MC-21: Inside Russia's Quest to Build Its Own Boeing-737
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- 👉 Download the Unacademy app - unacademy-lang...
- Learn Spanish, French and German with free daily lessons.
- Interactive lessons with unique cultural bites
- Gamified challenges to keep you motivated
- Start speaking fluently with Speak mode
- Absolutely uninterrupted learning with ZERO ADS!
Exclusive report from an aviation plant in Siberia where Russia is attempting to develop its first completely home-grown airliner since Soviet times. But can the MC-21 truly take to the skies without any Western components?
ckve3hv9ld
If you'd like to support Real Reporter:
💵Patreon - / realreporter
💵Boosty - boosty.to/real...
💵PayPal - paypal.me/Real... - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
👉 Download the Unacademy app - unacademy-language-learning.onelink.me/ewRt/r4ova2wj
- Learn Spanish, French and German with free daily lessons.
- Interactive lessons with unique cultural bites
- Gamified challenges to keep you motivated
- Start speaking fluently with Speak mode
- Absolutely uninterrupted learning with ZERO ADS!
No Russian??
Do you know if Andrey is still alive? Maybee you can make an update onm him?
Woohoo! the vid I was waiting on! Further comments after I watched it! ;-)
Edit: ok, watched it. It was again a fun and interesting vid, and your editing really is on pro-level, I would say: even regulr TV networks wouldn't be able to offer much better.
One thing I'm a bit confused though, is you calling the airplane "MS". I always figured it was MC, with the C pronounced as...well, C. (Sounding like "see"). Is it a Russian letter, mayhaps, or why is the "C" pronounced as "S"?
13:57 Nono, you can't fool us! It's because you are a spy/ Russian propagandist paid by the Kremlin. Or was it the Orthodox Church? Whatever; you're what the fat American will say you are! (cue, next vid of him "analyzing" once again your "soft propaganda"). ;-)
One thing I do find slightly disappointing however, is that you were pretty limited in your research, or should I say "examples" of airplanes and aviation-capabilities of Russia. I sort of expected you to shed more of a light on the whole Russian aviation and it's progress (or lack thereof); how it is doing, what airplanes they try to build or muster to keep going, etc. There are a lot of aviation projects and airplanes being build or planned or refitted, and not only the MC-21. But sadly, you didn't touch on any of them. I mean, I understand of course that you focus on that one, since you gained access after months of trying - so of course, you'd want to show this feat. But still, it wouldn't have hurt if you mentioned some others airplanes and attempts of Russia to remain self-sufficient in the aero-space domain, even if only in passing.
Ah well, maybe next time.
Also; is there no possibility for Russia to buy Chinese components, in the meantime that they develop everything on their own soil? What is the most realistic timetable for the MC-21 to go into serial production, if they have to build all the parts themselves? Can other planes be brought "online" faster than the MC-21?
There are still a lot of questions I'm left with, and I could easily have watched another hour of it without getting bored. ;-)
Well, anyway, I hope this vid does well too, and one coffee coming up! I see I'm being mentioned at 7:39! (Indirectly, as a "non-patreon supporter" :-p )
Well let me tell you a secret, sanction does not mean to stop a government from war but the sanctions help the world leaders to influence the target country people to revolt against their government and help CIA-like agencies to topple the targeted government... I hope I am clear in conveying my message.
Woohoo! the vid I was waiting on! Further comments after I watched it! ;-)
Edit: ok, watched it. It was again a fun and interesting vid, and your editing really is on pro-level, I would say: even regulr TV networks wouldn't be able to offer much better. One thing I'm a bit confused though, is you calling the airplane "MS". I always figured it was MC, with the C pronounced as...well, C. (Sounding like "see"). Is it a Russian letter, mayhaps, or why is the "C" pronounced as "S"?
13:57 Nono, you can't fool us! It's because you are a spy/ Russian propagandist paid by the Kremlin. Or was it the Orthodox Church? Whatever; you're what the fat American will say you are! (cue, next vid of him "analyzing" once again your "soft propaganda"). ;-)
One thing I do find slightly disappointing however, is that you were pretty limited in your research, or should I say "examples" of airplanes and aviation-capabilities of Russia. I sort of expected you to shed more of a light on the whole Russian aviation and it's progress (or lack thereof); how it is doing, what airplanes they try to build or muster to keep going, etc. There are a lot of aviation projects and airplanes being build or planned or refitted, and not only the MC-21. But sadly, you didn't touch on any of them. I mean, I understand of course that you focus on that one, since you gained access after months of trying - so of course, you'd want to show this feat. But still, it wouldn't have hurt if you mentioned some others airplanes and attempts of Russia to remain self-sufficient in the aero-space domain, even if only in passing.
Ah well, maybe next time.
Also; is there no possibility for Russia to buy Chinese components, in the meantime that they develop everything on their own soil? What is the most realistic timetable for the MC-21 to go into serial production, if they have to build all the parts themselves? Can other planes be brought "online" faster than the MC-21? There are still a lot of questions I'm left with, and I could easily have watched another hour of it without getting bored. ;-) Well, anyway, I hope this vid does well too, and one coffee coming up! I see I'm being mentioned at 7:39! (Indirectly, as a "non-patreon supporter" :-p )
Lots of Russian tourists here in Sanya, China. So many in fact that even some of the locals are speaking Russian, serving Russian food, installing Russian signs and playing Russian music in the shops. 😅
Why vacation in another country only to eat familiar food?
Well you guys are also more than present here. And welcome. Love from Russia, mate.
Here in Shanghai the Germans and french have left since COVID and we just see Russians now.
@@NoFL88in west europe they are not.
and indulging in Russian flesh trade too?
As a pilot of Boeing jets, I sadly agree the US civil aircraft industry is in a bad state. That being said, the MS-21 was supposed to use the Pratt and Whitney Geared turbofan. One area that Russia has never been able to compete with American aircraft is the quality and longevity of aircraft engines. I’m interested to see what happens going forward. Of course I wish success to every civil aviation manufacturer, Boeing, airbus, and yes even Yakovlev! When quality products hit the market, everybody benefits.
Thanks for the level headed comment 🤝
The PD-14 will power it.
I'd say 99% of Americans forget that, after the bankruptcy of the USSR, our sharks and hyenas went in and not only broke up Aeroflot but, we shut down the old Soviet civil aviation sector. That enabled us to compel the new Russian Federation to buy Boeing and Airbus airliners as part of their debt restructuring. We stripped the equity out of the Soviet estate and forced sales of Western stuff to boost Wall Street and City of London. The legacy Soviet-built airliners were suffering from neglect and parts stripping was rampant to keep the rapidly dwindling domestic fleet in the air.
Fortunately, Vladimir Putin saw the giant ripoff in all this and he's been working hard to dig Russia out of the hole that Yeltsin put them in.
efficient , price, longevity, and the list is so long !!!.......but to me, it is still a battle between quality and schedule, you dont shorten an engineering process to meet a schedule. i hope MC-21 will become a better airplane.
Oh, please… It’s like you never heard of new generation of Russian engines. While your engines (Pratt etc) are never 100% U.S.-made, sourcing components from EU, UK, Japan and SKorea, Russia manufactures those engines all by itself.
Boing is full of maintenance issues, two US engineers suddenly died who exposed boing 800+ safety problems ,particularly one you are flying with 😂
If two people die in the same year, in the same context, it can happen, but it is more likely that they were both murdered.
@swissneutro2648 Looks like it 👍 have a nice day 😊
And also the Boeing starliner spacecraft had issues and I wasn't surprised.
Maybe they need to hire less "pride people" and hire more real engineers?
@@swissneutro2648 Everybody knows they were assassinated.
I think Russia is one of the few countries on earth that has the resources and an educated population to rise to such tasks. Be proud of your country, necessity is the mother of inventions and you guys got pretty smart people living there ❤
I'm afraid it's not. The Ms-21 without the developed world's engines and avionics (not to mention tooling) is a big fat failure.
russian domestic hackjob engines are hopeless when you look at specs such as weight, service life, fuel efficiency and reliability.
@@Bac4-qu6qg7sk4v If it was any other country then I would kinda agree, but Russia is one of the few countries on earth that has the technical know-how/experience to overcome these odds. I mean they basically make all the equipment for their military, how many other countries can say the same? Of course it is my personal belief and they also got China to supply them with higher tech electronics if necessary.
People were laughing at Russian equipment at the start of the war, but it turns out that Western equipment has its own sets of challenges and are not any better (they burn the same).
Do you know any Good russian Product ? Lada , Vodka .... They sell only Gas and Oil and agriculture products, that's it.
@@JürgenWernicke-i8i Way to misunderstand what I wrote, just because you do not see Russian products being popular abroad doesn't necessarily mean that they are of low quality. Just because Russian civil aviation industry is not that advanced compared to the West does not mean that they cannot improve and overcome the challenges to produce their own. After all my whole point was that Russia is one of the few countries on earth that has the potential to overcome such challenges, mainly due to them being able to create such things in the past and them also being strong in STEM fields.
@@evilleader1991 Passenger aircraft are not can openers or facelifted 1960's era soviet tanks (which russia, admittedly is still able to churn out at some capacity) Russia presently produces a cessna clone that their state tv tried to present as some massive achievement but they failed to point out that it costs 3X the price of the by far superior real thing that is made in the US 🤣
African countries really need to learn survival skills and independence mentality from Russia.
Самое главное умение - умение вовремя объединиться❤
The Soviet Union made tremendous strides and improvements to their African clients many decades ago. Yet Africa has fallen back into its native primitive state. They cannot be helped.
Africa needs to stop "Murica and European colonists from looting their countries.
Yes. It could be usefull when they realised that russia took over their countries, just like others before them
a bunch of colonies
На самом деле проблема куда глубже. Сначала планировали 2 двигателя ставить: Пратт Уитни и ПД-14. После 14 года Пратт Уитни перестали поставлять свои движки, а ПД-14 был еще не готов. Потом, когда с движками уже разобрались, Японцы запретили поставки армирующих волокон для композитного крыла. Пришлось самим разрабатывать их и выстраивать производство и заново проводить все испытания крыла. Дальше, когда уже и с движками и с крылом разобрались, наступил 22 год и запретили уже всю электронику. Так по ступенькам и откладывали выход МС-21. И вот после первого запрета уже надо было понять, что ни на кого полагаться нельзя и нужно все делать самим, но у нас, к сожалению, решали, что незачем вкладываться в собственные разработки, если все можно было купить и это было дешевле, чем разрабатывать с нуля. Такая же логика, как с лизингом самолета, мол зачем разрабатывать свой за дорого, если можно взять в лизинг дешевле. С Суперджетом та же логика: его разрабатывали на базе западных компонентов, а щас также перестраивают все производство уже на нашу компонентную базу.
мне иногда кажется что они специально заставляют Россию всё делать самой. Это такой обучающий образовательный эффект для России со стороны Запада и ее сателитов. Если честно, то Россия могла бы сделать и полностью независимую собственную микроэлектроникку и полупроводниковую промышленность. Она это может.
> И вот после первого запрета уже надо было понять, что ни на кого полагаться нельзя и нужно все делать самим
Это надо было понять еще в 1991 году. Причем об этом говорили все и постоянно и во всех отраслях, не только в авиастроении. Но эффективным и мобильным манагерам это было не интересно. До последнего пытались встроиться в "западный цивилизованный мир".
Что же, остаётся только поблагодарить представителей западных компаний за развитие российской промышленности!) Им удалось то, что чиновники саботировали на протяжении многих лет. 😅
Электроника давно уже была своя или вы думаете на военные самолеты стеклянную кабину импортную ставили? Все оборудование ,FMS, МОНИТОРЫ и другое производит КРЭТ
@@vknfriendly не совсем. Понятно, что для военных ставили свои системы. Но для гражданки БРЭО не было. Об этом как раз в видео и отвечает один из инженеров завода. Обидно, что даже военные у нас иногда занимаются такой фигней. Я слышал, что в той же армате какая то часть аппаратуры планировалась импортная. А потом также наступил 24 год и парам парам пам.
Finally a video on Russia's MC 21 thanks Real Reporter for making this video
@@sailaab Надпись на русском языке. МС - [em] [es] где "С" соответствует английской S. В русском языке нет С-[si]
@@sailaab it is MS, in Russian C= Eng S
@@sailaab It's official name in Russian is "MS". Russia did branded it as "MC" though for international audiences and market. So there are 2 official names for this aircraft "MC 21" and "MS 21". Both are correct, it leads to confusion but it's the same plane.
большое спасибо. да, я должен был догадаться об этом, поскольку знаю кириллицу @@user-ri7we3rw9z
Thank you so much @@yalex3117 now i get
A unique case in the world of aviation. The Russians are the only ones in the world who have managed to create an aircraft completely of their own production on a full cycle. And it is incorrect to compare the production of aircraft in the USSR and in modern Russia. The USSR is 350 million people, a huge market and close cooperative chains. Russia is only a small part of the production infrastructure of the USSR. Therefore, it is quite correct to say that the aviation industry in Russia starts from scratch.
China already created their own aircraft
@@MsMelkus No. China has not created "its own" aircraft. Look at what kind of engines it has and what components it is assembled from. This is a cooperation of various global manufacturers in the aviation industry. The only caveat is that China forced these companies to open branches in their country (as part of the creation of joint ventures). Why do you call a Chinese plane "Chinese"?
@@xalekcey it is still a new plane and it is manufactured inside China
@@MsMelkus Do you understand the meaning of the comment? Today, Russia is becoming the only country in the aviation industry that is able to INDEPENDENTLY produce a full-cycle aircraft! China cannot produce airplanes on its own (only in close cooperation with international manufacturers, using their components on its aircraft). The "Chinese" aircraft has American engines, French avionics, Italian hydraulics, and so on... The only caveat is that these firms had to open their branches in China and create "joint ventures"
@@xalekcey mc21 was using a lot foreign components before 2022. Current situation with inventing everything domestic is not something good - it is problem that makes mc21 too expensive. Obviously China does not have problems with sanctions(yet) and don't need to invent everything. However, having all that factories inside the China will make possible sanctions useless
Bro, we live in Scandinavia, and prices have gone through the roof - food, electricity, restaurants, travel, hotels - everything. There's been a 35-100% increase across most things. So it's not just Russia. I also travel a lot across Europe, and it's the same everywhere. From watching different Russian TH-camrs, I can confirm that you guys have a better standard of living than most people here in the West.
Libya got better standard than you that's why they killed Ghadaffy
This is a very accurate observation. Sanctions on Russia and Iran are having the reverse effect. This tool that the west used to have has lost its effectiveness. Both Russia and Iran are far more self sufficient and technically advanced than they were before sanctions
@@WagnerGroup-iy6gr Correcto mundo!
“i can confirm” said no one from Scandinavia comparing their quality of life to Russians.
@@ArktinenJenkki did you see the video they comparing just about everything
Making the planes wider, so customers don't feel like sardines, will be a big selling point in itself.
Nobody wants to buy russian aviation- it is like Lada car.
@@JürgenWernicke-i8ior everybody wants to buy Russian aviation. It's like nuclear plants
@@daniilgavrilikhin34 like Chernobyl? they not so good with nuclear plants either and those don't fly
@os10v311 aha, still better than Fukushima))
Boeing and Airbus could make bigger Planes/Seats but that also increases the fuel cost which no one wants cause it is the biggest cost in operating an Airplane. Just look older Aircraft back 30-40 years ago
In the long run, this plane will benefit russia a lot.
1. Russia will be able to sell these to african and asian countries under sanctions as well. If they cant get a hold of Boeing or Airbus, then this is a great option.
2. Pride. It just shows that russia has smart people, not just buying everything from abroad.
3. The mc 21, shes beautiful
Edit: just because there's tons of problems right now, it doesn't mean it would be a good aircraft. Look at the sukhoi superjet. Very problematic at first but now, it's extremely reliable. Same for other aircraft that first started out but later became reliable. Both Western and Soviet aircraft. Like the Il 86, later became the Il 96 and now it's reliable. Or like the Tu 204. Not as "good" as western Aircraft but now reliable and safe like the west. It takes time to develop aircraft and thousands of man hours of engineering
@@er5hy The west has 0 leverage against BRICS countries (more than half of the world population).
@@er5hy The west has 0 leverage against BRICS countries (more than half of the world population).
1) They can sell it to the Chinese, and the other parts of the world that do not honor US sanctions or who are not allied with the US.
2) They can unite with the Iranians and possibly the Chinese for the scale of production to sell and produce them en masse.
3) The Iranians and Chinese can help them overcome any Technical or design issue.
🇷🇺
I live in Irkutsk, where the MS-21 aircraft is being assembled.
Irkutsk region is not the largest region of Russia, but Ukraine, Hungary, Slovakia, and Moldova may be located on its territory. In summer, some areas of the region can only be reached by plane. In winter, a car trip will take three to four days, which is fraught with dangers. Russia needs a lot of its own planes!
@@er5hy Yep. China needs airplanes. Be it 929 or MC-21 or both, they can procure both. :)
То Русијо, дивим се вашем народу, за све сте способни, љуби вас и воли Србин из Републике Српске, надам се убрзом пресељењу у Русију 🇷🇸❤️🇷🇺
Хвала! Какой красивый язык у вас, это просто праздник для сердца :)
Переезжают, мы вам рады!) Вы не те ребята из Средней Азии, кто не уважают Россию и коренное население, совершенно не знают русского языка, даже не изучают его.
Same shit serbs and russian, same people stuck in last century
Спасибо, друже!
Приветствуем! Всегда будем рады видеть, как гостя, так и соседа.
Great video!I am glad that you were able to obtain permission to film the facility!
He was asked to..
@@texfromro what?
@@GoodFella-xw8yx I don't understand what exactly you are not understanding. What i wrote are 4 simple words and one idea. The guy is a russian propagandist that was asked to make a video on how mighty Russia is just unbothered by the West's sanctions...
@@texfromro "on how mighty Russia is just unbothered by the West's sanctions..." did you watch the video? but sure he is a russian patriot. He does not have to be "bought" to love his country.
LokiOdinssnn it might be an exercise in futility to try to reason with someone who has a closed mind and not open to rationale thinking or even pragmatically apply critical thinking.
Уважаемые люди, кто причастен к этому самолету и другим российским авиационным проектам, Вы наша гордость, люди с замиранием ждут и верят , борясь со скептиками, пожалуйста сделайте серийный выпуск, это очень нужно для страны и народа России, чтобы поверить в себя! Дай вам бог всего!
I live in the West and it's interesting to see de-globalization starting. I wonder if Russia and China will succeed in decoupling.
You don´t understand trade
Absolutely. The winds of change are already here and you can feel the ground shaking in the US. Industry-wide massive layoffs, high prices, food, gas, medicine, inflation through the roof, massive unemployment, crumbling infra, etc.
Basically they only miss advanced (last 2 generations) chips now. Everything else they seems to do fine or even better by themselves.
It'll never happen cos they both lack in technology.
@@starhawkstarhawk969mentira
Кто-то недавно заикнулся о безопасности в боинг. И внезапно умер. Привет свобода .
Бизнес по американски. Ох сколько подобных случаев в политике и нефтегазе, не сосчитать
President Putin has some sincere admirers at Boeing 🙄
@@stefanodadamo6809 Do you know Dead Sea? Putin killed it
А в России кто то заикнулся о свободе. И тоже умер...Привет Zона.
@@nikolayl8930 your name is not debelko
USSR's aviation industry was one of the best in the world if not the best. Russia needs to earnestly work towards regaining that glory.
oh my God you are delusional. What propaganda tv show have you been watching? stop with your propaganda. Russia can't build anything worth shit. Employees are always drunk. Nobody would dare buy anything Russian. You don't have the proper chips to build anything electronic. Russian aviation today id crap and always will be.
What glory and best aviation nation are you talking about?
Do you mean the catastrophic failures such as Tupolev TU-144, TU-154, YAK-42, TU-116, TU-22, Sukhoi Su-7, Lavochkin LaGG-3, Silvanskii IS, early MiG-23MS, Antonov An-10 and probably some more which I never heard of. 🤣
Have you ever flown with USSR plane? They are so noisy and extremly thirsty if you compare them with other.
@@ThePanaconMy favorite plane is the IL-86.
You clearly know nothing about the aviation industry! Soviet planes where noisy, had less range and consummed far more oil than their western competition
Not all international flights from Russia are more expensive now. As an example flights to Australia are even cheaper than they were in 2021. 3 years after the price is about 20% less if you flight through China (China Eastern Airlines, China Southern Airlines). That’s compared to similar flights through China as well. When compared to Singapore airlines or Middle East (Emirates Airlines, Qatar) the current discount is even more.
Good to know! Maybe I can fly to Australia one day to make a video. That would have been great! 😁
@@RealReporterthe Russian TH-camr "Eli from Russia' did make some videos in Australia earlier this year. Its was about travelogue topics. So its possible. However, I wonder what unique, interesting topic would report on that is political or economically interesting that relates to Russia (and Australia)? Maybe look at trade? Most of Australia's top trading partners ate in or will be joining BRICS+, yet Australia is a US And EU vassal state.
It is also fair to say that the prices skyrocketed all across the globe, not just in Russia. The aviation industry is probably trying to compensate the losses suffered during the pandemic. Something tells me the prices will not go down..
@@ICochrane1 It is also fair to say that flights via Serbia and Turkey and UAE are more expensive because there is no competition and these airlines that service these routes are taking advantage of the situation.
@@MrDomingo55 yep, same story everywhere. Well, it would be naive to think big corporations can do something different..
I laughed when he said how safe is boeing. Dude ur in boeing aircraft u have a bigger chance of accidents than other planes lmao.
Russia can do but Russia should engage more and more with Asia and Africa instead of Europe. Russian companies can collaborate with China, Vietnam, Pakistan, Malaysia, Iran, Indonesia and South Africa to toll manufacture some of the plane parts to ease the supply line. The same countries from Asia and Africa can become big selling market for these planes..
Did you mention pakistan 😂
@@deepnijjar5 Pajeet spotted, women not safe in your country 😂
@@deepnijjar5Ok then let's replace Pakistan for Turkey they have a good skills and industry. 😅
А потом придет дядя сем с дубинкой и все прекратит
I feel like this is one of the best journalists to cover Russian issues in English or just at all. I really like your videos, keep it up and I hope you grow! We all need the income
If you like propaganda. So many Russians bots here - or at least paid posts - and so many useful idiots helping Russian shell civilians.
pretty risky. he could be arrested at any time for being a "spy" and held indefinitely. maybe he gets traded back to the west, maybe not
It's not a journalist. It's a russian propagandist sponsored by the kremlin.
The west: We will seize your assets russia
Russia: Ok ill seize yours then
the west: wait no thats theft!
Russia: We acted just like you did
the west: You don't understand, that's different!
There is fresh footage from test flights - looks very impressive for a commercial airliner that size!
Where airplane behave as fighter jet? Lol.
@@juliap.5375 Занудой то не будь.
@@juliap.5375 He was referring to the moment shown at 17:19. Definitely no Su-57, but easily as maneuverable as lame ducks like the F-35 and the like
@@juliap.5375what is the problem with that ?
@@jaylooppworld381 The problem is that as soon as you start to fly your civil aircraft as fighter, your reliability goes down to drain. And it would be good, if it would be only a financial problem to replace parts and repair 3-5 times than planned, but then you will crash to the ground much-much sooner. Try to use standard Ford Focus in NASCAR Racing and you will see.
Much love to Russia. Cheers from Spain
Western airports: "No entry"
Russian air traffic control: *[Uno reverse card]*
I hope it won't be Boeing replacement in terms of reliability :)
Sike
With all due respect, it would be a 1st generation product, with most of the cutting-edge tech still being tested. So this plane will likely be *tested in production.* It's also priced higher than Airbus' offerings, too, but the airlines would probably settle with paying more, so long as they can continue to even function
@@one_step_sideways With all due respect, once they test it in practice and manage to get the kinks out of it, they can streamline parts production and make it even more affordable. Once it has a proven record, there will be a few countries interested in them, like Iran, Cuba, Venezuela and possibly some of the countries in Central Asia and the Middle East.
So they can start exporting as well within the next 10 years. The fact that Boeing is rapidly losing any goodwill or reputation opens up the market internationally for another 1 or 2 production companies for civilian aircraft.
@@8wayz2shine exactly. Boeing is down bad
@@one_step_sideways That's not correct. It's the latest gen product. Most cutting edge tech has been already tested for many years. It's been in "production" since 2007. So it had plenty amount of time to be a reliable plane. It's price is questionable as it hasn't sold a single plane yet HOWEVER. Russian products are waay cheaper on the market because of the cheap ruble. And for proper price parity you need to increase it's price by x3. Because of that, lot's of the Russian tech becomes highly competitive on the int. markets. Planes were always harder to produce for Russia, but it's not going to be more expensive than the western plane.
Well, considering how terrible and unsafe Boeing is now, this is a great thing!
Yeah Boeing lost its way but boeing is far safer than russian aviation! Shukoi superjet 100 crash (July 12 2024)....
Boeing still has oversight though.. even if FAA is a tokenism.. the Europeans tackle the nonsense now and use a magnifying glass to sift through the minutest details too.. or try to.
If MC 21 ends up being used domestically at first.. who is going to independently monitor or guage it without bias or pressure from the powers that be?
@@MrKirua21 yeah, sukhoi kinda sucks unfortunately
Please look at the Wikipedia page for Aeroflot accidents and incidents. Or should I say the dedicated page per decade since the concern was founded.
@MrKirua21
Maybe in some parallel universe. In our universe Boeing have mistakes in engineering and as result fall already several planes. And company knew about this problems and hid this information from everyone. Died hundreds people. Also, before of court few month ago suddenly died two important engineers who know details… guest why.
Sukhoi Superjet - there are no examples of catastrophes because of mistakes in plane like it happens with Boeing. Were several incidents by human factor. Mentioned by you last incident from same category - only 3 people died. Not hundreds as in Boeings each time.
Boeing - in it only for 20% from US made parts. All rest do dozens misc countries, software write different countries. Boeing already failed to control own production. Here is results.
As we fly every Summer, ALL INTERNATIONAL flights have doubled and tripled in price since 2020. I was able to fly from Los Angeles to Bulgaria for $600 during the highest season; now it's $1,800 and more, i.e., 3 times as high!
All hail the mighty Jews for making our life easier
True. One of the reasons is that western air companies also have problems with spare parts
Kudos for being the only TH-camr to call the MS-21 by it's proper name. I must have watched at least three other videos on TH-cam where the English speaking narrators kept calling it the "MC-21" using the English letter C.
He’s Russian so wouldn’t make such a amateur mistake
You would think if the manufacturer put giant MC-21 decals on the plane he's standing behind that they would want it to be called the MC-21....
@@JakeJ.-yi1du Russian alphabet is different so C is like a S hence USSR in Russian is СССР
Republic = Республик hence Р
In English this is letter P
Brazil still has good friendship with Russia through BRICS. Perhaps it would be nice to see a cooperation between the Russian Civil Aviation and EMBRAER. Russia needs a flying plane, Brazil needs all the technology they can get to further compete with Boeing and Airbus. It'd be a win-win.
Superb video. This is the kind of stuff that makes your channel truly great!
Thank you! I’m really glad you enjoyed this episode 🫶
@@RealReporter даже на русском про него мало, а ты взял и с американским акцентом рассказал. Do more unexplored topics
awesome bird made 100% by Russia...I wish I could visit the factory of my beloved KA-52 !! Could you do a report on K-52 please?
Russia purchase over 3 countries so no problem at all
The MS-21 is of course designed in Russia for the most part, but unfortunately, much remains to be done for full import substitution. The same situation is with the Sukhoi Superjet. But it is much more complicated. If the MS-21 already flies on its native engine, then the Superjet still has to receive its native engine, instead of the Franco-Russian SAM-146 (CFM-56 in maidenhood), as well as many other systems.
It would be interesting to see a video about Russian military aircraft. Many aircraft have been known since the USSR, but there is practically nothing about new companies.
@@AnnaAnna-fd6yz all military aircraft comp are state comp.
@@AnnaAnna-fd6yz There is a wonderful series of documentaries about the history of Russian aircraft, called "Wings of Russia". In Russian "Крылья России". The series was created in the 2000s, and there is little information about the newest aircraft, but it provides excellent information about the history of Russian aircraft manufacturing. From the tsarist era to the mid-2000s. I don't know if there is English voiceover or subtitles, but if you speak Russian, these are excellent films for a few evenings.
@@Cergiossik stop with your propaganda. Russia can't build anything worth shit. Employees are always drunk. Nobody would dare buy anything Russian. You don't have the proper chips to build anything electronic. Russian aviation today id crap and always will be.
Suggestion: make a video about Russia's semi-conductor industry, like visiting their factories, exploring and maybe interviewing people there
Yeah do it
I do not think it will be interesting. Semi-conductor industry in Russia is in the very bad state if we talk about modern nanometers processors.
@@MsMelkus talking about modern nanometres. There is only two places in the world, where you can't say so. Thats Taiwan and Samsung foundary in South Korea
@@MsMelkus ROSTEC has been awarded billions of dollars to research X-ray lithography, which is advanced compared to UV lithography used by the West.
@@MsMelkus 110nm is perfectly fine for industrial purposes which Russia currently truly needs. Russia does not need to produce 7nm processors. Parallel imports are possible and they can always manufacture their microprocessors using SMIC, China's biggest chipmaker.
China has a lot more money to invest massively and become competitive against western solutions.
I love what Russia is doing in fighting US EU sanctions. More success and prosperity to the Russians. Happy to hear this great news.
Indeed!
Do you know any russian product you can sell on the world market ? ( without oil, gas vodka)
@@JürgenWernicke-i8i I'm shore you don't know where found Russian 🇷🇺 in location map 🗺️ , In your world the first highest Wheat seller to world is Russia ! Wool 🦙 , Melons 🍈, Green Tea 🍵, Iron , fertilizer, platinum, zinc, nickel, gold 🥇,many many chemical products, water , barley and flaxseed , Apple 🍎 🍏 , car 🚗 Lada ( my home country taxi products 🚕) , millet ,corn ,corn 🌽, Clorox,fish 🐟 🐟 🐠 🐠& seafood, plastic, strawberry 🍓, apricot, software, many parmacytical, jacket 🧥, swimming wear ; many cereals, meat , Paper 🗞️,salt 🧂, potatoes 🍠,flower 🌻 🌹,arm and ammnitions, textile products, military vehicles, other many projects
@@JürgenWernicke-i8i why nafoids are so stupid 😂 do you know that any western aircraft prior to 2022 had like 30% of parts made in Russia? Every airbus had chassis racks made there. Not to mention wing parts, composite materials and etc. jeeez... I won't even mention grains (or do you think that a bread you eat is German? Haha).
And what is actually German? A BMW? Not sure that even a lable on a wheel is made in Germany as most of it's parts are made in other European countries (including Russia), Canada and China.
@@JürgenWernicke-i8iweapon lol
50% of both Boeing and Airbus is made in other countries. Think this man is mostly guessing.
Crises equals opportunity ❤️🇷🇺 from South Africa 🇿🇦
These days world has just one problem "Lack of respect to other people and their cultures" ☝️
"Account created --> 29. jun. 2024"
Your Russian bot activity isn't well masked, Ivan - you might need to try harder if you want your vodka rations. 👎
When you Invade your Neighborhood you don't get Respekt.Russia invaded Ukraine in 2014.
@@elektrotehnik94this comment is worthless. Stalking isn't proof of a claim.
Delete the comment or provide sources.
@@JürgenWernicke-i8iyour English is extremely shit
@@bobsemple9341 Your account is created 20. Oct. 2022?
You aren't even trying anymore, fake profile Ivan 🙃
Every modern passenger jet have polymer wings. The special thing in the MC-21 is that it uses the Out of Autoclave process, that allows for better results overall
One of my students works as an aviation engineer at Pulkovo airport in St. Petersburg. Talking to him I clearly understand that the planes there are well-maintained)
Wow the sanctions actually made Russia THIS independent. It’s like they’re going back to the closed-economy during the Soviet-era. Really interesting tbh.
Nice vid man but can i ask
Where the Cocky lawyer vid both of them are gone is andrey ok?
По госпрограмме в 2023 году отрасль должна была выпустить всего три самолета Ту-214 и два самолета «Сухой-100». В связи с санкциями, поставки импортных двигателей и комплектующих для самолета «Сухой-100» прекратились. Соответственно, прекратился и выпуск. Ни одного самолета Ту-214 также собрать не удалось.
Ух, не, ну его нафиг этот Ту-214
how is Russia unable to make a soviet jet ?
@@cheeseburgersarecool6600 Russia can, this is just airlines do not want her in her current state with her crew of 3 in the cockpit. The key word is not "soviet", but "old". Can US produce today Boeing 707? Even if -yes - there is no need. The decision to restart Ty-214 was taken in the beginning of sanctions as no one new what is going to happen with western planes in the RF. Now it is clear that they can keep them in flying conditions long enough - until MC-14 and others are ready.
Wow, the industrial might of the soviets really withered away just like that, I'm glad Russia is reviving its civil aviation.
Poor leadership and decisions can really destroy anything.
@@MWENDA-vv5im During the 90'ies, Russia's leadership was indeed, poor and weak. The consequences of that period are still echoing to this day, alas.
@@AniMageNeBywell. Its bad now. And noone would like to fly these death boxes.
@kipnick, "Account created --> 30. nov. 2022"
Your Russian bot activity isn't well masked, Ivan - you might need to try harder if you want your vodka rations. 👎
@@MWENDA-vv5imMore likely Boeing lobbyists and Russian corrupt officials.
Boeing is struggling even harder without any sanctions anyway.
Number of jets delivered in 2023. Boeing: 528, Russia (UAC): 2.
С учетом того, какие проблемы у боинга, нам обязательно надо иметь все свое. Верю в наших инженеров!!! Спасибо за великолепный репортаж!
2020: 50% авиалайнеров мира боинг
2040: 30% авиалайнеров мира боинг
2050: 20% авиалайнеров мира боинг
и ведь они сами так захотели, невероятно...
Most excellent report! I absolutely love your reporting and analysis Real Reporter, you are a brilliant journalist! This report on Russias MC 21 commercial aircraft was very interesting and is right in line with my profession as an employee for a major American airline. Thank you for this fascinating video!
I am always surprised with the level of quality of your production of your videos. Well done. One of the best if not the best production on youtube about Russia.
13.24 это не ЯК-38, это ЯК-141, первый сверхзвуковой вертикального взлета и посадки. В серию не пошел.
Як 141 не существует. Это был Як 41.
@@korana6308 ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%AF%D0%BA-141
Yes it did. It goes by the name "F-35" nowadays
VJ 101 in the 1960s was 1st
Well done!
Best wishes from India!
I hope we will be able to make one in our country indeginiously one day
Few additional notes:
1. Before sanctions, western manufactures had close ties with Russian airspace companies and ordered some spare parts here. Including some rare and high - developed things like chassis rack. So some parts are known how to make even here
2. Some other details are quite easy to be found abroad and most of them are new. No secret that most of Russian air companies haven't ordered 737 Max as well as A220/320 Neo, preferring NG and CEO versions. It turned out to be a good strategy since those 'newer" types are difficult to maintain and there are no parts on the market, causing long queue of orders and...grounding. Passengers of WizzAir could notice that in reality, seeing a "wet leased" planes and cancelation of their bookings in emails.
3. Own Russian aircrafts are victims of "effective management " which didn't want to invest, research and develop but spend money in the West and buy their vehicles. This strategy seemed bad even in 2014, but they continued to do that.
Well, Russia was able to do that for a good 30 years after the second WW. It had quite a few successful Russian commercial airliners, such as the IL - 18, Tu - 134, Tu - 154, or Il - 62 and so on. The country need to return to its roots to be self sufficient in airplane manufacturing, like it used to be. It can also import in the meantime from Brasil, those Embraer planes. Perhaps it should pair up with China also, to share manufacturing parts to its airplanes. There are many solutions, which is good, because you need alternatives to survive in this tough environment.
What happened with Andrey and the videos?? 😢
Адвокат попросил удалить видео, его жена против.
Very interesting and non-biased. Thanks.
I'm glad Russia is close to sourcing all of their parts domestically for the МС-21, which is very exciting. I hope once sanctions lift and its easier to reenter russia, I'll get to experience a flight on one domestically!
Considering the United States can hardly keep Boeing aircrafts maintained by ground crew recently with all of these sudden pre and post takeoff "incidents", I think its fair to say Russia is experiencing the same exact thing, and it's probably a result of over reporting on these incidents compared to the past.
We don't exactly have our act together either, so we definitely aren't a country to be opining on for matters of aviation if we have our own extremely similar problems.
Спасибо за интересные репортажи. Здорово было посмотреть как собираются "птички". И да, всё будет хорошо. Привет с Юкона!
you showed a yak-141 (not yak-38) on the second picture 13:27 (the first picture was an actual yak 38)
average wt player:
@@AkyJLa_ damn, I play war thunder too.😎
Хорошо было бы придать огласке, анафеме и суду тех, кто разрушал советский и российский авиапром. Но власть молчит... Наверно это она и разрушала собственную промышленность.
Классное видео. Надеюсь что проект доведут до конца и доработают. Мы ведь действительно умели делать пассажирские самолеты.
Hello from Bulgaria ! Russia not just will survive , they developing ! Russian history is full whit tough times and the always win , it’s in their DNA !! Never give up !!..
Hello brother Slav Simeon! Of course, Russia has always emerged stronger from wars. I am sure in the future, I hope that the Bulgarians will understand that they are the side of the East, not the West, as in the Great Byzantine Empire!
Russian people nobody can stoped. Go forward Russia ❤❤❤
Is The cocky lawyer okay? it seems you deleted his video??
Yes I need to know
He is on deployment and asked him to hide the videos for his safety..
I think the video was deleted due to the threat of blocking the entire channel
Thank you for the documentary. ❤🇷🇺
My pleasure!
Russia engineer always make a masterpiece, and i believe this plane is a World level aircraft.
Self sufficient country with food ,technology , mineral resources and patriotism
Не могу понять, то ли у вас русский родной язык и на английском вы говорите с акцентом, то ли наоборот :) потому что акцент практически нулевой и там, и там!
Русский родной )
Спасибо, что посмотрели видео! 😄👌
@@RealReporter Вы единственный русскоязычный человек, которого я знаю в ютюбе, кто так хорошо / отлично даже, говорит на английском)
@@RealReporter у вас невероятно крутой английский! Это вам от человека со вторым образованием профильного переводчика ;) Единственный человек помимо вас, которого я знаю и который говорит не хуже- это, пожалуй, директор нашего международного центра где я учился. Правда, она говорит, скорее, с академияэческим британским аккцентом) Давольно давно наблюдаю за вашим каналом и только сейчас осознал, что вы русскоязычный. Сам работал в авиационной индустрии и не по наслышке про это всё знаю. От того в тройне интереснее и приятней видеть довольно объективный и развёрнутый обзор данной темы в англоязычном ютубе. Спасибо!
@@RealReporterдобрый день. Офигеть, первый раз смотрю Вас, думал Вы американец😊. Без акцента говорите вообще, просто супер. Лайк и подписка😊. Видео очень интересное, Россию не сломить санкциями, и не такое проходили. Буду следить за Вашими выпусками🤝. Вам удачи во всем, добра и мира.
Is The cocky lawyer okay? it seems you deleted his video?? I hope he is okay and can reunite with his beloved grandmother.
He asked for videos to be removed for some private reasons
@@er5hyПравильно мыслишь. Вот и хвали, может человеком станешь. А что? Чудеса бывают
@@er5hy no ,his family probably got death threats from Ukrainian terrorists
@@er5hyХаля, не хрюкай! 🐽
@@er5hyThe only thing dangerous of it is because it makes Ukrainian Nazis target you and your family.
Thanks for this video about the Irkut MS-21. I am sure that when the aircraft is fully ready to fly, it will be the best there is. I have been following the production of that aircraft for a long time, and know quite a lot about it. I have confidence in the Russian engineers and am sure that they will recreate a fantastic aircraft that the Russian nation can be proud of! As I said before, I follow Russian aviation closely and am fascinated by it. So also the Tupolev 214 and 204, the Sukhoi Superjet New and the new Ilyuchin 96-400 M. The mistake the Russians made in the past is that they neglected their own aviation industry compared to the Western one and that they are now finally taking everything back into their own hands. I am convinced that in twenty years the Russians will have the best aircraft! Fingers crossed!
stop with your propaganda. Russia can't build anything worth shit. Employees are always drunk. Nobody would dare buy anything Russian. You don't have the proper chips to build anything electronic. Russian aviation today id crap and always will be.
🇷🇺
That's right )))
Russians can only make AK-47 assault rifles, hypersonic missiles, nuclear submarines and huge icebreakers!
And at this time, on the ISS, American astronauts are shitting in diapers and do not know when they will be able to return to earth?
pretty sure russia will make great plane, their problem probably just engine.. not as efficient as western
Another interesting video from you, thanks.
Outstanding reporting and beautifully produced!
I periodically say a prayer for your friend the cockey lawyer and wish he remains safe. Cannot help but to like the guy.
как-то мало показали, ожидал если честно больше
Спасибо всем причастным к постройке самолета, мы верим в вас ❤
Russians should be proud of themselves ❤❤❤
Not at all- they should be ashamed for attacking Ukraine.
They should not attack ukraine then?
A true story. My ancestors came to America in 1645 from Holland, so I am very American.
Just for reference.
Almost 20 years ago I was flying to Russia, seated next to a young Russian woman, living in America but returning to Russia to visit her parents. She was casually well dressed. She told me on her first return to Mother Russia her parents were shocked upon seeing her at the airport. They exclaimed "Anna, you live in America, why do you dress like a homeless person!". Fast forward to today and how ironic!!!
you is occupant
Sanctions are simply opportunities for the country to thrive in its own. If they can build nuclear weapons ,needless to say they will build their own Boeings
Полетит и все будем гордиться им! Отличное видео, правда хотелось еще больше 😂
Thanks for the video!
Man this video is good
Hats off to you
Long Live Russia ❤
Сколько колониальной спеси в речи этого товарища. Их только могила исправит.
China is doing it, Japan had a go at it. But look at Tibet: The US refused to help so the French built a 5.5km runway that crumbled. Now they use a 4.5km runway and A319 planes on their second highest airport. Being inside a valley does help and I guess using the morning cold air gives them the extra needed lift. Brics can do it all together, Japan can develop avionics, India can solder it in their new Iphone factories. Brazil already builds good planes. So who needs Boeing?
The kind of access this guy has sheesh
I wonder why….
@@erikstenviken2652 connections from the "previous" job?
The kind you have when you are a Putin asslicker simples!
Making propaganda for russian government will give you that kind of access
@@athr_blu Everything except BBC and CNN is Russian propaganda?
If flights weren't so expensive, I would love to explore Russia
Yiu can fly to China and direct to Moscow.
Train tickets are rather cheap in Russia and Eastern Europe. It is slower than a plane but does let you see much more of the countryside. Since most large Russia cities are clustered in West of Russia, it is not a terrible option. Russians I know have always recommended just to go see Moscow, Saint Petr, and Sochi. I have heard very good things about Bikal as well. But, that is a very long distance from Moscow.
Same here!
@@truthful3777 l am in China, but still flights are expensive considering the short distance l need to take
Raliways are the best way to explore Russia
Soviets used to make good civil planes like the Ilyushin
Sanctions for Russia:
Bad now, good later
Lost productivity now, gained industry later
Sanctions from the US:
Bad now, bad later
Lost profits now, more competition later
most if not all airplanes are made of composite materials. The wingspan is just 10 cm wider than a airbus 320 neo. not sure if all the claims they are making are true in relevance of fuel efficiency.
They aren't *made of composite materials* but made *using* composite materials. Most or at least a half of the of the plane's airframe is made of metals, mostly aluminium. The only planes that are 80% made of composites are a few models of light and ultralight planes.
@@shadowflash705 you are right it's a aluminum alloy. my mistake. I translated it wrong. I thought it would cover both materials.
In long-term sanctions are blessing for Russia,they saved Russia independende and sovereignty.
Yeah, because not being able to trade with most of the world has always been a blessing to a nation. Just look at how well North Korea is doing!
Isolation is never good. There is not a single example when isolation made countries stronger.
@@drsnova7313 How's North Korea similar to Russia? Why should we look at them?
@@OhhCats Russia is not isolated, China,India and 75% states of world do not give ff to the western minority led by USA which claim the right to speak for all world states; Russia according to official international date is forth strong economy passing Japan.
@@georgeskwira7851
Russia is isolated. Neither India nor China invest in Russia. Since 2022 none of the countries of the “Global South” invested anything in Russia (no government lending, no construction of new factories, no new joint projects). Both China and India obey sanctions imposed by the Free World. Neither China or India recognise occupied territories of Ukraine as Russian. Foreign businesses avoid Russian clients or demand huge discounts. Russia and its trade partners are forced to do all business transactions secretly to avoid secondary sanctions.
I live in one of the western countries, but I love Russia, they don't let US & NATO to be the Tyrant of the world
Than you are a KGB/FSB man
Yeah, sure you do but on a more serious note, who do I have to contact in order to get hired to post this kind of stupid shit on the internet? Could use some extra cash and I like to shitpost on the internet anyways.
@@JürgenWernicke-i8i it's better to be a KGB agent than to be a slave of a Tyrant as known as NATO, US, the Western allies who is trying to become the only power of the whole world
@@littleponygirl666 Is it that hard to find a good paying job in the west nowdays?
Будем летать!И ничто не помешает!Все говорили что дальше бумаги не получится,только чем сложнее России тем она крепче!У России только два союзника-это армия и флот!
Мешает коррумпированная власть в Кремле. Что касается идиотскую фразу про союзников: Они в таком же печальном состоянии как вся страна.
This is an important project. The world needs diverse solutions and products. Russia should have started this project sooner. Boeing is having design issues and airbus is having financial issues. With the new prices from sanctions may give the Russian domestic market a boost. It is crazy that sanctions are now helping Russian and Chinese manufacturers catch up now. Good luck. 🍀
good if this can give a competition to Airbus Boeing monopoly.
Aibus and Boeing are not under sanctions. Nobody outside of Russia would buy these planes- nobody wants to get EU and US sanctions
Beautiful story
Video starts @ 15:00
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Russian-made equipments have problems with spare parts, as per experience with the philippine armed forces' trucks. Hopefully, they will strengthen their planning and marketing strategy on the availability of spare parts and service centers in countries that welcome russian equipments so purchasers will not worry. To be honest, Russian equipment is really built for long service.
The availability of spare parts is primarily logistics, and secondly, engineering. Who prevents you personally from setting up a company for the creation of warehouses with truck spare parts in the Philippines and finding a partner for the maintenance of equipment? Why did you decide that the support of purchased equipment is the prerogative of the manufacturer's factory? Contact the Russian trade mission in your country with a request for partnership with Russian manufacturers, I am sure they will help you, and at the same time you will become a millionaire.😁
prayers to the people of Russia, from America
Kid: “Mom I want an Airbus A320”
Mom: “But we have an Airbus A320 at home”
*Airbus A320 at home:*
It could be worse… The kid might sadly end with a Boeing.😅
Russia has no problem getting critical replacement parts for Airbus,Embraer,Boeing,etc. Fleets; UAE,China are the sources.
Parts are not the problem, the real problem is the price they have to pay. There is no friends on this, everybody wants to profit from this situation.
@@gonzalomunoz1819 Price is also not a problem nowdays
Forget Boeing & Airbus, the systems & component suppliers are what will choke off Russia’s commercial aircraft.
Let's see about that CIA bot
@@erenyeagerist7681 you must not know how planes work
You sound vaccinated
@@jesseking9254 lol. The latest in insults. I got the initial vaccine then sat it out. How about that. I work in aerospace for the company that designs, builds, and maintains a pretty good percentage of the parts on most western aircraft along with some stuff on Chinese & Russian ones.
I don’t care how spiffy Russian aerospace is, to clone much of that western hardware takes our competitors years to get right. They simply cannot get Russian produced components in production before the western hardware wears out or breaks down.
@chrissmith7669 🤣 I remember you. Ukraine and West are still winning the war in your wet dreams?
In Europe the flying ticket increased insanely too. Prices are easly triple if not more.