I am relieved...and pleasantly surprised...to hear Bach's music played without an imaginary metronome (usually set too high) and with accents on the rhythmically important notes!!! SO many contemporary Bach performances...especially on solo instruments...seem to be patterned on a pre-programmed computer model. No humanity. This is lovely!!! Like she's singing it. Like it SHOULD be!!! I don't know. Maybe it's a lute thing. Whatever. Beautiful. Thoughtful. Inspiring. And WAY too rare!!!
I feel like this is more a problem of (a) classical musicians playing all kinds of genres and also picking up a Bach piece here and there vs (b) musicians focusing their career on historically informed performances also focusing on Bach. Compare for example Cello Suite 1 played by (a) Maisky th-cam.com/video/mGQLXRTl3Z0/w-d-xo.html vs (b) Swarts th-cam.com/video/cGnZHIY_hoQ/w-d-xo.html (a) is from 1993 so arguably not contemporary and (b) has exactly what you describe, the breathing, the singing.
Rubato can be nice, but it can also be overdone very very easily. Bach intended for us to simply read what he wrote on the page. He was criticized by many of his peers for going as far as writing out ornaments and trills instead of symbols (not leaving the interpretive execution of these elements to the performance). Other composers from his era, especially Weiss, can be performed with liberal use of rubato to no degenerative effect. I have no criticism for performers who choose to use a rubato interpretation, but I also have none for those who simply play what is written.
Listening on the other side of this amazing planet in the land of Oz…. This is so deeply moving… few words… just heaven…. Awaiting a CD feverishly… please🙏💐💐💐😘😘😘😘😘
Exactly i have the feeling that alot of musicians just wanna be faster like a other one. John Dowland's Fantasia 7 is a perfect example for it. Theres some recordings on youtube and to me only 2 play it in the right feeling, rubato with no rushing so every note gets the space that it needs to shine.
Transcription au luth de la 5° suite pour violoncelle solo de BACH, magnifiquement interprétée par cette très jolie musicienne....un pur moment de bonheur !🎼🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶💖💖💖💖
15:22 Gavotte 1, my favorite piece of classical music ever, performed by my favorite lute player :) Recently learned this piece on guitar and fulfilled a life dream. Thanks for your precious hard work, Klaudyna.
I am so excited to live in a time with so much BAROQUE period performance practice. While all instruments can benefit and embody JSB, wowoweewow the lute really gets me going.
То, что люди хотят понять себя и обращаются к Баху - понятно. Потрясает то, как Бах смог понять мир и людей и рассказать это нам в музыке. Но ещё более потрясает, что Бах творил во всех жанрах и для всех инструментов, создавая вечную музыку. Скрипка или виолончель или любой другой инструмент или их сочетания - его гений показывает нам суть нашего мира. Никакая религия не сможет такого. Это исполнение - ещё одно обращение к вечности.
@@romariorosso9502, не совсем так. Никакой гений не сможет выразить бога. Дао, высказанное словами не есть истинное дао. Соответственно, степень приближения к божественной истине существенного значения не имеет, всё равно не поймём. Хотя, и тянет нас следом за гением. Например, квартеты Шуберта. Вся фишка в том, что мы в своём развитии, способны постигать то, что ранее постигли гении тех времён. Гении устаревают. Кроме некоторых, которых единицы. Поэтому не волнуйтесь. Берите от гения всё, на что способны, но помните, что возможно вы уже понимаете где-то больше него.
Your sensitive, conversational phrasing, tone, and presence is just the way I love to hear this suite! I have heard so, so many renditions but I believe yours is one of the Best! Bravo!!!
“Conversational” is such a great description of Klaudyna’s interpretation. And I agree; I’ve never enjoyed this piece more. Absolutely beautiful playing.
I think that God was quite dishonest when it came to you. You have the gift to play beautiful music in a beautiful way. Besides that you are beautiful yourself: quite a lot on one plate. You are privileged.
No nosso tempo em que se valoriza velocidade e informação resumida, alguém que captura a tua atenção por mais de vinte minutos já é um fenômeno. Agora, acrescentando sensibilidade e beleza , só nos resta agradecer imensamente pelo compartilhamento generoso. Parabéns e muito obrigado Klaudyna! Te desejo sucesso e saúde
It is a real issue I've encountered as well! I enjoyed playing all the Lute Suites on Harpsichord (a tempo) even more so than Guitar, even though I grew up on the John Williams BBC recording. The older and more into HIPP I got, the less I wanted to hear the works on Guitar, particularly due to the colors, timbres, attack, and rhetorical appeal.
This is my favorite recording of this work. The musician, the instrument, the recording quality. Beautiful. Honestly I find the lute does this piece better justice than cello. So much of it is so idiomatic of the lute, especially that incredible Gavotte. Even the keyboard Partitas are absolutely saturated with 'style luthe' figurations (especially the Cm, which seems like a spiritual sibling to this piece). The suite genre in general seems to secretly be a lute genre.
Well, this is a surprise. I long-time of fan of classical music, I didn't think I cared for either J.S. Bach or Baroque music. Then I stumbled across this video. I'm a convert. Thank you, Ker, for introducing me to a whole new world. Kind regards.
You say: "didn't think I cared for either JS Bach or Baroque music"!-and that after a lifetime of listening to classical music-I mean no disrespect but I find that astonishing, I too have been listening to this stuff for most of my life and right from the start, it was always acknowledged that he was the "Daddy", he was a massively prolific composer who expanded the repertoire of every musician on every instrument with exquisitely crafted works which, even today are regarded as the Gold Standard in compositional excellence. Give yourself a real treat, find his Concerto for Double Violins and lose yourself in it-I have to listen to it only when alone as it makes me weep with joy and something utterly undefinable which swells up inside and overwhelms the senses. You will not regret it-I promise!
If you are just a listener (fan) you usually go for just classical, like Beethoven and Mozart, but if you are a musician, born or trained, then you are "obliged" to listen to and know Renaissance, Baroque and modern music too... Well, it's fortunate that you discovered this in 2021, through TH-cam, better late than never, right?
This is great playing and a very nice quality recording. That lute has great tonality. I've recently discovered the lute on TH-cam and think is cool! I wish more people played it.
@@tomswiftyphilo2504 If you're tuning them from scratch it takes a long time but once in tune they're not too bad. They go out of tune faster than guitars but if you play every day you don't have to spend too much time on tuning (as long as you don't want to play pieces in very different keys on the same lute). Another limiting factor is the expense. They're aren't, to my knowledge, any inexpensive (playable) 13 course lutes for beginners. One big advantage of the baroque lute, though, is that music originally written for lute (e.g. Weiss) is generally easier to play on the lute than on the guitar.
Hello Klaudyna, Tout est beau y compris évidemment la prise de son. Avec une si jolie photographie de vous en plan fixe, j'ai des regrets de ne pas vous voir une vidéo, la musique que vous faites et vous même en mouvement ! Vive la Pologne et ses citoyens si sympathiques.
Oh the joy, the bliss of this instrument in the hands of a most fluid and gifted player. A Wonder !
I am relieved...and pleasantly surprised...to hear Bach's music played without an imaginary metronome (usually set too high) and with accents on the rhythmically important notes!!! SO many contemporary Bach performances...especially on solo instruments...seem to be patterned on a pre-programmed computer model. No humanity. This is lovely!!! Like she's singing it.
Like it SHOULD be!!!
I don't know.
Maybe it's a lute thing.
Whatever.
Beautiful.
Thoughtful.
Inspiring.
And WAY too rare!!!
I feel like this is more a problem of (a) classical musicians playing all kinds of genres and also picking up a Bach piece here and there vs (b) musicians focusing their career on historically informed performances also focusing on Bach.
Compare for example Cello Suite 1 played by (a) Maisky th-cam.com/video/mGQLXRTl3Z0/w-d-xo.html vs (b) Swarts th-cam.com/video/cGnZHIY_hoQ/w-d-xo.html
(a) is from 1993 so arguably not contemporary and (b) has exactly what you describe, the breathing, the singing.
Rubato can be nice, but it can also be overdone very very easily. Bach intended for us to simply read what he wrote on the page. He was criticized by many of his peers for going as far as writing out ornaments and trills instead of symbols (not leaving the interpretive execution of these elements to the performance). Other composers from his era, especially Weiss, can be performed with liberal use of rubato to no degenerative effect. I have no criticism for performers who choose to use a rubato interpretation, but I also have none for those who simply play what is written.
Listening on the other side of this amazing planet in the land of Oz…. This is so deeply moving… few words… just heaven…. Awaiting a CD feverishly… please🙏💐💐💐😘😘😘😘😘
Exactly i have the feeling that alot of musicians just wanna be faster like a other one. John Dowland's Fantasia 7 is a perfect example for it. Theres some recordings on youtube and to me only 2 play it in the right feeling, rubato with no rushing so every note gets the space that it needs to shine.
Magnifique version !
Bach has touched the heaven...no one else!...I could listen to this whole life.
Transcription au luth de la 5° suite pour violoncelle solo de BACH, magnifiquement interprétée par cette très jolie musicienne....un pur moment de bonheur !🎼🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶💖💖💖💖
Just tuning this beast makes you a mensch. Playing Bach on it makes you a rock star.
15:22 Gavotte 1, my favorite piece of classical music ever, performed by my favorite lute player :) Recently learned this piece on guitar and fulfilled a life dream. Thanks for your precious hard work, Klaudyna.
Could listen to it again and again ... breathtaking and beautiful ... Dziękuję bardzo, Klaudyna ...
This comfortable sound is something Incredible, and Incredible feelings
this is just stunningly beautiful. thank you.
😊 was für ein wunderbares Lautenspiel 😘
I am so excited to live in a time with so much BAROQUE period performance practice. While all instruments can benefit and embody JSB, wowoweewow the lute really gets me going.
what wonderful sound perfect tuned ! Incredible above all in low range; so deep sounds!
Wonderful performance, and a tip of the hat to the engineer who recorded this. Nicely done all around!
Human, not a computer quality, great.
Thank you very much.
Best performance by "allowing" resonances and strings to swing before damping too hasty.
Thank you, both, you and JS Bach.
Para tocar a Bach de este modo, hay que tenerlo interiorizado y ser poseedora de una gran tecnica. Todo a nivel muy alto
A version full of elegance and limpid serenity.
Thanks for sharing!
I was looking for words to praise this performance, I agree completely
То, что люди хотят понять себя и обращаются к Баху - понятно. Потрясает то, как Бах смог понять мир и людей и рассказать это нам в музыке. Но ещё более потрясает, что Бах творил во всех жанрах и для всех инструментов, создавая вечную музыку. Скрипка или виолончель или любой другой инструмент или их сочетания - его гений показывает нам суть нашего мира. Никакая религия не сможет такого.
Это исполнение - ещё одно обращение к вечности.
Гений есть гений. И понять гения способен только гений.
@@romariorosso9502, не совсем так. Никакой гений не сможет выразить бога. Дао, высказанное словами не есть истинное дао.
Соответственно, степень приближения к божественной истине существенного значения не имеет, всё равно не поймём. Хотя, и тянет нас следом за гением. Например, квартеты Шуберта.
Вся фишка в том, что мы в своём развитии, способны постигать то, что ранее постигли гении тех времён.
Гении устаревают. Кроме некоторых, которых единицы.
Поэтому не волнуйтесь. Берите от гения всё, на что способны, но помните, что возможно вы уже понимаете где-то больше него.
@@inbokru ой, б**ть, не надо вот этих маразматичных сказок про вымышленных персонажей...
An extraordinarily beautiful rendition on an extraordinarily beautiful instrument.
Extraordinarily beautiful comment.
Your sensitive, conversational phrasing, tone, and presence is just the way I love to hear this suite! I have heard so, so many renditions but I believe yours is one of the Best! Bravo!!!
“Conversational” is such a great description of Klaudyna’s interpretation. And I agree; I’ve never enjoyed this piece more. Absolutely beautiful playing.
She's the queen of the lute, no doubt here :) That elegancy.
I think that God was quite dishonest when it came to you. You have the gift to play beautiful music in a beautiful way. Besides that you are beautiful yourself: quite a lot on one plate. You are privileged.
I agree, that it is the best recording I've heard, so far
A conversation between two voice on the lute?
No nosso tempo em que se valoriza velocidade e informação resumida, alguém que captura a tua atenção por mais de vinte minutos já é um fenômeno. Agora, acrescentando sensibilidade e beleza , só nos resta agradecer imensamente pelo compartilhamento generoso.
Parabéns e muito obrigado Klaudyna! Te desejo sucesso e saúde
this is undoubtedly from heaven .. bless you
Bonjour, c'est une magnifique interprétation de cette pièce de JS Bach.
Merci beaucoup et bravo.
bonjour , enfin un commentaire en francais ! merci , je comencais a croire que j etai le seul a ecouter bach ! pierre xavier de chassot .
@@pierre-xavierchassot3183 mais non, pas du tout ! Voici encore un !
Had to study to get my guitar classical degree, but always hated, because only cello and lute can testify its beauty...thank you
It is a real issue I've encountered as well! I enjoyed playing all the Lute Suites on Harpsichord (a tempo) even more so than Guitar, even though I grew up on the John Williams BBC recording. The older and more into HIPP I got, the less I wanted to hear the works on Guitar, particularly due to the colors, timbres, attack, and rhetorical appeal.
Wonderful performance!
Definitely my new absolute favorite work-and-study music!!!
Thank you for such a great interpretation of Bach
Could not possibly be more right on. So many thanks...you are a gift to this world...
It's very nice, Klaudya! Thank's!!!
Nagyon szép volt,köszönet érte! Ön gyönyörűen játszik!
świetnie Pani gra , jestem zachwyyyyycooooonyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy :)
what a lute! That sound is soo profound.
wonderful performance
Exquisiteness
Monumental !
so beautiful, so nicely played with exquisite taste. Thank you so much Klaudyna.
Today May 12, I hear you for the first time. Greetings from Colombia. Beautiful.
How wonderful!!! Herr Bach would be proud and blessed by your excellent tonality and interpretation...continued success.
Amazing performance. Thank you very much for posting.
Hermosa mujer, hermosa música, hermosa interpretación, nos transporta en el tiempo,... Saludos desde México
This is my favorite recording of this work. The musician, the instrument, the recording quality. Beautiful. Honestly I find the lute does this piece better justice than cello. So much of it is so idiomatic of the lute, especially that incredible Gavotte. Even the keyboard Partitas are absolutely saturated with 'style luthe' figurations (especially the Cm, which seems like a spiritual sibling to this piece). The suite genre in general seems to secretly be a lute genre.
Znam tę suitę z transkrypcji gitarowej,ale na tej lutni brzmi szerzej.Znakomicie.
Świetna muzyka.
Ok. This is a perfect interpretation. First time I hear it in a lute. Loved it
Very clean playing making use of a good dynamic range.
It's refreshing to hear the presto part not played in a typical guitaristic fashion (fast and agressive)
Beautiful performing. Love it❤️❤️❤️
fantastic! not as dark as I want, but also not too light like other players who cant seem to hear the pathos here
Just amazing ! ! What a talent !
Muy bella musica...excelente interpretacion
Absolutely lovely!!
Amazingly beautiful. More please!
Bravissima! E anche bella.
Thank you for this! Yours is my favorite interpretation and I've been listening to it several times weekly ever since I found it.
Hi Klaudyna😀 I was à teacher at École Normale de Musique. I think your interprétation is very well👍
Well, this is a surprise. I long-time of fan of classical music, I didn't think I cared for either J.S. Bach or Baroque music. Then I stumbled across this video. I'm a convert. Thank you, Ker, for introducing me to a whole new world. Kind regards.
You say: "didn't think I cared for either JS Bach or Baroque music"!-and that after a lifetime of listening to classical music-I mean no disrespect but I find that astonishing, I too have been listening to this stuff for most of my life and right from the start, it was always acknowledged that he was the "Daddy", he was a massively prolific composer who expanded the repertoire of every musician on every instrument with exquisitely crafted works which, even today are regarded as the Gold Standard in compositional excellence.
Give yourself a real treat, find his Concerto for Double Violins and lose yourself in it-I have to listen to it only when alone as it makes me weep with joy and something utterly undefinable which swells up inside and overwhelms the senses.
You will not regret it-I promise!
I know what you mean. Generally I prefer early music or 20th century music to what I am supposed to like. But I like this very much.
If you are just a listener (fan) you usually go for just classical, like Beethoven and Mozart, but if you are a musician, born or trained, then you are "obliged" to listen to and know Renaissance, Baroque and modern music too... Well, it's fortunate that you discovered this in 2021, through TH-cam, better late than never, right?
Brilliant! Thank you!
Awesome interpretation, lovely phrasing dynamics and sound.
That's some great playing/interpretation.
Very soulful interpretation. Thank you
one of the best interpretations that was given to me to hear thank you for sharing this moment of grace with us
Beautiful arrangement, expertly played. Thank you for sharing
Absolutely gorgeous rendition of this suite, and wonderful phrasing and dynamics. Thank you for sharing!
Splendid! Very fresh, inspired, full of Bach's spirit, full of music! Thank you!
This is great playing and a very nice quality recording. That lute has great tonality. I've recently discovered the lute on TH-cam and think is cool! I wish more people played it.
they take forever to tune. I think that's the main limiting factor. Even harp-guitar, which is the modern equivalent, is pretty rare.
@@tomswiftyphilo2504 If you're tuning them from scratch it takes a long time but once in tune they're not too bad. They go out of tune faster than guitars but if you play every day you don't have to spend too much time on tuning (as long as you don't want to play pieces in very different keys on the same lute). Another limiting factor is the expense. They're aren't, to my knowledge, any inexpensive (playable) 13 course lutes for beginners. One big advantage of the baroque lute, though, is that music originally written for lute (e.g. Weiss) is generally easier to play on the lute than on the guitar.
@@bvgdez noted. I, for one am glad lute players make the effort.
Hello Klaudyna,
Tout est beau y compris évidemment la prise de son. Avec une si jolie photographie de vous en plan
fixe, j'ai des regrets de ne pas vous voir une vidéo, la musique que vous faites et vous même en mouvement ! Vive la Pologne et ses citoyens si sympathiques.
Que placer escuchar esta musica y que interpretacion! 🌸🌸
Great rendition and cover pic !. I've been struggling for many years playing this on the guitar
Beautiful playing, especially the ornamentation were wisely chosen and applied.
I really love your interprétation !! Thank you very much i m waiting for your next videoss!
Excellent rendition maybe the best that i Heard, thanks you Madam Professor !!
...az dusza plasa. Piekne dzieki, Klaudyna. Prosze o wiecej takich nagran!
Pozdrowienia z Akwizgranu!
Great performance! Congratulations!!!
Pięknie zagrane.
Muy bella interpretación Klaudyna
Wowwwwww, wonderfull!!!!!👍💞
Awesome! The best thing to begin my day! Exquisite interpretation!
Gorgeous ! And playing is fantastic too.
Congratulations for this recording! I agree very much with the phrasing and tempo, for me will be a authentic reference, all the best for you!
Great! A really brilliant performance! I like the meditative pace: it is enchanting! Thank you so much!
INCREDIBLE TONE
beautifuuuuul! thanks for sharing :D greetings from Argentina
Pure elegance.
can't have enough
so great!
Thank you, I'm glad to hear! :)
@@klaudynazonierek3598 ❤️
your interpretation of Bach is so deep and wonderful. your lute sounds touch my soul. thank you
Odlicna interpretacija. Kompliment madam i lijepi pozdrav iz Hrvatske.
Bardzo piekne dziekuje
Sublime and Beautiful
I love it. So glad I stumbled across this. Thank you for sharing.
Hermosas notas barrocas de un laúd antiguo y fiel...gracias.
Pięknie. Gratulacje!
Fantastisch gute Interpretation! Bravo bravissimo!!!
Ładne jest to, co Pani robi.
Perfection... Have put as background while working, and had to stop working :)
Thank You.
Great sound!
Bravo. I play also this suite, among some others of Bach. Very good, young Madam. Greetings from Croatia.
Thank you and greetings from Poland. :)
Brava!!! Fantastic playing!! ❤️
Klaudyna, sad I can't find you on Spotify!
Sorry, I'm only on Bandcamp..