i knew from the beginning something was off about Ezra, at first i thought he was a ghost because of how pale he is lol but it's so sad how these things happen in real life, because people are so traumatized and can't accept the fact that they were left by their loved ones they tend to imagine things they wished happens for real. Poor Penny, she just wanna feel loved. But i must say that Jenna and Noah are both genuine people, they're both true friends. I love how they handled Penny's situation without making her feel worse about it.
Ikr, It's very obvious that ezra is not real because why would a very wealthy boy will drool over an average middle class girl that he met for the first time and rain her lavish gifts on their first date? It doesn't make any sense at all, it really sounds like she is delusional/hallucinating. But still the MC is lucky for having an understanding friend and BF which she really needs
Both Jenna and Noah are honestly really nice people, also glad that Penny managed to realize it was all just imaginary. Also I feel really bad for her that her dad left like that and then she found out her perfect boyfriend was just imaginary, also another thing just gotta say I love Jenna's design.
I feel so bad for Jenna... All she wanted was someone to care for her. But, Noah came through no matter what and I am happy for the constant diversity that takes place now! Nice job, MSA!
I really love penny’s art style, to be honest, I feel that she really does deserve to be happy ever since her dad left, it’s great that she was lucky to have Jenna in her life knowing that it was smart of her to help her out by just imagining things.
no it doesn’t girlyy imagine having a perfect caring loving husband for over a year then you’ll just know that it was all an imaginary husband!? that hurts girl
She sure has a wild imagination 😂 Edit: guys, I know this is an actual illness and it must be terrible to have but I am not trying to offend ANYONE I am just trying to have fun watching TH-cam
The fact that Jenna was jealous of Penny made me crack up when she saw Ezra. Ezra is mad hot in the animations. This video is so funny and crazy at the same time. Jenna was very mad when she saw Ezra and Penny kiss. Why did the mom and the dad have to break up. The girl Penny was trying to go to the moon with her dad. This video has all sorts of emotions in it. There is happy,sad, and cool. Keep up the great work with the videos.
I'm glad she's back to Noah now! making matches with multiple personality boyfriend is way too hard for her to accept it. Noah is perfect for her to accept
Jenna and Noah are honestly the nicest and coolest people who respect Penny better than Ezra did. Ezra was a moron here. I felt sorry for her since her dad left her and her mom. I'd hug Penny in this story. This was such a beautiful story. And Jenna's design is awesome in this story.
People can't appreciate this story, the comments are mainly bots or people just trying to get likes and a minority of people actually appreciate it. I honestly like how this story isn't about love or family mainly and it's about having a mental disorder which is rare in MSA.
That is true and that was terribly sad. I was, however, thankful for Noah. He was a fantastic guy. The story would have been heartbreaking if he wasn't in it.
this just reminds me of that one movie where a girl finds a boyfriend, but he turned out to be in her head and turned out to be the donner of her heart
I feel so bad for Jenna... All she wanted was someone to care for her. But, Noah came through no matter what and I am happy for the constant diversity that takes place now! Nice job, MSA! :D Ya'll are the best!
We should all take a moment to appreciate how MSA put into these animated stories. There is nothing better than watching MSA Stories. They are the best animated stories I have ever seen. MSA IS THE BESTTT!!!!!!!!!❤❤👌👌✌✌
I wish you guys can show me as much love as you show her! I know I’m not as good as her but I still make entertaining videos and with your help 1 day we will get there together 🫶🏼🌟Thanks
Thank you msa for making this video, this is no joke cuz it happened to me more than once. And right now I'm still struggling to know which is real and which is not, I'm still undergoing therapy but this "imaginary friend" named Ari is still around me whenever I feel at my worst moment... My therapist told me the same thing.. going through so much trauma can really do so much damage to yourself... I hope everyone else is doing fine and be strong no matter what
Love Penny she's so sweet, kind, caring, talented, creative, fun, beautiful, honest, friendly, calm and playful. Penny had to go trough alot in life but thank god she has such a great friends like Jenna and Noah to always be there by her side. Jenna is the sweetest friend been there for Penny when needing it the most and Noah clearly loves Penny he takes well care of her. Such a beautiful story
Penny's been trough so much in life and yeat she faces every moment with such a bravery. This girl is a great inspiration for us all in life. Never give up no matter how hard things get you can get trough anything as long as you belive in yourself and are brave you will get though it all❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Honestly, MSA videos recently are like the *BEST* in the world. Each one of them feels real and so Interesting. They also gives off a important message.
@@yurikagarincultidk in Japan I had many tuitions because of my many absence in class and the teachers offer summer holidays school or late class , I returned home at 7:30!! Which was exhausting 🗿
Woah at first when Ezra started acting different and thought he really has multiple personalities that caused him to hate, resist, and love Penny at the same time thinking it was some type of toxic relationship but finding out that this whole time she made him up and imagined him in which was a shocking plot twist that I did not see it coming
THIS WAS SO GOOD!!! ZE DRAMAA!! I have been a subscriber since you guys were at 2.5k and ur drawings and animations have come so far and now 14.6 million?!! Y’all slay and I’m so excited for the upcoming vids and subscribers that you will gain bc you all deserve it.
This Story is amazing and so inspiring, I cried, it made me so happy how they found a way bck to each other and it made me smile how they got what they wished for. This story is truly inspiring and wonderful
I wish you guys can show me as much love as you show her! I know I’m not as good as her but I still make entertaining videos and with your help 1 day we will get there together 🫶🏼🌟Thanks
@@caylapelt I never shamed anyone for liking anime. I'm just saying that I personally don't enjoy it because I was forced to watch Naruto back in 2018. But, I'm not gonna lie, I did get attracted to fictional female characters before, but they weren't anime characters. I did get attracted to shulk from xenoblade chronicles though. (I am not bisexual) Also the only problem that I have with imaginary relationships are seeing other people with real relationships doing stuff like holding hands etc. and that will actually hurt witnessing other couples.
That's cause he represents the hurt and anger Penny has towards her father. It never left her and it's always finding her when she tries to leave it, much like a real stalker.
(2:45) okay...that guy was way overdoing it. Yes all those gifts were incredible. But a single rose for someone you like sounds way alot more better than giving her so much stuff on the first date. Don't you all agree?
hi msa, idk how long ive been watching you guys, but it’s been a very long time. i have recently gotten a scoliosis brace and a animation video abt scoliosis would be amazing and spread awareness abt scoliosis as I didn’t know abt it until I was diagnosed xx
Stop scrolling and watch the video! You want to see the twist at the end!
I Did And Your The Best YT❤
Lmao u caught me
3rd
the twisting was soo good❤️ i didn't expect it at all!
Ok ty
i knew from the beginning something was off about Ezra, at first i thought he was a ghost because of how pale he is lol but it's so sad how these things happen in real life, because people are so traumatized and can't accept the fact that they were left by their loved ones they tend to imagine things they wished happens for real. Poor Penny, she just wanna feel loved. But i must say that Jenna and Noah are both genuine people, they're both true friends. I love how they handled Penny's situation without making her feel worse about it.
Same
Samme
Bro you spoiled it aa
@@valerienearheart3356 Lol then you shouldn't be reading the comments before you watch the video
Ikr, It's very obvious that ezra is not real because why would a very wealthy boy will drool over an average middle class girl that he met for the first time and rain her lavish gifts on their first date? It doesn't make any sense at all, it really sounds like she is delusional/hallucinating. But still the MC is lucky for having an understanding friend and BF which she really needs
watching your friend kiss the air is the most horrific event ever seen
😂😂 where did you get that emote
youtube emojis are so stupid lol
😊
😂😂😂
I went through a lot of horrific shit but that obviously wasn’t that bad
Both Jenna and Noah are honestly really nice people, also glad that Penny managed to realize it was all just imaginary. Also I feel really bad for her that her dad left like that and then she found out her perfect boyfriend was just imaginary, also another thing just gotta say I love Jenna's design.
@@𱁬 Bastard, U Can't Force Us Subscribe To Your Channel.
@@𱁬 U Don't Even Got Videos On Your Channel To Make Subscribe 😒
yeah
i*
I thought Jenna was just jealous of her bf but the ending shocked me 😲
This episode really tells us how powerful our minds are
MEE to girl
I feel so bad for Jenna... All she wanted was someone to care for her. But, Noah came through no matter what and I am happy for the constant diversity that takes place now! Nice job, MSA!
It's penny who wants someone to care for her not jenna (jenna is her best friend)
@im dude no one wants to sub this is a dumb method
U mean penny?
Me too!😃
I know right!
I feel so bad for penny glad she was able to accept that erza was someone she made up and Jenna and Noah were there for her ! 😀
Ezra*
@@laurah.3811 its only the capital letter she didnt get. why you correct her
Because she spelt his name wrong.
Yes
Noah is such a sweet guy and I feel really sad for Penny, Jenna was such a good friend
True
Get ready for "Everyone take a moment to appreciate the amount of work MSA puts into these stories."
ft
On god
Yess
I know right
@@𱁬 Too bad I can read this without even translating because I know the language.
This genuinely does happen. Your mind and heart wants to protect themselves from trauma at all costs
i love how almost every msa video is like "this girl sees people who don't exist" because even if it happens often I still can't expect it
i really loved Jenna's character design. Her jewelries look stunning
10:33 Love that loyalty in that guy
I really love penny’s art style, to be honest, I feel that she really does deserve to be happy ever since her dad left, it’s great that she was lucky to have Jenna in her life knowing that it was smart of her to help her out by just imagining things.
Same
(2:15) that was actually really smart. One of the rules of any first date...always date in a public place...not a place where you two will be alone.
The story didn't end like expected it too. But I think we all need a friend like Jenna and a boyfriend like Noah.
Imaginary people are too good to be true😂 anyways I feel so sad that penny had to go through that.
NO
@tbhthecatsmallrxseroblox89 #roadto200subs🎄 i rebuke that. In the name of the lord.
Honestly imaginary boyfriend is better than having a real one
Bruh hahahaha
@tbh you are from Odisha.....?
@tbh 😂
@tbh what is this
no it doesn’t girlyy imagine having a perfect caring loving husband for over a year then you’ll just know that it was all an imaginary husband!? that hurts girl
Man I wish I could imagine the perfect best friend like Penny. I'm in therapy now but even still I can't shake the fact where I feel alone.
I'm sorry about that xx but I'm glad your in therapy and hope you get better x just remember , someone's here
She sure has a wild imagination 😂
Edit: guys, I know this is an actual illness and it must be terrible to have but I am not trying to offend ANYONE I am just trying to have fun watching TH-cam
lol
Definitely
No she doesn’t Freja Matilda Shockley
𝙻𝚘𝚕
Bro thsi happens real to punny it isnt funny to laugh this out.. this is a real thing u know?
11:34 the realization really hurts...
I blame her dad for this
The fact that Jenna was jealous of Penny made me crack up when she saw Ezra. Ezra is mad hot in the animations. This video is so funny and crazy at the same time. Jenna was very mad when she saw Ezra and Penny kiss. Why did the mom and the dad have to break up. The girl Penny was trying to go to the moon with her dad. This video has all sorts of emotions in it. There is happy,sad, and cool. Keep up the great work with the videos.
I was laughing tho when Jenna said she saw Penny kissing the air- lmao
I'm glad she's back to Noah now! making matches with multiple personality boyfriend is way too hard for her to accept it. Noah is perfect for her to accept
That was a very different, unexpected ending! I'm glad this story was unique and ended nicely
Who's watching in 2024👇👇 not forcing😅😅
@@ewaewen567 me
@@ewaewen567 me
H
Me every animated field I see a comment like this at the top
Meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Jenna and Noah are honestly the nicest and coolest people who respect Penny better than Ezra did. Ezra was a moron here. I felt sorry for her since her dad left her and her mom. I'd hug Penny in this story. This was such a beautiful story. And Jenna's design is awesome in this story.
Bro Ezra wasn't even real
..
Did u even watch the whole story? 💀
you are a moron not him...........................just kidding don't mind!!
Ezra never existed watch the whole story lmao
1:49 the way she ran like flash😂
Let's all agree Jenna is so good friend
@tbhthecatsmallrxseroblox89 #roadto200subs🎄 lmao what are u looking for clout or something-
For you 💕💖💟😉😜😁 Friday 😁😄❤️💞 for the house 😁🏠🏡
😴 Go 😴 to 😴 bed 😴 JB 💕😪❣️❤️👄💋 not 🚫🚭🎉😎😘 you 😴 to 😴 get 😴 it 😴 if 💕 I 😪 need ❣️ to ❤️ eat 👄 then 💋 we 🚫 will 🚭 go 🎉 to 😎 bed 😪
Well, we all found MSA videos randomly and we all obsessed with it😅❤
(4:03) I so love the aladdin and genie reference!!!! 🧞♂️🧞♂️🧞♂️🧞♂️🧞♂️🧞♂️🧞♂️🧞♂️
Jenna is such a sweet heart ❤️
Kind of
I like how Noah still loved her even after the whole incident
can we all talk abt how Noah Supported Penny even with that imaginary boyfriend crisis
Loved this story but we definitely need a part 2... like she meet her father and starting seeing him again !!
I love these kinds of stories soooooo much because the person that watches them always get almost as shocked as the character
These Stories just get better and better. The plot twist are the end blew me away
I love watching these. Very detailed and always full of surprising twists and turns.
People can't appreciate this story, the comments are mainly bots or people just trying to get likes and a minority of people actually appreciate it. I honestly like how this story isn't about love or family mainly and it's about having a mental disorder which is rare in MSA.
That is true and that was terribly sad. I was, however, thankful for Noah. He was a fantastic guy. The story would have been heartbreaking if he wasn't in it.
You know this never even happened right??…
MSA deals with a lot of disorder these days
who else loves watching msa ?
I love watching these. Very detailed and always full of surprising twists and turns.
this just reminds me of that one movie where a girl finds a boyfriend, but he turned out to be in her head and turned out to be the donner of her heart
Name
@@fatimakhan6288 last Christmas
the plottwist is crazy. i hope that i dont have imaginary friends and people around me. it sounds scary. im glad penny has noah♡
THIS ART IS SO CUTE and sending love to this voice actress!! She is SOO amazing 💞💖
Perfect guy is so good to be true 😭😭😭😭😭
Get ready for "everyone take a moment to appreciate the amount of work Msa puts in these videos"
lmaoo
@Jack Wrath Your content is BS and MSA is a company btw
@@StarsOfTheLand ikr lmao what a damn pick me
@@StarsOfTheLand its a bot yall ur just giving them attention
@im e
4:25 you’re joking right? Homeschoolers aren’t stupid 😑
4:47 When you already figured out what the plot twist was at this part 🥰 (also the title made it obvious)
Noah is the perfect boyfriend that every girl could have imagend it
2:27 um... didnt u hear the loud jet land in ur drive way oh and how's ur driveway that big
Bruh Ezra looked like a freaking vampire when I first saw him in the bushes 😂
Omg I'm obsessed 😍 with MSA love it
I feel so bad for Jenna... All she wanted was someone to care for her. But, Noah came through no matter what and I am happy for the constant diversity that takes place now! Nice job, MSA! :D
Ya'll are the best!
We should all take a moment to appreciate how MSA put into these animated stories. There is nothing better than watching MSA Stories. They are the best animated stories I have ever seen. MSA IS THE BESTTT!!!!!!!!!❤❤👌👌✌✌
Can we appreciate how consistent MSA is for us💀
I wish you guys can show me as much love as you show her! I know I’m not as good as her but I still make entertaining videos and with your help 1 day we will get there together 🫶🏼🌟Thanks
@Jack Wrath No u have 13 subs while MSA has millions also BOT ALERT!!!
Shut up bot 💀
@Jack Wrath bot
MSA like a modern-day Shakespeare, except you don’t rhyme and are not dead ✨✨✨
MSA puts so much effort into their videos and it’s amazing
Thank you msa for making this video, this is no joke cuz it happened to me more than once. And right now I'm still struggling to know which is real and which is not, I'm still undergoing therapy but this "imaginary friend" named Ari is still around me whenever I feel at my worst moment... My therapist told me the same thing.. going through so much trauma can really do so much damage to yourself... I hope everyone else is doing fine and be strong no matter what
Love Penny she's so sweet, kind, caring, talented, creative, fun, beautiful, honest, friendly, calm and playful. Penny had to go trough alot in life but thank god she has such a great friends like Jenna and Noah to always be there by her side. Jenna is the sweetest friend been there for Penny when needing it the most and Noah clearly loves Penny he takes well care of her. Such a beautiful story
Penny's been trough so much in life and yeat she faces every moment with such a bravery. This girl is a great inspiration for us all in life. Never give up no matter how hard things get you can get trough anything as long as you belive in yourself and are brave you will get though it all❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Honestly, MSA videos recently are like the *BEST* in the world. Each one of them feels real and so Interesting. They also gives off a important message.
agreed!!
Msa never disappoints us
Especially after a long day of school ❤
Dude this vid was uploaded at 8am, u going to night school?
@@yurikagarincultidk in Japan I had many tuitions because of my many absence in class and the teachers offer summer holidays school or late class , I returned home at 7:30!! Which was exhausting 🗿
@@yurikagarincultidk bro we all have different time zones
@@Gojosatoru.s Ooohhh, my bad- sometimes I can jump to conclusions. I hope u have a nice rest of ur day :D
@Jack Wrath 13 subs 💀
“They are not just making stories there making our day better”
Woah at first when Ezra started acting different and thought he really has multiple personalities that caused him to hate, resist, and love Penny at the same time thinking it was some type of toxic relationship but finding out that this whole time she made him up and imagined him in which was a shocking plot twist that I did not see it coming
Msa crew is so hard working they been working on this and didn’t post it until 6:00 where I live
I really appreciate MSA and their hard work on this content and i really love it I watch MSA everyday also Jenna's design is so good!!
I love how adventurous you are Penny 😍😍😍
You kissing the air in front of your bff will make her think your need to go to therapy
THIS WAS SO GOOD!!! ZE DRAMAA!! I have been a subscriber since you guys were at 2.5k and ur drawings and animations have come so far and now 14.6 million?!! Y’all slay and I’m so excited for the upcoming vids and subscribers that you will gain bc you all deserve it.
She works alot for us🥺u rock girl !.every time she tries to UPLODE all day she works so hard♥️
At first i thought Jenna was selfish and self-centered but now i can see that she didn't want her dating Ezra just to help her friend
This Story is amazing and so inspiring, I cried, it made me so happy how they found a way bck to each other and it made me smile how they got what they wished for. This story is truly inspiring and wonderful
0:01 who else thought of the penny from big bang theory?? who is also lives in nebraska??
Me!
I wish I did
Everyone (excpet Ezra and the dad) is so supportive in this video and I love it!
We all can agree that we cannot stay a day without MSA vids
I wish you guys can show me as much love as you show her! I know I’m not as good as her but I still make entertaining videos and with your help 1 day we will get there together 🫶🏼🌟Thanks
Image believing u
@@𱁬 i did and i dont regret
Penny from Nebraska ❤️ Loved the reference to TBBT. ❤️
12:29 this part is so sad. It's such a shame stuff like this actually happen in real life
Can people really imagine others that act genuinely nice, then turn against you overtime?
Can we all appreciate the work that goes into these videos each day?✨⭐️
@Jack Wrath bot
@@bronizzy2747 Even I got more subs than him
@@asphaltfurina bot
they don't post each day
@Jack Wrath nah mate my content is better than yours
THIS IS SOO CRAZY 😧 I HOPE PENNY GETS THE HELP SHE DESERVES , EZRA IS THE PERFECT IMAGINATION STORY NEVER FORGET YOUR BRAIN IS POWERFUL 🙏❤️
MSA always makes me feel better when am sad❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
❤️
I LOVE msa you guys make the best animated stories! :)
Having an imaginary boyfriend is like a weeb having an imaginary anime Waifu.
1. I'm actually a guy with an online gf
2. I'm not a fan of anime
@@airtiger4577 but they aren't talking about anyone or you??-
@@B3_H0N3ST Ik. I just wanted to say that I'm not a weeb.
@@caylapelt I never shamed anyone for liking anime. I'm just saying that I personally don't enjoy it because I was forced to watch Naruto back in 2018. But, I'm not gonna lie, I did get attracted to fictional female characters before, but they weren't anime characters. I did get attracted to shulk from xenoblade chronicles though. (I am not bisexual) Also the only problem that I have with imaginary relationships are seeing other people with real relationships doing stuff like holding hands etc. and that will actually hurt witnessing other couples.
@Vanixx Boi How?
Part when the dad left made me literally cry 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
This story was so unique and the title totally delivered.
I love it!!! my god MSA really don't fail to make us such amazing stories
Can we appreciate how msa has amazing story’s everyday there just too good💀
11:45 Mind blowing. Best plot twist in MSA this year
the title is quite relatable as someone who's in love with fictional characters
Ezra’s acting very stalker-ish so far
PLOT TWIST OF THE CENTURY
IKR!!!
Fr it feels so weird
Edit: LORD THIS STORY IS INSANE WTH
I guess he is more of imaginerish
That's cause he represents the hurt and anger Penny has towards her father. It never left her and it's always finding her when she tries to leave it, much like a real stalker.
ahh after a long tiring day, watching MSA while resting is just heaven
The plot twist I didn't expect for 🥺
(2:45) okay...that guy was way overdoing it. Yes all those gifts were incredible. But a single rose for someone you like sounds way alot more better than giving her so much stuff on the first date. Don't you all agree?
Nah
True, haha. But he was imaginary, so i guess everything was very extreme.
hi msa, idk how long ive been watching you guys, but it’s been a very long time. i have recently gotten a scoliosis brace and a animation video abt scoliosis would be amazing and spread awareness abt scoliosis as I didn’t know abt it until I was diagnosed xx
I really like how Noah and Ezra is the perfect boyfriend while Sam is a monster (am i imagining Sam?)
When you have a pretend "boyfriend" and he pulls up in your driveway in a golden jet and flies to urope for dinner:
We will always appreciate MSA
Every time I watch a new MSA video the animations always improve and I love it ❤
Can we appreciate how consistent MSA is for us ❤️
Bro nobody cares half the comments said that
I love MSA. MSA is the best story in the world ♥️💯
Msa we appreciate all the hard work you put in these videos. Thank you very much