Which Roommate Breached the Lease? | Part 2
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- Timothy claims Michael always had someone staying at their place - and he didn’t like it!
The Original! There’s only ONE Judge Judy. Visit our website for where to watch, weekdays.
Subscribe to Judge Judy on TH-cam: / @judgejudy
#JudgeJudy
Plaintiff is well dressed, but that doesn't hide the fact he is running what I'd call a flophouse.
He’s shameful .. bet’ya he doesn’t live like that ! 😡
Not a flophouse, it was a transient house, many poor guys just stay for a night or two. My uncle lived in one till there was a famous fire in 1978, Coates Fire in KCMO.
I have an issue with the way his tie is done up. If someone more capable had put it on him, he might have looked better. I'm not saying I'm God's gift, I'm just saying.
😂😂
He looks like the Wish version of George Clooney
Plaintiff hasn't figured out, CONVENIENTLY, that it was HE who breached the lease.
He's renting this guy a room in a warehouse where he has to climb a ladder to access it and invites a whole bunch of strangers over to freeload on that man's dime. This guy is nuts.
Sounds Like A Loft .
$1600 for a loft in a warehouse with 1 bathroom and a bunch of men…..🤢
They pee on the floor anyway
In San Francisco to boot. No, thanks.
Sounds hot to me
@@SpeckszDaBossplaintiff is well dressed daddy
Also climbing a ladder to go up to a room, $1.600, wow.
You don't understand how someone could sign a six month lease and then break it when YOU initiated the breach. Howww do people get to be grown and mature yet not take accountability?
there's no "maturity" there- he's just a grown baby-
Because it’s California.
Probably why he's single.
He aged but didn't mature.
He's grown but not mature.
He didn't break the lease, you did smart a$$.
The Plaintiff doesn't realize HE broke the lease by allowing people to move in and out. He changed the terms of the living arrangements. Cripes, the Plaintiff had SEVERAL people in and out from the very beginning. I was all ready for the Defendant to be a non-paying slacker. However, it turns out the Plaintiff had all kinds of "friends" coming and going. The Defendant had every right to move out early. "Several" roomates was not what he signed up for.
definetly ... !
and im a landlord ...
The more than two people with one bathroom did it for me. NO OTHER EXCUSE NECESSARY!!
Sharing a bathroom would be a big No for me 😑
Think for women it’s an eeewww 🥴 but I know some men that’s it’s an ok 🤷🏻♀️.. but yes oh yuk !
Even if it was the lead singer of Smash Mouth? I'd be starstruck!
It's a big no as long as you can affort it.
For me as well.
@@johnmcconnell8151 😂 guy fieri or sugar ray
Men don't care
$1600 for a warehouse room that you have to climb a ladder to and end up living with a ton of other people. Bet the plaintiff doesn’t live like that. He comes across as very smarmy and shameless.
He lived there as well did you miss that bit? He rented out the loft to the defendant amd they shared the bathroom, kitchen, and living room, so then they are both bound by the lease. The plaintiff though carried on as though he didn't have a tenant by letting people stay over etc.. which means he broke the lease.
Who in their right mind accepts a $1600 a month lease to move into a place where they have to climb a ladder? Did the defendant have a gun to his head when he signed it? I just cannot understand why accountability doesn't go both ways with the people posting under this video.
@@sothathappened one probably because he has a dog and two because his father was helping pay his rent. What do you mean accountability? The defendant did nothing wrong, he didn't leave because of the ladder!! He left because the landlord broke the tenancy agreement, the defendant was paying to share the space with one person. Then suddenly other people move in and others stay over so late they crash there. So now he can't use the living room he paid to share, and he has to queue for the bathroom etc... So there is no accountability here for the defendant as he did nothing wrong. The landlord was the problem, so your comment makes no sense.
It's in San Francisco, one of the cities with the highest prices for real estate
You breached the lease by having additional unanticipated tenants. Goodbye, plaintiff!
He doesn't understand he broke the lease! For a smart guy, he doesn't get it!
Good for the tenant! That guy is running a sham!
Plaintiff was building a boy harem.
This plaintiff took advantage of this student.....at $1,600 a month???? Slick!!
Plaintiff thought the lease was above all. He was wrong.
You can't just move other people in and expect the tenant to still be bound by the lease.
He should’ve stated in the lease that he was renting out rooms and the bathroom will be shared
He's one of those people who shouldn't be a landlord because they don't understand that they are bound by the lease as well. He rented out the room and then carried on as though he didn't have a tenant to consider, because that changes everything.
Plaintiff is a good example of a well dressed smooth talking conman.
like Trump
Bedbugs are awful. I got them from staying at a motel one night and my home ended up infested for awhile. It made me feel so disgusting. You have to get rid of everything and there were little blood speckles everywhere.
Yes! There horrible
Legend has it the plaintiff is still questioning how you can break a 6-month lease you signed. Well, the plaintiff broke the agreement before the defendant left. I found it hard to visualize this place, but it sounded like way too much commotion for one dwelling when the agreement was the defendant would be living with the plaintiff only. I get the impression there was a lot of partying and it was an unwelcome ambiance for the defendant.
Yes I mean he is there to study and suddenly finds himself in party central with people staying so late that they just crash in the living room he's paying to use.
Well done to the guy for not tolerating his chaos! 👏👏👏👏
JJ: What else was bothering you?
Me: The GODDAMN LADDER!!!
Lmao! Imagine carrying groceries up there. Eff that!
I was like “he carried a tables and a desk up there?” 🤔
I sure hope the defendant had a small dog or that was going to be chore carrying it up and down the ladder every time…
Judge Judy was done @ $1600 for a ladder. 😂😂😂
Glad Judy ruled the way she did.
Bedbugs? OH HELLS NO
Plaintiff acted all shocked about dude being bothered by them.
😂
Some people are just thick. She explained, more than once, why his case was dismissed and he's still asking why.
😂😂😂
If that kid, doesn't start to stand up straight, he will have back problems his whole life......
That "kid" is 41 yrs old.
@@dillionrose2782 He’s 41 and dad pays his rent .. still 😄
@@apollonia-avadaddy’s prolly a Silicon Valley billionaire.
@@caseyking0917 🤣👏
It is possible there is some disability from a prior injury there. Maybe that's the best he can do.
When Judge Judy didn’t correct the defendants grammar I knew he was going to win
Guy Fieri on Judge Judy was not on my bingo card
I found it kind of sweet the way the Defendant was awkwardly standing there like that. I like how he listened to Judge Judy's analogy and acknowledged it. I found him really respectful and I'm sure she would have liked that.
This is why they say never judge a book by its cover. The plaintiff is dressed so smart but thinks otherwise 🤦♀️
i think the landlord just wanted some extra men around the house 😬
Yeah if those walls could talk.
Frat house with bunch of young college men
Uugghh I got weird vibes
Like that. Just some old rich guy opening his home to some needy twink that goes by Prince. 🫤
I can agree 100000 percent the apartments I have rented from all my life never ever looked as nice when I first moved in.
What a flip. The older man is the party guy and the college student wants quiet.
They’re the same age 😂
Not this man looking like a hedgehog 🦔 😅
My god I just turned 41 a few weeks ago and I want to deny it every single day of my life......
He has my hairstyle when I was in 10th grade 1997-1998
I had it for about 6 months while the bleach turned to orange and i cut it all off.
I'm shocked he still rocking that stuff it was popular for 1 year MAX during 98 degrees LFO....o Town NSYNC boy band era
😂😂
The plaintiff still not understanding lol what a fool
Defendant is taking me to FLAVORTOWN!!!
Look up the word "shyster" in the dictionary and the plaintiff's face will appear as an example thereof. lol
The Plaintiff's smile looks like villeins in the movies.
Almost like Jack Nicholson in the Shining
Along with the defendant’s hair 👀
I thought he was a villain… $1,600 a month, moving guys in and out all the time, all sharing one toilet? 🤮
I feel bad for the Defendant. The Plaintiff is very sketchy!!
The PLAINTIFF broke the lease by having people move into the apartment who were not living there prior to signing the lease. The defendant agreed to 2 people living there total when he signed the lease.
"re rent the room!"
i don't think anyone would rent with him again
One bathroom, “that would be bothersome to me…” -Judge Judy
Nice way to say 🤮 😂
Plus the guy renting the room out should have told the perspective tenant that he is gay and he would be bringing in a lot of gentlemen callers for his pleasure.
We're done. Thank you. Bye (already halfway to the door)
Plaintiff had so much audacity thinking his place is still open to anyone when it is partly rented
I like how the Defendant just stood there hardly said a word and case got dismissed.
He moved his stuff out - down a ladder. It was most definitely uninhabitable.
Plaintiff does not seem to understand the phrase "breached the lease." Or just pretending.
Defendant shows zero emotion 🫣
Think he has problems of his own and doesn't need this one in court.
I’m wondering if he has Asperger’s. He kind of looks like he shows no emotion over anything.
Electric socket hair
He filed a claim to sue the tenant because he didn’t want to share a bathroom with a different stranger every other day while also paying $1600, and live with bedbugs 😮 the audacity smdh
Sadly, there are many greedy slumlords who take advantage of inexperienced people, specifically college students… #stayalert
im glad to see the series are in order 😂😭🤣
Not in order, best keep up. For this was from 2016.
@@trekgirl65 mightve been from 16 but is still in order in 2024 😂😭🤣
Defendant should have turned plaintiff in to code enforcement, the warehouse probably isn’t even zoned for occupants. There was a situation in Oakland across the bay from San Francisco where people lost their lives because they were living in a warehouse that wasn’t inhabitable, it caught fire and many died .
Plaintif thinks he can hook sombody in to a high dollar lease then turn the dwelling into a flop house, and doesn't understand how the victim can legally get out of it...
"Prince"😂😂😂😂😂
Someone pour the plaintiff a glass of water 😂
Sounds like a dump
Why dose it sound like this was some kind of… sex house.
The plaintiff is something else 😂
What is so hard to understand about breaking a lease? It’s not illegal, the tenant just does whatever is agreed upon in the contract. That might be a buy out, it might be you don’t get a security deposit back m, but you can’t make someone stay on a lease😂
Plaintiff is a party boy who's used to all things going his way, all the time.
Plaintiff is a dirty bird
that's one argument I stay getting into contracts this contract that like judges don't have the power to override it
Plaintiff wants to enforce a lease where self serving, but not respect that lease where it concerns his own contractural obligations. Even though the lease will not state it, you cannot lease a house to someone, then after moving in say "BTW, I am giving the key to your house to a couple of other people." The lease comes with the legal protection for the tenant, that the landlord cannot materially change the living conditions during the term of the lease. Landlord breached, but doesn't understand that he breached, because it is all about him. He should not rent until he learns that a lease means mutual obligations.
How is this guy here?????
He's literally renting a room only accessible from a ladder.
100% its illegal and he's coming here for this shit?
How embarrassing
1600 for a shared bathroom loft space in a warehouse in 2019?? How is that even possible ?
San Francisco rents
Sharing a bathroom never.
I was homeless, did drugs, went into prison, where I got to know God. He changed my life. Now I have a home, a wife and a lovely year old daughter (zoe), and a stream of income that gats me $47,000 weekly. Plus a new identity - a child of God, Hallelujah!!!🇺🇲❣️♥️❤️
@LawrenceDuvall-8Thanks to Kate Elizabeth Becherer
I always appreciate God for his kindness upon my life
@@marybradleyblack-fYES!!! That's exactly her name (Kate Elizabeth Becherer) so many people have recommended highly about her and am just starting with her 😊 from Brisbane Australia🇦🇺
Same here, with my current portfolio made from my investments with my personal financial advisor (Kate Elizabeth Becherer) I totally agree with you
@@MarkHyman-1This sounds so good and I would like to be a party to this, is there any way I can speak with her?
Too bad Judge Judy didn't do a little more digging about the lease, as I'm actually wondering if the room was even legal to be rented out...
In Part 1, it was mentioned that a person has to climb a ladder to enter the room, and that would seem to me to be an immediate fire code hazard, and a landlord shouldn't get permission to be able rent that room due to that and other safety concerns, such as falling off of the ladder...
Then there is the issue of having only the one bathroom, while I can't (yet) find any U.S. regulation on the minimum number of bathrooms per rented room/person, having 3 permanent tenants plus the extra visitors that stayed over and likely slept on couches or floor, I can't imagine that would pass inspection and another reason why the landlord wouldn't be allowed to rent out that or any other room in the warehouse...
So if it's actually an illegal tenancy and the landlord wasn't legally allowed to be renting out rooms, perhaps the defendant's countersuit should have been granted and the rent money returned to him...
I don't think anything in the case was illegal from a code standpoint. Bedroom lofts have ladders, that's how you get to them. It was the intrusion of an unexpected third tenant into the home, where there was already a shared bathroom between landlord and tenant. Nothing illegal to the inspector but a breach of lease by the landlord and discommodious, as JJ put it, as she has rather strong feelings about the ultimate privacy of the bath.
@@wintercame Yeah, I didn't consider it being like a loft, I was more envisioning an open concept warehouse with very high ceilings (room enough for lots of steel shelving and forklifts to move inventory) with the room(s) possibly being located at a second story height and perhaps needing a 15 foot ladder to climb up there.🙃
@@ONE-OF-THREE Sure, we don't know, quite. But with a dog? I have a small one and I wouldn't make it 15' up or down with the furball in arms.
@@wintercame Well, the way that the defendant stood semi hunched over, I'd say he made many a trip up and down that ladder, whether it was 5 or 15 feet tall!!!🙃
Poor guy he’s just a kid. He deserves better
He’s 41
I’m all for artistic living but yea if I move in somewhere and you invite someone to stay cause if hard times that’s your issue I’m moving . I clean my shower twice a week just for ne so sharing a bathroom with more than 1 other person would make me ick and I would def move
This is a college student?!? He looks the same age as the other guy and he has no personality
No way that this 41yo was really 'in classes'. More like another Pell Grant or something.
Love this episode, this was a good one.
£1600 for a room with no private bathroom?? That is just ludicrous
Dollars, and it's still outrageous.
plaintiff looks like Steve Martin
The plaintiff thinks that he is something special but he is not.
Today's new word - discommode 😁
That plantiff is awful he breached the lease not the defendant
Legend has it, he's still in that court room explaining how the defendant breached a 6 month lease...
Bed bugs in the bed. I would believe that one.
Mr.Kerwin is used to getting his way.
Defendant is Syndrome, aka Incrediboy
You are spot on!
The plaintiff is CREEPY!
Kerwin needs to shut up, he's done
Mr Kirwan is too cute by far
Bart Simpson looks depressed..
How many times can JJ explain the same things. 🤨🤦♂️😒
Why does this guy look like Hans Solo
Lease said 2 people, 1 bathroom...when you start adding people, you're breaching your lease! He could have signed a 100 year lease and break it if the landlord breached the contract! Even if it wasn't the bathroom, the bed bugs, the party, you have someone staying long-term, it's a breach.
Missing the point. He signed a lease for his enjoyment. Once you change demographics of that lease, you break the contract.
$1600/month?? Is this house really wort that much???
No wonder he can afford to buy some stud of hold to stick into his left ear lobe, like a big girl.....😁
What a dingus YOU BROKE IT by moving someone new in and cutting off his resources
41 yrs old found a time machine back to 2001 and brought his Eminem and Green Day posters w him
I knew there was a problem with the landlord when he said this loft cost $1600 a month, and with 1bedroom and a bunch of others coming and going. WOW!
Ewwww all men, ladder room, 1 bathroom, rotating visits from strangers, all for $1600. N O P E
I’d never thought I’d see the day on Judge Judy when a good looking businessman in a suit and tie loses his case to a dude who looks like he walked out of Hot Topic in a shopping mall, circa 2005.
Another scumbag landlord. But, he'll never realize it, or never want to.
Imagine if his family didn’t rally with him and he wasn’t smart, his life could have been ruined. This happened in Amerikkka everyday and those without support and from the ghetto would have accepted a lesser charge to a crime they never committed because they don’t see a way to get out of the system. I hope he sues the county!
He doesn’t understand how he gets to break the 6 month lease?? Someone orders a cheese pizza and a coke but later you bring them a coffee,pasta, tenderloin, hotdog, nachos and a sandwich then expect the customer to pay for the entire meal and return happy to the establishment?!? Heck no he can refuse to live there it wasn’t their agreement to have so many people in and out.
This reminds me of the recent case where someone got a restraining order against a guy, he showed up at his work and inadvertently crossed his path so he said he owed him money for getting within ten feet and "making eye contact" when he saw him. This guy thinks because he has a six-month lease, the guy has to pay four months rent even though he wasn't there. Thank God JJ knows the law.
I bet whatever state they're from would be very interested in the fact that this guy owns a warehouse and is renting out residential apartments within it which I'm sure is completely illegal
plantiff was a total prick.
To me, its a GAy situation, more ways than.... ONE....