Neil Young - Southern Man REACTION!!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ม.ค. 2020
- #NeilYoung #SouthernMan #reaction
react with me to Neil Young - Southern Man
• Neil Young - Southern Man
Thank you for watching
welcome
like ,comment and subcribe
road to 100k
instagram@indiamafiaaa
donate to channel @paypal.me/indiacbush?locale.x... - บันเทิง
Neil Young has always been an activist for anti-war, anti-racism and has stood alongside native tribes in both Canada and the US over land rights!
Very true, it's also very true that he is very underrated guitar player.
As did Buffy Sainte-Marie, The Guess Who, all Canadian musicians. !
This is my first time listening to this and I loved it from the word GO. This is not my genre of music but good is good, period. I have to listen to this guy some more. Here it is Jan. 2022........I'm LATE
Yeah but he let the side down a bit recently by pushing NWO jabs. Shame but I still love him.
@@smurfsrule9680 the jabs have noting to do with the nwo because Christians are still on earth and most things people like you think that are true are lies by conspiracy theorists and anti Jewish people who are as bad as racists which are extreme conservative republicans who clam to be Christians but are not Christians and will burn in hell because they believe in lies from the devil which is found in conspiracy theories and anti Semitic and racism.
So brave. What a song. Love you Mr Young. Ahead of your time
The guitar solo’s tone also reflects the pain & dissonance. I love how he crafted it to reinforce the mood of the song.
I know it's 3 yrs ago but that's what I was thinking. You can hear and feel it in the guitar. The song is deep but I love Neil Young's playing and vocals. He's one of those artists you only need a few notes or words to know it's Neil Young.
Neil Young is not fooling around. I've been listening to him for 50 years.
Spot on.
No he is not i love him
I practically grew up with this song as I was born in 63. This song has always grabbed me by my heart and guts. That was a really powerful experience watching a young black woman listen to this for the first time. It's indescribable the emotions I just felt watching you listen to this. God bless you beautiful girl.
I love how you can hear the rage in Neil's voice in this song. The song positively burns with white-hot anger
"White" in both senses of the word.
You are projecting.
@@kindnessfirst9670 Yes, Neil Young is white. Well observed
@@tonyiacomi4822 Sorry, Neil is of course positively delighted as he sings these warm nostalgic lyrics about the good old days. That better?
@@JayPhonomancer You don't have to get mad so easy. Its just weird for you to say what someone else is feeling when they are singing. You feel enraged so that's what you think and hear. Psychology 101
That whole cd by Neil Young is genius.
Our Canadian 🇨🇦 rocker is a treasure ! He is not afraid to say what he thinks especially when it comes to civil rights, he is a true activist. He could have lost his career over this recording, but he went ahead to tell this story & open peoples eyes to what was going on in the south. Neil, also has stood strong with Indigenous peoples & farmers who are losing their way of life.
I love how you were respectful of Neil’s guitar soloing and didn’t talk over it. He has said that The solo sections were really emotive for him during these sessions..He really got to the emotions and pain he was feeling and produced them in the solos. Thanks for being real cool about that. Thanks for being U🙏
Neil Young could really make anguish come out of his instrument as well as anyone ever could
Neil Young is an amazing artist. It just so happens that, what looked like the late 70's, Neil Young was being filmed and the people who were around him. They just released this movie 🎬 and it will be in theaters starting December 1st, 2022.
Neil Young is one of my biggest influences as a musician!
You can’t get better than Neil!
“God didn’t make any of us to be tortured”. That right there, wow so powerful. Thank you for your insight and perspective.
Neil had guts to write this song. Billie Holliday sang Strang Fruit. Please review that shocking song. It took guts for her to sing in in the 1930s. Remember what Gid says"The first SHALL be last and the last shall be first.GBY
Thank You so much! Much better understanding of the lyrics now.
Neil Young was a supporter of civil rights.
Neil Young is talking about Jim Crow in the south of 1970 as well as slavery that ended a century before that.
Is not.
And sadly continues today.
Neil Young is a musical genius. He has so many good songs.
Absolutely. Im a huge fan. I love his music, can feel it! Saw him last year. He performed with so much passion und energy. It was fabulous. I will never forget these live experiences for the rest of my life!
@John Signs And I read Neil Young say he'd rather play Sweet Home Alabama than Southern Man. To top it off look at the covers of Skynyrd's Street Survivors album. Notice what Ronnie Van Zandt is wearing?
@John Signs Yes, the shirt is the cover of Tonight's the Night album cover.
Good songwriter, terrible vocalist, okay guitar player.
@John Signs People who can't spell aren't allowed to comment on TH-cam, smegma boy.
This song is an unapologetic call out and indictment on the evil side of southern history and of southern racism. It’s not just the words, it’s how he sings them. Throughout history we have all been such beasts to one another.... I hope one day love will prevail. Love you and your perspectives on music
Interesting that a Canadian wrote two of the most iconic songs about what was (is) wrong about the USA back in the 1970's: Southern Man and Ohio.
That's because Canada is boring by comparison.
What's he gonna do...write songs about hockey and snow?
And Brittish band Iron Maiden wrote Run to the Hills.
A third would be "Alabama."
Greàt song
true So
I love watching these videos because I've heard these songs hundreds upon hundreds of times in my life, and I don't really appreciate them any more. Seeing someone's reaction to them on the first listen, it's like I'm hearing them for the first time again.
@wickedvideowatcher...... I agree 100%!
It's like vicariously hearing the songs again for the first time. I'm so glad that India and a few others of the "younger generation" (god, it makes me feel old saying that!) are listening to some of the good music that might all too easily be forgotten otherwise.
Yup
You articulated how I feel as well.
You took the words right off my keyboard!
The guitar purposefully being played in an ugly mangled fashion was genius. I always remember that part thoroughly.
No-one plays the guitar angrily better than Neil Young!
And the piano played by Nils Lofgrin is fantastic
So many Neil Young songs are in the minor key switching to an alternate major chord that throws in a hars discordant sound. I've never seen his style repeated. That's probably why 80% of the songs I play on guitar are Neil Young.
Sounded a bit like mayhem/chaos, craziness and suffering, maybe the insane inhumanity of the crazy people who seen no wrong in the wrongest thing!
ro he My son plays guitar also. There’s not many better than Neil.
Listen to Neil young in ?2021 you'll understand where he's comming from..Listen to all his Music..Back then till Now...He Has a Huge Heart..🙏✌Peace !! ❤😉🎵🎼🎶
.
Genius ....still gives me chills
His raw voice and emotion
How long how long awwwwhhh
Amazing thanks for the listen and thoughts
@India Reacts I'm only 3 minutes in but your shock was something I needed to mention. Rock and roll used to say important things. Sometimes it was overt but sometimes it was hidden in symbolic words or phrases. Neil Young was a Canadian looking into our world. Yes, this song was written in 1970 about racism and segregation. There are references to slavery and the KKK. The song "Ohio" is also a song about an important time in US history.
This was so well said.
AGREED!!!
I have heard this song for years and liked it but never actually listened to the words and the other day I heard the words and was like oh man wth am I listening to then I just looked up the lyrics and got it so when I saw your reaction I'm glad you're reaction I agree
so right! The sixties and early seventies was a special time and we had enough of racism, ignorance and all the things that DIVIDE us as humans!
Misinformed jackass! Northern Govment Ships! South no navy Throw in an anthrax blanket for da lndians!! Go Yankees
I saw him 30 years ago and it was just him, his guitar, his harmonica and another guy on a piano and it was one of the best concerts I ever saw.
I saw him last year for the first time and it was one of the best concerts I've ever been to. He's still brilliant.
@@oest2029 gad to know he still got it :)
Spooner Oldham on piano? Yeah those were some sweet shows!
If anything this song is a learning lesson for all to learn. It was controversial when it first came out in 1970 and it still resonate today 🤔
your reaction to lilly bell is priceless. hope you have heard Sweet home Alabama in response to this song.
Neal Young is a genius.
Neil Young talking to the Southern men about what he saw in the south and the devastating effects of institutionalized racism. Lynyrd Skynyrd responded with their song “Sweet Home Alabama” in which they told Neil Young off. Neil then wrote the song “Alabama” asking Alabama wtf is wrong with that state.
Neil's song "Alabama" came out before the Skynyrd song. "Sweet Home Alabama" was also a response to that.
"well I heard Mr. Young talk about her, I heard ol' Neil put her down yeah. Well I hope neil young will remember, Southern Man don't need him around anyhow" - Sweet Home Alabama, obviously written before Neil's song, It took a really great band to be able to do justice to a response to it, they fought Wallace too but they were stung by the scathing words about their home state. They carry about the same weight but I'm a 68 year old white guy and I lean toward Neil. Watching your face India, on hearing this song for the first time, made me smile and tear up at the same time, I'm crying as I type, God bless you girl.
Neil Young publicly said he was proud to be mentioned in one of their songs. He's also great at writing protest songs. However, he would never do anything to harm the memories of Ronnie Van Zant. Neil is a beautiful soul and I wish there were more like him.
Sweet Home Alabama was written in the same vein as Southern Man. It's not Lynyrd Skynyrd's fault people don't understand social satire, irony, and the intricacies of poetic storytelling. It's fortunate that Neil Young did.
Well i have nothing personal against Skynyrd, but from there reaction to this i can only assume there were at the very least pro-Confederacy, and possibly much more than that, but will say no more...
Proud to say...at 18...was in the Neil Young Appreciation Society.
I’ve been listening to this song since the 70s and the imagery and emotions it evokes are as powerful today as they were over 45 years ago. The lyrics “I heard screaming and bull whips cracking” still conjure horrible images in my mind and my spirit still aches for the poor souls who suffered at the hands of slave owners and other bigots. I have a friend who had never listened to rock until recently when I made her a cd full of some of my favorites along with a printout of the titles and short comments about the songs. For Southern Man I wrote “One of the most important songs ever written, Close your eyes and listen carefully to the lyrics. Have a box of Kleenex ready.’
Did you include STRANGE FRUIT by Suzie Q & Banshee's ????? Great follow on from S. Man.
@@HTJB60 the Billie Holliday song?
You are absolutely correct. Here it is Jan. 2022, I'm listening for the first time and I liked it from the word GO. This isn't my genre of music but good is good period. I was pleasantly surprised. From what I've gathered I have to listen to more of this legion.
22 seconds in and my reaction thus far "oh gods she's gonna listen to Southern Man. She's gonna cry and it's gonna suck for her". Just wanna say now, hope you're well
Sister you made me cry You took back Home to Senegal where I discovered Neil young back those days I didn’t understand a word of what he was singing about.Now That I understand the lyrics I love him Twice and the funny thing is at the same time I was a great fan of Lynyrd Skynyrd back in 1984 when I landed to New York I had a good friend he was a white man we become very good friends and was helping to perfect my poor English, he is the who told me how Lynyrd S replied to this song - in Sweet Home Alabama -: “ Heard what Neil Young said about us, Hope Mr young will remember Southern man don’t around anyhow “ .did you listen to The new song by Neil Young “ Looking for new leader “ he is not talking to America alone but to all Countries.Thank you sister and like Neil said “Keep on Rocking in Free World.
Sweet Home Alabama is the musical response to this song
Neal Young rocking in the freeworld is great to Def recommend
Harvest - Neil Young - iconic album - just say'n
🔥💟💙
I'm with ya, for me it was live rust. but yea, harvest is really really good.
HAS 2B IN EVERYONES COLLECTION
I agree.....classic xx
Not even in his top ten best, it's just his most famous one. Isn't half as good as on the beach
Whole album was great ,not a bad song on it
I love this song! Thank you Neil Young!
Neil's body of work is unsurpassed. GOAT.Peace to everyone. Cherish and learn from everyone. End hate.
You are a beautiful lady, you take information, then... Appropriate response! Thank you as always!
This song was a reaction to the south's treatment of blacks and how there must be change.
@KV Bradford Yeah, now they are racist southern Republicans..TODAY!
@KV Bradford Ever hear of the southern strategy? Lying dumbass!! Lol
@@jacksprat418-ju5qo I remember Lee Atwater
@@elegantirony78 Wasn't he a peach! lol
@@jacksprat418-ju5qo Southern Strategy was a BIG FAT LIE....................... that fools fall for.
Neil cuts straight to the point. I'm a Southern man and I love this song! I was born and raised in South Carolina but now live out West (thank goodness). Thanks for doing this song India, glad you appreciated it! On a side note, you have very pretty eyebrows, no big fake arch and very thick; two good things. *Stop racism people!* Peace.
Neil wrote many protest songs whenever he saw injustice. This song still applies today. A majority of the US folks dying of Covid 19 are blacks because they cannot access adequate testing nor treatment. Lynyrd Skynyrd wrote Southern Man as a rebuttal to this Neil Young song. Please do a show on that.
I don't remember the first time I listened to this song since my parents are big Neil Young fans but it's effective *every single time*
Never gets old and you can feel the fire and anger he plays with and it is some of the best music you will ever set your ears upon!!!
Way ahead of his time about generational racism and just about every social issue throughout his storied career. More please
i was for nearly 20 years on holidays in new orleans and nowwhere was more racism like there... only listening a rap cd in my car was dangerous... the whites were angry, because i listen black music and the blacks were angry, because i listen their music and no rock n roll... and i am coming from germany, formerly known as the hometown of racism, but here we havnt such problems... only in our next town near two big air base station of the US army... there are blacks and whites soldiers strictly in different pubs and shops... USA is in my eyes the most racist state on earth...
@@seelenwinter6662 You need to get to some world news. The USA is racist, but so is Israel, Saudi Arabia, China, Russia, etc. Don't make absolute measures of racism, it's all over the world!!!
@@falungongboy Well said.!
@James Mills It is weird saying someone was ahead of his time for talking about the past
He grew up with it. He was right in his time. Look at the history of civil rights from the 50s, the protests of 60s and 70s. He knew first hand.
This SONG! ...the lyrics..the guitar🎸🙌🏾🙌🏾
listening to neil young has been really eye opening to me as a 15yo
Yes, back in the day when musicians had some balls. "Ohio". "Monster" by Steppenwolf, "Volunteers" by Jefferson Airplane.... the list goes on and on.
They still do .., there are ,have been and always will be bands that have political messages . You just have to look for it yourself .. isn’t on the radio anymore .
Heart Of Gold, and Old Man are Iconic Neil songs
he hits the strings like whipping
Great song writer, singer and musician. He has it all.
I had the pleasure of seeing Neil live, even at 70 years old he was one of the most powerful experiences of my life.
The great Neil Young. Yes, his message was so real.
I saw CSNY live and enjoyed them very much they have harmonies you have nevr heard before ! Greetings from concord , nc. I have been following you and your reactions for a while and girl i am enjoying your reactions ! Keep up the great work ! 😍😍
Songs that hit the heart and soul and make you think about it ! He did his job ! Great writer and performer
Notice how much feeling he puts into the solos! The lyrics and vocals are evocative, but not less is Neils distinctive guitar style. Disturbing and raw....
I remember someone saying back in 1975 that described Neil Young's guitar style as "rancid". Somehow that seems to fit. We all liked him then and still do today.
@@sn1ckers100 Neil described it himself as 'it sucks' lol but it sucks like nobody else
@@blindriv3r No doubt about that.
I saw him in the early 1990's at the RPI Field House. He was changing guitars often because of how many strings he was breaking. He went berserk playing "Keep On Rocking In The Free World" - twice! Nobody can say he didn't feel it...
I always felt that his soloing, at least in Southern Man, was meant to feel painful. As if he were trying to describe the lyrics through his playing as well. Nothing about the man has ever really been smooth though. I love a lot of his music. We could use more Neil Young types, imo.
Down by the River is a GREAT song
Down by the river was the first song I learned on guitar. Well, one of the first... It's been a while
Rick Baltimore...my favorite Neil
If I could stand to see her crying I would tell her not to care, when she learns of all your lyin will she join you there. Country Girl.
Hurricane,,by Bob Dylan and what is it Death Most...? Both iconic
Was written about his beloved dog 😓
legendary
Thanks for your reaction India. Very honest and real. Ronnie Van Zandt and Neil Young were friends and respected each other.
You have to see this was written after the events of 1968 and previous years. Neil is one of my greatest heroes. This is a very cool video if it is indeed genuine and I believe it is her first time hearing a Neil’s southern man. His music changed me for sure from where I grew up and stuff. He changed my mind. The He’s straight up a song writing genius
Give Neil Young a paper bag and an E String and he will make you feel it.
Nicely said, lol
@@ryanm5578 God wishes he could write songs and play guitar as well as Neil Young.
Dude found some mediocre bar band musicians, but they had the soul and he knew it. Crazy Horse may as well be a paper bag and an E string as far as the studio musicians are concerned, but Neil is real.
@@BubbaBrazille I used to perform this song, haven't heard Neil's in a while, and I was actually surprised by how formal the arrangement is in retrospect. However, the sidelong version of Words really illustrates this band as being exactly what you've described, as does the whole Tonight's the Night album in particular, and all of them in general. Neil is a good arranger, the structures are relatively single, he dragged and kicked this band to the next level every night.
@@PincherVoice Neil’s autobiography is a must read. I played a lot of covers, but never could pull off a NY song. Not enough confidence, like trying to actually fly for me.
Neil Young was an activist, happy you have had the opportunity to hear it.
Another great song of his is Rock and Roll Will Never Die
I keep playing things like this for my older kids, they want to know what the 60's/70's were ....this was it.
Neil young has inspired soooo many musicians. The Thrasher changed my outlook on life. And Neil is one of the best guitarists period. He has used his fame and fortune to do many good things.
Yep, benefit concerts for disabled children, farmers, environmental issues etc.......
Best guitar rift ever!
I'm 1/2 black & 1/2 white; grew up in Jacksonville FL in the early 80s. This song was on major repeat in my house when I was a kid. The very 1st concert I ever went to was with my hippie parents: Neil Young in Gainesville; I was maybe 12? This song was one of my (white) mother's favorites. When Neil came out, she stood up & screamed "play Southern Man!!" Not a lot of other black people have heard this music that has been so much a part of my life. Thank you for being, as you said, "open minded" enough to take it in and give us your honest modern reaction.
I was hooked on Neil at 14 yrs old when I first heard "Heart of Gold". Genius!
One of his best! Lyrically, amazing guitar solo and the pure energy and aggression
I am with you all the way.....the world needs more positivity and less hate....I feel the tide turning very slowly in the direction of justice and reform.....I love how you are so open minded and never bitter or angry....Bless you and your family
So raw and powerful! Still to this day!
'Southern Man' by Neil Young is one of the greatest songs of the Rock & Roll Era (1954 to Present). India's reaction to this song is one of her greatest reactions ever.
Keith orlandini 😂 ok...
Gotta respect a man who stands up for what he believes. He's still putting his money where his mouth is.
Yea'Good'ol Neil's musical *BACKFLASH* about this one..'cos: Lynyrd Skynyrd basically gave Neil *the* *finger* in "Sweet Home Alabama":
"Well I heard mister Young sing about her
Well, I heard ole Neil put her down
Well, I hope Neil Young will remember
A Southern man don't need him around anyhow".. - True. Every Man Has a Voice ..Too. _( *True..* th-cam.com/video/9Cyokaj3BJU/w-d-xo.html ..or False..)
Yeah, Neil put it to them.
"Alabam You Got The Rest Of The Union To Help You Along, "
Neil Young, just amazing...
Whenever I wonder how anyone back then got by without any of the modern music of today, I remember that they had Neil Young.
1970's music more relevant today than ever.
Case in point - Marvin Gaye's What's Going On
70,000,000 MAGA fans hate this song.
More relevant than when blacks where actually enslaved?
Well this song hates them too lol
You are so freaking amazing and so insightful that's exactly what Neil Young was trying to portray. I have no tolerance for prejudice in any way.
😒
Your final reaction says it all we can't change the past. & Most of us went through a lot of BS and unfairness just the story is rarely told . God bless you love your reactions
I can't believe I'm 54 years old and this is the first time I've heard this song.
This entire album is amazing this song in particular and says so much about tyranny and oppression
I still remember the first time I heard Neil Young...'On the Beach' is imo his greatest work.......an artist for all times....especially now...'southern Man' is great because he doesn't try to make it pretty ....the guitar is a blunt instrument.......how about reacting to some Lou Reed?
A great song - also try Neil Young's "Alabama" in the same theme.
Wow. The legend, the myth................Neil Young
for the Neil Young newbies : he is regarded as one of the greatest songwriters of all time next to Bob Dylan or Van Morrison. For many of us the first steps in learning guitar was probably a Neil Young tune. One more detail : He NEVER cared if his songs would become hits or not and in the beginning of the seventies he was quite radical for change regarding political issues. Check out his music. lots of great tunes and lyrics out there. He is also know to be a grumpy old fart nowadays.....
No wonder he's grumpy... 60 years of nothing changing.
Hell I don’t blame him
Best kind of Grumpy ol' fart...I'm right there with him, but he has better wording!
his father was a very well known journalist in canada. wrote a few dozen books. also big on TV back in the day. controversial too. his mother was a tv personality....he lived in winnipeg and toronto
Also a great Canadian! Grew up in Winnipeg Qing with Burton Cummings and Randy Bachman
Liked your take on this song, bought the album when I got out of the army,still have the vinyl from back in the day.
Neil Young was a genies with his lyrics. This indictment of racism and slavery in the US remains relevant today. We're still talking about it and those of us who live through the sixties still have some pretty horrific memories of some of the things we witnessed. I was the white man in a mixed race marriage in the 80s and faced some difficulties early on. I'm pleased to say that my sons are experiencing a better world today.
DAMN, can you get anymore Beautiful Young Lady!!!!!!!!!!!! Love your reactions!!!!
You should be in movies. You have the look, passion, and humility.
humility?
among movie stars??
hahaha,thats a good 'un.
besides,why not aspire to be better than that in a nation where image is everything and how much you have in your bank account is equally important.
more to life than money,image and fame.
Just sayin she looks great on film!!!! Hollywood needs humility!!!!
😳
Neil Young is a legend. It's just sad how far society hasn't come.
Exactly. It pains me that in the 60's we fought for equal rights and my children today still do. I try to explain to them that we too had strong feelings so long ago. We did our best but it never seems that's enough.
No
Still painful to listen to even after all these years. Neil's a brave, brave man, coulda got hisself killed with this...
Nice job. I like the way that you questioned the lyrics in the beginning. Then, you got it-powerful.
Music lyrics meant more to my generation than they do today.
Brought tears to my eyes watching you react to this as a white male. Our nation has a horrific history.
One of the best songs about rage against evil! Not rage against black or white, but rage against evil! India, you stated it so beautifully, particularly when you said "your man" was white. Rage against evil!!!
he wrote music with HEART SOUL and MEANING.....
India, you hit the nail on the head.
......and just when we thought we were making progress.....
Our Canadian boy, Neil, spoke up, and got some flack. Love you India!
One of the most powerful songs written!