17th century? Hmm... didn't Poland conquer Moscow at the time? Trying to install a false czar (Demetrius)? It didn't work out, though... Then there was Napoleon. After that, the Germans in 1914. Followed by the Allied forces in 1918/19. Then, the Poles in 1920. Finally, Hitler.
Really struck by that story of the Ukrainian who was injured and lost two friends in the Carpathians due to unexploded ordinance from WW1. My heart hurts. So many of my closest friends have a very special affection for the Carpathians and that region of the country, including one, currently serving in the forces, who owns land there and wants to return there in peacetime to reconnect with their roots. I think regularly about how it will take decades to de-mine Ukraine; it is now the nation with the most mines in the world. This will require a multinational effort, lots of money, time, and bravery to do, as regardless of de-mining equipment, it is not a task without its dangers, and it is likely not just mines, but other unexploded ordinance may be present from the prolonged conflict in the Donbas.
Ukrainians also fought at the Western front of the 1st world war as part of Russian expeditionary forces sent to prop up the French (some 20,000 soldiers).My grand, grand, grand father was one of the grenadiers mobilised near Kyiv and took part in the battle of Verdun. He returned to Ukraine when revolution broke out and was executed by bolsheviks for organising an uprising in Brovary in mid 20s....
Thanks for another great episode. I tune in every day in the USA for your news updates, keen insight, and fascinating guests. Slava Ukraini! USA 💙 Ukraine 💛 UK
Bagging your enemy (china)to stop NK, is one way to deal with problem, but leads to US humiliation Another, is to give Ukraine what they need and lift restrictions ! Deterrence and fear of escalation only makes the matter worst! N.Korea already developed what they shouldn’t because of toothless American geo-politics
I just wanted to commend Dom for a very excellent eulogy for his coworker David Knowles, I think that was one of the finest tributes I have heard anyone deliver and a well done job, thanks Dom.
I find the First World War really fascinating, in a way the Great War continues today. The Second, First & Cold can easily be seen as the same conflict, with Orwellian switching, which continues. Sadly it’s centred on a country with the potential to be the a peaceful powerhouse of Europe, (not needing to force external resources)
Francis brings up a great point that procovsk is no longer a hub of any activity Since all of the regions it used to be a hub for, no longer have any military forces to support nor any ammunition to send them if they were still there.
Yeah, sure. N Korea’s recent history of illegal wars, occupations, regime change, and proxy wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria, Yugoslavia etc. is a legitimate cause for concern.
How selfish is Zelenski asking South Korea to supply arms for them? North Korea is supporting Russia, we don't want to get involved and get into another world war with the North. please leave us alone!
All russian advance is marginal since it's occurring along the edge of the front line. It has marginally moved from the russian border to the dnipre river. The marginal movement will continue westward To the border of poland if necessary.
It has to do with their progress relative to their resources, and expectations of modern militaries capabilities. Russia is suffering losses - and yielding the kind of results - that would never be tolerated in a modern western army.
In a previous episode they went over how some of the defenses (not sure where) where built by civilians with little military input and they where in poor locations, like in a field next to a treeline and where quickly abandoned for areas with better natural cover so I hope they don't make those mistakes again
@@sammiller6631That's a great question and the answer is yes. Both those cities were considered fortresses constructed on top of fortresses built decades ago. That's why anything rapidly built today will probably not survive.
Did i hear that right? A Ukrainian army General saying our front has crumbled..and that message being echoed by Ukraine the Latest moreover by Francis Durnley...Now these surely must be the biblical times mentioned when a Lion will sit with a lamb in a Den..😂😂
As incoherent as strategic causes of war often appear, ultimately wars are about resources. The defender has them, the attackers both want them and are prepared to use violent measures to achieve that aim. The Russia/Ukraine war is no different.
Well, if Trump gets in he can have a word with his chums Putin and Kim to calm it down, then Trump will be a hero to the world yayayay, Trump, he did it!!
Not like the Telegraph to one day have a guest on talking about demonstrations in Georgia the next day scoff about the idea of the west encouraging demonstrations then the next day have another guest on talking about the plans to interfere in the Georgian political process
🇺🇦❓ВІЙНА ЦЕ МИР, А СВОБОДА ЦЕ РАБСТВО? Україні хочуть реалізувати антиутопію Орвела роман 84? Чому неприймають не зупиняють геноцид в Україні, як в Косово та неприймають до Нато та ЄС? Скільки ще має загинути українського населення народу?
Just amazed at how much of an echo chamber this and other podcasts on all sides of the issues have become. I guess that is how the world eventually falls apart and perhaps it is ok, as long as it does not lead to more violence and wars.
Absolutely no chance of Sth Korea sending arms to Ukraine. The Sth Korean people would bring down the government. This idear is very very unpopular and the Sth Korean president is just hanging on.
The Big and bloody wolf of Europe, with all her size she puts up a fight, but then it would be another thing in all her slumber is she picked up any skill.
She sits at the edges of civilization, but where she sits is an empire of crumbling an archaic only fit for her understanding. The bloody wolf of Europe her name is Russia and her wounds richly deserved. The day most certainly will see her demise, but to what lies after, what has it nursed in her? What will be in mournings wait?
The UK budget ''included 3 Billion pounds of guarenteed Military Support to Ukraine per year....for as long as it takes.'' UK Pensioners have been leaping with joy at this announcement with the energy of amphetimined teenagers.
![BABYMONSTER - 'DRIP' M/V REACTION [WAS NOT EXPECTING THIS!!!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t0Lpgr1jo3Y/mqdefault.jpg)
Winnipeg Manitoba Canada 🇨🇦🇺🇦
Alberta 🇨🇦❤️🇺🇦
Slava Ukraini
💙💛
Russia: promoting global instability since the 17th century and Europe’s last remaining feudal empire.
Said hitler and napoleon.
@ Yeah, Zelensky’s massive invasion of Europe is really telling. 🤦♂️
@@Interglacial_optimist what exactly did napoleon say?
17th century? Hmm... didn't Poland conquer Moscow at the time? Trying to install a false czar (Demetrius)? It didn't work out, though... Then there was Napoleon. After that, the Germans in 1914. Followed by the Allied forces in 1918/19. Then, the Poles in 1920. Finally, Hitler.
@@sammiller6631 "Not tonight Josephine, I'm watching football."
SLAVA UKRAINE!
Excellent reporting.
Really struck by that story of the Ukrainian who was injured and lost two friends in the Carpathians due to unexploded ordinance from WW1. My heart hurts. So many of my closest friends have a very special affection for the Carpathians and that region of the country, including one, currently serving in the forces, who owns land there and wants to return there in peacetime to reconnect with their roots. I think regularly about how it will take decades to de-mine Ukraine; it is now the nation with the most mines in the world. This will require a multinational effort, lots of money, time, and bravery to do, as regardless of de-mining equipment, it is not a task without its dangers, and it is likely not just mines, but other unexploded ordinance may be present from the prolonged conflict in the Donbas.
❤Ukraine ❤
Why would people invade other peoples nations and go to war with them? That’s just like so evil
IKR
To give Russian bots jobs... while starving their own ppl.
Iran have been doing it since 1979
Everyone agrees that Russia is operating outside the international rules based order right now - there’s an arrest warrant out for Putler.
Because it was probably done to them .
Ukrainians also fought at the Western front of the 1st world war as part of Russian expeditionary forces sent to prop up the French (some 20,000 soldiers).My grand, grand, grand father was one of the grenadiers mobilised near Kyiv and took part in the battle of Verdun. He returned to Ukraine when revolution broke out and was executed by bolsheviks for organising an uprising in Brovary in mid 20s....
Bolshevik generals from the Ukraine put down the very first peasant uprising against the Reds...look up Tambov Rebellion
If I ever write an end of the world story I'd call it, Broken Buggy.
Shopping carts are almost as good as laundry buggies.
Thanks for another great episode. I tune in every day in the USA for your news updates, keen insight, and fascinating guests.
Slava Ukraini!
USA 💙 Ukraine 💛 UK
Bagging your enemy (china)to stop NK, is one way to deal with problem, but leads to US humiliation
Another, is to give Ukraine what they need and lift restrictions !
Deterrence and fear of escalation only makes the matter worst!
N.Korea already developed what they shouldn’t because of toothless American geo-politics
I just wanted to commend Dom for a very excellent eulogy for his coworker David Knowles, I think that was one of the finest tributes I have heard anyone deliver and a well done job, thanks Dom.
R.i.p. David Knowles 😢
I find the First World War really fascinating, in a way the Great War continues today. The Second, First & Cold can easily be seen as the same conflict, with Orwellian switching, which continues. Sadly it’s centred on a country with the potential to be the a peaceful powerhouse of Europe, (not needing to force external resources)
Francis brings up a great point that procovsk is no longer a hub of any activity Since all of the regions it used to be a hub for, no longer have any military forces to support nor any ammunition to send them if they were still there.
"Pokrovsk is no longer a hub of any activity" is the new version of "Pokrovsk was not strategically significant."
@@robertsteele474Not in this case. A hub is only a hub if it still supports a wheel.
The wheel is gone.
It´s spelled Pokrovsk. Sorry for the nitpicking, but spelling is useful for looking it up in a map.
@martavdz4972 Is that the russian name or the ukrainian name? It will be changing to the russian name.
@@Interglacial_optimist Therefore it is the new version of Ukraine's "Pokrovsk was not strategically significant."
Good morning Zbots, time to clock in, repeat the memo. And don't stray off message.
@@drewmalesky9869 Privit Dillweed enthusiast
Listening from Phoenix, Arizona. SLAVA UKRAINI, HEROYAM SLAVA
Sława Rosji!
Yeah, sure. N Korea’s recent history of illegal wars, occupations, regime change, and proxy wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria, Yugoslavia etc. is a legitimate cause for concern.
More that they're a weird Necrocracy that treat their people as slaves.
But sure: Whataboutery totally makes the Russia-NK axis whiter than white. 🤦
I know, right?
🤡🤡🤡
How selfish is Zelenski asking South Korea to supply arms for them? North Korea is supporting Russia, we don't want to get involved and get into another world war with the North. please leave us alone!
47:57 ...a poignant, yet true statement, Francis. Indeed, something to think about
The telegraph..,....yeah right...
Make Ukraine.
No show notes and no transcript. I wanted to look up the background of the academic interviewed about the first world war.
All russian advance is marginal since it's occurring along the edge of the front line.
It has marginally moved from the russian border to the dnipre river.
The marginal movement will continue westward To the border of poland if necessary.
@@sebastianforbes1The Polish national anthem says "Poland is not yet lost." To which must be added: "Let's try again, then!"
@@sebastianforbes1Only if donald trump allows it.
@@sebastianforbes1Greenland? New to me! But, at this stage, nothing would surprise me.
Self determination seems to make a lot of sense for Ukraine. How about for the Kurds?
"We can't verify it." - Well, if it's from the ISW, it must be true. 😊
Yes the kagens are as trustworthy as the keef post
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ever noticed, Russian advancements are always called marginal on here, no matter how far the advance ?
How far then?
It has to do with their progress relative to their resources, and expectations of modern militaries capabilities. Russia is suffering losses - and yielding the kind of results - that would never be tolerated in a modern western army.
3 years to advance a few kilometres? With recebt losses of 40,000 per month?
Yep, I'd call that marginal.
Propaganda at all times. It’s a policy.
@@JOHNMccaffrey-jc2wp It’s been 3 years and they’re still within a 20 minute drive of Donetsk/where they stated…Do the math.
All the German guy did was explain that yup, the Germans created the Ukraine. He could have added Latvia and Estonia too.
Will the defenses being rapidly constructed in prokovsk be enough?
Look at vuledar or bahkmut for your answer.
Why not look at Kyiv or Kharkiv for your answer instead? Did vuledar or bahkmut even have previously constructed defences before battles began?
In a previous episode they went over how some of the defenses (not sure where) where built by civilians with little military input and they where in poor locations, like in a field next to a treeline and where quickly abandoned for areas with better natural cover so I hope they don't make those mistakes again
@@sammiller6631That's a great question and the answer is yes. Both those cities were considered fortresses constructed on top of fortresses built decades ago. That's why anything rapidly built today will probably not survive.
@@RextheDragon881 yes, I remember they going over how defences were built by civilians with little input
@RextheDragon881 Yes I remember. Contractors were ripping Off the communities paying for the defences... Sounds like america
Another brilliant breakdown of how the British empire can't stop winning.
The british empire has enslaved my country since 1707
What British empire?
British Empire doesn't exist anymore?! Russian empire.....they just changed the name and called it the RF, and they thought no one would notice!
Did i hear that right? A Ukrainian army General saying our front has crumbled..and that message being echoed by Ukraine the Latest moreover by Francis Durnley...Now these surely must be the biblical times mentioned when a Lion will sit with a lamb in a Den..😂😂
Seems like the Telegraph is finally reporting the reality, not what they would like to hear…
Propaganda for the slow.
Nah - that's Moscow State TV 😏
😂😂😂 Yes indeed 👍🏻😂😂😂
Electric bikes are quiet and cheap.
I have two of them.
Can Russia fund organisations in GB
🇬🇧🇺🇦
Thanks UTL
Welcome back Venetia!!!! Congratulations on your lil baby. Glad to hear a woman back
As incoherent as strategic causes of war often appear, ultimately wars are about resources. The defender has them, the attackers both want them and are prepared to use violent measures to achieve that aim. The Russia/Ukraine war is no different.
Or Russia doesn't want.Ukraine never did was glad when the seventeen lost them.
Then along came a nato.
These guys have to catch up on international statutes.
Everybody talks about David but nobody talks about Gonzalo Lira He was a person too
Lira, in addition was abused, tortured & died of deliberate mediacal neglect.
Gonzo liar.
To the last...I didn't say it.
Ruzzia is lost.
Это ты потеряешься маленький глупый западный папуас.
Why the strange spelling?
Blah blah blah @@Andariel083
Lost in the glory of the greatest military victory in modern times
@@loredanatagliaferri5339 бла бла-бла оставь себе. Глупый западный человек.
South Korea and WW1. Anything other than discuss the current situation, I suppose 😂😂😂😂😂😂
So ask a real dumb questions so we can say how stupid the question is so I laugh every time I hear how grate the question is
?
So North and South Korea are beefing it out ON THE CHESSBOARD EUROPE as well. We do not want the whole world playing war here
Well, if Trump gets in he can have a word with his chums Putin and Kim to calm it down, then Trump will be a hero to the world yayayay, Trump, he did it!!
IT does feel like Europe is being pushed around, bloody realists like Meershambler think we don't count because muh great power politics **** off
America does.
@@jmcw9632He’ll probably send the troops into Ukraine to help Putin. He can’t have the only country that provides him loans falling apart.
The longer we string Ukraine along, the riskier this situation get. Full support for Ukraine, now, might stem the tide.
Meat is meat for the grinder wherever it comes from…
Laundry buggies are great.
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧❤️❤️❤️
That's OK, North Korea is supplying troops to Russia, much more useful.
10,000 starving slaves from a weird Necrocracy? No thanks - would rather have indoor plumbing than this evil war. 🤷
Not like the Telegraph to one day have a guest on talking about demonstrations in Georgia the next day scoff about the idea of the west encouraging demonstrations then the next day have another guest on talking about the plans to interfere in the Georgian political process
2:38 I love how this podcast just glosses over that the Ukrainian front is collapsing.
Your channel is the only source I follow that is paying any attention to developments in Georgia. I appreciate your effort to keep us informed.
370 international observer and absolutely not even one case of voter fraud...get over it.
The Duran is far better.
In no way has dom ever laid anything out in stark reality.
Wouldn't it be much easier if we let the ISW determine the outcome of elections in Russia's periphery and Latin America?
Чем дальше от реальности, тем больнее будет столкновение с ней впоследствии.
Better luck next election.
Money laundering 🤨
🇺🇦❓ВІЙНА ЦЕ МИР, А СВОБОДА ЦЕ РАБСТВО? Україні хочуть реалізувати антиутопію Орвела роман 84? Чому неприймають не зупиняють геноцид в Україні, як в Косово та неприймають до Нато та ЄС? Скільки ще має загинути українського населення народу?
Admit we lost, move on chaps 😊
who is this "we"? 🤷🤡
Not in ukraine
Россия дошла до ручки. Украина победит одной левой.
@@sebastianforbes1russian idiom equivalent of single-handedly
Just amazed at how much of an echo chamber this and other podcasts on all sides of the issues have become. I guess that is how the world eventually falls apart and perhaps it is ok, as long as it does not lead to more violence and wars.
Yes after the extinction of the human race there will be no more wars.
Absolutely no chance of Sth Korea sending arms to Ukraine. The Sth Korean people would bring down the government. This idear is very very unpopular and the Sth Korean president is just hanging on.
2:38 Ukraine front is COLLAPSING
Col-General Marshenko: “I won’t be revealing a military secret if I say our front has crumbled”
So your plan is to ukranize Georgia
Just a hint of bahkmut.
The Big and bloody wolf of Europe, with all her size she puts up a fight, but then it would be another thing in all her slumber is she picked up any skill.
She sits at the edges of civilization, but where she sits is an empire of crumbling an archaic only fit for her understanding. The bloody wolf of Europe her name is Russia and her wounds richly deserved. The day most certainly will see her demise, but to what lies after, what has it nursed in her? What will be in mournings wait?
Ukrains first world war... not true... they fought for the germans
The UK budget ''included 3 Billion pounds of guarenteed Military Support to Ukraine per year....for as long as it takes.''
UK Pensioners have been leaping with joy at this announcement with the energy of amphetimined teenagers.