31, gay man here. I live a pretty isolated life. My mom died back in February and my dad died in 2020. Lately, I’ve been having conversations with them in my head to get their advice on things, often imagining conversations with them sitting at my kitchen table or in my living rooms. That movie made me feel seen not only with my grief, but with my struggles with depression and loneliness. It almost felt like it was made for me. Thank you for your interpretation on this beautiful film. Edit: thank you all for the beautiful messages. I come back here from time to time to read them. Thank you for sharing your stories and reaching out to console. It’s good to know there are good people in the world out there that can empathize ❤️ Love to all of you.
Hey bud! Just wanted to say that the movie also shows to acknowledge all your past and traumas and move on from it as well❤Please try your best to recover from it soon and live your life to the fullest. I hope you start socializing and take help from counselors! I wish you All The VERY Best in life and hope that you find a great partner and friends in future 🫂 ~lots of virtual hugs ,support and well wishes!❤️
@@kimjunguwu4304 you are absolutely correct. It has been a couple months and I have had time to process and talk it out with several people, including my counselor. While the movie does highlight some pretty key issues I’ve dealt with personally, to your point, it’s super important to keep in mind that healing/confronting your past in a pathway to healing is a key element of this story as well. Especially when healing and understanding your grief can allow you to be a supportive and empathetic friend and partner to those that may need us just as much as we need them, as we witnessed at the end of the movie. Thank you for saying something and for your very kind words. All the virtual hugs and well wishes back to you, my friend ❤️
It is absolutely criminal how this film and Andrew Scott in particular have been largely ignored by a lot of awards bodies. He shouldn't just have an Oscar nomination, he should be at the top of the list to win it this year.
It’s also criminal it’s not being released on DVD or Blu Ray as the distribution company say they will only allow streaming. This is such an insult to the gay community and potential audiences everywhere who would like a copy of one of the few films that does not stereotype gay people and is so wonderfully, written, directed and acted of course.
This is why I will support queer creatives as much as I can because I feel like for some time to come still only we can have each other's back. I want them to keep telling our stories and clearly even when we have achieved so much better than a lot of the films that are nominated, they will be the ones that will get to go home with all the prizes and recognition. Nothing has upset me more this year during the awards season than the way this film and Fellow Travelers got robbed. 🥺😔
I am trying to watch this discussion = which I love - but I have to stop - for now. In the realest way this is both the most heartbreaking AND the most beautiful film I think I have ever seen. And I am almost 70
@@i.t.t. Yeah, it really just hits you right in the Heart. But I'm sending you a HUGE Hug all the way from Denmark! 🤗 I hope it helps just a teeny bit. Take care ❤🩹
To Any person really i also lived half my 20s by myself alone and almost burn down my place twice and the first tough trough my mind was if i die would anyone be sad or missed me ?
To Any person really i also lived half my 20s by myself alone and almost burn down my place twice and the first tough trough my mind was if i die would anyone be sad or missed me ?
I loved the connection with Harry's 'There's vampires at my door' at the beginning of the film and Adam's soft whisper, '[I'll] keep the vampires from your door' at the end of the film.
This was soooo poetic and storytelling at its best! When you can bring something back from the beginning and have it make a new meaning/impact by the end of the film. Loved this song before but I won't be able to listen to it and not think of this now. Hauntingly beautiful ❤
Just watched this review again, months later, still tears, and how you guys discuss and emotionally engage with the movie , I felt like we were watching it together. I just missed holding someone's hand while watching that ....
I feel this movie is able to trigger every human person, because it touches the universal subject of loneliness, and the subject-fear of dying without anyone noticing. What is one of the cruelest, but realistal thing which happens unfortunately. This is the second time I watch the movie, and I still cry deeply at that moment.
The relationship between Adam and Harry is the same as the relationship between Adam and his parents, so you could say they are "ghosts". Harry died at the night after they first met.If only Adam had been brave enough to invite Harry into his apartment maybe he would still be alive. Poor Harry died in loneliness waiting for someone to find his body.
@@erics1140 He's not dead..Because he's the only one the waiter can see when he's at the restaurant with his parents and when he ordered menu family special the waiter said that the portion was too much for 1 person.
I think the moment where Adam's dad says "I love you more, somehow, now that I know you" is the most beautiful thing. Because thats the point of coming out. Knowing someone is essential to loving them fully. What a great film!
Thank you for your wonderfully sensitive reactions. You guys really surpassed yourselves! I've seen All Of Us Strangers twice in the theater now, and as a 75-year-old gay man I have to say that it is truly one of the most moving and profound films centered on our experience that I've ever had the good fortune to see. (Andrew Haigh is pretty much my favorite film director for everything he's done, and of course particularly Weekend and Looking.) I'm particularly grateful that you both make the effort to see beyond dualities of sad/happy, black/white, etc. because life encompasses both great joy and great sorrow, and because as human beings we have the CHOICE, moment to moment, to open our hearts to LOVE -- both giving and receiving it. I hope those who watch your commentary, and who haven't yet seen the film, will go see it. Thank you again, and BE WELL.
I'm a couple of years older than Adam, and relate so hard to the movie. One of the things that I think is harder for younger generations to understand, is the extent to which being gay was only ever defined in terms of sex for so many, despite our internal sense that it's about love, hence the dislocation and uncertainty around "am I in love?" That, coupled with the knowledge that sex was fatal; I do not miss the 80s.
Said exactly what I was thinking: I'm Gen X, and intimacy seemed about sex=disease=death in the 80s/90s and not true love, note Adam's mother saying "it will be such a hard life." Actually, I never recovered from the trauma.
i recently watched an interview with claire foy and andrew scott on a podcast, and claire said something so insightful about how when a parent dies before their child, not only doesnthe child miss out on having that parent, but that the parent also misses out on seeing their child grow up. i’m absolutely butchering her eloquent way of wording things, but that statement made me want to cry.
In case no one has mentioned it yet, I think Adam was probably dead the whole time as well (lmao, sorry). There are many references to fire throughout the whole movie, but the most telling ones in my opinion are the fire alarm at the beginning (with Harry saying 'it will be real one of these days'), and Adam being hot throughout the movie and coughing a lot when he's upset (when they first kiss he also says he forgot to breathe etc.), so I think he died in a fire in his building. Also the whole vibe of the film is really giving purgatory in my opinion with the editing and sound design and just the whole disorienting structure, plus some other small things, like Adam waking up and asking 'how is it still Sunday?' So in my interpretation Adam and Harry are both something like ghosts who can't move on until they find each other and help each other heal :)
Siiiii, re-viendo a peli, tambien pienso que Adam muere en algun momento y creo que lo que dices es tremendamente acertado...yo pensé en algun momento al volver a ver la peli que fue en la fiesta, donde se ve solo, que ahi debe haber muerto de sobredosis o algo asi, pero siiii, Adam con fiebre durante la peli y lo otro que comentas, tiene mucho mas sentido....
My thoughts exactly !!!! Adam had to be dead also for them to become a beautiful star together ... I felt joy for Adam getting time with his parents and finding love with Harry....
Not possible, because the waitress sees him in the diner when he's saying goodbye to his parents. That's why she's mildly surprised that he orders the family special.
10:00 yes, it was directed by a queer person (and i agree, it showed) and more than that, andrew haigh used elements of his life to create this movie; btw all of us strangers was shot in the actually childhood house where andrew haigh lived
You two coped better than me, i nearly had to be carried out of the cinema, i cried whole way home, all the next day, my straight son cried, didnt sleep that night and cried the whole next day, this film should have gotten every award going, its the best film iv seen in a few years kudas to both actors, love andrew scott ❤❤❤❤ xx
This is such a devastating and beautiful film! I saw it in the theater and was just speechless afterward. One thing that really knocked me sideways was when his dad basically told him if he'd been a kid at his school he'd have probably bullied him. Sometimes a kids parents are their first bullies, and it's rarely been discussed so openly before, I think. I dunno, that whole scene really stuck with me, including when his dad apologized for not coming in his room when he was crying. I would give anything to hear my parents say they were sorry for certain parts of my upbringing. This whole movie was so powerful. It deserves all the awards!
This was my favourite film of 2023. Between this, Fellow Travelers, Heartstopper, Good Grief, and to a lesser extent even Red, White & Royal Blue (happy romcom focused on a gay relationship for once), gay media has been really helping me heal my trauma lately. It's allowing me to confront it and see what I didn't get in my own experience and to see what I needed. All of Us Strangers destroyed me the first time. I saw it with a full audience at the cinema and had to try and stifle ugly crying. All of the conversations he has with his parents could have been lifted from my own life. My parents are still alive but my coming out isn't something we ever really talk about and I had to figure out so much on my own. I got bullied and picked on growing up for many years by so many of my classmates. Over time it started to change me and family members noticed but nobody said anything or helped. That conversation he has with his dad and when his dad says "sorry I never came into your room when you were crying" and the way his voice breaks, I needed to hear that for myself, I was welling up in that moment. My mother had a bit of that AIDS fear that Adam's mother had, same kind of worries about what life would be like for me, both parents emotionally absent. The final conversation he has with them at the diner, hearing his dad say he was proud of him for making it through and then the way his mom says "such a kind and gentle boy", people have referred to me that way, it hit me so hard, I was crying so hard at that point. So many things said that I needed to hear. When the film was over, the crowd in the theatre took awhile to get up and start exiting, everyone was just kind of in this stunned emotional silence. I would have maybe changed the ending, maybe have Adam and Harry together as these 2 lonely people that found each other in this world.
I was able to see this in a theater about a month ago and it is still with me. I was almost disappointed that I didn’t have a more immediate reaction in the theater. But when I got to my car, it started hitting me in waves. And continues to now. This film is so impactful and mature in the way it deals with and what it says about loss, grief, depression and loneliness. Truly the best picture of 2023. That it got completely snubbed by the Academy is truly criminal.
I was anxious to see your reactions, since I spent two hours staring into space after I finished seeing this at the movies. And I would listen to Andrew Scott reading the phone book and he deserved every award in the book for this performance.
This not just a great LGTB film. It is a great film, period. You do not have to be gay to take a lot from this piece. It's simply an astounding piece of work.
Loved this reaction. The whole cinema was quietly crying by the end of this when I went to see it. It is just so beautifully tender and Andrew Scott conveys that so brilliantly. I can't believe he didn't get a Bafta nomination.
I watched this on a plane and the tears just didn't stop flowing out. I couldn't do anything but look into the screen and just go through the journey and cry almost the whole movie. It was both mesmerizing and so, so sad. I saw myself in it; it touched a place in my heart I didn't know was THIS tender. Thanks for helping me relive it!
I love how you both immediately just got this film, but what I find most impressive is that you were able to speak coherently afterwords. I was speechless for a long ass time after that ended. We drove home from the theater trying to talk about it but sobbing all over again 😂 grateful for you two ❤️
From the time that this film was first advertised, I knew that his parents were dead. I never realized that his neighbor past that first scene was a ghost as well. Wow. Everyone gave outstanding performances, but Andrew Scott's was so many level's above everyone else's I think.
I'm straight and found this film really touching I don't normally watch these kinds of videos but it was interesting to see this perspective a lot of the things you said gave me a deeper understanding as people of this community
Such a beautiful movie. Broke my heart. The end when you realize that Harry had died the first night and could have been saved if Adam let him in just broke me. The most amazing performances and am absolutely fuming that the movie and performances were not nominated for Oscars.
I am probably older than most people responding here AND a harsh critic about every Art but I really have to say this may be the 'best' - not even the right word - and definitely for me right now - the most beautiful film I have ever seen. It absolutely deserved an Oscar
I guess I grew up at the same time as the main character. The details of that time were just chefs' kiss perfect. I loved this film. I watched it last night, and i still keep feeling waves of emotions about the experience. Really, this is a film that feels like it is directly speakjng to me. A triumph.
Your last conversation really made me tear up. Your channel is so so important and needs even more recognition than it already has!!! I’m sure a lot of people seek hope and find it in your channel….I sure do!! Thank you Alex and Josh #youareloved
Watched it again with you guys. Adam is a screenwriter and he wrote a play to get through his past trauma. When he’s ready to love, and go looking for Harry. Harry passed away from alcohol and overdose that night when Adam denied him company. Sad sad story. 😭
I watched this film with my sister and father- we were all sobbing by the end, but each of us for completely different emotional reasons. I think that’s what’s beautiful about this film- it heals so many things for so many different experiences 😢
This movie broke me. Such an incredibly powerful story of love and loss. I expected nothing less with Andrew Haig at the helm. He’s such a talented filmmaker. Loved seeing your reactions to it. You guys are the best. ❤️ from CT, USA
I didn't cry at the ending when I first saw it the other day. Not because I wasn't affected, more because I was so affected I was past the point of being able to cry. As a straight woman, I can't relate in the same way to the LGBTQ+ element, even though I can have very strong feelings for it...but this film had so much more than just that. It was relatable in so many ways, so close to home. I agree with Alex that love isn't always an easy emotion to understand or recognise, i've had many times in my life where I have thought I don't know if what i'm feeling is love because i'm not sure I know what love feels like. No one can tell you what love is, I suppose, because its going to be unique to that person, but that doesn't help you when you can't recognise it in yourself. And for me, not recognising what loving someone feels like has made it very hard to understand how it feels to be loved by someone else. I sobbed through this reaction video, which was very much needed after being hit so hard by the film on first watch, so thank you.
I'm a straight woman too. I still can't articulate my feelings or explain my thoughts about this film. Achingly beautiful. I want everyone I know to watch it but ... there is so much pain here ... for me ultimately - sounds contrite - soul-affirming. But so painful to watch. I don't know how to prepare anyone in a kind way. And yet ... I think everyone must see this film. Especially the people I love
Not me crying at this again...I don't know how I managed to keep it more together in the cinema! As a queer person who is often lonely this really resonated with me. Absolutely beautiful film.
This movie brings out all the "baggage" that you didn't know you were carrying,makes you hear words that you didn't know that you needed to hear,reminds you of all the things you needed for yourself but forgot about,all words you want to say but can't get out but knowing that this movie touched so many people and really exquisitely depicts the life experiences that we all go through as queer or not but never really get to say outloud because of shame or whatever and it really dived deep into queer experiences that no lqgbt content that i know of has manage to depict so beautifully. Really loved it❤❤❤
As someone who lost the parents last year and didn't come out to them. this movie was a shock. I had to pause it so so many times because I was crying so hard I couldn't keep going. The idea of seeing and talking to your parents are a dream come true and to say goodbye to them again to going on is a nightmare. I must say after this movie I back to rails and start taking care of myself again. It helped me to get out of a hole I was trapped and graving myself into it. Today I watched it again, come to this video and saw this beautiful reaction... Unfortunately this is the only place I (and many of us) can be ourselves... Specially when you didn't come out yet... This still can be a lonely way of living but I appreciate places like this exist
I saw this a few weeks ago, and I keep going back to it, thinking about it, watching interviews with the cast and creators. Just such a powerful important film. I'm a straight female (and a mum) and I saw it with my fiancee, we were both just so blown away by it. We both got in the car in silence and then he played the power of love while we drove home. I lay awake that night just processing the whole film. Truly haven't had a film affect me so much in a long time. The performances were sublime, each of the four cast members deserves to be recognised for their work in this film, and Andrew Scott particularly was just everything. He's so subtle and yet every movement and inflection carries weight. Paul Mescal was heartbreaking and the parents, wow! Particularly as a parent I just crumbled watching them. The writer/director has truly created the most unusual and lingering piece of work here. You can tell the whole film in sprinkled in his life's experiences and the ability for him to trust his cast so implicitly (for very evident reason) and not rely on jumpy cuts etc and rather just simple direction gives this an even more realistic feel which allows the viewers to be pulled in even more. I had a creeping apprehension that Harry was similar to the parents. I started to get quite uneasy when Adam woke up in his childhood home in the kids pyjamas as initially the print looked like a hospital robe to me. It dawned on me that there was more to come and him preparing to say goodbye to his parents again was going to echo with Harry too. When he got out of the elevator I knew what he would find and just whispered "no, no, no" apparently. I didn't know how else to cope. I feel that Adam was actually dead too, in some kind of waiting room/purgatory, that he was destined to meet Harry and they both help each other. There are lots of instances of red light being used, him living high up above everyone else, mentions of him supposed to be in the car, him not seeing his mum when she woke up/after the accident, his unawareness of time in a way, him in an otherwise empty building. These two had to fall in love to heal, it didn't matter if it was in this life or not. Perhaps I have read too much into it, but I can't decide if he dies as a child or later as a result of all the trauma he has dealt with. I want to see it again to understand it more, but I'm not sure I can manage that just yet. It was so important to hear your point of view and your commentary about just how important some of the story was in a way I can understand but not fully relate to and it helped my understanding of the film even more. Thank you.
I agree with you, only I think Adam died in a fire, part way through the film (there are various mentions of him being hot and him coughing frequently). I think his ghost found Harry's body and that they decide to be together, forever.
Watching this movie in a fine arts theater was just heart wrenching. So many people openly crying and sobbing. A beautiful film for sure. ANDREW SCOTT is brilliant. I'm glad you guys did this important film.
I have been looking forward to watching this again with you. I saw it at the cinema on Tuesday with a friend. I haven’t been so moved by a film for a very long time. So many layers. So many tears! Just beautiful. Heartbreaking but beautiful.
I just found this beautiful movie in 2024. I watched it three days ago and have not been able to get it out of my mind. So I decided to do some research online. Watching your take on it was one of the better critiques I could find. I’m a 59 year old female. I’ve lost both my parents and my husband. I could relate 100% with this movie, the grief and loneliness. The want for connection and acceptance. The sex scenes were beautiful and I feel important for all people to see romantic love in all forms. The title is intriguing. To me it means, even though we’re all strangers. We all just need love. I love you all.❤
Thanks for letting me watch this again with you both. Saw it in the theatre in January and ugly cried then - it’s such a masterpiece. Having your emotional and intelligent commentary along with it was really a treat
Regarding the coming out scene to his mother, and you already touched upon it but it’s all his inner dialogue, a visualization of trauma of that generation! Such a punch in the gut. I went into this screening with a couple of colleagues and we were all wrecked by the end and totally out of it for the next couple of days. This gets under your skin and stays there. Extraordinary storytelling and performances!
Needed to see others go through the waves and emotions of this film. I just saw it yesterday at the cinema. And that ending my gosh. Thank you for sharing ❤
Yeah as someone who Maladaptively daydreams I related to this movie a LOT... As it really really seems like that is what the main character is doing... Obviously his daydreams are significantly more detailed and life-like than mine, most of the time... But if I get high on weed my daydreams get significantly more vivid. To the point where I can absolutely start crying because of whatever sad thing is happening in them. Most of the time my daydreams are pleasant...but not always... just like the main charater. Yeah I don't know if that was the intention of the writer ...but that's really what looked like was happening to me very intense daydreams and dissociation.
As a not queer gran from South Africa have to say your review was heartwarming. I absolutely loved this movie, everything from script, mood, premise, acting. The two main leads were astonishing but Andrew Scott is mesmerising.
Probably one of the best reaction videos I’ve ever watched - both of you are so true to yourselves in allowing the raw portrayal of your emotional reaction. The film itself, of course, is a masterpiece.
30:45 broke my heart, that line about having each other and fighting didnt matter…literally made me gasp for air and I just began to cry. Fuckin wonderful scene! 😢❤
Just watched the film and was consistently blown away by so many scenes, including during my WTF reaction at the end…& then immediately came here to watch your coverage of it. Such fantastic writing, all the acting was terrific, especially Scott, omfg.
I’m a straight person and I loved this movie so much. It was beautiful and heartbreaking, romantic and sexy. I am the same age as Andrew. I have queer friends and it hurts my heart when I think about anything cruel they have endured because of ignorance and hate. Everyone should see this movie. As Andrew says “Prejudice doesn’t survive proximity.” So glad I watched your reaction, it gives me insight into things that just wouldn’t occur to me as a straight person. Well done. Love from Canada ❤
Thank you for providing a platform for the representation I never saw and for showing the joy, laughter, hope, sadness and pain and showcasing the depth and breadth of the LGBTQ+ experience. Thank you for not shying away from the difficult parts but equally embracing and sharing the joyful moments. From one end of the spectrum of heartstopper to this, it is all so important and so appreciated. The only narratives I did see were coming out stories often with negative outcomes so seeing such an incredible constellation of the Queer experience has been truly life affirming and laughing along and crying with you both has really made experiencing all these forms of representation all the more impactful.
That feeling of coming out to your parents in your mind multiple times like test runs, and having the version of your parents in your mind be accepting and willing to learn more about you. Only to see the exact opposite in real life, oof. Can't wait to watch this for myself!
Just watched it in the cinema 1 hour ago, I don't want to let go of it, loved it, so I went to youtube looking for people who did any reactions or reviews :DD Lovely reaction!
sat in the cinema until the credits had finished just staring at the screen. had absolutely no words to explain how i felt, this movie is so incredibly beautiful and emotional. your reactions and conversations brought me back to that!
I've loved Andrew Haigh ever since I watched Weekend and Looking, but this film really is something else. Personally I think Adam is dying throughout the film and that's how he can see "ghosts". If you look at some of the imagery used it stronly invokes fire. And then of course there's the fire alarm at the beginning of the film and Harry saying "one day that alarm's gonna be for real" during their first meeting. Adam being hot and not being able to breathe at various points in the film. And then like you commented that shot where out his window you see what look like sirens, but maybe are the club lights.. And then of course at the end they become a star, which also suggests to me they're both dead at that point. I'm not yet sure if that interpretation makes me feel better or worse though. But I think this film is such a beautiful exploration of grief and loneliness that I think anybody can relate to. Truly a masterpiece of cinema.
I think Andrew Haigh said people had expressed similar thoughts to him and he hadn't thought of it like that but that he wanted people to believe what they wanted to believe about it all. I read it after watching it and was quite surprised that he hadn't considered people would draw this conclusion...like you say, the imagery was there. The fire alarm, him feeling hot, the coughing, the screaming, the image out the window...I thought exactly the same that this was what they were hinting at. I suppose though, if it was all a fire, then the Harry storyline doesn't really make sense because why show his death from alcohol and drugs, lying undiscovered for days all because Adam didn't let him in after the fire alarm. Haigh at least did confirm Harry was alive when he came to the door. Whether Adam is dead or alive, is up to the viewer to choose as far as Haigh seemed concerned.
@@jner7149 Thank you for that, I was wondering what Haigh thought of the "fire theory" / if it was intended that way. I don't like the thought of it, cause it would mean Adam lost his parents as a child, lived a lonely life, never fell in love and then died alone in a fire. That's just cruel
I saw it a few weeks ago and was stuck in my seat for at least 15 minutes afterwards! A truly sublime film! Also the film was directed by Andrew Haigh who wrote and directed Looking, so awkward gay stuff is his thing. Have you ever seen Weekend?. If not, you should! P.s you made me cry damn you!
Great analysis, guys. Loved it. Ugnnnnn, those wrong subtitles were driving me insane while we were watching it, and they’re still pissing me off. Some of them are hilariously wrong.
I’m slowly coming out as a bisexual man. I have also lost my mom tragically and it took me 9 years to accept the fact I never told her that I enjoyed the company of both men and women. It’s been a very lonely life for me, I’m only 28 and I feel as if I already died. But reality hit me a month ago and I said, “I’m ready to start a new life.” I’m prepared to lose my friends, my religion, and even my way. But man I can’t wait to be free This movie made me cry and feel so seen
I literally watched this movie last night and had no idea what I was going to get but omg I was devastated by this. It really messed me up for the rest of the night
Hey guys! I am glad I found you. I am an old Gay man, most of my friends have passed on. Now I have two new young Gay men in my life (so to speak). Thanks for sharing your reactions to the film. I watched it alone, I missed some of it. Loved seeing your emotions. Thanks again.
this movie shattered my heart and im still not healed 😭 the way the end scene explain the whole thing harry said whilst drunk in the beginning had me sobbing 😢😢6
Oh I’m so excited for thissss! Been waiting ever since you mentioned it in a livestream chat, 40 mins too!! 💖 it’s one of those movies where either you ‘get’ it or not, the imagination of the viewer with regards to which parts were real and when upon first watch changes the impact it has I believe
I so appreciate your take on this movie, it's been a revelation listening to you talk. You've helped me identify feelings and experiences in my own life that I hadn't been able to articulate myself. I am an older autistic person. We were/are not allowed to be ourselves, to express ourselves authentically. When his mother said, you don't look gay, that's something i hear all the time (replace gay with autistic). The bullying at school, the pressure to conform. What I take away from this is that I too am Queer. I'm not sure if I am 'allowed' to say that, but as an autistic person I feel that I could belong more comfortably in queer spaces than any other.
This movie taught me to treasure and take care of the people around me, to be kind to everyone (even and perhaps especially strangers) and that fear should not stop me from doing so Thank you guys, your brave beautiful gay men ❤
Fun watching this film with you guys. As a GenX'er, it surprising to see how you guys reacted to the scene he came out to his mom. He sumed up my feelings as just "everything is different now, Mom". I never thought younger gens would think too much about it and all the awkwardness of it. I guess I was wrong.
A long time ago I read a book by Taichi Yamada and it blew my mind. Even gifted it to people. I didn't realize until just before I watched it that this film is also bases on one of his books. I'm so happy I did though because I knew to be guided by my feelings instead of logic. It's what makes it work so beautifully. What's most masterful about this film for me though is that unlike many great filmmakers who take on a Japanese work and somehow never quite succeed in conveying the right atmosphere and feel and other elements that I can't quite verbalise, this film managed to get that special vibe about it while still making it appealing to a Western audience and, and in such a way that it is both relatable to them and deeply affects them. I liked watching this review because I could see in real time how. I also enjoyed seeing that we felt the same about many parts of the film although we didn't quite guess what was going to happen at the same time. You caught on to a few things well before I did 😅 I must say, I really appreciated hearing some of your thoughts too. You somehow always have something deep or meaningful to say which either makes me feel deeply understood or offers me a new perspective. So happy I found you. One more reason to be thankful to Fellow Travelers, it seems.
I took a long time time, spent days and weeks thinking about it after I’ve seen it. What an insightful thing watching it through your eyes, thank you so much ❤❤❤
@@zanyzander Its great. I own all three of those on blu-ray. Criterion is putting out a blu-ray disk for All Of Us Strangers. Of course this wasn't announced until after I bought a copy from the UK where they have it on disk, unlike here in the US where it has only been streaming until the Criterion comes out in Sept.
@@AStoryWorthTelling it’s 2 weeks later and I’ve watched this a few times with you now. I cried right along with you both once again during that powerful ending. Two things that gives me peace is that Harry wasn’t alone when he was able to move on. And Adam got to learn what true love feels like. Thanks Guys
It took me weeks to recover from this movie. It's the loudest collective sobbing I've ever heard in a theatre, we were all a mess & no one got up until the credits were over.
I have so many thoughts after watching this film. It was really helpful to watch this with you boys to unpack some of those thoughts and feelings. You are doing the lords work in these streets.
Watched this with my wife the other evening - I think it's such a powerful film for a variety of reasons and has many elements to which one can relate to. Being parents to a 4 year old boy and a 1 year old there were a few scenes which absolutely destroyed me emotionally. Particularly with Adam and his mother in bed... tragic. And that final scene, that last reveal was just devestating... what a beautiful film
I just watched this move a few days ago. And now that I’m almost recovered, I decided to find reactions to it. Thank you for this beautiful reaction. The gut punch at the end when we find out Harry has been dead since the first night he visited Adam’s apartment… (yes viewers have questioned if that was the case, it is as confirmed by the director. And yes Adam is alive, not also a ghost)… was so devastating. I cried for a whole night.
This is by far Andrew Haigh's best film to date. I considered "Weekend" one of my absolute favorite gay films ever (which he directed) but "All of Us Strangers" has by far surpassed it.
Every time I watch a clip of the final scene, I ugly cry. I can see myself in Harry so much. When I'm gone, I wish no part of me has to stick around in anxious despair for someone to find my body.
Volvi a llorar nuevamente al ver su reacción, es tan triste la soledad que viene muchas veces con mostrarse como es uno mismo con la familia, que te ignoren o no se hable mas del tema y ademas como el dolor y la culpa que puede seguirnos hasta el presente en cosas que nos fueron ocurriendo en nuestra vida :( me paso que cuando le conte a mi mamá sobre la chica de quien estaba enamorada, recibi una reaccion de rechazo y duda y preguntas de ella de que quizas yo estaba confundiendo las cosas, lo que hizo que estuviera confundida años acerca de mi sexualidad y deje ir a la persona que amaba en parte por eso y por el peso social mental que cargaba de por medio... y ver esta peli me llego al corazón, porque tal como lo dicen ustedes, si una no puede amarse a si misma, como vas a amar a alguien mas? e imagina teniendo que vivir la emocion de estar enamorada, pero al mismo tiempo estar descubriendo tu sexualidad asi mismo y ser vista rara en la calle o dentro de tu propia familia/amigos que quizas iban a criticarte y opinar... fue horrible y sé que muchas personas actualmente lo viven tambien D: Quiero decir que tal como Fellow Travelers y Young Royals, All of Us Strangers siento que me cambio la vida, y nunca olvidaré la primera vez que la vi (al igual que FT y YR) porque son de esos proyectos que te llegan mas adentro del corazon y del alma, que dejan cicatriz en ti y te hacen llorar y disfrutar como la primera vez...por eso lamento tanto que no siempre tengan el reconocimiento que se merecen, porque son ejemplos de vida para muchos de nosotros y nos dan herramientas y nos hacen sentir vivos nuevamente.... Ojala esta pelicula se vuelva de culto, porque te deja simplemente sin palabras
Bravo, gentlemen 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Your reaction and review were spot on🎯 You navigated the complexity and delicate nuance of this heartbreakingly hopeful masterpiece so well. ❤️🩹
I think love is an amplified emotional connection to other person. Like when he is happy - you are 100 times happier, and when he is sad you are devastated.
31, gay man here.
I live a pretty isolated life.
My mom died back in February and my dad died in 2020. Lately, I’ve been having conversations with them in my head to get their advice on things, often imagining conversations with them sitting at my kitchen table or in my living rooms.
That movie made me feel seen not only with my grief, but with my struggles with depression and loneliness. It almost felt like it was made for me.
Thank you for your interpretation on this beautiful film.
Edit: thank you all for the beautiful messages. I come back here from time to time to read them. Thank you for sharing your stories and reaching out to console. It’s good to know there are good people in the world out there that can empathize ❤️
Love to all of you.
You're not alone
I hope u find a nice man mate
@@xzxzxccxzcw2028 thank you, all the best to you ❤️
Hey bud! Just wanted to say that the movie also shows to acknowledge all your past and traumas and move on from it as well❤Please try your best to recover from it soon and live your life to the fullest. I hope you start socializing and take help from counselors! I wish you All The VERY Best in life and hope that you find a great partner and friends in future 🫂
~lots of virtual hugs ,support and well wishes!❤️
@@kimjunguwu4304 you are absolutely correct. It has been a couple months and I have had time to process and talk it out with several people, including my counselor. While the movie does highlight some pretty key issues I’ve dealt with personally, to your point, it’s super important to keep in mind that healing/confronting your past in a pathway to healing is a key element of this story as well. Especially when healing and understanding your grief can allow you to be a supportive and empathetic friend and partner to those that may need us just as much as we need them, as we witnessed at the end of the movie.
Thank you for saying something and for your very kind words. All the virtual hugs and well wishes back to you, my friend ❤️
It is absolutely criminal how this film and Andrew Scott in particular have been largely ignored by a lot of awards bodies. He shouldn't just have an Oscar nomination, he should be at the top of the list to win it this year.
Absolutely agreed.
True!
This is injustice! Such a brilliant actor!
It’s also criminal it’s not being released on DVD or Blu Ray as the distribution company say they will only allow streaming. This is such an insult to the gay community and potential audiences everywhere who would like a copy of one of the few films that does not stereotype gay people and is so wonderfully, written, directed and acted of course.
Yes, it's the best performance of the year for sure.
This is why I will support queer creatives as much as I can because I feel like for some time to come still only we can have each other's back.
I want them to keep telling our stories and clearly even when we have achieved so much better than a lot of the films that are nominated, they will be the ones that will get to go home with all the prizes and recognition. Nothing has upset me more this year during the awards season than the way this film and Fellow Travelers got robbed. 🥺😔
This movie just broke me..
"How come no one found me"😢😢 this line will haunt me forever
That part was heartbreaking. So bloody sad 😭
The response is the one that shook me. In the best way possible.
I found you.
They found each other.
It gets me every time.
I am trying to watch this discussion = which I love - but I have to stop - for now. In the realest way this is both the most heartbreaking AND the most beautiful film I think I have ever seen. And I am almost 70
Harry saying: "How come no one found me?" might be the Sadest and yet Truest thing a Queer person has ever said.
That it is the relatable to so many of us is what shatters my heart. I often think about that in my own private life. 🥺
@@i.t.t. Yeah, it really just hits you right in the Heart. But I'm sending you a HUGE Hug all the way from Denmark! 🤗 I hope it helps just a teeny bit. Take care ❤🩹
To Any person really i also lived half my 20s by myself alone and almost burn down my place twice and the first tough trough my mind was if i die would anyone be sad or missed me ?
To Any person really i also lived half my 20s by myself alone and almost burn down my place twice and the first tough trough my mind was if i die would anyone be sad or missed me ?
@@juliafloreshernandez6854 🥰Have a Hug! 🥰 from me to you!!
I loved the connection with Harry's 'There's vampires at my door' at the beginning of the film and Adam's soft whisper, '[I'll] keep the vampires from your door' at the end of the film.
And it's also a part of the lyrics of 'The power of love' by the way...
I loved it so clever. ❤
This was soooo poetic and storytelling at its best! When you can bring something back from the beginning and have it make a new meaning/impact by the end of the film. Loved this song before but I won't be able to listen to it and not think of this now. Hauntingly beautiful ❤
Just watched this review again, months later, still tears, and how you guys discuss and emotionally engage with the movie , I felt like we were watching it together.
I just missed holding someone's hand while watching that ....
" How come no one found me? "
😭😭😭
Omg that broke my heart💔💔😢😢
Poor Harry 😢🥺😭😭😭
The way I immediately started audibly sobbing in the theaters at this part…
I was bawling my eyes out at this part omgg 😭
Crushed. My. Soul. 😭😭😭
I feel this movie is able to trigger every human person, because it touches the universal subject of loneliness, and the subject-fear of dying without anyone noticing. What is one of the cruelest, but realistal thing which happens unfortunately. This is the second time I watch the movie, and I still cry deeply at that moment.
The relationship between Adam and Harry is the same as the relationship between Adam and his parents, so you could say they are "ghosts".
Harry died at the night after they first met.If only Adam had been brave enough to invite Harry into his apartment maybe he would still be alive.
Poor Harry died in loneliness waiting for someone to find his body.
I tought Harry died after going to visit Adam... this comment make it worse omg
wait, what!!!
Yes, his clothes are the same, and his body is decomposed a lot @@sammygogo1659
The more I think about the film, the more I think that Adam is dead as well.
@@erics1140 He's not dead..Because he's the only one the waiter can see when he's at the restaurant with his parents and when he ordered menu family special the waiter said that the portion was too much for 1 person.
I think the moment where Adam's dad says "I love you more, somehow, now that I know you" is the most beautiful thing. Because thats the point of coming out. Knowing someone is essential to loving them fully. What a great film!
Thank you for your wonderfully sensitive reactions. You guys really surpassed yourselves! I've seen All Of Us Strangers twice in the theater now, and as a 75-year-old gay man I have to say that it is truly one of the most moving and profound films centered on our experience that I've ever had the good fortune to see. (Andrew Haigh is pretty much my favorite film director for everything he's done, and of course particularly Weekend and Looking.) I'm particularly grateful that you both make the effort to see beyond dualities of sad/happy, black/white, etc. because life encompasses both great joy and great sorrow, and because as human beings we have the CHOICE, moment to moment, to open our hearts to LOVE -- both giving and receiving it. I hope those who watch your commentary, and who haven't yet seen the film, will go see it. Thank you again, and BE WELL.
I'm a couple of years older than Adam, and relate so hard to the movie. One of the things that I think is harder for younger generations to understand, is the extent to which being gay was only ever defined in terms of sex for so many, despite our internal sense that it's about love, hence the dislocation and uncertainty around "am I in love?"
That, coupled with the knowledge that sex was fatal; I do not miss the 80s.
Said exactly what I was thinking: I'm Gen X, and intimacy seemed about sex=disease=death in the 80s/90s and not true love, note Adam's mother saying "it will be such a hard life." Actually, I never recovered from the trauma.
@@zzzaaayyynnn it's not too late for us! ☺️♥️
@@YoungIskander let's hope haha
i recently watched an interview with claire foy and andrew scott on a podcast, and claire said something so insightful about how when a parent dies before their child, not only doesnthe child miss out on having that parent, but that the parent also misses out on seeing their child grow up. i’m absolutely butchering her eloquent way of wording things, but that statement made me want to cry.
In case no one has mentioned it yet, I think Adam was probably dead the whole time as well (lmao, sorry). There are many references to fire throughout the whole movie, but the most telling ones in my opinion are the fire alarm at the beginning (with Harry saying 'it will be real one of these days'), and Adam being hot throughout the movie and coughing a lot when he's upset (when they first kiss he also says he forgot to breathe etc.), so I think he died in a fire in his building. Also the whole vibe of the film is really giving purgatory in my opinion with the editing and sound design and just the whole disorienting structure, plus some other small things, like Adam waking up and asking 'how is it still Sunday?' So in my interpretation Adam and Harry are both something like ghosts who can't move on until they find each other and help each other heal :)
Gosh 😮😭😭😭😭
Siiiii, re-viendo a peli, tambien pienso que Adam muere en algun momento y creo que lo que dices es tremendamente acertado...yo pensé en algun momento al volver a ver la peli que fue en la fiesta, donde se ve solo, que ahi debe haber muerto de sobredosis o algo asi, pero siiii, Adam con fiebre durante la peli y lo otro que comentas, tiene mucho mas sentido....
I was trying to figure out that throughline with him being feverish all the time, I totally buy this lol
My thoughts exactly !!!! Adam had to be dead also for them to become a beautiful star together ... I felt joy for Adam getting time with his parents and finding love with Harry....
Not possible, because the waitress sees him in the diner when he's saying goodbye to his parents. That's why she's mildly surprised that he orders the family special.
He stole our hearts in Normal people, Now again in All of us strangers
Todavía no superó Normal People😭😭😭😭 y ahora con All of Us Strangers
Also Aftersun. His best work
@@millmaster413 ahora que esta en Netflix ire a verla, pero con pañuelitos si, sé que voy a llorar nuevamente jajaja
okay but that poses the question of what we deem queer sex is 12:00
It is romantic sometimes just like how any ither sex is romantic
10:00 yes, it was directed by a queer person (and i agree, it showed) and more than that, andrew haigh used elements of his life to create this movie; btw all of us strangers was shot in the actually childhood house where andrew haigh lived
In Croydon!
You two coped better than me, i nearly had to be carried out of the cinema, i cried whole way home, all the next day, my straight son cried, didnt sleep that night and cried the whole next day, this film should have gotten every award going, its the best film iv seen in a few years kudas to both actors, love andrew scott ❤❤❤❤ xx
this film is truly one of the best films I've seen in a long time and had me crying throughout it and hit so close to home in many ways.
This is such a devastating and beautiful film! I saw it in the theater and was just speechless afterward. One thing that really knocked me sideways was when his dad basically told him if he'd been a kid at his school he'd have probably bullied him. Sometimes a kids parents are their first bullies, and it's rarely been discussed so openly before, I think. I dunno, that whole scene really stuck with me, including when his dad apologized for not coming in his room when he was crying. I would give anything to hear my parents say they were sorry for certain parts of my upbringing. This whole movie was so powerful. It deserves all the awards!
This was my favourite film of 2023. Between this, Fellow Travelers, Heartstopper, Good Grief, and to a lesser extent even Red, White & Royal Blue (happy romcom focused on a gay relationship for once), gay media has been really helping me heal my trauma lately. It's allowing me to confront it and see what I didn't get in my own experience and to see what I needed. All of Us Strangers destroyed me the first time. I saw it with a full audience at the cinema and had to try and stifle ugly crying. All of the conversations he has with his parents could have been lifted from my own life. My parents are still alive but my coming out isn't something we ever really talk about and I had to figure out so much on my own. I got bullied and picked on growing up for many years by so many of my classmates. Over time it started to change me and family members noticed but nobody said anything or helped. That conversation he has with his dad and when his dad says "sorry I never came into your room when you were crying" and the way his voice breaks, I needed to hear that for myself, I was welling up in that moment. My mother had a bit of that AIDS fear that Adam's mother had, same kind of worries about what life would be like for me, both parents emotionally absent. The final conversation he has with them at the diner, hearing his dad say he was proud of him for making it through and then the way his mom says "such a kind and gentle boy", people have referred to me that way, it hit me so hard, I was crying so hard at that point. So many things said that I needed to hear. When the film was over, the crowd in the theatre took awhile to get up and start exiting, everyone was just kind of in this stunned emotional silence. I would have maybe changed the ending, maybe have Adam and Harry together as these 2 lonely people that found each other in this world.
I can’t listen to The Power of Love without crying in the corner anymore.
It played in Big Tesco and I felt like falling to the ground lmao
I was able to see this in a theater about a month ago and it is still with me. I was almost disappointed that I didn’t have a more immediate reaction in the theater. But when I got to my car, it started hitting me in waves. And continues to now. This film is so impactful and mature in the way it deals with and what it says about loss, grief, depression and loneliness. Truly the best picture of 2023. That it got completely snubbed by the Academy is truly criminal.
I am furious that this film did not receive an Academy Award. A stain on the Academy that they earned
I was anxious to see your reactions, since I spent two hours staring into space after I finished seeing this at the movies. And I would listen to Andrew Scott reading the phone book and he deserved every award in the book for this performance.
This not just a great LGTB film. It is a great film, period. You do not have to be gay to take a lot from this piece. It's simply an astounding piece of work.
Loved this reaction.
The whole cinema was quietly crying by the end of this when I went to see it.
It is just so beautifully tender and Andrew Scott conveys that so brilliantly. I can't believe he didn't get a Bafta nomination.
CIS Straight guy here, not to mention huge cinema watcher - If this isn't in my top 3 of 2024, it will have been a miraculous year for cinema!
I watched this on a plane and the tears just didn't stop flowing out. I couldn't do anything but look into the screen and just go through the journey and cry almost the whole movie. It was both mesmerizing and so, so sad. I saw myself in it; it touched a place in my heart I didn't know was THIS tender. Thanks for helping me relive it!
Me too!! I plan on watching again on my return home. I will ensure the tissues are to hand.
I love how you both immediately just got this film, but what I find most impressive is that you were able to speak coherently afterwords. I was speechless for a long ass time after that ended. We drove home from the theater trying to talk about it but sobbing all over again 😂 grateful for you two ❤️
From the time that this film was first advertised, I knew that his parents were dead. I never realized that his neighbor past that first scene was a ghost as well. Wow. Everyone gave outstanding performances, but Andrew Scott's was so many level's above everyone else's I think.
I'm straight and found this film really touching I don't normally watch these kinds of videos but it was interesting to see this perspective a lot of the things you said gave me a deeper understanding as people of this community
Such a beautiful movie. Broke my heart. The end when you realize that Harry had died the first night and could have been saved if Adam let him in just broke me. The most amazing performances and am absolutely fuming that the movie and performances were not nominated for Oscars.
I am probably older than most people responding here AND a harsh critic about every Art but I really have to say this may be the 'best' - not even the right word - and definitely for me right now - the most beautiful film I have ever seen. It absolutely deserved an Oscar
I guess I grew up at the same time as the main character. The details of that time were just chefs' kiss perfect. I loved this film. I watched it last night, and i still keep feeling waves of emotions about the experience. Really, this is a film that feels like it is directly speakjng to me. A triumph.
There's no cinema like gay cinema
Your last conversation really made me tear up. Your channel is so so important and needs even more recognition than it already has!!! I’m sure a lot of people seek hope and find it in your channel….I sure do!!
Thank you Alex and Josh
#youareloved
Watched it again with you guys. Adam is a screenwriter and he wrote a play to get through his past trauma. When he’s ready to love, and go looking for Harry. Harry passed away from alcohol and overdose that night when Adam denied him company. Sad sad story. 😭
I watched this film with my sister and father- we were all sobbing by the end, but each of us for completely different emotional reasons. I think that’s what’s beautiful about this film- it heals so many things for so many different experiences 😢
This movie broke me. Such an incredibly powerful story of love and loss. I expected nothing less with Andrew Haig at the helm. He’s such a talented filmmaker. Loved seeing your reactions to it. You guys are the best. ❤️ from CT, USA
Andrew Haigh director screenwriter was behind Looking.
I didn't cry at the ending when I first saw it the other day. Not because I wasn't affected, more because I was so affected I was past the point of being able to cry. As a straight woman, I can't relate in the same way to the LGBTQ+ element, even though I can have very strong feelings for it...but this film had so much more than just that. It was relatable in so many ways, so close to home. I agree with Alex that love isn't always an easy emotion to understand or recognise, i've had many times in my life where I have thought I don't know if what i'm feeling is love because i'm not sure I know what love feels like. No one can tell you what love is, I suppose, because its going to be unique to that person, but that doesn't help you when you can't recognise it in yourself. And for me, not recognising what loving someone feels like has made it very hard to understand how it feels to be loved by someone else. I sobbed through this reaction video, which was very much needed after being hit so hard by the film on first watch, so thank you.
I'm a straight woman too. I still can't articulate my feelings or explain my thoughts about this film. Achingly beautiful. I want everyone I know to watch it but ... there is so much pain here ... for me ultimately - sounds contrite - soul-affirming. But so painful to watch. I don't know how to prepare anyone in a kind way. And yet ... I think everyone must see this film. Especially the people I love
Not me crying at this again...I don't know how I managed to keep it more together in the cinema! As a queer person who is often lonely this really resonated with me. Absolutely beautiful film.
This movie brings out all the "baggage" that you didn't know you were carrying,makes you hear words that you didn't know that you needed to hear,reminds you of all the things you needed for yourself but forgot about,all words you want to say but can't get out but knowing that this movie touched so many people and really exquisitely depicts the life experiences that we all go through as queer or not but never really get to say outloud because of shame or whatever and it really dived deep into queer experiences that no lqgbt content that i know of has manage to depict so beautifully. Really loved it❤❤❤
As someone who lost the parents last year and didn't come out to them. this movie was a shock. I had to pause it so so many times because I was crying so hard I couldn't keep going. The idea of seeing and talking to your parents are a dream come true and to say goodbye to them again to going on is a nightmare. I must say after this movie I back to rails and start taking care of myself again. It helped me to get out of a hole I was trapped and graving myself into it. Today I watched it again, come to this video and saw this beautiful reaction... Unfortunately this is the only place I (and many of us) can be ourselves... Specially when you didn't come out yet... This still can be a lonely way of living but I appreciate places like this exist
Hugs ❤
❤
I saw this a few weeks ago, and I keep going back to it, thinking about it, watching interviews with the cast and creators. Just such a powerful important film. I'm a straight female (and a mum) and I saw it with my fiancee, we were both just so blown away by it. We both got in the car in silence and then he played the power of love while we drove home. I lay awake that night just processing the whole film. Truly haven't had a film affect me so much in a long time.
The performances were sublime, each of the four cast members deserves to be recognised for their work in this film, and Andrew Scott particularly was just everything. He's so subtle and yet every movement and inflection carries weight. Paul Mescal was heartbreaking and the parents, wow! Particularly as a parent I just crumbled watching them.
The writer/director has truly created the most unusual and lingering piece of work here. You can tell the whole film in sprinkled in his life's experiences and the ability for him to trust his cast so implicitly (for very evident reason) and not rely on jumpy cuts etc and rather just simple direction gives this an even more realistic feel which allows the viewers to be pulled in even more.
I had a creeping apprehension that Harry was similar to the parents. I started to get quite uneasy when Adam woke up in his childhood home in the kids pyjamas as initially the print looked like a hospital robe to me. It dawned on me that there was more to come and him preparing to say goodbye to his parents again was going to echo with Harry too. When he got out of the elevator I knew what he would find and just whispered "no, no, no" apparently. I didn't know how else to cope.
I feel that Adam was actually dead too, in some kind of waiting room/purgatory, that he was destined to meet Harry and they both help each other. There are lots of instances of red light being used, him living high up above everyone else, mentions of him supposed to be in the car, him not seeing his mum when she woke up/after the accident, his unawareness of time in a way, him in an otherwise empty building. These two had to fall in love to heal, it didn't matter if it was in this life or not. Perhaps I have read too much into it, but I can't decide if he dies as a child or later as a result of all the trauma he has dealt with.
I want to see it again to understand it more, but I'm not sure I can manage that just yet.
It was so important to hear your point of view and your commentary about just how important some of the story was in a way I can understand but not fully relate to and it helped my understanding of the film even more. Thank you.
I agree with you, only I think Adam died in a fire, part way through the film (there are various mentions of him being hot and him coughing frequently). I think his ghost found Harry's body and that they decide to be together, forever.
oooooh we're in for a ride...
this movie hit too close to home i literally am still picking myself up after watching it
We were in bits!
The turnaround for this movie? EXPRESS TRAIN LEVEL 1000. I’ve been impatient about watching this too.
Choo! Choo!
Watching this movie in a fine arts theater was just heart wrenching. So many people openly crying and sobbing. A beautiful film for sure. ANDREW SCOTT is brilliant. I'm glad you guys did this important film.
I have been looking forward to watching this again with you. I saw it at the cinema on Tuesday with a friend. I haven’t been so moved by a film for a very long time.
So many layers. So many tears! Just beautiful. Heartbreaking but beautiful.
I just found this beautiful movie in 2024. I watched it three days ago and have not been able to get it out of my mind.
So I decided to do some research online. Watching your take on it was one of the better critiques I could find.
I’m a 59 year old female. I’ve lost both my parents and my husband. I could relate 100% with this movie, the grief and loneliness. The want for connection and acceptance. The sex scenes were beautiful and I feel important for all people to see romantic love in all forms. The title is intriguing. To me it means, even though we’re all strangers. We all just need love. I love you all.❤
Thanks for letting me watch this again with you both. Saw it in the theatre in January and ugly cried then - it’s such a masterpiece. Having your emotional and intelligent commentary along with it was really a treat
This is my number 1 film of 2024. I saw it 3 x at the cinema in one week. And this is the best TH-cam reaction to it.
Regarding the coming out scene to his mother, and you already touched upon it but it’s all his inner dialogue, a visualization of trauma of that generation! Such a punch in the gut. I went into this screening with a couple of colleagues and we were all wrecked by the end and totally out of it for the next couple of days. This gets under your skin and stays there. Extraordinary storytelling and performances!
Needed to see others go through the waves and emotions of this film. I just saw it yesterday at the cinema. And that ending my gosh. Thank you for sharing ❤
Yeah as someone who Maladaptively daydreams I related to this movie a LOT... As it really really seems like that is what the main character is doing... Obviously his daydreams are significantly more detailed and life-like than mine, most of the time... But if I get high on weed my daydreams get significantly more vivid. To the point where I can absolutely start crying because of whatever sad thing is happening in them. Most of the time my daydreams are pleasant...but not always... just like the main charater. Yeah I don't know if that was the intention of the writer ...but that's really what looked like was happening to me very intense daydreams and dissociation.
As a not queer gran from South Africa have to say your review was heartwarming. I absolutely loved this movie, everything from script, mood, premise, acting. The two main leads were astonishing but Andrew Scott is mesmerising.
Alex is a screenwriter finally confronting his grief over the death of his parents and making it into a cathartic screenplay.
Probably one of the best reaction videos I’ve ever watched - both of you are so true to yourselves in allowing the raw portrayal of your emotional reaction. The film itself, of course, is a masterpiece.
30:45 broke my heart, that line about having each other and fighting didnt matter…literally made me gasp for air and I just began to cry. Fuckin wonderful scene! 😢❤
The 80s music in this movie is to kill for !!! So good ! It brought so much memories.
Just watched the film and was consistently blown away by so many scenes, including during my WTF reaction at the end…& then immediately came here to watch your coverage of it. Such fantastic writing, all the acting was terrific, especially Scott, omfg.
Alex and Josh, you’re Both Loved as well! Thank You so Much for providing this Content
I’m a straight person and I loved this movie so much. It was beautiful and heartbreaking, romantic and sexy. I am the same age as Andrew. I have queer friends and it hurts my heart when I think about anything cruel they have endured because of ignorance and hate. Everyone should see this movie. As Andrew says “Prejudice doesn’t survive proximity.” So glad I watched your reaction, it gives me insight into things that just wouldn’t occur to me as a straight person. Well done. Love from Canada ❤
This movie wracked me and left me scarred for life.
Thank you for providing a platform for the representation I never saw and for showing the joy, laughter, hope, sadness and pain and showcasing the depth and breadth of the LGBTQ+ experience. Thank you for not shying away from the difficult parts but equally embracing and sharing the joyful moments. From one end of the spectrum of heartstopper to this, it is all so important and so appreciated. The only narratives I did see were coming out stories often with negative outcomes so seeing such an incredible constellation of the Queer experience has been truly life affirming and laughing along and crying with you both has really made experiencing all these forms of representation all the more impactful.
That feeling of coming out to your parents in your mind multiple times like test runs, and having the version of your parents in your mind be accepting and willing to learn more about you. Only to see the exact opposite in real life, oof. Can't wait to watch this for myself!
I don't know if you've seen Weekend by the same Andrew Haigh, but you'll like its rawness (it will also break your heart)
Just watched it in the cinema 1 hour ago, I don't want to let go of it, loved it, so I went to youtube looking for people who did any reactions or reviews :DD Lovely reaction!
sat in the cinema until the credits had finished just staring at the screen. had absolutely no words to explain how i felt, this movie is so incredibly beautiful and emotional. your reactions and conversations brought me back to that!
I've loved Andrew Haigh ever since I watched Weekend and Looking, but this film really is something else.
Personally I think Adam is dying throughout the film and that's how he can see "ghosts". If you look at some of the imagery used it stronly invokes fire. And then of course there's the fire alarm at the beginning of the film and Harry saying "one day that alarm's gonna be for real" during their first meeting. Adam being hot and not being able to breathe at various points in the film. And then like you commented that shot where out his window you see what look like sirens, but maybe are the club lights.. And then of course at the end they become a star, which also suggests to me they're both dead at that point.
I'm not yet sure if that interpretation makes me feel better or worse though. But I think this film is such a beautiful exploration of grief and loneliness that I think anybody can relate to. Truly a masterpiece of cinema.
I think Andrew Haigh said people had expressed similar thoughts to him and he hadn't thought of it like that but that he wanted people to believe what they wanted to believe about it all. I read it after watching it and was quite surprised that he hadn't considered people would draw this conclusion...like you say, the imagery was there. The fire alarm, him feeling hot, the coughing, the screaming, the image out the window...I thought exactly the same that this was what they were hinting at. I suppose though, if it was all a fire, then the Harry storyline doesn't really make sense because why show his death from alcohol and drugs, lying undiscovered for days all because Adam didn't let him in after the fire alarm. Haigh at least did confirm Harry was alive when he came to the door. Whether Adam is dead or alive, is up to the viewer to choose as far as Haigh seemed concerned.
@@jner7149 Thank you for that, I was wondering what Haigh thought of the "fire theory" / if it was intended that way. I don't like the thought of it, cause it would mean Adam lost his parents as a child, lived a lonely life, never fell in love and then died alone in a fire. That's just cruel
@@xxjeaNot cruel, just tragic.
I saw it a few weeks ago and was stuck in my seat for at least 15 minutes afterwards! A truly sublime film! Also the film was directed by Andrew Haigh who wrote and directed Looking, so awkward gay stuff is his thing. Have you ever seen Weekend?. If not, you should!
P.s you made me cry damn you!
I finished it and stared at the wall sobbing for like 30 minutes. This fucked me up so hard
Great analysis, guys. Loved it. Ugnnnnn, those wrong subtitles were driving me insane while we were watching it, and they’re still pissing me off. Some of them are hilariously wrong.
I’m slowly coming out as a bisexual man.
I have also lost my mom tragically and it took me 9 years to accept the fact I never told her that I enjoyed the company of both men and women.
It’s been a very lonely life for me, I’m only 28 and I feel as if I already died. But reality hit me a month ago and I said, “I’m ready to start a new life.”
I’m prepared to lose my friends, my religion, and even my way. But man I can’t wait to be free
This movie made me cry and feel so seen
Really moved by this message. You are not alone. Peace, look after yourself, and know that you are seen by others too.
@@14478100 thank you 🙏 I really do appreciate it.
Yours is a brave, raw and honest reaction, to this film. I wish you all the best, on your journey. The world deserves to know you.
@@sinceslicedbread7422 I’m been pondering this comment all week
I truly appreciate it
@@chedderman101 You're welcome 😊
I literally watched this movie last night and had no idea what I was going to get but omg I was devastated by this. It really messed me up for the rest of the night
Hey guys! I am glad I found you. I am an old Gay man, most of my friends have passed on. Now I have two new young Gay men in my life (so to speak). Thanks for sharing your reactions to the film. I watched it alone, I missed some of it. Loved seeing your emotions. Thanks again.
this movie shattered my heart and im still not healed 😭
the way the end scene explain the whole thing harry said whilst drunk in the beginning had me sobbing 😢😢6
Oh I’m so excited for thissss! Been waiting ever since you mentioned it in a livestream chat, 40 mins too!! 💖 it’s one of those movies where either you ‘get’ it or not, the imagination of the viewer with regards to which parts were real and when upon first watch changes the impact it has I believe
Just watched this movie as a straight female ..it was absolutely brilliant ... And so insightful .. wept ..like wept ... It was just brilliant 🎉🎉
I so appreciate your take on this movie, it's been a revelation listening to you talk. You've helped me identify feelings and experiences in my own life that I hadn't been able to articulate myself. I am an older autistic person. We were/are not allowed to be ourselves, to express ourselves authentically. When his mother said, you don't look gay, that's something i hear all the time (replace gay with autistic). The bullying at school, the pressure to conform. What I take away from this is that I too am Queer. I'm not sure if I am 'allowed' to say that, but as an autistic person I feel that I could belong more comfortably in queer spaces than any other.
I've seen the movie twice, and seeing it again virtually with you 2 was great, your observations are grrrreat.
I cried again several times.
Thanks 😊
It is such a good story with a stellar cast. With only 4 characters it could easily have been a play.
Omg this movie is amazing and beautiful and haunting and emotional 🥹🥹🌈🌈
This movie taught me to treasure and take care of the people around me, to be kind to everyone (even and perhaps especially strangers) and that fear should not stop me from doing so
Thank you guys, your brave beautiful gay men ❤
That last visual in the ending has to be one of the most beautiful things I've ever seen in a film! Pure cinema magic!
Fun watching this film with you guys. As a GenX'er, it surprising to see how you guys reacted to the scene he came out to his mom. He sumed up my feelings as just "everything is different now, Mom". I never thought younger gens would think too much about it and all the awkwardness of it. I guess I was wrong.
A long time ago I read a book by Taichi Yamada and it blew my mind. Even gifted it to people. I didn't realize until just before I watched it that this film is also bases on one of his books. I'm so happy I did though because I knew to be guided by my feelings instead of logic. It's what makes it work so beautifully.
What's most masterful about this film for me though is that unlike many great filmmakers who take on a Japanese work and somehow never quite succeed in conveying the right atmosphere and feel and other elements that I can't quite verbalise, this film managed to get that special vibe about it while still making it appealing to a Western audience and, and in such a way that it is both relatable to them and deeply affects them.
I liked watching this review because I could see in real time how. I also enjoyed seeing that we felt the same about many parts of the film although we didn't quite guess what was going to happen at the same time. You caught on to a few things well before I did 😅
I must say, I really appreciated hearing some of your thoughts too. You somehow always have something deep or meaningful to say which either makes me feel deeply understood or offers me a new perspective. So happy I found you. One more reason to be thankful to Fellow Travelers, it seems.
IT IS MOVIE OF THE YEAR IN MY HEART ALREADY
I took a long time time, spent days and weeks thinking about it after I’ve seen it. What an insightful thing watching it through your eyes, thank you so much ❤❤❤
FIrst, Past Lives was my favorite movie of the year, then it was Poor Things. Now this is my favorite movie of 2023! Holy cow!
Poor Things was my favourite, then All of Us Strangers beat it, so now I'll have to watch Past Lives!
@@zanyzander Its great. I own all three of those on blu-ray. Criterion is putting out a blu-ray disk for All Of Us Strangers. Of course this wasn't announced until after I bought a copy from the UK where they have it on disk, unlike here in the US where it has only been streaming until the Criterion comes out in Sept.
Aww, here we go! I’m sending a Hug in advance because I’ll be working at premiere time. Of course I’ll be watching this evening.
Get those tissues ready!
When sensitivity, insight, and heart are needed, you two shine. Thank you. Beautiful film and performances.
@@AStoryWorthTellingit’s now 8pm here in NY. Tissues definitely ready!
Hugs to you Both!
@@AStoryWorthTelling it’s 2 weeks later and I’ve watched this a few times with you now. I cried right along with you both once again during that powerful ending.
Two things that gives me peace is that Harry wasn’t alone when he was able to move on. And Adam got to learn what true love feels like.
Thanks Guys
It took me weeks to recover from this movie. It's the loudest collective sobbing I've ever heard in a theatre, we were all a mess & no one got up until the credits were over.
I have so many thoughts after watching this film. It was really helpful to watch this with you boys to unpack some of those thoughts and feelings. You are doing the lords work in these streets.
Watched this with my wife the other evening - I think it's such a powerful film for a variety of reasons and has many elements to which one can relate to. Being parents to a 4 year old boy and a 1 year old there were a few scenes which absolutely destroyed me emotionally. Particularly with Adam and his mother in bed... tragic.
And that final scene, that last reveal was just devestating... what a beautiful film
I just watched this move a few days ago. And now that I’m almost recovered, I decided to find reactions to it. Thank you for this beautiful reaction. The gut punch at the end when we find out Harry has been dead since the first night he visited Adam’s apartment… (yes viewers have questioned if that was the case, it is as confirmed by the director. And yes Adam is alive, not also a ghost)… was so devastating. I cried for a whole night.
This is by far Andrew Haigh's best film to date. I considered "Weekend" one of my absolute favorite gay films ever (which he directed) but "All of Us Strangers" has by far surpassed it.
Every time I watch a clip of the final scene, I ugly cry. I can see myself in Harry so much. When I'm gone, I wish no part of me has to stick around in anxious despair for someone to find my body.
Volvi a llorar nuevamente al ver su reacción, es tan triste la soledad que viene muchas veces con mostrarse como es uno mismo con la familia, que te ignoren o no se hable mas del tema y ademas como el dolor y la culpa que puede seguirnos hasta el presente en cosas que nos fueron ocurriendo en nuestra vida :( me paso que cuando le conte a mi mamá sobre la chica de quien estaba enamorada, recibi una reaccion de rechazo y duda y preguntas de ella de que quizas yo estaba confundiendo las cosas, lo que hizo que estuviera confundida años acerca de mi sexualidad y deje ir a la persona que amaba en parte por eso y por el peso social mental que cargaba de por medio... y ver esta peli me llego al corazón, porque tal como lo dicen ustedes, si una no puede amarse a si misma, como vas a amar a alguien mas? e imagina teniendo que vivir la emocion de estar enamorada, pero al mismo tiempo estar descubriendo tu sexualidad asi mismo y ser vista rara en la calle o dentro de tu propia familia/amigos que quizas iban a criticarte y opinar... fue horrible y sé que muchas personas actualmente lo viven tambien D:
Quiero decir que tal como Fellow Travelers y Young Royals, All of Us Strangers siento que me cambio la vida, y nunca olvidaré la primera vez que la vi (al igual que FT y YR) porque son de esos proyectos que te llegan mas adentro del corazon y del alma, que dejan cicatriz en ti y te hacen llorar y disfrutar como la primera vez...por eso lamento tanto que no siempre tengan el reconocimiento que se merecen, porque son ejemplos de vida para muchos de nosotros y nos dan herramientas y nos hacen sentir vivos nuevamente....
Ojala esta pelicula se vuelva de culto, porque te deja simplemente sin palabras
Bravo, gentlemen 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Your reaction and review were spot on🎯
You navigated the complexity and delicate nuance of this heartbreakingly hopeful masterpiece so well. ❤️🩹
Wow. 🤧
I've always subtlety known this, but it sure hit me tonight:
Your Channel Is Incredibly Important. ❤
Best,
Ken
I think love is an amplified emotional connection to other person. Like when he is happy - you are 100 times happier, and when he is sad you are devastated.
(Cue Josh declaring he’d watch Andrew Scott do anything)
The club scene looks like all the people living in the apartment and it feels like they are in a fire and the siren are the rescuers or something