Slogans ki value nahi? Then you shouldn't have a problem with: 1: Ram Ram Chillaingay, mullay katay jaingay 2: Medina Ki Riyasat Write other problematic slogans in the comments.
Harris bhai ye science juarney ke sath bhim ta ban gaya hai namo gajputaye 😁 maine iske channel par comment Kiya tha buddha ko lekar isne mujhe block kar Diya ye kattar buddhist hai ambedkar ki jhant 🤣
1:Hindu raastra jindabad 2:India banega hindu raastra 3:Gustakh e nabi ki ek saza sar tan se........... Ye bhi ek slogan hi hai phir ghalib kamal usse kyu nafarat krta hai
Gustakhe nabi ki ek saza... Antisemitic slogans Kick brahmins out of the country( brahmins bideshi, brahmins ko euresia bhejo) If u see a brahmin and a snake. Kill the brahmin first( EV ramaswamy periyar - revered by brahmin hating political groups) Tilak, tarazu, aur talwar...inko maaro joote chaar( caste hatred slogan popularized by BSP) Don't exactly remember but mullo ko Pakistan bhagao type slogans by the right wing Calling hindus lindus Tel laga ke dabur ka, naam mita do babur ka
I am an ex muslim from Pakistan and I would never support Israel or Hamas, but if Israel have a right to defend itself the why doesn't Palestine have the right to live peacefully
Palestine was sending rockets into Israel, not sure if it was wanting to live peacefully. But I agree Palestinians were short changed by the UN, British and the Israelis, to get buy up land/transfer it. In the 50s Israelis have had raided Palestine villages to drive them away.
How did their fight start ? I remember watching them together for a couple of years. But since a few months, didn't see them together and now this fight.
O yaar 🙏🙏🙏 please aapas mein mat laro 🙏 tuhade aage hath 🙌 jore 🙏 , You both are very intelligent, and we need both of you. Please come to a platform. Don’t fight 🙏
Harish bhai, always admired your work, but in this video you blamed too much to Galib bhai... it's not good looking to see attacking like this as he has never taken your name in his video... this only gives bad impression to viewers who has left their religion after watching you both guys... at least there should be some respect regardless of the difference in small opinions although you both have very similar thinking about Palestine issue...
you and Ghalib used to do streaming together, many of us grew watching you two on same screen. It is sad to see you two are now down to personally attacking each other's integrity. Extremely Extremely disheartening.
Mr Harris, as a youtuber it may be your beginning. We don't know what are your other pursuits. I pray for you to play a very big role in establishing righteousness at international level. The kind of clarity about right and wrong you have, I don't have any doubt about that. God bless you. All the best from India.
@@sapien307 Yaar Ghalib Kamal bhale hi rational atheist insaan hain lekin gusse me control nhi hai...Kuchh bhi bol dete hain... Har jagah itna gussa thik nhi hota thodi flexible hona chahiye... Harris ke bhi apne problems hain Kahin kahin jyada liberal ho jate hain...Ek dusre se alag hue hain thik hai lekin itna anti nhi hona chahiye tha...🙂
Radical Hindus chanting: Ram Ram chilaenge Mullay Kate jaenge Muslim guy complained to Ghalib Kamal the Police inspector. GK's reply to man: "Naare se kya hota hai? Aap bohot zyada biased hai ya bohot naive hai".
the Native Americans are also living in deplorable conditions in the US, but the huge difference is the US is not humiliating atrocities against Native Americans today, like its being done to the Palestinians
It's normal for two people to not agree on everything, despite agreeing on most things. The problem arises when one side labels/paints you in a certain manner based on that one disagreement. The problem with Far Left is the same. Just like Far Right, even if you're on the same side as them on a certain issue, but if they think you're not standing on *exactly the same extreme position as theirs* on the ideological spectrum, your entire personality begins to be viewed suspiciously in their head, and as if you have a hidden bigoted agenda.
Come on sir! I found GK to be totally not rational and confused totally about "what is a dogma". Definition of dogma is "a principle or set of principles laid down by an authority as incontrovertibly true" and he declares that whatever he says is absolute truth so GK himself is Dogmatic and people who support him are exactly like muslims with blind beliefs.
I can only wish you guys revisit this coarse of action against each other. They were good times, when we used to watch your collaborations. I can only hope things work out between you two. Anyways, although, innocent civilian lives are getting lost in Gaza, which is heartbreaking and tragic, but, Israel 100% not only has a right but duty and obligation to defend itself and it’s people by every right and according to all international laws. They will liberate Gaza from Hammas, I hope life gets better for Palestinians once Hammas is defeated.
IMO as activists, you both need to put your objectives before your personal issues. This fight is very damaging to the movement. People can have different opinions but try to be respectful regardless of that. I really used to enjoy the streams you all did together in the past really felt like a family to me
Your difference from ghalib bhai is actually indian economy. He never even tried a single sentence about haris sultan but this man even goes for videos on ghalib bhai. I have listened lot of videos and streams together. That time they both were mindboggling giving aurguments against vices but soething happened between them that now they are at the opposite ends.
The most amusing word in this video is "Hindu atheist" first of all Hindu is ethnic identity and Sanatan gives equal space to a person who doesn't believe in a creator....🙏
kya bakwass hai...charwak ka pata hai...uski koi book hai ajj kal??? charwak ka kuch nhi nahi available kyonki woh sab sanatannio ne destroy kar diya hai...buddhism agar india se bahar na jaata toh...india main puri tarah khatam ho chukka tha...same with kabir panthi and other small sects.
@@0bajwa0 what about Jain and Shikhisum, there r many faiths which came in existence and lost there weight because of lack of scholars in it....and for ur kind information Buddhism is a branch of Sanatan and core beliefs are same or even more beautiful but You seems to me a hater who is from the new idea of Buddhism where You are following cult like ideology so first correct yourself before coming to comment. ....🙏
@@rishabhshukla9454 tumhe sikhism chorna pda vrna mughalo ke vanshaj bnjaate rahi baat jainism ki vo bhi sanatanio ka banaya hai you are just hyporcrites nothing else
I have been a silent watcher of sultan's videos . For sure his mindful superiority and intellect is reflected in his thoughts . I have seen a constant improvement in Mr Haris Sultan as a generic human being. His understanding is, and has been expanding, and he embraces it gracefully. Bar far he is one of the few most realistic intellectual ex Muslim's born in the indian subcontinent.
Now I really understood nothing is constant in the Universe 😊. Lets agree to disagree. I really respect both of you and your work.. There is nothing wrong in having difference of opinion, but I want you guys together please...🙏
He left speaking on muzhub and now seeing more clear picture. I think he is distancing himself from left realising it is more stupid than any center-right idea
Aaj mujhe bahut jyada dukh hua hai. Mujhe is baat ka dar to tha but ye itna buri tarah se hoga ye nahi socha tha. Haris bhai aur ghalib bhai, aap dono me duriya aa gai hai ye sunkar aur dekh kar bahut jyada taklif hui. Aap dono bahut achha kam kar rahe hai. Ho sake to apni galatfahmiya dur kar ke ek baar fir sath ho jaiye. Please
Bro Harris, Now You Are Getting The Complicated Difficult Issues. I Used To Not Fully Side With You Beforehand But Now You Have Clarity. I Am Not A Crazy Devoted Religious Hindu But I Am Logical and You Have Understood It That Even Though We Have Not Been Right Wing Until Now But The Only Way To Stop Jihad is By Supporting Rightist Leaders. 🙏
I myself am not a ritualistic person but stop explaining yourself like you are inferior. Let atheist first explain wether they will kill like crazy communist or they are for sexual intercourse with their sister, mother,child etc. Atheist have to also prove to you as they are not void of destruction and garbage behaviour. And if you were actually crazy follower of Indian philosophy your understanding of world is family will have more depth than these atheists. Dont seek approval from these atheists, Dont hate them and dont keep them on your head. Hope you understand.
I have been followiing and supporting you and Ghalib Kamal for almost 4 yrs. now. I agree with your position on this Israel and Hamas issue. Harris. I am sure Ghalib has very high IQ, he is well read and intelligent person, however on this issue he gets emotional and so when you get emotional logic is the first casualty. Armin Nawabi is the most unbiased atheist that I have seen on sociala media and that includes you, Ghalib and Apostate prophet.When he was being viciously attacked by hindu rightwingers on kaali issue, I never saw any bitterness in his streams. In fact he keeps emotions out of his arguments and he is against tribalism. Anyway Harris please don't make it personal with Ghalib. I think you both are good human beings.
I think Pakistan and Israel are not the same. Argument for creation of Israel was supported by persecution of Jews for hundreds of years. Argument for Pakistan was Islamic entitlement. Rest I agree with the fact that if Islam disappears from Pakistan and Bangladesh, we will become a Union because ethnically we are all Indians. Also Harris, you should have a debate with Armin on proportional criticism. I strongly disagree with his view that all religions should be equally criticized. The criticism should be proportional to the social destruction that the religion is causing currently.
Yes, also another difference is that in the establishment of Pakistan, the majority of native people stayed where they were unlike Israel where Jewish militas drove out tens of thousands of arab during "Nakhba" ethnic cleansing.
@@ConvergingHorizons Jinnah, the PM of Pakistan himself was not born in current day Pakistan and moved there. According to Pakistani census 7 million muslims moved to current day Pakistan. Thousands of non-Muslims were murdered by Muslims in their 'Direct action Day' for Pakistan formation. Either you are ignorant, or you lack empathy.
Who told you "ethnically we are all Indians"? That's just Indians' inferiority complex to keep relating themselves to Pakistan. Let's digest quickly, half of Pakistan isn't even remotely Indian, so you leave them(Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan). Then the "Indic" people are Punjabis and Sindhis - whom themselves are different to each other, similarly how every other Indian State has its own different cultures and ethnic backgrounds. And difference between Pakistani provinces and Indian States is way more than that. That's like Germany claiming all of Europe will become EU because ethnically they're all Europeans lol.
Who told you "ethnically we are all Indians"? That's just Indians' inferiority complex to keep relating themselves to Pakistan. Let's digest quickly, half of Pakistan isn't even remotely Indian, so you leave them(Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan). Then the "Indic" people are Punjabis and Sindhis - whom themselves are different to each other, similarly how every other Indian State has its own different cultures and ethnic backgrounds. That's like Germany claiming all of Europe will become EU because ethnically they're all Europeans lol.
Harris has become more practical and consistent in his opinion, cause I remembered years earlier he used to be equally diluded as Gaalib Kamal. Also he has accurately identified the emotional hole that is left on GK psychology that is brought on by years of discrimination/oppression/mistreatment received in his forming years. GK wants to fit everything into his yardstick which is custom made for measuring oppressor vs oppressed without any nuances!
@@usm2247 Yes true because GK don't realizing why war started even he don't know what is Genocide mean and using it again and again. Well Explaination from Haris.
Hi Harris, you are absolutely right. Prior to the Israel Hamas war, I was of the assumption that GK has rationale thought.. but after watching his few videos on Israel Hamas issue.. he exposed his knowledge and intuition very clearly.. he is softly supporting Hamas and openly supporting Palestinian civilians who have had never criticised terrorist_ actions of HAMAS instead elected HAMAS to power in GAZA. .GK is absolutely indifferent and OK with the persecution of Jews.. be it killing of Jewish children or murdering Jewish women after gangraping that too with sloganeering of Allah hu Akbar.. GK along with others supporting HAMAS and Islamic cause found nothing absurd in this. I think eight wars were started and imposed on Israel by peace loving Islamic world..and ended in victory by Israel. It is a perfect saying that If Islamic peace loving nations start loving their population and drop the arms, true peace will prevail in the region. At the same time, if Israel drops the Arms, there will be no Israel and no Jews. Scriptures of Islam preaches exclusivity and superiority above all other religious sects.. so there is no sense of coexistence in Islam.. but then.. Islam hates reforms.. so clashes among sects and communities will keep going till this school of thought is not annihilated comprehensively. 🙏🙏
Bit harsh. Not your character. I m your big admirer. Live and let live. Both of you are working for the same cause. The approach is different, but the goal is enlightenment. Keep it up.
the sloganeering point by GK is so riddiculous. If "from river to sea, palestine will be free" is not punishable then, "Heil Hitler" should also not be punichable. But since I oppose both the slogans, I believe it should be punishable. What the F*** bro????🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@Pan21335 tera allah hai hi nhi.. Jis allah ko yeh nhi pta ki zameen chapti nhi gol hai aur suraj ke bagal me chakkar lgati hai, to kya hidayat dega tera allah😂😂... Ek sui tk tum momin se bnti nhi😂😂 kafiro ki banayi cheeze use krte ho.. Bhaag yaha se😂😂
Galib on his channel gave the argument that Israel should make a safe zone in South Israel for Palestine refugees and then go after Hamas. How ridiculous is the argument.. pakistan attacks then India retaliates and Galib tells India to provide safe zones for Pakistani civilians. It's beyond hilarious..I skipped his channel..he has lost his mind.
@@pradjosh1well he is a great humanitarian I think. After all it’s Isreal occupying their lands. Although I don’t like Hamas but I do feel bad about innocent civilians caught in this
Germany started 2WW as hamas started,and world made a block and attacked Germany,in this case you can't say ,why worls killed so many Germans,world defended their freedom and protect their counries,and Israel has every right to defend itself ,
Brother aap ki iss video ne toh dil hi jeet liya. Aap ki aur respect badh gai. Koi v ho Jo fake propaganda karga aap os ke propaganda,ka postmortem kar denge. Respect man respect
GK is so damn self obsessed, mutes literally EVERYONE. Shouts at almost every other caller. I started watching him because of his group chats and now he's just a egomaniac diva
It's a shame because he has more than enough intellect to dismantle any stupid religious arguments but the fact that he instead resorts to such cheap tactics such as muting (which, albeit sometimes can be necessary) in order to gain trivial "wins" over technicalities as opposed to the soundness of the argument is just disappointing to anyone who watched him.
Ghalib babu ki ek dikkat hai : he believes there's no God, but his word is like a word of God, he won't even listen to your point or even acknowledge it.
By your logic, if Hamas somehow managed to destroy Israel and made a Palestinian state on Israeli land then will you also support Hamas right to defend itself?
Harry thank you for making this video. This was overdue on you. That barking-woof-woof-GK is so obsessed with you that he silently criticises your arguments without taking your name. Woof-woof is such a back biting negative-nelly. I was thinking about it all yesterday, Harry, you need to challenge him on a debate on his position vs yours. Debate is the most rational way to put competing ideas on a forum but I know that woof-woof will run away from it whilst you will be always welcoming it with open doors. Please send an open challenge to him for a debate, calling out his hypocrisy. DEBATE!! DEBATE!! DEBATE!!
I stand with Israel. At the same time, I feel sad for Innocent civilians in Gaza. So I'm still undecided on the whole conflct. Either way, I don't think it matters, who supports who, Israel will do what it wants because they have the Upper hand.
GK mujhe pahle se intellectually dishonest banda lagta tha, aur yeh baat us din prove ho gayi jab usne "The kashmir files" movie ko propaganda movie kaha tha.
I have unsubcribed his channel and stopped going live on his stream bcz he allowed some Buddhists to sit in his stream , started saying "Jai Bhim" "Jai Bhim" .. i highly respect Ambedkar, but he went against his own ideology. Come in India and see how radical these Ambedkarites have become here. There is no difference between radical hindus, radical islam or even these radical Buddhists. We see it everyday, but he just went and sat into their laps. Also, I started finding his arguments as impatient, intellectually shallow and filled with anger.
The Palestinians were offered a two state solution in 1947 and several time afterwards as well. They have shown no interest and lost territory after initiating wars and insurgencies. Even if they did have a claim before, they have no claim now
Thank You Harris Bhai-Jaan 💝 I was waiting for this MUCH AWAITED roasting of Arrogant Ghalib Kamal, and this was exceptional by you 💯 I left my religion and turned out to be Proud Agnostic atheist, for which I Thank both of you!! 🙏 BUT…..Over the pace of time, I believe with the rise in followers, GK has become more arrogant and ABUSE to most of his Callers. Most disgusting is, HE DO NOT LET OTHER TO SPEAK and insult almost everyone by saying CHANDA. He used to mock you indirectly in almost every LIVE Stream and I use to wonder why it don’t offend you. FINALLY, our wait is over now and You have roasted that arrogant GK just as like PERFECT BBQ.✍
The terms Genocide and Fascists are very demeaning. People don't have any idea what they truly mean. Genocide: Acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group. These five acts were: killing members of the group, causing them serious bodily or mental harm, imposing living conditions intended to destroy the group, preventing births, and forcibly transferring children out of the group. Fascist: A political philosophy, movement, or regime (such as that of the Fascisti) that exalts nation and often race above the individual and that stands for a centralized autocratic government headed by a dictatorial leader, severe economic and social regimentation, and forcible suppression of opposition. Nothing of this sort has really happened here. Ratherit is true for ISIS, Myanmar Buddhists who committed ethnic cleansing of the Syrian Kurds, Yezidis and the Rohingyas respectively. The main problem is 95% of human population is basically illiterate with no sense of rational understanding. They are driven by others opinions. Hense, such problems in the world are common.
Harris bhai today my respect increased for you many many folds. Taking on someone who belongs to same biradari😂 by that I mean an atheist and demolishing his arguments. Even I stopped listening to Ghalib much much before this Israel-Hamas war started primarily to his hatred towards Israel. His arguments are really really shallow and his hatred for Zionism is exactly inline with Pro-Hamas protestors.
Ghalib Kamal and Asim Saeed behave like two anpadh khatoons who have nothing to do but chugli in their free time. I am pretty sure that we 'll see their chuglikhori in full swing in their 'panel discussion' tonight. 😂
I agree with your historical reality argument And yes everybody has right to exist I guess the only solution for humanity is to move away from what you called tribalism 🤷 That seems to be the basic problem of human race 🤔
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 86 | คู่เอก "คมเพชร vs ชาติพยัคฆ์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/m3q_dRYDuU8/mqdefault.jpg)
Slogans ki value nahi?
Then you shouldn't have a problem with:
1: Ram Ram Chillaingay, mullay katay jaingay
2: Medina Ki Riyasat
Write other problematic slogans in the comments.
Harris bhai ye science juarney ke sath bhim ta ban gaya hai namo gajputaye 😁 maine iske channel par comment Kiya tha buddha ko lekar isne mujhe block kar Diya ye kattar buddhist hai ambedkar ki jhant 🤣
What about 'my body my choice and Zan Zindagi azadi'..these slogan are the core, central idea of the whole movement.. slogans are important..
1:Hindu raastra jindabad
2:India banega hindu raastra
3:Gustakh e nabi ki ek saza sar tan se...........
Ye bhi ek slogan hi hai phir ghalib kamal usse kyu nafarat krta hai
@@ExBuddhistExBuddhist yes
Shayad aap sahi bol rhe ho
Gustakhe nabi ki ek saza...
Antisemitic slogans
Kick brahmins out of the country( brahmins bideshi, brahmins ko euresia bhejo)
If u see a brahmin and a snake. Kill the brahmin first( EV ramaswamy periyar - revered by brahmin hating political groups)
Tilak, tarazu, aur talwar...inko maaro joote chaar( caste hatred slogan popularized by BSP)
Don't exactly remember but mullo ko Pakistan bhagao type slogans by the right wing
Calling hindus lindus
Tel laga ke dabur ka, naam mita do babur ka
I am an ex muslim from Pakistan and I would never support Israel or Hamas, but if Israel have a right to defend itself the why doesn't Palestine have the right to live peacefully
Bro please answer
Palestine was sending rockets into Israel, not sure if it was wanting to live peacefully. But I agree Palestinians were short changed by the UN, British and the Israelis, to get buy up land/transfer it. In the 50s Israelis have had raided Palestine villages to drive them away.
Definitely. But why Palestine attacked Israel and killed more than twelve hundred Jews ?
@AMZ.. They have but unfortunately they dont want it.. First thing they should stop supporting Hamas
Harris definitely has some vested interests.
Dear Harris, you are not just an atheist but an extremely intelligent human being. The explanation you give shows this. Great work keep it up.
what happened between harris and ghalib ??
@@swatteam2002I would like to know too
I am a Pakistani, a monotheist, and with regards to the current war, I stand with Israel.
Really bushra..
Yes.@@pabasheer9831
bani israel
Tunni 😂
May Allah give you hidayah, and the reason why our country is backward , my answer is due to you people....❤
Ghalim kamal is trying to be mohammad of atheists 😂
True bro
How did their fight start ? I remember watching them together for a couple of years. But since a few months, didn't see them together and now this fight.
@@rahuldhere4093no clue, but ghalib is a little intolerant of others viewpoints. I think it started with wasim akram calling someone chamar
it's better to have a civilized debate or conversation than this
yes he is mohammad of athiest
O yaar 🙏🙏🙏 please aapas mein mat laro 🙏 tuhade aage hath 🙌 jore 🙏 , You both are very intelligent, and we need both of you. Please come to a platform. Don’t fight 🙏
Harish bhai, always admired your work, but in this video you blamed too much to Galib bhai... it's not good looking to see attacking like this as he has never taken your name in his video... this only gives bad impression to viewers who has left their religion after watching you both guys... at least there should be some respect regardless of the difference in small opinions although you both have very similar thinking about Palestine issue...
you and Ghalib used to do streaming together, many of us grew watching you two on same screen.
It is sad to see you two are now down to personally attacking each other's integrity.
Extremely Extremely disheartening.
Ghalib kamal supports radical dalits
I am happy seeing it , i knew it will happen and it's here now 😂
@@HelloItsme-qv3mgkya hua hai dono ke becha
@@Aspirant278 jo hota hai wahi hua hai
@@HelloItsme-qv3mg matlab?
Mr Harris, as a youtuber it may be your beginning. We don't know what are your other pursuits. I pray for you to play a very big role in establishing righteousness at international level. The kind of clarity about right and wrong you have, I don't have any doubt about that. God bless you. All the best from India.
I feel sad when u both fight with each other...🙂 This harms movement of u both
Exactly 😢, we should unite against dogma , our mission is to embrace humanity and rationality
@@sapien307 Yaar Ghalib Kamal bhale hi rational atheist insaan hain lekin gusse me control nhi hai...Kuchh bhi bol dete hain... Har jagah itna gussa thik nhi hota thodi flexible hona chahiye... Harris ke bhi apne problems hain Kahin kahin jyada liberal ho jate hain...Ek dusre se alag hue hain thik hai lekin itna anti nhi hona chahiye tha...🙂
@@indianatheist2023 yehi problems dono ko resolve Karni chahiye, aik dosre seh bat Karke
@@sapien307unite against dogma and oppress all believers.. ultimately arrive in path of 7th century cult
Yakin hi nahi ho raha ke Ye dono ladrahe he😢
Very sad to see Ghalib and haris fighting 😢. I learnt so many things from both of you
Both side problem is that they don't want 2 state solution.
Today Israel has right to exist but you cannot ignore Palestinian right to exist.
I have been following Harris for quite a while and he is one logical person I have ever seen.
Slogans ki value nahi hai 😂😂😂 I had the same expression as Harris . 😂😂
Radical Hindus chanting: Ram Ram chilaenge Mullay Kate jaenge
Muslim guy complained to Ghalib Kamal the Police inspector.
GK's reply to man: "Naare se kya hota hai? Aap bohot zyada biased hai ya bohot naive hai".
the Native Americans are also living in deplorable conditions in the US, but the huge difference is the US is not humiliating atrocities against Native Americans today, like its being done to the Palestinians
It's normal for two people to not agree on everything, despite agreeing on most things.
The problem arises when one side labels/paints you in a certain manner based on that one disagreement. The problem with Far Left is the same. Just like Far Right, even if you're on the same side as them on a certain issue, but if they think you're not standing on *exactly the same extreme position as theirs* on the ideological spectrum, your entire personality begins to be viewed suspiciously in their head, and as if you have a hidden bigoted agenda.
Come on sir! I found GK to be totally not rational and confused totally about "what is a dogma". Definition of dogma is "a principle or set of principles laid down by an authority as incontrovertibly true" and he declares that whatever he says is absolute truth so GK himself is Dogmatic and people who support him are exactly like muslims with blind beliefs.
Ghalib kamal supports radical dalits,
@@SandipBajwa bajwa paaji Zindabad
Drcooper long time no see, best comment and exactly my thoughts.
@@SandipBajwa all these atheists are dogmatic. None of them are actually rational.
I can only wish you guys revisit this coarse of action against each other. They were good times, when we used to watch your collaborations. I can only hope things work out between you two. Anyways, although, innocent civilian lives are getting lost in Gaza, which is heartbreaking and tragic, but, Israel 100% not only has a right but duty and obligation to defend itself and it’s people by every right and according to all international laws. They will liberate Gaza from Hammas, I hope life gets better for Palestinians once Hammas is defeated.
IMO as activists, you both need to put your objectives before your personal issues. This fight is very damaging to the movement. People can have different opinions but try to be respectful regardless of that. I really used to enjoy the streams you all did together in the past really felt like a family to me
May Allah guide you on right path...❤
@@Pan21335Abe Allah ne tere ko right path PE dala?
@@nomadbanda9562 Alhamdulillah...♥️
Even i am a hindu-RW but can't say GK is dishonest.He is hardcore leftist
Your difference from ghalib bhai is actually indian economy. He never even tried a single sentence about haris sultan but this man even goes for videos on ghalib bhai. I have listened lot of videos and streams together. That time they both were mindboggling giving aurguments against vices but soething happened between them that now they are at the opposite ends.
Bro sabki apni apni soch hai bro
The most amusing word in this video is "Hindu atheist" first of all Hindu is ethnic identity and Sanatan gives equal space to a person who doesn't believe in a creator....🙏
kya bakwass hai...charwak ka pata hai...uski koi book hai ajj kal??? charwak ka kuch nhi nahi available kyonki woh sab sanatannio ne destroy kar diya hai...buddhism agar india se bahar na jaata toh...india main puri tarah khatam ho chukka tha...same with kabir panthi and other small sects.
@@0bajwa0 what about Jain and Shikhisum, there r many faiths which came in existence and lost there weight because of lack of scholars in it....and for ur kind information Buddhism is a branch of Sanatan and core beliefs are same or even more beautiful but You seems to me a hater who is from the new idea of Buddhism where You are following cult like ideology so first correct yourself before coming to comment. ....🙏
@0bajwa0 how come jainism survived in hindu India??
@@0bajwa0 nalanda kisne jalaya serch ker le Google per
@@rishabhshukla9454 tumhe sikhism chorna pda vrna mughalo ke vanshaj bnjaate rahi baat jainism ki vo bhi sanatanio ka banaya hai you are just hyporcrites nothing else
I have been a silent watcher of sultan's videos .
For sure his mindful superiority and intellect is reflected in his thoughts .
I have seen a constant improvement in Mr Haris Sultan as a generic human being.
His understanding is, and has been expanding, and he embraces it gracefully.
Bar far he is one of the few most realistic intellectual ex Muslim's born in the indian subcontinent.
This is low . Icj verdict on israel
GK doesn’t need your attention. I know you because of him. this war exposed lot of people like u. Feel sorry for you.
Please don't fight, we Athiests need unity to fight religious dogma 🙏, we heed both of you
Ye kya chutiyapa hai tumhare 😂😅
Ab galat ko galat bhi nahi bole 😅
@@Doremon0aa gaya tunni kuta😂
Galaib Kamal darpok jhuta hai hindu ko gali deta hai or super chat bhi hindu ki leta hai dogla galib ghatiya Kamal
@@sys9208 tere Muhammad ki ammi ko chodu pakad ke hjide
Hii Zara jay athiestism ❤❤❤
Now I really understood nothing is constant in the Universe 😊. Lets agree to disagree. I really respect both of you and your work.. There is nothing wrong in having difference of opinion, but I want you guys together please...🙏
Harish sultan is intelligent
Both are intelligent
Harish ? Hindu bna diye
@@theasharazizkab bana ye ??😅😅
Hindu hate nah dikhaya karo
Gadhhe ka
nasal
Kyu ? Wo tunni ko expose nhi krta
@@sys9208karta hai
I agreed with your logic Haris. I am an X Muslim, from Pakistan living in Canada.
I Respect Harris on their Unbiased Neutral postion on all issues
I always strongly agree with you and stand with Israel ❤🇮🇱⚛️
Came to your channel after many months and found a refreshing change in you. Good to see you being even handed in your analysis. Keep it up....
He left speaking on muzhub and now seeing more clear picture. I think he is distancing himself from left realising it is more stupid than any center-right idea
@@NolanGreysonyup.. it is a great change..
Aaj mujhe bahut jyada dukh hua hai. Mujhe is baat ka dar to tha but ye itna buri tarah se hoga ye nahi socha tha. Haris bhai aur ghalib bhai, aap dono me duriya aa gai hai ye sunkar aur dekh kar bahut jyada taklif hui. Aap dono bahut achha kam kar rahe hai. Ho sake to apni galatfahmiya dur kar ke ek baar fir sath ho jaiye. Please
I believe You both are best friend.and will never separate
Ghalib kamal and Harris sultan both guys are brillant
But Galib is hypocrite and has hates of different varieties in is deep heart.
their used be a time i remember when both of you used to qoum se khitab together, i always wondered why both of you never got back together.
Bro Harris, Now You Are Getting The Complicated Difficult Issues. I Used To Not Fully Side With You Beforehand But Now You Have Clarity. I Am Not A Crazy Devoted Religious Hindu But I Am Logical and You Have Understood It That Even Though We Have Not Been Right Wing Until Now But The Only Way To Stop Jihad is By Supporting Rightist Leaders. 🙏
I myself am not a ritualistic person but stop explaining yourself like you are inferior.
Let atheist first explain wether they will kill like crazy communist or they are for sexual intercourse with their sister, mother,child etc. Atheist have to also prove to you as they are not void of destruction and garbage behaviour.
And if you were actually crazy follower of Indian philosophy your understanding of world is family will have more depth than these atheists.
Dont seek approval from these atheists,
Dont hate them and dont keep them on your head.
Hope you understand.
I have been followiing and supporting you and Ghalib Kamal for almost 4 yrs. now. I agree with your position on this Israel and Hamas issue. Harris. I am sure Ghalib has very high IQ, he is well read and intelligent person, however on this issue he gets emotional and so when you get emotional logic is the first casualty. Armin Nawabi is the most unbiased atheist that I have seen on sociala media and that includes you, Ghalib and Apostate prophet.When he was being viciously attacked by hindu rightwingers on kaali issue, I never saw any bitterness in his streams. In fact he keeps emotions out of his arguments and he is against tribalism. Anyway Harris please don't make it personal with Ghalib. I think you both are good human beings.
galib is a self styled pseudo intelectual I stopped listening to him app 1.5 to 2 years back.Good job Harris
wx muslims should remain united , please dont fight
I think Pakistan and Israel are not the same. Argument for creation of Israel was supported by persecution of Jews for hundreds of years. Argument for Pakistan was Islamic entitlement. Rest I agree with the fact that if Islam disappears from Pakistan and Bangladesh, we will become a Union because ethnically we are all Indians.
Also Harris, you should have a debate with Armin on proportional criticism. I strongly disagree with his view that all religions should be equally criticized. The criticism should be proportional to the social destruction that the religion is causing currently.
Yes, also another difference is that in the establishment of Pakistan, the majority of native people stayed where they were unlike Israel where Jewish militas drove out tens of thousands of arab during "Nakhba" ethnic cleansing.
@@ConvergingHorizons Jinnah, the PM of Pakistan himself was not born in current day Pakistan and moved there. According to Pakistani census 7 million muslims moved to current day Pakistan. Thousands of non-Muslims were murdered by Muslims in their 'Direct action Day' for Pakistan formation.
Either you are ignorant, or you lack empathy.
@@Abhijit-mf8jh sahi kaha bhai , Direction Action day ki dhamki deke ye sab huwa THA
Who told you "ethnically we are all Indians"? That's just Indians' inferiority complex to keep relating themselves to Pakistan.
Let's digest quickly, half of Pakistan isn't even remotely Indian, so you leave them(Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan).
Then the "Indic" people are Punjabis and Sindhis - whom themselves are different to each other, similarly how every other Indian State has its own different cultures and ethnic backgrounds. And difference between Pakistani provinces and Indian States is way more than that.
That's like Germany claiming all of Europe will become EU because ethnically they're all Europeans lol.
Who told you "ethnically we are all Indians"? That's just Indians' inferiority complex to keep relating themselves to Pakistan.
Let's digest quickly, half of Pakistan isn't even remotely Indian, so you leave them(Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan).
Then the "Indic" people are Punjabis and Sindhis - whom themselves are different to each other, similarly how every other Indian State has its own different cultures and ethnic backgrounds.
That's like Germany claiming all of Europe will become EU because ethnically they're all Europeans lol.
10,000 people dead is a huge number out of of only 2.2 million, one US city of Houston Texas is 2.3 million, it’s like 10,000 people died in 1 city,
You mean out 4.9 million! Palestinians are Arab Muslims though; So out of more than 300 millions or out of 1.2 billion Muslims. You decide1
This is normal, some argument
GK is not far behind in good knowledge.
Can’t believe I was a patron of this guy
Kisi zamane me ye dono Jai aur Veeru ki jodi thi 😂😂 Waise purana dost hi aapka sabse khatarnak dushman hota hai 😂
harish sir islam troubling all humans as well as to all muslims.... You are world peace maker
Galib Kamal is classic example how athei$ts becomes woke (Iπdian version of) commuπist/libraπdus/leftists.
He can be the case study..👍
Harris has become more practical and consistent in his opinion, cause I remembered years earlier he used to be equally diluded as Gaalib Kamal.
Also he has accurately identified the emotional hole that is left on GK psychology that is brought on by years of discrimination/oppression/mistreatment received in his forming years. GK wants to fit everything into his yardstick which is custom made for measuring oppressor vs oppressed without any nuances!
not nuisance, nuance. But baaki achcha likha hai :)
@@85Sudi 👍!
It is weird to see an atheist claiming to be a Zionist. Why the hell would you support a Religious State while claiming to be an atheist.
You are so honest on Israel and Palestine issue.
You have grown intellectually, in integrity and in honesty as well.
1.Ralib, galib , chalib,
Kashmir Hindu aurato k saath, Hindu mardo k bina..
2. Jai Ary, Jai Aryvrat.
3. Katve, bhimte, kafir, etc
Haris i already assumed that GK slipping on one direction, and now you have proved that you are such a truly intellectual.
GK used to be very good even sometimes better than Harris but Gk's Narcissism is destroying his channel and he is full of himself nowadays.
@@usm2247 Yes true because GK don't realizing why war started even he don't know what is Genocide mean and using it again and again. Well Explaination from Haris.
when haris and galib started fighting? can anyone tell me the whole story?
Hi Harris, you are absolutely right. Prior to the Israel Hamas war, I was of the assumption that GK has rationale thought.. but after watching his few videos on Israel Hamas issue.. he exposed his knowledge and intuition very clearly.. he is softly supporting Hamas and openly supporting Palestinian civilians who have had never criticised terrorist_ actions of HAMAS instead elected HAMAS to power in GAZA. .GK is absolutely indifferent and OK with the persecution of Jews.. be it killing of Jewish children or murdering Jewish women after gangraping that too with sloganeering of Allah hu Akbar.. GK along with others supporting HAMAS and Islamic cause found nothing absurd in this. I think eight wars were started and imposed on Israel by peace loving Islamic world..and ended in victory by Israel. It is a perfect saying that If Islamic peace loving nations start loving their population and drop the arms, true peace will prevail in the region. At the same time, if Israel drops the Arms, there will be no Israel and no Jews. Scriptures of Islam preaches exclusivity and superiority above all other religious sects.. so there is no sense of coexistence in Islam.. but then.. Islam hates reforms.. so clashes among sects and communities will keep going till this school of thought is not annihilated comprehensively. 🙏🙏
Now this is what i can get behind, Harris's position is logical and on the other side ghalib has been sounding stupider than ever before nowadays,
Bit harsh. Not your character. I m your big admirer. Live and let live. Both of you are working for the same cause. The approach is different, but the goal is enlightenment. Keep it up.
Ghalib and co have been bitching about Haris on their livestreams. Haris didn't start this.
May Allah guide you on right path
@@Pan21335 Allah doesn't exist.
Saal baad is gende ko dubara dekha , vo bhi Harris ke hi channel pe 😂
the sloganeering point by GK is so riddiculous. If "from river to sea, palestine will be free" is not punishable then, "Heil Hitler" should also not be punichable. But since I oppose both the slogans, I believe it should be punishable.
What the F*** bro????🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
They used to be friends , ye dushman kb bne
No use of the 'Radicals' while comes to India. Hindutva is not radical thing. By the way you used to seat with that guy.
Hinduism is a "radicalised" Religion
I support Harris bhai...❤❤❤
I support both of them
May Allah guide you on right path...❤
@@Pan21335 tera allah hai hi nhi.. Jis allah ko yeh nhi pta ki zameen chapti nhi gol hai aur suraj ke bagal me chakkar lgati hai, to kya hidayat dega tera allah😂😂... Ek sui tk tum momin se bnti nhi😂😂 kafiro ki banayi cheeze use krte ho.. Bhaag yaha se😂😂
@@Pan21335may allah give justice to 6 year old aaisha's pussy which was destroyed by muhammad grandpa
@@Pan21335ab Daus ki aurtain dance 💃 karaingi jald hi Kala dabay kay agay 😂. Time agaya hai 😂
Galib on his channel gave the argument that Israel should make a safe zone in South Israel for Palestine refugees and then go after Hamas. How ridiculous is the argument.. pakistan attacks then India retaliates and Galib tells India to provide safe zones for Pakistani civilians. It's beyond hilarious..I skipped his channel..he has lost his mind.
In 2014 2008 2011 why israel first attacked gaza
@@Ahmad-oh6ic 1949 why Palestine attacked Israel?
@@Ahmad-oh6ic never did
@@pradjosh1well he is a great humanitarian I think. After all it’s Isreal occupying their lands. Although I don’t like Hamas but I do feel bad about innocent civilians caught in this
@@pradjosh1 why israel killed palestinians in 1948. Go read aboutnakba incident
Yes, Galib Kamal is confused now a days.
Hinduvtah is so Proud of you Harris
Harris you absolutely very clear person.and you always right and galib kamal always debating one side mute.....😅😅😅😅
Oye tunni😂
@@sys9208ale ale ...ola uber ko bura lga 😂😂😂
@@sys9208 c0nverted muIle ki gamd me khanjar chal gye😂😂
@@sys9208 Tu kaun hai??
Sunni hai??
Munni hai??
Chunni hai ya
Bhunni hai??
Kaun hai tu??
@@brijsaxena7781
Woh toh nahi pata magar Tu toh Tunni hi hai saala 😂😂😂
Haina ?
Ghalib is 100% right, slogans mean nothing if you have zero power, all bark no bites, only thing that matters is action and whats physically happening
Are Harris Bhai Bhai 😂😂 GK sahab ka Para shaat krna 🤣
Germany started 2WW as hamas started,and world made a block and attacked Germany,in this case you can't say ,why worls killed so many Germans,world defended their freedom and protect their counries,and Israel has every right to defend itself ,
Brother aap ki iss video ne toh dil hi jeet liya. Aap ki aur respect badh gai. Koi v ho Jo fake propaganda karga aap os ke propaganda,ka postmortem kar denge. Respect man respect
I must be a zionist too as I support Israel to have the right to a state.
You used to admire him for his knowledge.
You both conducted multiple live session together.
Kya hua ab?
One collecting information by own now so he is seeing the true picture and another is still getting information from same people
GK is so damn self obsessed, mutes literally EVERYONE. Shouts at almost every other caller. I started watching him because of his group chats and now he's just a egomaniac diva
It's a shame because he has more than enough intellect to dismantle any stupid religious arguments but the fact that he instead resorts to such cheap tactics such as muting (which, albeit sometimes can be necessary) in order to gain trivial "wins" over technicalities as opposed to the soundness of the argument is just disappointing to anyone who watched him.
Galib used to be sensible or at lest I thought so but now I have observed he is losing his balance…
Ghalib babu ki ek dikkat hai : he believes there's no God, but his word is like a word of God, he won't even listen to your point or even acknowledge it.
Yeah I agree with Harris 100%
By your logic, if Hamas somehow managed to destroy Israel and made a Palestinian state on Israeli land then will you also support Hamas right to defend itself?
Harry thank you for making this video. This was overdue on you. That barking-woof-woof-GK is so obsessed with you that he silently criticises your arguments without taking your name. Woof-woof is such a back biting negative-nelly. I was thinking about it all yesterday, Harry, you need to challenge him on a debate on his position vs yours. Debate is the most rational way to put competing ideas on a forum but I know that woof-woof will run away from it whilst you will be always welcoming it with open doors. Please send an open challenge to him for a debate, calling out his hypocrisy.
DEBATE!! DEBATE!! DEBATE!!
What happed between Harris and Ghalib??
I stand with Israel. At the same time, I feel sad for Innocent civilians in Gaza. So I'm still undecided on the whole conflct. Either way, I don't think it matters, who supports who, Israel will do what it wants because they have the Upper hand.
GK mujhe pahle se intellectually dishonest banda lagta tha, aur yeh baat us din prove ho gayi jab usne
"The kashmir files" movie ko propaganda movie kaha tha.
Propaganda movie he hai wo
@@r.k3261AA Gaya galib ka chela
WOH PROPAGANDA HI HAI
I have unsubcribed his channel and stopped going live on his stream bcz he allowed some Buddhists to sit in his stream , started saying "Jai Bhim" "Jai Bhim" .. i highly respect Ambedkar, but he went against his own ideology. Come in India and see how radical these Ambedkarites have become here. There is no difference between radical hindus, radical islam or even these radical Buddhists. We see it everyday, but he just went and sat into their laps.
Also, I started finding his arguments as impatient, intellectually shallow and filled with anger.
aREY Arey THis video is going to be awesum 🤣🤣🤣aristu ke saath baithke ludo khedanalya
aristotle ke saath ludo😂
The Palestinians were offered a two state solution in 1947 and several time afterwards as well. They have shown no interest and lost territory after initiating wars and insurgencies. Even if they did have a claim before, they have no claim now
Galib connected with islamik funding group
No he panders to buddhists and gets his views from them
Ye wahi adami hai na jo kehta tha ki ISRO wale scientist bewakoof kyunki wo mandir jate hain...🤔🤔
Aur khud ko unse jyada intelligent samjhata tha..😂😂
Waqt Badal Gaya, Jazbaat Badal Gaya.
😂
This munafiq GK never differentiate between action by the Muslim and reaction on the Muslim
Thank You Harris Bhai-Jaan 💝
I was waiting for this MUCH AWAITED roasting of Arrogant Ghalib Kamal, and this was exceptional by you 💯
I left my religion and turned out to be Proud Agnostic atheist, for which I Thank both of you!! 🙏
BUT…..Over the pace of time, I believe with the rise in followers, GK has become more arrogant and ABUSE to most of his Callers. Most disgusting is, HE DO NOT LET OTHER TO SPEAK and insult almost everyone by saying CHANDA.
He used to mock you indirectly in almost every LIVE Stream and I use to wonder why it don’t offend you.
FINALLY, our wait is over now and You have roasted that arrogant GK just as like PERFECT BBQ.✍
The terms Genocide and Fascists are very demeaning. People don't have any idea what they truly mean.
Genocide: Acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group. These five acts were: killing members of the group, causing them serious bodily or mental harm, imposing living conditions intended to destroy the group, preventing births, and forcibly transferring children out of the group.
Fascist: A political philosophy, movement, or regime (such as that of the Fascisti) that exalts nation and often race above the individual and that stands for a centralized autocratic government headed by a dictatorial leader, severe economic and social regimentation, and forcible suppression of opposition.
Nothing of this sort has really happened here. Ratherit is true for ISIS, Myanmar Buddhists who committed ethnic cleansing of the Syrian Kurds, Yezidis and the Rohingyas respectively. The main problem is 95% of human population is basically illiterate with no sense of rational understanding. They are driven by others opinions. Hense, such problems in the world are common.
Respect Harris on their Unbiased Neutral position on all issues
Nova festival me Israeli Buddha's statue ke samne celebration kar rahe the. These are modern, scientific and loving people.
Harris bhai today my respect increased for you many many folds. Taking on someone who belongs to same biradari😂 by that I mean an atheist and demolishing his arguments. Even I stopped listening to Ghalib much much before this Israel-Hamas war started primarily to his hatred towards Israel. His arguments are really really shallow and his hatred for Zionism is exactly inline with Pro-Hamas protestors.
Mai aap se Puri tarah se sahemat hu kyuki mai Galib ko dekhta hu ki wo bahut saari cheejo ko Jabardasti galat proof karne ki Koshish karte h
He terms hindus as "tunni". From now we term him as" athanee" atheist
Woh chuddhist hai ab.
He is a " Katwa " masquerading as an ex muslim.😂😂😂😂
Na Israel innocent hai aur na hi Palestinians..
Ghalib Kamal and Asim Saeed behave like two anpadh khatoons who have nothing to do but chugli in their free time. I am pretty sure that we 'll see their chuglikhori in full swing in their 'panel discussion' tonight. 😂
You are absolutely right Harris Bhai.. good job 💪👍
GK is influenced by Bheem Meem
Ye banda bhi sanatunni ki goud mein baith gaya hai 😂😂😂ye sssale so called xmuslim view ke liye kisi bhi had tak gir sakte hain 👎👎👎shame on you
There is no point for argument when you already have the conclusions...
I agree with your historical reality argument
And yes everybody has right to exist
I guess the only solution for humanity is to move away from what you called tribalism 🤷
That seems to be the basic problem of human race 🤔