I’ve always wondered what Indonesian sounds like to foreigners! 😆 It was also really interesting to describe the feel of these languages without going into actual vocab or grammar ❤
Indonesian languages is very simple, for example "where do you live?" You can place any word for the first, second etc in conversation (not for the grammar), "you live where?" "where you live?" "Live where you?" "live you where?".
whattt i had no idea how indonesian sounded like before this video and i had basically 0 contact with it and this made want to learn indonesian so bad lmao it seems easy and a very cool dash interesting language
This episode they manage to cast lots of good ppl, they're very communicative. They connect to each other naturally and the flow is very good. A bunch of smart extrovert ig. Except japan and Chinese girl, who seemed like introvert among this girls 😂
really? I find that the german girl is the introvert one instead. Or she is just choosing her words carefully, because i think germans can be very blunt with their words.
As an Indonesian, many people say German is the language of Hitler, but my president said German is the language of Schiller, Goethe, Beethoven and Mozart.
Thanks to Genesia, Indonesia can be more well known.. The Indonesian Ministry of Tourism should pay her for her engagement here in International community.. 😂😂
Genesia is beautiful lady at 0:38 for those who can't find the lady i meant and she destined to be borned in Indonesia.. her country also end with -sia.. 😊😊
I’m from Calamba City, Laguna in the Philippines and I’m currently learned Bahasa Indonesia on my own since March 2023 using my language application, Duolingo(developed by Luis Von Ahn) and a TH-cam Channel, IndonesianPod101 and because I’m starting typing Bahasa Indonesia on TH-cam in some Indonesia-related videos, like beauty pageants, etc., my birthday wish by September is I want to study more Bahasa Indonesia in Metro Manila, especially various language schools in Alabang or anywhere and Indonesian Embassy in Makati City, where free Indonesian Language classes there rather than in Calamba City, because the city dosen’t have single language classes 😊😊 I hope to practice Bahasa Indonesia well because Indonesia is my favorite country and I like to meet Indonesian people as friends including pageant lovers and many others and my Indonesian Celebrity Crush was Lyodra and Tiara Andini(both are singers) so with all my heart, I hope to see you in Wonderful Indonesia next year and I will be waiting for you 😊😊 Love from Calamba City, Laguna in the Philippines 🇵🇭💕🇮🇩
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 bahasa indonesia anda baku dan itu merupakan nilai lebih bagi anda karena kebanyakan warga indonesia sendiri cenderung menggunakan bahasa yang adalah bukan baku atau non baku.
@@itsmesoleh06 Indomie is so good as well as Nasi Goreng, oh let's not forget about kopi luwak the most expensive coffee in the world I personally never tried it since it's expensive and not on my radar but I'm sure it's good since I like coffee and I know how the process works but I don't have the cash to purchase it.
Phonetically it sounds a lot like Tagalog (Filipino dialect). Except that they have an emphasis on rolling their R’s more and also sound like they’re talking much faster.
Why do Indonesians say Indonesian is the easiest language to learn? because on average 90% of Indonesian people are born with a local language as their first language, when they are 5 years old they start learning Indonesian, this is a normal thing in Indonesia because Indonesia has many local languages, and that is the reason why people Indonesia says Indonesian is easy to learn, not only because we were born in Indonesia and we say Indonesian is the easiest language to learn, but that's the reality.
Thats true Indonesian is new language and unified language, also many languages that have been absorbed from English, Malay, Dutch, Spanish, Portuguese, Arabic, Chinese, Sanskrit and no affirmation in gender and time
Makanya Genesia bilang tidak semua orang Indonesia proper menggunakan bahasa Indonesia walaupun tergolong bahasa yang mudah dipelajari. Bahasa Indonesia yang baku alias proper hanya ada di berita dan buku. Mungkin maksudnya mudah karena strukturnya tidak serumit bahasa lain bahkan tidak menggunakan intonasi seperti Chinese misalnya. Kalau harus jujur dari pengalaman pribadi, yang paling sulit dari bahasa Indonesia adalah menulis. Saya butuh hampir 3 tahun untuk belajar menulis dengan benar. 😅
@@SitumorangPande0820 kalo aku sih meskipun ibu aku orang Jawa dan ayah aku orang Kalimantan, tapi bahasa Indonesia adalah bahasa pertama aku soal nya aku di besar kan di wilayah tran yang mana itu tuh tempat orang imigrasi dari seluruh pulau di Indonesia, makan nya bagi aku bahasa Indonesia mudah banget sedang kan bahasa Kalimantan bahasa kedua ku, dan bahasa Jawa bahasa ketiga ku, aku terlahir beda dari kebanyakan orang Indonesia yang mana kebanyakan dari mereka terlahir dengan bahasa lokal sebagai bahasa pertama nya dan bahasa Indonesia sebagai bahasa kedua nya.
@@Saluranmasadepanofficial Ya pointnya adalah bahasa Indonesia tergolong mudah dipelajari untuk lisan tapi untuk tulisan (yang benar dan baku) bahasa Indonesia sama rumitnya dengan bahasa Inggris misalnya. Contohnya anda, anda tidak menulis dengan bahasa Indonesia yang proper (benar dan baku). Berarti besar kemungkinan bahasa Indonesia formal anda juga seperti itu.
I'm Indonesian, and while it's true that the lack of tenses, genders, conjugations make Indonesian seem like a very easy to learn language, we have a lot of prefixes and suffixes to change the meaning of a word. Remembering when to use it and how to put it might be challenging for most people 🤣
In short, for beginner it's really easy, for deeper learning? It has no ending... I remember has question for a test about paragraph core = inti kalimat, i ask it into 2 different teachers, without the answer sheet. They give me two different answers. Most of the issue because in Indonesia I think we can yapping entire paragraph without any concrete structure. So to formulize it kinda like a Herculean task on its own.
Semoga *Bahasa Indonesia* suatu saat jadi Bahasa Universal setara dengan Bahasa Jepang Korea Mandarin saat ini banyak diminati untuk belajar. karena kita tau Bahasa Indonesia punya potensi besar dan tersebar ke beberapa negara yang penggunanya diaspora warganegara Indonesia Serta Fakultas Jurusan Bahasa Indonesia di beberapa negara. 😊
fyi skrg udah banyak bule yg belajar bahasa indo. bisa diliat banyak youtuber polyglot seperti RyanHale atau KazuLanguages memilih bhs indo sebagai salah satu bahasa yg dikuasai. Mungkin berkat pengguna sosial media di indonesia termasuk banyak juga, dan orang orang nya yg ramah dan gampang didekati jadi orang luar tertarik untuk belajar bahasa indo. shoutout juga kepada para polyglot indonesia yg memperkenalkan bahasa indo ke internasional seperti kak Genesia, SonnyWilson, Fiki Naki, dll
Kita doakan yang terbaik. Sekarang bahasa Indonesia juga sudah menjadi bahasa resmi ke 10 sidang umum UNESCO. Artinya harapan kita membawa bahasa Indonesia mendunia masih ada. Yang perlu adalah kita harus terus pakai bahasa Indonesia dengan benar dimanapun kita berada, perkenalkan dengan orang luar. Musik Indonesia dengan bahasa Indonesia juga bagus-bagus. Kita promosikan saja lewat lagu juga.
suatu bahasa diminati karena nilainya, bukan karena karakteristik bahasa itu sendiri. apakah nilai dari bahasa Indonesia sehingga diminati bangsa asing? ekonomi, budaya, politik? saya rasa tidak banyak. berbeda dengan kita orang indo lokal yang kalau gak mau belajar bahasa Indonesia sejak kecil bisa hilang dari peredaran.
Note that the languages featured in the video come from different language families, except for English and German, which are both Germanic. So when the American says that German sounds like an older, more sophisticated English, she's not entirely wrong. Although Chinese, Japanese, and Korean all use Chinese characters, they originate from different language families and have distinct characteristics. I understand why Genesia feels a bit defensive about Indonesian being perceived as similar to Thai. These languages don't even belong to the same language family. Judging them to be similar just because both are from Southeast Asia can come across as quite ignorant. If someone said Indonesian sounded like Tagalog, it would be more understandable since both languages belong to the Austronesian family. Stereotypes exist for a reason, but ultimately, how a language sounds depends on the speaker. A Japanese warlord and a kawaii girl from a maid café in Akihabara would sound completely different. Although I’m not a big fan, I do think Xiaomanyc’s impressions accurately reflect how foreigners perceive different languages. Genesia, as a polyglot, speaks all the languages featured in this video. If I were her, I’d be an insufferable show-off, so I’m thankful for her positive representation of Indonesia 😁
Tagalog lacks words or vocabularies that's why there's so many English words and some spanish words in tagalog speakers. The Philippine government needs to create more new words and to complete this language because right now it is very incomplete language like those pavement road projects that is left incomplete.
@@kunderemp ang sabihin mo ai wala ka lang nationalism para sa sarili mong wika na ai Tagalog. Gusto mo lang ng some English/Spanish words para mukha kang cool. Another branch of pridefulness and arrogance and colonial mentality of Pilipinos aka slavery mentality. Matutu maging humble para hindi mapapahiya. ᜋᜃᜊᜌᜈ᜔ ᜋᜃᜏᜒᜃ
Indonesian is big country. You need learn Indonesia language to travel deep more. If you just speak english, maybe you just can go to Bali or Jakarta. Same as like china there Cantonese, Hakka and other dialect. Indonesia language is lingua franca. Many of them dont speak english.
Indonesian language should be the official world language because its easy to learn, you can communicate in few months of learning it. In 3 months staying in Bali i can communicate and understand the locals with basic bahasa Indonesia. This language is beautiful.
Exactly. Or when they're comparing German words to French, English, Italian, Spanish. Yeah no shit, it's almost as if languages in the same language group will have similar words.
@@ginismoja2459they also come up with the exact same examples each and every time. How often do we need to learn about German matchbox and squirrels or ridiculous long words from law school or even completely made up ones?
I'm brazilian and have always been amazed by the german language, ever since I was 12 (I don't have any relatives from Germany, just pure curiosity for languages in general). I think it's such a beautiful and misjudged language, I went back to studying it now and am absolutely in love with it. People that replicate this stereotype are just ignorant 🤨
9:12 interesting as a German I get the same feeling when listening to Nordic languages. The words sound familiar but have that little bit of lost magic to them that out language lacks.
Besides just the tones themselves, Chinese is often spoken very expressively (Cantonese even more than Mandarin). Especially when the drinks are flowing, everything sounds 10x more dramatic than any other language. LOL I love it though.
I'm a German living in Spain married to a Spaniard. At our wedding celebration my Soanish family said about German that it sounded as if were always angry. My German family said about my Spanish family that it seemes they were always shouting at each other.. In one case it was for the sound of the language, in the other for the way of interacting. The outcome: the same.
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 Do you mean the Armed Forces of the Philippines uses Indonesian? I once read comments from Filipinos that Indonesian was the language studied in the Philippine army. But to be honest at that time I didn't really believe it.
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 But I believe that Filipinos are already used to Indonesian because there are lots of Filipino comments on Indonesian songs or music on TH-cam. Maybe you know the Indonesian songs Dola by Angga, Faja Skali by Angga, Cintamu Sepahit Topi Miring, and many more. Indonesian songs often go viral in several countries in ASEAN and even outside ASEAN.
Actually the ones who creating those stereotypes about German language they are German themselves. As far as I know those guys in the video who were comparing languages all of them are German.
22:06 𝗘𝘅𝗰𝗲𝗽𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻; ◽1 Butterfly : 1 Kupu-kupu ◽1 Spider : 1 Laba-laba ◽1 Firefly : 1 Kunang-kunang ◽1 Tortoise : 1 Kura-kura ◽1 Sheep : 1 Biri-biri ◽1 Dolphin : 1 Lumba-lumba ◽1 Otter : 1 Berang-berang ◽1 Squid : 1 Cumi-cumi ◽1 Falcon : 1 Alap-alap, etc If the animals above are plural, then; ◽2 Butterflies : 2 Kupu-kupu ◽2 Tortoises : 2 Kura-kura, etc If you ask how to differentiate between exceptions, then the answer is "I don't know".. wkwkwk 😂 🤣 🤭 The solution is that you have to specifically ask a native Indonesian about the word you mean.. We will tell you whether it is an exception or not..
I think she was trying to place more emphasis on the pitch itself, not the actual English accent. And at least one of their many accents does tend to go up in pitch just like that.
the way Bahasa Indonesia is fast flowing and really simple rule wise came from the way it originated being both based on a market language/dialect version of malay and being a designed uniting language so it's made to be easy to understand
I'm from Germany and I'm not a big fan of our language, BUT it's not that aggressive at all. My favorite languages are Korean, Japanese and Mandarin. I just love them. Especially Korean and Japanese. ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
If I can say Bahasa Indonesia don't have any characteristic accent. That's why, if you don't understand any word in Bahasa Indonesia, you cannot imitate or stereotyping the language
Bahasa Indonesia is easy. The problem is when you learn the bahasa in one place or one city, you'll learn it with its culture or its slang or its dialect and the mix with its local language. And when you move to another place, then you will know what you have learned from previous place is kinda different with your current place. I'm from bandung and now I'm working in bekasi (90 minutes away from bandung), even after 5 years working in bekasi, i still don't get much of bekasi's dialect or its local slang
Many stereotypes of the Chinese language came from Hong Kong movies, since it was very popular in the 70s, 80s, and 90s. So, the Chinese that the foreigners usually heard are Cantonese. Cantonese are loud, crude, and exaggerated. But the most spoken language in China is Mandarin. It sounds more soft, calm, and refined.
Oh bitch pls Another day, another comment shitting on Cantonese by the superior mandarin speakers. Talk to a northeasterner then come back and tell me Mandarin is refined and gentle and whatnot bs.
Now, german is one of the most melodic language. But you have to know it really and use it in the right way. I think that it s the same for any language.
Setuju banget kalo bahasa Indonesia itu mudah buat dipelajarin. Tinggal buang grammar, buang gender. Simpel. Thats informal form of Bahasa Indonesia you guys found hard to learn. Wichis depend from what region it come, it might be sounds diferent. In formal Bahasa Indonesia : Saya setuju sekali bahwa belajar bahasa Indonesia itu mudah. Tidak perlu menggunakan kata penunjuk waktu, tidak perlu menggunakan kata penunjuk kelamin. Sesederhana itu. Thats was the type of Bahasa Indonesia you guys can easily learn or mostly tought.
I speak Indonesian, English, and Japanese for fast language or not. From my experience, it is depend on people but women usually do speak faster than men no matter what language it is my teacher also said "yeah we (women) need to speak fast to save time"
I kinda hate when they say german (and russian) sounds aggressive, when it isnt right, it only sound loud if you say it this way Coming from a german/ russian
There is a video from around 12 years ago called "How English sounds to non-English speakers" and it was mostly nonsense sounds with a few basic words and swears being actual English.
indonesian talk in similar way as spanish speaker, really fast.. that's because there are so many syllables in just one word, their normal speed sounds really fast to other people.
I hear this for many many years and I'll believe it when I see it. I can see the potential but the religion can be an issue. Businesses close early during fasting month around 3ish in the afternoon. How can you expect international corporations to shut down operations around 3ish everyday for a month? Then 1 or 2 weeks off for Ramadhan.
I can guarantee that the man in the video is not speaking Mandarin, but Cantonese. Although I can't speak Cantonese, I can still hear it. To be honest, Cantonese is more suitable for singing because it rhymes, but it is very stiff and not soft when spoken normally.
Indonesian still similar to Dutch in the way pronouncing word, but Indonesian doesnt use throat vocal. Indonesian Alphabet adopt from Dutch Spelling, except G,J,R,U,Y.
Indonesian laguange is easy, yes, but in daily life, people in Indonesia speak their local/regional laguange more than Indonesia languange, because we have a lot of ethnicities, there are different accents even when we speak Indonesian languange. So nobody speaks proper Indonesian like the book taught 😁👍
I think I'm fell in love to Joana! 🫣 Btw, Indonesian is an easy language to learn because it doesn't use sentence structures like the one Genesia explains. But what is difficult about bahasa Indonesian is writing. 80% of Indonesian people I have known in my entire life cannot write bahasa Indonesian properly. In fact it took me almost 3 years to learn to write properly. 😅 Overall, Genesia's explanation of bahasa Indonesian is the best of the 3 other Indonesians I've seen in content like this. KERJA BAGUS, Neng!! 👏
You'd have to use more than one word on most of them, but I think "earworm" can be one word or two in English. That's the one I've heard, anyway. Zugzwang actually IS a word in English - stolen by chess players :)
i think the german sacon accent not dialect nut the slightly tone of dialect u know thats more like english flowe whise we scrunch words together and are verry fast its hard to follow for non native speakers its liek the adhd dialect of germany lmao in my opinion i at least once i got fuent in english never had the impression my melody of speach sounds any different i also never had difficultys with the flow or anything not even much with accent couse saxonian is a softer dialect for the most part more mumbled as well so it verrys within germany how ot sounds
7:35 as a german i really hate this video by now. Literally EVERY video that talks about language differences use this sketch as an example, which obviously is a bad choice for that.
I’ve always wondered what Indonesian sounds like to foreigners! 😆 It was also really interesting to describe the feel of these languages without going into actual vocab or grammar ❤
aku doain kakaknya di undang k podcast deddy corbuzier atau podcast lain atau collab dg jerome polin atau dg ytuber lain😂,
sukses slalu y kk
I don't know why im having love at first sight 💩😆
Du kannst auch im deutschen das r rollen, hörst dich dann halt blos an wie ein Franke
Beautiful language
Polak muwi rze pszyjazini narodowa to skarb jak Pan i pani 🎼🎶🎵📻📣🎓🎓🎓🎓🎓🎓🎓🎓🎓📣📣📣📣📣📣🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇🍇
Indonesian languages is very simple, for example "where do you live?" You can place any word for the first, second etc in conversation (not for the grammar), "you live where?" "where you live?" "Live where you?" "live you where?".
100% Valid
true
yes true
Or even only “live where?” Or “stay where”
whattt i had no idea how indonesian sounded like before this video and i had basically 0 contact with it and this made want to learn indonesian so bad lmao it seems easy and a very cool dash interesting language
This episode they manage to cast lots of good ppl, they're very communicative. They connect to each other naturally and the flow is very good. A bunch of smart extrovert ig. Except japan and Chinese girl, who seemed like introvert among this girls 😂
really? I find that the german girl is the introvert one instead. Or she is just choosing her words carefully, because i think germans can be very blunt with their words.
Thank you for your kind words ❤
I adore this group of girls so much. Not only they are attractive and stylish, but quite highly educated and very well-mannered.
Thank you so much!!!
Yeah, good group energy there 😊
As an Indonesian, many people say German is the language of Hitler, but my president said German is the language of Schiller, Goethe, Beethoven and Mozart.
Well, austrian dialect of german is the language of Hitler.
president-elect*
wtf 💀💀
Nobody said language of Hitler in Indonesia bro stop the cap
Nobody said that in Indonesia 🤦stop the cap
Thanks to Genesia, Indonesia can be more well known..
The Indonesian Ministry of Tourism should pay her for her engagement here in International community.. 😂😂
Can't agree more. But, as Indonesians, we all know this wish is too good to be true. 🤣
Agreed
Who/What is Genesia?
Nvm I replayed 😅 now I know who Genesia is
Genesia is beautiful lady at 0:38 for those who can't find the lady i meant and she destined to be borned in Indonesia.. her country also end with -sia.. 😊😊
I’m from Calamba City, Laguna in the Philippines and I’m currently learned Bahasa Indonesia on my own since March 2023 using my language application, Duolingo(developed by Luis Von Ahn) and a TH-cam Channel, IndonesianPod101 and because I’m starting typing Bahasa Indonesia on TH-cam in some Indonesia-related videos, like beauty pageants, etc., my birthday wish by September is I want to study more Bahasa Indonesia in Metro Manila, especially various language schools in Alabang or anywhere and Indonesian Embassy in Makati City, where free Indonesian Language classes there rather than in Calamba City, because the city dosen’t have single language classes 😊😊
I hope to practice Bahasa Indonesia well because Indonesia is my favorite country and I like to meet Indonesian people as friends including pageant lovers and many others and my Indonesian Celebrity Crush was Lyodra and Tiara Andini(both are singers) so with all my heart, I hope to see you in Wonderful Indonesia next year and I will be waiting for you 😊😊
Love from Calamba City, Laguna in the Philippines 🇵🇭💕🇮🇩
Jadi apa sudah paham bahasa indo bro?
@@rezamahendra12324Ya wkwk 😊😊
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797wow great job for you....mudah2 an impian dan usaha mu untuk bertemu lyodra dan tiara tercapai ya..😊👍
@@silvi359Terima kasih dan aku sangat cinta Lyodra dan Tiara banyak karena dia cantik 😊😊
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 bahasa indonesia anda baku dan itu merupakan nilai lebih bagi anda karena kebanyakan warga indonesia sendiri cenderung menggunakan bahasa yang adalah bukan baku atau non baku.
Whenever I hear Indonesian all I can think of is the R rolling and the only type of Indonesian entertainment that I can think of are The Raid films.
I wont blame you, the famous things from us are Indomie, the Raid, komodo Dragons, and Bali, not much. 😂
@@itsmesoleh06 Indomie is so good as well as Nasi Goreng, oh let's not forget about kopi luwak the most expensive coffee in the world I personally never tried it since it's expensive and not on my radar but I'm sure it's good since I like coffee and I know how the process works but I don't have the cash to purchase it.
It sounds like italian to me
you watch The Raid? 👍🏼
Phonetically it sounds a lot like Tagalog (Filipino dialect). Except that they have an emphasis on rolling their R’s more and also sound like they’re talking much faster.
2:25 English
4:59 German
9:16 Korean
12:13 Chinese
16:04 Japanese
19:03 Indonesia
20.09 "Terus kalian sekarang kaya bingung semua kan aku ngomong apa? Nggak ada yang ngerti." 😅😅
Wkwkwkwk
@@Bruuh05 20:09
Why do Indonesians say Indonesian is the easiest language to learn? because on average 90% of Indonesian people are born with a local language as their first language, when they are 5 years old they start learning Indonesian, this is a normal thing in Indonesia because Indonesia has many local languages, and that is the reason why people Indonesia says Indonesian is easy to learn, not only because we were born in Indonesia and we say Indonesian is the easiest language to learn, but that's the reality.
Yeah, Bahasa Indonesia isn't the first language for the most of Indonesians.
Thats true Indonesian is new language and unified language, also many languages that have been absorbed from English, Malay, Dutch, Spanish, Portuguese, Arabic, Chinese, Sanskrit and no affirmation in gender and time
Makanya Genesia bilang tidak semua orang Indonesia proper menggunakan bahasa Indonesia walaupun tergolong bahasa yang mudah dipelajari. Bahasa Indonesia yang baku alias proper hanya ada di berita dan buku.
Mungkin maksudnya mudah karena strukturnya tidak serumit bahasa lain bahkan tidak menggunakan intonasi seperti Chinese misalnya.
Kalau harus jujur dari pengalaman pribadi, yang paling sulit dari bahasa Indonesia adalah menulis. Saya butuh hampir 3 tahun untuk belajar menulis dengan benar. 😅
@@SitumorangPande0820 kalo aku sih meskipun ibu aku orang Jawa dan ayah aku orang Kalimantan, tapi bahasa Indonesia adalah bahasa pertama aku soal nya aku di besar kan di wilayah tran yang mana itu tuh tempat orang imigrasi dari seluruh pulau di Indonesia, makan nya bagi aku bahasa Indonesia mudah banget sedang kan bahasa Kalimantan bahasa kedua ku, dan bahasa Jawa bahasa ketiga ku, aku terlahir beda dari kebanyakan orang Indonesia yang mana kebanyakan dari mereka terlahir dengan bahasa lokal sebagai bahasa pertama nya dan bahasa Indonesia sebagai bahasa kedua nya.
@@Saluranmasadepanofficial Ya pointnya adalah bahasa Indonesia tergolong mudah dipelajari untuk lisan tapi untuk tulisan (yang benar dan baku) bahasa Indonesia sama rumitnya dengan bahasa Inggris misalnya.
Contohnya anda, anda tidak menulis dengan bahasa Indonesia yang proper (benar dan baku). Berarti besar kemungkinan bahasa Indonesia formal anda juga seperti itu.
I'm Indonesian, and while it's true that the lack of tenses, genders, conjugations make Indonesian seem like a very easy to learn language, we have a lot of prefixes and suffixes to change the meaning of a word. Remembering when to use it and how to put it might be challenging for most people 🤣
In short, for beginner it's really easy, for deeper learning? It has no ending... I remember has question for a test about paragraph core = inti kalimat, i ask it into 2 different teachers, without the answer sheet. They give me two different answers. Most of the issue because in Indonesia I think we can yapping entire paragraph without any concrete structure. So to formulize it kinda like a Herculean task on its own.
Semoga *Bahasa Indonesia* suatu saat jadi Bahasa Universal setara dengan Bahasa Jepang Korea Mandarin saat ini banyak diminati untuk belajar.
karena kita tau Bahasa Indonesia punya potensi besar dan tersebar ke beberapa negara yang penggunanya diaspora warganegara Indonesia Serta Fakultas Jurusan Bahasa Indonesia di beberapa negara. 😊
fyi skrg udah banyak bule yg belajar bahasa indo. bisa diliat banyak youtuber polyglot seperti RyanHale atau KazuLanguages memilih bhs indo sebagai salah satu bahasa yg dikuasai.
Mungkin berkat pengguna sosial media di indonesia termasuk banyak juga, dan orang orang nya yg ramah dan gampang didekati jadi orang luar tertarik untuk belajar bahasa indo.
shoutout juga kepada para polyglot indonesia yg memperkenalkan bahasa indo ke internasional seperti kak Genesia, SonnyWilson, Fiki Naki, dll
Kenapa tidak? Bahasa indonesia, bahasa yang mudah dipelajari, dan aku berharap banyak film dan drama indonesia yg makin diminati orang asing
Kita doakan yang terbaik. Sekarang bahasa Indonesia juga sudah menjadi bahasa resmi ke 10 sidang umum UNESCO. Artinya harapan kita membawa bahasa Indonesia mendunia masih ada. Yang perlu adalah kita harus terus pakai bahasa Indonesia dengan benar dimanapun kita berada, perkenalkan dengan orang luar. Musik Indonesia dengan bahasa Indonesia juga bagus-bagus. Kita promosikan saja lewat lagu juga.
suatu bahasa diminati karena nilainya, bukan karena karakteristik bahasa itu sendiri. apakah nilai dari bahasa Indonesia sehingga diminati bangsa asing? ekonomi, budaya, politik? saya rasa tidak banyak. berbeda dengan kita orang indo lokal yang kalau gak mau belajar bahasa Indonesia sejak kecil bisa hilang dari peredaran.
Note that the languages featured in the video come from different language families, except for English and German, which are both Germanic. So when the American says that German sounds like an older, more sophisticated English, she's not entirely wrong. Although Chinese, Japanese, and Korean all use Chinese characters, they originate from different language families and have distinct characteristics.
I understand why Genesia feels a bit defensive about Indonesian being perceived as similar to Thai. These languages don't even belong to the same language family. Judging them to be similar just because both are from Southeast Asia can come across as quite ignorant. If someone said Indonesian sounded like Tagalog, it would be more understandable since both languages belong to the Austronesian family.
Stereotypes exist for a reason, but ultimately, how a language sounds depends on the speaker. A Japanese warlord and a kawaii girl from a maid café in Akihabara would sound completely different. Although I’m not a big fan, I do think Xiaomanyc’s impressions accurately reflect how foreigners perceive different languages.
Genesia, as a polyglot, speaks all the languages featured in this video. If I were her, I’d be an insufferable show-off, so I’m thankful for her positive representation of Indonesia 😁
Tagalog lacks words or vocabularies that's why there's so many English words and some spanish words in tagalog speakers. The Philippine government needs to create more new words and to complete this language because right now it is very incomplete language like those pavement road projects that is left incomplete.
@@Toolbox12-y1pI wouldn't say "lack of words". I would say "flexible". Indonesian language also has loan words.
@@Toolbox12-y1p not lack but some new object exist from other country that why language usualy absorb, many english absorb latin/greece
@@kunderemp ang sabihin mo ai wala ka lang nationalism para sa sarili mong wika na ai Tagalog. Gusto mo lang ng some English/Spanish words para mukha kang cool. Another branch of pridefulness and arrogance and colonial mentality of Pilipinos aka slavery mentality. Matutu maging humble para hindi mapapahiya. ᜋᜃᜊᜌᜈ᜔ ᜋᜃᜏᜒᜃ
@@awancah7309 in denial slave mentality you have. Just like when Spain made Pilipinos slaves during the colonial period
Indonesian is big country. You need learn Indonesia language to travel deep more. If you just speak english, maybe you just can go to Bali or Jakarta. Same as like china there Cantonese, Hakka and other dialect. Indonesia language is lingua franca. Many of them dont speak english.
so back when i studied in korea in 2008, i had a relationship with a german woman and i could tell you it's a smooth and calming language.
Plz invite them together again this is very educational
Thank you
You really like education. Go deeply learn the languages then
Indonesian language should be the official world language because its easy to learn, you can communicate in few months of learning it. In 3 months staying in Bali i can communicate and understand the locals with basic bahasa Indonesia. This language is beautiful.
I am so sick of this stereotype that German is an angry language. Scream and every language sounds aggressive.
Exactly. Or when they're comparing German words to French, English, Italian, Spanish. Yeah no shit, it's almost as if languages in the same language group will have similar words.
@@ginismoja2459they also come up with the exact same examples each and every time. How often do we need to learn about German matchbox and squirrels or ridiculous long words from law school or even completely made up ones?
I'm brazilian and have always been amazed by the german language, ever since I was 12 (I don't have any relatives from Germany, just pure curiosity for languages in general). I think it's such a beautiful and misjudged language, I went back to studying it now and am absolutely in love with it. People that replicate this stereotype are just ignorant 🤨
All thanks to that austrian painter guy
As a native tonal language speaker, german sounds so strong and blunt compare to other european languages
9:12 interesting as a German I get the same feeling when listening to Nordic languages. The words sound familiar but have that little bit of lost magic to them that out language lacks.
As a slovene i get the same feeling with almost all other balkan languages and as a german speaking person i completely agree
Besides just the tones themselves, Chinese is often spoken very expressively (Cantonese even more than Mandarin). Especially when the drinks are flowing, everything sounds 10x more dramatic than any other language. LOL I love it though.
The Japanese girl sounds indeed super super cute. The soft spoken high pitch sound, irresistible!!!
I loved this episode. Specially learning about Indonesian
1:53 - I totally ship this !
I'm a German living in Spain married to a Spaniard. At our wedding celebration my Soanish family said about German that it sounded as if were always angry. My German family said about my Spanish family that it seemes they were always shouting at each other.. In one case it was for the sound of the language, in the other for the way of interacting. The outcome: the same.
Indonesian is a beautiful and cool language. In 2023, Indonesian will become the official language of the 10th UNESCO general assembly or conference.
Nice and the language become popular among the Filipinos especially Overseas Filipino Workers and Armed Forces of the Philippines 😊😊
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 That must be navy, I talked to a few of them
@@renofumi28Ooh yeah Philippine Navy also have 😊😊
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 Do you mean the Armed Forces of the Philippines uses Indonesian? I once read comments from Filipinos that Indonesian was the language studied in the Philippine army. But to be honest at that time I didn't really believe it.
@@darwinqpenaflorida3797 But I believe that Filipinos are already used to Indonesian because there are lots of Filipino comments on Indonesian songs or music on TH-cam. Maybe you know the Indonesian songs Dola by Angga, Faja Skali by Angga, Cintamu Sepahit Topi Miring, and many more. Indonesian songs often go viral in several countries in ASEAN and even outside ASEAN.
The craziest thing is, one person can speak to all of their languages, but they are cant talk her language, so she can be a spy among of them 😅
In what world was the guy in the first english video speaking in a uk accent? It was incredibly obviously an American accent.
Exactly, what is she talking about? Is she fake American? That's totally American, which part of British in his accent lmao
Older, rich brother of English xD I can totally see that personification
Actually the ones who creating those stereotypes about German language they are German themselves. As far as I know those guys in the video who were comparing languages all of them are German.
22:06 𝗘𝘅𝗰𝗲𝗽𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻;
◽1 Butterfly : 1 Kupu-kupu
◽1 Spider : 1 Laba-laba
◽1 Firefly : 1 Kunang-kunang
◽1 Tortoise : 1 Kura-kura
◽1 Sheep : 1 Biri-biri
◽1 Dolphin : 1 Lumba-lumba
◽1 Otter : 1 Berang-berang
◽1 Squid : 1 Cumi-cumi
◽1 Falcon : 1 Alap-alap, etc
If the animals above are plural, then;
◽2 Butterflies : 2 Kupu-kupu
◽2 Tortoises : 2 Kura-kura, etc
If you ask how to differentiate between exceptions, then the answer is "I don't know".. wkwkwk 😂 🤣 🤭 The solution is that you have to specifically ask a native Indonesian about the word you mean.. We will tell you whether it is an exception or not..
17:04 how did her arm merge with the TV?
Indonesian,,❤
I like the US girl's way of describing a language, and also the Indonesian one but probably I'm a bit bias as an Indonesian.
Udah mulai jago ngasih judul sama thumbnail, channel ini tahu apa yang harus dilakukan.
3:12..... What?? That didn't sound like a UK accent??? It was clearly American English. Did y'all watch a different video than what we saw?
Yeah, that was confusing, how the hell is that a UK accent.
I think she was trying to place more emphasis on the pitch itself, not the actual English accent. And at least one of their many accents does tend to go up in pitch just like that.
the way Bahasa Indonesia is fast flowing and really simple rule wise came from the way it originated being both based on a market language/dialect version of malay and being a designed uniting language so it's made to be easy to understand
thank you for invited a good women have better knowlage about indonesian languange, not like past time
Favorite group in world friends 😊😊
Thank you so much
Great episode
I'm from Germany and I'm not a big fan of our language, BUT it's not that aggressive at all.
My favorite languages are Korean, Japanese and Mandarin. I just love them. Especially Korean and Japanese. ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
If I can say Bahasa Indonesia don't have any characteristic accent. That's why, if you don't understand any word in Bahasa Indonesia, you cannot imitate or stereotyping the language
I hope we get a part 2 of this video with different countries ❤
Indonesian polyglots are people too bro
Bahasa Indonesia is easy. The problem is when you learn the bahasa in one place or one city, you'll learn it with its culture or its slang or its dialect and the mix with its local language. And when you move to another place, then you will know what you have learned from previous place is kinda different with your current place. I'm from bandung and now I'm working in bekasi (90 minutes away from bandung), even after 5 years working in bekasi, i still don't get much of bekasi's dialect or its local slang
This group very great
Thank you!!!
Yeaa I love it ❤
Post anothers pleasee
Many stereotypes of the Chinese language came from Hong Kong movies, since it was very popular in the 70s, 80s, and 90s. So, the Chinese that the foreigners usually heard are Cantonese.
Cantonese are loud, crude, and exaggerated. But the most spoken language in China is Mandarin. It sounds more soft, calm, and refined.
Oh bitch pls Another day, another comment shitting on Cantonese by the superior mandarin speakers. Talk to a northeasterner then come back and tell me Mandarin is refined and gentle and whatnot bs.
Fact is that every language sounds aggressive when you shout😂
Ngakak banget liat muka“ mereka fokus dan bingung gitu pas orang Indonesianya langsung ngomong pake bahasa indonesia 😂😂
Now, german is one of the most melodic language. But you have to know it really and use it in the right way. I think that it s the same for any language.
Explaining that a bit like chinese and french made sense. Because Indonesia does get influenced by it's asian influence plus european influence
Setuju banget kalo bahasa Indonesia itu mudah buat dipelajarin. Tinggal buang grammar, buang gender. Simpel.
Thats informal form of Bahasa Indonesia you guys found hard to learn. Wichis depend from what region it come, it might be sounds diferent.
In formal Bahasa Indonesia :
Saya setuju sekali bahwa belajar bahasa Indonesia itu mudah. Tidak perlu menggunakan kata penunjuk waktu, tidak perlu menggunakan kata penunjuk kelamin. Sesederhana itu.
Thats was the type of Bahasa Indonesia you guys can easily learn or mostly tought.
I speak Indonesian, English, and Japanese
for fast language or not. From my experience, it is depend on people but women usually do speak faster than men no matter what language it is
my teacher also said "yeah we (women) need to speak fast to save time"
I kinda hate when they say german (and russian) sounds aggressive, when it isnt right, it only sound loud if you say it this way
Coming from a german/ russian
There is a video from around 12 years ago called "How English sounds to non-English speakers" and it was mostly nonsense sounds with a few basic words and swears being actual English.
This is full of positive vibe yoo
Genesia explained Bahasa Indonesia very well x)))
I think the Indonesian accent sounds like a Spanish accent.
07:38 I love when Indonesian girl trying to speak it xD
Genesia!👍🏻
indonesian talk in similar way as spanish speaker, really fast.. that's because there are so many syllables in just one word, their normal speed sounds really fast to other people.
Sebenernya genesia termasuk orang yg ngomong bahasa indonesianya cepet.
Make Indonesia better known to the world
Indonesian language has suposed to be easy though, cause there's so many different languages and accent in every island in there....
She said the guys peaking English random words had a UK ACCENT? WTF- it was very clearly and obviously a standard american accent.
just wait till indonesia becomes 4th biggest economy in the world, and people are gonna learn Indonesian language and it becomes popular
I hear this for many many years and I'll believe it when I see it. I can see the potential but the religion can be an issue. Businesses close early during fasting month around 3ish in the afternoon. How can you expect international corporations to shut down operations around 3ish everyday for a month? Then 1 or 2 weeks off for Ramadhan.
Lets wait 20-30 years
dude just wait@@ryanhp3170
Indonesian language is mixed melayu dutch and japan. How i know from history before 1945
joana looks really soft
I can guarantee that the man in the video is not speaking Mandarin, but Cantonese. Although I can't speak Cantonese, I can still hear it. To be honest, Cantonese is more suitable for singing because it rhymes, but it is very stiff and not soft when spoken normally.
Please invite your friends to visit Indonesia☺
Indonesian still similar to Dutch in the way pronouncing word, but Indonesian doesnt use throat vocal.
Indonesian Alphabet adopt from Dutch Spelling, except G,J,R,U,Y.
Indonesian laguange is easy, yes, but in daily life, people in Indonesia speak their local/regional laguange more than Indonesia languange, because we have a lot of ethnicities, there are different accents even when we speak Indonesian languange. So nobody speaks proper Indonesian like the book taught 😁👍
12:00 Kotoha dozing off thinking about she talk very slow in Korean but the others says it was her cute point 😂😂
20:07 entah apa yang lucu di part ini tapi bikin ketawa 😆😆😆😆
For me Chinese is something like "................wan- 😊"
😂😂😂
I'm from Austria. No R in the back of the throat for me. Just speak the more relaxed Austrian German. 😄
"Hah!"nya realistik banget 😭😭
20:10 As a french person i can say it does NOT sounds like french 😭 it sounds more like italian
I think I'm fell in love to Joana! 🫣
Btw, Indonesian is an easy language to learn because it doesn't use sentence structures like the one Genesia explains.
But what is difficult about bahasa Indonesian is writing. 80% of Indonesian people I have known in my entire life cannot write bahasa Indonesian properly. In fact it took me almost 3 years to learn to write properly. 😅
Overall, Genesia's explanation of bahasa Indonesian is the best of the 3 other Indonesians I've seen in content like this.
KERJA BAGUS, Neng!! 👏
Where I'm from in California, people don't talk like that. 😂
I'm Indonesian.
*I think Indonesia accent sound like US English.*
Kalian setuju gak ?
Jauh
There are many german words with no english translation which are very useful. Weltschmerz, Ohrwurm, verschlimmbessern, gemütlich, Zugzwang.
You'd have to use more than one word on most of them, but I think "earworm" can be one word or two in English. That's the one I've heard, anyway. Zugzwang actually IS a word in English - stolen by chess players :)
I dare anyone in the comments to pronounce “Rindfleischettiketierungsüberwachungsaufgabenübertragungsgesetz” (a word for a German law about beef).
geanau
I hate strotype because not accurate, but it's how human learning
That english was NOT in an english accent that was 100% american 😭😭
0:33 gyoikitenkai !! Jujutsu Kaïsen !!!!!!!! i like it by Sukuna !
8:28 I AM ALSO FROM BONN
English was spoken in a North American accent, not British.
to be honest the woman from germany is cute and attractive, only her who is different from other woman
Kelihatan mau cari penonton 😂 dari Indonesia 😜, kelihatan dari tumbnail dan judul 😜😝😂
Bagus biar ada jejak digital tentang indonesia
dih
salah satu contoh netizen julid indo
Alhamdulillah kak, soalnya bisa sekalian ngenalin Indonesia kan ^^
@@itstammy15 yang sangat ramah itu 😊
Wow mantap 🇮🇩👍
20:14 doesn't sound french at all more like russian sound
The Korean Kkch sound lol I only make that sound if I have something super bitter or sour xD
i think the german sacon accent not dialect nut the slightly tone of dialect u know thats more like english flowe whise we scrunch words together and are verry fast its hard to follow for non native speakers its liek the adhd dialect of germany lmao in my opinion
i at least once i got fuent in english never had the impression my melody of speach sounds any different i also never had difficultys with the flow or anything not even much with accent couse saxonian is a softer dialect for the most part more mumbled as well
so it verrys within germany how ot sounds
7:35 as a german i really hate this video by now. Literally EVERY video that talks about language differences use this sketch as an example, which obviously is a bad choice for that.
Bravo 👏
11:09 cute
next guess the language of the Indonesian region
10:17 That didn't sound russian to me at all xD