو ں اور مسلمانوں کی عورتوں سے فرمادو کہ اپنی چادروں کا ایک حصہ اپنے او پر ڈالے رکھیں ، یہ اس سے زیادہ نزدیک ہے کہ وہ پہچانی جائیں تو انہیں ستایا نہ جائے اور اللہ بخشنے والا مہربان ہے۔
Ghamidi has clearly answered this many many times. Hijab is not Islamic ... it was added to muslim after Islam faced conservatory pressures due to sudden dissasters.... Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
I am afraid if one decides to neglect and follow his desire. Do so but beware that he is openly defying Allah عز و جل orders and not following the injunctions of our beloved prophet Mohammad ﷺ
@@FirstAnalysis no sir you need to read the the Quran and Hadith and form your opinion. Openly defying Allah عز و جل orders and not following prophet ﷺ and his companions is if following your own desire.
@@haqirfan1382 well the word is there but you’ve presented an out of context verse, if you read the translation, it’s referring to this “But Allah is never shy of the truth. And when you ˹believers˺ ask his wives for something, ask them from behind a barrier.” Hijaab is used here for the word barrier not to instruct women to wear head coverings, hope that makes sense now
Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
Excellent explanation. It all goes back to the reason/intent behind these directions as per the Quran. Living in the West, I cannot tell you how many times I have seen Muslim females wearing hijabs but then also wearing skin tight clothing! Now go figure.
Category ki Kia baat hai sahb. Parda musalman awraton k liye farz hai.jab koi gher muslim awrat musalman hoja ti hai to sab se pehli wo hijab ki paband nazar aati hai.
Asma, daughter of AbuBakr, entered upon the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) wearing thin clothes. The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) turned his attention from her. He said: O Asma', when a woman reaches the age of menstruation, it does not suit her that she displays her parts of body except this and this, and he pointed to his face and hands. Abu Dawud said: This is a mursal tradition (i.e. the narrator who transmitted it from 'Aishah is missing) Khalid b. Duraik did not see 'Aishah. Grade: Sahih (Al-Albani)
Because you said so ? Please, provide an evidence. Or go through Ghamidi's lectures and help us understand where you think he went wrong. Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
پسندیدہ ہے لازم نہیں آخری جملہ It is liked not compulsory last words Do you know the reality of world if yes then anyone cant ignore to take the cloth to cover his face and head if he is the one which ALLAH wants not likes
@@kanizfatima1377 ma'am ap ya koi aur hijaab kare ya na kare ye apka Personal matter but isko sahi ya galat btana is not your job, so please atleast Deen me koi change na kare whether you follow it or not
@@kanizfatima1377 suppose there is one particular thing in Deen which I am not able to follow but it doesn't mean that I will start modifying Deen as per my convience....
@@fatimanaveed5269 I am not blaming anyone but majority of Muslims ka yahi haal hai ki jab Deen nafs se nhi takrata they can easily practice religion but jaise hi unki nafs samne ati hai they start finding other way around.... Nafs badi cheez hai, bande ko asmaan se farsh tk lekar ati hai
Quran me surah noor me agar Allah keh rahe chehra haat aur pair dikha sakte hain toh, toh kya a cheez farz nahi hogayi.. Such a deceptive scholarship. Hadison me yahan tak kaha gaya hai ke awrath ke sar ke baal satr ka hissa hai.
Where in hadith? I haven't found any. I find Ghamidi sahib's opinion correct based on Quran and saheeh hadith. Please share the ahadeeth u are referring to.
@@utube2005utube hair is also attractive part of the women so he himself quoted that Quranic ayah And tell the believing women to reduce [some] of their vision and guard their private parts and not expose their adornment except that which [necessarily] appears thereof and to wrap [a portion of] their headcovers over their chests and not expose their adornment except to their husbands, their fathers, their husbands' fathers, their sons, their husbands' sons, their brothers, their brothers' sons, their sisters' sons, their women, that which their right hands possess, or those male attendants having no physical desire, or children who are not yet aware of the private aspects of women. And let them not stamp their feet to make known what they conceal of their adornment. And turn to Allah in repentance, all of you, O believers, that you might succeed. surah nur ayah31 Another Hadith where nabi (saws) told summary of Hadith is dont imitate other religion except Islam(until similar verses found in ahle kitab)so why are you copying western way of life or Hindus by showing hair. Another thing if 2 ladies standing both are covering full body except hair, one is Muslim another is mushrik how will you indent her as Muslim?
@@utube2005utube is it that much difficult for u yo study quran and Hadith bhai plz atleast study classical scholars understanding of best generations tabiin and tab tabiin
@@zainulseema455 Apparently, coz u have not provided the references. Again, respectfully, please provide references so I can validate your points which per ur post indicate that Ghamidi sahib got it wrong. I don't claim to know all ahadith so the references would be much appreciated.
Quran 24:31 - "And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and guard their chastity, and not to reveal their adornments1 except what normally appears.2 Let them draw their veils over their chests, and not reveal their ˹hidden˺ adornments3 except to their husbands, their fathers, their fathers-in-law, their sons, their stepsons, their brothers, their brothers’ sons or sisters’ sons, their fellow women, those ˹bondwomen˺ in their possession, male attendants with no desire, or children who are still unaware of women’s nakedness. Let them not stomp their feet, drawing attention to their hidden adornments. Turn to Allah in repentance all together, O believers, so that you may be successful." Footnote - 1 i.e., hair, body shape, and underclothes. Now tell me, how can you argue against the Quran? These are Allah's commands towards the believing women.
Whoever says that hijab/parda is not ‘laazim’ they don’t understand the Arabic language. Allah gave women clear commandments in Surah Nur. Women need to stop believing this fraud and accept Allah’s commandments.
Salam, In Surah Nur, Allah swt commands to cover the chest with the head covering that both man and woman used to wear. That doesn’t mean necessarily that you have to always keep your head covered… Its fard to dress modestly and cover our zina except what it appears and I believe hair falls in that category..:/. Allah swt knows best. I’ll keep searching for the truth but I have this feeling in my heart knowing that when something is fard it is very clear to do certain things and the verse claimed to command women to cover all their hair is not this one in my opinion. May Allah guide me and all muslims through the right path 🤲🏻.
If anyone's a fraud it's you. Allah never gave clear commandments to wear the headscarf. Stop lying. Also its ironic that you're using the word hijab when it doesn't even mean headscarf or anything synonymous. What has been emphasized clearly in surah nur is modesty both clothing and behavior wise
bat to ghamdi sab ki tek hai lakin aj konsi aourat ghar se baghair makeup ki bahair nektalti hai taqreeeban sari to on phar parda lazem hai ghair ma aghar nahi karti to tek hai oder khavand beta bahi bap hota hai maghar bahar lazim hai ha
Ghamdi sb se is parday wale maamly per mera shadeed qisam ka ikhtilaaf hy, quran mai 2 jaga parday ka hukm dia gia hy Allah ki taraf se or ghamdi sb keh rhe hen k parda kren to achi bat hy na kren to koi gunah nahi, deen ko khud parhen or samjhen
This is the 2 nd most watered down version of interpreting this verse that i ‘ve heard till now. 1 st most watered down version of this verse was women can wear crop tops and mini skirts as long as they don’t show their chest 😂 Like if you are going to interpret verses as you like you have no limits
غامدی صاحب کے استاد جن سے موصوف نے تیس سال علم حاصل کیا مولانا امین احسن اصلاحی مرحوم کا تدبر القرآن میں سورۃ الاحزاب کی آیت نمبر 59 کے حوالے سے تفسیر میں فرمانا ہے کہ ۔۔۔۔۔چہرے کا پردہ ضروری ہے یایھا النبی قلا لازوک وبنتک ونساء المومنین یدینین علیھن من جلابیبھن ذلک ادنی ان یعرفن فلا یوذین وکان اللہ غفور رحیما (٥٩ ) منافقین و اشرار کی ایذا رسانیوں سے محفوظ کرنے کے لئے نبی (صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم) کے اہل بیت کو بھی اور عام مسلمان خواتین کو بھی یہ ہدایت کردی گئی کہ جب انہیں کسی ضرورت سے گھروں سے باہر قدم نکالنے کی ضرورت پیش آئے تو وہ اپنی بڑی چادروں کا کچھ حصہ اپنے چہروں پر لٹکا لیا کریں۔ اس طرح ان کے اور دوسری غیر مسلم عورتوں اور لونڈیوں کے درمیان امتیاز ہوجائے گا اور کسی کو ان سے تعرض کے لئے بہانہ ہاتھ نہیں آئے گا۔ سورة نور میں، یاد ہوگا، عزہ و اقربا سے متعلق یہ ہدایت دی گئی ہے کہ جب وہ اجازت کے بعد گھروں میں داخل ہوں گے تو گھر کی خواتین سمٹ سمٹا کر رہیں، اپنی زینت کی چیزوں کا اظہار نہ کرین اور اپنے سینوں پر اپنی اوڑھنیوں کے بکل ما رلیا کریں۔ یہاں یہ ہدایت دی گئی ہے کہ وہ اپنی بڑی چادروں (جلابیب) کا کچھ حصہ اپنے اوپر لٹکا لیا کریں۔ اس کو اپنے لفظوں میں یوں کہہ سکتے ہیں کہ ان بڑی چادروں سے گھونگھٹ نکال لیا کریں۔ یہ واضح قرینہ اس بات کا ہے کہ یہ ہدایت اس صورت سے تعلق ہے جب عورتوں کو کسی ضرورت سے باہر نکلنے کی ضرورت پیش آئے۔ اس قرینہ کی ایک دلیل تو یہ ہے کہ اس کا فائدہ یہ بتایا گیا ہے کہ ’ ذلک ادنی ان یعرفن فلا یوذین ‘ یہ اس بات کے قریب ہے کہ ان کا امتیاز ہوجائے اور اسن سے تعرض نہ کیا جائے) ظاہر ہے کہ یہ مقصد باہر نکلنے ہی کی صورت میں مدنظر ہوسکتا ہے۔ اس کا دوسرا واضح قرینہ یہ ہے کہ یہاں لفظ حماد ’ نہیں بلکہ ‘ جلباب ‘ استعمال ہوا ہے۔ جلباب کی تشریح اہل نعت نے یوں کی ہے کہ ھوالردا فوق الخمار۔ جلباب۔ اس بڑی چادر کو کہتے ہیں جو اوڑھنی کے اوپر لی جاتی ہے۔ ظاہر ہے کہ اس بڑی چادر کے لینے کی ضرورت گھروں کے اندر نہیں پیش آتی تھی بلکہ شرفائے عرب کی خواتی اس وقت اس کو لیتی تھیں جب انہیں گھروں سے باہر نکلنے کی ضرورت پیش آتی۔ شعرائے جاہلیت کے کلام سے یہ بات ثابت ہے کہ شرفائے عرب میں ’ جلباب ‘ کا رواج تھا۔ یہاں بہت سے اشعار نقل کرنے کی گنجائش نہیں ہے۔ قبیلہ ہذیل کی ایک شاعرہ کا ایک شعر ہمارے دعوت کے ثبوت کے لئے کاف ہے۔ وہ اپنے کسی مقتول کے مرثیہ میں کہتی ہے : تمشی السنورالہ وھی لاھیۃ مشی العذاری علیھن الجلابیب اس شعر میں جو نا درتشبیہ ہے اس پر گفتگوکا تو یہاں محل نہیں ہے۔ بات دوسرے گوشوں میں نکل جائے گی۔ بس اتنی بات یاد رکھئے کہ زمانہ جاہلیت میں سب ’ متبجات ‘ اور بیگمات ہی نہیں تھیں بلکہ شرفاء کے خاندانوں کو بہوئیں بیٹیاں بھی تھیں جو باہر نکلنے کی صورت میں اپنی اوڑھنیوں کے اوپر جلباب ڈالا کرتی تھیں۔ قرآن نے اس جلباب سے متعلق یہ ہدایت فرمائی کہ مسلمان خواتین گھروں سے باہر نکلیں تو اس کو کچھ حصہ اپنے اوپر لٹکا لیا کریں تو کہ چہرہ بھی فی الجملہ ڈھک جائے اور انہیں چلنے پھرنے میں بھی زحمت پیش نہ آئے۔ یہی ’ جلباب ‘ ہے جو ہمارے دیہاتوں کی شریف بڑی بوڑھیوں میں اب بھی رائج ہے اور اسی نے فیشن کی ترقی سے اب برقع کی شکل اختیار کرلی ہے۔ اس برقعہ کو اس زمانے کے دالدگانِ تہذیب اگر تہذیب کے خلاف قرار دیتے ہیں تو دیں لیکن قرآن مجید میں اس کا حکم نہایت واضح الفاط میں موجود ہے، جس کا انکار صرف وہی برخود لوگ کرسکتے ہیں جو خدا اور رسول کے زیادہ مہذب ہونے کے مدعی ہوں۔ ’ ذلک ادنی ان یعرفن فلا یوذین۔ یہ مسلمان خواتین کے لئے ایک علامت امتیاز مقرر کردی گئی تاکہ جہاں کہیں بھی وہ نکلیں ہر شخص ان کو دور ہی سے پہچان لے کہ یہ مسلمان خواتی ہیں اور تعرض کی جرأت نہ کرے اور اگر کرے تو اس کے عواقب دور تک سوچ کر کرے۔ اس زمانہ میں مدینہ میں غیر مسلم عورتیں بھی تھیں جن کے ہاں پردہ کی پابندیاں نہیں تھیں نیز لونڈیاں بھی تھیں جن کا معیارِ زندگی اور معیارِ اخلاق دونوں پست تھا اس وجہ سے شریر لوگوں کے لئے عذر کے مواقع بہت تھے۔ اگر وہ کسی مسلمان خاتون پر اہ چلتے کوئی فقرہ چست کرتے یا اس سے کوئی بات کرنے کی کوشش کرتے اور ان پر گرفت ہوتی تو وہ یہ جواب دے دیتے کہ ہم نے سمجھا کہ یہ فلاں کی لونڈی ہے، اور اس سے فلاں بات ہم نے معلوم کرنی چاہی تھی۔ اس علامتِ امتیاز کے قائم ہوجانے کے بعد اس قسم کے بہانوں کی راہ مسدود ہوگئی۔ اس ٹکڑے سے کسی یہ گلط فہمی نہ ہو کہ ایک وقتی تدبیر تھی جو اشرار کے شر سے مسلمان خواتین کو محفوط رکھنے کے لئے اختیار کی گئی اور اب اس کی ضرورت باقی نہیں رہی۔ اول تو احکام جتنے بھی نازل ہوئے ہیں سب محرکات کے تحت ہی نازل ہوئے ہیں لیکن اس کے معنی یہ نہیں ہے کہ وہ محرکات نہ ہوں تو وہ احکام کالعدم ہوجائیں، دوسرے یہ کہ جن حالات میں یہ حکم دیا گیا تھا کیا کوئی ذی ہوش یہ دعویٰ کرسکتا ہے کہ اس زمانے میں حالات کل کی نسبت ہزار درجہ زیادہ خراب ہیں البتہ حیا اور عفت کے وہ تصورات معدوم ہوگئے جن کی تعلیم قرآن نے دی تھی۔ وکان اللہ غفورا رحیما۔ یہ فقرہ اس حکم تسہیل کے لئے ارشاد ہوا ہے۔ مطلب یہ ہے کہ خواتین اپنی ھد تک یہ احتیاط ملحوظ رکھیں۔ اگر اس کے باوجود کوئی بھول چوک ہوگئی تو اللہ غفور رحیم ہے۔
سلطان صلاح الدین ایوبی رحمتہ اللہ علیہ کو انکے جاسوسوں نے بتایا کہ ایک عالمِ دین ہیں جو بہت اچھا خطاب کرتے ہیں لوگوں میں بہت مقبول ہو گئے ہیں۔ سلطان نے کہا آگے کہو جاسوس بولے "کچھ غلط ہے جسے ہم محسوس کر رہے ہیں مگر الفاظوں میں بیان نہیں کرپا رہے" سلطان نے کہا "جو بھی دیکھا اور سنا ہے بیان کرو" جاسوس بولے کہ وہ کہتے ہیں کہ "نفس کا جہاد افضل ہے، بچوں کو تعلیم دینا ایک بہترین جہاد ہے، گھر کی زمہ داریوں کیلئے جد وجہد کرنا بھی ایک جہاد ہے۔ سلطان نے کہا تو اس میں کوئی شک ہے؟؟ جاسوس نے کہا کہ انہیں کوئی شک نہیں لیکن اس عالم کا کہنا ہے کہ: "جنگوں سے کیا ملا؟؟ صرف قتل وغارت گری صرف لاشیں، جنگوں نے تمہیں یا تو قاتل بنایا یا مقتول " سلطان بے چین ہو کر اٹھے، اسی وقت عالم سے ملنے کی ٹھانی، ملاقات بھیس بدل کر کی اور جاتے ہی سوال کردیا کہ "جناب ایسی کوئی ترکیب بتائیے کہ بیت المقدس کو آزاد اور مسلمانوں کے خلاف مظالم کو بغیر جنگ کے ختم کرایا جاسکے؟؟" ، عالم نے کہا دعا کریں سلطان کا چہرہ غصے سے لال ہو گیا، وہ سمجھ چکے تھے کہ یہ عالِم پوری صلیبی فوج سے بھی زیادہ خطرناک ہے سلطان نے سب سے پہلے اپنے خنجر سے اُس عالم کی انگلی کاٹ دی، وہ بری طرح چیخنے لگا۔ اب سلطان نے کہا کہ اصلیت بتاتے ہو یا گردن بھی کاٹ دوں پتہ چلا کہ وہ سفید پوش عالم ایک یہودی تھا، یہودیوں کو عربی بخوبی آتی تھی، جسکا اس نے فائدہ اٹھایا سلطان نے پایا کہ اسکے جیسا درس اب خطبوں میں عام ہو چلا تھا، بڑی مشکل سے یہ فتنہ روکا جاسکا۔ یہ فتنہ اس وقت بھی پوری آب وتاب سے رواں دواں ہے۔ آخر کیوں لوگ اسلام کو بدھ ازم بنا دینا چاہتے ہیں ۔ جبکہ کھلی حقیقت ہے کہ ظالم کا سامنا کئے بغیر ظلم کا مداوا ہوجائے یہ ممکن ہی نہیں۔۔ ghamidi bhi jehad ke khilaf hai
غامدی صاحب اصل میں بہت سے مسائل میں غلطی کا شکار ہیں جس کا ان کو خود بھی نہیں پتا۔ بس اس بات پر زور دیتے ہیں کہ میں نے اپنی کتاب المیزان میں سارے کے سارے دین کو بیان کر دیا ہے۔ کچے ذہن کے لوگ بھی بڑے خوش ہوتے ہیں کہ یار یہ بہت بڑا کام ہے سارے دین کو ایک چھوٹی سی کتاب میں ٹھونس دیا۔ روایتی مولویوں کو کیا پتا دین کا۔
Ghamdi sahab. We can't pick and choose and give our own interpreatation to Quranic clear verdict. It is so simple and clear that women and man should lower their gazes . In ayah 31 of surah Noor Allah ( SWT) addresse believing man to lower their gaze then in ayah # 32 believing women are clearly addreseed to lower their gaze and cover themselves with outer garments. In surah Nisa it is explained as well and surah ahzab too. Allah is in the Hijab and Allah gives women high status by commanding them to cover themselves except for their Mehram. Believing women should be proud of herself by observing pardah. It is mandatory not an option
Ghamidi sahib, aurat k jism mei sb se pehle us k chehre hi pe aik ghair mehram ki nazar jati hai tou phr ye kaise ho skta ha k chehre k parda na ho, logically ye baat zehan mei nahi beithti. jb k Quran ki ayat bhi hai jis k mafhoom hai k apni aurhnion ko sir se neeche phela lo. Tou is k maqsid chehre ko cover krne hi k zumre mei nahi aata?
Just because someone is looking at a womans face do we have to cover it. Ghamdi saab has clearly stated that sharam ghaoon ko dhakligiyay in proper and modest way. A womans face is not what anyone should be attracted to. Both sides should have decency and if man is looking at a womans face when she is following these guidelines then he is committing a sin. Aik aurat ka chehra sharam gha nahi hai kay banday
@@honey0331 First of all, I am not saying k aik aurat k chehra sharamgah hai, I was just talking about obligation of hijab. Also either woman is following guideline or not, man would always be sinner if he looks at a woman. Also, most astonishing & latest fact for me is the statement that no one is attracted to a woman face, really surprising. My bottom line question was simple in context of Surah Noor verse which says to women to stretch down their scarf aur dupattas (audhnian). Doesn't this verse points to obligation of hijab?
Hijab and scarf are very important for the grownup girls and women. Khimar which is mentioned in Quran is nothing else but Hijab Hadiths about hijab With regard to the Ahadith : It was narrated from Safiyyah bint Shaybah that ‘Aishah (may Allah be pleased with her) used to say: When these words were revealed - “and to draw their veils all over Juyubihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms)” - they took their izars (a kind of garment) and tore them from the edges and covered their faces with them. Narrated by al-Bukhari, 4481.
khimer is mentined in a sense of covering chest which is compulsory but not for the head , if you read the full verse you will understand the context, So if women can cover their chest with any cloth that will do the work but Quran never says it should be use to cover head as well
@@iic2689 Khimar comes from the word "khamr" which means an intoxicant, and guess what an intoxicant does? It messes with your head. Literally. How can you say this doesn't mean head up as well? Also, if it's only the chest that is to be covered up, then later on it says this covering up is not necessary in front of mahram, so will you not wear anything covering your upper body in front of your father/brother etc? Of course not. This clearly refers to the hijab.
@@huzaifatahir5738 where i said Khimer doesnt mean head? read my comment again i was saying Quran mentioned khimar in a sense to cover chest part meaning Quran is not ordering to cover your head but actually Quran is saying Cover your chest by using the cloth of your head since the best way to cover chest is to use the cloth that usually women has on their head so thats why Quran use the word khimar ,,, this verse is not ordering the head cover it order is about chest cover using cloth that usually women use to cover their head مِنْهَا ۖ وَلْيَضْرِبْنَ بِخُمُرِهِنَّ عَلَىٰ جُيُوبِهِنَّ ۖ Let them draw their [ head ]veils over their chests. // later on it says this covering up is not necessary in front of mahram, so will you not wear anything covering your upper body in front of your father/brother etc? // when someone says to any women to put y veil on chest does it means she was naked before? obviously not , she already wear a dress that covers her body on that Quran sis demanding women to add one more piece of cloth on your chest apart from your dress covering
@@iic2689 So you agree with me then. If the verse says it's a head cover that should go over the chest, then it's already a given that the head cover is compulsory. That doesn't need to be stated. Where do you get this view from, by the way? Ghamidi is a contemporary, and the ijmaa of the scholars of the past was that at the minimum hijab is compulsory, with differences of opinion on the niqab.
@@huzaifatahir5738 i never disagree on "khimer mean head" what i was saying is totally different thing that you didnt get , having a name khamir doesnt indicate the ruling about head covering is compulsory in Islam ,, read whole verse or sentence atleast, the rule is about covering chest and in order to do that Allah is saying just use the cloth that is on your head to cover your chest ,,, it means having a cloth on head was already a tradition in arab just like right now it is and in many other deserts Quran is just saying to use that cloth to cover chest as well ... Quran didnt mention to cover head or its compulsory.
ghamidi saab se pehle jitne bhi muhaddiseen ,mufassareen , auliya , ulema etc kisi ko deen samjh nahi aaya bas ye samjhe hain asal deen ......Allah hidayat de
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 kaun se aalim ,ulema ne bola tha bhai ??? naam batana zara ?? Ulema to daari rakhne k liyen bolte hain bhai wo baat humne maan li kyunki Rasulullah sallallahu wa alaiyehewasallam ki beard thi ,or ulemao ne music sunne ko mana kiya to wo bhi chhor diya .......achcha bhai engineer ali mirza to abhi aaya hain, aap k bade to ulemao ko or aalimo ki sunte honge kiya wo sex slave rakhte the ??????? bhai bura mat manna tumne misaal ghalazat waali di to wohi pooch rhaa hun bas , samjhane k liyen
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 aap koi hawala to den ??? jinke aapne naam liyen hain waise unhe engineer saab babbon mein shumaar nahi karte ,yeh to wo log hain jinke zariye deen sahabon k baad seena b seena laya gaya or mehfooz kawaya gaya ....😀😀😀
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 arre mere bhai aap ghair muslim ho kiya ?????? ye arab k culture tha , jisko baad mein forbid kar diya gaya , ye sab baatein kaafir usr karte hain islam ko or nabi ko defame karne k liyen , khair baat ho rahi hai babao ki jinka aapne naam kiya , bukhari ,shafai ,malik etc ...unhone kab kaha ki aap cocubines rakh sakte hain ,, Apne jo bhi hawale diyen hain woh direct sahab or nabi Allah k taraf se hain .... to aapke hisaab se cocubines are still allowed ??
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 bhai unhone jayaz kab kaha ?????or mein to jahil aadmi hun bhai bas itna janta hun mein us mozu ko bilkul touch nahi karta jisper baat karna behad fizool ho , issue aapne chher diya or abhi tak ye pata nahi chala ya misaal aapne di kyun ??? jabiki ye masail bilkul aam majlis mein karne k nahi hai .....per lagta hai aap bahut bade aalim hai headscraf bhi lagana zarorri nahi hai , parde k hukm hai ya usse bhi faarigh ho jaayen hum ???? ye or bata dijiye ,beard ki to zaroorat hi nahi hai ghamidi saab ne bata diya or bataiye kiya kiya chhorna hai
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 agar abu jehal ki bhi daadi thi to Aap ne kyun rakhi ??? ya yun kahen ki daadi itni zaroori hai ki abu jehal bhi rakhta tha ........aap kaafi azad khayal maloom hote hain hazrat mein parde k baare mein itna janta hun ki parda to poori aurat k hai .........or daadi to mere bhai javed ghamidi k alawa , saare nabiyon ki saare sahabaon ki saare tabaeen ki ,taba tabaeen ki , har maslak k ulemao ki rahi hai or rahegi in sha Allah , Aap cleavage chhipwayen bas humein aurton ko poora dhankne k mamla karne den ,aakhirat k mamla hai bhai , or taqwa bhi koi cheez hoti hai ......bina beard waale imamo k peeche namaz padhte hain aap??? ohh per bina beard waale imam to milta bhi nahi hoga masjid mein 😁😁😁😁😁bhai maaf kar dena per mein ulemao ki badi izzat karta hun ,or javed sab or aap mujhe bilkul ek jaise lagte hain bas javed saab k mutalla bada hai ......Allah hidayat k muamla kare
He very conviniently misinterprets things written in Quran and then propagate it with all his confidence. For concerned people, plz do watch a short video clip of Dr Israr Ahmed on the same topic on you tube "Chahray ka parda".
Can you please elaborate how you think that Ghamdi saab is "conveniently misinterpreting" and "propagating" his teachings. Learn to control your language rather than enforcing stamps on people according to your wishes. If you think he is wrong than no need to stay here. Move on.
@@JB-su6wt i just did and nothing that he is saying is backed up by verses from the Quran or hadith.that being said I don't disagree with some of the things that he says but Allah kami paeshi maaf karat but he uses more poetry enhancing and overly sexualizing woman's face and other parts and the way he speaks in general is not appeasing. A Muslim should cover modestly, respectful to themselves aswell and both men and women should not look at each other with bad intentions. How can some one change the verses in Quran and take out meanings that suits them best is quite an insane idea to me. Please watch Ghamdi saabs whole lecture so that you can get an idea of what he is saying. And my question to you was not about womans hijab it was about the parts that were propagated and misinterpreted. Try to understand the jist of the question
Why all the muslim scholars all over the world are in agreement with the issues of hijab,sood,sharab and music but he is the only one scholar who has altogether different openion on every issue.Even the scholars who are arabs are not able to comprehend these issues correctly in the light of Quran as he does....confusion🤔
Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
@@FirstAnalysis all muslims in the world huh? Lmfaoooo you're islamiphobic and clearly haven't met any muslims in real life. Most of us are wonderful people.
Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
@@FirstAnalysis I have viewed all his lectures. I am well read in religion. He is clearly thinking in liberal paradigm. Liberalism itself is a religion of sorts. Watch Mohammad Hijab on liberalism for better understanding the poison of liberalism.
Well Allah has commanded the azwaaj e muteheraat to cover their faces in Quran, so we have to follow them, those holy women were far more respectable than we are, if they did so we will too cover our faces
You're disgusting as hell. The Quran doesn't confirm your corrupted desires. The Quran explicitly emphasizes modesty but doesn't even say to cover the head "and" that it is compulsory
Hijab is mandated, can't argue with it. Enough proof of it in graded Hadith. This world is not for our pleasure, even marriage isn't for our pleasure because we can't do certain sexual things even with our wives, so we are repressed in that sense, but this repression is for the greater goal : Jannah. Where there will be no repression.
@Ali Siddiqui The rules of modesty are legislated and ordained by Allah, not dictated by the whims of people. the word Khimar is used in th Quran and expanded upon in the Sahih Hadith.
@Ali Siddiqui it actually does, have you even read hadith? Or is it because you're personally against the idea of a woman wearing one because your nafs doesn't like it
Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
This scholar is propagating a deviant teaching about hijab. Sadly his knowledge is a curse for him. He is an example of those people of knowledge about whom Allah warned us: Have you seen he who has taken as his god his [own] desire, and Allāh has sent him astray due to knowledge and has set a seal upon his hearing and his heart and put over his vision a veil? So who will guide him after Allāh?” No one sobhanak.
استغفراللّٰہ آپ کی کوئی بھی بات قرآن و حدیث کے مطابق نہیں صحابیات آج کی عورت کی نسبت بلکل سادہ رہتی تھیں مگر پھر بھی پورے پردے میں ہوتی تھیں آپ نے ایک غلط ترغیب دے کے اللہ کے عذاب کو دعوت دی ہے اللہ سے معافی مانگیں
I have a question for you.Mr. Ghamidi what is the meaning of Khimaar.I think you don't know,people like you are changing islam but believe me put everything you have into your fitna but you can't change the word of God.
You can disagree with him. However, you can't claim any such things without evidence. Because a sahih hadis declares spreading news without authentication a lie and im Holy Quran, Allah curses those who lie. So provide some evidences.
@@hamaidmk hahahaha... Taliban to wo hai Jo tm jaise napak logon ko smjh na ayega... Q ki tme to aurat nangi chahiye bazaron me... Hme to izzt k sath aurat ko rkhni hai ghr mai... Tmre papa America ne v toh aab Taliban ko aabu keh rhe
@@hamaidmk Surah 24:31, telling women to guard their private parts and draw their khimār over their bosoms. Khimar includes covering head in the meaning . For more info refer th-cam.com/video/AALgGKSnU2g/w-d-xo.html by nouman ali khan for arabic meanings.
@@hamaidmk bhai aap apni zaaban par ghor karain. Aap jaise auraton kay baray mai baat kar rahain hair, saaf zahir ho raha hai kay aap kitni izat kartain hain ghar mai rakh kar apni auratein.
I have watched his videos as I watch every other scholars but what I noticed is he misinterpreted Islam by his own will he uses verses then twist them in the way he wants and make Islam so liberal and free no doubt he is an educated person but I swear he is not a right scholar don't follow what he says
Ek ayat to pesh kr dya kro quraan ki sirf qayasi aur acchi baaten karte ho aurato ko behaya banana chahte ho ghamdi saheb Ap Quran ar hadees ke munkir ho
Akram Ali LOL the claim is being made by you.. so apki zimdari hai kaa proof dain. Koi ayat bayaan karen jahan Allah pak naa hukam diya hoo kaa hijab(face covering) har aurat par lazim hai.. jaisa Allah naa roza, zakat, hajj farz kia hain aur clearly mention ki hai.. pls show me. Behaya jisna hona hai wo burqa mein bhi ba haya hoti hain... jaaa kar mohallo mein dekho, kisi aurat ke haaya aur ba hayai hijab sa nhi paida hoti.. baharhaal aurton ko chahiye kaa aisa libaas pehanain jo vulgar naa hoo, koi body part visible naa hoo, khoola khoola kapra pehanain.. Kitni burqa wali pakri jaati hain hotel saa? Pata hoga apko.. hayaa kapron saa nhi, zehaniyat saa ati hai Munki janaab ap lag rahe hoo Quran kaa.. kiyon kaa Allah naa quran mein farmaya hai ka kisi ko judge krna galat hai.. Allah apko aur mujhe hidyat daa
The verses of Quran being quoted simply mean that it's good to wear it. If we see, for the things that are prohibited in the Quran, there are then warnings given about hell and how's theyll be punished. This surah was revealed because the Muslim women at that time were being harassed. If Allah dislike women not wearing hijab that much then he'd also write that he curses those women or something along the lines of that
No punishment for men who gaze at women sexually, either.
Nicely explained
Beautiful! I think more than his argument, his way of saying things attracts me more.
Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning):
“O Prophet! Tell your wives and your daughters and the women of the believers to draw their cloaks (veils) all over their bodies (i.e. screen themselves completely except the eyes or one eye to see the way). That will be better, that they should be known (as free respectable women) so as not to be annoyed. And Allaah is Ever Oft‑Forgiving, Most Merciful”
[al-Ahzaab 33:59]
Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: “Allaah commanded the believing women, if they go out of their houses for some need, to cover their faces from the top of their heads with their jilbaabs, and to leave one eye showing.”
Nowadays women get harassed for wearing the hijab lol
@@ashley_brown6106 i think you need to see the surveys held by your father countries that how islam's order to khimaar for women protect them from harrasment.I think people like you and Mr.Ghamidi can do anything to get certificate from west that they are liberalised nation.
@sadaf You added the text in brackets by yourself it’s not part of translation
@@sumairayasmin8868 im not qualified or brave enough to do so
@@ashley_brown6106 yes like France
Head covering is not made compulsory in Quran
Mashallah
Surah ahzab ,verse 59...plzz lection on
Brother you will get your answer in thi debate with clear content of Surah Ahzab.
th-cam.com/video/4IJnR-OdInA/w-d-xo.html
@@AbdulRehman-qm2py जज़ाकल्लाह भाई मैंने वो डिबेट मुकम्मल सुनी जिसका आपने लिंक दिया है।
اَلنُّوْر: 24 آیت :31
وَ قُلْ لِّلْمُؤْمِنٰتِ یَغْضُضْنَ مِنْ اَبْصَارِهِنَّ وَ یَحْفَظْنَ فُرُوْجَهُنَّ وَ لَا یُبْدِیْنَ زِیْنَتَهُنَّ اِلَّا مَا ظَهَرَ مِنْهَا وَ لْیَضْرِبْنَ بِخُمُرِهِنَّ عَلٰى جُیُوْبِهِنَّ۪-وَ لَا یُبْدِیْنَ زِیْنَتَهُنَّ اِلَّا لِبُعُوْلَتِهِنَّ اَوْ اٰبَآىٕهِنَّ اَوْ اٰبَآءِ بُعُوْلَتِهِنَّ اَوْ اَبْنَآىٕهِنَّ اَوْ اَبْنَآءِ بُعُوْلَتِهِنَّ اَوْ اِخْوَانِهِنَّ اَوْ بَنِیْۤ اِخْوَانِهِنَّ اَوْ بَنِیْۤ اَخَوٰتِهِنَّ اَوْ نِسَآىٕهِنَّ اَوْ مَا مَلَكَتْ اَیْمَانُهُنَّ اَوِ التّٰبِعِیْنَ غَیْرِ اُولِی الْاِرْبَةِ مِنَ الرِّجَالِ اَوِ الطِّفْلِ الَّذِیْنَ لَمْ یَظْهَرُوْا عَلٰى عَوْرٰتِ النِّسَآءِ۪-وَ لَا یَضْرِبْنَ بِاَرْجُلِهِنَّ لِیُعْلَمَ مَا یُخْفِیْنَ مِنْ زِیْنَتِهِنَّؕ-وَ تُوْبُوْۤا اِلَى اللّٰهِ جَمِیْعًا اَیُّهَ الْمُؤْمِنُوْنَ لَعَلَّكُمْ تُفْلِحُوْنَ(۳۱)
اور مسلمان عورتوں کو حکم دو کہ وہ اپنی نگاہیں کچھ نیچی رکھیں اور اپنی پارسائی کی حفاظت کریں اور اپنی زینت نہ دکھائیں مگر جتنا (بدن کاحصہ) خود ہی ظاہر ہے اور وہ اپنے دوپٹے اپنے گریبانوں پر ڈالے رکھیں اور اپنی زینت ظاہر نہ کریں مگر اپنے شوہروں پر یا اپنے باپ یا شوہروں کے باپ یا اپنے بیٹوں یا شوہروں کے بیٹے یا اپنے بھائیوں یا اپنے بھتیجوں یا اپنے بھانجوں یا اپنی (مسلمان) عورتوں یا اپنی کنیزوں پر جو ان کی ملکیت ہوں یامردوں میں سے وہ نوکر جو شہوت والے نہ ہوں یا وہ بچے جنہیں عورتوں کی شرم کی چیزوں کی خبر نہیں اور زمین پر اپنے پاؤں اس لئے زور سے نہ ماریں کہ ان کی اس زینت کا پتہ چل جائے جو انہوں نے چھپائی ہوئی ہے اور اے مسلمانو! تم سب اللہ کی طرف توبہ کرو اس امید پر کہ تم فلاح پاؤ۔
Does Allah command it Yes or No. There no middle way going into it especially if its mentioned in quran. More focus should be on the meaning of aayat and context. No need to rationalizing this with biases first. Rationalizing is the second step not the first. Text is the first step sir.
Aur kya logic hai jab aaraish zabaish kare tab haath aur head cover kare. Yeh kahan likha hai . Sir sirf aapka opinion sunne nahi aaye hai quran aur hadees se islamic answer sunne aaye hai phir opinion. Jo jab convenient ho woh baat kyun karen.
Aur yeh kaunn decide karega ab exposure zyada ho raha hai. Aap apne intelligence pe sab chod rahe hai par Allah ki intelligence aur hukm pe kam focus kar rahe hai. Hamari judgement society ke standard ke saath change hoti hai. American school main shorts pehenna decent aur modest hota hai . Par woh point nahi hai . Point quran aur hadees ka hai.
So why are you watching this short clip. Ghamdi saab has full lecture going into full detail and depth. Why not watch those rather than commenting and criticising?
@@honey0331 I am not watching this . I am critiquing him.
@@naumankhan422 but the question still stands, have you watched the lectures that are available on TH-cam and on the site, before coming and "critiquing" him.
@@honey0331 stop being a bhakt . If you don't have any thing substantial to say.
How do I know if Quran is talking about the "mustahabaat or nafl" and not the obligation?
I need all the captions in text please!!!!!
Same
Bilkul sahi kaha ghamidi sahab ap ne..hum Quran ko samjh h nai pae abi tk.isko rasam o riwaj se elahada nai KR pae
To bhai ye apka masla hai ...
Ap abhi tk kyu nhi samajh paye????
Kisko blame kar rhe hai isper jakar samajhiye
Alhamdulillah aj to sab kuch available hai
@@mohddanishsiddiqui1694 o bhai ankhein khol k parh msg..blame to kisi ko kia h nai.bilawaja logo ko larne ki adat hoti hai
@@mmmm7656 🤗
@@mmmm7656 bhai Ramzan hai main ladna nhi chah rha hu sorry bhai
Zohar ki namaz padne ke baad karte hai ok bro
Tumhare hisab se 1400 sal Tak koi samajh nahin paye ghamdi ke siba😂😂😂
And tell the believing women to reduce [some] of their vision and guard their private parts and not expose their adornment except that which [necessarily] appears thereof and to wrap [a portion of] their headcovers over their chests and not expose their adornment except to their husbands, their fathers, their husbands' fathers, their sons, their husbands' sons, their brothers, their brothers' sons, their sisters' sons, their women, that which their right hands possess, or those male attendants having no physical desire, or children who are not yet aware of the private aspects of women. And let them not stamp their feet to make known what they conceal of their adornment. And turn to Allah in repentance, all of you, O believers, that you might succeed.
The Glorious Qur'an Surah Ahzab : 31
This ayat is from Surah Noor not Ahzab
@CookieDough My dear Cookie,
1. The word '*Hijab*' is not present in Quran; but the words '*jilbab*'(www.google.com/search?q=jilbab&oq=jilbab&aqs=chrome..69i57&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8) , '*khimar*'(www.google.com/search?q=khimar&oq=khimar&aqs=chrome..69i57&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8) and others; Altogether the meaning is '*Covering*' or '*Curtain*' in such a way that only face, wrists and feet are exposed.
2. The Quran itself cannot be taken as full understanding of manners. So, hadith must also be taken into consideration. There ample of hadith which relates to the above explanation of '*jilbab*' and/or '*khimar*'. Besides that, we must also take the life sahaba (The companions of Prophet swt) if one cannot understand.
The above are the metrics based on which the society norms are established. The modern word is '*Hijab*' which simply mean '*dresscode*'. So, there are several implementations of hijab ranging from Turkey and Azerbaijan in Caucasus, Saudi and others in Arab, Pakistan, India and others in South Asia, and many more regions as per their understands.
3.If you think the meaning only *covering* but no head cover or any other then a women can hide only vagina and show everything else. In hotels, at home, office, schools and also on streets; one can even forget clothes to wear and think of hijab as a psychological covering, Ultimately promote nude culture.
in short, don't fool yourself!
@Ali Siddiqui parda farz hai baqi bkwas band kr
@Ali Siddiqui lagta hai apki maa bhene mohalla ki behaya besharam aurto mei se hai
@Ali Siddiqui tum kafir banjao to behtr hai bhai...Parda farz hai Ghamdi kon hota hai ye kehne wala..hamare nabi(صل الله وعليه وسلم)ne jab farma diya to baat khatam...Fatima(رضى الله عنها) ne farmaya jb mera janaza uthe to raat ko uthaya jaye takai meri mayyat pr bhi kisi gheir mard ki nazar na pare..(mafhoom)...aur tum Log kehte ho parda farz nhi..wah wah ye deen tmhre baap ka nhi samjh ii
Where does Allah says in quran that cover the face
It was in surah ahzaab about covering face for nabi ki wife's and for the wife's and daughter's of believers. But this in my language
أَعـوذُ بِاللهِ مِنَ الشَّيْـطانِ الرَّجيـم
بِسْمِ اللّٰهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ
يٰۤـاَيُّهَا النَّبِىُّ قُلْ لِّاَزۡوَاجِكَ وَبَنٰتِكَ وَنِسَآءِ الۡمُؤۡمِنِيۡنَ يُدۡنِيۡنَ عَلَيۡهِنَّ مِنۡ جَلَابِيۡبِهِنَّ ؕ ذٰ لِكَ اَدۡنٰٓى اَنۡ يُّعۡرَفۡنَ فَلَا يُؤۡذَيۡنَ ؕ وَكَانَ اللّٰهُ غَفُوۡرًا رَّحِيۡمًا
القرآن - سورۃ 33 - الأحزاب - آیت 59.
اس کی وضاحت فرمائیں
Mashallah Allah has blessed us with a great scholar Ghamdi saab. Everything he says is backed up with so much information and knowledge from Quran. The Quran is such a beautiful book the perfect guide for all Muslim ummah. Islam itself is such a simple and idealistic religion that has been distorted by so many of many of our traditional scholars who boil it all down to their own satisfaction and desires backed up by nothing but their stupid and non sensible idiocracies. May Allah guide everybody to the straight path. AMEEN
Ghamidi sahab magribiyat or liberalism k manhaj se bht mar-oob nazar aate hain. Unhune insanu k banaye huye human rights charter k mutabiq deen ko samajhne ki koshish ki hai jaise... Unke bht se arguments qabil qadr hain lekin pardah, nizam-e riyasat-e islami, nuzool e Isa AS, aur hadees ki hasiyat ko leke woh bht kamzor ladi pe khade hain... Women empowerment k naam pe jo be pardagi feli hui hai Ghamidi sahab usko silently endorse karte nazar aate hain... Unki majlis main nange sir auraten hoti hain... Kaash ki woh unko kam se kam ye bolte ki iss cheez main zabardasti agar nahi ki jasakti lekin pardah baharhal aik bht bada hukum hai shariat ka jiski hukme udooli aik gunah hai. Lekin afsoos... Libaeralism ki fikar se mar-oob loug Ghamidi sahab ko hujjat mante hain... I would recommend such liberal muslims who want to stay at the boundary for protecting their dunya, to watch Mohammad Hijab's philosophical deconstruction of liberalism. Liberalism is like religion. A muslim can not be liberal. He can only be a muslim. However, that doesn't mean a muslim has to be intolerant. Islam has better moral guidelines for co-existence than Liberalism. Lakum deenukum wa lia deen.
@@sophosalpha A muslim who decides to follow the path of Allah in a righteous way, and has a strong understanding of the principles and fundamentals of Islam and doesn't like to blindly follow the teaching of others without analysing for themselves what is right and wrong is not a person following a liberist path. I am sorry but if you want to label someone liberist and following maghrib propaganda for understanding and implementing guidance of Allah swt.tallah should point a finger at themselves rather than others. When you dont agree with someone and their teaching you do not need to go against them in a comment section just ignore them but if you really care about the fact that so many people follow Ghamdi saabs teachings then you confront him and seek out what it is that bothers you so much about his ways. If you have enough confidence and want to prove him wrong ( which he is completely open to) then go through his lectures do your research, find out what it is that you are labelling liberism and then confront him. Trolling people and putting irrelevant and unwanted reply is not the solution.
@@honey0331 I have watched all his lectures on TH-cam. I have not trolled him. Don't you see i use Ghamidi Sahab. I didn't use abusive words. ! What makes you think I am trolling him. If you have read Quran and Hadith, you can't deny that Ghamidi sahab is very selective in taking hadith. He says darul ulooms and madrassahs teach terrorism. He ,being well versed in social science, ignores politics and blames religion and madrassahs. Let me give you an example. In India, despite a strong anti-muslim propaganda done by hindu right wing outfits against islam and frequent killings of muslims, we don't see madrassah students waging jihad!!!. Even in Kashmir, no local madrassah students have joined militancy! Most militants in Kashmir are university and college passouts!! Ghamidi sahab's allegations on madrassah's are baseless. You must read Robert Pape on how terrorism is linked to politics of occupation. In Pakistan, it was the combined political manipulation of madrassahs by State along with US and Saudi Arabia to fight Afghan jihad which lead to where you are now. Madrassahs per se had nothing to do with jihad or terrorism whatever you want to call it.
Another thing that is worth mentioning is the ideology of groups like Al Qaeda and ISIS. That ideology is denounced by all muslim scholars. First and foremost by Arab salafis like those following Baaz and Uthaymen who are thought to be advocates of the stictest version of Islam(salafism)!!. The point is such violent groups have risen more because of oil based American interventions in the middle east and occupation of Palestine by Israel. You see Politics!
But Ghamidi sahab gives convenient answers and blames madrassahs which is preposterous.
Which Ayath of the Quran and Hadith did he quote then in this video??? Answer: None. You can reject ALLAH's Word Of Quran and accept his words in this video . But, if ypu accept his words then surely you will answer to ALLAH
@@hrashid4222 other videos me btaya ha yr .. ye bht short clip ha
nice explained but against the concept of Quran. if you believe that Quran is a historical book then you will have this meaning ...."ager koi kerly to achi baat hai wagerna lazmi nahi hai"
when did ghamidi say it is a historical book ?
he said hadiths are historical records
Quran me aurat ka sar cover karne ka zikar waqai me aik baar b nahi aya. Muhazib libaas ka he aya hay. Sar aur chehray ka lafz aik dfa b nahi hay
parda farz hai
@@ScienceadobyDrEishal thora sa khud bhi research kerlaty ap to achi baat hoti
Her bt scholers ki ankh band ker kay nahi manni chaheay thora khud bhi quran khol k perhna chaheay kay Allah n rasool kay kia ahkamaat han
Quran me Allah surah ahzab ayat 59 me fermata hay
اے نبی! اپنی بیبیوں اور صاحبزادیوں اور مسلمانوں کی عورتوں سے فرما دو کہ اپنی چادروں کا ایک حصہ اپنے منہ پر ڈالے رہیں یہ اس سے نزدیک تر ہے کہ ان کی پہچان ہو تو ستائی نہ جائیں اور اللہ بخشنے والا مہربان ہے ،
@@easyartwithfizza257 different scholars have translated it differently. When you read the English translation, there is no mention of covering the face. It talks about how Muslim women should cover their chest (which is common sense). Again, you need to read multiple translations.
Good
Ghamidi sb se sawal hy k is ayat ka kia mafhoom hy????? Agr parda orat ne apni marzi se krna hy to is ayat ka kia matlab hy??
Masha Allah
ہمارے ہاں عورتیں آرائش۔ زیبائش کے بغیر گھر کے باہر قدم نہیں نکالتی
That is exactly what Quran says... Do not show yourself to the world with "makeup" or jewlery.... but quran clearly sets the minimum requirements for all muslims men & women equally. We tend to wrongly misunderstand sorah Ahzab (ayat 59) that was for a particular event and for particular individuals not for the general public......... Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
Zbrdsttt
First he says that covering is mandatory but then he says its not if the woman hasnt worked on herself? What does that even mean?
Ghamdi shab Allah apko salamt rakha ap ikhtilaf Ray ko bht Acha andz ma address krta magr Hazrat prda orat k lia farz e aein ha, surah ehzab ma tamam muslman Orton ko prda k hukam h akhr ya kesa mumkin, us dor ki Orton k lia ya tha or ajj ni, dunia ki behtreen Orton na dunia k behtreen mrdon(shaba) sa prda kia to ajj k mashra ghan hr traf fitna prda kesa farz ni hoga???
App apna ik bayan ma frma rha tha k chand obashon ki wjah sa us time hukam aya to kia ajj dunia sa Sara obash khtm ho ga hn???
Rie bt apka is muwaquf ko appreciate krna ki to hr Wo Mard orat Jo prda sa rah e farar hasal krna chata Wo zarur apka is muwaquf ki taied krn ga....
Ghan bhe orat Mard k azadana ikhtilat hoga whan ya sb hoga Jo ajjj hmara mashra ma ho rha
اَلْاَحْزَاب: 33 آیت 59
یٰۤاَیُّهَا النَّبِیُّ قُلْ لِّاَزْوَاجِكَ وَ بَنٰتِكَ وَ نِسَآءِ الْمُؤْمِنِیْنَ یُدْنِیْنَ عَلَیْهِنَّ مِنْ جَلَابِیْبِهِنَّؕ-ذٰلِكَ اَدْنٰۤى اَنْ یُّعْرَفْنَ فَلَا یُؤْذَیْنَؕ-وَ كَانَ اللّٰهُ غَفُوْرًا رَّحِیْمًا(۵۹)
اے نبی!اپنی بیویوں اور اپنی صاحبزادیو ں اور مسلمانوں کی عورتوں سے فرمادو کہ اپنی چادروں کا ایک حصہ اپنے او پر ڈالے رکھیں ، یہ اس سے زیادہ نزدیک ہے کہ وہ پہچانی جائیں تو انہیں ستایا نہ جائے اور اللہ بخشنے والا مہربان ہے۔
Death is reallty plz learn Quran
@@kanizfatima1377 why do some muslim women hate allah's law
Will i get sinned if i decide I don't wanna wear a hijab?
Man dont wear hijab bro...🤣
Ghamidi has clearly answered this many many times. Hijab is not Islamic ... it was added to muslim after Islam faced conservatory pressures due to sudden dissasters.... Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
I am afraid if one decides to neglect and follow his desire. Do so but beware that he is openly defying Allah عز و جل orders and not following the injunctions of our beloved prophet Mohammad ﷺ
@@FirstAnalysis no sir you need to read the the Quran and Hadith and form your opinion. Openly defying Allah عز و جل orders and not following prophet ﷺ and his companions is if following your own desire.
La hawla wala quatta ilah billah
Ghamdi sahb keh rahe hn k her bahir nikalni wali aurat ko parda krna chahey q k aj kal her aurar make up k sath e bshir nikalti he.
He’s right the word “hijaab” isn’t even in the quran
Assalamualaikum
It is there
Sura AHZAB : 53
@@haqirfan1382 well the word is there but you’ve presented an out of context verse, if you read the translation, it’s referring to this
“But Allah is never shy of the truth. And when you ˹believers˺ ask his wives for something, ask them from behind a barrier.”
Hijaab is used here for the word barrier not to instruct women to wear head coverings, hope that makes sense now
What hijab means is our goal not the word
When we are said to ask over the hijaab it means there is not any proof to come infront of me
@@haqirfan1382 no it means to NOT stand in front of the prophets wives without a barrier
This is basic understanding
How you dare to misinterpret Quran
Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
Excellent explanation. It all goes back to the reason/intent behind these directions as per the Quran. Living in the West, I cannot tell you how many times I have seen Muslim females wearing hijabs but then also wearing skin tight clothing! Now go figure.
Orat ek hi soorat mai nahi pehchani jati jb us ne chehray per naqab ya chadar ki hoti hy,
Bhai parda karna hal main surah azaab 59 main likha hai
Category ki Kia baat hai sahb. Parda musalman awraton k liye farz hai.jab koi gher muslim awrat musalman hoja ti hai to sab se pehli wo hijab ki paband nazar aati hai.
I did not get it.u should cover your head and hair or it is not obligatory?
It is surely obligatory face hair should be covered
@@muhammadattaurrahman1138 is that what is he saying?
@@centric145 No
Asma, daughter of AbuBakr, entered upon the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) wearing thin clothes. The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) turned his attention from her. He said: O Asma', when a woman reaches the age of menstruation, it does not suit her that she displays her parts of body except this and this, and he pointed to his face and hands.
Abu Dawud said: This is a mursal tradition (i.e. the narrator who transmitted it from 'Aishah is missing) Khalid b. Duraik did not see 'Aishah.
Grade: Sahih (Al-Albani)
Hijab aur parda Allah ka hukm hai .
Because you said so ? Please, provide an evidence. Or go through Ghamidi's lectures and help us understand where you think he went wrong. Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
@@FirstAnalysis
Read quran with authentic translation and book of seerah ..you will get you answer ..
Islam is what in the quran and seerah ..
Salam aap par🫡🫡
Khana Doulat aur Aurat ke liye parda Zaruri Hai.....
پسندیدہ ہے لازم نہیں آخری جملہ
It is liked not compulsory last words
Do you know the reality of world if yes then anyone cant ignore to take the cloth to cover his face and head if he is the one which ALLAH wants not likes
It's only ignorance and this man is only satisfying his audience, may Allah give me hidayat
Yes exactly
@@kanizfatima1377 ma'am ap ya koi aur hijaab kare ya na kare ye apka Personal matter but isko sahi ya galat btana is not your job, so please atleast Deen me koi change na kare whether you follow it or not
@@kanizfatima1377 suppose there is one particular thing in Deen which I am not able to follow but it doesn't mean that I will start modifying Deen as per my convience....
@@fatimanaveed5269 I am not blaming anyone but majority of Muslims ka yahi haal hai ki jab Deen nafs se nhi takrata they can easily practice religion but jaise hi unki nafs samne ati hai they start finding other way around....
Nafs badi cheez hai, bande ko asmaan se farsh tk lekar ati hai
Your comment seems more ignorant.
Quran me surah noor me agar Allah keh rahe chehra haat aur pair dikha sakte hain toh, toh kya a cheez farz nahi hogayi.. Such a deceptive scholarship. Hadison me yahan tak kaha gaya hai ke awrath ke sar ke baal satr ka hissa hai.
Where in hadith? I haven't found any. I find Ghamidi sahib's opinion correct based on Quran and saheeh hadith. Please share the ahadeeth u are referring to.
@@utube2005utube hair is also attractive part of the women so he himself quoted that Quranic ayah
And tell the believing women to reduce [some] of their vision and guard their private parts and not expose their adornment except that which [necessarily] appears thereof and to wrap [a portion of] their headcovers over their chests and not expose their adornment except to their husbands, their fathers, their husbands' fathers, their sons, their husbands' sons, their brothers, their brothers' sons, their sisters' sons, their women, that which their right hands possess, or those male attendants having no physical desire, or children who are not yet aware of the private aspects of women. And let them not stamp their feet to make known what they conceal of their adornment. And turn to Allah in repentance, all of you, O believers, that you might succeed.
surah nur ayah31
Another Hadith where nabi (saws) told summary of Hadith is dont imitate other religion except Islam(until similar verses found in ahle kitab)so why are you copying western way of life or Hindus by showing hair.
Another thing if 2 ladies standing both are covering full body except hair, one is Muslim another is mushrik how will you indent her as Muslim?
@@zainulseema455 I don't think u understand my question. No need to quote the hadith. Please provide the reference. Book and hadith #.
@@utube2005utube is it that much difficult for u yo study quran and Hadith bhai plz atleast study classical scholars understanding of best generations tabiin and tab tabiin
@@zainulseema455 Apparently, coz u have not provided the references. Again, respectfully, please provide references so I can validate your points which per ur post indicate that Ghamidi sahib got it wrong. I don't claim to know all ahadith so the references would be much appreciated.
Quran 24:31 - "And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and guard their chastity, and not to reveal their adornments1 except what normally appears.2 Let them draw their veils over their chests, and not reveal their ˹hidden˺ adornments3 except to their husbands, their fathers, their fathers-in-law, their sons, their stepsons, their brothers, their brothers’ sons or sisters’ sons, their fellow women, those ˹bondwomen˺ in their possession, male attendants with no desire, or children who are still unaware of women’s nakedness. Let them not stomp their feet, drawing attention to their hidden adornments. Turn to Allah in repentance all together, O believers, so that you may be successful."
Footnote - 1
i.e., hair, body shape, and underclothes.
Now tell me, how can you argue against the Quran? These are Allah's commands towards the believing women.
Footnote is just an interpretation from one person you daft.
Whoever says that hijab/parda is not ‘laazim’ they don’t understand the Arabic language. Allah gave women clear commandments in Surah Nur. Women need to stop believing this fraud and accept Allah’s commandments.
Which ayaat says that barda is not wajab
Salam, In Surah Nur, Allah swt commands to cover the chest with the head covering that both man and woman used to wear. That doesn’t mean necessarily that you have to always keep your head covered… Its fard to dress modestly and cover our zina except what it appears and I believe hair falls in that category..:/. Allah swt knows best. I’ll keep searching for the truth but I have this feeling in my heart knowing that when something is fard it is very clear to do certain things and the verse claimed to command women to cover all their hair is not this one in my opinion. May Allah guide me and all muslims through the right path 🤲🏻.
If anyone's a fraud it's you. Allah never gave clear commandments to wear the headscarf. Stop lying. Also its ironic that you're using the word hijab when it doesn't even mean headscarf or anything synonymous.
What has been emphasized clearly in surah nur is modesty both clothing and behavior wise
Asaan deen hhhh
bat to ghamdi sab ki tek hai lakin aj konsi aourat ghar se baghair makeup ki bahair nektalti hai taqreeeban sari to on phar parda lazem hai ghair ma aghar nahi karti to tek hai oder khavand beta bahi bap hota hai maghar bahar lazim hai ha
Ghamdi sb se is parday wale maamly per mera shadeed qisam ka ikhtilaaf hy, quran mai 2 jaga parday ka hukm dia gia hy Allah ki taraf se or ghamdi sb keh rhe hen k parda kren to achi bat hy na kren to koi gunah nahi, deen ko khud parhen or samjhen
This is the 2 nd most watered down version of interpreting this verse that i ‘ve heard till now. 1 st most watered down version of this verse was women can wear crop tops and mini skirts as long as they don’t show their chest 😂 Like if you are going to interpret verses as you like you have no limits
غامدی صاحب کے استاد جن سے موصوف نے تیس سال علم حاصل کیا مولانا امین احسن اصلاحی مرحوم کا تدبر القرآن میں سورۃ الاحزاب کی آیت نمبر 59 کے حوالے سے تفسیر میں فرمانا ہے کہ ۔۔۔۔۔چہرے کا پردہ ضروری ہے
یایھا النبی قلا لازوک وبنتک ونساء المومنین یدینین علیھن من جلابیبھن ذلک ادنی ان یعرفن فلا یوذین وکان اللہ غفور رحیما (٥٩ ) منافقین و اشرار کی ایذا رسانیوں سے محفوظ کرنے کے لئے نبی (صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم) کے اہل بیت کو بھی اور عام مسلمان خواتین کو بھی یہ ہدایت کردی گئی کہ جب انہیں کسی ضرورت سے گھروں سے باہر قدم نکالنے کی ضرورت پیش آئے تو وہ اپنی بڑی چادروں کا کچھ حصہ اپنے چہروں پر لٹکا لیا کریں۔ اس طرح ان کے اور دوسری غیر مسلم عورتوں اور لونڈیوں کے درمیان امتیاز ہوجائے گا اور کسی کو ان سے تعرض کے لئے بہانہ ہاتھ نہیں آئے گا۔ سورة نور میں، یاد ہوگا، عزہ و اقربا سے متعلق یہ ہدایت دی گئی ہے کہ جب وہ اجازت کے بعد گھروں میں داخل ہوں گے تو گھر کی خواتین سمٹ سمٹا کر رہیں، اپنی زینت کی چیزوں کا اظہار نہ کرین اور اپنے سینوں پر اپنی اوڑھنیوں کے بکل ما رلیا کریں۔ یہاں یہ ہدایت دی گئی ہے کہ وہ اپنی بڑی چادروں (جلابیب) کا کچھ حصہ اپنے اوپر لٹکا لیا کریں۔ اس کو اپنے لفظوں میں یوں کہہ سکتے ہیں کہ ان بڑی چادروں سے گھونگھٹ نکال لیا کریں۔ یہ واضح قرینہ اس بات کا ہے کہ یہ ہدایت اس صورت سے تعلق ہے جب عورتوں کو کسی ضرورت سے باہر نکلنے کی ضرورت پیش آئے۔ اس قرینہ کی ایک دلیل تو یہ ہے کہ اس کا فائدہ یہ بتایا گیا ہے کہ ’ ذلک ادنی ان یعرفن فلا یوذین ‘ یہ اس بات کے قریب ہے کہ ان کا امتیاز ہوجائے اور اسن سے تعرض نہ کیا جائے) ظاہر ہے کہ یہ مقصد باہر نکلنے ہی کی صورت میں مدنظر ہوسکتا ہے۔ اس کا دوسرا واضح قرینہ یہ ہے کہ یہاں لفظ حماد ’ نہیں بلکہ ‘ جلباب ‘ استعمال ہوا ہے۔ جلباب کی تشریح اہل نعت نے یوں کی ہے کہ ھوالردا فوق الخمار۔ جلباب۔ اس بڑی چادر کو کہتے ہیں جو اوڑھنی کے اوپر لی جاتی ہے۔ ظاہر ہے کہ اس بڑی چادر کے لینے کی ضرورت گھروں کے اندر نہیں پیش آتی تھی بلکہ شرفائے عرب کی خواتی اس وقت اس کو لیتی تھیں جب انہیں گھروں سے باہر نکلنے کی ضرورت پیش آتی۔ شعرائے جاہلیت کے کلام سے یہ بات ثابت ہے کہ شرفائے عرب میں ’ جلباب ‘ کا رواج تھا۔ یہاں بہت سے اشعار نقل کرنے کی گنجائش نہیں ہے۔ قبیلہ ہذیل کی ایک شاعرہ کا ایک شعر ہمارے دعوت کے ثبوت کے لئے کاف ہے۔ وہ اپنے کسی مقتول کے مرثیہ میں کہتی ہے : تمشی السنورالہ وھی لاھیۃ مشی العذاری علیھن الجلابیب اس شعر میں جو نا درتشبیہ ہے اس پر گفتگوکا تو یہاں محل نہیں ہے۔ بات دوسرے گوشوں میں نکل جائے گی۔ بس اتنی بات یاد رکھئے کہ زمانہ جاہلیت میں سب ’ متبجات ‘ اور بیگمات ہی نہیں تھیں بلکہ شرفاء کے خاندانوں کو بہوئیں بیٹیاں بھی تھیں جو باہر نکلنے کی صورت میں اپنی اوڑھنیوں کے اوپر جلباب ڈالا کرتی تھیں۔ قرآن نے اس جلباب سے متعلق یہ ہدایت فرمائی کہ مسلمان خواتین گھروں سے باہر نکلیں تو اس کو کچھ حصہ اپنے اوپر لٹکا لیا کریں تو کہ چہرہ بھی فی الجملہ ڈھک جائے اور انہیں چلنے پھرنے میں بھی زحمت پیش نہ آئے۔ یہی ’ جلباب ‘ ہے جو ہمارے دیہاتوں کی شریف بڑی بوڑھیوں میں اب بھی رائج ہے اور اسی نے فیشن کی ترقی سے اب برقع کی شکل اختیار کرلی ہے۔ اس برقعہ کو اس زمانے کے دالدگانِ تہذیب اگر تہذیب کے خلاف قرار دیتے ہیں تو دیں لیکن قرآن مجید میں اس کا حکم نہایت واضح الفاط میں موجود ہے، جس کا انکار صرف وہی برخود لوگ کرسکتے ہیں جو خدا اور رسول کے زیادہ مہذب ہونے کے مدعی ہوں۔ ’ ذلک ادنی ان یعرفن فلا یوذین۔ یہ مسلمان خواتین کے لئے ایک علامت امتیاز مقرر کردی گئی تاکہ جہاں کہیں بھی وہ نکلیں ہر شخص ان کو دور ہی سے پہچان لے کہ یہ مسلمان خواتی ہیں اور تعرض کی جرأت نہ کرے اور اگر کرے تو اس کے عواقب دور تک سوچ کر کرے۔ اس زمانہ میں مدینہ میں غیر مسلم عورتیں بھی تھیں جن کے ہاں پردہ کی پابندیاں نہیں تھیں نیز لونڈیاں بھی تھیں جن کا معیارِ زندگی اور معیارِ اخلاق دونوں پست تھا اس وجہ سے شریر لوگوں کے لئے عذر کے مواقع بہت تھے۔ اگر وہ کسی مسلمان خاتون پر اہ چلتے کوئی فقرہ چست کرتے یا اس سے کوئی بات کرنے کی کوشش کرتے اور ان پر گرفت ہوتی تو وہ یہ جواب دے دیتے کہ ہم نے سمجھا کہ یہ فلاں کی لونڈی ہے، اور اس سے فلاں بات ہم نے معلوم کرنی چاہی تھی۔ اس علامتِ امتیاز کے قائم ہوجانے کے بعد اس قسم کے بہانوں کی راہ مسدود ہوگئی۔ اس ٹکڑے سے کسی یہ گلط فہمی نہ ہو کہ ایک وقتی تدبیر تھی جو اشرار کے شر سے مسلمان خواتین کو محفوط رکھنے کے لئے اختیار کی گئی اور اب اس کی ضرورت باقی نہیں رہی۔ اول تو احکام جتنے بھی نازل ہوئے ہیں سب محرکات کے تحت ہی نازل ہوئے ہیں لیکن اس کے معنی یہ نہیں ہے کہ وہ محرکات نہ ہوں تو وہ احکام کالعدم ہوجائیں، دوسرے یہ کہ جن حالات میں یہ حکم دیا گیا تھا کیا کوئی ذی ہوش یہ دعویٰ کرسکتا ہے کہ اس زمانے میں حالات کل کی نسبت ہزار درجہ زیادہ خراب ہیں البتہ حیا اور عفت کے وہ تصورات معدوم ہوگئے جن کی تعلیم قرآن نے دی تھی۔ وکان اللہ غفورا رحیما۔ یہ فقرہ اس حکم تسہیل کے لئے ارشاد ہوا ہے۔ مطلب یہ ہے کہ خواتین اپنی ھد تک یہ احتیاط ملحوظ رکھیں۔ اگر اس کے باوجود کوئی بھول چوک ہوگئی تو اللہ غفور رحیم ہے۔
Wow wow Ladkio ke to maze hi maze ye video dekhke😂 Ya Nisa Fear Allah
سلطان صلاح الدین ایوبی رحمتہ اللہ علیہ کو انکے جاسوسوں نے بتایا کہ ایک عالمِ دین ہیں جو بہت اچھا خطاب کرتے ہیں لوگوں میں بہت مقبول ہو گئے ہیں۔
سلطان نے کہا آگے کہو
جاسوس بولے "کچھ غلط ہے جسے ہم محسوس کر رہے ہیں مگر الفاظوں میں بیان نہیں کرپا رہے"
سلطان نے کہا "جو بھی دیکھا اور سنا ہے بیان کرو"
جاسوس بولے کہ وہ کہتے ہیں کہ "نفس کا جہاد افضل ہے، بچوں کو تعلیم دینا ایک بہترین جہاد ہے، گھر کی زمہ داریوں کیلئے جد وجہد کرنا بھی ایک جہاد ہے۔
سلطان نے کہا تو اس میں کوئی شک ہے؟؟
جاسوس نے کہا کہ انہیں کوئی شک نہیں لیکن اس عالم کا کہنا ہے کہ:
"جنگوں سے کیا ملا؟؟ صرف قتل وغارت گری صرف لاشیں، جنگوں نے تمہیں یا تو قاتل بنایا یا مقتول "
سلطان بے چین ہو کر اٹھے، اسی وقت عالم سے ملنے کی ٹھانی، ملاقات بھیس بدل کر کی اور جاتے ہی سوال کردیا کہ "جناب ایسی کوئی ترکیب بتائیے کہ بیت المقدس کو آزاد اور مسلمانوں کے خلاف مظالم کو بغیر جنگ کے ختم کرایا جاسکے؟؟" ،
عالم نے کہا دعا کریں
سلطان کا چہرہ غصے سے لال ہو گیا، وہ سمجھ چکے تھے کہ یہ عالِم پوری صلیبی فوج سے بھی زیادہ خطرناک ہے
سلطان نے سب سے پہلے اپنے خنجر سے اُس عالم کی انگلی کاٹ دی، وہ بری طرح چیخنے لگا۔
اب سلطان نے کہا کہ اصلیت بتاتے ہو یا گردن بھی کاٹ دوں
پتہ چلا کہ وہ سفید پوش عالم ایک یہودی تھا، یہودیوں کو عربی بخوبی آتی تھی، جسکا اس نے فائدہ اٹھایا
سلطان نے پایا کہ اسکے جیسا درس اب خطبوں میں عام ہو چلا تھا، بڑی مشکل سے یہ فتنہ روکا جاسکا۔
یہ فتنہ اس وقت بھی پوری آب وتاب سے رواں دواں ہے۔
آخر کیوں لوگ اسلام کو بدھ ازم بنا دینا چاہتے ہیں ۔ جبکہ کھلی حقیقت ہے کہ ظالم کا سامنا کئے بغیر ظلم کا مداوا ہوجائے یہ ممکن ہی نہیں۔۔
ghamidi bhi jehad ke khilaf hai
Ģhámidi sáhib zulm ke ķhiláf haiń, jihád ke nahiń. Albatta qissa aćhha hai aur fáidamand hai.
غامدی صاحب اصل میں بہت سے مسائل میں غلطی کا شکار ہیں جس کا ان کو خود بھی نہیں پتا۔ بس اس بات پر زور دیتے ہیں کہ میں نے اپنی کتاب المیزان میں سارے کے سارے دین کو بیان کر دیا ہے۔ کچے ذہن کے لوگ بھی بڑے خوش ہوتے ہیں کہ یار یہ بہت بڑا کام ہے سارے دین کو ایک چھوٹی سی کتاب میں ٹھونس دیا۔ روایتی مولویوں کو کیا پتا دین کا۔
@@positivelife6254 Maiń Ģhámidi sáhib ka muqallid nahiń, lekin áp Ģhámidi sáhib ko kahań ģalat samajhte haiń?
@@positivelife6254 absolutely right
👍👍
Very confusing and not acceptable
Ghamdi sahab. We can't pick and choose and give our own interpreatation to Quranic clear verdict. It is so simple and clear that women and man should lower their gazes . In ayah 31 of surah Noor Allah ( SWT) addresse believing man to lower their gaze then in ayah # 32 believing women are clearly addreseed to lower their gaze and cover themselves with outer garments.
In surah Nisa it is explained as well and surah ahzab too.
Allah is in the Hijab and Allah gives women high status by commanding them to cover themselves except for their Mehram.
Believing women should be proud of herself by observing pardah. It is mandatory not an option
Great scholar 💯
Ghamidi sahib, aurat k jism mei sb se pehle us k chehre hi pe aik ghair mehram ki nazar jati hai tou phr ye kaise ho skta ha k chehre k parda na ho, logically ye baat zehan mei nahi beithti. jb k Quran ki ayat bhi hai jis k mafhoom hai k apni aurhnion ko sir se neeche phela lo. Tou is k maqsid chehre ko cover krne hi k zumre mei nahi aata?
Just because someone is looking at a womans face do we have to cover it. Ghamdi saab has clearly stated that sharam ghaoon ko dhakligiyay in proper and modest way. A womans face is not what anyone should be attracted to. Both sides should have decency and if man is looking at a womans face when she is following these guidelines then he is committing a sin. Aik aurat ka chehra sharam gha nahi hai kay banday
@@honey0331 First of all, I am not saying k aik aurat k chehra sharamgah hai, I was just talking about obligation of hijab. Also either woman is following guideline or not, man would always be sinner if he looks at a woman. Also, most astonishing & latest fact for me is the statement that no one is attracted to a woman face, really surprising.
My bottom line question was simple in context of Surah Noor verse which says to women to stretch down their scarf aur dupattas (audhnian). Doesn't this verse points to obligation of hijab?
@@honey0331 abey jahil insan kisi ghasti maa k bachay tujhe kch pata nhi hai to bkwas mat kr...sabse pehle chehre se attraction hoti hai
Yes u r right
Hijab and scarf are very important for the grownup girls and women. Khimar which is mentioned in Quran is nothing else but Hijab
Hadiths about hijab
With regard to the Ahadith :
It was narrated from Safiyyah bint Shaybah that ‘Aishah (may Allah be pleased with her) used to say: When these words were revealed - “and to draw their veils all over Juyubihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms)” - they took their izars (a kind of garment) and tore them from the edges and covered their faces with them. Narrated by al-Bukhari, 4481.
khimer is mentined in a sense of covering chest which is compulsory but not for the head , if you read the full verse you will understand the context, So if women can cover their chest with any cloth that will do the work but Quran never says it should be use to cover head as well
@@iic2689 Khimar comes from the word "khamr" which means an intoxicant, and guess what an intoxicant does? It messes with your head. Literally. How can you say this doesn't mean head up as well? Also, if it's only the chest that is to be covered up, then later on it says this covering up is not necessary in front of mahram, so will you not wear anything covering your upper body in front of your father/brother etc? Of course not. This clearly refers to the hijab.
@@huzaifatahir5738 where i said Khimer doesnt mean head? read my comment again i was saying Quran mentioned khimar in a sense to cover chest part meaning Quran is not ordering to cover your head but actually Quran is saying Cover your chest by using the cloth of your head since the best way to cover chest is to use the cloth that usually women has on their head so thats why Quran use the word khimar ,,, this verse is not ordering the head cover it order is about chest cover using cloth that usually women use to cover their head
مِنْهَا ۖ وَلْيَضْرِبْنَ بِخُمُرِهِنَّ عَلَىٰ جُيُوبِهِنَّ ۖ
Let them draw their [ head ]veils over their chests.
// later on it says this covering up is not necessary in front of mahram, so will you not wear anything covering your upper body in front of your father/brother etc? //
when someone says to any women to put y veil on chest does it means she was naked before? obviously not , she already wear a dress that covers her body on that Quran sis demanding women to add one more piece of cloth on your chest apart from your dress covering
@@iic2689 So you agree with me then. If the verse says it's a head cover that should go over the chest, then it's already a given that the head cover is compulsory. That doesn't need to be stated. Where do you get this view from, by the way? Ghamidi is a contemporary, and the ijmaa of the scholars of the past was that at the minimum hijab is compulsory, with differences of opinion on the niqab.
@@huzaifatahir5738 i never disagree on "khimer mean head" what i was saying is totally different thing that you didnt get , having a name khamir doesnt indicate the ruling about head covering is compulsory in Islam ,, read whole verse or sentence atleast, the rule is about covering chest and in order to do that Allah is saying just use the cloth that is on your head to cover your chest ,,, it means having a cloth on head was already a tradition in arab just like right now it is and in many other deserts Quran is just saying to use that cloth to cover chest as well ... Quran didnt mention to cover head or its compulsory.
comment section is like male Muslim have 5 farz and female muslim have 6 farz lol
ghamidi saab se pehle jitne bhi muhaddiseen ,mufassareen , auliya , ulema etc kisi ko deen samjh nahi aaya bas ye samjhe hain asal deen ......Allah hidayat de
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 kaun se aalim ,ulema ne bola tha bhai ??? naam batana zara ?? Ulema to daari rakhne k liyen bolte hain bhai wo baat humne maan li kyunki Rasulullah sallallahu wa alaiyehewasallam ki beard thi ,or ulemao ne music sunne ko mana kiya to wo bhi chhor diya .......achcha bhai engineer ali mirza to abhi aaya hain, aap k bade to ulemao ko or aalimo ki sunte honge kiya wo sex slave rakhte the ??????? bhai bura mat manna tumne misaal ghalazat waali di to wohi pooch rhaa hun bas , samjhane k liyen
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 aap koi hawala to den ??? jinke aapne naam liyen hain waise unhe engineer saab babbon mein shumaar nahi karte ,yeh to wo log hain jinke zariye deen sahabon k baad seena b seena laya gaya or mehfooz kawaya gaya ....😀😀😀
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 arre mere bhai aap ghair muslim ho kiya ?????? ye arab k culture tha , jisko baad mein forbid kar diya gaya , ye sab baatein kaafir usr karte hain islam ko or nabi ko defame karne k liyen ,
khair baat ho rahi hai babao ki jinka aapne naam kiya , bukhari ,shafai ,malik etc ...unhone kab kaha ki aap cocubines rakh sakte hain ,, Apne jo bhi hawale diyen hain woh direct sahab or nabi Allah k taraf se hain .... to aapke hisaab se cocubines are still allowed ??
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 bhai unhone jayaz kab kaha ?????or mein to jahil aadmi hun bhai bas itna janta hun mein us mozu ko bilkul touch nahi karta jisper baat karna behad fizool ho , issue aapne chher diya or abhi tak ye pata nahi chala ya misaal aapne di kyun ??? jabiki ye masail bilkul aam majlis mein karne k nahi hai .....per lagta hai aap bahut bade aalim hai headscraf bhi lagana zarorri nahi hai , parde k hukm hai ya usse bhi faarigh ho jaayen hum ???? ye or bata dijiye ,beard ki to zaroorat hi nahi hai ghamidi saab ne bata diya or bataiye kiya kiya chhorna hai
@@arifahmedlaskar8271 agar abu jehal ki bhi daadi thi to Aap ne kyun rakhi ??? ya yun kahen ki daadi itni zaroori hai ki abu jehal bhi rakhta tha ........aap kaafi azad khayal maloom hote hain hazrat mein parde k baare mein itna janta hun ki parda to poori aurat k hai .........or daadi to mere bhai javed ghamidi k alawa , saare nabiyon ki saare sahabaon ki saare tabaeen ki ,taba tabaeen ki , har maslak k ulemao ki rahi hai or rahegi in sha Allah , Aap cleavage chhipwayen bas humein aurton ko poora dhankne k mamla karne den ,aakhirat k mamla hai bhai , or taqwa bhi koi cheez hoti hai ......bina beard waale imamo k peeche namaz padhte hain aap??? ohh per bina beard waale imam to milta bhi nahi hoga masjid mein 😁😁😁😁😁bhai maaf kar dena per mein ulemao ki badi izzat karta hun ,or javed sab or aap mujhe bilkul ek jaise lagte hain bas javed saab k mutalla bada hai ......Allah hidayat k muamla kare
He very conviniently misinterprets things written in Quran and then propagate it with all his confidence. For concerned people, plz do watch a short video clip of Dr Israr Ahmed on the same topic on you tube "Chahray ka parda".
Can you please elaborate how you think that Ghamdi saab is "conveniently misinterpreting" and "propagating" his teachings. Learn to control your language rather than enforcing stamps on people according to your wishes. If you think he is wrong than no need to stay here. Move on.
honey03 do watch a video clip by Dr Israr on the same topic, the one I mentioned up, and then decide yourself.
@@JB-su6wt i just did and nothing that he is saying is backed up by verses from the Quran or hadith.that being said I don't disagree with some of the things that he says but Allah kami paeshi maaf karat but he uses more poetry enhancing and overly sexualizing woman's face and other parts and the way he speaks in general is not appeasing. A Muslim should cover modestly, respectful to themselves aswell and both men and women should not look at each other with bad intentions. How can some one change the verses in Quran and take out meanings that suits them best is quite an insane idea to me. Please watch Ghamdi saabs whole lecture so that you can get an idea of what he is saying. And my question to you was not about womans hijab it was about the parts that were propagated and misinterpreted. Try to understand the jist of the question
Well Said
parda lazim aur farz hai islyeh shut the nonsense 😏😏
Apni zuban check kro nonsense
No its not
Good manners are also "lazim", I don't see you following that sunnah.
@@daniaansari2763 ap nangi ghumti hai bazar mei?
Well said 👍
Why all the muslim scholars all over the world are in agreement with the issues of hijab,sood,sharab and music but he is the only one scholar who has altogether different openion on every issue.Even the scholars who are arabs are not able to comprehend these issues correctly in the light of Quran as he does....confusion🤔
Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
@@FirstAnalysis all muslims in the world huh? Lmfaoooo you're islamiphobic and clearly haven't met any muslims in real life. Most of us are wonderful people.
@@ashley_brown6106 muslims are not bad.
@@FirstAnalysis 🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻
I feel the same
Ghamidi sahab is clearly opening the door to be pardagi. He is relying on his interpretation and neglecting all hadith on this issue.
Yes thats exactly what he's doing, selectively picking and choosing may he be guided
@Ali Siddiqui nah we not he is v misguided indeed
@@SDSen And you too cherry picking his 3-minute video and establishing the assumption about him while neglecting his entire discussion on it.
Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
@@FirstAnalysis I have viewed all his lectures. I am well read in religion. He is clearly thinking in liberal paradigm. Liberalism itself is a religion of sorts. Watch Mohammad Hijab on liberalism for better understanding the poison of liberalism.
Well Allah has commanded the azwaaj e muteheraat to cover their faces in Quran, so we have to follow them, those holy women were far more respectable than we are, if they did so we will too cover our faces
Wo msg specifically Un k lye tha .. farz ni ha bhai ,, kr lo to acha ha
Allah also asked azwaj e mutahrirat to not to get married after pbuh
But this rule doesn't implement on lay women
@@mnafees364 Farz he
Hadis me bhi aya he agar Quran is not enough
Best Scholar MASHALLAH
Ghamdi fintna
A great scholar for the one who prefers his desires and lust in the name of the relegion well done sir
You're disgusting as hell. The Quran doesn't confirm your corrupted desires. The Quran explicitly emphasizes modesty but doesn't even say to cover the head "and" that it is compulsory
He is a traditional muslim
He is just having his opinion
You are ridiculous
Hijab is mandated, can't argue with it. Enough proof of it in graded Hadith. This world is not for our pleasure, even marriage isn't for our pleasure because we can't do certain sexual things even with our wives, so we are repressed in that sense, but this repression is for the greater goal : Jannah. Where there will be no repression.
@Ali Siddiqui The rules of modesty are legislated and ordained by Allah, not dictated by the whims of people. the word Khimar is used in th Quran and expanded upon in the Sahih Hadith.
@Ali Siddiqui it actually does, have you even read hadith? Or is it because you're personally against the idea of a woman wearing one because your nafs doesn't like it
@Ali Siddiqui oh there are plenty on hijab you just don't wanna see that. Now back to watching more deviant Ghamidi videos for you
Thats ridiculous. We wanna live our best lives. Hijab is not mandated.
Don't interpret the ayahs the way you want just to satisfy the audience. Allah will severely punish such people. Beware of his anger.
You should fear Allah as well for falsely accusing a learned scholar..
True this man is totally false
Why all muslims in the world are showing the worst character among humen? That should not be the reasoning for understanding Quran. In my humble opinion, we received a version of Islam that is a product of dark ages to Islam. Conservation is obvious... it happened to christianity and hinduism as well. When a religion is at the very edge of being lost, regious cleric try to conserve by implementing even harsher practices in order to survive. Thanks to tatars who in a matter of 50 years not only destroyed the highly intellectual islamic society but also killed the men and burnt the books. Islam revived on a thin note and eversince we have what we have. The conservative view of the religion. Take anything from Quran and apply the worst scenario, multiply it by 10 and send out a decree for people to follow. Unfortunately, this new religion turned out to be supressive to every weaker part of the society and benefited the most powerful and wealthy. In case of muslims of India, we saw that Hindu women was abused and veiled so we went one step further. The best thing would be to watch all of Ghamidi's lectures and then have an intellecture angument so we all learn from you and you also have an opportunity to learn from someone who has studied the topic.
@@al-manarinstitute8176 this ghamidi is a modern day fitnah.
@@muslimboyilyas775 read Quran my brother you will know who is right on the day of qiamat
It's just gamidi sb openion not all Islam. Veil is must obligatory for Muslims womens in all conditions Islam except in front of Mehram.
This scholar is propagating a deviant teaching about hijab. Sadly his knowledge is a curse for him. He is an example of those people of knowledge about whom Allah warned us:
Have you seen he who has taken as his god his [own] desire, and Allāh has sent him astray due to knowledge and has set a seal upon his hearing and his heart and put over his vision a veil? So who will guide him after Allāh?” No one sobhanak.
Ghamdi ki samjh nae ati
Hijab per pabandi hai hijab main haya hai aur Hijab Allah Tallah ka Hukam hai is liye Hijab faraz hai
Strongly disagree ....
استغفراللّٰہ
آپ کی کوئی بھی بات قرآن و حدیث کے مطابق نہیں
صحابیات آج کی عورت کی نسبت بلکل سادہ رہتی تھیں
مگر پھر بھی پورے پردے میں ہوتی تھیں
آپ نے ایک غلط ترغیب دے کے اللہ کے عذاب کو دعوت دی ہے
اللہ سے معافی مانگیں
Baqwas
I have a question for you.Mr. Ghamidi what is the meaning of Khimaar.I think you don't know,people like you are changing islam but believe me put everything you have into your fitna but you can't change the word of God.
GAMDI belongs to LAHORI GROUP. Be careful with him.
You can disagree with him. However, you can't claim any such things without evidence. Because a sahih hadis declares spreading news without authentication a lie and im Holy Quran, Allah curses those who lie. So provide some evidences.
علمی انداز میں غیر علمی اور بے دلیل بات کر رہے ہیں جناب غامدی صاحب ۔۔
Hijab on women is not optional it is mandatory May Allah guide him
Astaghfirullah...it is mandated in Quran
@@kanizfatima1377 it is
May Allah guide him before his death .. Parda is compulsory ..
Ignorance .May Allah give him hidayat.
Fitna e kabeer
Dangerous, n not right opinion.
Jahil ghamdi ko Allah hidayat De or agar hidayat k kabil na hai to haalak kre
@@hamaidmk hahahaha... Taliban to wo hai Jo tm jaise napak logon ko smjh na ayega... Q ki tme to aurat nangi chahiye bazaron me... Hme to izzt k sath aurat ko rkhni hai ghr mai... Tmre papa America ne v toh aab Taliban ko aabu keh rhe
@@hamaidmk Surah 24:31, telling women to guard their private parts and draw their khimār over their bosoms. Khimar includes covering head in the meaning .
For more info refer th-cam.com/video/AALgGKSnU2g/w-d-xo.html by nouman ali khan for arabic meanings.
Aameen
@@hamaidmk bhai aap apni zaaban par ghor karain. Aap jaise auraton kay baray mai baat kar rahain hair, saaf zahir ho raha hai kay aap kitni izat kartain hain ghar mai rakh kar apni auratein.
Ye line se hata huwa he ghamdi
That's called nicely misguiding people.
And what your doing is called enforcing an opinion that is clearly not needed
I have watched his videos as I watch every other scholars but what I noticed is he misinterpreted Islam by his own will he uses verses then twist them in the way he wants and make Islam so liberal and free no doubt he is an educated person but I swear he is not a right scholar don't follow what he says
Spent 3 minutes explaining nothing then just gave his opinion in the end. Classic Ghamidi 😭
Ek ayat to pesh kr dya kro quraan ki sirf qayasi aur acchi baaten karte ho aurato ko behaya banana chahte ho ghamdi saheb Ap Quran ar hadees ke munkir ho
Akram Ali LOL the claim is being made by you.. so apki zimdari hai kaa proof dain. Koi ayat bayaan karen jahan Allah pak naa hukam diya hoo kaa hijab(face covering) har aurat par lazim hai.. jaisa Allah naa roza, zakat, hajj farz kia hain aur clearly mention ki hai.. pls show me.
Behaya jisna hona hai wo burqa mein bhi ba haya hoti hain... jaaa kar mohallo mein dekho, kisi aurat ke haaya aur ba hayai hijab sa nhi paida hoti.. baharhaal aurton ko chahiye kaa aisa libaas pehanain jo vulgar naa hoo, koi body part visible naa hoo, khoola khoola kapra pehanain..
Kitni burqa wali pakri jaati hain hotel saa? Pata hoga apko.. hayaa kapron saa nhi, zehaniyat saa ati hai
Munki janaab ap lag rahe hoo Quran kaa.. kiyon kaa Allah naa quran mein farmaya hai ka kisi ko judge krna galat hai..
Allah apko aur mujhe hidyat daa
Sutah ahzab verse 59@Ali Mansoor
No doubt
Very well explained
But not right